/mlp/ Town Hall

You forgot Nyx

Since she's best pony.

>>28437785
Porn should be allowed, so we can turn shit and bait threads into porn dumps.
Gore might attract edge lords though, so I wouldn't mind if it's still banned.

File: 1461553909174.png (718KB, 4037x4476px) Image search: [Google]

718KB, 4037x4476px

>>28437785
>>Should EQG be removed/contained to a general?
Yeah, that will totally work :^)

File: absolutely into the trash.png (537KB, 600x450px) Image search: [Google]

537KB, 600x450px

>>28437794

Allow porn
Nothing else is needed

File: image.png (504KB, 829x720px) Image search: [Google]

504KB, 829x720px

>>28437785

>Should EQG be removed/contained to a general? Why?

File: red.png (12KB, 2000x1200px) Image search: [Google]

12KB, 2000x1200px

>>28437785
Thats all I will say this time.

>>28437814
>>28437838
Many posters have wanted it gone since EQG1. Feel free to provide actual reasoning as to why it shouldn't rather than just passive agressive memeing.

>>28437785
Porn should not be allowed because it will then become like how /b/ is now where over half their threads are just various porn fetishes.

Trying to remove EG or contain it to one general will not work. It is growing in popularity and if it is removed, we will have the same thing happen that happened on /co/ and /b/ 4 years ago

I wouldn't mind CYOAs being given their own board ot moved to trash but it doesn't bother me much. This board is slow enough already

File: 1459019702139.png (438KB, 757x571px) Image search: [Google]

438KB, 757x571px

>>28437814
>>28437838
>gyeheheh r u mad ponyfag
>eqg heer 2 stay lel top kek

>>28437871
Because most of this board likes it now. The only ones who don't are loud faustfags. If it was removed, we would see a repeat of what happened on /co/ and /b/ 4 years ago.

Tl;dr
Try it, see what happens.

File: tumblr_lzjro2Tv011r4gei2o4_400.gif (301KB, 319x240px)

301KB, 319x240px

>>28437881
About half of the threads on this board is EG. There is a better chance of GR15 being removed than EG being banned from here. But by all means, keep posting your trash memes. Your tears never get old.

File: everyone_is_stupid.jpg (22KB, 500x376px) Image search: [Google]

22KB, 500x376px

>>28437931
>About half of the threads on this board is EG.
>the EQG movies have about 1/5 the total hours of content as the show but still take up approx. half the board
And yet you don't understand why people want it gone.

>>28437983
Because the movies have a massive amount of content to explore. Proven by all the green text constantly being pumped out of the EG threads. Stay mad, kid

>>28437785
>>Should EQG be removed/contained to a general? Why?
No.
>>Should generals be moved to their own board or confined to /trash/? Why?
If MLP is essential to the concept of the thread, like AiE, then it can stay here. If it's a topic with ponies attached to it, like foot fetish, then it belongs somewhere else. This can lead to some grey areas, but as a rule of thumb, I think it's fine.
>>Should /mlp/ become a red board? Why?
Why? We have /trash/ now. Porn isn't going to keep newfags out.There's no reason to believe that it will, other than conjecture.
>>Should GR15 be abolished? Why?
Don't really care. I have no desire to post ponies outside of /mlp/
>>implying this has a chance in hell of being changed
>>Should we see our sticky return? Why?
Sure. I don't see what good it will do, but why not?
>>Should the winners of /mlp/'s banner contest be revised to exclude the troll options? Why?
If this rule has been applied to other boards, and you can clearly define which options were trolls, and which ones weren't, then sure.

>>28437871
There's a good number of green that's based entirely on EQG/Humanized MLP, confining it to one general is similar to confining /mlp/ onto one general on /co/. You'd removing content that people have grown to love just because you prefer one thing.

I know you don't care, and >no hooves/S1+S2/>anthro fags hate anything that isn't pony and hate people having fun, but think of others. Get rid of EQG, you lose a portion of the board.

It would suck ass for us.

>>28437871
Feel free to provide actual reasoning as to why it SHOULD rather than just passive aggressive memeing.

EQG sucks
You simply have to pretend they dont exist, just like their movies.
Eventually seeing that nobody gives them the replies they want, they will stay inside their safe spaces and it will be as if they didnt exist at all.

>>28437807
>>28437834
there's /trash/ for that

>>28438005
The show still has more.

Let's do some math.

I'll say your three movies has about 5 hours of hard content total.

The average episode has a runtime of 21 minutes. There are 136 episides that have been aired. 136 x 21 = 2856 minutes ÷ 60 = 47.6 hours of content. I was wrong, actually. FiM has about 9 times the content of EQG, yet you yourself have admitted to it taking up 50% of the board. It's just circlejerking at this point. And if the majority of the board actually wanted EQG to stay, why is it every thread on the topic has several people actively calling it shit and saying it doesn't belong here?

>>28437872
>CYOAs being given their own board
>people actually want this

>>28438100
>why is it every thread on the topic has several people actively calling it shit and saying it doesn't belong here?
For the same reason that dumbasses come to this board to call ponies shit and say that the board shouldn't exist, you newfag

File: 1460950756339.gif (1MB, 216x268px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 216x268px

>>28438100
>why is it every thread on the topic has several people actively calling it shit and saying it doesn't belong here?
Because >nohoovesfags are loud and obnoxious
EG produces a shitton of content on this board like art and greens. We're not leaving.
If the show has 9 times the content, but EG takes up 50% of the board, that should really tell you something about the popularity and quality of each.

>>28438116
False equivalence. Those people are just trolls looking for (You)s, our people legitimately browse the board and are just fucking sick of seeing it everywhere.

File: 1456946962015.jpg (65KB, 960x448px) Image search: [Google]

65KB, 960x448px

>>28437785
>Should GR15 be abolished? Why?
Yes, it absolutely should. It's seriously an outdated rule and just gives Barneyfag a reason to make the mods want to kill themselves.

People seem to think that if GR15 is removed, so will /mlp/, which is stupid. There are so many goddamn active threads on this board. Where will they even go? If we all tried to migrate back into one thread on /co/ and /b/, history would just repeat itself. /mlp/ is going to stay right where it is.

Make the mods actually work for their fucking hot pockets and make it to where pony reaction images are allowed, as well as discussion of the show contained in one thread, but off-topic derailing should be removed with extreme prejudice, as should any off-topic derailing should.

>>28438145
Bullshit, there are people on /qa/ who legitimately hate pony content and want /mlp/ deleted

>>28438150
>and just gives Barneyfag a reason to make the mods want to kill themselves

But this shit is fuckin hilarious though.

File: image.jpg (415KB, 993x1024px) Image search: [Google]

415KB, 993x1024px

>>28437785

Going to namefag if you don't mind (even though it's heavily frowned upon)

>No. EQG movies happen after each season (after 3 onwards) so there isn't that much discussion about them to be confined to a general/one thread. Most human threads like /dzg/ for example just rely on Greentext/pictures.

>Getting rid of the generals/cyoas here would leave the board in a near barren state. The shitposting would probably rise, and discussion is usually in the main episode thread. The board would dramatically decrease in posting speed as well.

We're always welcome in trash since gr15 doesn't exist there. That and it'd probably just be over flooded with porn if we did become a red board.

As for GR15, I wish it'd be a bit more lax. So we could use pony reaction images outside this board and boards like /toy/ could have threads on pony toys/figurines.

I saw a screenshot of the sticky once. And the one scruffy had up for a while. I don't think it's necessary. It was a bit of a eyesore. Seeing how we've got th most chill mods here, I don't think we need a constant reminder of rules.

>last one
Ehh i dunno. It does blow that only gold members could vote tho. Which I feel it was heavily rigged against us.

>>28437807
If gore will attract edge lords, then what do you think porn will attract? I'll give you a hint: the first letter is F, and it rhymes with 'worries.'

>>28437785
>Should EQG be removed/contained to a general? Why?
No. Because the current situation doesn't exactly do anything negative or positive. If it's not broken, don't fix it. Also, it's apart of FIM thanks to all of them involving horse Twilight.
>Should generals be moved to their own board or confined to /trash/? Why?
No. Story greentexts with # on them can easily be confused and deleted, causing needless shit.
>Should /mlp/ become a red board? Why?
No.By the looks of /trash/ we'd just get more generals people will bitch about.
>Should GR15 be abolished? Why?
No. Better to keep it all here, we can't afford to lose traffic.
>Should we see our sticky return? Why?
No. Nobody comes here saying "stop spamming our board" anymore.
>Should the winners of /mlp/'s banner contest be revised to exclude the troll options? Why?
No. Can't tell what's a troll and what's not. And most anons use adblock, so they'll never actually see it.

>>28438176
But could you imagine the backlash of rampant shitposting from barneyfags that are desperately trying to fight against the pony flood but just end up getting deleted?
More keks will be had, my friend.

