How many anime do you rank as 10/10?

>>151395545
1, I also have very few 9/10's. Most of the stuff I enjoyed falls between 5 and 8

>>151395545
0

>>151395682
Exactly.

1. Inferno Cop.

File: 1482634506942.jpg (50KB, 400x600px) Image search: [Google]

50KB, 400x600px

>>151395545
Fewer than 10.

>>151395545
>How many anime do you rank as 10/10?
0.
Some 9 tho

File: The Greatest Masterpiece In The History of Humanity.jpg (2MB, 1278x2160px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1278x2160px

>>151395545
Just one.

File: 1469782272900.png (956KB, 950x1050px) Image search: [Google]

956KB, 950x1050px

>>151395807

File: coma_satoru.jpg (35KB, 368x360px) Image search: [Google]

35KB, 368x360px

lot of 8-7/10s, 2 10/10, ERASED and FMA:B

Just Madoka

Three.

File: 1481564370904.jpg (347KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

347KB, 1280x720px

0
Most of the seasonal anime I finish fall into 4-6 range, 7 usually means it's AOTS or in top 3, 8 - AOTY i.e 1-2 anime per year. I have very few 9

File: image.jpg (50KB, 400x400px) Image search: [Google]

50KB, 400x400px

>>151395833
>ERASED

File: shio-chan.jpg (10KB, 236x234px) Image search: [Google]

10KB, 236x234px

>>151395545
Only one. Basicly what this >>151395679 said.

File: choking.jpg (53KB, 480x650px) Image search: [Google]

53KB, 480x650px

>>151396079
>doesn't like erased

>>151395545
Oreimo and Evangelion are 10/10.

>>151396079
He's obviously a mal retard.

>>151396386
It was shit

I have about 5 I would put as 10/10.

File: doorman.png (133KB, 808x637px) Image search: [Google]

133KB, 808x637px

>>151396447
I guess if you like School Days, nerd

>current year
>people have no 10/10
The best show you've seen is a 10, and the worst is a 0 (or 1, if you're MAL). Everything else falls between.

Basing your score on some imaginary perfect 10 that you haven't seen yet is just retarded

I have three 10/10 but I'm not gonna tell yoooouuuuu guys

>>151396736
10/10 means flawless.
Out off all the shows you've seen, can you really call your favorite one "flawless"?

14

>>151395545

7 outta 10

File: brat.png (308KB, 460x600px) Image search: [Google]

308KB, 460x600px

>>151395545
14

Code Geass: Hangyaku no Lelouch
Code Geass: Hangyaku no Lelouch R2
Clannad After Story
Full Metal Alchemist: Brotherhood
K-ON!
K-ON!!
Suzumiya Haruhi no Shoushitsu
Sono Hanabira ni Kuchizuke wo: Anata to Koibito Tsunagi
Chihayafuru
Chihayafuru 2
Mahou Shoujo MadokaMagica Movie 2: Eien no Monogatari
Chuunibyou demo Koi ga Shitai!
Yuyushiki
Tamako Love Story

>>151396963
>10/10 means flawless
No, unless you work with an arbitrarily fine grained scale.

>>151396963
>10/10 means flawless.
That's your choice.
We all know nothing is flawless. So you're stuck with a score you'll never use and you're comparing other shows against something that doesn't exist. That's retarded.
Alternatively just use 10/10 to mean "best"

If you gave a 10 to more than a half a percent of the things you've seen you're a casual easy grader

>>151397111
>K-On
>Haruhi
>Chu2
>Tamako
>Yuyushiki
I can see how those others could be your 10/10s, but those? What the fuck

>>151395545
Too many i'm afraid. I find the 10/10 ranking quite inefficient to be quite honest. Because i don't watch anything blindly, i do a little bit of research before hand and seek out something that i am susceptible to like. So it either turns out exceptional so a 10, really good a 9, enjoyable 8, average or it had some glaring flaws 7, and i hardly ever go below that.

File: IMG_0019.png (114KB, 500x212px) Image search: [Google]

114KB, 500x212px

>>151396388
>Oreimo
>10/10
Is Oreimo literally Evangelion of our generation?

>>151395545
6 or 7

About 20% and I've completed more than 300 series.

>>151397272
You can compare anime to other works of fiction though. If my favorite anime isn't at least just as enjoyable as my favorite book or a movie, I won't rate it as 10/10.

>>151397462
10% I mean

File: Cx6yhhqXcAAY7ON.jpg (28KB, 334x442px) Image search: [Google]

28KB, 334x442px

>>151395833
>ERASED

File: 1479176220444.jpg (193KB, 1112x978px) Image search: [Google]

193KB, 1112x978px

>>151397337
It's simple, I enjoyed every minute of all those.

File: Screenshot_2016-12-25-02-55-53~01.png (303KB, 1327x2163px) Image search: [Google]

303KB, 1327x2163px

>>151395545
10: 4/344
9: 8/344
8: 22/344

>>151397470
Your average score for anime must be pretty low then.

Whats your 10/10 considering anime medium by itself?

File: 1479609264568.gif (437KB, 420x420px) Image search: [Google]

437KB, 420x420px

>>151395545
Most of the animes in my MAL I've given 10/10s. I'm super easy to please.
Unless an anime really irritates me like oreimo, I won't really give it a low score

>>151397687
>344 series
>78.15 days
LMAO that's why you barely have any 10/10. Stop watching shit, fampai.

KKN IS THE ONLY RIGHT ANIME YO RATE 10/10.
TENSAIIIIIIIIIIIIIII

>>151395545
0

>>151397695
Yes, my mean score is around 5

Touch

File: 1464930527785.jpg (78KB, 535x658px) Image search: [Google]

78KB, 535x658px

>anime is serious business!

File: ew.gif (307KB, 697x400px) Image search: [Google]

307KB, 697x400px

>>151397537
>ERASED
>vomit
>cuck

None of it. Fuck anime.

Most of JoJo

Even my favourite one has flaws, so none of them.

File: Capture.png (8KB, 358x327px) Image search: [Google]

8KB, 358x327px

>ranking

File: bang.jpg (67KB, 600x464px) Image search: [Google]

67KB, 600x464px

>>151395545
Overrated but just the one

>>151395545
Exactly 0 (zero)

7. I don't think they're perfect, but a step above my 9s.
Eva
Gurren Lagann
Madoka
Cowboy Bebop
FLCL
Higurashi
Tatami Galaxy

>>151395545
Technically 3 but the other 2 is the sequel of the same show so only 1 I guess.

File: reeeeeeee.jpg (36KB, 680x680px) Image search: [Google]

36KB, 680x680px

>All of that typical highschool life, pantsu, moeblob, SoL.
Where's my pretentious?

>>151398884
merry christmas dumb frogposter

>>151398857
Didn't realize there was pretentious there.
Eva 0/10
Gurren 0/10
Madoka 0/10
Cowboy 0/10
FLCL 0/10
Higurashi 0/10
Pretentious Galaxy 10/10

10

anohana
chuunibyou
mushishi
mushishi hihamuge
nhk
kuuchuu buranko
parasyte
paprika
perfect blue
tatami galaxy

20 out of 437 seen.

