The great debate http://www.strawpoll.me/12510982

The girls in PW are like a million times hotter than the entire Dragon Maid cast.

>>154467341
the one of the right doesnt even have a story

>>154467445
It clearly does

>>154467341
I liked Phantom World, but this isn't even a contest.

>>154467341
Phantom World is irredeemable shit, so Maid Dragon wins by default

>>154467341

phantom world is absolute trash

any votes for it are trolls or retards

Literally the only good thing about phantom world was Ruru. It was a piece of shit overall, though.

>>154467341
The only good thing about Phantom Worlds is visuals. At least Maid Dragon has a comfy SoL atmosphere

>>154467596
>>154467692
>>154467745
>Phantom Worls was bad
When will this shitty meme end?

>>154467833
Its not a meme. You just have terrible taste.

>>154467341
Why the fuck would anyone choose Phantom World? Leaving the shitty plot and characterization aside, the girls are no where near as cute.

Maid Dragon is on the same level as Phantom World, but Hipsters defend it because it's airing rn. Make this thread in a year OP and it'll be roughly even, because both are trash.

>>154467341
both are shit desu

I would say Maid Dragon is better but Lucoa and Shouta exist so I really don't know what to pick

>>154467969
Says the guy typing like he's texting someone. Fuck off.

>>154467969
>no new IP

>>154467969
Maid dragon is by Cool kyou so it has that advantage, I don't think it will be seen as bad in the future.
Phantom world on the other hand has nothing.

>>154467341
Mayonnaise-sama and Reina can't hold a candle to Lucoa

>>154468041
>Says the guy typing like he's texting someone
>a written post looks like it was written
Autism

>>154467341
Yep, I feel kinda bad because we're always complaining that all Kyoani does is anime with cute girls doing cute things. So when they do something different (even if it's haremshit) it makes me want to support it, but I just can't. Musaigen is just mediocre, and they perfected the moe SOL.

>>154467969
>hey guys look at me! I'm so edgy and above it all.
If you can't something nice, then suck my cock nigger. How about you

>>154468094
Not all forms of writing are equal. Maybe you're too underage to understand.

>>154468142
Take your own advise.

>>154468055
Being by Cool is a handicap though.

Meme Dragon

>>154468163
shut up

>>154468175
How?
The man is a genius.

>>154467969
I don't think so. People have been (unjustly) shitting on Phantom World since episode 1 or 2, while Maid Dragon's reception was much more positive.

>>154468206
I find his art simply revulsing, and there's nothing special about his writing.

File: 1489071408339.png (709KB, 840x780px) Image search: [Google]

709KB, 840x780px

>>154468241
>unjustly

>>154467341
Phantom what? Anyway
>90% dragons

>>154467341
PW win, because hippy said so. Anything that win in a poll are shit. Here some example god tier anime like PW:
>Hyouge Mono
>Tatami Galazy

>>154468148
Or you're just retarded, because "typing like he's texting someone" means nothing here.

>>154468190
Kill yourself.

>>154467341
Phantom World has pretty girls but it's just dumb chuuni harem bullshit. Maid Dragon is actually funny and can even tuck your heartstrings from time to time, I also like the way they visualize certain scenes.

>>154468241
An assload of people shitted on Maid Dragon Episode 1 though when it came out.

>>154468357
>"typing like he's texting someone" means nothing here.
Spot the newfag. Kill yourself back to /v/ kid.

File: 1489244101371.png (698KB, 797x682px) Image search: [Google]

698KB, 797x682px

>>154468241
>unjustly

>>154467341
Phantom world. But only because of ruru.

reina and kurumi are worst girls

>>154468428
>says something that makes no sense
>y-youre just new
Pathetic.

>/v/
stop projecting

File: fddsf.png (315KB, 417x460px) Image search: [Google]

315KB, 417x460px

People unironically like Phantom World?

>>154468479
Are you going to whip out some smileys next? Just go back to wherever you came from.

>>154468537
Stop trying to fit in, it makes you look like a manchild.

>>154468586
Yet you look like a literal child.

>>154468520
People voting for PW only hate it less than DM.

>>154468520
It had Mai, who is KyoAni's best girl and one of the best anime girls in general.

