So, whats the verdict?

>>140941506
I love KyoAni but they were both shit

Kanpeki

KnK is my favorite kyoani show. Phantom World was shit

KyoAni needed to pay off some bills.

>>140941506
Phantom World inspired this gem, so it wasn't all bad.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6QRMni0L79M

Amaburi is still worst KyoAni show.

>>140941506
Directing:
Setting:
Plot
Character set:
Character development:
Character design:
Animation:
Fight choreography:
OST:
Voice Acting:
Visuals:

Go!

>>140942230
KnK for all of them.

File: 1456341293082.png (510KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

510KB, 1280x720px

phantom world was like a stock photo bin that lets you pick out your own reaction images. KnK at least had a plot and somewhat likable characters.

>>140941506
Curse of Munto

File: 1461415171703.jpg (600KB, 1457x1600px) Image search: [Google]

600KB, 1457x1600px

Mai best girl.

>>140941506
I like KyoAni, but I dropped both after the three-episode-rule.

File: 1399556012239.gif (215KB, 400x524px) Image search: [Google]

215KB, 400x524px

KnK was well designed and very enjoyable throughout its run. It was subject to an unnecessary amount of hate because of some dedicated autistic shitposting brigade.

Phantom World was mostly terrible until the last few episodes, which still weren't amazing. Utterly forgettable.

File: knk.jpg (94KB, 1920x1080px) Image search: [Google]

94KB, 1920x1080px

>>140942230
Directing: KnK, PW was mostly episodic so the directing was hit or miss.
Setting: KnK, urban fantasy a nice
Plot: PW, KnK tried too hard
Character set: KnK, the characters as presented were more interesting, however
Character development: PW, I enjoyed Haru, Koito, Mai and Enigma's development more
Animation: KnK
Fight choreography: PW
OST: Tied
Voice Acting: KnK
Visuals: KnK, again PW was episodic so it's hit or miss.

>>140942441
This.

>>140942636
>Fight choreography: PW
Someone didn't watch the movie.

>>140942762
I'm only judging the TV versions though.

>>140942625
Don't forget that PW's novel is TG-level edgy.

>>140942636
Relistening to KnK's OST, gonna go with KnK instead of a tie.

Phantom world was garbage and I liked aspects of KnK so I'll go with that

>>140941588
dess

File: 1458315915868.gif (312KB, 342x512px) Image search: [Google]

312KB, 342x512px

The verdict is this

>>140941506
Obviously KnK. It wasn'y really great, but at least it wasn't actual trash like Phantom World.

>>140943792
The first novel isn't edgy.