It is the truth. What is your objection to the idea that these

>>31426888
SoulS Gold is my favorite verdion

http://www.strawpoll.me/12123806/r

Sun and Moon are 3rd place.

You should add Emerald with Platinum. It looks weird seeing Pt all by it's self.

>>31426888
Trips of truth.

Platinum is shit. The post-game might be good but the region is pretty bland, Victory Road practically requires two dedicated HM slaves, everything is slow as fuck (health bars, saving, etc.), Team Galactic is pretty underwhelming, the main game is the most generic Pokémon experience there is, and they actually made some things from the previous generation worse (Hidden Bases, contests).
Replace it with Emerald.

>>31426888
Great taste, my nigga.

>>31426888
Yee

Honorable mentions to Emerald & BW

>>31426902
What is this meme? Sun and Moon are overhyped and dog shit.

>inb4 300 replies
Should be BW2, BW and SM, so it's not even right.

File: shofu.png (320KB, 1890x438px) Image search: [Google]

320KB, 1890x438px

>>31426940
/vp/ says otherwise

File: you nigger.png (134KB, 300x252px) Image search: [Google]

134KB, 300x252px

>>31426888
damn check me out.

>What is your objection to the idea that these are the three best Pokemon games?
That all of gen five and all of gen four should be up there, not just the sequels/third version.

>>31426939
>BW
BW was kinda ass in my opinion

You should have specified main series games.

PMD Sky is best.

>>31426944
>BW and SM
Get off my board, storyfag.

>>31426951
Is this the reason why the Sun and Moon circlejerk never ends? What the fuck??

Nintendo paying poketubers to shill their games

>>31426962
It's not for everyone definitely but that's one hell of a climax for a game

>>31426939
For some reason BW seems shit. I mean I did like the games but there is something about Black & White that makes it very off putting.

-I don't like replaying BW
-I don't like watching playthroughs of BW
What could be the reason for people disliking BW?

Is it the fact that it has an original dex?
Is it the animations in battle?
I cannot put my finger on it.

>>31426944
Abysmal taste.

>>31426993
"le honeymoon" phase
S&M was pretty mediocre
-it lacked post game
-the geographical nature of Alola was very different to other regions where cities and route were clearly defined.
For this reason the towns and routes don't seem memorable. I hate that Melemele is basically one circle of a route.

>>31426944
HGSS + Plt > BW & S&M

>>31427075
SM shouldn't be ranked anywhere near BW or BW2

>>31427014
I enjoyed BW too! I think they're some of the most solid first games. However, I think maybe it's due to the fact that BW2 exists. When people want to play Kanto, Johto, Hoenn and Sinnoh they don't play the first versions, they play the third/remakes. Idk, but just my two cents.

>>31427086
HGSS + Plt > BW >>>>>> S&M

>>31427014
I dont like playing it because of the overall atmosphere of the game. I loved playing it when I first got it, but now it's meh. I dont really have any memorable moments playing the game as I did with the others.

BW2 > HGSS = PLT = BW1 > E > SM = FRLG > GSC > RBY >>>>>>>>>> Dash > XY = ORAS

>>31427014
Graphics aren't appealing at all

and It's like rewatching a drama. I can understand your point but that doesn't take away from the quality

>>31427059
>it's different
>it's not memorable

Pick one

>>31427114
With the other games I can remember the shape of routes and towns, I can't remember the routes shapes for Alola

>>31427111
>B2W2 at the top
>SM that high
>Emerald that low

Wasted trips.

>>31426993
Or maybe, you know, people just like the game?

When I first bought Sun and Moon I was put off from playing it so much so that it is the longest I have taken to finish a Pokemon game.
-the cut scenes were so long and monotonous at the start
-a lot of the new Pokemon are sub 80 base speed shitmons

>>31427151
>B2W2 at the top
Yes

>SM that high
It's not that SM is high, it's just that the other games are too low

>Emerald that low
Swap BW1 with E if you want, the only thing that matters is that those top 5 games are the best of the franchise and that I enjoy spending my time with you in this board.

>>31427197
HGSS and Platinum really outclass B2W2

>>31426888
Trips confirm. Honorable mention to Emerald, SM shills need to fuck off asap.

