[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / bant / biz / c / can / cgl / ck / cm / co / cock / d / diy / e / fa / fap / fit / fitlit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mlpol / mo / mtv / mu / n / news / o / out / outsoc / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / spa / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vint / vip / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Search | Free Show | Home]

2017 will be the year isekai saves anime

This is a blue board which means that it's for everybody (Safe For Work content only). If you see any adult content, please report it.

Thread replies: 513
Thread images: 87

File: dungeon seeker.jpg (161KB, 728x1030px) Image search: [Google]
dungeon seeker.jpg
161KB, 728x1030px
2017 will be the year isekai saves anime
>>
>>151707554
Why?
>>
File: mudada.jpg (146KB, 960x758px) Image search: [Google]
mudada.jpg
146KB, 960x758px
>>151707554
>more video game shit
>>
At least make a decent otherworld, no RPG mechanics if you never played a game in your life
>>
File: 3588e57c66a6dee6c900b58404697749.png (306KB, 800x1137px) Image search: [Google]
3588e57c66a6dee6c900b58404697749.png
306KB, 800x1137px
>>151707554
>This will take over battle-shounen within the next decade
>>
>>151707554
But evasion is useless if you dump accuracy
>>
>>151709288
>what is RNG fuckery
>>
>>151707554
Godmode evasion stat, get's knocked out by a club to the head by a random villager. nice.
>>
File: dragon-ball-super-how-will-power.jpg (211KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]
dragon-ball-super-how-will-power.jpg
211KB, 1280x720px
>>151709234
>>
>>151707554
What I like about this manga is how artist's artstyle convey all this edginess. A perfect union with the story.
>>
Mushoku Tensei anime 2017 is practically guaranteed. Feels good getting to see Roxy's panties animated in all it's pure white glory.
>>
>>151707554
Is Sakamoto666 /our guy/?
>>
>>151709355
Dodge works only from the front.
>>
hp tank > armor tank > hp regen tank > healer tank >>> shit >>>>>>>> evasion tank
>>
>>151710986
He's not a tank, he's a glass canon.
>>
File: 000014.png (381KB, 850x1208px) Image search: [Google]
000014.png
381KB, 850x1208px
>>151710866
No. He is hero we can only dream to become.
>>
>>151710997
A glass cannon has high atk, that guy has nothing
>>
File: img000020.png (409KB, 888x1263px) Image search: [Google]
img000020.png
409KB, 888x1263px
>>151711048
He has high level weapons which give him an ATK boost.
>>
>>151707554
why are we still talking about this ripoff?
>>
Funny, that was 2016.
>>
>>151711110
That is agi tank. Not a glass cannon.
>>
>>151711110
AGI can only get you so far. That shit DEF will bite him in the back sooner or later.
>>
>>151711617
He is DPS not a tank. Even a AGI tank needs to be able to take more than one hit.
>>
>>151711635
Depends on the game. I've seen AGI turn one into an unhittable god unless the enemy has an always accurate attack.

And since there's no luck stat things like crits are likely determined by AGI too.
>>
>>151707554
>ultra grade appraisal
The fuck does that mean

>inb4 he can make an ordinary stone a diamond just by "appraising it"
>>
File: 1476629267249.jpg (42KB, 480x360px) Image search: [Google]
1476629267249.jpg
42KB, 480x360px
I don't mind isekai but god damn if it doesn't get hard to remember the differences between most of them after awhile.
>>
>>151707554
Why does /a/ love this shit so much?
>>
File: 1471923072217.png (23KB, 212x172px) Image search: [Google]
1471923072217.png
23KB, 212x172px
What's even the point in 90% of contemporary Isekai featuring a videogame RPG System when it's not even a videogame. You could completely remove it and nothing would change at all.

Skills like Appraisal only exists because the author is a lazy shit that doesn't want to explain the strength of an enemy properly.
>>
>>151711793
Looking at the way nips use it, it probably gives him the ability to see everything about a monster when he uses it.
>>
>>151711110
Why does every isekai have to resort to stats

It's such a fucking copout
>>
>>151711859
Cruel gods who love RPGs making RPG mechanic based worlds to play their own version of videogames.

Yet being so lazy they bring in bots(Isekai Protags) to beat the game for them.
>>
Can we get an isekai with NO magic and NO rpg mechanics, with actual worldbuilding for once?
>>
>>151707554
>Sakamoto666 got his WN deleted on narou because of plagiarism
>A place where almost everyone copy/pastes the most popular shit which is on top of the list
How badly did he fuck up?
>>
>>151711929
>every isekai
Its not even most of them
>>
>>151711929
Because the majority of the writers are hacks who couldn't have an original idea if you stuck all their heads together.
>>
>>151711929
Just modern ones, they want to skip all the world building.
>>
>>151711956
That's stupid and boring. Why make a world where people are fucked aan't actually blame the RNG for actually screwing them over? Only some kind, benevolent deity would not intentionally fuck up the place for fun.
>>
>>151711978
In another DS thread someone said that the latter chapters of the novel were literally Arifureta, word for word, except for some name changing
So pretty bad
>>
>>151712027
Did you have too much wine on the new year's table anon?
>>
File: 1313432519021.jpg (19KB, 235x204px) Image search: [Google]
1313432519021.jpg
19KB, 235x204px
>>151711956
Like Muv-Luv Alternative?
>>
>>151707554
What's he gonna do with 6000 slime?

I hope the helpful notes bro won't also turn out to be a backstabbing shit.
>>
>>151712078
I hadn't thought of it like that, I had medieval worlds in mind, but now that I think about it yes, alternate versions of our world or even cyberpunk and steam-punk settings can work.
>>
Wouldn't it be great if the guy that bullied him ended up even more broken than he was after he gets out
>>
>>151712122
Will it involve cell phones?
>>
MC is so fuck as soon as he gets to an enemy with an unavoidable attack.
>>
>>151707554
Is Drifters isekai?
>>
>>151712017

World building is fucking laborious. Only a few people can actually pull it right. It's not something that gets better with practice, as well.

Jumping a bit out of the anime/manga world, there is a reason why authors like J.K Rowling and J.R.R. Tolkien became quite famous. It's all about the world building.

You rarely find an author that is both good at drawing, composition and a good storyteller (well versed in world building).
>>
>>151712017
I don't understand why you would think that when there's just as much without it, see Majou no kuni, legend of the white kingdom, Kingdom building chronicles, Mushoku tensei, Black Maria, Risou no Himo, Nagai Koto and much more.

/a/ just likes to shitpost about the worst of them.
>>
>>151712162

yes
>>
>>151712140
Let's not go there.

>>151712162
Yes. It's actually sort of the isekai I would like to see, people going into another world and inventing shit and conquering.
>>
File: 1334657945742.jpg (126KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]
1334657945742.jpg
126KB, 1280x720px
>>151712187
Well I'm sorry Mr Isekai Expert.
>>
My favorite Isekai is Tensei Shitara Slime data ken

It's just fun and I really enjoy the world building.

And I especially enjoy that he's building his own country and not just walking aimlessly in the world.
>>
>>151712051
Jesus that sounds awful I wonder if the LN fixed it.
>>
>>151712112
As of the end of vol. 2 he is still a bro.
>>
>>151712166
This. Also, both Rowling and Tolkien relied heavily on other literary eras for references and such. Rowling was, especially in her nomenclature, relying mostly on Roman and Greek literature and mythology, whereas Tolkien drew a lot of inspiration from Nordic and Anglo cultures with the token Greek reference (Numenor, also called Atalante), and later incorporates some Christian stuff as well.
>>
>>151712187
>Legend if the White Kingdom
Pretty good. The art is also good and it helps that MC married best girl 10 Chapters in. Though I feel like the Isekai part only exists to get the Isekai fans on board since its completely irrelevant after 3 pages in.
>>
>>151707554
I hope we get to see slut girl taking giant dick.
>>
seems just like an angrier version of shield hero to me
>>
>>151712467
Makes sense. Shield Hero just got robbed and then painted as the villain. This guy gets cucked by his bully and then thrown into a death dungeon.
>>
File: Nice joke m8.png (763KB, 908x676px) Image search: [Google]
Nice joke m8.png
763KB, 908x676px
>>151712344
>>151712166
>Harry Potter have good worldbuilding
>Tolkien is a good writer

The only reason Harry Potter become popular is because it is written for the consumption of children without the writer belittling the reader too much and the vocabulary demonstrate that, making it literature that is readable to the masses. As fiction, it's averagely entertaining and its worldbuilding is simply witch folklores tack on with the wording changed.

Tolkien is a garbage writer. Very few can read his actual books to the end due to how boring and pointlessly verbose it is. He use 1000 sentences to write about something when 20 will do.
Many people attribute Tolkien in regards to modern fantasy but that's just wanking when most fantasy is based on all the fictional works on their time of creation, not just boring textbooks about European folklores written by an old fart.
>>
Is there an isekai where a massively overpowered garry stu from a fantasy world get's summoned to the real world and becomes a reclusive NEET with no freinds?
>>
>>151712590
Hataraku Maou-sama is something like that. But he becomes wageslave in mcdonalds instead of NEET.
>>
>>151712658
Yeah, that and Yuushibu were the closest thing I could think of.
>>
>>151712589
I wonder that, if Lord of the Rings are never made and Hollywood use other fantasy writers such Raymond Feist for their movies, would anybody give a shit about Tolkien?
>>
>>151709355
Dodge stats don't matter during cutscene, anon
>>
>>151712763
Never read the Lord of the ring books but the hobbit is a short delightful read.
>>
>>151709234
>Implying
Battle-shounen is eternal.
As long as WSJ is alive, Battle-shounen will never die
>>
>>151712785
Because the hobbit is written to pander to teenagers of his era, unlike his other works.
>>
>>151711818
>why does /a/ love stories that feature losers with no real skills being transported to video game based fantasy would and gaining the affection of a harem of girls, with one elf usually included

Gee, I wonder why.
>>
File: foundation_covers.jpg (371KB, 1248x662px) Image search: [Google]
foundation_covers.jpg
371KB, 1248x662px
>>151712589
You forgot to mention the part where you marked an envelope every time a character "stretched his legs" and how reading Rowling trains you to read Stephen King

>>151712763
He'd probably be on the same level as Asimov.
Interestingly enough, New Line was actually working on the Foundation trilogy before they shifted to LOTR
>>
File: maou shoujo ariel-chan kumo.jpg (246KB, 1500x1900px) Image search: [Google]
maou shoujo ariel-chan kumo.jpg
246KB, 1500x1900px
>>151712925
Isekai only works when the reincarnation itself gives an interesting angle to the story.

