Is this the most overrated anime of all time? the only things

>>143703170
Maybe not of all time but it's sitting somewhere near the top of the list.

>>143703231

every single time that its brought up in literally any place that discusses anime (except 4chan) its ALWAYS in somebodys top5

i honestly dont get it

it's a 6/10 rebellion is a 8/10 since the characters aren't stupid for the sake of being stupid (sayaka)

>>143703170
Most of it is very entertaining. It's well made and fits a broad range of tastes.
Of course it's going to get rated highly. Many people like it and that's why you perceive it as overrated.

>>143703700

i didnt say it was 'bad' i said it was overrated

is it a good show? sure. is it top5 anime of all time material like mal/reddit users believe? no fucking way

>>143703808
Post what you think would be the all-time top 5.

>>143703170
> Is this the most overrated anime of all time?
No, that's Evangelion

>>143704331

>LoGH
>monster
>s;g
>SSY
>cowboy bebop

>>143703808
True, but everything high up on that site is stuff with broad appeal and decent execution while not really being all that great.

>>143704626

i dunno, it just feels like people rate it so highly / put it in their top 5 just because ... everyone else is, not because they feel like its an actual 10/10 show

>>143703170
because you are a pleb

>>143704452
>monster
>Steins Gate
>Shin Sekai Yori

please be a troll

>>143704807

my bad i meant haruhi is the best anime of all time am i rite my fellow patrician anyonmous XD

>>143703170

Of all time? Probably Akira, GITS:SAC, or FMA.

Madoka is legitimately bad though. Pure niwaka bait trash.

File: kinosmug.jpg (150KB, 1366x768px) Image search: [Google]

150KB, 1366x768px

>>143704893
>haruhi
please, it's stupid even as a sarcastic remark

>>143703170
It's both critically acclaimed and enjoyed by audiences. While I think it's fan base takes it way more seriously that the creators intended, it will go down as one of the most solid anime of the decade.

>>143705421
it can be all those things and more
Its still overrated

Gurren Lagann, not so good

Sounds like a hot case of opinions.

Hitohira
Saiunkoku Monogatari
Gosick
SZS
Boku no Pico

>>143705620
I think Gurren Lagann is a good example of an anime that gets more praise than it actually deserves. It has many flaws (plot, character development), yet it gets praised solely based on its entertainment value.

>>143703170
What?
2Deep4U??

>>143708174
Madoka really isn't that complicated.

haruhi
code geass

>>143707650
Its baby's first mecha. For some reason newfags have a hard time getting into mecha.

>>143708220
It obviously is for OP.

>>143708374
What? No, nothing he has said suggests he doesn't understand it. He just thinks it gets more praise than it deserves, and he's absolutely correct about that.