Is rebellion shit?

Will it spoil the show?

File: 1440233676786.jpg (100KB, 645x450px) Image search: [Google]

100KB, 645x450px

No, and when the new movie comes out people will be praising Rebellion and wishing it ended there while shitting on the new movie.

>>134143110
No.

>>134143110
Oh!

>>134143110
No
>>134143213
Yes

>>134143110
no

>>134143110
Yes.

>>134143110
what?

File: Kyouko_here we go.jpg (39KB, 429x519px) Image search: [Google]

39KB, 429x519px

>>134143269
The cycle continues

It's ok and holds up to the show.
People say it's shit because of a minor detail in the plot near the ending of the movie.

Puella Magi Madoka Magica Rising: REVENGANCE

>>134145455
>minor detail

Are the other movies worth watching in place of rewatching the series? I saw the show and Rebellion and want to rewatch it but I don't know if I should give the movies a shot or no

>>134143269
It's almost as if people have different opinions on things.

>>134147759
My re-watch order tends to be episodes 1-8, Then movie 2 and 3.

Generally I think movie 2 did episodes 9-12 better than the series but movie 1 skips some stuff in 1-8 that's somewhat important.

That said Movie 1 is still worth a watch at some point.

>>134143110
No

>>134143110
It was unnecessary and added nothing of value to the canon.

>>134143110
I enjoyed it, but it killed the conclusiveness that the original had.

So my final opinions might rely on the quality of any future continuation.

>>134143110
Best part of the series

That fucking soundtrack though.

File: 1414123683138.jpg (42KB, 600x670px) Image search: [Google]

42KB, 600x670px

On the contrary, it's one of the best animated films of the past 15 years.

>>134143110
its shit to retarted monkeys, the kind who throw it around and sniff it for the lols

fucking great for everyone else

Entire movie is based off what Homura said to Kyuubei. It's retarded, could've been avoided.

>>134143110
complete. Just like the show, it's plot, story, animation, and characters minus Mami.

>>134155832
Entire series is based off the girls making contracts with kyuubei. It's retarded, could have been avoided.

>>134143269
I'd be interested in seeing whether or not this will happen, but it'd probably be better to get a film just as good.

>>134143110
Yes.

>>134143110
Only the last bit, which only exists so SHAFT can milk more money out of the franchise.

is it okay that i only watched the three movies?

>>134158155
that was the best part

>>134158180
Yes. Not very much is missing from movie 1, and movie 2 has no cut scenes. If you want to rewatch though, go for the series. You'll notice a couple more things being said and much more QUALITY

>>134158237
i doubt ill ever rewatch it to be Honest