Could a Speed Boost for (Sp) Attack be balanced? Assume reasonable stats (no Smeargle tier stats).
Speed Boost itself isn't balanced.
>>32555000
>Moody is imbalanced
>Speed Boost is imbalanced
Why doesn't Gamefreak just get rid of these abilities?
>>32555003
Game Freak doesn't care about balance that much. They care about gimmicks.
Their main competitive metagame is also a doubles format, where neither Moody, nor Speed Boost are even close to broken.
>>32555000
It's only broken on 1/5 FE pokemon that get it.
Beserk is a balanced speed boost for special attack
>>32555000
Be glad that it activates at the end of the turn. Imagine a Speed Boost that activates at the beginning.
>>32555287
A once-off, two stage Speed raise when the pokemon enters battle.
Better or worse?
Yes, it entirely depends on the Pokémon. Fur coat is an ability that seems broken on paper but since everything that has the ability is shit it's balanced.
Make an auto-Trick Room ability and Speed boost is balanced again.
Also, all these slow attackers will finally get some usage.
>>32556495
The good slow bulky attackers already get usage.
>>32555340
Much better actually. +2 speed is more than enough to start sweeping, and you get that in just one turn, too. It benefits Mega Sharpedo in particular.
>>32555340
That's so much better I'm not sure why you even asked.