[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / bant / biz / c / can / cgl / ck / cm / co / cock / d / diy / e / fa / fap / fit / fitlit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mlpol / mo / mtv / mu / n / news / o / out / outsoc / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / spa / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vint / vip / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Search | Click for more| Home]

Is this the greatest manga ever written?

This is a blue board which means that it's for everybody (Safe For Work content only). If you see any adult content, please report it.

Thread replies: 123
Thread images: 14

Is this the greatest manga ever written?
>>
for retarded plebeians, sure.
>>
>>124996730

What this faggot said.
>>
>>124996704
Yes

Only faggots will say otherwise
>>
>>124996704
It's not the greatest ever but it's definitely up there.
>>
File: 1405188666264.jpg (88KB, 700x995px)
1405188666264.jpg
88KB, 700x995px
>>124996704
GLSET
>>
>>124996704

>not Koe no Katachi

Faggot
>>
>>124998235
>implying KnK is good
>>
it was so bad the true end got reduced to a fucking LN

Also, best girl won
>>
>>124998235
Koe no Katachi's a train wreck. Good things die quickly. It should have stayed a one-shot.
>>
>>124998275

Miles better than fap note.
>>
>>124996704
No.

It's damn good though and definitely in my top 10. Story-wise probably first or second though.
>>
>>124998326
In my top 10 not among all manga I mean. Greatest is kind of hard to quantify and the only manga that has any material claim to that currently is Wan Piss.
>>
Why did she become Tsuruya?
>>
Was until he confessed like a faggot.

Molester man is better.
>>
>>124999651
>he confessed like a faggot
>implying him facing the consequences of his actions wasn't the best part
>>
>>124996704
Yes, Sugawa end was wonderful.
>>
File: fapping.jpg (138KB, 653x665px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
fapping.jpg
138KB, 653x665px
>>124996704
Not the greatest, but it's really good.
>>
>>124999701
The best part was dumb bitches opening their bags and seeing it filled with man juice and him just sitting somewhere with that smug look of his knowing those bitches won't be able to find out it was him.
>>
I've been waiting for the day someone started a thread without 'that' image.
>>
>>124996730
>>124996791
You're both retarded, and your opinions will never matter, ever.
>>
>>124999751
Don't you have some potato chips to eat?
>>
Somebody has the summary for the sequel novel?
Too lazy to read it (I already forgot all the characters)
>>
>>124996704
yes. it's at least up there. whenever i have to think of "the best" this one comes to mind for some reason.
it's short and good, even with the gimmicky premise.
>>
>>124999651
Agreed.
An ending drivelled with pretentious ideals trying desperately to pose itself as growth. 10/10 for shipping Sugawa though, painting her as a bittersweet tsun; might as well have labelled it a lovecom.
>>
>>124996704
ITT: I started reading manga last week
>>
>>125001002
It actually was growth though. Kurosawa started changing way back when he decided to apologize.
>>
>>125001145
At least its good and not normie pandering trite.
>>
No, it's shit and I can't wait till /v/ stops coming over to /a/ talking about it

Fuck off
>>
I liked Molester Man more.
>>
>>125001191
That is exactly what it is, are you retarded?
>>
No, it was a fairly average coming-of-age story.
>>
>>125001267
*cumming of age story
>>
Why's everyone shitting on it now? Did it get popular outside of /a/ or something?
>>
>>125001191
He confesses to his crimes and submits to the collective will and is punished and ostracized. This is exactly what normies want and would say he should do.
>>
File: 1331394871234.jpg (106KB, 554x439px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1331394871234.jpg
106KB, 554x439px
>>125001295
Who knows.
>>
>>125001182
Uh-huh, now stop looking at the MC through the scope.
>>
>>125001295
Everybody grew up :^)
>>
>>125001295
>it's popular where I come from so people on /a/ can't have different opinions
>b-but muh hipster pattern
Kill yourself.
>>
>>125001251
Nigga the name is usually enough to scare of any recomendies.

>>125001309
Willing atonement ≠ modern social expectation
>>
>>124996704
Yeah sure.

Can someone re-scanlate this shit at some point? It would be a lot better with a higher quality scan, its quality feels like I'm reading it on mangafox .
>>
>normies, normies, normies, normies
When did /r9k/ start infecting /a/ to such an extent?
>>
>>125001426
>Willing atonement ≠ modern social expectation
I'm not sure what you're trying to say here. Just because he is willingly confessing doesn't mean that his confession doesn't align perfectly with society's expectations.
>>
.>>125001541
I just use it to start shit in shit threads.
>>
>>125001466
What part of web manga do you not understand? YOKO's old works were all web manga he put up on his website.
>>
>>125001145
i've already read more manga than you ever will.
>>
>>124999818
Says the idiot who isn't able to properly explain why it's good.
>>
>>125001360
>Uh-huh
why haven't you killed yourself yet?
>>
>>124996704
this manga is by far the most based yet not so good manga by far, everything at the end was so "daijobu" that i felt really comfy.