>>31427210
>Pokemon World Championship
>Perfectly curated dex that combines 150 new pokemon with 150 old pokemon
>Only game with various dificulties, with the standard one being an actual challenge
>Memorable characters, interesting gym leaders

It's better than Platinum, that's for sure. Emerald should be the last one of the trio

Black and white 2 is laughable. Replace it with emerald and you are good.

>>31426888
Crystal, XY and SM for me.

>another gen/game war thread

Honestly, who cares. It really depends on what region is your favorite, what Pokemon is your favorite, etc etc. These threads are just pretty much
>you're having fun the wrong way
over and over again. God damn.

BW, BW2, and HGSS imo. Haven't played SM yet.

Pt, HGSS, and BW1 have my votes. BW2 is more polished than it's predecessors, but loses the freshness that made it great IMO.

File: Screenshot_2017-01-16-20-18-07-1.png (173KB, 1440x2292px) Image search: [Google]

173KB, 1440x2292px

>>31426888
what the fuck dude? the polls we've had all say that SM have replaced Platinum as /vp/s third favorite game.
>inb4 honeymoon phase
this has got to be the stupidest fucking meme I've ever read. ok. you want to talk about outside factors influencing people's opinions? how about NOSTALGIA. I cna guarantee that people's nolstalgia influences their choice of favorite game much more than "honeymoon phase" does. fuck off.

>>31426926
this

>>31427730
>honeymoon phase
For something that you claim is not real, you sure seem assblasted about it. Did Platinum kill your gf?

File: Screenshot_2017-01-17-15-42-12.png (199KB, 1440x2560px) Image search: [Google]

199KB, 1440x2560px

>>31427788
nice deflection faggot

>>31427464
Some people just like to argue with each other. So what?

>>31427111
Trips of truth. I'd put Plat over HGSS, just because in-game HGSS teams are hella weak

>>31426926
this

>>31426888
It's hard to argue with trips, but I'd personally put BW in place of Plat. I really like Gen 5.

>>31426888
HGSS shouldn't be there.It carries too many of the flaws of G/S/C.

>>31426902
recency bias

Drop HGSS already and put Emerald in there.
>muh following pokemon
>muh kanto
>m-muh red
>muh little gimmicks

>>31426888
I don't have an objection, this picture is right.
Even the numbers confirmed.

>>31428082
As opposed to
>Muh shittier region
>Muh shittier Frontier
???

>>31428091
>shittier region
well, uh technically, nah
>shittier frontier
nah, nah

>>31428081
You keep telling yourself that. Poketubers have already declared this is the best game in the series; Sun and Moon is not going anywhere but up.

>>31428112
technically.... yes and yes

>>31426888

Because HG/SS is mechanically ass.

>>31426905
I would argue the Platinum spot should be replaced with SM

File: Screenshot_2017-01-17-15-42-12-1.png (156KB, 1440x2065px) Image search: [Google]

156KB, 1440x2065px

>>31428430
it already did, but OP and the other Sinnohfetuses are too insecure about their shitty game being put down that they aggressively shitpost.

pic related was our most recent poll.

>>31426944
>HG/SS aren't in the top 3
Die in a dumpster fire.

>>31428121
>Poketubers have already declared this is the best game in the series
>Poketubers

Opinion discarded. I'd love to see if you'd still agree with them if your precious Poketubers claimed gens 1 or 6 was the best, you underage alolacuck.

>>31426940
>>31428081
>D-doesn't count!

>>31429655
>I'd love to see if you'd still agree with them if your precious Poketubers claimed gens 1 or 6 was the best

If they gave solid reasoning behind their support for choosing either RB or XY as their favourite Pokemon game, I might be inclined to agree.

You're just mad that poketubers can decide which Pokemon game is the best on behalf of the Pokemon community and there's nothing you can do about it.

>>31429752
>being so much of a sheep that you could literally be influenced to change your opinion just because someone's popular

I honestly can't even be mad at you SM shills anymore. Oy vey, my friend.

>>31426888
That's a really good taste. Personally I'd switch HGSS for GSC and Platinum for Emerald.