>>28438183
They were here the whole time
You are one

>>28438123
>EQGfag calling >nohoovers loud and obnoxious
Topkek

FiM still produces more art and green that EQG. Look on Derpibooru. More pony pics than EQG. Look on FIMFic. More pony fics than EQG. You're just a fringe group shitting up this board with the same stale topics over and over and over with no real discussion going on.

>>28438216
EqG isn't separate from pony and you treating it like it's some entirely different subject is fucktarded
It's a part of MLP G4 just like FiM is and belongs on this board

>>28438100
>Time=/=content
If you recycle characters, locations, themes, etc. You'll find that the amount of 'content' starts to dwindle. Also, we don't talk about certain 'content' anymore. Old episodes for that matter. By your logic, if time was equal to content, then every episode should be talked about equally, and every surge of threads talking about new episodes would be circlejerking.

>>28438231
>Belongs on this board so we have a free pass to shitpost and circlejerk
You forgot that part, faggot.

>>28438204
>A large group of ban-evading barneyfags

The mods might genuinely kill themselves.

>>28437785
Make the board red, or at the very least make a general for porn. thats about it

File: Glimmer.jpg (184KB, 1920x1080px) Image search: [Google]

184KB, 1920x1080px

>>28437887
>Most of /mlp/ likes EQG

File: 1473448244660.jpg (10KB, 200x303px) Image search: [Google]

10KB, 200x303px

>>28438216
>FiM still produces more art and green that EQG.
I'm not so sure about that. We have full generals based off of the Dazzlings and Scitwi that are constantly producing greens and art while you guys can barely keep you nightly Twilight thread alive. What does that say when we have the strangest generals like Spider-shim getting more attention and content than the thread for FiMs main character? Many people are admitting that LoE looks far better than Season 6 and there are strong rumors of an EG show. EGs popularity is growing, ponies are dying.

>>28438252
EqGfags literally do the same fucking things that everyone else on this board does, you dumb shit

>>28438207
You're right, Anon
and they want the board red

>>28438258
>The mods might genuinely kill themselves.
Good, we could use a change in management

>>28438285
Then why don't you do it? Why don't you apply to be a janitor?

File: 1470300299868.png (373KB, 647x519px) Image search: [Google]

373KB, 647x519px

>>28438261
You know it's true. My meme face is stronger.

>>28437785
>Should EQG be removed/contained to a general? Why?
no, it's related to the mlp franchise its discussion should be allowed but it shouldn't be allowed to takeover the board (at least while the main series is active)
>Should generals be moved to their own board or confined to /trash/? Why?
not really
>Should /mlp/ become a red board? Why?
I say go with something more akin to /e/ and leave the hardcore stuff in /trash/
>Should GR15 be abolished? Why?
>implying this has a chance in hell of being changed
maybe, GR15 is used more as bait than keeping ponies off other boards
in all honesty there is no reason to post pony outside of /mlp/ just as there is on reason to post anime outside of /a/ or cartoons outside of /co/
rules like GR15 should exist for obvious trolling with images unrelated to the board they are posted on, put simply if an image has anime/cartoon/pony that's not the central focus of that image (i.e. something in the background, desktop/battle station pic with a anime/cartoon/pony theme) then it should be allowed
>Should we see our sticky return? Why?
stickies serve no purpose
>Should the winners of /mlp/'s banner contest be revised to exclude the troll options? Why?
seeing how the banners are suppose to 'give users all across 4chan an idea of what each board is all about by using banner images' I would say any banner that primarily used text should be disqualified or at the very least brought under review

>>28438294
What are the requirements for that anyway? I wouldn't mind doing that.

>>28438294
I don't browse Reddit or Tumblr, I'll never be a mod

>>28438216
>>EQGfag calling >nohoovers loud and obnoxious
>Topkek
You are proving his point. >nohooves fags are the ones that are ruining the board. The same way Barney fag ruins /v/ threads. EQG is part of the story, having a thread on /mlp/ isn't doing anything negative until a >nohooves fag comes and tries to start shit up.

Also, EQG is insanely popular considering a fuck ton of green revolves around it. There's also much more freedom in EQG stories that doesn't revolve around using magic as a cop out. FiM stories are usually limited to Ponyville, or any other set town.city in the show. EQG can take place literally anywhere in the world, especially if you consider humanized a subset of EQG. EQG stories also have better characterization, and plot elements.

>>28438309
They have applications every year. If I remember right, you need to be good with computers, be able to work at a consistent time (regardless of how little time that may be), enforce the rules as objectively possible, and >do it for free

>>28437785
>Should EQG be removed/contained to a general? Why?
I don't really care, honestly. Doubt it would happen.

>Should generals be moved to their own board or confined to /trash/? Why?
A /mlpg/ board sounds like a disaster, and they don't belong on /trash/. Let's keeå them around, I honestly don't see the issue.

>Should /mlp/ become a red board? Why?
Again, don't really care, but I don't see the need now that /trash/ exists.

>Should GR15 be abolished? Why?
Should it? Yeah. Will it? No.

>Should we see our sticky return? Why?
That would be nice.

>Should the winners of /mlp/'s banner contest be revised to exclude the troll options? Why?
Again, don't really care, though I do wish some funnier ones won.

>>28438330
I think I'll apply next year. I wouldn't mind making this a better place.

File: 1473443104441.jpg (10KB, 348x145px) Image search: [Google]

10KB, 348x145px

>>28438330
>enforce the rules as objectively possible

Honestly if people believe that the distribution of content on the board should be different then they should try to make threads that are good and relating to the content that they wish to discuss
However it requires people of like mind and with similar interests to keep those threads alive

File: download (1).jpg (8KB, 214x235px) Image search: [Google]

8KB, 214x235px

>>28438341
>sticky
Can someone explain to a newfag what this is?

>>28438309
You need to spend 8 hours a day browsing 4chan and be good at licking RapeApe's balls, basically.

>>28438345
It has a high turn-over rate. Nobody likes you, and it sucks what little fun there is in browsing.

>>28438359
We had a sticky back in 2013 that basically told people not to shitpost with "I don't understand the appeal" threads

>>28438359
There's a sticky up right the fuck now, fagerino.

>>28438359
You know how we have episode stickies that stay at the top of the board every week?
We used to have a permanent sticky with the rules and some information about /mlp/.
Many other boards have this too.

>>28438367
How is that any different from browsing normally?

>>28438359
Thread that is permanently stuck to the top of the board. The episode thread going on right now is a sticky. Many boards have one, but not always. They're mostly used to make announcements, or expand on things that won't fit in the rules list.

Lurk moar

>>28437872
>Porn should not be allowed because it will then become like how /b/ is now where over half their threads are just various porn fetishes.
You dumbass motherfucking nigger have you looked the fuck around? Half the board IS already various fucking porn fetishes! The only difference is that no-one's allowed to post actual fucking pictures so everyone's sitting there with blueballs bumping the thread to hell and back waiting for a single writefag to continue their shit attempt at a story so they can pretend it's more than just getting their fucking load off. Fuck damn.

>>28438371
>>28438376
Ohhh, ok. So it's like what the other boards have to tell newfags what the board is for, right?

>>28438383
You have responsibilities

>>28438391
I can feel your anger through my monitor.
That's kind of what I was thinking but if porn does become allowed, I fear that the whole board will end up being a massive porn site.

>>28437785
>Should EQG be removed/contained to a general? Why?
No, it shouldn't. Like it or not, EqG is a part of the board. It is a part of the fandom. It is even confirmed canon by McCarthy. EqG is MLP content like everything else on this board. Just because some people get buttblasted every time they see it doesn't mean that 50% of content on the board should be nuked.

>Should generals be moved to their own board or confined to /trash/? Why?
Again, no. In fact this is a really dumb idea. I agree that there are a lot of generals, but removing them from the board isn't an option. I think combining them--some of the less active ones or those who think they could do with a fusion--would work. For example, Plane Ponies and creepy waifus. Every CYOA thread. Those are small threads that could do with some fusion and it doesn't eliminate a huge amount of content from the board like banning EqG would.

>Should /mlp/ become a red board? Why?
No. We have /trash/ to post porn on now. Changing it to a red board would be pointless.

>Should GR15 be abolished? Why?
No. I'm not retarded enough to expect that everyone here will be good and not spam other boards with pony shit just on principle. /mlp/ is full of cancer. Removing GR15 would be detrimental to our health and the heal of other boards. You don't need to go around posting ponies everywhere anyway; you have a whole 1.5 boards for it.

>Should we see our sticky return? Why?
I never liked /mlp/ with a sticky. I don't even see what the point of it would be. I guess I don't care enough to argue too strongly, but I don't like the idea.

>Should the winners of /mlp/'s banner contest be revised to exclude the troll options? Why?
Again, I don't care. Anyone who uses adblock won't see them anyway and it's not like anyone on another board is going to come to /mlp/ just because they saw a super keen banner advertising us. They're useless. Just be happy the mods let us have one in the first place.

