[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Search | Home]
4Archive logo
Is Mahoyo another form of TM garbage? It...
If images are not shown try to refresh the page. If you like this website, please disable any AdBlock software!

You are currently reading a thread in /a/ - Anime & Manga

Thread replies: 118
Thread images: 19
File: 1414083232992.jpg (52 KB, 400x484) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1414083232992.jpg
52 KB, 400x484
Is Mahoyo another form of TM garbage? It is literally praised by weebs who can read Nihonjese while no translation is out, but I bet that they'll turn their back on it when it gets popular
>>
File: 28.png (415 KB, 1024x576) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
28.png
415 KB, 1024x576
>when it gets popular

I fucking wish.
>>
It's actualy the least popular TM VN because
>too short for the price
>linear
>seemingly only 1/3 of the story
>neither voice acting nor H-sceney
>>
>>117900969
Good soundtrack though.
>>
>>117900812
>but I bet that they'll turn their back on it when it gets popular
That's literally what happens with every VN that is translated.
>>
>>117900812
By default anything shat out by TM is garbage.

>>117901243
And manga and LN.
>>
Who would make the best otouto, Shirou, Shiki, or Soujuurou?
>>
>>117901658
Shirou or Soujuurou, they're both hard workers with agreeable personalities (if rather dense). Shirou is a better cook, Soujuurou is purer.

Shiki would probably end up raping you sooner or later.
>>
>make a vn about the aozaki sisters
>show nothing about how they grew up or clocktower shenanigans
>just show aoko living with a dense guy
>>
File: 1272671618701.jpg (124 KB, 337x367) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1272671618701.jpg
124 KB, 337x367
>there's people out there who don't enjoy TM works
It's like you hate having fun.
>>
>>117901272
>By default anything shat out by TM is garbage.
Explain. Yourself.
>>
>>117902389
The important stuff about their childhood was touched upon in the game and nothing says that the clock tower won't show up in the sequels. Besides, the game focused pretty heavily on the most important aspect of their relationship, which is their rivalry.

Also,
>complaining about Soujuurou
>>
>>117903122
>show up in the sequels.
After Tsukihime remake
>>
So we will get Mahoyo 2 in 2020, after tsukihime remake in 2017 right? There would be several Fate products in between too.
>>
>>117903184
Don't remind me.

At this point I'll be perfectly happy if they get released at all.
>>
>>117903279
>tsukihime remake in 2017
Pretty optimistic
>>
In term of Nasu stuff:
CCC > Mahoyo > FSN > Tsukihime > FHA

Nothing he did is bad but it's not like there is anything great either, he is well in the 8/10 territory.
Though the sequels of Mahoyo could do something pretty nice if they keep the same production values and keep developing the setting/cast, chapter 5 of Mahoyo is probably the best thing Nasu wrote overall, it was awesome

But yeah it's hard to really get into the TM hype when you have access to stuff like Dies Irae or Muramasa
>>
>>117903418
>Mahoyo being better than FSN
>CCC being better than anything
Post disregarded.
>>
>>117903279

You get Fate/Extra zZz somewhere around 2019 and that's the last you ever hear of TM, because Nasu will be living off of fanfic novel and anime royalties for the rest of his life without ever touching the pen again.
>>
>>117903447
I reread FSN in Japanese one year ago and both Mahoyo and CCC have much better writing, FSN's script is really really unrefined compared to everything he did recently.
And I put CCC first because it really felt like Nasu had a lot of fun writing it and I had a lot of fun reading it (the gameplay part wasn't very good though)
>>
>>117903508
In terms of writing quality I might agree but in my opinion Mahoyo has simply not enough story and I'm pretty biased against CCC because I already hated Extra's whole setting
>>
>>117903418
What about Kara no Kyoukai?
>>
>>117903772
Meh/10
>>
>>117903691
It's true that Mahoyo doesn't have much story and unlike it's previous stuff Nasu doesn't try to do anything really "epic" with it but it's pretty self-contained in its own right and manage to build a mood unlike anything he did before, in term of characterization it's also some of the solid stuff he wrote.

