http://bulbapedia.bulbagarden.net/wiki/Pok%C3%A9mon_Sun_%26_Pok%C3%A9mon_Moon:_Super_Music_Collection
Now knowing who directed which tracks in sun and moon, what can you make of the quality of tracks vs the composer.
I know one thing for sure, Junichi masuda is a shit composer who forces his soulless electronic music fetish into everything he writes and needs to step down from composing music for the series.
>>32402649
Everything that was "composed" by Masuda is just rehashes of the previous version of the song in the older games.
Masuda bringing nothing new to the table is no surprise.
>Made the wild battle, trainer battle Solgaleo/Lunala themes, the Tapu battle theme and worked on the Champion theme
Wow, I guess he really is pretty shit, since those are all the worst themes of their kinds. Alola Elite Four and Island Kahuna battle are pretty good though.
>>32402649
Oh wow, all of my favorite tracks were the same guy.
Yeah, Masuda is stuck in the past and mostly plays off past themes. (mostly because he wrote them himself)
>>32402708
island kahuna theme was composed by ichinose. The encounter theme was masuda, and since the battle theme is a remix of that, masuda is due credit.
I love Ichinose Go. I seem to gravitate towards his tracks.
>>32402649
Since you brought it up, I looked into the previous games' soundtrack too, and fuck this guy. None of my favorites are from him. The God tier soundtrack from BW, like Castelia, Nimbasa, Alder's Theme or even the End Credit theme. None of those were by this faggot. And Shota Kageyama is a fucking genius. All of those were by him, even Zinnia's theme was his work.
I always thought Masuda was at least a good composer, but no, this faggot is fucking cancer. Pokemon might not be dying, but it will if this faggot isn't dealt with.
>>32402746
his biggest influence was in b2/w2, hence why it has such a stellar ost
http://bulbapedia.bulbagarden.net/wiki/Pok%C3%A9mon_Black_2_%26_Pok%C3%A9mon_White_2:_Super_Music_Collection
who was responsible for most of R/S/E's ost?
>>32402793
http://bulbapedia.bulbagarden.net/wiki/Pok%C3%A9mon_Ruby_%26_Pok%C3%A9mon_Sapphire:_Super_Music_Collection
>>32402793
>>32402809
to answer you question, if you exclude masuda, probably go ichinose.
>>32402708
I liked the Solgaleo/Lunala and Tapu themes tbqh, especially the former. It has an interesting and catchy tune that felt really different from past games I played, though it could get repetitive. I agree that the other stuff you listed is garbage though.
Go Ichinose put out most of my favorites though, huh.
Hitomi Sato a best.
>>32402809
>>32402819
>sootopolis and route 113 by Go
guess we found the mastermind
>>32402858
>Mt Pyre Exterior
>Go Ichinose
More like Goat Ichinose
>>32402858
>can't remember the route 113 theme
>seraching in youtube
>there's a lot of commentaries shitting about some snowman theme rip off from Earthbound
>search the snowman theme
>both themes doesn't even are alike
???
>>32402965
this one is fun though
Konikoni City Night
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3XGaM5WLjxI
Message from Nightopia
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EGx4J5L5LZA
>>32402965
motherfags are autistic, I say this as a fan of the series
>>32402649
Best job was done by Minako Adachi, hands down: The route themes, team ether music etc.
>>32402649
Wow, holy fuck. I never knew how many of my least favourite SM tracks were made by Masuda. He's truly become the cancer killing/zombifying this franchise.
>>32402708
>Champion theme
The champion theme this generation is the most complex and well elaborated of all anon.
Also the Tapus theme and the E4 are good theme.
>never heard of Minako Adachi before
>did Skull themes, Aether themes, Malie city and Route 4
based
>>32402688
I had the same feeling and Sun and Mood made it more obvious. Compare the tracks and you can guess right his on the fly.