>reading the manga/LN version when there's an anime adaptation

>>145260308
that's a nice picture

File: 1460491741737s.jpg (8KB, 174x231px) Image search: [Google]

8KB, 174x231px

>>145260308
What if the anime isn't a complete telling of the story tho

>>145260379
99% of the time the "complete telling" of the story goes completely off rails or is abruptly canceled. You'd know this if you read a lot of manga and LNs

>>145260431
I'm just bringing up the first obvious point. If anything you should respond to the Op instead of me.

File: 1465290762067.jpg (52KB, 339x407px) Image search: [Google]

52KB, 339x407px

>>145260308
>Reading/watching the adaptation before reading/watching the source material
I almost feel bad for you.

>>145260308
>watching the anime when there's a 100% chance it's worse than the source material

>>145260308
>read source material for years
>all of a sudden I'm expected to stop because some faggy studio wants to make 30 minute commercials of it
How about you fuck off

>>145260734
The vast majority of manga is little more than rushed out the door doodles

Similarly LNs are nothing more than D-tier anime scripts of almost zero literally worth.

Anime brings fun to the table with things like color, animation, voice acting and consistent art.

>>145260308
There are like 3 anime that aren't worse than their manga counterpart.

I honestly think there's 0 but I'm saying 3 to give myself some leeway.

>>145260308
That looks like a lot of semen. I mean a lot

File: 1439948696474.jpg (104KB, 581x668px) Image search: [Google]

104KB, 581x668px

>I am too stupid to appreciate manga as a medium, so I'm sure everyone else is too
Fuck off.

>>145260994
That's because there are literally 0 manga that offer the same wide range of experiences that a corresponding anime would, so since it only focuses on a couple things it's way easier to execute them well. Anime still has better immersion and impact than manga or LNs for that matter could ever have.

Is cum stuffed cheeks a tag?

It should be, because that shit is my fetish.

>>145261030
What's there to appreciate about mass produced black and white doodles that are so badly drawn you can barely even tell what's going on, and which is made worse by all the god awful scans.

What's there to appreciate about babel-fish tier translations?

>>145261075
Nah. I get more into stuff when I read it than when I watch it. The only advantage anime has over manga is music.

File: 1133.jpg (91KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

91KB, 1280x720px

If the anime interests me I'll pick up the manga.

Only worked for Terra Formars though, Did for Prison School but I dropped it since I got over it.

>>145260431
A lot of people just use the lack of relative popularity of manga in the west as hipster cred. So they don't care that the works that typically get complete adaptations tend to be of higher quality anyway.

File: I came here to laugh at you.png (138KB, 375x375px) Image search: [Google]

138KB, 375x375px

>>145260308

File: 1469046191168.png (247KB, 421x1003px) Image search: [Google]

247KB, 421x1003px

>>145260927
>>>fun
If color, animation, and voice acting are the only way to enjoy comic books then that's pityful, you're missing out on tons of media that'll never even get adapted.
>consistent art
Not every studio willing to pick stuff up is blessed with even that.
At least with source material I can blame faults on the author, not some guy who can't put things to a screen.

>>145260526

https://exhentai.org/g/733840/6d2cc8e66e/

Thanks /v/ archive

>>145261224
>lack of relative popularity of manga in the west as hipster cred.
People eat up shit like Tokyo Ghoul all the time here, manga isn't exactly obscure

The only problem with watching the anime is that I have to wait a week inbetween episodes of Berserk.

>>145261224
For me it's more that anime requires a budget so they take less risks. You don't generally see stuff like YKK or Dorohedoro being animated and if you did it would cover 1/4 of the story and cut a bunch of characters.

File: 1470418496365.jpg (157KB, 432x531px) Image search: [Google]

157KB, 432x531px

>>145261340
Couldn't find it after searching my ass off. Thanks.

I only watch anime adaptations that cover the whole plot from the source material, my autism stops me from enjoying a show if there's still unadapted material.

>>145261455
YKK got some OVAs. You're right about them not covering much though.

I don't really bother following most manga series, I just read everything and then revisit the manga months later when there's more.

That said, I appreciate the source material more than the adaptation in 90% of cases, the 10% being Keyshit VNs and similar crap.

>>145261285
>manga
>comic books
Good joke, but comic books actually have good art and colors

>>145261173
>music
>voice acting
>animation
>color art
>real time direction
All have significant effects on viewer immersion and enjoyment for obvious reasons. Manga is much more one-dimensional; it's a thousand times easier to make a perfect manga than a perfect anime. The experience of the anime is still usually better overall.

>>145261683
Manga is literally Japanese comic books, I don't see the point in your shitposts

>>145261819
No, manga are literally doodles that are rushed out the door every single week through what amounts to sweat shop labor.

99% of manga looks like absolute trash because of this. They sell Manga insanely cheap to make up for this.

Manga is completely lifeless and on top of that you're reading shitty scans and even shittier translations.

Manga is made specifically for the lowest common denominator.

Anime is made for people who actually care about things like art, direction, immersion, etc. this is why anime is sold at a premium.

