G-Recofags were always telling people who disliked their show

>>153919530
Aldnoah Zero. At least G-Reco has nice designs.

>>153919530
Iron Blooded Orphans

>>153919530
G-Reco is literally the worst work of fiction even written.

I loved watching G-reco for some reason.

>>153919530
both are tolerable and have things going for them, Active Raid does now

At least G-Reco had some ambition, even if I don't think it succeeded at it. And it looked nicer to boot.

Meanwhile Aldnoah was just a much worse SEED clone.

>>153919530
G-Reco was wacky and fun at times. It was honestly pretty enjoyable and letting it sink in since it aired only made my opinion of the show better.

>>153919856
>does not

>>153919636
Are you really sating that after watching A/Z?

>>153919530
Both were equally retarded, but at least G-Reco was intentionally funny and had a nice production design.

>>153919530
Valvrave. G-Reco had Armorzagan and AZ had most of my fetishes across five different women so I can't dislike either

>>153919936
>G-Reco was intentionally funny
No, Tomino is just senile and autistic.

>>153919530
G-Reco had a blunder of an ending, but overall it was enjoyable. And it even got pretty good mid-way through.

Aldnoah was good for about 6-7 episodes of the first season and everything after that, especially that embarrassment of a second season, was complete dog shit.

>>153919530
Both are great though

>>153919989
Only decent thing about Aldnoah was the final battle. And they completely ruined it in the second season.

File: 1367600641721.jpg (21KB, 291x302px) Image search: [Google]

21KB, 291x302px

>>153919964
>hating VVV

>>153919530
Hi ya Valvrager, still failing to demean good shows are we?

>>153919964
>AZ had most of my fetishes
Cucking?

>>153919530
G Reco is a mess but still something an anime fan can admire for its minor qualities like worldbuilding and art.

Aldnoah Zero just got worse and worse and had hardly anything going for it as an anime.

File: Winter 2015.jpg (307KB, 616x913px) Image search: [Google]

307KB, 616x913px

>tfw will never have a mecha season this good again

>>153919903
AZ is just shit.
Greco goes above and beyond ignoring any rule and common sense about storytelling, direction and character writing. It's the worst thing I've ever experienced.

>>153920029
I agree with the first 6-7 episodes being alright. The first three were damn solid, the next few were passable but worse with the repetitive Martian of the Week battles, and then it jumped the shark with the Hime cliffhanger/fakeout.

>>153919530
Daimidaler

>>153919530
Dai Shogun

File: [HorribleSubs] Soukyuu no Fafner Dead Aggressor - Exodus - 11 [720p].mkv_snapshot_06.55_[2015.03.19_16.39.07].jpg (78KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

78KB, 1280x720px

>>153920161
>Winter 2015
You're forgetting about the only good mecha that aired that season.

>>153920066
The only thing I liked about Valvrave was that his robot was literally powered by rape and the zero-g fist fight on the moon in space suits. That scene is still one of the unintentionally funniest things I've seen in an anime.

File: [HorribleSubs] Soukyuu no Fafner Dead Aggressor - Exodus - 07 [720p].mkv_snapshot_04.53_[2015.12.31_11.11.59].jpg (359KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

359KB, 1280x720px

>>153920161
>Nobody watched the actual best mecha that aired that season

File: houkouin.jpg (250KB, 845x1200px) Image search: [Google]

250KB, 845x1200px

>>153920268

>>153920288
>not liking Moses' scene
C'mon, that shit was comedy gold.

>>153920161
Mecha is dead and Sunrise killed it.

>>153920268
Did anyone actually manage to finish that?

>>153920353
I did. 'Twas bretty gud.

File: 1482321602880.jpg (37KB, 800x552px) Image search: [Google]

37KB, 800x552px

>>153920178

>>153919530
Concrete Revolutio

>>153920178
I can see your point.

>>153920417
Not even mecha. Also, great.

>>153920337
I don't even remember that. Thankfully I've erased most of that show from my mind, kind of.

File: 1483762900082.jpg (85KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

85KB, 1280x720px

>G-Reco weeded out stupid people
>A/Z was watched by stupid people

>>153919530
AZ is just rubbish. Reco is actually good.

>>153919636
That's Garzey's Wing, anon.

>>153919880
A/Z was better than SEED, so if it was a clone it was actually an improvement.

>>153919530
G-Reco was worse. Even with Aldnoah going full retard in S2

>>153920161
Good thing Argevollen's not on that card.

>>153920457
hi Nick Creamer
>>153920624
That's a weird way of saying Infinite Ryvius

>>153920757
Ryvius was fantastic, bitch. Don't even play.

>>153920757
>Infinite Ryvius
Masterpiece.

>>153920757
That's a weird way of saying Gasaraki.

G-reco was just kinda boring, but AZ's blandness was just insulting after how much it was hyped up by Aniplex. Holy shit the hubris of the team that made AZ is galling, they actually claimed they would surpass gundam.

>>153919530
Hard to so anon, they were both so fucking awful.

>>153920662
I watched them at basically the same time. I got far more enjoyment out of SEED than A/Z, and that's taking into account Destiny.