>Mushoku Tensei: Restarting life with the intelligence and determination of an adult from birth
>Kumo-chan: Using the cunning of a human to survive as a weak spider monster
>Kingdom Reform: Political science student with a hard-on for Machiavelli uses his expansive knowledge of history and diplomacy to improve a medieval kingdom
>Everyone Else is a Returnee: MC is the only person on earth who WASN'T isekai'd

Otherwise it might as well just be a normal fantasy story
>>
>>151707554
Lets see

>Youjo Senki
>Knights and Magic
>Death March
>Some food isekai
I don't know, but at least it beats Arifureta getting adapted!Though the threads would've been amazing thats for sure
>>
Slime isekai was decent
>>
File: 1460775316295.png (72KB, 223x255px) Image search: [Google]
1460775316295.png
72KB, 223x255px
>bland as fuck MC
>with an edgy defined attitude
>sidegun that's legendary
>bullied highschool kid turned badass
>even more edgy bored antagonist
>g-gotta save muh love interest
I hope you guys don't make these threads daily because you like it, right?
>>
File: You have to try harder.png (9KB, 500x501px) Image search: [Google]
You have to try harder.png
9KB, 500x501px
>>151712589
>Tolkien is a garbage writer.Very few can read his actual books to the end due to how boring and pointlessly verbose it is
>>
>>151712925
What I like about reincarnated isekai (not the transported isekai) is that the MCs try to fix their problem in their previous life. It gives them at least decent characterization with their problem, like gun-ota.
For transported isekai, as long as it's fun to follow I'll just read it to waste my time.
>>
Here is an idea to make an Isekai story interesting: to make good Isekai, it has to be suffering porn, edgy, and it has to have to a MC that faces some opposition.

So what you do is you pull a merciless double-Isekai.

>Isekai story where not one, but TWO guys get killed and reincarnated in a fantasy world where they are both OP as fuck
>but one is the leader of a group of rebels fighting to free the mountain people from an evil noble
>and the other guy IS THE EVIL NOBLE
>if the rebel wins, the noble guy and his friends are killed and you get a loop
>if the noble wins, the rebel and his friends are killed and you get a loop
>as they go through loops again and again, the rebel becomes more and more heroic, while the noble guy becomes more and more evil (pic related)
>the two MCs get more and more entrenched in their roles, following a clichƩd fantasy narrative

The story can end there as a FUCK YOU to Isekai stories, with the MCs getting fuck-all for their efforts and OPness, or it can change. Another character can get Isekaied as a third party to break the deadlock, or maybe the MCs figure out they have to work together, or maybe the only way to break the loop is for both of them to die at the same time, following which they become mythical figures in the fantasy world (and in the epilogue, two more people from our world turn up there... and it turns out people getting Isekaied there is how the legends of that world are born).
>>
>>151713497
edgy isekai is the worst
neck yerself
>>
>>151713528
>edgy isekai is the worst

Agreed. But the reason I make my example edgy is to give a motivation to the characters to continue doing their shit. They want to end the other guy rightly so their friends donĀ“t suffer torture or death.

Also, I really like Wolfsmund and I just read it to the end (it is finally over!).
>>
>>151713497
Pic not related? That's a historical edgy manga and a pretty good one at that. Although that fuckhead gets tiresome after a large chunk of the manga he gets his just deserts in the end.
>>
>>151713417
But what is he going to do with all the slimes?
>>
>>151713417
>love interest
The weird thing is so far he has none at all.

Unless you count shota god.
>>
>>151713528
Nothing can't be the worse than commu.
>>
File: 013_1483072451.jpg (355KB, 951x1352px) Image search: [Google]
013_1483072451.jpg
355KB, 951x1352px
It will save 2017, but will it save another world with only the abilities of seven superhuman high school students who can do anything?

Is this a parody? Is Misora Riku a hack?
>>
>>151713764
I'm voting either slime mecha or he will feed them small parts of his body to get an army of poison slime.
>>
>>151709355
Worse yet can't even break free from the peasant girl whose more than a hundred levels lower. His whole strategy is completely useless against surprise attacks and is even losing it's edge against the current enemies. And the one time he gets thrown a fucking bone that perfectly complements his style it drives him fucking nuts before being promptly stolen from him. Kinda sad really.
>>
>>151707554
>reading the ln
>junpei gets a free magic erupting burning finger to destroy his enemies when his speed fails him

Just when I think it can't get worse.
>>
>>151714935
>Just when I think it can't get any better.

ftfy
>>
>>151714935
He didn't even get to use it outside of that one asshole before it drove him mad and the skill stealing bitch took it from him though.
>>
>>151715612
>skill stealing bitch took his cursed ability that drove him mad so he could regain his sanity

Not really seeing much a drawback unless his arm never grows back even in healing zones. When Junpei steals skills he usually kills the victim in the process so she was very kind in comparison.
>>
>>151711110

What was his latest skill list in the novel? Did he get the torture guy's skill?
>>
>>151715852
>>
File: raw.png (92KB, 512x671px) Image search: [Google]
raw.png
92KB, 512x671px
>>151715957
>>
>>151712589

About Harry Potter, I agree it might not be an epic literature piece. And what I am arguing is that worldbuilding and storytelling is so much more than just exploring folklore and expanding it.

It is also about making the pieces connect together. There has been only a handful of works (anime/manga related) that have achieved this.

And because there are so few of them, it is truly enjoyable when you come across such a piece.

Not everyone needs to be great at writing, drawing or even at worldbuilding. But sometimes I wish people put a bit more effort in balancing these.
>>
File: 005.jpg (497KB, 1304x1854px) Image search: [Google]
005.jpg
497KB, 1304x1854px
Anyone scanlate this yet?
>>
>>151713585
>the first 5 pages of chapter 1
I'm getting Saint Foires Festival flashbacks and I do not like it.
>>
>>151715788
Point was >>151714935 bitching about it was kinda meaningless since it literally showed up for less than a chapter before it was taken from him. And he's probably getting thrown outside now so it'll be a while before it gets brought up again.
>>
File: d003.jpg (600KB, 1672x1200px) Image search: [Google]
d003.jpg
600KB, 1672x1200px
>desc: "A young pharmacologist and researcher in Japan died from overworking, and was reincarnated in a Medieval Parallel Europe."

I think this one is like Mushoku tensei, where the 30something year old becomes reincarnated as a rich kid with magic powers. This time it's alchemy.

2017 will be peak isekai. New ones are being made every month
>>
>>151717217
This got a manga s well? Damn.
>>
>>151707554
>Have passive that can retaliate with massive blight/acid/poison damage when hit
>can't get hit
His build is fucking retard
>>
>>151711635
In Payday 2 I run dodge and I laugh as I watch all the slow shitters who use Armor getting downed constantly
>>
I don't wanna go to some weird MMO/JRPG pseudo fantasy world

I want to stay here
>>
>>151707554
yo, this page is edgy as fuck.
>what if like... we made a sasuke.. but gave him a magnum!!!! lol
>>
>>151717703
He doesn't need to get hit in order to use his poison you know. Controlled self-inflicted damage and poison slime abuse is a million times better than letting the shit with Cerberus happen again. His build is still retarded as fuck just because of what happened in the cannibal village, and the fact his poison isn't worth shit on lower levels.
>>
File: edge.jpg (121KB, 728x1031px) Image search: [Google]
edge.jpg
121KB, 728x1031px
>>151717828

It gets worse every chapter. He gets trapped by a cannibal village later and chopped up for food, but his entire body is made of poison.
>>
File: NT2.jpg (96KB, 1024x819px) Image search: [Google]
NT2.jpg
96KB, 1024x819px
>>151717828

not just any magnum. It's National Treasure rank
>>
>>151717960
>controlled self-inflicted damage

How does that even work when he only had 10 HP anyway? The lvl 900 mythical beast Cerberus devouring his arm should've inflicted more than 10hp of damage. Stubbing his toe on the corner of a table should put him in the ICU.
>>
>>151711110
How can he use that beast fang weapon thingy if his attack is only 5?
>>
>>151718542
maybe the damage is ā„… based.

or it could be that normal humans have 10 hp
>>
>>151718892
Poke.
>>
>>151718892
maybe it's a dex weapon
>>
>>151718542
Apparently even 10 hp gives you leeway to take hits as long as it's not immediately lethal. Besides, the average human durability over there is like 15 hp and he raises it way beyond that later so it's not like he's that fucked.
>>
How is this any different from Arifureta?
>>
>>151719186
It stays edgy the whole way and no harem.
>>
File: arifureta.jpg (45KB, 509x359px) Image search: [Google]
arifureta.jpg
45KB, 509x359px
>>151719186

In Arifureta, MC has an eyepatch, white hair and a robot arm. He's also dressed like a Nazi officer for some reason. Instead of one gun, he has like 4 of them, and they have edgy german names, plus he drives a jeep and has a grenade launcher. All that he built himself from scratch, using magic. Arifureta MC also has a harem including a vampire loli, a bunny girl, and a dragon.

This one is a solo adventure of a guy who was thrown into a new world by an evil, bored god. Some similarities, but it's more edge-fulfillment than wish-fulfillment. He gets betrayed by everyone he trusts, while arifureta mc keeps growing his harem.
>>
>>151711635
>>151711762
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IcfXnAsBHRY
Never go full agility
>>
>>151712467
Actually this is more comparable to arifureta than shield hero.
>>
>>151707554
Isekai saved 2016 too with Konosuba and Rezero
>>
>>151710809
I can't tell whether or not I like that series.

I think I just hate the way its written, the manga has been solid.
>>
>>151719341
That is some awful character design.
>>
>>151707554
>Level 178
>15 HP
>>
>>151711635
It depends on the game, man.

I made Fie an evasion tank in Trails of Cold Steel II and she had 100% evasion once I built her properly so almost every single attack in the entire game missed her.
>>
>>151719441
Yet it sells like hotcakes. The japs love it.
>>
File: 016.png (337KB, 800x1137px) Image search: [Google]
016.png
337KB, 800x1137px
I love DS
>>
>>151719565
im gonna read this shit but idk if i should go with the mango or the LN
thoughts anon-senpai?
>>
File: 017.png (320KB, 800x1137px) Image search: [Google]
017.png
320KB, 800x1137px
>>
File: 018.png (303KB, 800x1137px) Image search: [Google]
018.png
303KB, 800x1137px
>>
File: 019.png (487KB, 800x1137px) Image search: [Google]
019.png
487KB, 800x1137px
>>
>>151719341
> He's also dressed like a Nazi officer for some reason.

