two best girls? how is that even possible

>>136025815
it happens once when a blue moon is in the sky

>>136025815
Both are best, but Tomoyo is bestest

>>136026292
really tough match

File: 1281297565524.jpg (183KB, 728x999px) Image search: [Google]

183KB, 728x999px

I only see one

This is true, deciding which is the best amongst those two is hard. They each have their pros and cons.

>>136025815
But that's not Nagisa, OP.

>>136025815
That's not even the right twin.

>>136027615
Nagisa belongs to Tomoya!

>>136027615
Cockroachfags need not apply.

File: 1315544186501.jpg (51KB, 640x480px) Image search: [Google]

51KB, 640x480px

>>136027615

>>136027390
As far as I can tell, Tomoyo's only flaw is that she inexplicably likes Tomoya.

>>136027651
This. She deserves better than a garbage collector worker

>>136027651
>>136027680
Tomoya is based, fuck off

File: clannad.jpg (30KB, 500x375px) Image search: [Google]

30KB, 500x375px

>>136027637
>>136027645
>>136027648
Calm the hell down, I was joking. Nagisa a shit.

>>136027651
>>136027680
>hating Clannadman
Into the trash you go

this is the right order

>>11047945

>>136026292
>>136026962
Nice taste anons.

>>136025815
Wrong OP. Best girl is on the left while second best girl is on the right.

>>136027680
a garbage collector is better than some NEET who posts on /a/

>>136027615
Go to sleep Tomoya

File: 1451047515185.jpg (192KB, 1920x1080px) Image search: [Google]

192KB, 1920x1080px

>>136026962
me too

>>136025815

Would have liked to see a Kotomi alternate reality, but I can't deny the greatness of both Kyou and Tomoyo.

Is Tomoyo After any good? I doubt it would top After Story but I want to know if it's at least good

trash > Nagisa

>>136028347
Best arc

>>136028380

See, now you and I are gonna have to fucking fight. Where you live?

>>136028442
Calm down Tomoya!

>>136028347
It's absolutely amazing. I have never watched something that meaningful before. Even until today it's my favourite LN and OVA, if not story as overall. There are no words fit enough for describing It. Simply.. just, amazing. A Masterpiece of OVA. I couldn't stop crying because of how perfect it was. I highly recommend to spend hours on the LN too.

File: best_couple.png (1MB, 1920x1080px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 1920x1080px

>>136028504
Forgot pic.

>>136025815
god tier taste OP

>>136028540
I seriously wonder if Key regrets making Nagisa the main girl. These two had infinite more chemistry.

>>136028729
Not entirely true, both of them helped fix each other's problems, and Nagisa is probably the only one who wanted Tomoya to better the situation with his dad. She is also a better foil for him than Tomoyo.

Tomoyo is the better girl, but Nagisa is the better girl for him.

>>136028347
If you mean the visual novel then is a fucking piece of shit, watch the anime ova tomoyo-hen and live with that, never touch tomoyo after.

>>136028729
Can't agree more.

>>136028757
I was going to post this.
A best.

>>136025815
They are the best girl but Kyou is the one we need to get Tomoya's love.

Why did Tomoyo After have to be so shit?

>>136028580
th-thanks y-you too

File: 1445460588329.jpg (41KB, 704x396px) Image search: [Google]

41KB, 704x396px

;_;

File: trembling - 0.png (385KB, 1097x404px) Image search: [Google]

385KB, 1097x404px

>>136030918
The whole sequence is considerably better in the VN though. Her constant failed attempts at keeping up her facade after that string of mistakes that she made are part of her appeal.

>>136027918
I was literally reading that thread earlier today.

File: 1449837309142.gif (1MB, 300x200px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 300x200px

>mfw twin route in the Visual Novel

>>136028823
Shut Up nagisafag

>>136025815
That's not Kotomi and Ryou

>>136032459
Ryou is best girl. Sucks about her route in the VN though.