>>151399158
great, except anohana and chuunibyou

File: 1377886759349.gif (880KB, 344x360px) Image search: [Google]

880KB, 344x360px

Not many, It depends on how much I enjoyed it and how memorable the ending was to me.

So far I've put.
Champloo.
Hyouka.
NNB S1/S2.
Diamond no Ace.

as 10s.

>>151395545
Psycho Pass

>>151395545
Three.

Every anime that is 10/10 goes on my top three list. If one gets bumped down I typically say its 9.5 from then on

Once you reach true enlightenment you realize that all anime deserve to be given a 10/10.

None

File: snapshot20090504143259.jpg (37KB, 848x480px) Image search: [Google]

37KB, 848x480px

NGE/End of Evangelion and one other, pic related

Anyone who says Haruhi should kill themselves immediately.

>>151398857
>Gurren Lagann

I love the show but 10/10?

>>151399812
It's more defensible than a lot of shows that have been listed so far, especially if it was one of your first

>>151399158
>nhk
What's wrong with you? Even if you had shit enough taste to think that all the filler arcs were great in every way, the God awful animation every other episode would surely bring the score down. 10/10 means that the show is perfect or as close to perfect as any anime can be and nhk (while good) has way too many flaws.

>>151397687
Why do you spend so much time on 3s and 4s? Why not drop them?

4.
AnoHana
Clannad: After Story
NHK
Madoka

Shirobako and Ping Pong the Animation

>>151399863
10/10 for lots of people means they achieved peak enjoyment from it.

I used to have 8 or so but then I re-watched End Of Evangelion and have finally realised what a true masterpiece looks like.

Utena and GitS: Stand Alone Complex 1st GIG

>>151395545
Hard to say. Probably around 0-2 of the anime I've seen since I was a kid in the 1980s.

>>151395545
All of them

I give almost everything a six for some reason. I've been thinking about reavaluating my critique process to making those sixes 5 so my average score is a 5. I don't think I will though cause I like to mix subjective and objective opinions in my scores, which in that case I think it's ok to have a 6 by my average score.

Plenty, because I'm not crossboarding scum like most people here who've seen less than 100 series and fell for the "The medium is inherently shit" meme that /lit/ and /tv/ posters need to believe in order to continue pretending to be smart and mature.

>>151400127
You should make it 1/3 5, 1/3 above 5, 1/3 below 5, and 2/3 at 4, 5, or 6. That's what I do

>>151400127
That being said I think I gave a 10 to ichigo marshmallow, can't remember if the others were 10s or 9s though

>>151400142
>everyone who doesn't have plenty of 10/10 just pretends to be smart and mature!

File: gaogaigarBD-17.jpg (330KB, 1440x1080px) Image search: [Google]

330KB, 1440x1080px

BITCHES

>>151395545
Only Hyouge Mono and Symphogear

>>151400142
Or perhaps I don't have a massive chip on my shoulder and appreciate that perfect works in any medium are very rare.

>>151400181
Or simply doesn't expose themself to enough of the medium to warrant posting here, yes.

>>151395545

I think only CCS + the second CCS movie and both seasons of Non Non Biyori. Everything else is a 9.

As for manga, YKK is a 10 and everything else is a 9.

>>151400215
Or maybe you simply don't expose yourself to other mediums if you think anime has a lot of legit 10/10 shows that you can put next to 10/10 movies or books.

FMA Brotherhood, a rare example of the ending living up to the ride. And maybe, just maybe NNB and K-On!
Not sure if they deserve a 10 though, there is so much moe that a few of them are bound to be good.

>>151400208
Correct. For every 100 anime, books, movies or games you have a couple 10's. People who say none exist haven't watched enough anime, and don't belong here.

>>151395545
5

TTGL
Texhnolyze
End of Evangelion
Ashita no Joe
Ashita no Joe 2

>>151400168
I don't really want to get that anal about it anon-kun

File: 1481545216516.jpg (78KB, 631x659px) Image search: [Google]

78KB, 631x659px

>>151400276
>For every 100 anime you have a couple 10'
Ok go ahead and name a "couple of 10s" from summer and spring seasons this year.

>>151400248
Nope, sorry. I'm not stupid enough to pretend any medium is inherently better. There are more 10/10 simply by virtue of them having existed much longer. There are also more garbage books than total anime exist.

>>151395545
I have 8 10/10s:
GitS
FLCL
Lain
Texhnolyze
TTGL
HxH 2011
Ping Pong
Shirobako

Honorable mentions, but still 9/10:
Madoka
Disappearance
Haibane Renmei
Perfect Blue

>>151400313
>say an anime so I can call it shit
yeah nice try pal

>>151400313
>100 anime aired in 2 seasons
You're an idiot, but Flip Flappers depending on the ending, and Working for being a perfect workplace comedy with some romance, which is exactly what it sets out to do.

Now when the inevitable memetext comes back, try to only comment on shows you've actually watched, and try not to pretend that only super serious 2deep4u shows can be 10/10.

>>151400351
Why would I call it shit?
I can call it ok or fine

File: IMG_0716.jpg (180KB, 640x783px) Image search: [Google]

180KB, 640x783px

What's the name of this manga?

1: Aria the origination

I think you have to be supremely knowledgeble in any medium if you want to start pitting them against each other. It's possible if you somehow have a perfect understanding of each, but not if you don't. I.E. I doubt anyone on this site is qualified to make those judgements.

>>151400390
Did anyone else like The Natural the best?

>>151400127
Just FYI, the average of 1 and 10 is 5.5, which rounds up to 6 because decimals are for retards using the wrong number scale.

File: 1479169433162.gif (2MB, 250x282px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 250x282px

EoE
Some Ghibli shit
FLCL
Ping Pong


Nothing else really, 99 percent of shows go on and end up fucking up a tiny bit in some department. These are just off the top of my head, I'm sure theres a few more movies that are 10 to me if not 1 more.

File: 1481562976032.jpg (75KB, 647x647px) Image search: [Google]

75KB, 647x647px

>>151400358
>100 anime aired in 2 seasons
>You're an idiot
I'm sure not, because unlike you, I can count
https://www.livechart.me/summer-2016/tv
https://www.livechart.me/spring-2016/tv


>Now when the inevitable memetext comes back, try to only comment on shows you've actually watched, and try not to pretend that only super serious 2deep4u shows can be 10
Really nice strawman, considering I never mentioned it has to be 2deep4u, but I gess that's the only thing people like you can come up with when they defend the fact that they have 20-30 10/10s

>>151400410
>I doubt anyone on this site is qualified to make those judgements.
Lurk more.

>>151400358
>Working for being a perfect workplace comedy with some romance
It's a generic manzai ridden garbage with one-sided characters, if you think it's "perfect" comedy than there's no hope for you.

