What's the verdict on this, /a/?

Masterpiece

Kinda hard to watch, except for Kagami.

>>141879907
my verdict is you tried making this thread yesterday

I want to have sex with Miyuki.

>>141879907
Good but didn't age well. Should have relied less on referential humor. I love the artstyle but I don't think there will be any more anime that look like it.

Best anime of 2007

>>141879907

Only KyoAni show I've yet to watch.


Hope it's a winner.

File: 1449534251266.jpg (119KB, 467x394px) Image search: [Google]

119KB, 467x394px

>>141880032
The referential humor wasn't what made it so good, it was the bantz.

File: 1456763171780.gif (122KB, 286x277px) Image search: [Google]

122KB, 286x277px

>>141879907
That kagami is pure love

Who is responsible for the opening? Did Yamakan at least do something right?

>>141879907
me on the left

>>141880087

other moe SoL did it better though

>>141880090

So dickable. The doujin by Ishikei is fap material of the highest order.

File: kagami a.jpg (25KB, 500x262px) Image search: [Google]

25KB, 500x262px

>>141879907
Timeless classic. Should be considered as a literary canon.

>>141880225
Like what? The only one I can think of that could rival it is Joshiraku, but not quite

>>141880525

azumanga is still king of SoL moe comedy

File: Cute-Girls-Doing-Cute-Things.png (776KB, 735x881px) Image search: [Google]

776KB, 735x881px

>>141880595
No.

>>141880595
Azumanga is great, but the dialogue isn't near Lucky Star's level

File: 01e.jpg (133KB, 800x1200px) Image search: [Google]

133KB, 800x1200px

Here's my verdict.

>>141880807
OH BOY HERE WE GO

>>141879907
american cartoons have more depth.

File: 130454cc159af618b1bf4684a61b1c6d.jpg (361KB, 1440x1540px) Image search: [Google]

361KB, 1440x1540px

>>141879907
from the thumbnail I though she was holding a huge black dick.

File: freud_holding_a_penis.jpg (8KB, 294x400px) Image search: [Google]

8KB, 294x400px

>>141881561
Anon...

/a/ will never have a good verdict on this because it was both hugely loved and hated while it aired.

Think Watamote-type crossboard appeal, Lucky Star absolutely was that. Konata was /co/'s daughter for a while, /v/'s game of pretend etc.

I thought it was a fucking great show though, really still one of the very best moe sol/comedies (up there in rarified air with Azumanga, Hidamari, Yuriyuri etc).

>>141880650

sure, but azumanga was still funnier

Its objectively better than TTGL

>>141881882
You pretty much can order them best to worst going top to bottom. K-on's not bad, but overrated.

>>141880807
Ive never seen this before, what happens?

>>141880248
I agree

Just watched it. It's timeless and should be required viewing.

I think I might like it more than K-ON

Explain what's so good about it

>>141882528
I like it more than k-on desu

I watched lucky star on my withdrawal from xanax and it helped me go through hell basically so I consider it one of my most favorite things

>>141882629
Good group dynamic, the dialogue feels so smooth and natural that can you listen to the manzai routine all day. Shiraishi EDs and Lucky Channel.
The references are a bonus too.

It was complete garbage. Idiots love it though, the same way they love k-on.

>>141882629
All characters are equally likeable (except for Kagami being best girl) and the show's got a good sense of comedic timing, especially in the editing.

>>141883055
But I love Lucky* and think K-On is hot trash.

What's that make me fampai?

File: 1335414063611.jpg (134KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

134KB, 1280x720px

Kagami is the best girl.

>>141881561

She could hold my huge black dick.

Greatest OP of all time.

I loved it, it was one of the first anime I watched along with death note

I think the bantz, referential humor and interesting style was all great

shame about no s2

>>141880650
k-on is shit and you're shit

File: 1449446199457.jpg (3MB, 10000x10000px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 10000x10000px

>All of this shitting on K-on
Why though?

>>141886060
now now, lets not hate on others young lady

>>141881916

Great news, as TTGL is a solid 8.

LS was amazing, but a terrible entry level show (not that this is a bad thing). So, I can understand why some post-2010 Anons may not like it, since it has too many references for old anime (not the biggest issue, since many were well-know classics) and for anime airing at the time (this being the biggest issue).

That being said, LS could easily be made if they referenced anime from the past 5-6 years.

I'm actually surprised KyoAni hasn't made more of it, but I suppose it might have something to do with the preferring to focus on their own stuff these days.

File: 8534.jpg (7KB, 94x88px) Image search: [Google]

7KB, 94x88px

>>141880032

>But didn't age well

It aged better than Azumanga that is for sure

File: Chocolate_cornet.jpg (7KB, 480x267px) Image search: [Google]

7KB, 480x267px

>>141879907
Nearly dropped on episode 1.

Like it or not, it was one of the main staples of anime boom around ten years ago and attracted “Lucky Star kids” the same way “Sailor Moon kids” who flooded the scene once.

>>141879907
How can there be a verdict if it's still ongoing?
Fucking secondaries REEEEEEEEEEEEEE

>>141882455
Alienated in a uni full of normalfags? I forgot.

Lucky Star was a fucking horrible show, in every way including pacing and writing, but it was fun to watch

>>141879907
it was good. single best performance from aya hirano from her short career. also kagami is waifu tier

>>141880000
fuking wasted

The manga actually continues to be exceedingly comfy.

>>141879907
A nearly perfect anime

File: smex.gif (146KB, 250x188px) Image search: [Google]

146KB, 250x188px

Watch a better SoL

>>141879907
It's good. A bit low-key and too commercial, but still good.

>>141887358
I truly love episode one. The perfect retard screen.