>>136032352
He's right in that Nagisa had better chemistry with Tomoya and that she was more helpful in getting Tomoya to right his wrongs, but it's not really saying much considering the "chemistry" in both pairings relies entirely on Tomoya being the "lesser" person, which is unhealthy.

>>136025815
This is a good thread. Great taste, OP.

>>136025815
That's some good taste you've got there, friend. Starfish in 2nd place, by the way.

Nagisa dies

>>136032553
Ah no because his sister is shit and Kyou in the ova is a totally hypocrital bitch

File: he's right though.png (569KB, 1187x292px) Image search: [Google]

569KB, 1187x292px

>>136032874
It's a pretty typical conundrum for people who can't bring themselves to be selfish outside of the limitations that they impose on themselves.

>>136032561
Blah Blah Blah nagisa is a USELESS BORING she is THE WORST GIRL

>>136032933
Cmon kyou is the second worst girl

>>136032987
Nah, Kyou's the one with the most selfless intentions by far, even though they are ultimately flawed. There's a fair bit of value in that. Even Nagisa's selfish as fuck.

>>136032933
Sorry I write bad is ryou the second worst girl

File: 1434494001213.jpg (455KB, 1920x1200px) Image search: [Google]

455KB, 1920x1200px

best route is afterstory where nagisa stays dead and clannadman gets with kindergarten teacher who already gets along with his daughter

I wish Kyou had gotten a comfy and harmless After episode of her own. Then again, with Tomoyo After being shit as it was, it's for the best.

>>136032561
It's not like Tomoya really does much to be the "better" person

>>136033215
Only chances he could possibly have after Nagisa's death are her or Fuko because they both like him and Ushio.

But even then remarrying may not be easy on Ushio.

>>136033752
>Fuko
Who?

>>136033752
>may not be easy on Ushio
Good thing Ushio likes Kyou quite a bit and would, after a few years at least, likely think about the option that would make her dad happiest.

There's no way either Tomoya or Kyou would allow themselves to even consider anything of the sort though. They both have too much respect for one another and for Nagisa to do that.

>>136025815
I feel like I was heavily biased against these two because they weren't sperglords who would die from embarrassment the moment someone so much as looked at them.
Tomoyo = Kyou + δ though. Just enough to make her my eternal waifu.

I'm in love with Kyou

File: Youhei_sunohara.jpg (56KB, 500x375px) Image search: [Google]

56KB, 500x375px

while we're on the subject of clannad, did anyone else realize how based sunohara is?

A girl was begging to be his girlfriend, something he always wanted. but he refused because he knew what was going on.

and then, he trusts Tomoya enough to let him have his little sister. what a bro

>>136034261
And yet he gets treated like trash anyways

Sunohara needs more respect.

>>136034261
Man that football club part was such a bro moment. I think I teared up so bad.
For all his faults, he's a great pal.

File: observant.png (2MB, 1280x960px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1280x960px

>>136034261
He may be bookdumb, but he's fantastic at guessing people's thoughts and seeing beyond simple facades.

>>136034261

He is the biggest bro of all time.

>>136034261
based indeed

his VA and Tomoya's is the best duo

>>136032207
Accurate. ;_;

I like Tomoyo, but Kyou has dat voice though.

File: imsofullofshit.jpg (45KB, 387x295px) Image search: [Google]

45KB, 387x295px

>in love with Tomoyo
>don't want to do any other route in the VN

Also I obviously didn't mean LN here >>136028504 but in fact VN, I'm just a retard needing some sleep (the manga is satisfying, though, hate me the much you want)

File: imgresize.jpg (40KB, 590x443px) Image search: [Google]

40KB, 590x443px

Why does Tomoyo after have to be so damn depressing? My copy of Tomoyo after btw
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4YriByfkn8w

File: hqdefault.jpg (15KB, 480x360px) Image search: [Google]

15KB, 480x360px

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sinjEsTa6do

Piraruku Piraruku Gyogyogyogyogyo
I love fish~!

