Tsukimonogatari TV vs BD

Oh boy, my favorite thread is here.

I fucking love nonsensical changes, oh boy.

>>122160559
Cinematography in the BD looks a lot better composed

>>122160591
No he's just a manlet.

>>122160567

I applaud SHAFT's attention to detail.

something something increased BD sales...

>>122160642
Did they just give a vampire a mirror reflection just because they can?

There's a whole story ark about Araragi shitting his pants over not showing up in the mirror. What the hell.

>>122160559
Manlets, when will they learn?

>>122160694
ooh boy, I love unnecessary shading. Thanks for slowly killing the signature style, Shaft.

>>122160737
This is the story arc about Araragi shitting himself over not showing up in a mirror. Shinobu explains why she has a reflection before this.

>>122160737
Shinobu mentions in this very arc she can make herself have a reflection.

Why is SHAFT the greatest studio?
Their attention to detail is amazing.
Other studios wouldn't improve any of these scenes.

>>122160831
I just noticed Araragi always wears hoodies.

>>122161043
I would guess they would cover the bite marks better than normal clothes?

>>122160907
This looks like half of a perspective fix gone wrong.

File: 1411670686626.jpg (330KB, 1256x1860px) Image search: [Google]

330KB, 1256x1860px

I'm still mad they censored my manly araragi body in the bath scene of Nise.
At least he looks sexier here >>122160642

>>122160907
This looks wrong.

File: 1333330832795.jpg (366KB, 680x1091px) Image search: [Google]

366KB, 680x1091px

>>122161114
I'm still mad that they removed that scene

"Let us just slide the character position a bit on BD"
-SHAFT

>>122160866
Think I prefer QUALITY feet over BD hand feet

>>122160776
Since when was not shading their characters Shaft's 'signature style'?

All these Yozuru BD fixes just make her less angry-looking.

>>122161000
Right looks odd

>Shaft wasting money because they can

>>122161308
>>122160907
Please tell me you accidentally switched sides in these two pictures, OP

>>122161459
Sasuga Shaft.

>>122161459
>For the BD version lets show less!

File: 1410916759874.jpg (613KB, 894x2400px) Image search: [Google]

613KB, 894x2400px

SHAAAAAAAFT!

>>122161459
Why would you remove the Araragi snowman?

>>122161544
ebin

These started out okay. But now I want to kill myself. gg shaft

>>122161234
Which scene?

>>122161619
That pic dumbass.

File: 1416893369455.jpg (137KB, 1876x522px) Image search: [Google]

137KB, 1876x522px

These are my favorite threads. I fucking love Shaft, they're so ridiculous.

>>122160559
I don't think that's the same frame.

>>122161664
Oh shit one of the stone men is missing, I've read enough hentai to know where this is going

>>122161672
what the fuck

>>122161459
I didn't notice those thighs on Shinobu earlier. God damn.

>>122161611
>all of the trees on Ougi's side of the bridge are dead
>dat symbolism

D E E P
E
E
P

File: Tsukimonogatari-BD-2-026.jpg (1MB, 2560x720px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 2560x720px

>>122161680
I know, but is the same scene, they just moved Araragi a little bit down

>>122161544
BD Mami's house is 10/10

Would live with

>>122161668
I-I know anon, I just don't remember which scene he did that in, I feel like it's from when they were in the past but I can't exactly skim through episodes to find a scene that isn't there.

>>122161744
The one on Arararagi's are starting to die as well.

>>122161784
He's starting to go full vamp isn't he?

File: Tsukimonogatari-BD-2-028.jpg (1MB, 2560x4320px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 2560x4320px

>>122161783
In that scene the BD moves, while the TV is a static

>>122161459
Horrible change.

Did they fix rectangle Tsukihi and Koyomi in the bedroom?

>>122161853
I've always wondered, why do scenes get darker when there's intense animation?

>>122161728

Nisekoi had some real WTFs. Like actually adding censoring instead of removing it.

>>122161853
I liked Yotsugi's eyes better in the TV version.

>>122161921
Pokemon.

>>122161921
Because of Pokemon.

>>122161961
>>122161969
Oh shit really? I thought it was to cover QUALITY. Didn't know it was related to the seizure thing.