>so if it was a clone
All it was missing was for Inaho and Slaine to be childhood friends or something.

>>153919530
Aldnoah takes the shitcake. G-reco was fun, had an "interesting"directing at times and was overall unremarkable as another Gundam spin-off.

>>153920885
Then I'm sorry you have tragedy for taste, but objectively A/Z was superior to SEED in every respect, up to and including OST, plot, and character design. SEED had flashing lights and people with triangles for skulls.

File: 1465831570420.jpg (317KB, 800x533px) Image search: [Google]

317KB, 800x533px

G-Recofags were just upset they had dead threads while A/Z threads were reaching the bump limit 3 hours in. A/Z wasn't that great but it miles better than G-Shitco

>>153919530
IBO is fucking awful

File: 1352313173084.png (267KB, 576x432px) Image search: [Google]

267KB, 576x432px

>>153921847
Why do G-Recofags feel so threatened by IBO? The question was Aldnoah Zero vs G-Reco, not IBO.

>>153919636
Just proves how much of a complete idiot you are.

File: 1487498511819.jpg (20KB, 450x253px) Image search: [Google]

20KB, 450x253px

>>153921498
>G-Recofags were just upset they had dead threads
On /a/ maybe but not on /m/ and given the type of shows that get constant threads here (VVV, CA, Try) why would they consider it a con? G-Reco threads were fun while A/Z were filled with retardation, shipperfaggotry and delusion that amounted to absolutely nothing in the end.

>>153921973
Why do you assume it was a G-Recofag? You IBOfags are more pathetic than A/Zfags
>>153921498
>A/Z wasn't that great but it miles better than G-Shitco
Not even close

>>153922754
>why would they consider it a con
You tell me, becauset he butthurt is real. Also tell me why G-Recofags are so butthurt at a trash site like ANN "hating" their show.

G-Reco has no Gunpla.

That's how bad it did.

>>153921973
Because they know instinctively that IBO is better than their shitshow and they're terrified everyone else will clue into it and laugh at them. Seeing as how they can't even conjure enough evidence to show how or why their trash show is even as good as A/Z is proof of their insecurity.

>>153922812
Why do you assume I'm a IBO fag? You G-Recofags are more pathetic than A/Zfags.

>>153922894
Why do you assume I am a G-Recofag? You IBOfags are more pathetic than A/Zfags

>>153922957
Let's use a ∞ and end it for real.

>>153922843
Not even Japan thinks IBO is better

>>153923032
see >>153922840

Yes, they do.

>>153923032
Prove it. Because this week IBO placed fairly high in another best anime poll. G-Reco didn't even make it to 2ch top 50.

>>153922816
>butthurt
The only butthurt are from the retards still shitting on it 3 years later
>ANN
You mean the site that constantly posts false information and gets called out on it?
>>153923075
>>153922840
http://gundam.wikia.com/wiki/High_Grade_Reconguista_in_G
You retarded bro?

>>153923123
>best anime poll
Kek

>>153923032
>G-Recofag going delusional again
IBO consistently does better than G-Reco in all polls and merchandise sales.

>>153919530
G-Reco is a masterpiece and everyone who disagrees must like that other shitty mecha show that happened to air that season.

>>153923135
And nobody buys them.

>>153923123
You mean that shitty poll fujos hijack hence why shit like Joker Game and K Missing Kings was ranked?

>>153923228
At least fujos cared enough to hijack the poll. Who cared about G-Reco?

>>153923215
>Source: my ass.

>>153923195
Cool horseshit bro

>>153923208
>BvS is a masterpiece and everyone who disagrees must like that other shitty capeshit that happened to air that year

>>153923215
Actually the line was extended because it did so well. Better luck next time.

>>153923271
Source is the Gunpla community.

>>153923273
I agree
>>153923032
is complete horseshit and the delusional /m/fag needs to go back to his solitary confinement board

>>153923320
[citation needed]

File: G-Reco vs IBO.jpg (182KB, 1052x1088px) Image search: [Google]

182KB, 1052x1088px

Remember that G-Recofags are full of shit and evidence proves that IBO is the more popular show.

File: 1458723855361.jpg (26KB, 740x370px) Image search: [Google]

26KB, 740x370px

>>153923328
>>153923075
>>153923123
>>153923195
>>153923328
Would you guys stop making fools of yourselves now? IBO even flopped on Toonami and the only place that still cares about it is ANN and Animesuki

File: hqdefault.jpg (12KB, 480x360px) Image search: [Google]

12KB, 480x360px

>>153923426
>no TV ratings posting
I wonder why?

>>153923509
Oh, is that one poll (the only one) were G-Reco won.

>>153923593
Because you can stream the episodes but you can't stream your Gunpla.

>>153923509
>IBO even flopped on Toonami and the only place that still cares about it is ANN and Animesuki

I'm sure japs care what the west think

oh wait they don't

>>153919530
G-Reco was more all-over the place, but it had more interesting pieces that just didn't really cohere. A/Z was consistently boring even when it wasn't being a mess. I prefer the former. Also, Yoshida fucking Kenichi.