>>151400450
That makes me feel a little better, thanks.

>>151400516
There is no such thing as perfect comedy.

>>151400500
Don't be upset because you'll never get to watching/reading/listening(and thoroughly digesting)everything you'd like to in your lifetime.

>>151400468
Now take out leftovers, OVAs, shorts and movies unless you want to start counting those to overall count, seeing as those are higher production value and inflate the number more than you'd like.

I also noticed you didn't even pretend to talk about the two I mentioned. Good to know you don't actually watch enough anime to have seen them.

>>151400516
It's hilarious with likable characters. You just have shit taste.

>>151400558
That's what I was waiting for.

I ctrl+F for "gundam" and got nothing. Doesn't anyone else think it counts, or can you not tolerate Hanna-Barbera tier animation?

>>151400604
This doesn't have anything to do with my post.

Fafner

>>151400673
First Gundam is a 9 imo, but I only have 4 10s out of 1364

>>151400692
Your post was pure rhetoric, I was really just using it to build off of my post.

>>151400699
I'd put 0079 as about a 9 if I had to rank it, only because of the animation. It's still a personal favorite, but I can't dish out the 10 in a visual medium with animation that rough.

>>151400699
I suppose because of the salt and the island, right? It wasn't always perfect but the aesthetic had a huger influence than less flawed shows did.

File: 1478463181139.jpg (47KB, 573x681px) Image search: [Google]

47KB, 573x681px

>>151400617
>there are no 100 anime in 2 seasons, you're an idiot!
>no there are, here's a proof
>b-but you can't count shorts and other things because that means I'm wrong!!
Nice backpedaling here
They're anime, period. The format doesn't matter, you only said "anime".

>I also noticed you didn't even pretend to talk about the two I mentioned. Good to know you don't actually watch enough anime to have seen them.
What do I have to say about them?
Working is a generic comedy with the jokes you've seen countless times before, there's nothing 10/10 about it. And what kind of retarded reasoning is "which is exactly what it sets out to do"? By that logic you can rate some random ecchi harem 10/10 because that's what it's trying to be. Your whole point is "if you don't have taste shit enough to rate every other anime 10/10 that means you have't seen enough anime!!"
FliFla is a nice a show, but I wouldn't rate it 10/10 either. And just you know, I watch around 17-18 anime on average every season, so I sure watch enough.

>>151400751
I wouldn't even take a point off for the animation; by the end the action choreography is exceptionally good and the world is developed visually even if has a lot of rush animation. A lot of the episodes just aren't that good, and not just salt and the island. A bunch of the early and middle episodes are meh, it only becomes godly in the last third

>>151400789
>Adding in movies and OVAs to try and prove 10/10 don't exist
>Counting 2 cour shows
Be honest, are you shitposting or actually retarded?

>No you're wrong because I say so
>Trust me, I watch lots of anime
Whatever you say, anon.

File: vlcsnap-error878.png (666KB, 1280x738px) Image search: [Google]

666KB, 1280x738px

Only ever been three for me.

Yosuga no Sora, Oregairu, Seitokai

>>151400801
I don't think there are any bad episodes, just some slower ones that are needed for characterization and world building. My point definitely comes off for animation.

>>151400789
Rating shows is all about context. It has to do with the the viewers experience and how saturated the genre is. It's fine if it's perfect to him, but that just isnt an objective opinion, and speaks to his own inexperience.

The more a genre or medium ages the harder it is to produce a perfect work cause of cliches and lack of originality. It's like the classics set an iron precedent that can't be broken on an objective basis

File: 1447840232573.jpg (58KB, 582x582px) Image search: [Google]

58KB, 582x582px

>>151400834
>Adding in movies and OVAs to try and prove 10/10 don't exist
I actually never mentioned OVAs and movies, if you'd actually followed the link you'd see that it lists TV anime. You can exclude 2 cour shows, it will still have around 100 anime.

>No you're wrong because I say so
That's what you're saying though? You're the one who started the whole "if someone doesn't rate at least 2-3 anime 10/10 evey year that means they haven't watched enough anime!!"
Also you still haven't adressed this
>And what kind of retarded reasoning is "which is exactly what it sets out to do"? By that logic you can rate some random ecchi harem 10/10 because that's what it's trying to be.

File: images.jpg (4KB, 128x120px) Image search: [Google]

4KB, 128x120px

>>151395545
I use a 3 star system; not worth watching, watched but could easily have dropped it, worth watching and watched ending episode several times.

I have one 10/10, one 1/10 and everything else falls between.

>>151400743
Are you alright? I didn't use any rhetoric at all.

If what I quoted was just an exaggeration on your part, very well - just don't act upset when someone calls you on it.

>>151400985
Inability to count aside, I'll bite on the second one. Working is a workplace comedy with romance. It's hits those two notes beautifully. Random haremshit tries to have meaningful character drama, and the one with battle academies or isekai try to have serious world building and high stakes plot full of tension and drama. No, they most certainly do not succeed at everything they try to do.

File: whatwereyouexpecting?.jpg (37KB, 704x396px) Image search: [Google]

37KB, 704x396px

>10/10 thread
>seasonalfags

File: 1474042179352.jpg (187KB, 1280x1080px) Image search: [Google]

187KB, 1280x1080px

>>151401157
>Inability to count aside
I'm glad you admit that you were wrong. See? Not that hard.

>Working is a workplace comedy with romance. It's hits those two notes beautifully
Yep, I'm sure that overused gags and archetypes are the pincale of comedy genre.

>Random haremshit tries to have meaningful character drama
Working tries to have romance with one-joke characters, I'm sure that's not romance is all about.

>>151401106
It was somewhat of an exaggeration but I do think that it would be very rare to find someone that in the know here. I have a few reasons. 1. Most of us are still quite young and wouldn't of had the ability to devote the time needed to fully understand more than one, 2 4chan is divided by boards where people discuss 1 broad topic and probably only branch out enough to obtain a begginers understanding of another. To constantly stay current in any one would require a lot of time and a lot of previous experience, that I just don't think would be characteristic of your average 4chan user.
And telling someone to lurk more without addressing any of his points directly would definately fall under rhetoric.

>>151401347
that's not what*

>>151401347
Uh oh, you pretended to make a point at first, but then outright lied and sidestepped what I said.

It's ok avatarfag, everyone expected you to be an idiot anyways.

Anime that i keep rewatching

Why would I spend any time contributing to MAL's arbitrary ranking system?

File: 1442242574064.jpg (46KB, 456x488px) Image search: [Google]

46KB, 456x488px

>>151401450
>lied
Why are you getting so defensive? Just because I don't consider a boring romance with generic archetypes a 10/10 doesn't mean I "lie" or whatever.