>>122161961
>>122161969
Damn porygon.

>>122161921
seizures and pokémon

File: bakemonogatari shinobu hachikuji yotsugi.jpg (3MB, 2812x2000px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 2812x2000px

Yotsugi is so pretty!!

>>122161993
Huge improvement.

Will Commie finally release this now that it's on BD?

I haven't watched it because I refuse to watch Daisuki

>>122161114

Yare yare daze~

>>122161993
>throw some bloom on it and call it good

>>122161993
I somehow prefer the colour of the TV version.

Holy shit, Shinbo's style has become repugnant to the eyes.

>>122161993
dat blush

>>122161997
>believing everything people tell you

You're not gonna make it

>>122162060
same, it's more subtle and dollish

>>122162053
>Directed by JJ Abrams

>>122162086
It seems like a reasonable explanation.

>>122161502
He got a bulge.

Monkey's been there

Does anyone know what changes they made to the Sayonara Zetsubou Sensei BD?

>>122162032
>that anatomy
>tumblr noses
>more donut bullshit
Thank fuck we got Akio Watanabe to set the visual style of Monogatari.

>>122162142
>remove rock
>cover up araragi instead
ok

>>122162180
wow

>>122162180
Good.

>>122162220
woah

they made him awfully bishounen here

>>122162180
What does he see?

Yet another commentary that no one will ever sub ever.

;_;

>>122161930
That little bit of butt in BD version.

Fuckin worth it.

>>122161043
I always wear hoodies, it's a hard habbit to break

>>122162305
What the fuck is up with her face?

>>122162180
Holy hell, an actual improvement.

>>122162032
Snail looks nothing like that.

>>122162305
They fucked up BD

>>122162305
....what's wrong with your face?

>>122161796
bottom right was a good change

File: Kam1422671270[1].jpg (243KB, 640x1866px) Image search: [Google]

243KB, 640x1866px

Panty shot fucking where?

>>122161961
hasn't it gotten worse lately? I never used to notice dim lighting and now it's all over the place

>>122162082
dolls can't blush shaft what are you trying to pull

>>122161502
He's packing.

>>122161993
>let's add some details
>let's remove details with some bloom

>>122162218
truly an artistic sense beyond what us plebians can invision
also shimbo confirmed faggot

>>122161196
>Ghibli reference

SHAFT confirmed for bros.

Why is it that the TV version never seem THIS QUALITY till the comparisons are out?

>>122162619
Your mom is a Ghibli reference.

>>122162674
I kinda like this.

>>122162674
That lighting was actually an upgrade. It really sets the whole "Actors following a script" thing Tadatsuru was talking about.

>>122162674
These are cool changes.

>>122162660
Because it's in motion and you have no point for comparison.

>>122162769
>Monogatari
>Motion
You're funny anon.

>>122162619
They also did an Akira reference with Araragi's mike in one of the early Nise episodes.

These CAPTCHA foods are just getting weirder and weirder.

>>122162282
Who's doing the commentaries? Ononoki and Shinobu?

>>122163026
Fuck that. Give us Yozuru and Tadatsuru.

>>122163099
Why?

File: Tsukimonogatari-BD-2-041.jpg (898KB, 2560x720px) Image search: [Google]

898KB, 2560x720px

>>122163026
Yotsugi and Tsukihi

>>122160907
Why did they give Araragi a jew nose?

Why is Shaft so uneven about the BD fixes? Is it just that we're all tasteless plebs that can't understand their god-tier taste, or are they just trying out artsy shit for the fuck of it, regardless of if it looks better or not?

File: 7057540.png (47KB, 180x180px)

47KB, 180x180px

Nothing can beat Mekaku's

>>122163350
I wonder how much money they spend with these changes.

>>122161502
I approve of this.

>>122163350
Nice change on those eaves.

>>122163429
One-Three freelancer AD and one editor, maybe like 200-300K Yen per volume.

>>122163174
This change is more consistent with the later scenes.

>>122163512
Wow. They made Yotsugi more white than my gooch.

Did they touch up the bath scenes, or did they already spend so much on them in the first place that they were at terminal shaftage

If I had to guess I would say that they just let the creative staff review every scene and do whatever seems cool; different people touch different scenes. I doubt there's much in the way of overall direction. That's just how it seems.