That's not any kind of Nazi officer uniform.

It is just some edgy chuuni clothes piled over.
>>
>>151719599
She knows what's up.
>>
>>151719418
Both of those only worked because they were toying with regular Isekai traditions.

Konosuba with a character who really doesn't care about changing the world or himself and Re Zero where the only rpg mechanic is a save point function and otherwise the main character is a big of a shit as he should be.

Nobody likes the Isekai in the OP post where the guy comes from nowhere and is suddenly super good at everything because he was a neet who only played video games all day and he can autistically crunch numbers about stupid shit.
>>
>>151713417
>bland as fuck MC
I'll give you that
>with an edgy defined attitude
That's a bad thing?
>sidegun that's legendary
I'll also give you that since I barely saw any use out of it yet
>bullied highschool kid turned badass
I'll even give you that
>even more edgy bored antagonist
Again, that's a bad thing?
>g-gotta save muh love interest
Are you retarded? Who's his love interest?
>>
>>151719964
I love the people who try to defend Re:Zero's MC who's a murdering, rapist, hypocrite.
>>
File: 149435023543.jpg (159KB, 1080x1920px) Image search: [Google]
149435023543.jpg
159KB, 1080x1920px
>>151713528
>edgy isekai is the worst
But that's wrong, faggot; it's a requirement.
>>
File: 746804678467.jpg (8KB, 210x240px) Image search: [Google]
746804678467.jpg
8KB, 210x240px
>>151720019
rapist?
>>
>>151719598
manga is short, then go for LN so you can read how slut chan regrets tricking him and then being sold into sex slaves and kills alpha fag by shoving poison into his asshole
>>
>>151720047
The elves? Though who seriously gives a fuck about knife-ears.
>>
>>151719598
It's not even that far along; you can catch up fairly quick. Updates are apparently slow as well.
>>
>>151719441
>>151719563
>tfw /a/ speaks in code about how good it is but make it seem like it's bad to the public
You guys are so weird
>>
>>151720092
That's re:monster, not re:zero.
there's a difference one is good and the other is harry potter.
>>
>>151720288
Oh. Well, fuck me then. I'm just an idiot.
>>
>>151720288
So re:monster is good and re:zero is shit like Harry Potter?
>>
>>151719598
where did you find the LN?
>>
>>151719964

In dungeon seeker, there's nothing particularly special about the MC at first. He just accidentally finds a way of killing the "unkillable" first zone boss, and gets insanely powerleveled from just that.

After that, he has the snowball effect of his skill-hunting ability, which just exponentially powers up any protagonist who has ever had it.
>>
>>151720446
Nah, Re:Monster is "Ohlook I ate a rock and gained these 7 skills." and "I stopped a bunch of goblins from raping women, look how awesome I am. What do you mean drugging elves to fuck them is rape?"
>>
>>151712166

But we have Kawakami as our Tolkien
>>
>>151720603
So both of them are shit then.
>>
>>151720731
I haven't read Re:Zero, but it sounds nicer at least.
>>
File: 1479365867722.png (2MB, 2560x1440px) Image search: [Google]
1479365867722.png
2MB, 2560x1440px
Why can't these damn things ever have consistent clothing?
Castles, horse pulled carts, small villages of wooden houses but everyone's wearing jeans, cardigans, schoolgirl skirts, fur coat leather jackets or early 20th century military garb.
>>
>>151720675
Tanaka Romeo is better.
>>
>>151720463
literally googled "dungeon seeker english"
https://paichuntranslations.com/tds/
>>
>>151720805
i was hoping for something more readable but ok
>>
>>151719599

What ever happened to her anyway?
>>
File: new gate.jpg (400KB, 844x1200px) Image search: [Google]
new gate.jpg
400KB, 844x1200px
>>151720783

Probably because isekai draws inspiration from video games, not folklore.
>>
>>151719964

The MC in OP's pic isn't even using NEET skills. He just became really edgy after getting cucked real hard
>>
>>151720783
Because they're all authored by 21 y/o NEETs who dont know anything about history and don't want to put in the effort to learn.
>>
File: green_penis.gif (492KB, 460x345px) Image search: [Google]
green_penis.gif
492KB, 460x345px
>there'll never be an isekai taking place in 18th-20th century America
>>
>>151720890
>you will never get cucked so hard you become a super hero and save the future
>>
>>151720951

The first ever isekai was written in the 19th century by an american. It started the tradition of only going to medieval fantasy-europe
>>
>>151720844
Well The bully sells her once he gets tired of her and she gets passed around by masters that are into some weird sex shit. Eventually, one her classmates that was part of the bully's group buys her because he liked her but never had the guts to go for her. He proceeds to try to rape her because edgy death world. She comes to the realization of how much of a bitch she had been and kills the guy by shoving poison in his ass. She takes his Clairvoyance skill and decides to start hunting for rare skills to get revenge.
>>
Every single isekai that gives attributes and skill values to its characters, or is otherwise based off video game mechanics, is absolute garbage and I refuse to be a part of it.
>>
>>151707554
>muh ordinary Nipponk students Stronk

For once i want to see an Isekai with a Japanese MC who gets owned for being an incompetent femboy bitch and who has delusions of being great.

Bonus points for some westerners ''snatching'' the ''hero'' position and having the cheat powers while the MC stalks them with his inferiority complex.
>>
>>151721134
That's actually not as straight forward as i'd imagine it going down.
>>
>>151721195
The one with the spider is delightfully decent.
>>
>>151713417
I think the point of the manga was to laugh at the MC and the cringe he brings to the table.
>>
>>151721195

It's not the use of attributes itself that's bad, it's that it tempts the writer into fucking up the pacing of the story. Arifureta and Re:Monster started off interesting when it was a struggle for survival, but now both MCs are demi-gods. Without struggle, there's no excitement. It's like playing an RPG with gameshark codes to get infinite health and mana.

There's an isekai where a girl is reborn as a weak little spider. It's pretty far along, but still great because the author used the power-ups very sparingly.
>>
>>151717217
There's one of a dude who gets reincarnated as a nobles son.
He's so affraid of dying again that he starts to research alchemy/magic/medicine etc. from a young age.
Then he goes of the deep end with the research and goes full Dr.Death.
>>
>>151721501
Not to mention the spider gets fucked up quite a few times, so they quite literally struggle the entire way up.

I liked it.
>>
>>151719964
Hey Kazumas only real cheat power is his super-high luck stat which only comes to play in games and marksmanship.
He's super gimped most of the time and stuck with the worst possible muchkin party,
And then there's the point of
>NEET MC gets transported to another world
>Only to become a NEET again
>>
>>151707554
You know what would be even better? By making girls the protagonists and giving them the harems, turning into a yuri amazon battle harem! It's genius!
>>
File: animewhen.jpg (378KB, 774x1100px) Image search: [Google]
animewhen.jpg
378KB, 774x1100px
need this to get an anime, or atleast more chapters
>>
>>151707554
I would rather have anti-Isekai
Like where magical holy beings came to our world to become normal beings in society, while keeping touch with their own world.

Dude Isekai is a great concept, but milk the idea too much, and we will all be tired of it eventually.
>>
>>151709440
Even if it is DB it is still fucking impressive of the number of people that streams it on YT
>>
>>151722319
Like Hataraku Maou-sama? No thanks.
>>
File: 1469360794410.jpg (46KB, 285x322px) Image search: [Google]
1469360794410.jpg
46KB, 285x322px
>berserk does edge
>holy shit this is the best thing ever
>any modern manga/LN/anime does edge
>what is this edgy chuunishit
>>
>>151722566
Guts is a beefcake. Modern MCs are not
>>
>>151712051
Copying Arifureta is a sign of pretty bad standards
>>
>>151722566
Comedic relief is important
>>
>>151722566

Guts isn't a 15 year old japanese high school student.
>>
What the fuck is a "skill hunter" anyway?
>>
>>151719341
Started reading the manga and is 100% power tripping self-fulfilment.
>>
>>151723326
someone who hunts for skills
>>
File: 16.jpg (126KB, 713x1024px) Image search: [Google]
16.jpg
126KB, 713x1024px
Should there be more isekai with cute girl MCs?
>>
>>151723326

A rip-off of the blue mage from final fantasy. Basically collecting unique skills that monsters and bosses have
>>
>>151721259
It was rather surprising. It's still edgy shit, but usually, with revenge plots like this, the bitch stays one-dimensionally evil.
>>
>>151723801
No.
>>
>>151723801

There's the one of the guy reincarnated as a sword, and the one who finds him is some slave girl
>>
>>151721910

You kinda described Saki.
>>
The only non-comedy focused isekai I really like right now is Chihou Kishi Hans no Junan, as the MC is a natural inhabitant of the fantasy world who has to deal with all the Japs being sent there en masse all of a sudden. It's a great read, in that all the isekai'd are treated as people, rather than the insanely determined gary stu's, and are mostly just grateful for him finding them work and lodging.
>>
File: 020_1482806222.png (481KB, 1000x1422px) Image search: [Google]
020_1482806222.png
481KB, 1000x1422px
>>151724289
Haha, I remember that thread.
>>
>>151719341
Vampire loli is truly best girl.
>>
>>151712970
Why is sci-fi so underrated? Is it because it's "harder to digest" when they're novels? Sci-fi often explores ideas that are novel or far more interesting than tired old tropes in fantasy literature, but fantasy is always more popular.
>>
>>151714106
I got the feeling it was a parody but he went very seriously into business boy's chapters.

I thought it'd be boring as fuck if it tried to take itself seriously with an over the top setting like that but i kinda like it, in the same way i like Dangan Ronpa and i don't know why.
>>
>>151724445

Whats the source on this?
>>
>>151724630

Because there's too many types of sci-fi while fantasy has a loose definition of fairy tale creatures that people are familiar with and sci-fi is much harder to pull off since there are no go-to established races in aliens unless its star trek or star wars
>>
>>151724845
Tensei Shitara Ken deshita
>>
>>151724964

my man
>>
>>151721600
Name?
>>
>>151724445
man this series is stupid as all hell.
>>
File: 053.jpg (451KB, 1022x1121px) Image search: [Google]
053.jpg
451KB, 1022x1121px
Blandy McBland is killed one day after a fire broke out in his apartment, only to reawaken in a new universe...as a still molten freshly born planet.