>>28438319
>EQG can take place literally anywhere in the world, especially if you consider humanized a subset of EQG. EQG stories also have better characterization, and plot elements.
Not that guy, but none of those things are inherent to EQG. You can have FiM green take place anywhere that hasn't been established in the show. Same thing with characterization, and plot elements. Good or bad isn't inherent to the original elements. I agree though that >no hooves can be massive autists

>>28438275
>Dazzlings and Scitwi that are constantly producing greens and art

>princess twilight (49,617)
>human twilight (3,565)
>midnight sparkle (821)
>sonata dusk (7,097)
>adagio dazzle (5,692)
>aria blaze (4,754)

Yeah EqG produces way more more art than ponies.

>>28438371
Oh so you mean the threads we don't get anymore? Yeah let's get a sticky up to prevent those threads.

>>28438460
We are talking about on this board, shithead.

>>28438460
>using derpibooru numbers to gauge how much content a general produces on /mlp/
Nice try. Go post that in Nightly Twilight Thread and see how long it takes for someone to reply to you with "bump".

>>28438412
I'd prefer that to another "hey anon (insert shitty writebait)" thread.
Besides, you know it will settle in naturally once the novelty wears off.

File: 1462256544925.jpg (84KB, 960x864px) Image search: [Google]

84KB, 960x864px

>>28438319
>EQG stories also have better characterization, and plot elements
Sex with milf Sunset Shimmer, sex with teen Sunset Shimmer, sex with sister Sunset Shimmer.

>>28438489
Go look at /trash/ and tell us the variety of porn threads you see. It's not too much of a change.

>>28438470
And your still wrong. How many green on this broad only have nothing to do with EqG. Lets see shall we.

>49 threads about ponies
>11 threads about EqG.

Yeah so much more.

File: 1219827__safe_solo_clothes_equestria+girls_vector_sunset+shimmer_absurd+res_smirk_shorts_raised+eyebrow.png (732KB, 3380x7570px) Image search: [Google]

732KB, 3380x7570px

>>28438498
Shes sexy and she knows it.

>>28438498
>MLP stories also have better characterization, and plot elements
Anon gets all the pussy, Anon gets all the pussy comedy, Anon gets all the pussy really bad comedy that people think is funny, Anon gets one pussy, Anon rapes one pussy, Anon uses shitty jokes as he fumbles around a fimfiction-tier world trying to get pussy.

File: 1463362394384.jpg (19KB, 316x400px) Image search: [Google]

19KB, 316x400px

>>28438391
THIS

>>28438509
We are talking content produced from the threads. Much (not all) of the EG threads are healthy while much (not all) of the pony threads are half bumps and half "wheres the content?" posts or they are shitty CYOA and generals based off of OCs

>>28438509
So which is it? Are EQG threads overtaking the board, or are they not? If you define threads as content, then there's no situation where banning them is justifiable. If they don't have many threads, then they're not taking up much space, which means there's no reason to ban them, but if they produce more threads, then that means they're producing content, which means you probably don't want to ban them.

>>28437785
>Should EQG be removed/contained to a general? Why?
no. it's a part of mlp and everyone knows this

>Should generals be moved to their own board or confined to /trash/? Why?
no. regardless if you like them or not, they produce content

>Should /mlp/ become a red board? Why?
no, we have /trash/ for that

>Should GR15 be abolished? Why?
no. only shitposters want it removed so they can trigger people all over again

>Should we see our sticky return? Why?
yes. it will stop the "I don't get the appeal" type threads as well as make it confirm that /mlp/ is EqG's home so wer can stop hearing faggots on both sides whine and bitch

>Should the winners of /mlp/'s banner contest be revised to exclude the troll options? Why?
?? I don't follow that shit, so I don't care
---
no one seems to know how to use 4chan properly
>filters
>hide threads
>report shitposters/trolls and ignore them
it's not that difficult, it's like you WANT to be triggered
these tools are there for a damn reason

File: 1463687436352.png (807KB, 982x980px)

807KB, 982x980px

>>28438520
I was going to actually start replying, but then I noticed that even with you sarcasm, what you have described still has more variety and
>have better characterization
and more
>plot elements

File: 1469846403513.jpg (46KB, 568x479px) Image search: [Google]

46KB, 568x479px

>>28438498

File: medium (31).png (77KB, 800x450px) Image search: [Google]

77KB, 800x450px

>>28438520
>Implying that's a bad thing

>>28438504
Yes? /trash/ is not overrun with mlp porn threads. That's my point. There was an increase in the beginning since people could, but now it's a varied mix of other topics. That /trash/ is inherently about porn doesn't factor into this.

File: 1473630027955.gif (1MB, 250x250px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 250x250px

>>28438545
>no, we have /trash/ for that
And we have boards for drawing and writing, lest ban the fuck out draw-threads and write-guild.

File: sunset dissapoint.jpg (8KB, 178x142px)

8KB, 178x142px

>Should EQG be removed/contained to a general? Why?

File: janitorsMlp.png (605KB, 803x777px) Image search: [Google]

605KB, 803x777px

>>28438588
Don't give them ideas.

>>28438498
Both sides of the spectrum have a substantial amount of smut in their greens. Saying that one side is purely smut when the other isn't is just biased. Now, from all the non-smut stories I've read around the board, I have noticed that MLP greens seem higher quality because they tend to be more spread out across the board. You come across them more often. On the flip side, the quality EqG stories tend to be concentrated into their own generals. Because of that, you don't really see them unless you venture into that general. That doesn't mean they don't exist. In fact, I'd go as far as to say that the highest quality of EqG greens far outclass the highest quality MLP greens. Again though, you wouldn't know that unless you took the time to go into those generals. I can understand why you wouldn't, but just keep in mind that unless you're willing to go out there and experience both sides of the spectrum, you can't make blanket statements like the one you did.

File: 1473913483774.png (2MB, 929x1282px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 929x1282px

>>28438608
They haven't felt the warmth of the setting sun, yet.

>>28438533
That not the point. There is more content being created through ponies than through EqG. AJ on Derpi has 94 thousand pictures, and she is the least favorite pony of the mane6. Still has 30 thousand more pictures than all of EqG.

>>28438544
His point was that EqG creates more content, I'm just proving him wrong.

>>28438533
and yet those shitty cyoas, pone oc's and pure mlp threads are the ones reaching bump limit while EQG dies. look at the archive, EQG gets maybe 1 in every 10 500+ threads.

>>28438547
Anon gets all the human pussy, Anon gets all the human pussy comedy, Anon gets all the human pussy with comedy that is bad but people think is good, Anon is just a high school kid and gets raped, Anon lives out his high school waifu dream, story isn't about Anon at all and follows someone else

>>28438617
The way the light touches that balcony might be the most beautiful thing I've seen all year...

>>28438623
>That not the point
Yes it is. We are talking about how much content the EG threads on /mlp/ produce compared to others and they make a shit ton. Other characters may have more art in general on the internet but they were a thing when the fandom was at its strongest. EG is 3 years younger and only came about at the fandoms initial decline. Looking at the EG threads compared to the pony threads, EG produces a shitton of content. We're not leaving. Get used to it.

>Keep porn on /trash/
Otherwise, I agree, it will turn this board into various fetish threads and a pony themed /b/

>EQG
If we contain it to one thread, it'll constantly be on page one due to popularity and people will bitch about that too, rather than a few threads bumping a different intervals

>no hooves
Just delete the posts that try to incite arguments. Its terribly annoying

>GR15
At least flexed to allow pony reactions, but no active discussions that detract from the boards intended theme

>too many generals
Maybe look into combining a few, ifk

>banners
Get rid of the obvious troll entries

>sticky
Sure, an updated sticky wouldn't hurt


Thats my two cents at least

>>28438544
This. In any situation, there's no reason to ban or alter the board's structure over EqG.

>>28438588
Wow, anon. You're so smart and perceptive. I never realized that the point of porn threads was to encourage creative expression and celebration of the show. I always thought they were just for posting porn.

>>28438670
I seriously love how well written your post was. I could taste the sarcasm. Teach me, senpai

>>28438685
Well, anon. If you stopped saying stupid shit, I wouldn't have to talk to you like this.

>>28438654
>Looking at the EG threads compared to the pony threads, EG produces a shitton of content.
Are you this autistic or do I actually have to explain why EG content would appear concentrated when its contained to a miniscule subsection of the board?

You have 5 places in which all your content aggregates and you think that makes you healthy. You don't even burn through those threads particularly fast, so you're not even making content that quickly.

mlp cyoas alone have half as many images as the entire EQG fandom. You guys aren't even close.

>>28438700
No, I wasn't that Anon. I just really loved your sarcasm.