File: Tsukimonogatari-BD-2-050-2-BD.webm (2MB, 1280x720px)

2MB, 1280x720px

>>122162834

>>122163772
Waaaayyy better, jesus

>>122163772
These BD movements make a lot more sense

>>122162834
Sometimes Ryo Imamura would animate a scene.

>>122163772
Aw yes. They actually animated something this time.

>>122163772
Now we're talking.

>>122163772
If you cover up the lower third of the screen, it looks like you're fucking them.

>>122163772
20 seconds out of 2 hours.

>>122163933
Thanks, this will serve a good fap.

File: 1419908140195.jpg (42KB, 493x575px) Image search: [Google]

42KB, 493x575px

>>122163917

>>122163917
Or they're fucking you/him.

>Implying that isn't intentional

>>122163960
You can't fap in 20 seconds. No one is that fast.

>>122164201
I misquoted but I was too lazy to fix.

File: Nise_Compare.png (618KB, 1920x577px)

618KB, 1920x577px

>>122161728
>>122161445
The answer is simple, Shaft makes both the blu-ray and TV version at the same time and then splices scenes between the two.

>>122164217
Suuure. You don't have to front here /a/non. Also I'm sure Comical Psychosomatic Medicine will dedicate an episode to your issue soon.

>>122163917
I feel bad about not saving slowpoke images for when I need them.

>>122164315
Oh cool, I'm not the only on watching that.

>>122160866
Fuck, why is Yozuru so delicious?

>>122164344
Yeah it's only 5 minutes a week, why not.. Nurse is sex.

>>122164532
Pretty sure it's the visible navel and the smug.
I want to trip her and make her fall on the ground.

>>122164540
Yeah but I don't think I ever saw a thread about it. Tsukkomi Kaiki is great too.

>>122164532
Kyoto dialect

>>122161089
>The crane was ruining the feng shui of the room by tilting right
SASUGA SHAFT

>>122161459
Those snowmen shadows are just begging for a rape doujin.

>>122163099
I forgot how SHAFT sometimes hates snow.

>>122165366
>>122161047

>>122160694
>vampire
>reflection

>>122165441
Really?

>>122165441
They explained this shit in the arc you dipshit.

>>122165420
I saw that, hence the "sometimes". The insult was more severe in 2nd season.

Shouldn't they be announcing Final Season by now?

>>122165776
Maybe they want Kizu out first? Which means nothing else is going to happen now?

>>122165366
Marijuana is more their speed.

When will my meme subs be ready?

File: 1401220290892.jpg (32KB, 298x403px) Image search: [Google]

32KB, 298x403px

>>122166054
Don't worry, they'll be out before Kizu, Anon.

>>122161459
B L O C K I N G
L
O
C
K
I
N
G

Nice, almost all good changes across the board

File: internet fight.gif (295KB, 200x150px) Image search: [Google]

295KB, 200x150px

>>122166685
>>122166687

>>122160776
>SHAFT was the one to do flat

I am a SHAFTfag but I and Tatsunoko and every other studios are here to laugh at you.

>>122161421
This is the only true statement in the thread.

>>122163045
BD gets magically unbroken doors in middle?

File: nigger what.png (194KB, 663x537px)

194KB, 663x537px

>>122161502
>fix his face
>make his hands look like a mutants

>>122167700
The animators got caught up in making the crotch bulge just right.

>>122163239
huh. I thought they would all be sleeping together.

Man, I haven't even watched second season yet. Is it worth going with Coalgirls for the BD, but different translation, or should I stick with Commie tv that I already have? Just listing those "choices" made me feel ill.

>>122168396
You can watch what Commie released so far and if you don't mind horrible encoding with bloat then watch with coalgirls, they use HS

>>122168396
Commie's translation is the best one out there. I'd stick with what BDs they have released and patch in anything else with whatever version you feel like.

>>122161043
i never wear jumpers and only ever wear hoodies

So anybody got volume 1 comparisons? Seems like i missed it.

>>122168496
it seems like Monogatari is the only show they bother translating seriously

>>122169214
same

>>122160831
I like the look of BD's, it's MENACING as fuck.