>>153923647
So where's the TV rating?

File: 1485383721130.png (240KB, 600x337px) Image search: [Google]

240KB, 600x337px

>>153923426
>Pixiv
>Modelers G
>First BD came with an event ticket/voucher for kusoge PSV game and dropped harder with later volumes selling less than G-Reco overall.
>twitter

Are you done anon?

>>153919530
Aldnoah Zero is great

>>153919530
I hate to admit it but G-reco is worse, it was more entertaining but theres really little defending how god awful the writing got near the end. Aldnoah shit the bed early on too but there was alot more....coherency to the whole thing even if it was bad, G-reco kind of said fuck it in the final 5 episodes and turned into a fever dream rehash of Char's counterattack.

I want to say G-reco at least tried something different, but it didnt, it was a rehash of turn-A's plot and morals but done in a far more offensive and delusional light with the final stretch just being char's counterattack minus the asteroid aka the only good part of chars counterattack. Music and animation were nice but that cant redeem this mess of not only a gundam but a show in general.

>>153923745
(You).

>>153923627
Then where are the stream numbers?

File: 1482697902235.png (30KB, 392x349px) Image search: [Google]

30KB, 392x349px

>>153923810

>>153923859
There aren't, just like we'll never get Gunpla numbers. Everyone go home now.

>>153923810
I forgot the 1 thing that pushes G-reco over the edge of being bad to terrible, if it were just a mess it'd be forgettable, but Bellri is the single most sociopathic protagonist in the entire franchise and kills countless innocents all whilst blaming them for it and never accepting responsibility nor getting comeuppance. The whow was so tonally deaf when it came to his actions that it came off as downright offensive at points especially when bellri killed his teacher.

>>153923810
>Aldnoah shit the bed early on too but there was alot more....coherency to the whole thing even if it was bad
When a show betrays its own tagline you know you done fucked up

>>153923810
>G-reco is worse, it was more entertaining
That means it wasn't worse.

>>153923962
yes it does, Part of its entertainment came in how bad it was at points. The final episode i legit hilarious especially when that old due just gets hit from behind with a gundam foot and flung off a cliff.

Entertainment is something to consider, but something can be entertaining for a plethora of reasons and not exactly for flattering reasons. I'd consider G-gundam more entertaining than turn-A due to its fast pace and absurd set pieces but as an overall package turn-A is better. Aldnoah and g-reco are just 2 awful shows in the same example.

>>153923952
>>153923810
Another entertaining aspect of G-Reco threads is seeing idiots fail to explain what makes it bad.

File: mpv-0067.jpg (94KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

94KB, 1280x720px

G-Reco is just a shittier less coherent Turn-A

>>153924173
Another entertaining thing about G-reco is seeing you shitpost every thread with nigh identical posting patterns and samefagging. The only thing I hate ios that you spark more stupid blood between /m/ and /a/ even though a bunch of people on /m/ think youre retarded as well.

>>153924219
So Gainer 2.0

File: 1483030460476.jpg (12KB, 400x267px) Image search: [Google]

12KB, 400x267px

>>153924257
There he goes again with his stupid comments.

>>153923745
G-Reco fags lying again, color me surprise. Even if you ignore their first volumes, IBO still sold more than G-Reco. G-Reco vol 2-9 63,756. IBO vol 2-9 65,602. The only G-Reco volumes that outsould IBO's were 5, 7 and 8.

>>153924219
It feels like turn-A but with the anger and aggressiveness of zeta gundam which doesn't mesh well together at all. its a shame cause G-reco's world looks pretty interesting, i say looks cause they did fuck all with it in favor of shoving fodder mech fights in your face over actualy world building and character development. The best episodes of the show came near the end of the first cour where the show actually slowed the fuck down its pacing and showed how characters lived in this world outside of the soldiers. It made me think it was about to improve when watching it ongoing but the show just went back to its frantic pacing and angry tone immediately afterwords.

>>153924272
Gainer at least had likable characters, the story was a fucking trainwreck but there were still character arcs with satisfying conclusions that made the show worth picking up even with its narrative shortcomings. Good characters go a long way to save shows and in g-reco's case it basically had.....like klim and that was it.

It's kind of sad that the only reason G-reco is relevant is for shitposting purposes. I was really looking foreword to it before it came out.

File: 1474388508596.png (64KB, 1095x805px) Image search: [Google]

64KB, 1095x805px

>>153924418
>Even if you ignore their first volumes, IBO still sold more than G-Reco.
Nope. That first volume helped IBO a lot and gave it the edge and it was the only one with a special offer.

>>153919530
Aldnoah, it's very premise has holes in it. It couldn't even hold itself together for the first 3 episodes.

G-Reco was a total mess but Aldnoah (at least season one I didn't bother with the second) just the same exact setup and resulting turn of events every single goddamn episode. So, at least G-Reco could confuse the shit out of me with its bizarre choices.

>>153920288
>was that his robot was literally powered by rape

It wasn't, but I know how much people who shit on Valvrave don't actually remember Valvrave.