As for Extra itself disliking the setting may be understandable and the game itself isn't much more than a cash cow but CCC did a lot of interesting stuff with the setting and is more like a thematic follow-up to the entire series rather than a cash cow, at least that's how I saw it
>>
>>117900969
Why couldn't he release the entire damn game? There's a limit to how much he can ride the Type moon name.
>>
>>117904120
>Why couldn't he release the entire damn game?
He would have to write instead of playing video games
>>
>>117904194
If he is too lazy to write why not just hire someone to do it for him or something. He is far too lazy to do anything besides Extra shit apparently.
>>
>>117900969
Nothing wrong with a linear story.
>>
>>117903418
Are Dies Irae and Muramasa that good or is it just moonspeaker hype?
>>
>>117904261
>If he is too lazy to write why not just hire someone to do it for him or something.
Well actualy they pay him royalties to write in the Nasuverse.
See Apocrypha, Prisma , Strange Fake
>>
>>117904264
Should just write a LN or Manga for a linear story
>>
>>117904082
>but CCC did a lot of interesting stuff with the setting
Doesn't help if I dislike the whole setting
>and is more like a thematic follow-up to the entire series
No matter what Nasu said I realy don't see that
>>
>>117904409

>I haven't even played the game but I hate it just because
>No, no, no, no
>I can't hear youuu
>>
>>117904482
I've played it though
>>
>>117904357
I guess, yah
>>
>>117904357
Then what about visuals or sound cues? Properly used, they can make a better story than a glorified movie script or comic book.
>>
>>117903508
>Mahoyo and CCC have much better writing
Having better writing isn't all there is in a story anon.
>>
File: bZezSRA.jpg (1 MB, 5498x3615) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
bZezSRA.jpg
1 MB, 5498x3615
More spinoff.
>>
>>117904646
Or maybe he could try write a real Novel
>>
File: 51Jr2hCdebL.jpg (59 KB, 353x500) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
51Jr2hCdebL.jpg
59 KB, 353x500
>>117904676
>>
>>117904683
Now don't demand too much from the mushroom
>>
>>117904676
Isn't it just Waver in a castle with a Loli?
>>
>>117904713
Can Enkidu use Enkidu?
>>
File: 1417695547206.jpg (49 KB, 337x497) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1417695547206.jpg
49 KB, 337x497
>>117904713
>>
>>117904265
They're just the two go to chunni VNs that aren't translated people always mention to give off a false sense of elitism and attempt to shit on Fate. Neither are anywhere near as popular, and only Muramasa is regarded as having the same quality. Dies Irae is a tier below FSN and Muramasa.
>>
>>117904683

>hurrp durrp, don't try anything new and different, write books like everyone else

By the way, he has written novels.
>>
>>117904665
Writing encompass more than just prose you know, Nasu got a lot better at pacing and making sure the scenes are relevant too.
If you just care about the barebone story FSN has a "greater" concept sure but that's just for 2004, some titles already did the same but better since.
>>
File: 1417690529354.jpg (107 KB, 600x600) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1417690529354.jpg
107 KB, 600x600
>>117904722
Who knows?
>>
>>117904745
Has Jeannu used her suicidal NP yet?
>>
>>117904747
Popularity = Quality now? Are you retarded or something.
Play these first before talking please.
>>
>>117904725
Chain was named for him, not used by him.
>>
File: 27040902_p4.jpg (133 KB, 350x490) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
27040902_p4.jpg
133 KB, 350x490
>>117901658
Soujuurou for sure. He's like a male version of the typical magic pinkhaired airhead moeblob that pops out of nowhere and doesn't understand anything about the world.
>>
>>117904747
The latest version of Dies Irae, Amantes Amantes has a better rating than FSN in egs if you want to play the rating card
>>
>>117904827
Popularity plays a role in hype and the quality I later described has nothing to do with popularity, otherwise I wouldn't have said Muramasa is regarded as having the same quality as FSN.
>>
>>117905049
There is no actual correlation between quality and popularity you know
And again you are talking about shit you have no idea about so you mentioning Muramasa like it gives you some credence is pretty fucking stupid
>>
>>117905117
>There is no actual correlation between quality and popularity you know
I have not implied one, and if you think I have, you're an idiot who doesn't understand what hype means and have a very low level of reading comprehension.

>>117905015
The latest version also doesn't even have over 200 votes.
>>
>>117901036
Don't forget that it's also probably the single best looking Visual Novel ever in terms of direction
>>
>>117902669
>hurr durr popular thing is garbage am I cool!
>>
>>117905313
I know what hype is and that's has nothing to do with quality, that's why I'm telling you there is no correlation to be made there.
Hype is all about timing, countless artists that are considered great nowadays ended their life in poverty because they missed that timing, that little bit of chance.

And countless utter shits manage to sell millions because they were released at the good time and managed to find their public.
That has nothing to do with popularity once again.

And once again I'm telling you that whatever you think is of no matter since you didn't actually play through these games.
>>
>>117904788
>some titles already did the same but better since
What the fuck has done F/SN better than F/SN?
>>
>>117904788
>>117905767
Beat me to it
>>
>>117905767
>>117905840
Beat me too.
>>
>>117905504
>that's why I'm telling you there is no correlation to be made there
Which doesn't matter since it's completely irrelevant to the point made that has nothing to do with statements made in the original argument. I never implied popularity = quality, I specifically went out of my way to avoid that implication by saying FSN and Muramasa are regarded as having the same level of quality despite the popularity difference, and you still stick by this point for no reason other than your own misunderstanding of what I said.