As usual people let the fags that want the mods to ruin the place win.
/mlp/ is dead.

>eqg shouldn't be confined because we have lots of green text
probably some of the shittiest logic I've seen in a while. I know most eqgfags are complete newfags, but there was a time when all of AiE fics were in one general.

>people are actually debating the quality of greentext
This is legitimately hilarious, because all greentext is complete trash that reads like it was written by a five year old

>>28438707
No matter what you say on here, there is no way on God's green earth that EG will ever be banned, but please, by all means keep crying. You're kinda like the barneyfag of EqG

>>28438717
Sorry about that. My bad.

>>28438728
I never said anything about banning EQG.
Are you new to 4chan and the whole 'anon' shtick?

>>28438670
You also don't realise, being obviously too fucking clever, that it will allow to post any pony art, regardless of having porn in it or not.
And if you make any fucking difference between good pony art and good pony porn, I can only suggest you kys, retarded bigot.

>>28438748
Well then you must have taken the place of the other guy I was arguing with. Either way, EG is here to stay. That was the original discussion.

>>28438658
>Otherwise, I agree, it will turn this board into various fetish threads and a pony themed /b/
For (You) >>28438391

>>28438726
>selective perception
EqG shouldn't be confined because it's pony content that gets released regularly and people enjoy posting about it and discussing it

>>28438654
>We're not leaving.

Ah so this is the root of it. Please point to me where I said that EqG should leave, I'll wait, but in the mean time.

>Looking at the EG threads compared to the pony threads, EG produces a shitton of content.

Except they don't. What you seem to take as content is nothing more than discussion on the topic, and there are more pony threads that do just than EqG, as I pointed out earlier. Even if you disregard bump thread.

>>28437881
Behold, the average /mlp/ poster

File: 1356991734993.png (177KB, 900x931px) Image search: [Google]

177KB, 900x931px

>>28438359
We've got one right now. >>28435857
Note how it's at the top of page one even though it's far exceeded the bump limit.
Any normal thread would have dropped off the edge of page ten and into the archive by now.

>>28438777
>Ah so this is the root of it. Please point to me where I said that EqG should leave, I'll wait, but in the mean time.
How the fuck do I know who said what? We're all anonymous. I just reply to whoever replied to me and earlier I was arguing with someone who wanted to van EG and then you took his place when we started talking about content.
>Except they don't.
Have you ever browsed any EG thread ever? They are constantly pumping out more content. We just gave birth to a new general too. The lewd slumberparty one which is constantly making more green.

>>28437785
So, arguments for the porn are:
1. More material
2. MAYBE more content
3. More freedom
Arguments against are:
1. I ARE SURE THIS IS BAD IDEA BECAUSE EVERYTHING IS GOING TO BE JUST AS I ARE PREDICTING, DUUUH, LISTEN TO MY ALLKNOWIING ME ALREADY

File: 772320_solo_clothes_solofemale_blushing_humanized_equestriagirls_suggestive_simplebackground_sunsetshimmer_pixiv.png (241KB, 912x1200px) Image search: [Google]

241KB, 912x1200px

>>28437785
I say we ban clop fags, iwtci*fags, and every other horse fucker and force them into /trash/. That should improve our standing across 4chan considerably.

>>28438791
Thanks mate. I appreciate the help.

>>28438811
Really, kid? That's the best you can do?

>>28438811
Wow, what a balanced point of view. You sure convinced me with your hot opinions.
Tell me more.

>>28438812
Stop. You're a nohoovesfag posing as an EGfag trying to make all EGfags look bad.

>>28437785
Don't forget better moderation

>>28438832
>eqgshitter damage control
lmao

>>28438520
>Implying FiM are any different.

EQG stories is just superior to FiM stories. Environment, setting, characterization, story telling, realism, everything is just better. Get fucked >nohoovesfag

>>28438812
>>28438838
>samefag

>>28438818
>>28438830
>kid
>biased

You have so fuuuuuucking much to say, I see. So many fucking point to make, arguments to bring up.
Why don't you just leave this thread, scum?

>>28438770
It will always get worse as a red board

>>28438632
>Anon becomes friends with the Mane 6
>Anon becomes close friends with princesses
>Anon has sex with princesses
>Anon has sex with background ponies
>Anon deals with ponies who call him a "hyooman"
>Anon dates ponies
>Anon lives a wonderful fantasy life with ponies
And that's somehow worse than EQG stories? lol, okay buddy.

>>28438854
Go back and read my post you mongoloid. I'm for EqG.

>>28438811
All those could be applied to anthro

>>28438854
>Environment, setting, characterization, story telling, realism, everything is just better.
Because YOU are saying it? So fucking based.
Average EqG imbicil, meh.

File: !GuidetoNewfag.png (2MB, 3147x3423px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 3147x3423px

>>28437785
>Should EQG be removed/contained to a general? Why?
Nah, it's here to stay, no matter how shitty the source material is. There's some interesting concepts to explore with the series, and it seems to becoming more fantastical in nature, which is good. Most EqGfags are alright, but too many have this mentality that they're the counter-culture on /mlp/.

>Should generals be moved to their own board or confined to /trash/?
No, /mlp/ has always had generals and always will. They provide decent amounts of content and almost every green comes from a general of some kind.

The problem comes from when meta shittery infects a general.

>Should /mlp/ become a red board? Why?
No, /trash/ exists now and we've managed to find other ways to post porn like imgur links. I wish that mods would fuck off like they did in the first year of /mlp/'s existence, but I realize that's likely never going to happen again.

>Should GR15 be abolished? Why?
No, Barneyfag will reveal that he's actually a gestalt consciousness and shitpost every board into oblivion. I'm biased on this point, because my pony reaction folders and non-pony reaction folders are of equal size; there's no struggle for me to find the perfect meme face.

>Should we see our sticky return? Why?
I think we should have a sticky, but one that shoves newfags into the board culture like pic related.

>Should the winners of /mlp/'s banner contest be revised to exclude the troll options?
Who even sees them?

>>28438858
Because you've yet to show a structured argument yourself, kiddo.

>>28438726
>probably some of the shittiest logic I've seen in a while.
Same could be argued for MLP general on /co/. Nothing of value is going to be lost except for shitty art and shitty stories, so why do we need a board instead of one general?

>>28438807
I have, and once again no they don't. Spawning a new general isn't hard to do anon. Flurry, Equestria at war, Hunter Anon, and Where do you work Anon? are all new pony generals. CYOAs are mostly pony focus, and can have a new one created. (Your waifu, FoE outcasts etc.) In the mean time only Lewd Sleep over, Incestuous Relationships Thread, and the Moondancer thread are the new EqG threads created thus far, and I'm stretching the definition of new. Oh and Casual/ public sex came back too.

>>28438868
>It will always get worse as a red board
Because...?
>>28438871
Yes. But let's sort this out with porn first.

>>28438869
>And that's somehow worse than EQG stories? lol, okay buddy.
What? You arguing it's better, yet you make it sound worse. Everything you listed makes FiM stories seem stupid.

>>28438881
So you can claim that my argument is not structured, without presenting any youself, just like you did the last time, moron?
Get the fuck out.

>>28438885
This seems like a very trivial topic to argue about. I thought you were that Anon I was originally arguing with who said he wanted EG banned. If you're not him, why are we fighting?
I bid you a good day, Anon. May you have many lewd dreams of your waifu

File: 1370692858789.jpg (35KB, 500x423px) Image search: [Google]

35KB, 500x423px

>>28438858
>Implying there's no arguments
You're not going to convince many people to your opinion by dismissing the opposition outright.
I'm for porn but you need to give their ideas a fighting chance.
Some things discussed against last thread were >>28428936 and >>28429285.

>>28438465
>we don't get anymore
But that's wrong, you fucking casual.
The only way you haven't seen them is if you only come here an hour or so each day.

>>28438934
I'm here for a great many hours every day, actually.

>>28438758
You want to repeat that?

>>28438918
They yet to bring at least one fucking argument except
>I KNOW FOR SURE HOW THING WILL BE
>I JUST KNOW
The only other argument
>Porn should not be allowed because it will then become like how /b/ is now where over half their threads are just various porn fetishes.
Was already dismissed by >>28438391

What I really, really hate about this shithole is how'd far you faggots would live in denial. So let me state the facts clearly as the ever blue sky, and the ever blue state of this board
>WE ARE FURRIES
and
>EQG ARE THE PART OF THE G4 PONY FRANCHISE

>>28438960
Who are you quoting?

EqG belongs here. I only object to, as others have said, something with five hours of content taking up so much board space.

>>28438914
I don't know, just felt like having a dick measuring for some reason. Good day anon.

File: Illidan Stormrage - Villains Wiki - villains, bad guys, comic books ....png (169KB, 310x323px) Image search: [Google]

169KB, 310x323px

>>28438971
Illidan :^)

>>28438960
Anon what are you doing? They're just going to spam memes at you.