>>153924498
>but there were still character arcs with satisfying conclusions that made the show worth picking up even with its narrative shortcomings.
No there wasn't. One of the biggest plot points in that show (Hanzo killing Gainer's parents) gets cast aside like nothing, the only character with a satisfying resolution to his character arc was Asuham due to how utterly pointless his actions were by the end of it.

>>153924705
Dude, I even did the math (well, Excel did because I suck at maths): G-Reco vol 2-9 63,756. IBO vol 2-9 65,602. That chart is outdated, by the way. IBO's volume 9 outsold G-Reco's. Stop using dumb charts to back up your arguments and check someanithing

Anyone else wish tomino would of just made the original pirate themed mecha that G-reco originally was. Not much was known other than it was in development hell for like 7 years but it sounds like it was originally about a princess who was dethroned only to join up with pirates to go on space adventures trying to reclaim her throne. You can kind of see how it turned into G-reco since bellri kind of went from high class living to living with rogues but they really didnt do much with that other than basic set up.

I say tomino should just go ahead and try to make the original story even with G-reco existing. Its tomino so its par for the course he'd shit on his work but given that tomino expressed disappointment in how G-reco turned out it'd could be a perfect time to redeem the storyline.

>>153924956
>IBO's volume 9 outsold G-Reco's.
It didn't dumbass

>>153925070
>9 9 7,508 2015/08/26 Fall Gundam G no Reconquista
>9 9 7,515 2016/08/26 Fall Kidou Senshi Gundam Tekketsu no Orphans

Now kill yourself, lazy retard.

>>153924956
Also it becomes even more irrelevant once you realize IBO is twice the length of G-reco anyway. They were both successful series regardless of what people want to write the narrative out to be, but IBO is also no doubt more successful due to larger popularity and merchandise in addition to successful gunpla. Its still less than 00 and seed's popularity but hey barely anything is.

The moral of the story is, neither are even close to age's flop so whats the point in the dick measuring..

>>153925211
It probably doesnt add that much to profits but it is notable that IBO is the first TV gundam in close to 10 years to actually be successful in the west. Thats just a really nice way to say age and G-reco werent popular outside of japan and emphasizing jesus christ its been 10 years since 00.

>>153925153
>someanithing
Also good job comparing G-Reco's first week sales to IBO's second weeks

>>153919530
I didn't watch G-Reco

Aldnoah Zero pissed me off with the decisions it took and Slaine and the other guy getting cucked at the end and accepting it because reasons and then Slaine not even scoring with lemons and other guy not scoring with his sister.

>>153925398
Again, retard. Those are total sales by volume.

>>153925322
>It probably doesnt add that much to profits but it is notable that IBO is the first TV gundam in close to 10 years to actually be successful in the west
IBO flopped on Toonami. GBF is the most successful Gundam anime to be released in the West since Unicorn, its BD Box set was the best selling Gundam release of the year.

>>153925457
Those aren't total sales. >>153925211
>Also it becomes even more irrelevant once you realize IBO is twice the length of G-reco anyway

>>153925532
>Those aren't total sales.
Source? Prove it.

>>153919530
>>153919573
This Greco had cute girls ,aldanoah just sucked

>>153925488
Where did you read IBO flopped on toonami? People also said the same thing about space dandy but both bones and cartoon network's CEO said it did well and were potentially interested in doing an ova or movie one day.

I like how that G-reco cant get mentioned without people somehow shitposting ibo too. I mean granted its the newest one so it kind of comes with the territory but still.

>>153925211
>Also it becomes even more irrelevant once you realize IBO is twice the length of G-reco anyway
Do you really want to add IBOs second season numbers? They're aren't good.
>but IBO is also no doubt more successful due to larger popularity and merchandise in addition to successful gunpla.
Well yeah because they already had a predetermined amount of stock into it while they didn't for G-Reco. It was the same situation with GBF in which its success was unprecedented so Bandai had to make more merchandise than was planned due to demand hence why TRY had a shit load more merchandise out the gate than GBF.

Even on Nyaa IBO episodes have more donwnloads than G-Reco. I don't know if they are accurate, but

G-Reco first episode 50k. G-Reco last episode 16k (what a massive drop by the way)
IBO first episode 60k. IBO S1 last episode: 30

>>153925720
I think thats more representative of how many people dropped the series. I remmember how on mal's episode discussion the first 2 episodes had hundreds of posters but by the time the show was in the final stretch it had like 12 people.

TSUKAME PURAIDO

>>153925644
>Where did you read IBO flopped on toonami?
It had really shitty ratings worse than something like Akame Ga Kill and Dimension W
>>153925644
>People also said the same thing about space dandy
No they didn't, Space Dandy was a huge fucking success on TV and on BD in the West so much so that the Japanese BD Box included the dub with it.

>>153925720
>Nyaa
Kek

The thing that angers me about G-reco wasnt that it was awful, its that its so bad yet it still gets mentioned more than something like fafner which was actually a well made mecha airing around the same time which cared more about telling a compelling story than selling toys like G-reco did.