>And once again I'm telling you that whatever you think is of no matter since you didn't actually play through these games.
What does that have to do with the general opinion at large in regards to what people think of these games? I could say that my favorite VN is Tsukihime, but me having played it isn't all of a sudden going to magically make it more well regarded than FSN.
>>
>>117905952
>What does that have to do with the general opinion at large in regards to what people think of these games?
You know nothing about the "opinion at large" too you fucking idiot, you are just seeing some numbers in egs and think they mean something without caring about their real significance
>>
Who is this "he" you guys talking about?
>>
>>117906065
>think they mean something without caring about their real significance
And what real significance do these numbers have then if egs is somehow so much more magically different than every other rating site out there? That all the well rated VNs on that site aren't actually good? egs isn't the only place out there I can look to see that VNs like MLA, Clannad, or WA2 are still held in high regard.
>>
>>117904017
Taste this shit should be illegal.
Even if you consider the rest mediocre Paradox Spiral alone is exceptional without question.
>>
>>117906595
It's pretty different actually.

Egs itself is the playground of 2ch users and is countless going through waves of anti-pro wars, stema and artificial hype

Then you have to take into account the time these titles were released and the situations these titles were in at that time.
Dies Irae for example got a lot of anti because people were fed up with the releases and rereleases due to Light incompetence, that has nothing to do with the intrinsic quality of the game itself.
Another famous example would be Asairo, the game itself is fantastic but it got a really low rating in egs because the game marketed itself as having several heroines but ended up having only one with only one real sex scene.

And then you have to consider that the rating themselves don't correlate with each other since they aren't made by the same people, people who rated shit in 2004 aren't necessarily the same people who rate shit in 2010 and they don't have the same vision of things

In FSN's case in 2004 there was nothing really like it and it was hyped to hell and back since 2002 or so with it even appearing in mainstream media at that time, that was before its release, and hype build on hype.
That has nothing to do with quality (not saying FSN is bad by the way)

Anyways like I said before you see the number but you don't understand what they really mean, you'd have a better case if you used actual reviews but it's not like you can read moon
So stop being a retard who use the words of other people to form its own
>>
>>117900969

Nothing wrong with no h
>>
>>117907502
It doesn't have voice-acting either, so it just seems lazy
>>
File: 1380800690331.png (192 KB, 284x353) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1380800690331.png
192 KB, 284x353
>>117907502
>>
>>
>>117902669
>>117905400
No, but because NASU IS A HACK
>>
File: 39.png (305 KB, 1024x576) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
39.png
305 KB, 1024x576
Can we talk less about EGS and more about best boy?
>>
Hey should I wait for fuwanovel to upload their torrent of it or can I find a torrent to the game somewhere else where there are a decent amount of seeds for it.
I've tried google but I've only seen ones that have either a couple of seeders or just no seeds at all.
>>
File: Mahoyo.jpg (11 KB, 461x124) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
Mahoyo.jpg
11 KB, 461x124
At least they nailed the art, where was the guy who did the art hiding all this time?
The Tsukihime remake will be fucking vastly inferior than this.

Anyway I tried to install the game and it doesn't run, any ideas?
>>
>>117909224
>fuwanovel
Why would they be uploading any time soon? It's not translated.
>>
>>117909424
http://fuwanovel.org/novels/mahoutsukai-no-yoru
says it's completed it's just in TLC
>>
>>117900812
Two things are inevitable despite what TMfaggots believe:

1.) The inevitable translation will at least boost it's relevancy, if only by a little.
2.) This will get an anime adaption.

It;s just a matter of time.
>>
File: 13091450.jpg (206 KB, 524x661) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
13091450.jpg
206 KB, 524x661
>>117909469
>it's completed it's just in TLC

