>Michiko no Hatchin >Fujiko Mine >Yuri on Ice >various

>>152590158
No.

Mine Fujiko was a disgrace to the franchise though.

>>152590158
>yaoi on ice
>saving anime

But i gotta say though, THE best female anime director out there with her current reputation.

>>152590158
Literally who?

>>152590305
Naoko Yamada is miles better.

>>152590158
Fujiko was garbage and Yuri on Ice was unremarkable aside from the ambitious skating and gayness.

>>152590305
Right now it's Makoto Moriwaki. Will be Eunyoung Choi whenever she gets to direct something for real

>>152590347
>Makoto Moriwaki
Literally who?

No, she's a middling director who covers subject material that's somewhat out-of-the-ordinary for anime.

>>152590158
Only ones liking her works are probably fujoshi and anime reviewers on ANN.

File: 1477297288234.jpg (548KB, 1000x1000px) Image search: [Google]

548KB, 1000x1000px

>>152590323
I will say she is the better director once she finally functions outside of her crutch studio and staffs. Even a noob director would do a decent job if they're backed with talented animators and storyboarders with the likes kyoani. But at this point she just like to keep staying in her comfort zone.

>>152590879
>Even a noob director would do a decent job if they're backed with talented animators and storyboarders with the likes kyoani.
Kigami, Ishidate, and Yamakan all utterly failed in their debut.
Hell Yamakan got fired for being an incompetent director.

>>152590158
Damn she hasn't been involved in a good series at all. Guess she got lucky with appealing to fujo with yoi.

>>152590329
My wife Yamada is so cute

>>152591006
Yamakan got fired because he tried to rape my beloved Yamada, but he was kinda decent as a director.

File: luckystar.jpg (33KB, 544x144px) Image search: [Google]

33KB, 544x144px

>>152591081
Yamakan officially got fired for not being up to par as a director

>>152590879
>Even a noob director would do a decent job if they're backed with talented animators and storyboarders with the likes kyoani.
Do you think all of KyoAni's output is of identical quality then?

She looks fucking crazy.

Literally who?

>>152591006
Their debut was a long time ago when kyoani wasn't yet a big name and their in-house staff wasn't groomed to potential. Now everyone is paying attention the dragon maid anime just because it's being adapted by kyoani. I bet if a newbie director is doing maid dragon right now, it'd still get just as a popular reception.

tl;dr if you're building a reputation in kyoani, you're going to have an easy time

>Yamakan got fired for being an incompetent director
And he got fired from his own studio. That's why i wonder how well would these directors fare outside of kyoani. Let's see if you'd still defend Yamada then.

File: 1484059143295.jpg (90KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

90KB, 1280x720px

>>152591006
Ishidate was doomed to fail because he's Kigami's student, maybe if he was under Ishihara he would have nailed it like Yamada did.

>>152591204
Of course, they all have decent production quality, are they not? Weren't you all just gushing at that one scene in maid dragon episode 2?

Yamada is clearly better, and she's also nearly 10 years younger than Yamamoto who's already got a dried up womb

>>152591433
All KyoAni shows have good production quality, but that has nothing to do with the director.

>>152591672
Of course.

>>152590158
Objecting power ranking:

Fujiko Mine > Michiko to Hatchin > Yuri on ice

>>152591433
Deliberate obtuseness is fun