This manga is not "normies should die" type, is more like "don't be a piece of shit" type and that's the shine of this work, even punpun is bad compared to this one.
>>
>>125001555
Not going to inform someone over the internet about collective morals of society.
>>
>>125001898
>even punpun is bad compared to this one.
punpun is bad period.
>>
>>125001883
I'll get right onto that. Wanna jump off together, salty-senpai?
>>
>>125001555
just because it's "society's expectation" doesn't mean you shouldn't/should do it you little wannabe rebel.
>>
>>124996730
Right up your alley
>>
>>125002038
>>125001360
what scope
>>
File: qk258.jpg (244KB, 700x998px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
qk258.jpg
244KB, 700x998px
posting best page
>>
>>124996730
One of the few where MC actually ends up with best girl

Admit it, I'm right
>>
>>124998235
>KnK second half
>Not a piece of shit

Man, I was all aboard the hype train, but halfway through it started getting worse and worse
>>
It's good for it's genre, outside of it not so much
>>
>>124999751
That's exactly why I hate this series. From the beginning the theme was this edgy kid fapping on peoples things like he's a /d/ version of Kira, then all of a sudden it goes all Cerebus on you and the fag gets NTR'd and faps on his friend's shit, then starts feeling guilty and confesses. Why the fuck did it have to go that route? It would be absolutely good with just the antics of faplouche, it didn't have to turn into 'hurr durr jizzing on peoples things is wrong'.

And the gloomy fuck was the second worst girl, but she didn't deserve to end up like that. She was justified in wanting those peoples' lives to be shit. Why did the author have to punish her with eternal solitude for that?
>>
>>125008510
>it didn't have to turn into 'hurr durr jizzing on peoples things is wrong'.
kill yourself.

the way it went, we got the best of both worlds. if it didn't go that route, it would just have been a gimmicky and most likely forgettable manga.
>>
>>125008882
Yeah, if you think the best of both worlds means all of a sudden wrecking a perfectly fine train into a concrete wall of faux moral high ground.

From the beginning, this series was a comedy with dark themes. It had absolutely no right to go preachy. Cerebus Syndrome is a symptom of bad writing, and this one's no exception.
>>
I wish I can read this series for the first time again.
>>
>>125001799
Says the idiot who isn't able to properly argue why it's not good.
>>
>>125001295
Starting a thread with "greatest" anything is asking to get trolled. The series is alright.
>>
>>125009437
no. it was never much of a comedy. if anything, it was a parody, and the tone was always fairly serious.
>>
>>125008510
You're the type of people it was subtly making fun of.
>>
File: omk.jpg (130KB, 657x674px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
omk.jpg
130KB, 657x674px
Obligatory.
>>
Is the author still writing shit?
Is there anything ongoing by him that I can read?
>>
>>125005486
The girl that didn't get any development, but the audience liked because of her archetype?

That doesn't make the manga good, idiot.
>>
>>124996704
terrible pseudointellectual normalfag self insert NTR bullshit manga with terrible characters
>>
File: 1424538736160.jpg (489KB, 1024x724px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1424538736160.jpg
489KB, 1024x724px
>>124996704
Here /a/non. For you.
>>
>>125011665
He starts in Jump's next issue a new series about dancing
>>
>>124996704
Didn't you make this exact thread for Punpun two days ago?

Fucking stop.
>>
>>125014422
Oh no, my girlfriend didn't grow as a person because she was great to begin with, how horrible!
>>
>>124996704
I was just about to make a thread about this. Also the same image

Jesus, anon
>>
>>125010623
Reminder that this wasn't NTR and that they did nothing wrong.
>>
File: image.jpg (110KB, 700x1031px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
image.jpg
110KB, 700x1031px
Was I suppose to self insert in this creepy motherfucker? That's absurd.
>>
Kansai is best girl
>>
>>125015247
6/10 b8, I started to get mad, but you put in too many flags.
>>
>>125015247
>mangafox
>>
>>124999651

Molester man is shit. There's nothing special about it. It's just blogshit with probably a lot of make up shit.
>>
>
>>
>>125015327
>blogshit
A manga can't be blogshit.
>>
It's great. The author planned everything right.
>>
>>125015247
>not being a creepy motherfucker
>2020-5
>>
>>125015402