File: Hell no.jpg (39KB, 500x717px) Image search: [Google]

39KB, 500x717px

>>28438960
>EQG ARE THE PART OF THE G4 PONY FRANCHISE
Sure. Doesn't mean everyone has to like it, though.

>WE ARE FURRIES
We've already had that argument before, and no we're not.
Yes, My Little Ponies technically are animals, in the same sense that humans are animals. They're a cute little sentient species that happen to be surprisingly hot in r34 form.

That doesn't mean that any of us want to jerk off to gay foxes or wear a fucking fursuit like picrelated.
Just because you're a furry doesn't mean everyone here is like you, don't try to put us down to your level.

>>28438909
Go back and look at your post you snot nosed little shit. You give arguments for porn 3 points in which you make one look someone what bad to pretend you're unbiased, and then you immediately go on to shit all over the anti-porn consensus, lumping them all into one argument, and writing them as stupidly and incoherently as you really sound. I mean come one, you dumpster diving little slut. Who do you think you're fooling? Why don't you take your room temperature bargain isle hotpockets and slither off to whatever grimy corner of your dark and dingy basement you came from, you cock gobbling, cum guzzling, piss drinking, shit eating, fart sniffing, scat loving, Hillary supporting, mom fucking, artery clogging, spit sucking, toe curling, neckbeard growing little asshole?

File: Screenshot_2016-09-08-19-25-34.jpg (47KB, 540x678px) Image search: [Google]

47KB, 540x678px

>>28438960
>Sarcastically shocked comment

File: Screenshot_2016-09-17-15-33-14.png (301KB, 1440x2560px) Image search: [Google]

301KB, 1440x2560px

>>28438857

File: 1467570301734.png (552KB, 1600x2191px)

552KB, 1600x2191px

>>28438960
>Smug, contradictory opinion

>>28438981
I know the risk, and I even think about putting a spoilered "come at me, faggots" or a picture of a semi-serious bait.jpg, but I realize that if I want to make a difference, the change had to start from the man in the mirror ^:)

>>28438973
>I only object to, as others have said, something with five hours of content taking up so much board space.
It takes up so much board space because it has so much potential. It's just more entertaining and the stories have more substance. I personally enjoy the freedom, you can't write a story about taking a pony to an arcade then going to the mall, or doing some human shit unless you force magic into your story for plot. EQG has that realism side, shit that's more relatable, and it just makes it much better.

Another opinion I have; FiM related stories are best when there's no anon, whereas EQG stories are the opposite.

>>28438973
look here
>>28438243
If you think EQG is taking up too much space, then it has to be based on the threads themselves and as to whether they're producing stuff. It has no relation to the amount of 'hours' the source material is.

>>28438891

People push the boundaries of a blue board as it is. Without the current limits in place, it'll escalate to more and specific threads. They always do on this site. There would be at least a page worth of different porn threads on the board at various times, and who knows what else as a red. I can tolerate the threads here as a blue, it'd be all the eqg threads tenfold.

Tl;dr clusterfuck of porn

File: 1472955727260.jpg (33KB, 720x706px)

33KB, 720x706px

>>28438960
>UNNECESSARILY RUDE REPLY ALL IN CAPS

File: 3836218197_896967a38a.jpg (162KB, 422x500px) Image search: [Google]

162KB, 422x500px

>>28438960
>Unintelligible comment accompanied by a pic that has nothing to do with the discussion

>>28438985

Yeah, what this guy said. Fuck everything about his pic and that kind of thing.

>>28438998
Nah, I see a lot of circlejerking and attempts to make FiM-only fans mad, like your posts. EqG is the exact opposite kind of story I got into this franchise for.

Those restrictions are what made FiM so great in part.

>>28439001
I'll just hide any thread with a mention of EqG because I don't like it. Just a shame when it pushes FiM threads off.

>>28438986
Nice fucking post, dipshit, again, so many fucking points made, like you being buttblasted autistic whore.
Trying to critic only that very post, ignoring any points made by me and Anons, that appeared before, and then opening your filthy stinky mouth to say something about ignoring someones arguments.
Wow, I haven't seen such a dumb ape like you on the internet for a while, gratz, you surely impressed the whole thread, lowbrow.

File: Oh You Do Do You.jpg (446KB, 1920x1080px)

446KB, 1920x1080px

GR15 should be abolished and the sticky should come back, everything should be left alone.

>Implying Hiro's actually going to do anything

>>28438986
Behold your average blue-poster.
I woun't be surprised, if an actuall horse cunt brought you to this world, you fucking filthy animal on the loose.

>>28439059
I'm not talking about other Anons. I'm talking about you specifically. You and your retarded fucking post that I originally replied to.

File: 4chanInANutshell.gif (285KB, 300x100px) Image search: [Google]

285KB, 300x100px

ITT

>>28439078
Honestly, even though I'm fine with the way things are now, and the amount of shit that will probably follow after lifting GR15 is really unappealing, this is the most fair thing to do. It would make the rules that apply to other blue boards like /v/, /vp/, /a/, etd. also apply to us. It's the most consistent thing to do.

File: 1406837098549.jpg (56KB, 445x500px) Image search: [Google]

56KB, 445x500px

>>28438986
Jesus, Anon. He touched a fucking nerve.

File: tumblr_inline_oaac3zDk8T1seq8ew_500.gif (1MB, 500x272px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 500x272px

I'm disturbed by the amount of toxic and problematic ways of thinking present in this thread.

>>28437785
>Should EQG be removed/contained to a general?

Contained to a general.

>Why?

To end the 'why is she so perfect' threads.

>Should generals be moved to their own board or confined to /trash/? Why?

>Should /mlp/ become a red board?

No.

>Why?

Because there's not enough show discussion and too many fetish generals as it is.

>Should GR15 be abolished?

Yes.

>Why?

To irritate barneyfag and so that I can bring the glorious love of ponies to /his/.

>Should we see our sticky return?

No.

>Why?

It isn't necessary.

>Should the winners of /mlp/'s banner contest be revised to exclude the troll options?

Yes.

>Why?

To irritate barneyfag. If he's irritated enough he'll just suicide live on /v/ and all the peoples of 4chan will rejoice.

>>28439111
Leave.

File: will2.png (47KB, 262x261px) Image search: [Google]

47KB, 262x261px

>>28439124
Or else?

File: b8c.gif (1MB, 662x600px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 662x600px

Dis gunnna be gud

>>28439133
Yes.

>Should EQG be removed/contained to a general? Why?
no
>Should generals be moved to their own board or confined to /trash/? Why?
no
>Should /mlp/ become a red board? Why?
yes
>Should GR15 be abolished? Why?
yes
>Should we see our sticky return? Why?
no
>Should the winners of /mlp/'s banner contest be revised to exclude the troll options? Why?
yes

>>28439133
Enjoy more problematic dialogue I guess, nigger.

>>28439092
>You and your retarded fucking post that I originally replied to
That originaly got you triggered, so you started simply sperging out, meanwhile even daring to say something about structured arguments.
Spare me from your autism already.

>>28439112
>To end the 'why is she so perfect' threads.
you do know those are mostly done by shitposters to trigger people like you, right?

File: 1457598301241.png (24KB, 260x332px) Image search: [Google]

24KB, 260x332px

>>28439111
>trips
>tumblr filename

Quality shitpost.

File: mandream_by_gabbslines-da5wcm1.jpg (93KB, 752x1063px) Image search: [Google]

93KB, 752x1063px

>>28439112
>Contained to a general.
We've already discussed how badly that will fail.
Ain't gonna happen

File: tumblr_lm0pgxepRx1qdde4g.gif (482KB, 350x277px) Image search: [Google]

482KB, 350x277px

>>28439124

>>28439149
He's also gotten dubs now, he's one of the bright new minds.

>>28437785
There was a strawpoll regarding red mlp in the last thread, here
http://www.strawpoll.me/11232190
Everyone who still hasn't voted can simply join.

Are people seriously talking about removing EG?
Back when EG was announced faggots kept thinking that GR15 didn't apply to it until moot said that it belongs only in /mlp/ and that it wasn't a gray area.
The point of this board is to be a containment board and EqG is part of that containment.

>>28437785
>Should EQG be removed/contained to a general? Why?
I don't think it can be removed or contained, but it would be interesting to see an all in one eqg thread. It would never work though.

>Should generals be moved to their own board or confined to /trash/? Why?
There will never be another board made for mlp, and if they're sent to /trash/ pony would take it over. It'd be a huge shitstorm.

>Should /mlp/ become a red board? Why?
With /trash/ around I don't see it happening.

>Should GR15 be abolished? Why?
It will only happen if/when /mlp/ is deleted and the mods are ready to deal with the shitstorm for a few weeks until the novelty wears off.