Oh, and please tell me how are something like chocolate gag or that "smile" gag they kept repeating over and over again 10/10 comedy, I'd like to hear you explanation on how it hits "those notes beautifully"

>>151401533
>MAL invented the scale from 1 to 10

>>151401586
ugh

No anime deserves a solid 0 or 10 out of 10 I think. Everything has pros and cons to me. Even the greatest or worst one.

>>151401586
/v/: The List

>>151401567
Where else do people collect 1 to 10 ratings of Anime?

>>151401539
>Explain the joke to me
Wow, you're actually more retarded than I thought.

Way to change up the avatar to avoid a ban, though.

>>151401704
Who are you quoting?

File: 1435340956244.gif (185KB, 600x338px) Image search: [Google]

185KB, 600x338px

>>151401704
>expain why do you consider this comedy the best
>n-no!! you're just retarded!!!
Really nice going here

>Way to change up the avatar to avoid a ban
Blonde girls are not "avatar". I used Karen, Alice and Nene.

>>151395545
>ranking anime with numbers

>>151395807
What is this, looks terrible and I want to watch it.

Have a few 10s, mostly 7-8 and then a shit load of dropped anime. If its still a 6 or less by episode 5 I drop it.

Lots of people complain about there being too many 8-10 but are any of you really going to waste time on shovel shit that are below 6/10?

>>151401805
>not knowing that anime
How new?

>>151401820
That depends on what you consider a 6/10. Your 6 might be a 4-5/10 for someone else.

>>151401825
I dont watch allot of seasonal trainwrecks, or mecha, and that looks like both.

eva series (not movies)
madoka (plus movie)
toradora
hyouka

haruhi movie

>>151401726
I was paraphrasing the guy who literally asked me to explain why a joke was funny. Now run along back to /jp/ and keep your shitposting the.

>>151401747
>Explain the joke to me
>Explain a fucking joke to me
You're definitely retarded.

And every other post up until then was Nene, shitposterkun.

>>151402004
And why do you think that "paraphrasing"(basically strawmanning) someone is a correct way to use greentext?

>>151402212
>Uh oh, he called out my bannable meme
>Better pretend to be stupid and bring up logic fallacies
Why do idiots think citing logic fallacies they don't understand that don't apply is an instant win?

>>151402271
Again, who are you quoting?

Utena
Fmab
Penguindrum
Ping pong
Evangelion
Millennium Actress
The tale of princess Kaguya
Shinsekai no yori
Kyousou giga(tv)

>>151402300
Paraphrasing, anon. Is English not your first language? Do you need a dictionary?

>>151402482
And why do you think that "paraphrasing"(basically strawmanning) someone is a correct way to use greentext?
Did you read my post?

>>151401359
>telling someone to lurk more without addressing any of his points
Welcome to /a/. If your new is showing, you will be told to lurk more. So don't let it show if that's a problem for you.

>>151402510
>basically strawmanning
There you go again, using words you don't understand.

>Did you read my post?
I did. You don't have a point. Parroting shitposting memes from /jp/, no matter how much you want them to be, do not constitute arguments.

>>151402547
Your posts here:
>>151402271
>>151402004
>>151401704
consist of nothing but strawman.
>I did. You don't have a point. Parroting shitposting memes from /jp/, no matter how much you want them to be, do not constitute arguments.
What shitposting memes? You're using one of the basic functions of 4chan incorrectly.

>>151402612
>nothing but strawman.
He quite literally asked me to explain a joke to him. He asked me to explain slapstick humor. Let that sink in for a minute, and tell me which part of my post was a strawman.

>What shitposting memes
I know you're used to shitposting on /jp/, but that gets your posts deleted on other boards, crossboard-kun.

>>151395545
ALL ANIME

LoGH
Eva
Disappearance of Haruhi

>>151395545
Very few, but the last animu I'd consider a legitimate 10/10 was Katanagatari.

>>151399863
I'm confused you brought up nhk to rant over from the shows I've rated 10. like the other anon stated I gave it a 10 for the enjoyment - even though there's slight nostalgia attached to it for nhk being the first serie I finished years ago, I can't remember disliking anything about it. also the animation wasn't even bad, what are you talking about?

File: 1460772907753.png (69KB, 439x485px) Image search: [Google]

69KB, 439x485px

>>151395545
7, because my taste is the best.

Aria the Origination
Cowboy Bebop
Cromartie High School
Eve no Jikan
Millennium Actress
Space Brothers
Tatami Galaxy

>>151402648
>tell me which part of my post was a strawman.
The parts where you used greentext incorrectly, so these.
>>151401704
>>Explain the joke to me
>>151402004
>>Explain the joke to me
>>Explain a fucking joke to me
>>151402271
>>Uh oh, he called out my bannable meme
>>Better pretend to be stupid and bring up logic fallacies
>>151402648
I'm pretty sure that "greentexting" was looked down here too in 2011

>>151395545
0

>>151402825
>used greentext incorrectly
Greentext is frequently used for quoting, paraphrasing, and telling stories. Welcome to 4chan.

>in 2011
Damn, if only it were still 2011 you might actually have a point and not just be a retard shitposting with /jp/ memes. Now run along back to your homeboard.

Like 5-10 a decade

>>151395545
Cowboy Bebop.

That's it.

>>151402861
>Greentext is frequently used for quoting, paraphrasing, and telling stories.
Yet the only the quoting function is correct.
>Now run along back to your homeboard.
How about you go to /r9k/ or /v/ if you like greentext stories and strawmanning so much?

File: 1398017717175.jpg (92KB, 768x900px) Image search: [Google]

92KB, 768x900px

Only my favorite anime, what makes a standart.

Everythin under it go from 0 to 10, everthing above... I have never seen something this good, not even close.

>>151402941
>Yet the only the quoting function is correct.
Sorry, you being as assmad idiot won't change reality.

>How about you go to /r9k/ or /v/ if you like greentext stories and strawmanning so much?
Oops. looks like you forgot to make a point again. It's ok, one day maybe you'll learn that falsely crying about logic fallacies isn't the way to make a point. Probably not, though, you seem really stupid.

File: Samurai Flamenco.jpg (103KB, 800x320px) Image search: [Google]

103KB, 800x320px

Just the one. It was brilliant.

Only one in Aria the Origination, but I only have around five across all mediums so it's par for the course i guess

>183 replies for stealth rec thread

>>151403027
>Sorry, you being as assmad idiot won't change reality.
It's your choice to stay ignorant of the site functions and behave like a fucking retard when someone corrects you.
>looks like you forgot to make a point again.
I thought I made my point clear to you. Well, if you want me to spell it out for you then here it goes: Please stop misusing greentext on /a/ and go back to /r9k/ or /v/.
>falsely crying about logic fallacies
Sure, if you ignore all the name-calling and strawman used in your posts.