Don't expect that to change anytime soon.
>>
>>117909469
It's been that way for quite a long time.
>>
>>117909495
>2.) This will get an anime adaption.
I doubt that immensly.
Atleast until Nasu releases the other 2 parts
>>
>>117909495
>This will get an anime adaption
The remake would be out sooner than this getting an adaption
>>
File: 1409602558757.png (553 KB, 638x799) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1409602558757.png
553 KB, 638x799
>>117909495
I doubt it'll get an anime, especially with what they said in the interviews leading up to the release.
>>
>>117909522
>>117909526
Well that's depressing
But I've just checked the current statues of the project http://commiesubs.com/mahoyo/
and only 4 out of 14 are still being processed
>>
>>117909785
If you look closely at that page you'll also see that it hasn't been updated in a year and a half now.
>>
>>117909547
>Implying they won't make an anime specifically to promote the 2nd part
This is how it work anon.
>>
>>117907590
The animation are pretty ridiculous though
>>
>>117909908
There simply isn't enough material for an anime
>>
>>117909935
This. A ridiculous amount of work went into the scripting and direction; the game may have its problems but "laziness" isn't one.
>>
>>117905374
Nope, those would be Aiyoku no Eustia and Kaijiri Kamui Kagura.
>>
>>117908977
Tell me about Soujuurou, why does he wear the bandage?
>>
>>117909956
..it's this short?
>>
>>117909886
>look closely at that page you'll also see that it hasn't been updated in a year and a half now
Fuck how did I miss that.
God I take it back
This shit is super depressing why has it been so long.
>>
>>117909956
It isn't much shorter than a single FSN route, is it? You could easily fill a single cour, especially if you add in the side chapters.
>>
>>117910039
Can't say about KKK but Eustia is vastly outclassed by Mahoyo's presentation.
>>
File: 1409602899044.jpg (234 KB, 992x1344) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1409602899044.jpg
234 KB, 992x1344
>>117910060
If you removed his bandage, would he die?
>>
>>117909956
There's plenty for a ufotable paced 1 cour.
>>
>>117910254
Why do 1 cour Mahoyo if they could do 2 cour/movie series Apocrypha?
>>
>>117910331
Maybe someone on the ufotable staff with pull REALLY liked Mahoyo?
>>
>>117910331
Because Mahoyo isn't fanfiction.
>>
>>117910531
>look mom, I posted it again
>>
>>117910210
Too bad presentation is amongst the less important things in a vn, unlike having voices, branching/lengthy story, good OST...

Mahoyo is the shortest TM novel and will never be translated because no one cares for it
>>
>>117910562
I wonder if they'll keep saying that when the number of not-written-by-Nasu spinoffs surpasses the number of stories actually written by Nasu.
>>
I STILL HAVE HOPE THAT HIS MAJESTY IS STILL ALIVE AND IS SPENDING TIME WITH C.C.

Happy Birthday Lelouch.

ALL HAIL LELOUCH!!!! THE 99TH EMPEROR!!!!!!!!!!!
>>
>more DDD never


Fatefags are quite lucky.
>>
>>117910870
The only king we praise here is Gil.
>>
>>117910911
>Praising Gil
Go home Enkidu
>>
File: 1409603102295.jpg (41 KB, 400x493) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1409603102295.jpg
41 KB, 400x493
>>117910888
Whenever being a Mahoyo-fags gets me down, I think about you people and remember count my blessings.

Hang in there.
>>
>>117910967
I thought we were friends, dog D:
>>
File: Lancer, Gil.png (605 KB, 799x601) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
Lancer, Gil.png
605 KB, 799x601
>>117911039
Also Lancer is the only servant Gil calls by name in F/SN. I don't remember whether he called Iskander by name
>>
>>117910911
>>117910967
>1500 years since the Battle of Camlann
>not praising the glory and majesty that is King Arthur of Camelot

A guard dog and a man outwitted by a serpent are not worthy of such respect.
>>
>>117907858
Define hack. No seriously, please give me your definition of that word.
>>
>>117911174
I was not a hound of taking of a fort,
I was a hound of taking of a deer:
I was not a hound of a forbidden trotter,
I was a hound strong for combat:
I was not a hound of round lickings of leavings,
I was a hound who visited the troops:
I was not a hound to watch over calves,
I was a hound to guard Emain Macha.

That guard dog did a far better job than your failing king
>>
>>117911174
The one that fucked up everything? And she's the snake-guy waifu >:D
>>
>>117910612
I hope you aren't implying that Mahoyo doesn't have a good OST.
>>
>>117910612
Only thing out of those you listed that's objectively above presentation is story. The rest just function to set the atmosphere, which is something Mahoyo's presentation does very well. The reason people don't really care for Mahoyo as much is not because of a lack of voices and porn, but because it's so small. It doesn't feel like a complete story like Tsukihime or Fate do. It feels like a glorified prologue, which I guess it is if Nasu really is going to make it a trilogy.
>>
>>117900969
>H-scene
Who cares?
Type-moon don't need porn for fat otaku anymore.
I hope for PS4 version Mahou
>>
>>117900969
>no h
dropped
Thread replies: 118
Thread images: 19
Thread DB ID: 24812



[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Search | Home]

[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / biz / c / cgl / ck / cm / co / d / diy / e / fa / fit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mu / n / news / o / out / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Search | Home]

All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the shown content originated from that site. This means that 4Archive shows their content, archived. If you need information for a Poster - contact them.
If a post contains personal/copyrighted/illegal content, then use the post's [Report] link! If a post is not removed within 24h contact me at wtabusse@gmail.com with the post's information.