>Should we see our sticky return? Why?
Yes. We don't need it for troll threads anymore, but it would be very useful in setting what's allowed and what isn't. It would get rid of a lot of bitching and arguing.

>Should the winners of /mlp/'s banner contest be revised to exclude the troll options? Why?
The mods should want this to happen because barneyfag said he would leave 4chan if we got a banner we like.

File: 1397320589683.jpg (89KB, 1440x1484px) Image search: [Google]

89KB, 1440x1484px

>>28439218
I think part of the idea is to remove EqG completely from 4chan, or at least banish it to /trash/.

>>28439253
>It would get rid of a lot of bitching and arguing
We had one that was written by a mod during the Scruffening. It did nothing but provide ammo to arguments that mods were overstepping.

>barneyfag said he would leave 4chan if we got a banner we like
Man, you think that they would be jumping at the chance to get rid of him. I doubt he'd actually leave though.

>>28437785
>Should the winners of /mlp/'s banner contest be revised to exclude the troll options?
Yes, and same for /adv/ and the other boards that got screwed. Ideal solution would be to only count votes if the pass used for voting has also been used to post on the board in question (with some requirement on # of posts/threads)

We should totally make more boards for /mlp/ topics! Ponychan does it and they're super fun XD

>>28439306
Ponychan's only fun if you're into necrophilia :^)

File: 1434344255626.png (243KB, 840x950px) Image search: [Google]

243KB, 840x950px

>>28438617
>Implying

>>28437785
>Should generals be moved to their own board or confined to /trash/?
The number of generals is a problem but I think the best solution is not to move them but rather to prevent people from bumping dead generals. Start handing out 3-day bans for bumping without content and the problem would go away real quick.

>>28439292
>I think part of the idea is to remove EqG completely from 4chan
The board instantly loses a good number of generals and loses traffic from the people who only come to read EQG stories.

That isn't good in the long run.

>>28439328
>3 day ban for posting "bump"
Jesus Christ man calm down. It's not like he's spitting on moot's grave or anything. I'd say 1 day TOPS if you really want to start banning people for it. That said, I think banning people for bumpinf a thread is retarded and it shouldn't be implemented.

>>28439328
>Start handing out 3-day bans for bumping without content and the problem would go away real quick.
Do you know how hard that would be to enforce? Mods and janitors couldn't even hope to be even slightly uniform. People would be getting bans, while others would walk free, only to create some delusion that the moderation would be picking favorites.

>>28439310
If half the items on OP's list are implemented, /mlp/ will be Ponychan.

>>28439349
I used to think that way, but frankly with how much it's used to bump dead and useless generals, I'm all for it now

>>28439339
>That isn't good in the long run.
I agree, but you're points are really bad, my dude.

>Board instantly loses a good number of generals
A lot of people think that there's already too many generals. You're not going to change their minds by saying this.

>loses traffic from the people who only come to read EQG stories
Chances are, if they only come here to read EqG Green, they weren't contributing much to the board in the first place.

>>28439349
Who's m00t?

>>28439352
They need to add a word filter to bump. I don't think that banning for using the word is a good idea, but it gets tedious to see it everywhere.

>>28439383
>who's moot
I really hope you're joking

File: 1469429912913.png (320KB, 929x689px) Image search: [Google]

320KB, 929x689px

>>28437785
>Should GR15 be abolished? Why?
Give me liberty or give The Barneyfag death

>>28439383
>Who's m00t?
Anon...
I'm sorry but your arguments are now completely invalid

File: 5C6NIOV.jpg (56KB, 650x366px) Image search: [Google]

56KB, 650x366px

>>28437785
OP, this could have been a productive thread, but you just HAD to bring up EQG, which pretty much ensured this thread's downfall.

Next time ignore EQG and focus on the shit that really matters, like making /mlp/ NSFW and GR15. The Eqg shit you put in your post is extremely unnecessary and accomplishes nothing.

>>28439404
This
You can't have expected a structured discussion when you throw EG into the mix.

File: 1461464818931.jpg (33KB, 640x319px) Image search: [Google]

33KB, 640x319px

>>28439394
>>28439402
>Actually taking that seriously
I didn't even put effort into it, c'mon.

File: 1473297377629.png (533KB, 850x900px) Image search: [Google]

533KB, 850x900px

>>28439417

>>28439416
>You can't have expected a structured discussion when you throw EG into the mix.
This is the fucking problem. It's the >nohooves kiddies that shit up EQG discussion.

>>28437785
Yes. Ban the eqg trash. Possibly to >>>/trash/. It's been coming to them since the day one.

Keep the generals for all I care. They are probably one of the main reasons the board is still alive.

I actually have no opinion in this matter. Red or blue, I don't give a fuck, I don't browse 4chan at work.

No. GR15 is the reason #1 to the existence of this board. Without GR15, /mlp/ has no reason to keep existing.

Yes, the sticky would be nice. Possibly by some based mod, if there are any left.

Probably, yes. I don't care though, I block the banners with my ad blocker.

File: 1467672316396.jpg (205KB, 727x1100px) Image search: [Google]

205KB, 727x1100px

>>28439441
>Yes. Ban the eqg trash. Possibly to >>>/trash/. It's been coming to them since the day one.
Nope. You're stuck with us. Eat shit.

>>28439404
>>28439416
Believe it or not eqg is actually a big fucking problem. Whether or not it is mentioned in the OP doesn't mean shit. You just know one of the first five posters would have brought it up anyway.

>>28439417
Pretending to be retarded is just as retarded as actually being retarded.

File: 1470068662424.png (589KB, 901x934px) Image search: [Google]

589KB, 901x934px

>>28438457
>No. I'm not retarded enough to expect that everyone here will be good and not spam other boards with JoJo shit just on principle. /a/ is full of cancer. Removing GR15 would be detrimental to our health and the heal of other boards.
>You don't need to go around posting JoJo's everywhere anyway; you have a whole 1.5+ boards for it.
ftfy

>>28439437
This is a pony board not a fucking board for ayylmao monstrosities

File: 1467946246891.jpg (62KB, 428x410px) Image search: [Google]

62KB, 428x410px

>>28439465
>Believe it or not eqg is actually a big fucking problem
How is it a problem? Just because some people don't like it?

>>28439441
>Keep the generals for all I care. They are probably one of the main reasons the board is still alive.
>Generals are what's keeping the board alive
>So lets ban 10 of them because people are enjoying shit I don't like.
>Nothing wrong with them, really. It's just that I always go into their threads and type ">no hooves" to ruin their discussion, then in threads like this one I say they are shit eaters and faggots even though I'm the one who derails threads.
Logic, everyone.

>>28439465
>You just know one of the first five posters would have brought it up anyway.
The same way one of the first five posters in a EQG general tries to derail it with >No hooves?

File: 1469313712482.gif (134KB, 480x480px)

134KB, 480x480px

>>28439478
Whaddya gonna do about it? Cry? Like a little bitch?

>>28437871
>hue hue still being triggerd by ponie after 4 years
Kys faggots that get triggered by EQG ain't more than normalfags

>>28439465
EqG isn't a problem. Faggots whining about it make it one. Nigger it's part of MLP and that's the end of it. It belongs on this board. You will NEVER, not in 1000 years and 1000 after that, find enough nor/mlp/eople to come to a consensus and ban EqG content from /mlp/.

>>28439394
You didn't even type m00t right

>>28439466
I see your autism got in the way of the joke anon he's dissing the faggot that left us

Unless i'm the one being tricked in that case I concede you got me guys

>>28439478
>This is a pony board not a fucking board for ayylmao monstrosities
Ironic how those ayylmao monstrosities draw up more discussion and better stories than the ponies this board is supposedly made for. Keep crying.

>DENIAL, DENIAL, DENIAL
oh boy
Hiro, you're not getting anything from a 50 dudes trying to do shit about a board that has fallen so low

Im sorry, but we arent salvageable. Leave us be in our purgatory, and good luck with the other boards

>>28439437
>eqg
>discussion
You mean circlejerk. That about sums up literally every eqg thread. Since, as you likely know first-hand, the majority of eqgfaggots are "refugees" from Ponychan and EQD, as compares to the "refugees" who don't migrate to Europe to escape war, but to get a better living on social support, just like niggers and gypsies do.

File: twi angry.png (918KB, 1483x1070px) Image search: [Google]

918KB, 1483x1070px

>>28439465
EqG is not a huge fucking deal. Look. I personally hate EQG. The franchise is complete cancer and hangs on MLP's name like a turdball sticking to a goat's ass.

But that doesn't change the fact that it belongs here. Trying to change that is a massive waste of time, and the discussion will just be instantly derailed be autists posting smug Sunset pictures anyway.

Time spent arguing about EQG could be put towards discussion of GR15 and other things. It's honestly frustrating seeing a good thread die because anti-EQG shitters and pro-EQG smugposters can't keep it in their fucking pants.