>>31426888
Emerald is better than Platinum and HG/SS are overrated as fuck, so just put them in Platinum's space. B2/W2 can stay. So it's Emerald, Platinum, B2W2

>>31426902
>>31428430
>>31429366

They're both at 15 now, the quiz isn't even decent because there's not a big enough sample size and SM just came out a few months ago

>>31426888
Couldn't STAND Platinum.

>>31430304
Me neither. I think ti was the HMs, especially defog.

>best Pokémon game
>anything but Pokémon mystery dungeon: blue rescue team
played that game to total completion back in the day, recruited everything worthwhile (including kecleon)

>>31426902
It's still in the honeymoon phase.

>>31426888
Sinnoh is dogshit. Platinum doesn't deserve to be on there.

I found B2W2 boring. First time I've actually put down a Pokémon game without bothering to finish post-League exploration.

>>31427111
This sounds about right.

Why is ORAS bad? Seriously?

I loved it. They went all out with it, and it shows.

>>31432600
/vp/ is still mad about the "no battle frontier" thing.

ExWai > SuMo >>>>> OmRuAlSa > BlaTsuWhiTsu > BlaWhi > Em > HaGoSoSi > RuSa > Pla > DiPe > FiReLeGre > SoDoSoPa > GoSi > Cry > BluRe > Ye

>>31429752
This is the first too bait I've seen in weeks. Legitimately fuck off

>>31434270
>bumping a thread last bumped 4 hours ago to tell someone to fuck off
??

>>31426902
Not anymore

>>31427075
>>31427095
>>31427111
HGSS = Platinum = Emerald = BW2 > RS = DP = FRLG = BW > GSC > XY = ORAS > RGBY = SM

>>31434410
>>31432469
>>31427891
>>31427111
>people being this butthurt over gen 6

ORAS is automatically above RS, and both it and XY are almost certainly objectively ahead of GSC and RBY just due to the quality of life and general improvements the series has had over the years.

>>31428081
>>31431800
>>31426888
>The fucking denial
You were some living grain of salt outta the last thread weren't you OP?

>>31429560
>HG/SS in the top 3
Opinion discarded

>>31426905
lolno. Hoennbabies nostalgia kicking in right there

File: 1483755444520.jpg (719KB, 1308x1700px) Image search: [Google]

719KB, 1308x1700px

>Hoennbabies
A reminder to get a load of this and know your place as the gen that killed the Pokemon fad.

I actually agree OP
Honorable mentions to SM and BW I played Emerald and it doesn't feel good as SM/HGSS/BW2.

>>31435559
>bumping a thread after 2 hours

>>31434797
This has to be bait. This is absolutely without a doubt retarded. Anyone who thinks "Gen 1 and/or 2 are superior to another" have a chromosomal disorder. The games in Gen 1&2 have been outclassed by remakes.

>>31426888
>No Emerald

Make this a Diamond and I'll agree with you

>>31426888

gen 5 is garbage, swap it with emerald

>>31426888
but anon, each pokemon games are the best. It is only a matter of preference for each person which defines what it is

>>31434797
Have a (You) my good friend.

>>31435593

This is my full list
>>31435287

>>31434797

It was dead by the time crystal came out. Nobody had or cared about crystal.

B2W2, Platinum and Emerald.

SM aren't very good. HGSS is overrated as fuck.

>HGSS
>follower Pokemon
>muh comfy
Shit games.

>>31426888
I don't think Pokémon had enough good games to make a trinity. HGSS and BW2 are definitely there for me but I can't say there is another game which is at comparable level.

File: 1468850721880.jpg (704KB, 3686x1752px) Image search: [Google]

704KB, 3686x1752px

>>31427142
Because the routes in the other games are a bunch of straight lines thrown together. The towns were fucking garbage though, I agree.

File: 13347852194514.png (588KB, 781x836px) Image search: [Google]

588KB, 781x836px

>>31434797
>Muh Hoenn killed Pokemon meme
Actually, there was a bigger fall-off in sales from Gen 1 to Gen 2 then there was from Gen 2 to Gen 3, so it's a FACT that Gen 2 was were the series began losing it's popularity. Deal with it Johtoddler.

>>31426888
I didn't like HG.
Also gen 4 is very difficult to go back to after 5, it feels really "dead."

>>31426926
Platinum cock sucking should really stop
the game is fucking average, people like it only for nostalgia