File: legend of the galactic heroes.jpg (206KB, 709x877px) Image search: [Google]

206KB, 709x877px

>>151395545
only this

File: berserk-1592947.jpg (309KB, 1200x869px) Image search: [Google]

309KB, 1200x869px

>>151395545
Not anime but Berserk is straight up 10/10

>>151395545
Detective Conan, NGE, LOGH, Monster, Texhnolyze,, GitS, Akira, HxH

Easy 10/10s

End of Evangelion
Evangelion 2.0
Madoka movies 1+2 (or TV)
Cowboy Bebop
Disappearance
Kara no Kyoukai 5
Tsuioku-hen
Ghost in the Shell
5 cm/s
Ping Pong

Quasi-perfect:
Clannad AS
Steins;gate
Penguindrum
Akira

>>151403370
>It's your choice to stay ignorant of the site functions and behave like a fucking retard when someone corrects you.
If you're going to pretend to know how the site actually works without actually spending time using it, then knock yourself out. You won't be the first or the last.

>misusing greentext
See above.

>name-calling and strawman used in your posts
Ad hominem isn't interchangeable with insult, nor is strawman with paraphrasing.

Stay mad and stupid.

>>151403799
>>151403856
i'm guessing you haven't seen legend of the galactic heroes

File: key_art_ghost_in_the_shell_stand_alone_complex.jpg (159KB, 900x350px) Image search: [Google]

159KB, 900x350px

I don't generally rate things from 1-10 but the only perfect anime is Ghost in the Shell: Stand Alone Complex.

It's not even my favorite I just recognize it as the best.

File: ssy.jpg (448KB, 1623x1600px) Image search: [Google]

448KB, 1623x1600px

3-
SSY
Tatami
Ping Pong

If I could I was rate SSY a 11/10 if that makes sense. I guess I could drop Tatami and Ping Pong down to a 9.5 but there aren't any huge flaws or obvious ways the shows could be largely improved.

Do other anons use comparative rankings like that? Or are all of your 10/10s equal to each other?

>>151404021
If something is the best but not your favorite doesn't that mean that you essentially have shit taste?

Basically your admitting that what is objectively good and what you feel is subjectively the best is misaligned.

Sorry if that comes off as rude but I'm genuinely interested.

Evangellion 10/10
Trinity Blood 10/10
Naruto 10/10 without filler
Jojolion future 10/10
Btoom 10/10

>>151400142
There can be only one ten out of ten animation for me, and sadly it's not Japanese.

probably between 6 and a dozen

>>151395545
A couple.

End of Evangelion
Ghost in the Shell 1995

>>151395545
8. With 4 of them being from the 70's, 2 from the 80's, and 2 show's from the 00's. 462 days of watching.

2016 had great shows - Rakugo, JoJo, FliFla and Natsume were excellent. If a show of that caliber makes your top ranking, whatever a numerically expressed rating may represent for you, that's cool.

>>151404122
Seconding what this anon asked. SAC is one of my favorite series too, and I agree it is objectively good. Kinda interested in how you deal with that dissonance or if it doesn't really matter to you.

File: 1431888926623.png (426KB, 720x720px) Image search: [Google]

426KB, 720x720px

>>151395545
Only one ofc.

>>151395545
0 whats the point in rating shit either i liked it or i didn't

File: 1453088237098.jpg (582KB, 1600x1131px) Image search: [Google]

582KB, 1600x1131px

>>151403891
>If you're going to pretend to know how the site actually works without actually spending time using it, then knock yourself out
I'm pretty sure that the fact that "greentext" should be used only in quotes isn't that hard to grasp.
>Ad hominem isn't interchangeable with insult, nor is strawman with paraphrasing.
Pic related.
Strawman is misrepresenting someone's argument to make it easier to attack which you did in:
>>151401704
>>151402004
>>151402271
And I didn't accuse you of ad-hominem, I accused you of name-calling, which you did in
>>151403891
>>151403027
>>151402861
>>151402271

>>151404993
>I'm pretty sure that the fact that "greentext" should be used only in quotes isn't that hard to grasp.
Anon, you're wrong. Flat out, objectively wrong. You don't know how this site works even a little bit.

>Strawman is misrepresenting someone's argument
He asked me to explain how a joke was funny. I know you're really stupid, but that's a big no-no when it comes to comedy.

>I accused you of name-calling
You responded with me telling you to stop crying about logical fallacies (because only idiots who don't understand them try to cite them in the first place) by telling me "but you called me names". Name calling is not a logical fallacy. You can mosey back on over to /v/ or reddit or anywhere else that takes that kind of pseudo-intellectual bullshit seriously.

3.

Rebellion
EoE
Monogatari SS

Three

Shinsekai Yori
Cross Game
Death Note

I rate shows based purely on enjoyment and I enjoyed the fuck out of those.

>>151395545
4:
1. Fate/Zero
2. Non Non Biyori
3. Carnival Phantasm
4. Lucky Star

File: 1482469538913.jpg (144KB, 668x668px) Image search: [Google]

144KB, 668x668px

Here's my list l/a/ds, get ready to be triggered by my shit taste.

>Been watching Animu since November. Please spare me I'm a newfriend and I like the shows I watch.

Minami-ke - 10
Minami-ke Okawari - 10
Minami-ke Tadaima - 10
Minami-ke Okaeri - 9
Minami-ke Omatase - 9
Toradora! - 10
K-on - 10
K-on!! - 10
K-on! Movie - 10
Sword Art Online - 10
Sword Art Online II - 10
Sword Art Online II: Debriefing - 8
Hyouka - 10
Sakurasou no Pet na Kanojo - 10
Anohana - 10
Tamako Market - 10
Shingeki no Kyojin - 10
Shingeki no Kyojin: Kuinaki Sentaku - 10
Non Non Biyori - 10
Non Non Biyori Repeat - 10
Koyukai no Kanata - 10
Tamako Love Story - 10
Shigatsu wa Kimi no Uso - 10
Hibike! Euphonium (Faveroite) - 10
Hibike! Euphonium: Kakedasu Monaka - 10
Hibike! Euphonium S2 - 10
Re:Zero - 9
Kimi no Na wa. - 10
Kono Bijutsubu ni wa Mondai ga Aru! - 10
Angel Beats! - 9
Oreimo - 9
Oreimo S2 - 9
New Game! - 10
Chuunibyou - 9
Chuunibyou S2 - 9
Kokoro Connect - 9
Saenai Heroine no Sodatekata - 9
Musaigen no Phantom World - 9
ReLIFE - 7
Prison School - 6

pls no bully

File: [HorribleSubs] Diabolik Lovers - 01 [720p].mkv_snapshot_09.59_[2015.10.19_13.51.00].jpg (74KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

74KB, 1280x720px

>>151395545
why are you making so many questions lately, umi-chan?

>>151395545
Four hundred and ninety seven

Number ratings like this are fucking stupid because they imply that art can be generally quantified.

>>151405692
Lurk the fuck more

>>151405868
s-sorry

>>151402771
Watch it again with the animation in mind. I didn't notice it on my first watch either but there are quite a few episodes where the animation can be so bad that it ends up being a distraction.

I love nhk but for me, 10/10 are a mark of quality not QUALITY and so it wouldn't even come close.

