Best magical girl of all time

>>142338795
All of the meducas are in top 10 except red.

>>142338795
Doremi, Sakura and Nanoha should be top 3.

Madoka is relatively new. The fact that Sakura still makes it in the top 3 even when it's 20 years old says good things.

Why I got the feeling that this poll was answered by (creepy) adult men rather than the usual target audience of those kind fo shows...

>>142339501
I got news for you about the target audience.

>>142339501
>Respondents between the ages of 10 and 29 made up 63.6 percent of the group, with the remainder in their 30s. 65.2 percent of the survey participants were male.
I'm guessing the 30 year olds are the only reason sakura is that high in the ranking.

>>142338795
>http://en.rocketnews24.com/2016/05/14/the-20-best-anime-magic-girls-as-chosen-by-10000-japanese-fans/
facebook ranking

>>142338795
Why are they squatting like slavs?

>>142339501
>creepy
>usual target
>..

Back to Tumblr you go.

I wish Madoka didn't exist.
I wish Shaft didn't exist.
Everything is ruined now.

>>142339589
They are meant to be the Delinquent type girls of japan vs the cute and pure sakura.

>>142338795
And when the next magical girl anime airs, it'll make it to number one.

>>142339501
Have you tried suicide lately? Try reading the article.

>>142338795
>nanoha #4
>ILLYA #5
illya is the 5th best magical girl of all time?

>>142339397
>doremei
Who?

File: image.jpg (36KB, 704x396px) Image search: [Google]

36KB, 704x396px

>>142339803
Illya is a miracle of the universe.

>>142339858
>doremei

>>142339872
Illya was just a fanservice series. I cant believe she would be top 5.

>>142339858
If you dont know Doremi you don't have the right to an opinion on magical girl anime.

>>142339902
Did you even read the manga? 3rei is really good.

Tutu should have been on the list.

>>142339954
Not him but Doremi wasn't that great there are plenty of better magical girl shows.

>>142340017
Sorry about your case of the shit tastes.

File: amu.jpg (2MB, 1678x2560px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1678x2560px

>>142339991
so should amu.

>>142340017
>Doremi wasn't that great
>he only watched the first season

>>142338795
I can understand Homura but Madoka is not a magical girl more of the time.

>>142340087
>>142340111
Maybe you should watch it again nostalgiafags.

>>142340176
>nostalgia
I watch it last year for first time so there is not nostalgia about what I'm saying.

inb4 he watched the dub

File: 1457471503581.gif (1009KB, 390x219px) Image search: [Google]

1009KB, 390x219px

>>142338795
>Madoka is shit.
>Japanese otaku are fucking cucks who deserve nothing less than public execution
>Sakura is too pure and beautiful to be understood by anyone autistic enough to actually vote in this election
>The whole madoka franchise could never have existed and anime would be the exact same shit it is today, the same cannot be said for CCS

>>142340227
What makes it so great? I like magical girl series and genuinely have never heard of it.

>>142340227
Ah so you just have shit taste. Watch more magical girl anime.

File: 1455237402448.png (245KB, 662x972px) Image search: [Google]

245KB, 662x972px

>>142339902
>fanservice series
Not anymore.

>>142340243
Madoka was an ok series. The whole cast does not deserve to be on the top 20 magical girl of all time list. Only black and yellow i think are that original as characters.

>>142338795
>charapedia
into trash it goes

>>142340305
what is "Charapedia?"

>>142340257
>Nuh, you wrong
K

>>142340246
It's how mature some episodes turn out, there are pretty basic episodes, especially in the first season. Second season for example it's all about parenthood and they explore different issues about it. And as the story progress, various characters become more interesting and less cliche.
It not about fancy magic tricks or fights, magic is more a tool that the girls use to solve common problems, it's more about the characters and how they grow.

>>142340596
>K
Kill yourself

>>142340099
My exact complaint.