File: a342ed26bff3e91f2a14c7f923066610.jpg (28KB, 500x375px) Image search: [Google]

28KB, 500x375px

thoughts?

>>136036812
About what?

File: 1303175295879.jpg (827KB, 1920x1080px) Image search: [Google]

827KB, 1920x1080px

All this good taste.

Also, fuck you Ryou.

There's one thing that's been bothering me after watching After Story: Does Nagisa still have the mysterious illness after the reset?

File: 1315544205300.jpg (117KB, 525x394px) Image search: [Google]

117KB, 525x394px

>>136036913
>fuck you Ryou.

>>136036920
It doesn't really matter since she's extremely unlikely to go through anything life-threatening during the illness ever again unless she's unlucky. The important thing is that Ushio does not have it after reloading the save file.

>>136025815
Multiple losers.

>>136033794
Underrated post

>>136036977
they don't have another kid, so yeah Nagisa is safe.

File: 1206583391039.jpg (50KB, 265x265px) Image search: [Google]

50KB, 265x265px

>>136033794
>>136037007

It's still weird how Kyou's own connection to the Illusionary World via the meadow is casually glossed over.

>>136037158
So does Nagisa have any connection to that world, or does she somehow not despite Ushio being there

>>136037225
She can't see the lights until the very end of AS when they're revealed to everyone, so she herself probably doesn't have much of a connection except by proxy, unlike Tomoya and Akio (or even Kyou in her own route).

File: 1450898115231.jpg (67KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

67KB, 1280x720px

sup /a/ upgraded your Kyou.

>>136037350
How does Nagisa know of that world enough to be able to write a play about it?

>>136037380
>short hair
nah

File: stop being cute.png (2MB, 1280x960px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1280x960px

>>136037380
The sweetest.

>>136037413
It's an odd case of her being the creator of the world without actually knowing about it.

>>136037498
The part where she says she'll grow her hair out more and more was such a cute moment.

File: this is not the correct timeline.png (3MB, 1280x960px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 1280x960px

>>136037413
>>136037498
Actually no, thinking on it, Nagisa didn't have to know anything about the World to come up with that play. The way I now see the progression is as follows:
* Nagisa's route (the play creates the Illusionary World in Tomoya's mind) (we do not see this first traversal happening)
* After Story (the two meetings with Akio, along with Tomoya's violent reactions to the town changing, establish the meadow as the gateway to the Illusionary World on the basis of the miracle Akio witnessed)
* Nagisa's death (thanks to Tomoya's pessimistic hopelessness)
* Ushio's death (Tomoya wishes he was in a better world -> retreats into the Illusionary World - this is when the events of the dreams happen and how he learns of the lights)
* Tomoya repeatedly relives every single route apart from Nagisa's (thus acquiring the lights)
* Nagisa's route happens again (this is what we see)
* AS happens again (complete with Tomoya having various sudden realizations about the play, the Dango Daikazoku and his own dreams)
* Ushio dies
* Tomoya is transported to the Illusionary World again, but now Ushio knows everything and gives him the necessary information, thus making Tomoya remember everything
* Tomoya is once again transported to the start of Nagisa's route, but he now knows absolutely everything (...and so does Nagisa?)
* very quick timeskip to the birth moment (Tomoya is not hopeless this time -> the lights show up)

I bet a lot of it is still wrong, but it makes sense to me.

>>136037380
>have to NTR her to complete the VN
Fucking bullshit

>>136038628
The line in the screenshot and Nagisa's response are completely unprompted and devoid of context the first time, but they're perfectly sensible once you've finished AS, since the final traversal to the start of Nagisa's route is all about Tomoya knowing everything and now having the knowledge necessary to proceed without panicking, being hopeless or having any other reason to wish he'd never met Nagisa and thus "caused" the birth chapter to happen.