>>153925830
im asking where you got that info from, im not accusing you of lying I genuinly am just curious where to check these stats.

and im assuming you mean BD exclusively in the west, cause space dandy fucking bombed so hard in japan and depressingly enough didnt even crack 1K sales for first week volumes. It was well received in nico ratings at least.

>>153925720
Nyaa isn't a representative of anything since it has a very small pool of users on it also G-Reco had areally fucked up release schedule so episodes never came out on time and often not anons from /m/ had to rip episodes from Vimeo because Daisuki UK would always be late while IBO had four fucking companies streaming it and episodes were readily available an hour after the episode finished airing.

Have some more first episode vs last episode Nyaa numbers, this shit is interesting:

>Aldnoah
146,7k - 73,6k
>Valvrave
45k - 13k
>Fafner
27k - 11k

>>153926024
It really doesnt surprise me valvrave fucked up just as much as G-reco.

>>153925950
>im asking where you got that info from
Check the fucking ratings report dumbass. IBO had below million viewers constantly even /co/ thought the show was boring as shit
>and im assuming you mean BD exclusively in the west
>>153925830
>No they didn't, Space Dandy was a huge fucking success on TV and on BD in the West
>in the West
Seriously dude you're fucking stupid

>>153926024
Thank you for such worthless information

>>153926060
At least Valvrave was fun.

>>153926094
Ok given that your posting no links and are just resorting to throwing insults I'm going to actually assume your pulling stuff out of your ass. Good job when I was just asking for a link.

I always find everyone's sheer indifference towards IBO amusing dedpite Bandai's push towards it.

>>153926170
I mean G-reco was fun for me, but valvrave there was more to talk about after it was done. The extent G-reco discussions go are "yeah that show kind of sucked"

>>153926206
It's the Hillary Clinton of Gundam.

>>153926215
>but valvrave there was more to talk about after it was done.
Barely anyone fucking discussed VVV after it finished while G-reco still gets regularly discussion. Hell VVV was bad enough that Aniplex dropped it and gave it to Sunrise.

Even Reddit threads for G-Reco had less than 100 replies. I'm checking everywhere and literally there's no place where G-Reco was popular. G-Recofags are full of shit.

>>153926252
Yep, they're both losers and will be forgotten.

>>153926206
Seems to be super well received everywhere but here. I know its 2nd season is already shaping up to be the highest rated TV gundam on a few sites both jap and weaboo. I imagine the shitposting about mal and ann are going to be through the roof for that mentruel-kun guy who posts the same 5 comments over and over again every week.

>>153926283
>Reddit
Scraping to the bottom of the barrel aren't ya?

>>153926206
But people like it. It's not SEED or 00 levels of people loving it, but it's not ignored.

>>153926261
>after it finished while G-reco still gets regularly discussion

You call this discussion? Its literally only brought up in reference to how hated it was and its usually only on this site. Pretty much everywhere else the fandom has forgotten it entirely especially since Try completely overshadowed it even with its lukewarm reception.

>>153926338
Don't be autistic, Reddit is huge. If we are discussing popularity, Reddit stats are far more valuable than the 100 people posting on /m/.

>>153926338
The gundam reddit is actually full of very pleasant people with threads having little to no shitposting even when people bring up criticsms. Compared to /m/ its basically gundam fandom heaven.

I'm really surprised how many views fights for IBO get on youtube. Its kind of nice knowing this franchise still has pull in the west.

Getting /m/ to admit IBO is even remotely successful is like getting a devote christian to lose faith in god. Its possible and happens but so rarely its not even worth trying.

>>153926317
>Seems to be super well received everywhere but here
Nope. Only sites such as ANN and Animesuki are praising it, nobody else seems to give a shit and the general conseus seems to be its boring as fuck. It was quite amusing seeing that it didn't fare all too well on Toonami too and most people on /co/ agree that they fell asleep through most of it.
>I know its 2nd season is already shaping up to be the highest rated TV gundam on a few sites both jap and weaboo.
Cool horseshit bro

>>153926462
You forgot your fedora.

>>153919530
A/Z at least had Slaine.

>>153926342
>But people like it.
Not really.
>>153926362
That's an awful lot of bullshit you just spouted.
>>153926385
>Reddit stats are far more valuable than the 100 people posting on /m/.
Not even close
>>153926398
So its a safe space with more autism. Why don't you go back then

>>153919530
Aldnoah is just a series of cheap cliff hangers. Can't do much worse than it.

>>153926488
Well for example ibo S2 is already the highest rated TV gundam on MAL and has been rapidly climbing in rank every week since the hasmal fight.

but of course it doesn't count cause it doesn't fit your narrative.

>>153926549
I've always been curious, are you a poe or not? Like your shitposting ability is commendable but I don't know if your just a well experience troll or actually autistic and treat criticsm of shows you like as insults to you personally.

>>153926588
>ibo S2 is already the highest rated TV gundam on MAL
It doesn't deserve it at all, but fuck, I'm happy. This BTFO the no one cares about IBO narrative.

>>153926588
>MAL
Kek

>>153920308
I love how manimefags complain about the industry being "not as good as before" and still they didn't watch Exodus.