>>145261980
Since you're adamant that your opinion is fact then I guess you can believe what you want.
Just don't surprised if people disagree.

File: 1390385428040.gif (574KB, 250x164px) Image search: [Google]

574KB, 250x164px

>>145261340
>NTR

File: anon pls.jpg (32KB, 287x195px) Image search: [Google]

32KB, 287x195px

>This entire fucking thread

>>145260308
Only mainstream anime like Naruto and One Piece can be compared to manga. Everything else is just expansive commercial of source material. That is why there is never s2. You are supposed to buy manga.

Let's talk about anime that have covered the entire manga/LN. From the top of my head (excluding infinite shonen):
>FMA: Brotherhood
>Cross Game
>Hellsing OVAs
>Ping Pong
>Monster

>>145260585
>implying he reads/watches the source material at all

My God you have your head so far up your ass your inside out at this point.

>>145261793
This bait is so good I thought you were serious for a moment.

>>145262395
Aria IIRC
Mushishi

>>145262395
Did Akagi/Kaiji cover their full mangas?

>>145262395
BokuMachi
Parasyte

>>145262537
>Manga is low effort doodles made for the lowest common denominator.
>
>There is more emotion in 1 episode of Re:Zero than in the entire WN
There it is.

>>145262420
I thought I was an autist among autists. I don't understand how people can watch anime adaptations without having read the manga/LN.

>>145262854
No, both of them are still ongoing in manga form. The Kaiji anime covered the first two out of five parts (5th one is ongoing). Parts 3 and 4 have been completely scanlated.

>>145262537
>Manga
>Lowest common denominator
Now that's some absurdist shitposting

File: 1460758794297.png (763KB, 820x1200px) Image search: [Google]

763KB, 820x1200px

>>145262537
>Manga is low effort doodles made for the lowest common denominator.

>>145263101
>>145263022
>>145262956
Not an argument.

File: low effort.jpg (1MB, 2028x1440px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 2028x1440px

>>145263458

>>145262588
I'm not the guy who's baiting in this thread. If you thought that post was bait then you're delusional

File: doodles.jpg (844KB, 1600x1073px) Image search: [Google]

844KB, 1600x1073px

>>145263458
Nothing but doodles!

>>145262537
>Manga is low effort doodles made for the lowest common denominator.
As opposed to anime of the same calibur?

>>145263687
>>145263806
Epic outlier /b/ro!

Monthly series make up a tiny % of the industry.

>>145263821
There are certainly lots of shitty cash in rush jobs in the anime industry, but overall anime is a much, much higher quality product.

>>145261529
I feel you, anon.

Most manga adaptations downgrade the art so it's easier to animate.

>>145263955
Most manga are monthly serials you idiot pleb.

>>145263955
>Monthly series make up a tiny % of the industry.
Well, now I know you are retarded.

>>145264091
>gets blown the fuck out
>starts making shit up
lol sorry you can't accept the fact manga is bottom of the barrel garbage that's literally sold for cents

>reading LNs
why would to do this to yourself

>>145263458
No argument necessary

>>145264169
Most manga is shit
Most anime is shit
You're still retarded

File: 1451825452990.png (10KB, 352x351px) Image search: [Google]

10KB, 352x351px

>>145263955
>but overall anime is a much, much higher quality product

>>145264142
OP by itself has sold more volumes than the entire monthly magazine industry ever put together

95% of the money goes to weekly maga

>>145264198
This desu
Why would I want to read poorly written garbage when I can watch the anime and spare myself from terrible prose and translations?

>>145264231
Yeah but at least anime has color, animation, music, voice acting, actual direction, pacing, etc.

Manga are literally doodles.

>>145264372
>voice acting
A very good reason to read manga and skip anime, unless you enjoy listening to mongoloids whining or shouting.

>>145264372
Exactly once have I ever seen those improve the original. Usually they turn it to shit.

>>145263955
Please tell me you're not serious. Please tell me that you're not an ignorant asshole.

>>145264584
Color, animation, music, etc are automatic improvements for 99.99% of manga.

Otoh there are probably no more than two or three manga that didn't go off rails or get canceled. They all end like garbage

File: diu_color.jpg (947KB, 1560x1200px) Image search: [Google]

947KB, 1560x1200px

Tell us OP, how many manga have you actually read? And just skimming or seeing a few images here and there doesn't count.

File: KINGU KRIMUSON.jpg (63KB, 688x720px) Image search: [Google]

63KB, 688x720px

>>145261110
>>145260308
>>145263955
(you)

>>145264751
No, it's not an improvement. They are different mediums.

>>145264315
That is irrelevant to this exchange.

>>145265106
Yes it is a direct improvement.

Manga is black and white and badly drawn due to monetary reasons. That's it.

Most manga are so badly drawn you can't even tell what's going on in the panels once the action kicks off. If you think this is intended and part of the manga "medium" then you are a delusional hipster idiot

>>145260308
>not reading the anime

>>145265161
It is directly relevant.

