[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / bant / biz / c / can / cgl / ck / cm / co / cock / d / diy / e / fa / fap / fit / fitlit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mlpol / mo / mtv / mu / n / news / o / out / outsoc / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / spa / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vint / vip / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Search | Free Show | Home]

So what does /a/ think of the manga adaptation of "The smiling,

This is a blue board which means that it's for everybody (Safe For Work content only). If you see any adult content, please report it.

Thread replies: 94
Thread images: 9

File: lol.jpg (180KB, 670x951px) Image search: [Google]
lol.jpg
180KB, 670x951px
So what does /a/ think of the manga adaptation of "The smiling, proud wanderer"? It was originally a famous wuxia (martial arts) novel.
>>
File: lol.png (313KB, 670x1071px) Image search: [Google]
lol.png
313KB, 670x1071px
>>149012768
>>
>>149012768
First time I've heard of it, art looks pretty clean. Would you recommend it?
>>
>>149013418
yea, the story and themes present in wuxia novel is very differrent from most manga
>>
File: lol.jpg (286KB, 1340x957px) Image search: [Google]
lol.jpg
286KB, 1340x957px
>>149013976
>>
>>149013123
But they aren't even fighting yet? Why are the people so distressed?
>>
>>149016081
last chapter the bandit was fighting some guys from the Mt Tai sect.
>>
>>149013123
>>149014216

Was this inspired by a real life event, or did it inspire other media?

The sitting duel is something I've seen a lot in wuxia stuff, especially films.
>>
>>149012768
>wuxia (martial arts)

If you don't know what wuxia is then you don't belong here
>>
>>149016777
Well, most martial arts films are heavily influenced or even based off Jin Yong's novels.
>>
>>149016835
"martial arts" is a simplified explanation.
>>
>>149012768
Chinkfag here. The original story is a very intriguing read starring a likeable, perscuted protagonist, combining elements of suspense and political allegory.

Becoming a girl is a major plot element in this story so /a/ will probably love it.

It gets bonus points because the protagonist's endgame is a tsundere
>>
File: lol.png (301KB, 670x1057px) Image search: [Google]
lol.png
301KB, 670x1057px
>>149017272
>>
>>149014216
That looks pretty neat. Why aren't the chinks making anime based off these instead? Looks better than their attempts to copy nip's moe anime.
>>
new "Blood and Steel" fucking when ;_;
>>
File: SD001_006.jpg (77KB, 1340x953px) Image search: [Google]
SD001_006.jpg
77KB, 1340x953px
I hope this one gets translated next.
>>
>Most powerful martial arts require castration

>Mc got ntr'd

>Mc is 60% injured in the novel without internal energy because bullshit sword technique.

Heaven sword dragon sabre is the ultimate jap novel. It's beta mc with a harem of loli maid, 2 yandere and semi-yandere tsundere coisine.
Mc is overpowered but choke in every fight
>>
>>149025195
>Heaven sword dragon sabre
Yeah, I remember being really annoyed with how indecisive he was. Truly Top Battle Harem material right there. But he's still better than the fucking monk from Demi-Gods and Semi-Devils. Now that's a shitty mc that would fit the shittiest of harem anime.
>>
>>149025195
>>Mc got ntr'd

Return of The Condor Hero?
>>
>>149025347
There's plenty of NTR in wuxia.
>>
>>149025347

Smiling Proud Wander was true ntr. To the extent the bitch still loved him even after the guy who ntr-es reveals himself to be a huge dick.

Return was rape and many occasions of almost ntr.
>>
>>149012768
Are you from the scanlation team, OP?
>>
>>149025195

I prefer Yang Guo's harem

>older sister teacher
>bitch hand-cutting childhood friend
>loli imouto
>meek nice girl
>that other childhood friend

Don't remember if he had other girls pinning on him, but those were the major ones.
>>
>>149017272
>Becoming a girl is a major plot element in this story so /a/ will probably love it.

HalfChinkfag who read the book here, now that's how you spread miss information.
>>
>>149025347
>Return
Not NTR! His waifu was raped, it doesn't count!
>>
>>149025450

You miss the passionless valley girl. Well it's not a harem when
mc is faithful to only one girl, 16 years ffs.
>>
>>149025450
>>bitch ARM-cutting childhood friend
she want hate fuck so bad I can tell
>>
>>149025512

I labelled that as meek nice girl.

Well, the only true harem in Jin Yong's works are Wei Xiabao in Deer/Cauldron anyway.

Nothing quite like gaining some harem members by raping them and impregnating them in their sleep.
>>
>>149025495
>to try and "trigger" people
Seems like it's working with you.
>>
>>149025450
Duan Yu's harem is pretty good too.
He's got the super smart ojou-sama who ended up ditching the other guy for MC, a kuudere, the oujo's sisters etc.