Blandy McBland can subtly influence all the laws that govern his planet because of a field of magical energy that covers him. Realizing how BORING being a giant floating rock in space can be, he quickly (in Planet time) begins to work so that his planet can support life.

When life finally develops, he learns that his overall strength of his magic field increases with each life and death on the planet proportional to how influential that lifeform was to the planet. He also gains all their memories and experiences upon death.

Thus for a while he enjoys the simple life of raising life, thwarting extinction events and seeing what crazy shit he can do to influence evolution. Eventually humanity develops but around the time humanity reaches the medieval society, something strange begins happening.

People are being born whose memories don't come to him upon their death and who are able to actually draw and deplete his overall pool of magical energy. Eventually a friend of one of those people dies and he learns that these people are likely people from his Earth being reincarnated onto him and basically using him as a means to get their rocks off and live out their power fantasies.

Now Blandy McBland at first is tolerant upon learning, but when one of these Isekaijin fucks up one of his favorite civilizations and goes on to do it again and again, Blandy McBland now decides that they've all got to die and he's got to find a away to do so before they waste all his assimilated magic energy and turn him into an unthinking rock of a planet.
>>
>>151709234
Not all isekai are equal.
Reddit zero for example doesn't count as a true battle isekai.

Slime and spider will open the flood gates when they get an anime.
>>
>>151711110
trash ass build desu
>>
>>151725343
not gonna lie, if written well enough that could be rather awesome.
>>
>>151725276
You should see all the replies that page got in one thread.
>>
lost it
>>
>>151725655
Also neko-Yukino a cute
>>
>>151709234
>implying when fucking dragonball is still going.
>>
Was killing the dryad really worth it? I'm really feeling the edge
>>
Vol 3 ilustrations just updated at paichuns'

>>151712925
This may happen lmao
>>
>>151726380
who? gotta be specific here, considering it's general now
>>
>>151726380
Mimicry skill could be quite usefull since he is (as of now) a glass cannon, yet doesnĀ“t seem like his going to use it anytime soon....
>>
>>151726460

Dungeon Seeker, he killed the qt Dryad who actually is peaceful for a mimicry skill that he actually hasn't used yet.
>>
File: 1479590650127.jpg (59KB, 500x375px) Image search: [Google]
1479590650127.jpg
59KB, 500x375px
>>151715957
>catching M-block
>>
>>151726924
the hell is that even mean?
>>
>>151712162
No,its a after life story,not an isekai. Dantes inferno isnt isekai,drifters isnt isekai
>>
>>151727097
Gantz isn't isekai?
>>
File: 1481434066329.jpg (45KB, 400x400px) Image search: [Google]
1481434066329.jpg
45KB, 400x400px
>Friendly remineder of the best isekai out there.
>>
>>151727097
> MC's from driftters go to another world right before dying
> They go to a medieval era world with magic
> There are most of the races previously mentioned / tipical of isekai genre

So... yeah. It may be different, but Driffters IS an Isekai
>>
>>151727097

But the Drifters didn't die, they just got transported right before they're about to die
>>
>>151727195

Honestly, I'm just waiting for more cooking isekai
>>
>>151727280
that one is nice as well
>>
>>151722621
>>151723215
But Guts is a cuck. Griffith did nothing wrong.
>>
>>151727195
I love that spider.

I just with the LN was better than written than 1st person.
I want more descriptions in the area, what things look like and the like instead of "lol and then I shot web"
>>
>>151725655
>>151725705
This would be decent if not for Whitepod's autistic blurbs on every page.
>>
>>151727280
how's that work though? is it in medieval, futuristic or alien world?
>>
>>151727195
I cant relate to a bug so fuck that
>>
>>151727485

Normally set in fantasy medieval and adventurer's POV get comfy in a modern restaurant.
>>
>>151727509
give it a read. It is fun to see how a girl would do in a world like re:monster
>>
>>151727584
I cant self insert as a bug or a girl
>>
>>151726589
Then he went on to kill the youkai chick he could have just passed by but he just had to go for mind reading. It was actually pretty funny that after all that effort the mind reading was race-specific so it was all for naught.
>>
>>151727826
> She didnĀ“t let him pass to the next floor and wanted to kill him --> need to kill her
>>
>>151720951
>alternatehistory.net
>>
>>151727416
nigga just ignore them. it takes a while but it works.
>>
>>151727195
We already have some images of konosuba/re:zero crossover. Just what will be next?
>>
File: Team.jpg (66KB, 600x438px) Image search: [Google]
Team.jpg
66KB, 600x438px
>>151725182
>>151721600
It was the Ouroboros Record. Author has been in a slump since April.
>>
>>151727942
He figured ou her trick moreover she even lets you pass if you're not a total idiot. Besides that she literally can't move from her spot so he could have bypassed her completely with his agi. MC is just too hung up on his edgefest due to how fucking crazy the dungeon is.
>>
>>151727280
Like that one where some guy from our era become Nobunaga's cook?
>>
File: Hacc.png (614KB, 427x606px) Image search: [Google]
Hacc.png
614KB, 427x606px
I'll give you a decent isekai. Read this.
>>
>>151722566
Berzerk edge feels justified, and there isn't only edge in the world. The world is shit, but it's still a "Human" world.
>>
>>151728401
>another world
>it's literally the same world but she got teleported
>>
>>151729097
She came from the esper world.
>>
>>151729137
"The esper world' is a lab in the normal world.
>>
File: Cover.png (2MB, 410x600px) Image search: [Google]
Cover.png
2MB, 410x600px
>>151727280
Eh, cooking.
>>
>>151729158
This was never said. What are you talking about?
>>
>>151729233
Everyone comes to take her back to the "Foundation" or "The lab". Not once is it ever even implied that this is a different universe or reality, just a well hidden lab. What are you even on that you read this and you immediately thought "World of espers".
>>
>>151729288
Probably because I got mixed up with the author's other work. Hm.
>>
File: Unnamed.jpg (220KB, 620x375px) Image search: [Google]
Unnamed.jpg
220KB, 620x375px
Best Isekai protag.
>>
Let's come up with Isekai plots
>MC is ""loner"" high school student with no friends
>also pervert because represents sexual desires
>hates everyone else for being posers
>brought to magical world
>fuck kings and fuck government, he goes out by himself
>unique magic
>gets a magical elf slave princess because talking to girls is hard when you don't have absolute control over their bodies
>item box
>billions of gold coins, but everyone is so poor that they use a few copper coins each year to feed themselves
>builds a BATH HOUSE
>puts RAW EGGS on RICE
>FERTILIZER and CROP ROTATION
>there's someone more powerful than OP, but OP survives and never has any real conflicts with people who are stronger than him
>>
>>151729568
>Any Isekai who chooses to leave
>The best of anything
>>
>>151729058
Yeah and Guts is not a character people would really self insert in. I doubt most isekai protagonist would ever have raped as a child as part of their history
>>
>>151729983
Man I just want a really good story about someone founding a kingdom. But every time they try it in Isekai they basically skip out on the "founding" part because the OP protagonist has tons of wealth and other shit from being an OP piece of shit.
>>
>>151729988
Why would he stay? His place is at S-mart.
>>
>>151730321
Now I'm remembering the musical again.
>>
File: newchap.jpg (757KB, 836x1200px) Image search: [Google]
newchap.jpg
757KB, 836x1200px
Is this wat people call edgy ?
>>
>>151730428
This dream again, deja vu.
>>
There was this pretty good isekai.

>Humans reincarnate in this one village
>All grownup adults,everyone gets a superpower, but only one
>Blacksmithing,monstertaming and such
>They setup a monster farm and bootleg the village economy.
>Garrison commander was some king of knight,looking for peaceful life. Thats not going to happen


It was pretty fun and I think its going on. Too bad I forgot the name
>>
>>151723801
Old series. Rayearth, Fushigi Yuugi, Escaflowne
>>
>>151725343
Alpha Centauri's PLANET?
>>
>>151729983
This is a stupid idea that just came up to me but I want to see one of those retarded videogame worlds with one of those people that absolutely SUCK at videogames. Nothing but suffering and misery for them the whole time as they repeatedly fuck themselves and then at the end they discover something incredibly stupid like there was an instruction manual in their pocket the whole time or that there's a magic menu and they were a mage this whole time, or something like that. Just something so mind bogglingly stupid that my brain actually can't comprehend something stupid enough and needs to actually research the great imbeciles of history.
>>
>>151711635
I'll bet you five internetpoints that he will be betrayed and hit from behind a lot.
>>
>>151731663
I wanted to see something like this
doesn't even need to be isekai, but it's an easy genre for people to relate to

MC is terrible at everything, but not an idiot. Always fails, but when they enter the fantasy world (or just the main stage of the story) they end up succeeding due to pure coincidences and accidents. Bad guys accidentally defeat themselves and everything just dues exs into place for him, and he knows it. Everyone thinks he's hot shit, except for one girl who knows he's just full of shit, but can't convince anyone else to see it.