It was a sequel of a show that aired ten years ago, during the "golden age of anime". Why aren't all of you watching it?

>>153926717
Why would manimefags watch a homolust anime?

>>153926588
You do realize that not even MAL users take the ratings system seriously right?

>>153926704
>>153926747
Still something to go off of unlike your baseless claims of its unpopularity when pretty much everything else says otherwise.

>>153926747
6k people think the show is a 7/10 or higher but no one likes the show, right?

File: Valrave.png (95KB, 1053x342px) Image search: [Google]

95KB, 1053x342px

>>153926024
The gg release of Valvrave has way more downloads than HS

File: 1483661844489.jpg (56KB, 1200x675px) Image search: [Google]

56KB, 1200x675px

>>153926588
>>153926803

>MAL
Funny enough less than half of the people are actually watching IBO S2 in comparison to S1, the score system is flawed enough that all you need to do is to have watched a significant amount of episodes to have your votes tallied so essentially everyone who voted were hardcore fans already.

>>153926803
>Still something to go off of
Not really its actually quite worthless. You're just saying its accurate because it fits your narrative is all.

>>153926870
>the score system is flawed enough that all you need to do is to have watched a significant amount of episodes to have your votes tallied

I always love that this is considered a bad thing when it basically means only people that actually watch the show can have their input added. For IBO s2 that isnt even implemented yet anyway cause its ongoing and all scores even dropped at ep 1 ones are held to the same power. Aka ibo is gonna get an even bigger boost at this rate once it ends.

>>153926926
When everything is fitting my narrative its no longer a narrative, its just reality at that point. Provide me any decently populated websites where ibo has low scores or any proof that the series is unpopular/unsuccessful and I'll concede, but all youve done is just ignore anything presented at you.

>>153926024
>Fafner
Something about comparing first/last-episode numbers for a sequel to non-sequels seems off.

>>153926870
Why do you post this same fucking picture every gundam thread.

>>153926588
I swear I don't have a horse in this race, but isn't everything new/recent on MAL rated unusually highly? I assumed that's why we get all those instances of "X FotM is currently in the top ten on MAL!" shitposting - because stuff gets high ratings while it's airing and then declines later.

>>153924219
Turn-Afags are the worst

>>153926979
>I always love that this is considered a bad thing when it basically means only people that actually watch the show can have their input added
It is a bad thing because it loses any sense of objectivity and /a/ proved this by score bombing Horizons low average because casuals couldn't get into it so they rose it just by spamming 10s.
>For IBO s2 that isnt even implemented yet
It already has been implemented since the season started hence why its the highest rated Gundam TV series. Its the same way how Gintama is constantly in the top percentile everytime a new series aires, the people who dropped it didn't have their scores tallied because they didn't watch enough episodes but the people who did were hardcore fans who would rate it high regardless same shit with IBO only its more obvious that a lot of people dropped it early on.

>>153927059
>When everything is fitting my narrative its no longer a narrative, its just reality at that point.
Will no because as the other anons stated IBO flopped on Toonami, is doing terribly on TV in Japan as well, it's BD sales also aren't terribly impressive either and it doesn't have much of a traction anywhere. You using MAL is just proof of how desperate you are.

>>153927223
When they first air they are yes, but thats in reference to their first few weeks which did happen to ibo, ibo started out at 8.27 and then dropped proptly to about 8.15 for the first cour before it started growing again. The ongoing scores are kind of worthless but the way they progress is very telling of what the final score will be. If something remains stagnant most the airing its actually likley there will be little to no score change by the end or it will actually drop. In a case where the score is constantly rising each weak its actually shaping up to have a big score jump at the end of its run. Mob psycho, shinsekai yori, et cetera for example was in the 7's for the longest time and started moving up rapidly after half its run with its final score jumping itself into the top 100 of the site by shows end. Compare that to kabenari which started off in the top 100 (8.60 score) to what it is now
https://myanimelist.net/anime/28623/Koutetsujou_no_Kabaneri

>>153927415
And none of them provided sources, and the bd one not only has been debunked multiple times but is debunked in this very thread.

>>153927223
Slightly. G-Reco used to have a low six when it was airing, now it has a high five. The score dropped, but not much.

>it's like I'm back in 20XX

>>153927415
see
>>153923426

>>153927476
it dropped alot while it was airing. It started off as a high 6 then just kept plummeting as the weeks went on.

>>153926870
So thats why G-reco and age have such high scores then right?

>>153927469
>And none of them provided sources
Google is a thing you know. We don't feed newshits.
>BDs got debunked
No it didn't.

>>153927552
See
>>153923745

File: 1444954112703 (copy).png (788KB, 1305x892px) Image search: [Google]

788KB, 1305x892px

Daily reminder

>>153927614
>Google is a thing you know. We don't feed newshits
http://lmgtfy.com/?q=Then+why+dont+you+google+it+numbnuts+to+prove+yourself.

>>153927711
I've been looking for this picture for so long since my hard drive got wiped a year back. Thank you.

>>153927601
That doesn't change anything I said. Hilariously enough the top review rating on the G-Reco page gave it an 8 so all we have here are Ragers spamming 1s while the top review scores for A/Z is a 3 despite its user score being a 7

I don't think I've seen one person actually defend G-Reco with an argument.