Get the fuck over it. Let's talk about something else that actually fucking matters.

>>28439404
It would have been brought up by the anons who hate eqg anyways.

Honestly, it's perfectly fine to dislike and even hate it, but the anons who are so strongly against it are starting to look just as autistic as barneyfag. Seeing the ">no hooves" fags trying to bully the eqgfags off the board is like watching a sperg pick on another sperg. It's fucking pathetic and it needs to stop.

Get rid of the anthro ban it's fucking retarded

>People ITT actually hate on EQGfags and claim they shit up threads.
>They also conveniently forget how it's FiMfags who shit up EQG threads.
Autism. Don't be mad because some "monster high bullshit" draws more attention than your pony fantasy fanfic. EQG is a huge cashgrab for Hasbro, if it weren't for that, there could possibly be no FiM anymore.

>>28439503
>You mean circlejerk. That about sums up literally every eqg thread
>Implying that's not the same for pony threads.

>>28439500
>more discussion
That's what eqgfaggots call circlejerking.

>better stories
You genuinely made me chuckle. I don't actually even know how to reply to that bold statement, it's just that fucking ridiculous.

>>28439507
>hangs on MLP's name like a turdball sticking to a goat's ass.
You're playing it on pretty thick there, mate. But yeah, I like your point. I just wish others thought more like you.

>>28439549
>playing
Laying*

>>Should EQG be removed/contained to a general? Why?
No. EqG doesn't pose as a spam problem. It's a portion of the content. I'm not even an EqGfag.
>>Should generals be moved to their own board or confined to /trash/? Why?
No. The generals are a hub of content. They're still related to the show, despite being fanon.
>>Should /mlp/ become a red board? Why?
Spoilered porn is a nice in between, otherwise I'm fine with it. The punishment should be less strict.
>>Should GR15 be abolished? Why?
In a sense, yes. Reaction images should be allowed. That's it. It must also follow the rules of spam.
>>Should we see our sticky return? Why?
Yes. Newfags or spamposters should see a clear set of rules at the beginning, so they can't spam the same thread.
>>Should the winners of /mlp/'s banner contest be revised to exclude the troll options? Why?
Yes. It's clear wha the spam is. Also rigging has been used, so it's automatically against the rules.

>>28439540
>I don't actually even know how to reply to that bold statement, it's just that fucking ridiculous.
>I can't prove you wrong, but I'll laugh at what you said and reply in a condescending manner so it seems as if I just don't want to talk about the counter arguments that I don't have.
You figured out how to argue on the internet, fantastic. You done, kiddo?

>>28439339
> loses traffic from the people who only come to read EQG stories.
Good riddiance

>>28439520
It's got to the point where everybody is trolling everybody and nobody actually knows who started it. While the newcomers don't notice anything strange since they never knew what was "normal"and just blend in with the crowd.

It's literally like the room with a ceiling shower, twentt monkeys, and a banana.

>>28439566
But then the site loses money, retard.

>>28439500
>Ironic how those ayylmao monstrosities draw up more discussion and better stories than the ponies this board is supposedly made for. Keep crying.
You again? Just fucking gtfo already, you are mentally invalid, just as your arguments.

>>28439578
No, it's not me again. I have a brain and stopped arguing. That's some new faggot.

>>28439561
>kiddo
Invent something new already, you are patheti, as you have nothing to say. Again.

>>28439561
My reply to you was of the same nature your reply to the other guy was. They are both shit and don't add anything of value to the thread.

>>28439586
Then someone is actively trying to compromise you EqG fags, my best guess.

>>28439576
Do you...do you think 4chan actually makes money? The site is already a fucking cash sink that loses the owner money every year. Both moot and hiro have stated this. So the site would lose money whether it has anons coming for EQG or not.

File: 1471663290302.gif (1023KB, 297x168px) Image search: [Google]

1023KB, 297x168px

Let's play a game.
Try to summarize this thread in 1 picture.

only allow pony porn on /aco/ and /i/, you know stories are only written here for lack of porn and we need more stories

>>28439540
As a writefag who has done several stories for both FiM and EqG, I feel my EqG stories are on average better. I also notice this about other greens. When a story does not revolve around smut, EqG tends to deliver higher quality green.

>>28439619
Aye, but it will lose less money with them here. Always look on the bright side.

File: (You).gif (415KB, 480x238px) Image search: [Google]

415KB, 480x238px

>>28439626

File: 1459443051701.gif (1MB, 253x236px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 253x236px

>Thread made to discuss board issues
>oh and Eqg too lol
>instead of having meaningful discussion it's instantly derailed into a EqG focused autismfest
>nothing will change

>>28437814
>>28437838
>>28438123
>>28438296
>>28438512
>>28438608
>>28438993
>>28439454
>>28439491
It's always the sunfags, isn't it

>>28439650
It's probably just one guy avatarfagging.

>>28439632
How many more of this vague "But I feel this way" post do we still need? Can someone pls tell me? Someone, who "feels how many shit we need itt" mb?

File: Screenshot_2016-09-17-13-53-19.png (113KB, 540x960px) Image search: [Google]

113KB, 540x960px

>>28439650
Yup. Fite me irl, mate. Ima reck you. I swear on me mum.

File: image.jpg (26KB, 300x100px) Image search: [Google]

26KB, 300x100px

>>28439626

>>28439650
Is there anything in EqG besides Sunset Shimmer?
I'm yet to see.

File: sunfag.jpg (20KB, 640x437px) Image search: [Google]

20KB, 640x437px

>>28439650
They're called shimmerfags.

>>28439674
Tbh, most of my posts with Sunset on them were shitposts, sarcasm, and purposeful autism.

>>28439632
That's because coming up with a story about humans doesn't require any significant intelligence. Any retard can and will write about humans, and it fucking shows.

>>28439614
>>28439578
>Complains about EQG
>Gets told on how EQG is more popular than FiM on the board made for FiM
>"ur arguments suck kid, gtfo"
Have an unironic: XD

File: PonySkeleton.jpg (41KB, 500x431px) Image search: [Google]

41KB, 500x431px

>>28439640
Honestly /mlp/'s biggest problem isn't its moderation or policies right now. Our biggest problem is the show. We're trying to keep it alive with sheer willpower but it... it just wants to die, man.

>>28439690
THANK YOU!
Sunfags are for Celestia

>>28439691
>purposeful autism
Keep telling yourself that, mate.

File: (You).png (106KB, 1301x620px) Image search: [Google]

106KB, 1301x620px

>>28439650
There's literally nothing wrong with EQG

>>28439632
>When a story does not revolve around smut, EqG tends to deliver higher quality green.
But just like FiM green, 90% of it IS smut, because that's what the majority of anons want. It's a shame.

>>28439692
>That's because coming up with a story about humans doesn't require any significant intelligence.
Please show me some examples of great green that involves FiM. This isn't even about me putting my best EQG stories against your best FiM, I just want to see for myself if anyone can actually link me to some pony stories that are stuff I(me, not other anons, ME(ME)) can rank higher than my top 5, personally.

>>28439710
See, this is why you never bring up EQG in board discussions. It'll be instantly spammed by smugshim posting. Next thread, do NOT fucking mention EQG in the OP.

Is that so hard?

File: 1470553206034.png (1MB, 768x1024px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 768x1024px

>>28439701
Daddy won't let that happen. They will keep beating this dead horse till the last drop of blood falls from Twilys veins.

>>28439700
>>Complains about EQG
>Gets told on how EQG is more popular than FiM on the board made for FiM
What? Anything of it actualyl happened? Are you having seizures or something?

>>28439632
I think it stems from the fact that writing humans is easier than ponies. Technicolor horses lack the describable body language that we have, specifically hand gestures. They can't cross their arms when they're irate, they can't shove them in their pockets when they're shy, they can't give a thumbs-up or flip the bird.

>>28439627
They would still have GR3 in /aco/ so lifting it there is meaningless.
That would only means humanized is allowed there.
Really no point with the existence of /trash/

>>28439689
This.
INB4
>But muh content! Muh diversity! Muh characterization..

File: this entire conversation.jpg (1MB, 2052x1329px)

1MB, 2052x1329px

>>28439723
>this irrelevant pissing contest isn't actually an irrelevant pissing contest lol
Both of you quit it.

File: Smokey the Bear Only You Can Prevent Forest Fires Retro Vintage Tin S ....png (125KB, 400x400px) Image search: [Google]

125KB, 400x400px

>>28439728
He might be. You never know what could happen. Are you prepared for an emergency?

>>28439725
It isn't even a problem. Some guy posts a shimmer pic, and says EQG doesn't need to leave. It's you anti-EQG fags that blow it out of proportions and going out of your way to call him and EQG in general, shit. Nothing wrong with EQG, it's the antiEQG which make it bad.