Story would be MC, soulless harem, and the one girl who sees through it going on adventures and solving problems, but would focus on the MC and the girl in their eternal conflict of "keeping it a secret that he's actually pathetic" and "showing everyone he's not doing anything special"
>>
>>151711762
Rogues in WoW during BC could get enough dodge to solo raids

Even Mages in early BC could stack agility on random stat gear. They removed agility from random stat cloth gear because mages got abnormally high dodge from agility since they weren't supposed to have it. Plus people would farm Karazhan for the epic random stat gear, and if they got an epic "of Agility", then they'd have retarded amounts of dodge and could destroy people via dodging
>>
>>151721806
A one-shot mob killer, a masochist Shuckle with the combined HP of Blissey, Wobbuffet, and Guzzlord, and a deity you don't have enough Gym Badges to properly control (or ever will because she's retarded) doesn't that bad munchkin-wise.
>>
>>151727280
Remind that Other World Dining Hall is getting an anime.
>>
>>151722566
>Comparing a coldsteel fanfic to actually thought out and believable edge.
Griffiths betrayal and sacrifice had me at the edge of my seat and it made sense for him to do so while still not being completely obvious from chapter one.
The betrayal in dungeon seeker only had me rolling my eyes because it felt so forced, it felt an excuse to make the mc edgy and rutheless and it really didn't come as a shock, the characters felt like a cheap carboard cutoutt of real characters and the betrayal could be predicted from the first few pages
>>
>>151731860
Shit I swear to god I read a light novel similar to that once. Protagonist either took credit for a kill he had nothing to do with or just never spoke up when people assumed he did it, and the person that actually did it was following him around as he got progressively more and more famous, essentially saving his bacon from the shadows. Can't recall what it was called, but it was okay.
>>
>>151731860
Isekai Angel Densetsu?
>>
>>151712839
>teenagers
The Hobbit was a children's book.
>>
File: RARE.jpg (88KB, 378x365px) Image search: [Google]
RARE.jpg
88KB, 378x365px
>>151709234
>>
>>151711032
>>151711110
I know "edgy" is a buzzword, but
>>
When did this shitty trend of edgy Isekai protagonists start? What shitheap of a novel started it?
>>
>>151732581
just read the description and I'm not sure how that relates at all.
>>
>>151733014
Sword Art Online
>muh death game
even if it doesn't fit exactly into isekai, it's first season does
>>
>Have isekai idea
>The premise is incredibly edgy
>So edgy you would look at current "edgy" isekai and think they are tame

Is it okay for a story to go full edgy if there is a reason for it to be so edgy?
I'm talking more edgy than Berserk Eclipse 24/7
But there is a reason for it to be so edgy in setting.
>>
Is the Realist Hero any good? Apparently it's a J-novel Club new license. I'm hoping they don't go under, since they're the only ones translating Ore ga Heroine.
>>
>>151733406
You don't need to have a reason for anything in order to do it. That's what it means to be truly edgy

describe your wonderful original donut steel plot
>>
>>151733420
It's okay.
Basically, reforming the kingdom with food and remote controlled teddy bears.
>>
>>151711110
>S&W M57 .41 Magnum
Every time.
>>
>>151733685
>https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=drYZ-KkdXB4
nice gun, check out 25~ seconds
>>
>>151733497
I'm never going to actually write it ( maybe I will, but I can't think of where the story can go )

Background information:
>God exists
>God created earth and humanity
>But not for the reasons humans think
>There are other gods, and they war with each other over domains
>God created angels, but they aren't anything special relative to what other gods have
>So God came up with a plan to create immortal soldiers to one up every other deity in the wars
>God creates Humans, who have immortal souls
>God realizes he fucked up, Humans might go traitor or if they aren't 100% loyal they have the potential to completely replace every deity through sheer attrition because human souls can't be destroyed
>So God creates Hell, an extra dimensional space humans can't escape from and throws any human who hasn't demonstrated their 100% infallible loyalty to God into Hell

Now for the edge
>Hell is a very, very basic dimension
>Because the only thing in there are human souls, which are immortal and constantly regenerate, there is literally nothing in that dimension but humans and human byproduct
>Humans still have needs and a sense of pain though
>Because of this, the humans that manage to retain sanity through the sheer trauma eventually start harvesting other humans for resources
>Countless aeons later you have some semblance of human society situated upon an endless desert of dried blood, flesh, and bones.
>Only everyone is a monster who have been forced to subsist through cannibalism
>People are enslaved for meat
>Women are enslaved for sex and milk ( yes )
>People with nice hair are harvested for for cloth and decorations
>Tears are harvested for salt and water

The plot is humans making a tower to escape from Hell to wage a war on the Heavens. Deals with Angels and other celestial beings are made in the process.
>>
>>151733685
Yeah, sniper rifles when?
>>
>>151734065
>not hell is a fantasy world that when the human dies is questioned whether or not they truly believe in a god
>in which they say yes because the fantasy world was so great
>it truly was isekai
>>
>>151734065
That sounds both insanely stupid and kind of entertaining.
>>
>>151734065
meh, not really the edge I was expecting
doesn't sound that interesting to be honest because all the edgy components are easily ignored

it's like how we ignore the fact that women in diapers so they don't take breaks being hit with sticks by chinese factory owners make iphones for us. Edgy if you think about it, but no one cares
>>
>>151733014
>>151733403
Even knowing what SAO is i don't consider kirito edgy.

>>151733630
Excalibears?
>>
How do nip teenagers even know how to make revolvers?
>>
>>151734242
I agree that Kirito isn't edgy. That said he has no proper depth, so he's still fucking awful either way.
>>
>>151734242
forced deaths, forced crying, muh PKers, muh solo, muh BEATER
yeah, it was edgy. If you don't actually see it, you're not looking or are blind
>>
>>151734065
I can't quite describe it right but that sounds really pointless. Like it just doesn't sound like something that can be made into anything of any length other than some art for a death metal cover or some shit.
>>
>>151734337
Also MUH YAMATO DAMASHIIIII
>>
>>151707554
Does literally every single one of these need to be set in a video game
>>
>>151734266
Handcrafted? not sure. A person with extensive knowledge on guys might be able to with access to tools and such.
>>
>>151713417
The girl was a whore. Closest to a love interest is the bored shota antagonist if that slave servants comment about them being similar.
>>
>>151734337
>being this edgy
Chill
>>
>>151724630
Genre fiction used to be viewed as a lowbrow cheap literature, in contrast to literary fiction.
>>
>>151734599
world building is actually a really difficult thing to do well.
Videogames let you offload that onto the reader and it lets you write filler which is just pages and pages of explaining game mechanics, stats, and abilities
>>
>>151734266
Gunota at least has the excuse of having a gun nerd.
>>
>>151711929
nah but dude these meaningless numbers are so cool isn't it so much fun knowing that X has 50 more attack points than Y? i bet that when the tournament arc comes around, Y'll kick X's ass!!
>>
File: MR-30360-754388-12.jpg (125KB, 728x1051px) Image search: [Google]
MR-30360-754388-12.jpg
125KB, 728x1051px
>>151734837
>meaningless numbers
Speaking of...
>>
What are some good obscure isekais that you enjoy reading?
>>
>>151734790
The best kind of world building is the reader's interpretation
>>
>>151735089
You know what, I like that demon lord design. That is one fancy antagonist.
>>
>not liking Skill based isekai
>not liking The Lazy King
>>
>>151735089
That's almost imaginary lvl 100
>>
>>151735196
The only thing better than Skill based isekai is Stats AND Skill based isekai. Rare nowadays though.
>>
>>151735153
no, that's actually terrible for world building
there can be obscurity that the reader interprets, but if you leave too much to the user then you ruin the suspension of disbelief.

Letting the reader interpret things is good in some places, but not when it comes to major rules of the world.

If your characters do things that are too far outside of the rules of the world that have been established and it affects the plot, then the story is going to be ruined. This happens all the time in writing, and is huge in the 'asspull' community.

Let the readers interpret some things, but lay down ground rules that the world works within.
You also can't suddenly have some "foriegn empire that we're at war with" if the empire is literally never mentions for the majority of the story. It's too sudden, it needs to be introduced. That kind of world building is hard because you are required to prepare your major plot events ahead of time and work within them. Most writers want to just "write" and don't realize that like all things in life it's a process of planning and developing and revision. It's why indiegames flop or are shit, people don't plan things out.
>>
>>151735089
>le imaginary numbers

What the fuck is that supposed to represent?
>>
File: MR-30360-780257-2.jpg (1MB, 2178x1032px) Image search: [Google]
MR-30360-780257-2.jpg
1MB, 2178x1032px
>>151735089
BUT WAIT, members of the circus have their own edgy levels as well!
>>
>>151735532
What the actual fuck is occuring right now?

Why has the protagonist turned into some Tokyo Ghoul looking motherfucker?
>>
>>151735557
>Why has the protagonist turned into some Tokyo Ghoul looking motherfucker?
If edgy successful shit ain't broke, don't fix it.
>>
>>151735532
Is this the new season of that KyoAnus chuuni show?
>>
>>151735532
>Root Minus Breaker
>tfw he removes the Root and Minuses turning you into just a mere real number
Whoa, this manga sounds amazing.
>>
>>151711929
Amateur writers are bad at conveying the strength of characters in manners other than numerical.

Even fucking Type Moon just sticks to ranks which are much more malleable, and the actual text makes use of ludicrous metaphors to get the point across.
>>
>>151735701
>bad at conveying
>stats literally get to the point
>people don't like this
You guys are the dumb ones.
>>
File: v-9999.png (896KB, 1600x1163px) Image search: [Google]
v-9999.png
896KB, 1600x1163px
>>151735089
>>151735161
>>151735230
>>151735419
Whoever did the typesetting did this pic wrong
I was autistic enough to change it back
>>
>>151735658
It's pretty silly since the level would be much lower if he just takes the "Minus" and not the "Root"
>>
>>151735532
What manga is this, I kind of want to read it. Seems like a trainwreck.
>>
>>151735726
It's only THAT particular page. It's rectifying any other time the edgy level is mentioned.
>>151735740
Yakushoku Distpiari - Gesellshaft Blue. It's extremely edgy; just how I like my isekais.
>>
>>151735726
>Dice Mcswordhat
>Hands Mclongbody

Best characters.
>>
File: YAKUSHOKU DISTPIARI.jpg (170KB, 869x1273px) Image search: [Google]
YAKUSHOKU DISTPIARI.jpg
170KB, 869x1273px
>>151735557
>>151735634

> In a fantasy world, with slight RPG-like element, the demon king has been revived and it is up to the Subjugators class to find him and slay him before it is too late. Follow Tolza, a young Subjugator, on his journey to slay the demon king along with his teammates he makes along the way. However, there lies a dark secret that his teammates must never know, regarding the Subjugator class.

