Is this the objective ranking of Pokémon games? (using the definitive

>>32963989
I can at least agree with everything in the fourth row and Emerald. Platinum and S/M rank much higher in my eyes.

File: 1492181138214.gif (2MB, 303x277px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 303x277px

>>32963989

That is the first ranking that is actually good. Im fine with that.

Only problem I have is that Platinum should be in Master Ball tier, but you make up for that by not acknowledging ORAS at all.

File: 1435885389979.jpg (15KB, 320x310px) Image search: [Google]

15KB, 320x310px

>>32963989
Where's Red, Blue, Green, Yellow, Gold, Silver, Crystal, Ruby and Sapphire?

File: 1498481128167.png (36KB, 848x955px) Image search: [Google]

36KB, 848x955px

>>32964127
>(using the definitive versions of each gen)

>>32963989
Pretty close to my personal taste.

For me, swap Pt and E. Gen 3 wasn't super great for me. Hoenn specifically. I totally get the criticisms people hurl at Gen IV/Sinnoh but DPPt were the games that brought me back to the series after RS nearly made me quit. I would also put ORAS down with XY unless there is a tier worse than pokeball.

>>32964154
>Canon Games only
>Has games made by Genius Sonority on it
Well buddy which is it, because you can't have both.

>>32964154
>XD
>>>/reddit/

>>32963989
Near flawless. Swap HGSS with Platinum and its perfect.

>>32964190
Not even close

I can understand why you didn't put rbygscrsdp, but where the fuck is ORAS. Unless you are inplying it has been outdone by a game that came out ten years before it, this will make it automatically shit-tier.

>>32964227
ORAS is a step down from Emerald desu and despite being 10 years older it had more content. It's not even debatable.

>>32963989
Switch BW2 and Platinum

>>32964227
ORAS isn't a Emerald remake.

>>32963989
Add Yellow and Crystal in ultra or great tier.

File: iQw7QBW[1].png (2MB, 3678x1138px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 3678x1138px

No. This is.

Swap emerald and platnium, swap BW and FRLG

>>32963989
I'm a fag and haven't played any Pokemon in a long LONG time, which would be better for me to get back to the series? Are Black2/White2 playable without playing the older ones?

>>32964550
>without b/w 1? yeah, just that you'll miss out on a bit of the story
That's what i meant my bad. I guess i should start with b/w 1 then, thanks.

File: 1498365003673.jpg (22KB, 480x480px) Image search: [Google]

22KB, 480x480px

>>32964415
>Red/Blue and X/Y is Master Ball tier.
>Platinum is Ultra Ball tier.

lol no

>>32963989
Put SM and B2W2 one tier lower and it'd be good with me.

>>32964127
I think it's because he's only using one version/version pair for each "story", and only using the games that told it the best

>>32964313
yes and for this very reason it needs to be listed.
>>32964250
It misses many things from emerald, and despite myself I prefer Emerald, it also have things emerald doesn't. So it needs to be listed as it's a different title with its pro and cons, not just a downgraded version.

I'd move BW and maybe Platnium up a tier, but drop FRLG, but those are just personal opinions. Otherwise it looks fine.

>>32964589
lol yes

>Poke shop inside the healing center
Wow i've missed much.

>>32963989
Swap XY/SM and FRLG/BW and put Platinum on top and I'll agree with you.

>>32963989
I'd switch Emerald for Platinum personally, but this is pretty good taste, I can agree with most of it.

>>32964580
This anon again, 1 last question. If i started with black1 and then went with white 2 would there be a problem?

>>32963989
Switch FRLG with BW and you've got it

>>32964589
Platinum is a highly overrated game, the only place that tends to rate it so highly is /vp/. Everywhere else tends to rate it as a mediocre game.

>>32965467
You say it's "highly overrated", but then you go to say that the general consensus outside of /vp/ considers it an average game. With that sort of logic, Platinum isn't as overrated as what you say.

>>32965499
I guess you couldn't get the idea that it's overrated here, hence why I mentioned /vp/.

>>32965510
/vp/ is only one place. And a lot of people here love to overrate it, that's true. But in general, it's a pretty polarizing game. Some people love it, but most others find it pretty boring.

>>32965541
Yeah, you're right. I was being a bit retarded trying to get my ideas across, sorry.