File: 1470603946566.gif (404KB, 500x532px) Image search: [Google]

404KB, 500x532px

>>28439706

Hiro's statement about the /mlp/ banner contest result:
>>>/qa/678806

>>28439754
In any case, EQG doesn't need to be brought up at all. It's not as big of an issue as GR15.

>>28439738
Not only is writing about humanoids easier but the EqG world is not defined at all. It has literally zero worldbuilding so it's far easier to come up with your own shit. The world is also more familiar since it takes place in a more contemporary setting rather than FiM mush mash of contemporary and fantasy elements

>>28439725
This only proves it's a legitimate concern. God knows a shift in board culture can't be forced. Mods restrict it, angry shitposting ensues. Mods leave it be, normal shitposting continues freely.

File: 1466654313274.gif (558KB, 384x288px) Image search: [Google]

558KB, 384x288px

>>28439725
>spammed by smugshim posting
BUT IT'S NO HOOVES HATERS TO BLAME

>>28439751
What's Smokey going to do? Bury the guy so he can't hurt himself? Also you're supposed to play dead around bears. A seizure only agitates them.

File: Screenshot_2016-09-17-14-03-47.png (223KB, 540x960px) Image search: [Google]

223KB, 540x960px

>>28439754
>Some guy posts a shimmer pic
I think this was all my fault. I didn't realize how triggered some people are by a girl with bacon hair

>>28439761
Complete and total bullshit and obviously done by sabatours. Sift through all the clear troll submisssions and throw up whatever's left over.

>>28439640
>nstead of having meaningful discussion
>about a board that was dedicated to weekly loreless cartoon targeted toward little girls with season long hiatuses
Take around 2000 people then close them inside a room and leave like this for 3 years,only allowing them to talk about meal they receive.The meal must be taken from the nearest unfinished building site which will be finished in around 7 years.After a year and a half ,start using electroshock on people who try to masturbate.After three years will pass , allow some people to leave,and close the door yet again.We're what is left after next two years in that room. And the foreman and chief engineer has left.

>>28439741
Not if hiro is smart and allows furry, loli and shota on red boards like eveyone wants

>>28439783
Not the anon you or anyone was arguing with, but Baconhair's acceptance on this board is only a daily reminder that pony dropped out of school to be princess, but princess is only master of an empty castle with bad insulation.

>>28439772 -guy
Im actually laughing now. Kinda, semi-retarded semi-hysterically.
>>28439754

>>28439807
>empty castle with bad insulation.
They just haven't discovered Owens Corning Fiberglass Insulation yet :^)

Hiro #2:
>>>/qa/678826
What exactly does this man want from us?

Quick! We need to convince Hiro to remedy the banner situation

>>>/qa/>>678840

>>28439818
They already did the episode where AJ fixes a steam pipe. Maybe they can do an episode where AJ installs insulation in the castle. It would be at least as good as the rest of this season.

>>28439839
whoops
>>>/qa/678840

>>>/qa/678840

File: 1469478045341.gif (1MB, 248x189px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 248x189px

>>28439845

>>28439851
Just tell him to remove the troll banners and change nothing else on the board.

Everyone please take note. These posts >>28437881
>>28437871
are what derailed the thread. Anti-EQG fags trying to shit on EQG and baiting a EQG fag to prove why EQG shouldn't be removed.

You complain about EQG, yet you are the cancer worse than EQG, lmaowtf?

>>28439801
What everyone wants is not what is good for the site.
Loli shit will never be allowed outside /b/. It just brings too much problems with it because of laws. Just look at what derpibooru recently did, they recently put a complete ban on underaged material if it is even remotely humanoid because it's too much trouble.
As for the furry bit it's the same with gr15. It's part of this site's culture. You can even see it here where anons are okay with an anthro ban but not with GR15

Can someone with better writing skills than me formulate some kind of proposal for Hiro? Like: "We, the users of /mlp/ want the third winning banner, because.....". Then we have to gather replies to this proposal. But then this could also be looked at as samefagging.

>>28439835
Strawpoll for the banner issue.
http://www.strawpoll.me/11246031

Barneyfag is trying to convince Hiro to keep the banner up.

>>28439495
>dissing the faggot that left us
m00t is the reason you're here right now. He stuck with 4chan for years through all the shit we put him through. When ponies were being buttfucked across 4chan he gave us our little cancer corner of the internet. Just because he doesn't want to be the 4chan man anymore doesn't make him a deserting faggot. Show some respect.

>>28439835
xD, it's Hiro. He wants us to settle it ourselves, because he lives in a world where that's magically possible. Remember, this is /mlp/, a board dedicated to a show about friendship, we should be able to solve the problems on our own and become friends with the mods.

I just sent Hiro this post:
>>28405085

Give him expressive evidence with many replies so he doesn't have to read much.
In the shortterm archive I found two threads with the "banner" filter:
>>28392299
>>28404388

>>28439650
You mean shimmerfags. Sunfags worship Celestia.

Somebody get this newfag out of here.

>>28438391
I can agree with you on some points, but then there would be about 8 different porn threads up at the same time.
How about, if the board does go red, There is a limit on porn threads.
Ex. No different threads about MILFs, BDSM, Loli, just one central porn dump

>>28439974
>inb4 "i dont see conclusion"

Lets face it, he doesnt care

>>28439673
That's all ANYTHING in this thread is. That's all ANY discussion about rules ever is. How people feel dictates the law of the land.

>>28439996
We could never reach a conclusion.

>>28440000
Quads confirm truth. We are sadly a site of anons, and not of rules.

File: hiro-usagi.png (366KB, 636x478px)

366KB, 636x478px

gookmoot is useless, he's going to listen to all the screaming children and papa barneyfag on the literal reddit board.

>>28439996
>Lets face it, he doesnt care
I don't think that it's because he doesn't care, it's because he doesn't understand. There's obviously a language barrier going on, either that or he's just slow in the head. Even Barneyfag is more level headed than Hiro, he can actually put up a conversation, it's just that he "hates" /mlp/. Hiro can't even solve a simple problem.

>>28440028
>Hiro can't even solve a simple problem.
Anon, I'm not out to defend every action of anhiro, or even this one, but have you ever considered that problems on this site are actually more complex and nuanced than they seem?

>>28439111
TOXIC
PROBLEMATIC
TROUBLING

>>28440028
>implying it isn't the mods in disguise

Just because it says ##admin in red lettering doesn't mean he's writing those posts

>>28439963
moot was the one doing the buttfucking, though. And don't you remember "tomato garden"? moot viewed 4chan as his personal little thing and mostly seemed annoyed by how many people were here using it. I mean aside from basic back-end stuff, I'm not sure of a good thing he did for any board in the last half decade. We used to call him the little girl for reason, and it was because he was kind of pissy and not really too well respected. Once he got to be an adult he pushed back, but all it did was throw wrenches into board communities. It took years for them to stop perma-banning for random bullshit and even longer to realize consistency and warnings (so somebody could come back after breaking a rule) were the only way large groups are going to follow rules in the first place.

File: 1338608718870.png (66KB, 500x479px) Image search: [Google]

66KB, 500x479px

Mods should only limit themselves to remove spam, illegal shit and fags that are massively obnoxious like Nyxfag, NRDT
They shouldn't touch any other thread.

>>28440085
The retarded thing is that the mods all hate /mlp/ yet they are still allowed to moderate it. It's like having a racist cop patrolling the ghetto. Nothing good is going to come from it aside from #/mlp/livesmatter posts.

>>28440107
We have the one mod that makes the new episode threads. Why haven't we heard anything from him? I mean if he hated this place i seriously doubt he'd make those threads.

>>28437785
>Should EQG be removed/contained to a general? Why?
Removed? No. General? Maybie. EQG is still part of the friendship is magic franchise. The only reason aginst it besides the weak plot is basically
>no hooves
>Should generals be moved to their own board or confined to /trash/? Why?
No. Beacuse it will be /b/+ponies if that happens. And genral ot just appers from thin air ,some of the best general comes from greentext prompt threads.
>Should /mlp/ become a red board? Why?
No. We already have /trash/ for that. The shitposting is already high ,and I don't want to see some bored edgelord posting futanari necrophila squat watersprting lesbian anthro horses.
>Should GR15 be abolished? Why?
The shitstorm will be big. And good. But then this board is going to be deleted.
>Should we see our sticky return? Why?
We need a new sticky like /fit/ has. Writing down all the shit that newfags need to know. Our new sticky should be similar ,and about our trashy memes.
>Should the winners of /mlp/'s banner contest be revised to exclude the troll options? Why?
Yes. I wan't this board to have nice things. Six fucking year passed and the autistic buttthurt are still exist.

>>28440131
Tha was so fucking late, mate. We're way past that now.

>>28440107
That was a very bad comparison, Anon. You know how much of /mlp/ overlaps with /pol/.

It's more like allowing necrophilliacs to become undertakers, or known ISIS members to become pilots for American Airlines.