It's your run of the mill hot-topic tier series
>>
>>151735796
What's going on with her leg
>>
File: 1470881683636.png (169KB, 960x1408px) Image search: [Google]
1470881683636.png
169KB, 960x1408px
>>151735780
>It's only THAT particular page.
Oh oops, that's what I meant
>>
>>151735823
Read it and find out ;^)
>>
>>151735796
>slight RPG-like elements

Nigga it's not slight if you have fucking levels and talk like you're a hollywood fucking hacker. The fact that shit like this gets a manga baffles me.
>>
>>151735419
Attacks using real-numbered power levels have no effect on someone who has an imaginary power level.
>>
>>151735842
She comes back to life right
>>
>>151735796
>>151735842
OH I remember this now, it's the one where he has to kill off his allies for powers. Yeah that's not even a fun trainwreck, it's tedius shit.
>>
>>151735731
How are you supposed to just remove the minus when the root is in the way?
>>
>>151735903
Yeah as experience points >:^)
>>
>>151735939
He uses his inverse function technique.
>>
Nothing will ever beat Mondaiji's ten episodes.
>>
>>151736045
Re: Zero's 25 episodes
>>
>>151736071
nah I agree with >>151736045
Mondaiji showed how to create an over powered main character male without him being a gary stu, despite the fact that he could easily be if he used his abilities differently
He's also one of the most GAR main characters to be made
>>
>>151712187
Release that Witch is the shit, I want my chink comic adaptation.
>>
>>151736071
RE:Zero is bad.
>>
>>151735796
>dude edgy face scar lmao
end me
>>
>>151737146
I can't tell if it's a step up or down from an eyepatch.
>>
>>151730689
I think I know what you're talking about. I follow it on Batoto and it has ultra shitty scans.
>>
File: 033.png (548KB, 726x1033px) Image search: [Google]
033.png
548KB, 726x1033px
>>151737146
>>151737309
Whatever man, this transformation sequence is way cooler than whatever Arifureta did
>>
>>151738872
Congratulations for being a single tiny step up from literal shit. Congratulations on achieving Tokyo Ghoul.
>>
File: the hero of the story.jpg (254KB, 869x1276px) Image search: [Google]
the hero of the story.jpg
254KB, 869x1276px
>>
>>151740308
That was my first taste of an edgy isekai protagonist, and I thought it was kind of cool compared to the other isekais I had read. For about 5 or so chapters of the web novel. Then I realised it was just a crock of shit.

But god damn if shields aren't cool.
>>
>>151707554
This is clearly Isekai's first life. It will die shitty and save anime in another world.
>>
>>151730281
Twelve Kingdoms kind of has this.
>>
File: hero of the baloon SUCC.png (634KB, 887x731px) Image search: [Google]
hero of the baloon SUCC.png
634KB, 887x731px
>>151740388
I know, he becomes less and less edgy as arcs go by and time moves on. Even though he gets over most of his trauma he's still gonna be cynical and bitter however. This is however better than he had not been betrayed as he'd be much more nicer but also coddled as fuck and naive.
>>
>>151741388
The problem is the less edgy he got the more cookie cutter mary sue he got. I don't know how the light novel is going to go, assuming it's still going, but man the web novel was a train crash.
>>
>>151741464
From what point would you say? Some people been saying the series jumped the shark straight after the war between melromarc and fabuley.
>>
Are there any isekai where the transported/reincarnated ends up having to do non-combat criminal activity to get by? Grifter/pickpocket/grave robber kind of deal?
>>
>>151712589
thank you anon i am glad I am not the only one who sincerely dislikes Tolkien
>>
>>151741550
I can't exactly remember but I know it was around the time the chick who traumatised him was renamed along side the king. I remember there was a point when I thought "this is retarded, but if it ends around here it'll be okay" but it kept going. Then it kept going. Then it kept going a little more, with the final antagonists being fucking hilariously awful and the ending being nail bitingly bad.
>>
>>151707554
i unironically like dungeon seeker.
>>
>>151741725
t. sakamoto666
>>
>>151741689
Oh, we're just about to reach that point in the manga after a few more chapters. I agree with you, it would be a good ending point if they had an anime i would also argue that it's a good point to end 24 episodes, or end it at the dragon zombie battle if it was 12..

They never focused on the threat of the waves and kept most of the conflicts internal and rarely moved to other places. ONLY after 200-something or so chapters they were talking about the waves again . And then they throw a fast one with gods, reincarnators and so on, not to mention the original and the revised endings.

Even with it's flaws i like it, and the LN is doing a good job of fixing all of the problems i mentioned (to the point of adding an extra arc that happens in yet another world). But i understand why it would not be your cup of tea after that point.
>>
>>151741911
I've actually yet to read the light novel, but if they can tidy it up a bit then I might give it a shot. The only good thing about the web novel ending is that best princess is an official harem member.
>>
>>151730689
Chihou Kishi Hans no Jyunan
>>
>>151711859
>What's even the point in 90% of contemporary Isekai featuring a videogame RPG System when it's not even a videogame.

Authors are lazy and writing growth and consistent magic systems is hard. Adding RPG mechanics means that you can be lazy about both the magic system AND the showing character growth. Just have it all be handled with experience points, statsm and leveling.

For extra laziness just rip it all, setting included, from Dragon Quest.
>>
File: dinner with slaves.png (61KB, 276x577px) Image search: [Google]
dinner with slaves.png
61KB, 276x577px
>>151741985
If you gonna read them i suggest you fetch them up at the goddess, they have up to vol 5 there. Might buy 6 and add it there once it's out.

The overall plot is the same but things change up completely. vol 1 & 2 dont have much change, if only some extra scenes and side stories. 3 is where changes become apparent and 5 is where the story diverts the most.
>>
>>151742023
Isn't that what all the jap hero & demon lord stuff is based on? DQIII specifically
>>
>>151731663
>Just something so mind bogglingly stupid that my brain actually can't comprehend something stupid enough and needs to actually research the great imbeciles of history.

He stumbled through the whole series powerless and weak because he forgot to talk to a guy all the way back at the starter town who assigns you your job/class. He didn't talk to this guy because he ignored everyone in town who's dialogue all mention going to see this one guy. Also ignored all the signs and flyers posted around town advertising this one guy. THIS ONE GUY IS LITERALLY STANDING AT THE GATE FOR THE TOWN AND CALLED OUT TO HIM AS HE PASSED.
>>
>>151742023
So it's lazy to rip the concept of magic as well right? And you know fighting and war, and pretty much everything. Why write at all? Gee, why read at all? Fuck, why even are you here? Waste of your time. It's like you have no life or something.
>>
>>151742130
Pretty much. It popularized the fuck out of the concept.
>>
>>151742130
>tfw the prologue of DQIII is the hero falling into lava
So much for being a hero
>>
File: Abuse.jpg (436KB, 1078x613px) Image search: [Google]
Abuse.jpg
436KB, 1078x613px
When you are reincarnated into isekai, will you hold slaves?
>>
>>151742503
I will end slavery and stop the industrial revolution as well, anon.
>>
File: Gordan.jpg (42KB, 512x512px) Image search: [Google]
Gordan.jpg
42KB, 512x512px
What would happen if Gordan Ramsay were sent to isekai?
>>
>>151742557
Cooking shenanigans. Probably would be praised as a god.
>>
>>151742371
It's lazy because instead of coming up with a consistent magic system and basing what your character can learn and do with magic around it for a more consistent and well thought out setting and narrative, you instead copy the mechanics from that video game you played as a teenager and just toss in random spells and abilities with numbers attached to them along with a convenient mana bar/number.
>>
>>151725361
Kumoko in early stages was somewhat similar to chinese wuxia and now it's more about grand plans and conspiracy. A bit of strange genre shift if you ask me.
>>
>>151725361
Which slime are we talking about? I remember Slime Tensei when the first manga chapter came out and the reactions were quite good actually.
>>
>>151742557
Wasn't there literally an isekai with a guy who was really good at cooking to the point it somehow made him good at fighting too?
>>
>>151742503
>>151742544
I will start slavery if it doesn't exist and also I am an arsonist.
>>
File: Maids.jpg (143KB, 519x727px) Image search: [Google]
Maids.jpg
143KB, 519x727px
What will you do with maids and servants on your journey?
>>
>>151743046
Hopefully be able to pay them.
>>
File: rimuru.jpg (595KB, 1920x1080px) Image search: [Google]
rimuru.jpg
595KB, 1920x1080px
>>151742719
I would assume it's this kind of slime
>>
>>151720951
This nigga gets it.
>no WW1-esque battles with humans against demons or any other mythological creatures
Or better yet
>No Spaghetti Western isekai
>>
>>151743724
>YWN see a battle at high noon of a cowboy vs. an elf
>>
>>151721134
Didn't she get modified for ogre cock?
>>
>>151720870
this one's not really a good example since it literally is a video game, not a civilization developed in an alternate universe with RPG world mechanics
>>
>>151743908
Giant apparently.
>>
>>151742701
How's Kumoko similar to wuxia (genuinely curious)? I never read any wuxia novels but watched drama adaptation for most of the popular ones.
>>
>>151743436
>draw girl
>call it unisex
>>
>>151713196
>>Knights and Magic
So we've finally come full circle and mecha-fantasy isekai is back in style after a few decades of languishing?
>>
>>151707554
What are some decent isekai animes?
>>
>>151744418
He becomes even more beautiful after recovering and consuming veldora
>>
>>151744428
Mondaiji-tachi
>>
>>151742503
I'd probably try to end it. It's never sat well with me how easily they adapt to that and I recall one LN that i had to sit down and stop reading because i got sick of that boot licking Uncle Tom and his stockholm syndrome when he actually chose to stick around with his masters out of loyalty and some other crap in addition to the misc slaveowning demons acting like they had the moral high ground about how he's obligated to continue helping the family that enslaves him after he (and the daughter) escaped a purge and I see that I need to stop before this turns into a long rant.

It feels like a creepy realization that the Japanese have not had a frank explanation to them about ethics and war crimes in WWII but then again that extends to most Japanese WN/LN MCs.
>>
Anybody laughing at the edgefest so far? The chapter with The Mandragora Kush was hilarious
>>
File: get used.png (352KB, 738x737px) Image search: [Google]
get used.png
352KB, 738x737px
>>151742544
>>151744631
>implying you faggots arent gonna get your ass raped by day 1
>>
>>151744420
Not really, well at least its the only narou isekai I know of that is mech focused and seems to be popular more or less.

Its pretty mediocre btw especially in the begining, but I guess the mech building autism/battles carry it.