>>145264751
Oh well I guess if you just say it it must be true

Color doesn't match, animation done poorly by Korean slaves, music ruins scenes, any number of things can and will ruin the anime. Except in exactly one case as I said.

>>145265167
>badly drawn due to monetary reasons.
Then I guess at least manga has an excuse

>>145265167
Nice ad hominem. Not my fault you are not able to read a manga and you find it confusing.

>>145265167
>Most manga are so badly drawn you can't even tell what's going on in the panels once the action kicks off.
So what does that say about the anime adaptation that has even worse art?

>>145265278
Nobody said bad adaptations didn't exist. The vast majority of them are good and provide a huge improvement over the source material.

>>145260308
Gate. Where the opposite applies.

>>145265348
You can stop pretending now

>>145265360
sounds like a personal problem

How can such a gigantic hook fish so many fishes?
It's supossed to have only ONE edgy point

>Replying to such low quality bait.

>>145265513
I feel like you're arguing solely for the reason of winning. Nobody cares about your shit opinion. No one is going to stop reading manga because of an autist like you.

File: baitkake.png (98KB, 625x626px) Image search: [Google]

98KB, 625x626px

>>145265529
>ONE

>>145265568
>opinion
Manga is cheaply made
Manga is black and white
Manga is badly drawn
Manga is sold for cents
Manga is made for the lowest common denominator

None of those are opinions

File: image.gif (415KB, 480x238px) Image search: [Google]

415KB, 480x238px

>>145265646
Here you go, baby boy

>>145265646
You sound like the type of guy that needs someone to read books to you with funny voices or you get bored.

The voiceacting in my head is better than any Japanese dude squeaking into a mic. Black and white is fine. Some of it is drawn fantastically.

Furthermore because the budget isn't as high you can get some creative stories instead of: Premise x highschool + walking tropes = show

File: 1433140762807.png (35KB, 625x626px) Image search: [Google]

35KB, 625x626px

>>145265646
>4 out of 5 apply equally if not more to anime

>>145261381
>lack of relative popularity of manga
>relative
relative to anime, manga isn't popular

>>145260308
Why would I watch the Noragami anime when it changes stuff from the original intent?

ITT:
Autists pretending 90% of manga isn't shit. Most of the other 10% isn't well drawn anyways even if the story is good.
Even those that are good stories will be redrawn for tonkoban releases.
In 15-30 years it'll be rereleased in color and finally reach the level of art comic books contain.
That anime adaptations have a chance of taking some of the good stories and making them crap again.
We should all probably just kill ourselves, that excited feeling you got while reading a manga/watching an anime that interested you will probably never come back.

>>145260526

I don't even need to search to know that's Rocket Monkey. And to know that means its NTR.

>>145262917
>BokuMachi

They cut off the last arc entirely and changed the whole ending though.

File: Rikka trash..jpg (49KB, 300x386px) Image search: [Google]

49KB, 300x386px

>>145260308
>Being shameless secondary scum when you could read the more complete source material
Plebian trash.

File: 1466518787094.png (46KB, 213x361px) Image search: [Google]

46KB, 213x361px

>Quality of fight scenes

Light Novel > Anime > Manga

File: Kino loses a bet.png (993KB, 1354x1491px) Image search: [Google]

993KB, 1354x1491px

>preferring an adaption over the source material

File: 1459707181637.jpg (133KB, 602x1327px) Image search: [Google]

133KB, 602x1327px

I hate it when an anime adaptation has a bad original ending for a manga series that's not even finished and when the manga is at the end, its ending is about of the same quality as the anime one. It's even worse if the endings are very similar.

>>145267865
Worst opinion I've ever seen.

>>145260308
How the fuck did anyone read the area88 manga? The action scenes are just a mess of lines that take dedication to make sense of

Kuso thread

>all this (Dead)

>all these replies

good job /a/, you became /v/

File: ndhf.jpg (146KB, 829x599px) Image search: [Google]

146KB, 829x599px

>>145267932

When it comes to Sailor Moon, Saber Marionette or basically any Takahashi/CLAMP work, you bet I prefer the anime adaptation.

>>145261980
I can name assloads of anime that have sweatshop tier animation. Also don't expect to be able to find an anime studio that can actually animate Vagabond or Berserk and have it look as detailed and well done as the manga without throwing a fuckton of money into it. And even if they do I doubt it would still look good as those.

I mean I understand you're too illiterate to read comic books, and need color, sound, and movement but not everyone has that problem. Or do you think music is the worst medium since it's the most abstract and fill in the blank one out there over something like movies.

Also, I laughed at you last sentence. Anime really is just a glorified advertisement for the source material in Japan. Most people read the manga/LN instead and just tune in to the anime to see their favorite characters animated not as a pure substitute. Why are there so few original anime that isn't based off a manga or LN now if that isn't the case?

>>145269430
>Also, I laughed at you last sentence

not an argument

>>145261478

is this Nagi Ichi?

please respond

I barely even watch anime anymore.

>>145269430
>Vagabond or Berserk

And basically nothing else even has art of that quality in a consistent way.

>>145260431
>Deadman Wonderland