>>151405692
Fuck off to MAL holy shit.

>>151405692
>shit taste
This goes beyond that, drink bleach and fuck off back to MAL.

>>151395545
Idk, I want to say eva but that's kind of a meme
maybe cowboy bebop, but it has like 2 bad episodes so it's not really perfect

>>151405692
embarrassing

10/10 is reserved for your personal favorite anime.

File: 1480964931597.jpg (75KB, 1200x675px) Image search: [Google]

75KB, 1200x675px

>>151405692
Anon...

3. One of my personal criteria for a 10 is that it's popular as well as good. That's a very small gap.

>>151395545
As many as I want. Who can stop me?

34, of 444 completed.

4 out of 100ish shows and movies since I won't give anything that didn't drastically impact me emotionally a 10/10. I have probably 20ish shows I would consider 8 or 9's though

File: 10 out 10 anime.jpg (83KB, 664x299px) Image search: [Google]

83KB, 664x299px

a lot

File: IMG_2344.png (226KB, 576x699px) Image search: [Google]

226KB, 576x699px

>>151396732
>he doesn't
School Days is the pinnacle of human storytelling.

One, and it's Boku no Pico like it should be for everyone.

File: IMG_2400.jpg (37KB, 328x466px) Image search: [Google]

37KB, 328x466px

>>151406641
The Biyoris are great but they ain't no 10 lad.

File: 1444500809083.png (735KB, 1189x810px) Image search: [Google]

735KB, 1189x810px

The way my ranking system works, 10/10s are just my personal favorites (where as 9/10s are anime that I loved, but didn't reach "favorite tier")

K-On!! and the K-On! movie
Tamako Market/Love Story
Overman King Gainer
Shirokuma Cafe
Lucky Star
Mushishi (both seasons)
Natsume Yuujinchou (first two seasons)
Tamayura (both seasons)
Serial Experiments Lain
Joshiraku
Wakaba Girl

>>151405145
>He asked me to explain how a joke was funny.
But that's wrong you fucking retard.
>me telling you to stop crying about logical fallacies
Considering the fact that the only way you know how to argue is twisting around opponent's words and finishing it with badass cool-kid finisher, it's obvious that you will commit lots of logical fallacies. If you don't want me pointing them out, I will just tell you straight that your posts are garbage.

File: d46n54a.jpg (108KB, 150x450px) Image search: [Google]

108KB, 150x450px

>>151395545
Aria
Mushishi
Kino no Tabi
Clannad
5cm per second
Sora no Woto
Evangelion
Cardcaptor Sakura
ef

The first season of Code Geass is a 10/10

The second quarter of LoGH is a 10/10

The first half of Death Note is a 10/10

Episode 25 of Gintama is a 10/10

The last episode of every Rolling Girls arc are 10/10

Nanoha A's is a 10/10

>>151406752
I literally can't think of any flaw in the show that could affect my personal enjoyment. For me it's literally the peak of the genre in animated form.

File: [HorribleSubs] Flying Witch - 08 [720p].mkv_snapshot_15.06_[2016.05.29_10.58.39].jpg (105KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

105KB, 1280x720px

I have a couple, less then 10 I think. The ones that people find odd that I rate 10/10 are Horizon in the Middle of Nowhere and Saki.

>>151406752
You're wrong though

>>151400428
Yes, I'm with you, I loved all the Arias but in the end I think I liked The Natural best. Origination had everything coming to an end which didn't feel as comfy and as "Aria" as The Natural felt like.

>>151406808
>But that's wrong you fucking retard.
That's verbatim what he said, you fucking idiot. I didn't add or remove any thoughts to his question. Highlighting the inherent stupidity i nthe question is not strawmanning, paraphrasing is not strawmanning, he just asked a stupid fucking question.
>B-But muh logical fallacies!
You're a bigger idiot than he is.

>twisting around opponent's words
Oh, you must be an ESLfag then, because there's no other way that an objectively accurate paraphrasing of a question would cause a native English speaker to think that words were twisted. English just isn't your cup of tea, right? You're not actually so fucking stupid that you think paraphrasing and twisting are interchangeable, right? Please, please don't tell me you think those words are synonyms, anon.

>>151406848
The quality of a show isn't solely dependent on its lack of flaws.

>>151406848
Not enough Nii-chan. It's a 9 at best.
>>151406914
No, you are.

>>151406641
As opposed to others I'm fine with Non Non being 10 but whenever I see someone giving FLCL so much praise I can't see them as anything but a pretentious shit. Seems like it fits since you're a tripfag.

>>151397111
I agree with you some what but why would K-ON be a 10 outta 10 for you?

>>151404122
If objective excellence guided your taste, you'd basically have no taste. Taste is discriminating between things based on preference, not objective value.

However, if those values aren't entertaining to you, why would you prefer them?

>>151395545

All of them, because I watch mature anime for mature people like me

Also, I have better taste than you

File: sugoi.jpg (110KB, 833x385px) Image search: [Google]

110KB, 833x385px

>madoka being the anime of the decade
>madoka not being a 10
>/a/

File: giraffes.jpg (51KB, 737x501px) Image search: [Google]

51KB, 737x501px

>>151405804
Your enjoyment of the art can be generally quantified.

Haibane Renmei
Texhnolyze

File: 207653755683.jpg (35KB, 554x439px) Image search: [Google]

35KB, 554x439px

>>151400428
>he finished watching it

>>151400340
>bearsuit
>8/10
>same category as Texh

Smuganimegirlface.jpg

>>151408071
For simpletons like you maybe. But that's also just an illusion.

>>151405804
>everything's, like, subjective, man

File: wallpaper-431619.jpg (2MB, 4094x3554px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 4094x3554px

Neon Genesis Evangelion

>>151408174
I liked it 2
Meh 1
I didn't like it 0

Are you sure you're not just blowing smoke, anon?

>>151408174
Jesus Christmas the tippage here is impressive

>>151408206
That's not what I said.

>>151408228
This is fine just to express your attitude. Rating scales are stupid though.

File: 1482584191662.jpg (351KB, 813x861px) Image search: [Google]

351KB, 813x861px

Samurai Champloo
Milky Holmes
Non Non Biyori
Berserk (Old anime, not manga nor movies nor new anime)
Strike Witches OVA
Kiki's Delivery Service
Neon Genesis Evangelion

Ah fuck it I have so many

>>151408383
Like I said, it depends what you're rating.

The only real problem is when you want other people to think your ratings have some objective worth.

File: 1481708183842.png (176KB, 495x495px) Image search: [Google]

176KB, 495x495px

>>151405692
That is the shittest taste I've ever seen.

>>151403955
Its only good until Yang Wenli dies, then it becomes shit.
And the author used navy battle formations and techniques which doesnt make sense in 3D space.

3, unless you count Neon Genesis Evangelion and The End of Evangelion separately, in which case it would be 4.

>>151405692
So you just like anything you see?