>>153919530
Still waiting for based SageSubs so I can watch G-Reco properly

File: 1455669760895.png (512KB, 1100x500px) Image search: [Google]

512KB, 1100x500px

>IBOfags take MAL scores seriously
Can't say I'm surprised. They need something to validate it's existence.

>>153928006
Lots of people can, that's what happens when the detractors of something just so happens to be idiots

>>153928046
holy shit this feels so reversed now.

>>153920508
let me just get by shitbag

>>153928046
>site with hundreds of milions of users
>you can't use it to prove if shows are popular or not
Okay.

>>153928089
>just so happens to be idiots
Case and point.

Thanks.

>>153928006
>hurr too deep for you

>>153928122
>site with hundreds of milions of users
Not even correct

>>153928147
Pretty ballsy to insult yourself like that

>>153927900
And another lie! The top review rates it a 3 (133 upvotes vs the 122 of the guy rating it a 3).

>>153928262
Do it.

Make an argument about why G-Reco is good.

It's not hard.

>>153928292
*The 122 upvotes guy rates it a 8

>>153928098
Indeed, she is so irrelevant that with minor modifications she could be completely removed from the story, I didn’t like her that much but I wonder why they did that in S2

>>153928089
Do you have any sense of self-awareness at all.

>>153920178
Nicely said.

>>153928292
Cool bullshit bro

>>153928344
As soon as you make an argument about why its bad.

>>153919613
This

Anyone still has the gif of Raraya going from laughing to crying in half a second?

File: 3 guy.jpg (168KB, 1012x357px) Image search: [Google]

168KB, 1012x357px

>>153928410

>>153928698
>This much autism
These are the people who hate G-Reco folks

>>153928779
Everyone's autistic?

File: af6ff253e52d3e61b69136a9bce58184193812e3.jpg (182KB, 875x989px) Image search: [Google]

182KB, 875x989px

I unironically enjoyed G-reco and even bought the BDs and manga. Then again, my fav series in the franchise is Turn A s maybe that's why I found G-Reco to be the perfect epilogue to Tomino's Gundam.

As a standalone, yeah, I can see why it's got such polarising reactions since I certainly doubt most of the people who watched G-reco has done the core UC series + Turn A experience. But for me, it was great. People say it's a mess but I found that it's fine as a simple, additional short story sort of thing that adds to/ callsback to the UC lore and enjoy all the little character moments here and there. One thing I really got to hand it to old school directors like Tomino and Miyazaki is that they know how to create an atmosphere that actually wants me to be part of it.

Yeah, the story is weak but again, to me, that's not the point. It's sort of like a bonus/omake to the UC+CC series and I like how the themes being explored ties in to that. It's about the little character interactions and how they interact with the world around them. In a way, G-Reco is like Blame!, it's not about the story, it's just about throwing you into the world and see how their characters are a like.

Aldnoah Zero was just boring. it's like it's half-assed itself between trying to be bold (e.g. cliffhanger that appears to kill off cour 1's protagonist, press releases talking about a contrast in cour 1 and cour 2having different focus etc) and trying to be different but in the end it just became yet another by-the-number mecha.

>>153928881
>Everyone'
Nah just MAL and ANN apparently

>>153928890
Very good post.

Almost makes up for the autism of the usual G-Reco fans seen in this thread.

>>153928980
Unfortunately the G-Reco detractors have to show off their stupidity to everyone

>>153929068
Nah.

>>153928890
>Yeah, the story is weak
Stopped reading there

>>153929098
And there he goes again

>>153929155
Keep being a testament to G-Reco fans everywhere, retard bro.

>>153929682
He just won't stop

>>153929682
Stop responding to that shitposter.

>>153929682
>>153929765
Get a room, you two.

>>153919530
>Even IBO is better than g.rekt

Really makes you think

>>153929900
>Stupid things IBOfags say
Not even Japan agrees with you

>>153928890
>Then again, my fav series in the franchise is Turn A
stopped reading there

>>153927711
Would love to get the original of that redhead there. For research purposes, of course.

It's nice to see that people in this thread quickly switched from G-Reco vs A/Z shitposting to G-Reco vs IBO. Maybe A/Z finally stopped triggering enormous autism from mecha fans. There will be new mecha anime directed by Aoki next season. And if by some miracle it turns out to be at least decent I really don't want its threads to be ruined by 1000th iteration of A/Z shitposting.

>>153931006
>There will be new mecha anime directed by Aoki next season.
Its not a mecha

>>153931068
Even if it's not it still has at least one mecha and one mecha pilot. It's enough to attract /m/ crowd and their shitposting.

>>153929900
Found the retard.

>>153931479
>It's enough to attract /m/ crowd and their shitposting.
No not really but I expect /a/ to start trolling /m/ with it

>>153927711
>Basic Human Interaction in the garbage
10/10

>>153919530

Both meme shows that people shitpost for the sake of shit posting, that aren't even that bad in their own right.

So. The usual.