Its almost like /m/ getting transported to a mech fantasy world or something.
>>
>>151742130
I think another thread said it was a DQ manga specifically.
>>151731663
>>151731860
>>151742243
New idea to continue where I left and expand upon a tiny detail/explanation i didn't write or just present a second pitch.
The bad videogamer picks "stupid" things that actually help unknowingly avoid massive disaster from time to time. There are also now other people that came along and are min/maxing munchkins that ignore some basic necessities for life in their builds like the ability to cook, or a diplomancer with no fighting stats that fails to realize that sometimes there are people who are just assholes you can't reason with and without diplomacy they're just some shitty lv 1 dude that's REALLY pretty. The most important thing to avoid is any character showing up that plays the video-game "right" since that character will just end up looking like one of the MCs LN authors try to claim is a genius when really they're just surrounded by idiots. Unless he's actually really full of himself and an arrogant jackass thanks to this while onlookers think it's more like he's surrounded by idiots.
>>
>>151744958
There are several shit like this, but then they all ended with MC RANDOMLY GOT A LEGENDARY ITEM / PET LYING ON THE SIDE OF THE ROAD

Either that or the author has no fucking idea how RPG works at all
>>
>>151729983
>MC is a guy coming home from the store.
>Car runs red light and hit-and-runs him.
>MC is reincarnated as a fantasy Belgian.
>Joins the fantasy Belgian Army in the late-19th century and becomes an officer for the artillery.
>Hangs around a young private and elf sergeant most of the time.
>During a trip to fantasy Prussia for his vacation he encounters a young witch who developed a crush on him, and who works in magical artillery for the Prussians.
>Fantasy Franco-Prussian War breaks out and Fantasy Belgium decides to join Fantasy Prussia side instead of staying neutral.
>MC and his men have to hold back the invading forces, then assist the Fantasy Prussians in their campaigns and MC re-encounters the Witch.
>Old 19th century warfare going on with regular artillery + magical artillery. Romance is on the side.

All I got.
>>
>>151744477
ty
>>
>>151743046
Make them work and get more money for me
>>
>>151742701
It isnt though
>>
>>151745030
Fuck that. The shitty gamer person tosses one of those because they never heard of it like excalibur, masamune or a Katana, so it clearly must not be that good and a lv 1 peasant eventually finds it to become king of the realm.
The shitty gamer also will accomplish random preposterous feats of awful playing.
Eg.
IRL I was playing a game with my friends and eventually it got to a car chase part. Now I didn't think one of my friends could possibly be worse at car racing than me. I was wrong. He somehow managed to send the car flying into cartwheels bounding everywhere during high speed traffic. We're generally just laughing at how bad he was/is and being impressed at how he managed to crash. Then we stopped as that same crash managed to parkour itself a perfect 4 point landing on the roof of a 3 story building like that car's destiny was crafted for that purpose. Then our sides went into orbit and the AI couldn't understand what the hell was happening so the police/etc couldn't track us down.
>>
I really want to see a world of warcraft anime/manga but it will be hard to translate it from game into an animation media.
>>
>>151742768
Upstart Pastry Chef is like this. MC has a D rank latent ability with a spear that he trained with every day for 10 years because the spear is his family's symbol or something and gets his ass kicked by his B-ranked brother who never trains but wins anyway 'cause B rank. Then he unlocks SSS sword ability out of nowhere because lol why not, cuts cabbage for 3 days with a kitchen knife, and becomes the best swordsman the world has ever seen. Presumably anyway, translations haven't gotten that far in.
>>
>>151745347
i don't want that because it would follow the named characters or even worse the murderhobo you play as.
the story absolutely ruins the series, especially after cata where everything goes to hell.
i really hope it is never ever made into a manga/anime.
>>
>>151745347
>100 chapters about how MC farmed 901238123878612396813289 mudcrabs
>>
>>151745347
>man dies and is reborn in world of warcraft
>spends 15 episodes farming level 19 gear to make a twink
>sits in bgs for 10 episodes
10/10 would watch again
>>
File: 1468030061477 (1).png (1MB, 935x670px) Image search: [Google]
1468030061477 (1).png
1MB, 935x670px
>>151745415
>wow
>mudcrabs
>>
>>151745415
>>151745638
Are you reffering to that one chinese dude with a pandarian character who spent time farming to lvl 90 somewhere around the spawn zone because he didn't want the boost because he'd have to choose one of the pandarian tribes or something?
>>
>>151745347
Said it before but FFXI would be better, even if it didn't follow the storyline it could take place during the Crystal War.
>>
>>151745687
Still mad that every single time farming appears in isekai, MCs will make it seem like it's so simple.
>oh yeah just crop rotation
>>
>>151713497
read kumoko, who class gets reincarnated and then there's faction battles as the plot progresses
>>
>>151745365
>>151745374
>>151745415
>>151745624
>>151745728
not that kind of story, like a Fantasy story where the story is told in the views of two MC's the Human Male Paladin(representing Alliance players) and the Female Blood Elf Warrior(representing the Horde players) they do their faction quests until they meet in a zone where horde bloodelves can meet with alliance humans , there they meet and go to journey together while doing the raids and dungeons and the story being experienced by each factions perspective, and put a little bit of Blood Elf x Human romance interactions to keep the lovefags hooked.
>>
File: tumblr_m7h1rpkci61rbe8h7o1_500.png (120KB, 500x357px) Image search: [Google]
tumblr_m7h1rpkci61rbe8h7o1_500.png
120KB, 500x357px
>>151746221
Someone's gotta be the ricing carry, anon.

>oh yeah just crop rotation
Or find a miracle seed that's easy as fuck to genetically modify and make flying skull castles with.
I believe we're talking about different types of "farming" here anon.
>>
File: 1334712065485244.png (58KB, 300x281px) Image search: [Google]
1334712065485244.png
58KB, 300x281px
>>151734266
They dont.
>But myh gun-ota,a gun otaku surely knows.

He might know the mechanism but that isnt enough. You have to have a extensive knowledge about metallurgy and blacksmithing, something that is hundreds of years more advance of that in renesance. You also have to know how to make blackpowder, while possible the more advanced smokeless powder is beoynd your power to make.

Thats not considering infra needed for all of that.

Tldr: you cant make a revolver in isekai
>>
>>151746427
Normally, yeah they can't. Unless you use magic to fill the gaps, like in arifureta.
>>
>>151707554
What I actually find the most irritating about this is that his gun is still labelled a Smith and Wesson in spite of the fact that he is in a different world which means that the weapon could not have been constructed by an American company.

It's not a Smith and Wesson if it was not built by the firearms manufacturer called Smith and Wesson. That S&W at the beginning of the gun's name should not be there. Also the M57 refers to the model number, once again this means if it wasn't manufactured using the specific model specifcations of S&W for making a model 57 .41 revolver the M57 should also not be there.

What's more, "Magnum" refers to the ammunition the weapon, not the weapon itself.

Honestly the gun should be labelled as ".41 Double Action Revolver".

It's also not 'Sub' equipment if it's the only equipment you have, that would make it your main equipment by default.

Geez, this is a mess.
>>
File: easy mode.png (179KB, 600x453px) Image search: [Google]
easy mode.png
179KB, 600x453px
>>151746427
Magic
>>
File: 1457930174413.png (278KB, 500x356px) Image search: [Google]
1457930174413.png
278KB, 500x356px
>>151746479
>>151746512
I hate that copout with a burning passion. People who ruin decent serials with it should be put into camps
>>
>>151736149

mah nigga of good taste
>>
>>151746427

Didn't Gun-ota have MC worked in a metal factory before getting shanked? Also I remember the made bullet was compressing mana inside the bullet like the time he fucked his arm trying magic.
>>
>Another shounenshit dungeon thing with video game stats.

Looks like 2017 is the death of anime.
>>
>>151746570
it even has reasonable explanations for revolvers
>>
>>151746587
People in metal Factories are uneducated masses anon
>>
File: pm1.jpg (160KB, 882x905px) Image search: [Google]
pm1.jpg
160KB, 882x905px
Find a better RPG based manga / anime

Protip : you cant

>Solid as fuck character
>Great story line
>Great character development
>Great foreshadowing
>Original battle ability
>>
>>151746608

For you maybe. Isekai may have low points with vidya stats from shit title but its a much better alternative to the fujobaits and male idols
>>
>>151746610

It's also nice that he's not some super genius that knows how to invent everything because he's from the future. I remember there was a chapter where he was like 'yeah I got no idea how this works so I can't invent that'
>>
>>151746487
How do you know that it's not made by Smith and Wesson? The MC even says it was most likely brought from our world.
>>
>>151746487
>Implying it isnt Summoning and Wrestling Magic 57. 41 Magnum
>>
>>151746561
There's guns in shieldbro but they work differently than in IRL. They can misfire if a competent enough mage sets off the gunpowder before you shoot, but there's always fire magic to replace gunpowder-based propulsion, slower but with more powerful results. The other caveat with guns, firearms and pretty much any weapon that uses projectiles is that projectile damage scales with the user's stats. Meaning a high-level soldier operating a cannon or a catapult will deal more damage and projectiles will fall off less than one of a lower level.

Taking also into account that guns need maintenance and there's also ammo costs not a lot of people use them. Armed vehicles such as tanks and fighter planes are also subject to this.
>>
File: Experiment.jpg (180KB, 640x360px) Image search: [Google]
Experiment.jpg
180KB, 640x360px
In isekai, are you willing to go as far as to discard morals for your own benefit? Even at the price of other's lives?
>>
>>151727637
She becomes a god of sorts eventually, would you like to self insert as that?
>>
>>151716334
http://mangaichiscans.mokkori.fr/release/release-256-isekai-mahou-wa-okureteru-1/
Novel was kind of interesting but shit at the same time, the ending of first volume with the future foresight being the worst yet. Horrible translators didn't help either.
>>
>>151712709
Yuushibu isnt isekai, its straight up fantasy.
>>
>>151718130
>Not wanting to turn his semen into acid
>>
>>151747127
Oh hey it's here, yoo bad the ln translations are a mess
>>
>>151742503
There is slavery and then there is slavery.
>>
>>151746957
nah; Karma's a real bitch.
>>
>>151746221
I remember a chinese Web Novel of some sort about a guy who becomes a godlike leader figure because he knows how to make pesticide and kill and culture crops or some shit. It was super fucking long, and I got bored around the first quarter, but hey. It had slightly more than rotation.

And he was a massive prick. Like not even an edge protagonist style prick, but a literal villainous prick.
>>
>>151746724
I mean the problem was he didn't need to be a super genius by the time he reached that chapter considering all the other shit he had.
>>
File: img000015.png (908KB, 1125x1600px) Image search: [Google]
img000015.png
908KB, 1125x1600px
New isekai manga familias
>>
>>151748608
God that's even worse than playing it straight. I can't stand a medium that tries to joke about it's own cliche nature, especially since that's become a cliche in and of itself.
>>
>>151748608
>"do it yourself."
>"b-but..."
>"no. fuck off."
>"...."
>>
Has there ever been an isekai where the protagonist was summoned by a Demon Lord?