File: 10 10 shows.png (1MB, 1363x1091px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 1363x1091px

>>151395545
Way more 10/10 there should be. I might have to re-rate everything later and bring the amount of 10's down to 10 or something.

>>151395545
A lot. I wouldn't watch it if I didn't enjoy it.

File: 1373613605511.gif (627KB, 373x360px) Image search: [Google]

627KB, 373x360px

>>151405692
>Chuunibyou S2 - 9
Is this a fucking joke?
This is EASILY Kyoani's worst anime.

Aria The Animation
Aria the Natural
Aria the Origination

File: 1397597748357.jpg (189KB, 450x450px) Image search: [Google]

189KB, 450x450px

>>151402004
>And every other post up until then was Nene
>every
Seriously, check your eyes, retard. You're clearly blind

And I actually didn't ask you to expain the joke, I asked you why do you consider overused gags to be the pinnacle of a comedy.

File: 1481272795521.png (1MB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 1280x720px

>>151405692
>Kyoani Shills

File: 1479436056233.png (30KB, 1007x1002px) Image search: [Google]

30KB, 1007x1002px

Reminder
>"normie" taste is fine, because generally something is fairly good if people outside of the anime niche like it
>"pretentious" is a buzzword, which means "stop liking anime that lots of people like"

>too many old animes

I guess nostalgia plays a big role in scoring?

>>151395545
LOGH and Milky Holmes S2 are top of my list.

File: 1482525858259.jpg (113KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

113KB, 1280x720px

>>151408648
Not everything but most things I've watched so far, yeah

>tfw return to all these bullies
>tfw not allowed to like what I'm watching

w-well what should I watch guys?

Two, Ping Pong and Planetes. But I give ranks to anything but 10/10s.

>>151399303
Surely Geass "Lelouch"?

>>151408834
How should we know? Looking at your list I can't tell what your taste is other than actual shit. If you just give everything you watch great marks what does it matter?

Think of this, I could recommend an objectively perfect anime to you that everyone agrees is a timeless masterpiece and AT BEST it can rank on the same level as both seasons of SAO. It's a waste of time asking that question.

>>151408652
rofl looks like 10/10 is not what i thought it was supposed to be

>>151409060
I like everything, idk

tend to watch SOL shit

sorry senpai

>>151405692
lol i cant even

>>151404319
Trinity Blood i would have loved to rate 10/10 but it ended at a lame place. 9/10

Most of my favorite shows really. Rose of Versailles, Space Cobra, Ashita no Joe 2, Black Jack OVA's, Rurouni Kenshin OVA's.

>>151408652
>dubbed
Good bait, since this is not yours.

Toradora is the only show I've ever considered flawless.

If Eva 4.0 confirms the theories about it being a continuation of the series and not just a shitty reboot, then the series as a whole will be a 10/10 for me too

File: 1481046602713.png (3MB, 580x2632px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 580x2632px

>>151395545
Only one anime series deserves a 10/10 rating. Not because it's perfect, but because nothing will ever come close to being as good.

>>151409233
It is mine, im just logged in with my other account at the moment.

File: 1423825229578.jpg (59KB, 636x476px) Image search: [Google]

59KB, 636x476px

>>151395545
Well out of the 672 seen I only rated like 8 as 10/10. Kind of chuckling about it now.

>>151395545
Just Evangelion and Madoka

>>151409284
Wasn't as good as the TV ending desu

There's some anime that I rate as a personal 10/10 but nothing I would say is perfect in literally every way

Giant Robot comes close (technical execution, direction, presentation of plot, music are all close to flawless)

Eva, Tatami Galaxy and Baccano are 10/10s for me but I wouldn't call them perfect

File: 1462907178337.png (181KB, 448x463px) Image search: [Google]

181KB, 448x463px

Clannad After Story
K-On!
K-On!!
Steins;Gate
Gekken Shoujo Nozaki-kun
Kimi No Na Wa

My only one is FMA: Brotherhood (read the manga). Because usually my ratings go down looking at the series in retrospect. I'm sure most people who just finished Gurren Lagann would give it a 9001/10 but looking back it's not as good out of the moment.

>>151409527
The 10/10 rating applies to the TV series, 25/26, and EoE all together. Without EoE it'd be like 9.5/10 because EoE has so many aspects that have become iconic in their own right. Eva pushed the boundaries of the industry and medium while EoE just completely ignored the boundaries and shat all over the typical anime watcher's expectations.

>>151405692
A lot of these are probably rated way too high but not a horrible list desu. Don't listen to the contrarian hipster faggots here. They have shit taste and can't appreciate anything just because it's popular. Pretty sad, really.

254. I only have two ratings: 10 and 1. Like and dislike.

>>151395545
Psycho-Pass, Code Geass (both seasons), FMA: B, HxH, Parasyte, Gurran Lagann, Howl's moving castle, Evangelio, and Bakemono no ko.

Not having any tens is dumb.

File: 1478145195629.png (830KB, 792x792px) Image search: [Google]

830KB, 792x792px

>>151409680
thank you senpai
i probably did rate everything too high, but they're all my favorite

>another thread with people who can't comprehend some anime are the same thing despite having separate MAL entries

>hurr I rated Clannad and Clannad AS differently even though they're both literally the VN durr!
>hurr Evangelion and EoE aren't the same thing!
After all these years anons still haven't understood how anime seasons work in Japan?

>>151409711
Having lots of 10s is dumb. When critically evaluating an artistic work, you're supposed to start at 5/10 (average) and add/deduct points as you see fit. Too many people start at 7/10 or 8/10 and only go lower if the work is really bad and stay at 7-9 if it's even moderately satisfying.

>>151399812
>I love the show but 10/10?
It just took the tropes and brought them to the extreme and celebrating them, which almost brought new meaning to them.

Also the fights are so hype.

>>151409758
>Clannad and Clannas AS are the same because the game
Anime != videogames.
>Evangelion and EoE are the same
>anime seasons
?????????

>>151399303
No Code Geass?
I've gone years thinking you're favorite was Code Geass.

File: colorful-2010.jpg (362KB, 1920x1080px) Image search: [Google]

362KB, 1920x1080px

This and the hosoda's girl that bla bla bla time

>>151409835
>?????????
Thanks for proving my point.

Anime nowadays are either 1 or 2 cours. If KyoAni could've made everything at once they would have, but they had to cut the project in half because too big, that's all. If you had played Clannad you'd realize 1/5 of the AS anime isn't even in the After Story route.

Your videogames argument is also wrong because what I implied applies to many other franchises out there, not only VN adaptations.

EVA and EOE are the same, yes, they're Evangelion, one of the same.

>>151405692
>all that shit rated so highly
>prison school only gets a 6
Prison school is no masterpiece by an means but damn that's a pretty brutal score when you give everything 9 or 10

>>151409768
I also start at five, but I drop anything if it stays at a five.

>>151409924
How can EVA and EoE be different cours if EoE didn't even air on tv?