Also wincest end since his harem is his cousins.
>>
>>149025557
>Nothing quite like gaining some harem members by raping them and impregnating them in their sleep.
And of course some good old NTR in the mix well.
>>
File: onefor(you).jpg (165KB, 640x480px) Image search: [Google]
onefor(you).jpg
165KB, 640x480px
>>149025543
Paranoid will do that to you sometime.
>>
>>149025495
>>149025543
>>149025573
Look, clearly no one gives a fuck but you. Even you were right about the OP, that doesn't hinder our ability to have a valid discussion in this thread. Which we are, aside from your shitposting.
>>
Gu Long has more smarter and sexier female villiansthan jin yong.
>>
>>149025389

Ah yes I remember now, I don't remember if the mc liked the the junior girl though? I never read the book only watched the tv series (2001 is the one I think).
>>
File: No bully.png (341KB, 689x795px) Image search: [Google]
No bully.png
341KB, 689x795px
>>
>>149025490
Well she almost married another guy if that counts.
>>
>>149025643
Just ignore and report. Same deal with anti-crack kun.

>>149025486
I think it'll be even more misleading if you bait /m/ with this series. They'll be super pissed off that TOUHOU FUHAI wasn't what they expected.
>>
>>149025672

MC liked junior girl. Even after he got his new evil sect waifu, it was clear that he still liked his junior girl a lot. Honestly the way it was written, half of his devotion to his new waifu felt like it came out of obligation because of how much she was willing to sacrifice for his sake.
>>
>>149025702

Smiling Proud Wanderer was full of subversive qualities. Most powerful character in the series dies like a bitch through threats and manipulation, and in only one chapter despite being hyped half the series.
>>
>>149025672
>junior girl
Yue Lingshan? He does. In fact, many fans think that the romance in Wanderer wasn't romantic at all since he seems to be with the cult princess to repay her.

Seriously, you should read the novels as you're missing out a lot. None of the TV series have been close to faithful.
>>
How the fuck has this thread one shitposter who ruined everything.

Dude, we only get just one manhwa thread for months or something just let us have discussion u fucking autistic.

Why aren't spamming at other threads?
>>
>>149025643
Remember to report him.
>>
>>149025775

Yeah, reading Wanderer felt weird. There was a lot of emotion when it came to Lingshan's drama in Ling Wu Chung's case. But with YingYing, it felt more like a respectful relationship of people who agreed to marry via an arranged relationship.
>>
>>149025758

It was 3v1, and he stomped easily the other 3 if not for Ren Ying Ying threaten him with his lover.
>>
>>149025802
He did, at /u/.
>>
>>149025758
Pretty much, yeah.
>the so-called heretic cults have plenty of loyal bros
>most of the villains came from the so-called righteous sects
>the notorious evil rapist bandit was more honourable than a lot of the "good guys"
>strongest martial arts move makes you not want to give a shit about being the best fighter anymore

>>149025802
Just report, ignore and keep the conversation going.
>>
>>149025768
>No one is autistic as you
Says the guy getting completely assblasted by a file name. You can't make this shit up.
>>
>>149025663
Anon my phone can't connect to the internet, yes I'm that poor.

If you can check IP you'll see it from different country unless the main hub is from Singapore, even if it's from the same hub the last 4 or 3 digits still isn't the same.

Your level of paranoid is way of the chart right now.
>>
File: lol.png (143KB, 1629x726px) Image search: [Google]
lol.png
143KB, 1629x726px
>>149025742
>>
>>149025842
>>149025846
Just report and ignore. Engaging him only makes it worse.
>>
Yang guo dugu sword style is stronger than Ling Wu chong 9DJ
>>
>>149025865
>don't reply to him
>he accuses you to be !akemi/Troid/Neko something/whatever mod
>reply to him
>he still accuses you to be !akemi/Troid/Neko something/whatever mod
It's a lost cause.
>>
>>149025817
Proud Wanderer is all about bros before hoes, man. Hanging out and bonding with your bros matter more in that work (no homo, unless you're Master Asia). Liu Zhengfeng and his family got killed because Zhuo Lengchan is jealous of Liu and Qu's bromance.
>>
To me, it's clear that I'm talking to at least two different people (not including the one who claims we're all the same), and why does it matter if all of us has some typo or poor grammar? At least it's eligible.

I want to discuss and reply quickly. Not waste time with pretending I am different. It's so difficult to talk wuxia on /a/, I want to enjoy this.
>>
Is this chink shit /a/ related?
>>
>>149025931
Well, it's more /a/ related than >>149025495 for sure.
>>
>>149025931

>Saw a thread about katawa shoujo/nekopara, mods choose to ignore it
>>
>>149025909
>because you are upset you got made of
What was that about garbage English?
>>
>>149025911
It's about the lesser evil.

>>149025924
That's why it's all the more important to learn to ignore. As long as we keep to the topic, thread won't get derailed since he's screaming alone.

>>149025891
It's not fair, Yang Guo learned more bullshit hax martial arts and qi shenanigans than Linghu Chong.
>>
>>149025951
So it's not /a/ related?
>>
>>149025974

I think XLN dual wielding is still stronger than LHC.