>>154468615
>no u
Cry more.

>>154468671
How is it "no u" when I called you something different? Thanks for affirming your underage status I guess. Better luck hiding it next time kid.

>>154468708
>you're x
>n-no you're Y!!
I said cry more.

Left: Dropped.
Right: Not dropped.

>>154467882
Bullshit.

It introduces a new theme every episode, and the phantoms are actually relevant and interesting instead of just being copypaste villains; and every time the protagonists have to figure out a new way to deal with them instead of mindless fighting.
That already makes it better than the average action/school setting.

People complaining this hard about PW are just fanboys mad that Kyoani made something different for once, instead of the xteenth SOL.
Teel me one(1) concrete thing that is wrong with Phantom World.

>>154468740
>doubling down on being wrong
ok kid

>>154468787
>misunderstanding "no u"
Degenerate

>>154468648
Delusion.

>>154468832
see >>154468787

>>154467391
>Characters being hot is what makes a series good.

>>154468880
>>154468832

KyoAni hasn't made a good anime since Hyouka.

>>154468786
Watch more than 5 anime before posting.

>>154468924
>>154468880

>>154468923
>being gay
interesting

>>154469045
>>154468924

>>154468786
I don't want to gang up on you or anything, buddy, but from what you said, it just sounds like a typical monster of the week sort of deal. The series itself wasn't very memorable either.

>>154468786
>Teel me one(1) concrete thing that is wrong with Phantom World.

well i dont dislike the show, but

theres a lot of fights and there are pointless fights. they are pointless because it never feels for a second like the characters are actually threatened or might lose. which is how you define a pointless fight - it cant engage you emotionally. and many episodes are built on the characters facing these trivial challenges.

>>154468393
Not as much as they did with Phantom World, which never had the support Maid Dragon has now anyway.
>>154468282
>>154468434
Yes, unjustly. It's not half as bad as people make it out to be, and it pretty much redeems itself in the last few episodes.

>>154469345
It was established early that Phantoms don't usually harm people and mostly cause trouble.

>>154468923
Correct.

>>154469414
ok sure but theres no reason to create conflicts that dont feel like conflicts, they are just dead air time. its not unlike what goes on in a lot of superhero movies lately. directors lose sight of why you have battles to begin with. its not just to make the characters look cool. that doesnt work on most of your audience that isnt 12.

>>154467341
Put some effort into your bait next time

File: yande.re 340501 bikini cleavage headphones ichijou_haruhiko izumi_reina kawakami_mai minase_koito open_shirt pantyhose pointy_ears seifuku swimsuits thighhighs.jpg (4MB, 6393x4084px) Image search: [Google]

4MB, 6393x4084px

>>154469469
The earlier interviews state PW is meant to be a silly comedy anime. Taking it seriously is watching it with the wrong mindset.

>>154469345
>>154469469
You can enjoy the action scenes while knowing the good guys aren't actually threatened, and more generally you can enjoy something even if the resolution of the conflict is predictable. Otherwise nobody would read battle manga. It's about the journey dude, not the destination.

>>154467517
so whats the plot been so far senpai?

>>154469624
Personally I'm pretty jaded with action stuffs, unless it's absolutely bonkers or if there's any real consequences to be had.

>>154467341
Maidragon easily
Even as a silly comedy show, Phantom World was goddamn boring, the whole cast was extremely bland except Ruru. Enigma best girl

>>154467445
Neither is the one in the left.

>>154469957
good taste

>>154467341
DAMN
People really don't like Phantom World.

>>154467341
Both are shit.

File: [HorribleSubs] Kobayashi-san Chi no Maid Dragon - 02 [720p].mkv_snapshot_14.05_[2017.01.18_23.35.18].jpg (164KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

164KB, 1280x720px

>>154468055
>Maid dragon is by Cool kyou
woah, hadn't noticed

>>154467969
>Hipsters defend it because it's airing rn
Except that this didn't happen when PW aired at all.

File: 1488909241538.gif (3MB, 400x400px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 400x400px

>>154467341
what debate? Phantom World is shit. The anime barely made a dent into the LNs. Maid Dragon wins.