>>151409928
Some people are bad with ecchi. Or I should say they don't necessarily want to be seen as pervert, or accept that side of them that actually enjoys ecchi. It's pretty common among newfriends.

Once they'll have watched more the shame will go away and they'll rate ecchi shows for how they really enjoyed it rather than how they think it "should be rated by some sort of social norm".

>>151409985
stop posting.

>>151409758
Why does it bother you so much?

>>151409928
I don't, I just didn't list everything

I have plenty of things rated between 4-10 but I just posted all of my high ones and the 'low' popular ones I've watched

not that i have watched a lot

to be honest Prison School anime was shit imo compared to the manage but yea

>>151409924
Also, would you consider dragon ball, Z, GT, super and the over 20 movies and specials the same thing?

File: 1480972241702.jpg (80KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

80KB, 1280x720px

>>151410030
manga*

>>151410006
pretty much, i don't really like ecchi, not that I think it's weird or whatever I just don't find it funny or arousing

i don't understand the point of ecchi

maybe it is being a newfriend

>>151409985
EoE is an alternate ending/extension to the TV series. If you're rating NGE as a whole it'd make sense to include it, especially since it fills a lot of gaps that the original ending didn't really elaborate on.

File: 1482372249105.jpg (9KB, 302x225px) Image search: [Google]

9KB, 302x225px

>>151401805
If 5 is average why the fuck are you dropping 6's

>>151410032
No, because they were clearly made at different periods of times, by different studios, directors, etc. That'd be silly.

My point was directed towards things that aired in a fragmented way, back to back, by the same people.

>>151410013
Bothered is too strong, I just find it silly how imaginary separations somehow make people feel and think differently about piece of arts, that's all.

>>151410103
Well ultimately to each their own, I was just projecting a bit.

File: 45c62e08f2ae575b37f4d98807086e4d.jpg (11KB, 197x255px) Image search: [Google]

11KB, 197x255px

>>151409756
>SAO is 8/10 at absolute best
>Re:Zero is irredeemable trash
>Prison School that low? Really?
Could nitpick more but whatever, as long as you're enjoying yourself who gives a fuck? Just watch more and you'll see why anons are so salty. I give your taste a solid 7/10 for now senpai

>>151410103
Ecchi is either something that you get or you don't. Some ecchi series like SnO or KlK take advantage of the ecchi aspect to do more than just be softcore porn, but there are people who just like ecchi in general as long as it's well-made.

It's not unusual to have a distaste for pure ecchi that has nothing else to offer but boobs and fanservice. Having a distaste for it isn't exclusive to newfags, either.

File: r8.png (38KB, 634x639px) Image search: [Google]

38KB, 634x639px

>>151395545
None. It's a lot easier to find anime with no redeeming qualities than ones with no faults.

I have 830 completed entries and I've only ever dropped one show.

It was Strike the Blood, 8 ep watched / 24(? or something, was 2 cours-long).

>>151410203
10s aren't supposed to be """objective""".

>>151410126
Dragon ball and its sequels was made by toei, tons of episode directors but it was a fragmented adaption of the same manga by the same people.

Only two anime have made a 10/10 on my list. Evangelion 2.0 and Azumanga Daioh. Very close 10's have been Lucky Star and Nichijou.

>>151410262
I have never watched any of this I just implied what you wanted to convey considering DBZ is old and has dragged on for decades.

Perhaps you could actually argue or discuss what I'm actually getting at instead of being a pretentious little shit?

File: ss+(2016-12-26+at+02.14.14).png (21KB, 624x593px) Image search: [Google]

21KB, 624x593px

>>151410203

Brother?

>>151410180
well prison school in particular is probably cause it's the only manga I've actually read and I felt the show was pretty garbage in comparison but still entertaining

>>151410190
do you watch ecchi? why do you watch it if you do? pretty curious desu

>>151410203
This is what a good rating distribution should look like. Assuming you avoid series that are obviously irredeemable trash it makes sense to have a bell curve centering around 5-6. It also means you have a tendency to approach a show from a more objective viewpoint as a critic.

>>151410243
A 10/10 is a perfect score. Ascore is an opinion and an opinion cannot be objectively true, but even then a 10 should be extremely rare if you give everything you watch a fair chance and start at 5 like a good critic should.

I personally have one 10/10 score reserved for Evangelion because it is the only anime work that has such a high degree of literary value, production value, and influence to be considered anywhere near a truly perfect work despite its flaws.

4: Steins;Gate, Cowboy Bebop, Madoka, Disappearance.

My criteria is 9 for shows that I really enjoyed, 10 for shows that really stood above and beyond other shows, and 8/7/6 for shows that were fun but I didn't enjoy as much as the 9's. If I were to watch something bad I would start using 5 and below, but why would I do that? I spend a lot of time deciding what to watch, and because of that I've never seen something absolutely abysmal.

File: weather_is_speachless.png (237KB, 241x390px) Image search: [Google]

237KB, 241x390px

3
>Book of Murder
>Big O
>Steam Boy

>>151410116
Most anime is shit.

>>151410404
To me 10s are often personal, especially when it comes to manga.

>>151410307
I'm just following a basic logic way to discuss your problem.
>It's a fragmented adaption made by the same people and that's why clannad ans clannad AS / Evangelion and EoE are the same thing
If you say that and I show and example where saying the same thing would be stupid then your argument is invalid. Calling me names won't change that.

>>151399303
Oh man you still post with a trip? I didn't expect you to last this long you loser.
You're as sad as the sakurafish anon

>>151410006
It's hilarious how, even when people are alone in their rooms, social pressure can still be stronger than the base sex drive.
Or could it be the opposite case, that some of these shows are so creepy and self-depreciating they provide no sexual arousal whatsoever.

>>151410462
If you can't see how Clannad and Clannad AS are a different case than a series dragging on for 20 years then I'm afraid I can't help you get you out of your secondary bubble

File: 1459538299805.png (343KB, 800x730px) Image search: [Google]

343KB, 800x730px

How do you set up your rating system, boys?
For me:

10: Personal favorites. Emotional attachment tier
9: Loved it
8: Satisfying
7: Decent
6: Had to force myself to finish it
5: Number of flaws and good points are about equal
4-2: Based on how much I regret watching it
1: Guilty Crown

>>151410310
I enjoy ecchi shows similar to the ones I mentioned (SnO, KlK) because they tend to utilize the ecchi for more than just getting the audience erect. Tying ecchi to a work's themes or using it for (effective) comedic value is hard to pull off. When it's done right, ecchi can be an effective method of adding sexual (social) commentary to a story without being too obtrusive. Especially in anime, which tends to be fairly comedic or lighthearted by nature.

>>151410450
Part of the personal value ties into literary value in my opinion. If I find a work to be emotionally moving or think it does a good job at connecting to its audience it'd definitely make me want to rate it higher, but you have to be careful to avoid rating something higher just because it has aspects which appeal to your interests.