Hell, LHC 9DJ weakness is speed, no way he can't beat her.
>>
>>149025891

Yang Guo's Dugu style was basically the level where he doesn't need a physical sword anymore, whereas 9DJ still requires a sword.
>>
>>149025924
You should swing by /tg/ more often. Pretty fun wuxia threads once in a while.
>>
>>149026067
>Sorry, that was a keyboard error.
More like you don't know speak English.
>>
>>149025924
>It's so difficult to talk wuxia on /a/
Why the hell do you want to discuss not /a/ related on /a/? just go to /m/ or /lit/ something
>>
I let the shitposter win and made another thread >>149026102

Not like it matters.
>>
>>149025924
Just wait for the puppet show's 2nd season.
>>
>>149026116

/lit/ sure, but why /m/?
>>
>>149025722
>>149025775

Well that killed any interest left in reading the novels, since it sounds like it will be quite an ntr ride. Weird since I get off on ntr hentai (I blame it on the condor 1995 rape scene).

Mind telling me what happens at to the end for the junior girl? Killed with the guy or so?
>>
>>149026166
gundam wuxia. God, you such a newfag
>>
File: 0.jpg (177KB, 1320x655px) Image search: [Google]
0.jpg
177KB, 1320x655px
>>149026067
>Sorry, that was a keyboard error.
A keyboard error made you skip a whole word. Ok. Same thing happened to me when you accused me of being this person who fuels your paranoia.

Also, no native English speaker would use the term "keyboard error" to refer to a typo.

>>149026013
>see, I'm ruining this thread with my shitposting and THEY AREN'T MAKING A NEW ONE, that clearly proves it's just one person
Someone forgot to take his meds. Also, the stats at the bottom of the page show the amount of unique posters, you dumb fuck.
>>
>>149026187

OK.

NTR guy manages to achieve the revenge he intended through entire series. He reveals all the evil shit he's done to reach that far to junior girl. Junior girl sympathises with him and wants to have sex with him, but he reveals he's castrated himself to learn the super powerful ability.

He reveals more stuff about himself and her father, she becomes disraught and betrayed, then he kills her. In her death, she ask the MC and MC's new waifu to not kill the NTR guy.
>>
>>149026214

Why aren't you responding to loli garbage threads then, u sperglord?

>149020356
>149018920
>149023041
>>
>>149026187
You should still read it for the banter. Which is what the novels really excelled at and the TV adaptations keep messing up. And yes, she dead.
>>
>>149026214
Let's say you're right. WHO FUCKING CARES? He isn't doing it in this thread.
>>
Read deer of cauldron if you hate ntr.

The mc will do the ntr there.
>>
>>149026148
>>149026148
>>149026148
>>
>>149026213
>>149026116

Not that anon but mind explaining what gundam wuxia is all about? I haven't lurked /a/ and other boards so much for a couple years now.
>>
>>149026359
Where's the rape in those pics? Isn't that what you had a problem with?
>>
>>149025702
>anime called TOUHOU comes out
>it has nothing to do with the touhou project
>>
>>149026213
It's time.

ANSWER ME DOMON
>>
>>149026364
No, fuck off newfag. Also these wuxishit thread is not /a/ related, fuck off to /m/
>>
>>149025865
This.
>>
>>149022796
Mein neger.

I check EG site pretty much everyday, official releases where I live are slow as fuck, we're up to the 6th volume or so.

I met the author (writer) at the Paris Expo, dude looks like a South China Sea pirate. Totally a chill guy, got an autograph and all p,us a little chat with both him and the translator.
I felt bad that me and my gf were the only ones there, B&S puts to shame 99% of fighting manga.
>>
>>149025576
This always works.
>>
Where is the Journey to the West?
>>
>>149027583
...what?
>>
>>149026427
dude, the OP is a manga, manga is allowed on /a/.
>>
>>149022757
They think that it's not profitable, even if it's better.
>>
>>149028394
[citation needed]
>>
>>149028898
Their "anime" can talk for themselves. The Chineses try to imitate the Japaneses because anime attract a lot of people.
>>
>>149029065
you know that animation isnt a japan only thing right? it just originated there.
>>
>>149017272
I like you
Thread posts: 94
Thread images: 9


[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / bant / biz / c / can / cgl / ck / cm / co / cock / d / diy / e / fa / fap / fit / fitlit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mlpol / mo / mtv / mu / n / news / o / out / outsoc / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / spa / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vint / vip / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Search | Top | Home]

I'm aware that Imgur.com will stop allowing adult images since 15th of May. I'm taking actions to backup as much data as possible.
Read more on this topic here - https://archived.moe/talk/thread/1694/


If you need a post removed click on it's [Report] button and follow the instruction.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com.
If you like this website please support us by donating with Bitcoins at 16mKtbZiwW52BLkibtCr8jUg2KVUMTxVQ5
All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties.
Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from that site.
This means that RandomArchive shows their content, archived.
If you need information for a Poster - contact them.