Just recently finished the tsukihime manga. Wanted to know how /a/ thought of it compared to the VN.
>>150987787
I haven't read it just watched thevisual novel
>>150987787
Manga is pretty decent, but it's no replacement. You're missing the far-side routes:Akiha, Hisui, Kohaku. Which many consider the better half of the story.
Kagetsu Tohya is great as well, as a sequel of sorts.
I forget, was SHIKI even introduced in the manga?
Oh yeah, I consider the soundtrack pretty great as well. It's overall a different experience.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0sgQOBJrPnI
>>150987787
Why is she so best, /a/?
>>150988375
It is the long flowing skirt.
>>150987939
SHIKI was in the manga, but later gets completely taken over by Roa. A shame, I liked SHIKI much better as an antagonist.
>>150988402
Rip in 17 pieces.
>>150987787
I've only read the manga so I wouldn't know. How different is Arc's route in the VN?
>>150987787
I actually love the manga more than I loved the Arcueid route it is based on from the VN. Even Nasu admits as such. It is superior. What it lacks, of course, is the other remaining routes of the VN.
>>150989082
The manga is basically the Arcuied route itself, with lots of elements from the other routes in it.
I think the manga is a better Arc route, but less good then the entire VN itself.
The whole scene at the end where Shiki goes and finds her is manga only. In the VN you have true end where Arc never comes back, and good end where she does come back herself.
>>150989614
What's nice about the manga ending is that it directly connects it to Eclipse.
>>150989082
so her hair goes from ¬ to m to n
The manga is the better Arc route, but the VN is the better Tsukihime.
>>150987787
God-tier for the near side routes.
>>150987787
the anime was better