I mean those guys are all about magic and shit, so you'd think they'd want to summon some other wordly champions for their cause.
>>
>>151748635
It's just that girl loves this kind of novels (and also has dark chuuni past) and forced to read both guys some of them. But it actually mostly playing it straight.
>>
>>151748718
Dungeon defense is about a demon lord doing demon lord stuff
>>
File: img000026.png (584KB, 1125x1600px) Image search: [Google]
img000026.png
584KB, 1125x1600px
benis
>>
File: img000028.png (1MB, 1125x1600px) Image search: [Google]
img000028.png
1MB, 1125x1600px
>>
>>151748743
Confirmed 50 volumes and an anime.
>>
>>151748718
Lazy Dungeon Master is pretty close in that he was summoned by the morally gray dungeon loli in order to help entrap and kill adventurers
>>
What defines Isekai? Is it just reincarnation, or transportation into another world?
>>
>>151742544
>stop the industrial revolution
what do you have against progress?
>>
>>151750125
Say what?
>>
>>151712808
What if they're Isekai battle-shounen?
>>
Mango or LNs?
>>
>>151748608
What is the different between LN version and WN version?
>>
>>151707554
no, still watching any of that tough.
>>
File: 56549212_p0.jpg (266KB, 650x800px) Image search: [Google]
56549212_p0.jpg
266KB, 650x800px
>>151750894
in general, the WN are the first versions of most series, and are generally only casually made by the authors at their leisure.

When WNs get turned into LNs, that's when things like editors get involved, and can lead to massive changes in a story. It also lets the author change anything they didn't like in the WN.

You can take Overlord for example if you want. The WN is waaay different from the LN.
>>
>>151750996
I mean for Isekai Mahou wa Okureteru. That's why I quote that manga version post.
>>
File: 54339111_p9_master1200.jpg (469KB, 1200x827px) Image search: [Google]
54339111_p9_master1200.jpg
469KB, 1200x827px
>>151751015
Well maybe someone learned something.
>>
>>151749359
A person going from (mostly) Earth to another world regardless of the means.
>>
How did that one Isekai when the guy turned into a slime go? I cant remember where i last left off but it was amusing to read.
>>
>>151712589
Sup /lit/
>>
Is isekai just a byproduct of lonely nips being obsessed with mmorpgs and only having that as a reference for writing?
>>
>>151751412
its an inherent instinct of humanity to crave what they cant have
>>
>>151751231
Become true demon lord or someshit.
>>
>>151746957
>ABANDON HUMANITY
> ā–ŗYES ā–‘ NO
>>
>>151751412
It's a convenient template for a wish fulfilment story that's easy for losers to get into, since the only defining characteristic of the main character is that he was born and raised in the modern day
The fact that they all take place in a generic fantasy world with RPG mechanics is inconsequential, and mostly just because nips really like Dragon Quest
>>
>>151750996
But both the WN and LN have something in common. They're both terrible.
>>
File: 1438804333735.jpg (293KB, 960x699px) Image search: [Google]
1438804333735.jpg
293KB, 960x699px
>>151752299
>>
>>151752327
I am not afraid of Skelly.
>>
>>151712589
God, it's like listening to those Oliver Twist faggots but worse
>>
>>151751412
No

Most of the author has no fucking idea how RPG stats work
>>
>>151746957
I'd be a good guy but id be morally gray on select issues, so if say, the douchey elf prince was all "if u hurt me, the humans git it" i'd reply with a hearty lmao before knocking his block off
>>
>>151752470
That's not particularly morally grey if the humans will actually get it. That's more like... evil. Especially since he was "douchey"
>>
Is MA Area ever explained? Same with Divinity zone (or whatever it's called)? I'm at the part where Kumo, Maou Shoujo and Vampire-chan go on a grand adventure to the demon country and I'm still super confused about a lot of things.
>>
the only thing im looking forward to in 2017 is more wolf fang fist

god i hope that isekai spinoff takes off
>>
>>151727195
Why do people even like this shit when post dungeon it's basically re: monster sans all the sex?
There's such a huge market for RPG based power fantasy I feel like I should try writing one myself.
>>
>>151752668
I mean hey, if nothing else it can be fun to put your own little spin on it. It's fun to write power fantasies.
>>
>>151752730
I'm wondering if there is anyone on /a/ who has written their own isekai. I don't see any threads where people post there attempts at web novels.
>>
>>151720019
>hypocrite
Wtf since when is that a bad thing. Everyone is a hypocrite, retard.
>>
>>151752782
I've half written the start of one but I'm sure more people have written their own. I don't think people post them because the threads would probably just devolve into shitposting.
>>
>>151752828
Post it. I'm getting bored of japanese take on anime tropes and want to see western perspective of anime tropes instead.
>>
File: 017.png (364KB, 1024x1536px) Image search: [Google]
017.png
364KB, 1024x1536px
>>151746681
>>
>>151746957
I'm already morally grey, so yes I would do that.
>>
>>151748824
He's not ok
>>
>>151753863
Would you say you're also nihilistic, with a wicked sense of humor
>>
File: Goblin Guy.png (200KB, 437x332px) Image search: [Google]
Goblin Guy.png
200KB, 437x332px
Is goblin slayer isekai?
>>
>>151755189
Nah, it's straight fantasy, no one is getting teleported from a modern day setting
>>
>>151720603
He used aphrodesiac sure, but in the end, they wanted it, literally

That was his intent because he didnt want them to be cumdumps who lose their will to live

Hes not a hypocrite, he just didnt want the same fate for the elves that the human women early on suffered, nothing said explicitly that keeping people around for sex was something he was against, and plus, they still have freedom and have to consent, so its not lot they turn into cock/GobPussy addicted rape slaves
>>
>>151711929

They want a young audience that played videogames his entire existence, stats are easy for understand for young teens
>>
>>151711956

no game no life and have decent worldbuilding
>>
File: escapism.png (115KB, 500x229px) Image search: [Google]
escapism.png
115KB, 500x229px
FFTA is the best isekai you'll ever get.
>>
>>151711956
In ReZero there arent any rpg mechanics, and while there is magic, the MC is abyssmal at it and his mana source is fucked, so he gotta use grit for now
>>
>>151755524
Man, im a sucker for isekai, but this is easily one of my top 2 favorite GBA games so that compounds it rather unhealthily
>>
>>151727195

I dont like Spider Girl because is 100% monologues and serious literature should evade monologues, here >>151727342
>>
>>151727195
>both MCs are japs who reincarnate into monsters and skill acquisition is almost the exact same

Crossover when
>>
>>151727195
Kumo a cute! CUTE!
Kumo so cute she even turns cannibalizing on baby arms cute!
>>
>>151755609
But it's not healthy!
>>
>>151742544
>strop the industrial revolution
So end slavery and stop the thing that pushed slavery out by convenience. Without those big scary machines, we would have to rely on all the manpower that they replaced.
>>
File: Konjiki.jpg (1MB, 2192x1580px) Image search: [Google]
Konjiki.jpg
1MB, 2192x1580px
Konjiki no Moji is pretty good. It's about this kid who gets summoned by accident alongside a group of students, but he doesn't want to get caught up in saving the world so he just leaves and does his own thing.

The art is great, but scans release at around the same rate as Berserk.
>>
>>151751412
It's a byproduct of them loving Alice in Wonderland.
>>
>>151758043
Nah the protagonist was shit in that, dragged the whole thing down.
>>
>>151755615
Aye. Spider Girl is something I can only enjoy in manga form. The narration style most of these novels use is just boring.
>>
>>151758043
MC looks interesting

Is it entertaining?
>>
>>151751412

Only retards say its a product of MMOs. It's a product of Alice in Wonderland and other old fairy tales. Isekai has been there since the late 80's in anime
>>
File: jesus christ what is this shit.png (104KB, 818x536px) Image search: [Google]
jesus christ what is this shit.png
104KB, 818x536px
>>151759223
No, it reads like dogshit.
>>
>>151759223
>fantasy land
>there's porn books
Im not sure what to say about this.
>>
>>151759786
Jackpot?
>>
File: dungeon defense.jpg (443KB, 700x1026px) Image search: [Google]
dungeon defense.jpg
443KB, 700x1026px
>"dungeon defense"
>doesn't have a dungeon
>has a castle but fails to defend it
>takes the offensive and leads a war
Dantalian is so edgy and contrarian that he goes against his own novel's title.
but it's gookshit so it'll never get an anime
>>
>>151759832
He threw them out though
>>
>>151760029
what a nerd.

But honestly what happens in that story? Is it any good?
>>
>>151713497
I actually like this idea. I'm sucker for closed loops though. I like the idea of characters being defined by their habits though, and the roles that they think they need to play. What would be cooler though, imo, is for the noble to occasionally do some heroic things, and for those actions to be spun in the legend to be evil, and for the hero to do some terrible things.
>>
>>151759994

Bloodivores was adapted into an anime, from a chinese web novel. It was the biggest piece of dogshit to air this season, by far. I don't discount anything being adapted now, after seeing that garbage.
>>
>>151760175
He seems to be doing his own thing, figuring out stuff, trying to return to his own world. While reading BOOOOOOKS and eating FOOOOOD on the way. i think you'll like it if you like isekai mahou and death march.
>>
>>151727195
The slime one was so fucking tryhard
The whole deal with that isekaiĀ“d human girl was shoehorned just because the author needed a way to get a cute human form for the slime, and it shows.
>>
>>151752668
Because the MC is a fucking girl

Yeah people are retarded
>>
>>151760989
>Tfw they are not actually girls reincarnated into slimes or spiders
>>
is someone gonna make another thread or should we let it rest for today?
Thread posts: 513
Thread images: 87


[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / bant / biz / c / can / cgl / ck / cm / co / cock / d / diy / e / fa / fap / fit / fitlit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mlpol / mo / mtv / mu / n / news / o / out / outsoc / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / spa / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vint / vip / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Search | Top | Home]

I'm aware that Imgur.com will stop allowing adult images since 15th of May. I'm taking actions to backup as much data as possible.
Read more on this topic here - https://archived.moe/talk/thread/1694/


If you need a post removed click on it's [Report] button and follow the instruction.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com.
If you like this website please support us by donating with Bitcoins at 16mKtbZiwW52BLkibtCr8jUg2KVUMTxVQ5
All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties.
Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from that site.
This means that RandomArchive shows their content, archived.
If you need information for a Poster - contact them.