>>122169214
>>120911275

>>122169214
It took me literally 5 seconds of searching the archive. Apply yourself.

>>122169448
Alright, thanks. Literally no changes in vol 1.

>>122161459
Bravo Lucas

>>122165776
SHAFT doesn't even have a booth for AnimeJapan this year. It's odd.

>>122168496
>>122169249
Commie's typesetting in Monogatari is actually really good too.

File: image.jpg (423KB, 1920x2282px) Image search: [Google]

423KB, 1920x2282px

lets see BD tsukihi already

>>122160776
Flat coloring was really only a part of the aesthetic in Bake. Ever since Itamura took over there has generally been shading.

File: 1422611901777.png (1MB, 2408x5000px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 2408x5000px

>>122172945

Is anyone out there still waiting on Commie?

Seeing all these changes, what's the biggest BD change SHAFT has ever done?

>>122174241
No, I caved and watched the HS of Tsuki. I just edited the subs a bit so I didn't have to deal with "big dem-other" shit. My autism was safe.

>>122174321
I think I'm going to cave soon too. Then again, it's been so long I barely feel like watching it anymore.

I like going to these threads without knowing which is the BD and which is the TV. It's like a game.

>>122174241
I'm waiting on them for Tamako Love Story.

>>122174124
Jesus Christ.

>>122174321
You don't need to be autistic to be physically sickened by "big dem-other." Good on you anon.

>>122174241
Nah, I know Japanese. Watched raw.

Although for archiving purposes I'll get either Commie or Coalgirls. They encodes are better than raws.

>>122174241
Yes. It's suffering, especially considering how fast they released Hana last year.

>no kizu

>>122174755
>mfw Kizu late 2015 or early 2016, just when I'm in Japan so I can go see it three times

>>122174605
>"big dem-other"
Yes. Either try to do the wordplay in some way that at least makes sense in English, or don't bother at all. "Devil boy" is fine with me.

File: image.jpg (51KB, 400x281px) Image search: [Google]

51KB, 400x281px

>>122174124
>hd tsukihi

Mine Eyes have seen the glory

>>122161308
>Kagenui isn't smug enough, we need to fix this.

>>122161196
I'm glad she's happy now

>>122162619
>Ghibli reference
>Not 10th century folklore reference

>>122175265
isn't it also Amaterasu symbolism?

>>122175380
There probably is a link between Kaguya-hime and Amaterasu (everything is linked to Amaterasu at some point, I figure), but she's not mentioned in the folktale: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Tale_of_the_Bamboo_Cutter

>>122175460
I also like that Kaguya could be called Tsuki-hime (not a nod to Type Moon)...

>>122162619
The Bamboo cutter story is literally fucking 1000 years old you shitface.

>>122175538
It's clever because there's a moon reference in Tsukihi's name AND she's a supernatural 'fake' child, like how kaguyahime is to the old couple.

>>122163239
I'm getting tired of your shit SHAFT. I'm gonna write an angry letter.

>>122175590
Why are you angry about more detailed covers and softer shading?

>>122175571
For a 1000 years old thing it's rather short and relatively easy to actually read, even nowadays.

>今は昔、竹取の翁といふものありけり。野山にまじりて、竹を取りつゝ、萬づの事に使ひけり。名をば讃岐造麿となむいひける。その竹の中に、本光る竹一筋ありけり。怪しがりて寄りて見るに、筒の中光りたり。それを見れば、三寸ばかりなる人、いと美しうて居たり。翁いふやう、「われ朝夕毎に見る竹の中に、おはするにて知りぬ。子になり給ふべき人なめり」とて、手に打入れて家に持ちて來ぬ。妻の嫗に預けて養はす。美しきこと限りなし。いと幼ければ籠に入れて養ふ。

>>122175643
Because my autism works in strange ways.

>>122163239
Just noticed the books are all organized. Did Tadatsuru clean up after kidnapping them?

>>122175583
Clever upon clever, indeed. Tsukihi[me].

>>122175677

Guess so.

BD version looks much better.

>>122161196
Anon, after all this discussion, Tsukihime of the bamboo must be seen as high art. Can we please have a full-res (1080?) capture of the BD version?