The one thing I'm still puzzled about is Nagisa's wish for Fuko's recovery generating its own light, which makes me wonder if Fuko is the reason why Ushio knows everything after the second traversal through the main timeline and gets the chance to inform Robot!Tomoya about it.

>>136025815
>Tomoyo
>best girl
You can only pick one sorry.

File: [Doki] Clannad After Story - 23 (1280x720 Hi10P BD AAC) [22D22C63].mkv_snapshot_04.09_[2016.01.10_03.55.56].png (2MB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1280x720px

>>136040057
It's okay, we've long since established who the sole winner is.

>>136034261
After I knew him I started to hope more shit to the bros in manga and anime.
Actually I watch/read series where the "bro" gets some love like in Bakatest and disrespect Monogatari for the lack of male friends for Araragi.
Maybe for that reason I like Suruga there.

>ITT : Butthurt Kyoufags & Tomoyofags

>>136040747
>projecting

File: 39107418.png (218KB, 1000x600px) Image search: [Google]

218KB, 1000x600px

>>136036536
Did you import that anon?
I always wanted to buy one for myself especially after Tomoyo After Perfect Edition is available and buyable in J-List.
I'm just not sure if custom going to check it or not especially since I can't exactly remember if the back of the disc case shows a h-scene or not.
I live in the US now but I'm going back to a shitty third-world country after I'm done with my college (which is pretty soon) so there's that adding to my worry.
Granted the game is coming to Steam soon and I'll probably going to buy it but I want a physical copy of my favorite VN because my love for Tomoyo hasn't died since 2011 when I first read the VN.

File: 1429420276442.jpg (34KB, 630x627px) Image search: [Google]

34KB, 630x627px

>>136032933
>get into college
>for the first time ever, a girl is super into me, and comes forward and tells me
>shes a chubby slut
JUST
felt so bad turning her down too, really was a bother

File: c7d9966d452352b611fa3aab6213a48d.jpg (387KB, 1024x687px) Image search: [Google]

387KB, 1024x687px

>>136033215

>>136043566
>recolored Ushio
>not just a different kid
c'mon you can do better than that

>>136043566
I still don't understand why afterstory Tomoya didn't try to get with Kyou when they met again. Ushio liked her and he was moving on in every other aspect of his life. Was he planning to be celibate forever?

>>136044289
>He moved on
In the scene after that where he sings Ushio Dango Daikozaku he tears up, and he thinks about what it'd be like if Nagisa were alive when he's playing cards with Fuko.

He's far from moved on at that point.

>>136036722
Best girl.

File: 1230107923162.gif (2MB, 250x188px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 250x188px

She's best girl.

>>136044289
Both Tomoya and Kyou would probably consider that idea to be filthy.

>Was he planning to be celibate forever?
Yes.

File: caf02-27.jpg (33KB, 360x270px) Image search: [Google]

33KB, 360x270px

I want to commit a sin!

File: [Doki] Clannad After Story - 04 (1280x720 Hi10P BD AAC) [F5F1B7D4].mkv_snapshot_21.16_[2015.12.13_21.38.39].png (1MB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 1280x720px

>>136045893
Oh?

>>136045972
She doesn't seem to mind https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f7GPcqJ4u6E

>>136046257
Well I don't think you're her son-in-law though you gigantic faggot. She just has a thing for NTR.

File: 1434575915567.jpg (301KB, 802x1290px) Image search: [Google]

301KB, 802x1290px

>you will never be clannadman

>>136025815
Tomoyo > everyone else

>>136036812

Thought on what, Anon? Did you forget to post an image?

File: clannad Sanae.jpg (34KB, 640x480px) Image search: [Google]

34KB, 640x480px

>>136045893

Is Sanae the best MILF in anime?

>>136049138
Have you fallen in love with her all over again?

>>136025815
Shit. An OP with excellent taste for once? Madness!

>>136049138
Sanae is shit

>>136032820
[Spoiler]No shit

>>136037498
but she is a moron