It's based off from a guy on 2ch blogging his story.
>>
>>125015411
we are all healthy and normal here
>>
>>125015446
Yeah, but that's a different thing. The issue with blogshit isn't that the content is somehow a bad story, it's that this isn't the space for blogging. Autobiographies aren't blogshit, and neither are doujins based on someone's life.
>>
>>125015199
Isn't that common knowledge?
>>
>>125015457
Talk for yourself.
>>
>>125015565
People get mad over that page all the time.
>>
I like how the most frequent complaint I see about it on /a/ is how it was only good when Kurasawa was a kind of fucked up outcast, and how once he actively took steps towards improving himself it got bad. It's pretty telling.
>>
>>125015108
Again, doesn't make the manga good, I'm sorry you're stupid enough to believe it does.
>>
Reminder that the mangaka is getting published in WSJ.
>>
>>125015655
What I like is how /a/ laughs at Light for being an edgy chuuni and then gets mad because Kurosawa wasn't exactly like Light.
>>
i can't believe people think this is a great manga
>>
>>125001280
My sides, anon, you killed them.
>>
File: ntr.gif (574KB, 250x164px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
ntr.gif
574KB, 250x164px
>>125015199

Then why was I disgusted?
>>
>>125015747
I can't believe people think this isn't a great manga.
>>
>>125015613
It made me feel really sad for MC...
>>
>>125015860
>...
REDDIT PLS GO
>>
>>125004662
i fucking lovedhikki-chan, i wished her to win...
>>
>>125015793
Because you self-inserted into the MC and the painful highschool memories returned.
>>
>>125015942
fuck i spoilered it! maybe the tagging has changed and 4chan-x is not updated..
sorry.
>>
>>125015942
>>125016000
I really hope this is deliberate shitposting.
>>
File: 1415186636061.png (978KB, 1000x1200px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1415186636061.png
978KB, 1000x1200px
Isn't this a doujin work?
>>
>>125015247
Aya kitahara best girl. So pure. I want to make her squeal.
>>
>>125015655
This. You're all hilarious to listen to.
>>
File: 00000146.jpg (73KB, 283x359px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
00000146.jpg
73KB, 283x359px
Let's be honest here, the main character was kind of a wanker.
>>
>>125016062
every author has a shameful doujin in their closet
>>
It was decent for what it was. I remember raging really hard when I got to >>125010623 that page.
I got over that, but I'm still mad that Kurosawa didn't at least tell her how he felt. The closure didn't feel as real.
Also, I laughed at how the author wrote an epilogue that pretty much said, "Afro-kun and childhood love are going to break up eventually, stop getting mad at me".
>>
I don't see how this can even be considered as the greatest manga of all time. Welcome to the NHK did everything better except NTR.
>>
>>125016231
What? Welcome to the NHK was totally different.
>>
>>125016231
N.H.K. manga seemed more like a supplementary work to the anime and novel. It was pretty disjointed at times imo.
>>
>>125016231
No it didn't. It didn't even have a proper ending.

In fact the story ends right before things would actually get interesting.
>>
>>125015997

I never had a crush though.
>>
>>125015288
Hes right though
>>
File: img000037.jpg (217KB, 700x995px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
img000037.jpg
217KB, 700x995px
>>125015286
This, but I still liked OMK more.
>>
>>125016062
>>125015036
>>124999733
>>124997851
da best
>>
>>125016213
That's such bullshit. If the author actually did that, he's a real joke. The pairing makes sense and I was fine with it. Was there anyone who actually liked that girl anyway? She was boring.

Bully was 10/10
>>
>>124997851
I normally don't like Tsunderes but I really can't help but love Sugawa, even though I thought she was a cunt at first.
>>
>>125002050
Please pay attention to the context of a conversation before you respond. I'm not saying whether it's the "right" thing to do or not, I'm saying it's what normies would say is right, in response to a poster who said the manga wasn't pandering to normies.
Thread posts: 123
Thread images: 14


[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / bant / biz / c / can / cgl / ck / cm / co / cock / d / diy / e / fa / fap / fit / fitlit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mlpol / mo / mtv / mu / n / news / o / out / outsoc / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / spa / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vint / vip / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Search | Top | Home]
Please support this website by donating Bitcoins to 16mKtbZiwW52BLkibtCr8jUg2KVUMTxVQ5
If a post contains copyrighted or illegal content, please click on that post's [Report] button and fill out a post removal request
All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from that site. This means that 4Archive shows an archive of their content. If you need information for a Poster - contact them.