>>153927711
>warning shots
Bellri was fucking based

>>153919530
>G-Recofags were always telling people who disliked their show to stick to Aldnoah Zero, but honestly, I think both shows were equally terrible.
naw. G-reco might be boring and ultimately pointless, but az is on a whole nothing level of bad

A/Z could've been at least decent, and then the second season happened and ruined any possible thing the story could've had going for it. I will still never understand why it became associated with G-Recofags looking down on people who hated it, /a/ didn't even like A/Z at that point either. Still, A/Z is probably worse simply for having an interesting ending to the first season and ruining it completely.

>>153928890
I mostly agree with this anon.
The thing I liked most about G-Reco was how it felt like watching an early UC series. Everything from artstyle to music to suit designs felt like classic Tomino, and was super nostalgic.
It had some of the most fun and likeable characters in any Gundam series imo, and the attention to detail in how the mundane side of the character's lives worked was refreshing compared to shows like 00 and SEED which only ever focused on the mecha part of the setting. Stuff like airbags and built-in toilets, or the architecture and workings of the Venus Globes were really fascinating to see.
Also Bellri is one of the more charismatic and likeable Gundam main characters. He's just some random kid who really wants to bone his sister, and the fact that he wasn't a super powerful Newtype or SUPAH PIROTO or what have you made him more empathetic than most modern Gundam protags.

>>153934478
Stick to AZ. That's why.

>>153919636
>>>/ANN/

>>153934478
A/Z was always shit from the very first episode, where the MC cared more about eggs than the Martian princess dying, and is generally an emotionless husk and yet we're somehow supposed to find it believable that people don't find him creepy.

>>153934829
Right, he was a bizarre motherfucker, but I'm not sure if a character lacking emotion is enough to make everything about it shit. I absolutely agree with you that he doesn't make a good main character in any case. At the end of S1 they killed him off and it seemed like things would finally get interesting as they could've taken it in any number of directions all of which would've been much better than the first season.

Holy shit I remember Greco autists telling everyone to watch A/Z instead. Feels good to know the show crashed and burned and will always remembered as a piece of shit that it is. IBO being a successful fujo pandering follow up AU Gundam series is just icing on the cake.

>>153927711
Pretty good.

>>153935078
Good for you, enjoy your icing cream because the cake is hollow inside.

>>153935078
>the show crashed
Sold better than IBO.

>>153935078
>crashed and burned
It didn't though?

>>153927711
>No bucket of Kuntala Fried Children.
Shameful taboo, commit sudoku.

>>153935191
No, it didn't.

>bellri goes apeshit and anihalates rockpie
Damn, the gself was a fucking monster.

>>153935078
>Feels good to know the show crashed and burned
Yeah that's why it sold well and is getting movies this year
>and will always remembered as a piece of shit that it is.
Only by stupid Americunts

>IBO being a successful fujo pandering follow up AU Gundam series is just icing on the cake.
And it having some of the worst ratings in the franchise and people not giving much of a shit about even the staff is even sweeter.

>>153934972
Eggs was just the tip of the iceberg. The first episode alone has logical flaws up the ass. Such as, why doesn't Asshime have any means of contacting Cruhteo? I mean, she was staying on his ship. And if she does, why didn't she have immediately inform him that the person who died was a body double? I stands to reason that she would have been provided some Earth guards so why didn't they inform the people that the Asshime that died wasn't the real one?

>>153935593
I'm not going to argue that a show I watched ages ago that I also think is shit now is really actually any good. The only thing that I am saying is that, whatever flaws the first season had, A/Z could have gone on to be much better following S1's ending. It could have been at least decent. But it isn't, it's just bad. We agree on that.

>>153935524
Keep telling yourself that, bro. Even Try was more popular than Greco. Greco and Age are the more irrelevant and ignored Gundam shows since Turn A. And Turn A at least has the excuse of being good.

>>153935954
>Even Try was more popular than Greco.
Greco sold more thab Try and had better ratings
>>153935954
>Greco and Age are the more irrelevant and ignored Gundam shows since Turn A.
(You )

>>153936117
And Try had more discussion, fanarts, merch, Gunpla, a sequel, side materials... And more importantly, people still remember it.

>>153936560
>And Try had more discussion
Nope
>fanarts
Who cares
>merch
Nope
>Gunpla
Because it was about Gunpla
>a sequel
Nope
>side material
The only side material are for GBF not TRY
>And more importantly, people still remember it.
Nope.

>>153937673
>being this delusional
Tsukame praido and Greco is better and more popular than Try, right? Gotta stick to those delusions, it's the only thing you have.

>>153938225
Serious question, what are you trying to achieve here? People who care can already check the sales records/ moon sites to see that you're wrong. People like you who already hate it irrationally already hold the same thought as you so preaching to the choir is pointless. Who are you trying to convince here?

File: tumblr_ndkn9oLOXt1r3rdh2o1_500.gif (432KB, 500x375px) Image search: [Google]

432KB, 500x375px

>>153919985

Aldnoah Zero is worse because of how much potential it had to be a masterpiece. It threw all that away

G-Reco was shit from start to finish