Is this a good comparison /a/?

The rebuilds aren't really that bad, so I'd say no.

>>118675236
I'm not even a star wars fan, but I didn't like the prequels.

File: pottery-slides-woodfired1.jpg (170KB, 1293x1276px) Image search: [Google]

170KB, 1293x1276px

>mfw Mari gets shoehorned in NGE

>>118675236
Yes. Anno really lost his touch and hasn't had it since the 90's.

>>118675236
Did Disney buy Evangelion too?

Mari is jar jar binks essentially

>>118675424

The Star Wars acquisition was enough schadenfreude for me but that would work too.

What so bad about 3.0 and episode 1? They was enjoyable to me

No, because the prequels were shit as a result of no one wanting to stop Lucas and tell him his ideas were shit. Anno's not taking enough control of Rebuild.

You can't even compare the two, as much as I dislike Rebuild, they're still leagues better than Star Wars.

>>118675514
oh boy
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FxKtZmQgxrI

>>118675236
Add Peter Jackson to that list too

>>118675592
>Part 1 of 7
>10 mins
I aint watching that shit

>>118675514
i respect your opinion

>>118675637
>2014
>not having already seen it
You're really missing out tho

No, because Lucas is a bad director. Anno's a fantastic director, but any time he makes a mistake people call him a hack.

File: 1415586003153.png (109KB, 432x576px) Image search: [Google]

109KB, 432x576px

>NGE blu-rays coming out next year

Oh no he won't.

Oh god please don't tell me what I think Anno will do.

File: Eva_Mari_Makinami.png (281KB, 468x586px) Image search: [Google]

281KB, 468x586px

Mari is the key to all this, if we get Mari working. 'Cause she's a funnier character than we've ever had in Eva.

>>118675697
Of course he won't, you fucking idiot. He's not a kike. Rebuild is a separate entity specifically because he doesn't want to tamper with the original.

>>118675514
3.0 was the most boring and pointless shit Anno ever shat out

>>118675699
is mari like the middle ground for asuka and rei?
red + white = pink
asuka personality + rei personality = mari personality

>>118675944
>asuka personality + rei personality = mari personality
Not even a little.

>>118675944
No, you fucking moron. Mari's as old as Gendo.

>>118675514
>having such shit taste

My condolences

>>118675966
asuka = crazy
rei = psychopath
mari = crazy psychopath
are you a dunce

File: 1399587800655.png (258KB, 495x314px) Image search: [Google]

258KB, 495x314px

>>118675944
Jesus no.

>>118675514
I hope you know your parents are very disappointed in you.

>>118675514
3.0 descent parts
>fight scenes
episode I descent parts
>Pod race
>darth Maul fight (except the energy walls part)

File: zj9csg.jpg (209KB, 1212x1600px) Image search: [Google]

209KB, 1212x1600px

It's like poetry, it rhymes.

>>118675236
It's an interesting comparison. Broadly, the SW prequels were bad because Lucas is kind of an out of touch idiot who's surrounded himself with people who only tell him his ideas are brilliant for decades. He's lost all discernment. So, like, as a result of his success, he snuffed out his own talents.

With Eva, Anno was never at any point considered anything like a visonary genius. He was making otaku anime in a failing sudido for a very limited audience of strange, picky, deranged and hard to predict wierdos. It just, as a fluke, caught on. Unlike Lucas, Anno knew his success was just accidental the whole time. He kept trying to develop as an artists by trying different things and reaching for different audiences, but never really made it. So he returns to Eva in basically the exact opposite sitaution as Lucas. He knows he isn't anything special, and the things that made it work the first time around were just random chance, basically. So any attempt to change it is so precarious, because how can you tell if this will ruin it? It's all just a wild guess with no real way to tell. All the same obvious sort of things that Lucas just blitzes through with his impenetrable shield of sycophants telling him he's great, Anno has to deal with as a mediocre person.

