https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xOf3MVMPGOc
Is this the GREATEST musical anime moment in anime history?
I don't know but it's one of my favorite.
For the song and its arrangement, definitely one of the best. The noticeable CG and that hilariously god awful rotoscoping in the middle definitely distracted from the scene. I can think of a couple that were more impactful in an emotional sense.
https://my.mixtape.moe/eqszzj.webm
https://track3.mixtape.moe/eohtoi.webm
>>155674751
>k-on
>great
>>155674205
Maybe. But to be fair I can think of like maybe three if we don't count Macross.
>>155674205
FUCKING YES.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1x5VyzK-_zg
No commentary, no reactions, just music.
>>155674751
>second one
Correct.
>>155674751
Why would you choose those over the song they sing Azusa at the end of the series? Shit was touching.
>>155674205
No, but still good and I always remember it
>>155674751
Decent
>>155674985
Not even worth remembering
Here is the best musical anime moment
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=srmim3m15MY
>>155675157
>blocked in my country
>>155675157
>K-ON is the only decent one
How to spot bad taste
>>155675220
>J-pop shit anything over decent
>>155675256
Exactly, K-ON is okay animation and character-wise, but the music is just an irrelevant plot device.
Probably not the best but I love this anyways
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JJ8rnv4_IWQ
the guy being like "what the fuck is wrong with these people" is believable and priceless
>Rotoscoping
No
This is an unexpectedly good track from the NNB soundtrack. I was pleasantly surprised when I heard it.
https://my.mixtape.moe/hjmqpt.mp3
>>155675618
We are talking about anime with music as the theme, not about anime OST
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q8FvM8H_0-k
>>155675314
> the music is just an irrelevant plot device.
As opposed to what other use in the examples posted so far?
>>155675681
Oh, right, sorry. I'm gonna leave it up because it's still pretty good.
>>155675720
K-on is a SoL about eating keiki and cute girls doing cute things
>>155675720
I guess they're all technically plot devices, the difference is K-ON just uses a generic soundtrack and has the characters sing it as the main theme/focus of the anime. Stuff like the OP and Hibike actually attempt to make the musical theme realistic.
>>155675921
Kids on the Slope and Hibike were school dramas that used playing music as a setting more than anything. Just because it's not pop doesn't suddenly mean it's all about the music. Nodame Cantabile was much more about the music than those two.
>>155674205
Does Kure-nai episode 6 count?
>>155676169
I'm not saying that just because it's pop, it's just very obvious that K-ON didn't spend a lot of time on making the music itself realistic whereas something like Hibike did. It was extremely focused on being completely musically correct, as this was the entire purpose of the show, while K-ON was about cute girls doing cute things while playing their soundtrack.
>>155676394
> it's just very obvious that K-ON didn't spend a lot of time on making the music itself realistic
Huh? What the hell are you talking about, honestly? How is the music in K-On unrealistic?
It's not THE GREATEST, but it's pretty good:
https://youtu.be/6kA4tGu60mo
>>155677742
unrelated
>>155677805
maybe so but as an exercise in mood it is without equal
>>155677742
>>155677908
It can't stand on its own so therefore it's shit.
Also it's 3D.
Pls go kys.
>>155674205
I still remember when this aired and some jackass was all 'This is bullshit, we did stuff like this in my band class all the time and nobody came running to listen to us.'
>>155677988
rudebois
>>155674205
LOL no
>>155674751
Yui is always so fucking happy during the live performances, it's delightful and contagious.
>>155676940
>not the russian dub
what are you doing?
>>155674205
Where have I heard this song before?
It's very familiar but I never watched the Disney movie.
>>155680027
its got a bit of my favorite things in it
The last episode of S1 Kinmoza deserves honorable mention
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HijMAax4N-Q
>>155674205
This made me tear up when I first watched it. Fuck rock music.
https://my.mixtape.moe/rsknyr.webm
strong feels
>>155682139
>still "feeling" over K-on
>>155682210
>ever not feeling over k-on
>>155674205
good show but the opening for me was out of place
>>155682259
>feeling anything beyond lukewarm 'that was a nice show what's next on my backlog'
>>155682316
>not having watched it as it aired
>>155674205
I'll remember it for being based Bahi's professional debut. What a charismatic way to enter the industry.
>>155682386
>implying it was on my backlog
>implying I meant to imply that it ever was
>implying it makes a difference because in the end k-on was just "okay"
>>155674205
it was pretty good
>>155674205
Such a bad rendition of My Favorite Things, wish they could've just used another jazz standard that can be played in 3 minutes and not have it sound utterly mediocre.