I don't think Rebuild works, ultimately. But it's broken in ways that show Anno is very different person now. You can see how he's older, if not exactly more mature, how his vision has changed in all kinds of interesting ways in every scene.

>>118675699
>Messa Evangelion pilot!

File: 1389290295582.jpg (1MB, 2400x2890px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 2400x2890px

>>118676110
>With Eva, Anno was never at any point considered anything like a visonary genius

Dude what?

>>118676078
All the fight scenes in 3.0 were terrible

>>118676110
Confirmed for not having a fucking clue what you're talking about, holy shit. This is seriously the most blatantly uninformed opinion about Anno I've ever heard.

>>118675236
Pretty much.

>>118676178
Are those all of those actual fucking books about NGE?

>>118676214
I enjoy them

>>118675236
I would say it his Indiana Jones 2. Wasn't that bad

File: 1367188369884.jpg (3MB, 1920x3382px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 1920x3382px

>>118676078
>fight scenes
God no, the only good parts of 3.0 was the scenery porn and the OST

The Return of the Jedi wasn't all that good either

>>118675236
Does that make Steven Spielberg Miyazaki, or is he not bitter enough?

>>118676254
>The OST
I fucking hated 3.0, but the soundtrack was absolutely fantastic.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-_x_q6IKDMg

>>118676254
I'm a little confused, if thats supposed to be the earth after third impact, shouldn't it look more lika a paradise? why does it look like post apocaliptic hell?

File: 1410276526002.png (839KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

839KB, 1280x720px

>>118676240
Yes

File: 1357089574754.jpg (12KB, 301x309px) Image search: [Google]

12KB, 301x309px

>>118676395
Consult my picture

>>118676395
The fuck? Have you not seen the original series?

>>118676287
>that awful taste
the only bad part is elite imperial stormtroopers losing to a bunch of ewoks

>>118675236
Yeah,both are talentless hacks

>>118676460
I do, but tha's a question that's always been in my mind

>>118676499
>the only bad part is half of the movie

>>118675592
Is that Alex Hirsch voicing Soos from Gravity Falls, doing a parody of online film reviews?

>>118677454
I have no idea what the first half of your sentence means, but underageb& pls go

>>118677485
there are so many stupid things about this post I hardly even know where to start. But I figure a good enough point would be to point out that your lack of reading comprehension seems to have confused you into thinking I in any way shape or form condoned the prequel trilogy, or devalued the original trilogy.

File: 1414954164617.png (656KB, 600x900px) Image search: [Google]

656KB, 600x900px

>>118675236
hes like a self aware george lucas, hes releasing the original series, death and rebirth and the end of evangelion on blu ray 2015 summer so he respects his original shit compared to george lucas

>>118677665
>your lack of reading comprehension

I'm calling you underage for both watching /co/ shit and never having seen those reviews before, they're like six years old.

>>118677698
>so he respects his original shit
If the whole sequel-loop shit ends up being canon, then no he doesn't respect NGE

I think we're all going to see the last Rebuild just to get it over with. It's like an obligation. Like going to your stupid daughter's college graduation. You know it's gonna suck, but you gotta go just to get it over with. Nah, fuck that metaphor. It's going to be like going to an autopsy. You know it's dead, and nothing's going to change that. But you gotta do an autopsy to find out what killed it... or who killed it.

3.0 is a masterpiece compared to ep1

>>118677765
>If the whole sequel-loop shit ends up being canon
>If
Did you not watch until You come to me?

>>118675236
Episode 1 was great save for the exaggerated scenes with Jar-Jar and the existence of the Gungans. There is no other fault with it besides Jake Llyod's shitty acting.

Does it really matter what Anno does at this point? If you like Evangelion but think the rebuilds are shit nobody is forcing you to watch them. You guys just can't ignore them and enjoy the original series?

File: The Japan Animator Expo - 07 (until You come to me).mp4_snapshot_05.36_[2014.12.21_01.48.02].jpg (43KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

43KB, 1280x720px

>>118678026
I did and I am still hoping he pulls his head out of his ass and doesn't make it canon