Considering it's the least liked gen among normies, will

>>30805953
Not just that - It has the distinct problem of being a 2-part series making it difficult to remake even if it was liked by normies.

they will remake them. the games made lots of money and remakes are an easy way to make even more money.

>>30805971
>both Parts in one game, meaning Other Character could be in the second part and it would have more post game than Gen 2

>>30805991

>the games made a lot of money

They were the worst selling Pokemon games.

>>30805971
I would imagine it could be a 2-part remake in one game. Not sure how they would pull it off though. Could be interesting.

Remakes happen to pander to nostalgiafags

The DS games brought in the least amount of new fans to the series

>>30806007
NOPE, just BW3

>>30805991
>the games made lots of money
Literally the worst selling Pokemon generation. Even XY has outsold BW despite the sales of DS being over twice as much as the sales of 3DS.

>>30805971
They Can just ignore the second part, not that big of a deal. Like they didnt implement Emerald Story in ORAS, they will probably just do something similar to the Delta Episode.
However by the time BW are suitable for a remake it will pass so much time is impossibile to predict anything.

>>30806092
>Literally the worst selling Pokemon generation

But that's because there was no remake in 5th gen. There was only BW and BW2.

>>30806008
Still a lot of money there

>>30806008
You say that like a Pokemon game that sells less than the others doesn't sell a lot regardless.
>>30805953
Why don't normies like these games anyway? Is it just because muh genwun?

>>30806092
XY sold a lot more for several reasons, chief among those being the 3D jump and being the first Pokemon game on the 3DS itself (which was sorely lacking for games for quite a while).

Meanwhile BW had little genwun pandering, was released at the tail-end of the DS' lifetime, and tried something different than the others.

>>30807088
Gen VI also had just two games, XY and ORAS. Didn't stop them from outselling their predecessors.

>>30807191
>was released at the tail-end of the DS' lifetime
>tried something different than the others
By that logic, S/M should have performed like shit.
Though I do admit Go's success kind of makes S/M harder to judge.

>>30806008
>They were the worst selling Pokemon games.

Objectively the worst selling pokemon game is crystal

>>30807363
SM has a lot of success behind it due to marketing, Pokemon Go, and (again) another graphical jump.

I don't recall BW being as heavily marketed as XY and SM.

>>30805953
>will this be the only gen to not get remakes?
Eh, Gen 4 is actively hated and ignored among the fanbase so I'd say that won't get a remake.

>>30807418
>Gen 4 is actively hated and ignored among the fanbase

(You)

>>30807434
Dude, it's literally the lowest regarded game.

>>30805953
The Smugleaf meme was bigger than the this-entire-gen-sucks-because-of-a-few-objectmons meme, right?

>>30807455
Gen 4 made pokemon "hot" again
If theres a moment that was slept on it was gen3

>>30807413
Not to mention the fact it had the anniversary behind it.
And didn't follow up the worst gen yet, 4.

>>30807004
It's already been 6 years since B/W, dude.

Sounds crazy, but we're closer to a remake than we are farther from one at this point.

>>30807489
>Gen 4 made pokemon "hot" again
Eh, not really. I wouldn't say selling a paltry 1m more than the previous generation on a vastly more popular system is "hot" by any stretch of the imagination.

>If theres a moment that was slept on it was gen3
That's when Pokemon started to come back after Pokemania dropped about mid gen 2.

>>30807578
Pokemon's lowest point in popularit was gen 3

>>30807603
Again that's like mid gen 2. Pretty much every part of the franchise was going downhill from the merch sales to the anime ratings.
The anime in particular was a big driving force in the west.

>>30807603
Gen V, actually. Stay triggered :)

File: tumblr_mme1kdfL9D1qdgi63o1_500.png (225KB, 496x375px) Image search: [Google]

225KB, 496x375px

Gen 5 doesnt need to be remade because its already perfect
though I wont rule out GF doing some BW3 bullshit

>>30807489
>gen 4 made Pokemon hot again
What fucking world do YOU live in?

>>30807684
>He says it, without any data to back up his claims
Stay triggered :)

>>30807156

"Genwun" is a meme invented by butthurt genfivers over the fact that so many people didn't like their games.

>>30807767
Why not BW0?
With some Young Xehanort in BBS bullshit with your mom fighting Hilbert/Hilda's future self

>>30807845
>nostalgiafags are now a meme
have we come full circle yet

>>30805971
>2 part
I try to pretend the second part doesn't exist

>>30807845
>This is what genwunners actually believe

File: image.png (177KB, 501x506px) Image search: [Google]

177KB, 501x506px

>>30807845
>people actually believe this

>>30807845
It was already a thing in gen 4

>>30807845
Genwunners sure are the cancer of this franchise.

>>30807874
>>30807906

>everyone loves Platinum
>everyone loves HG/SS
>Gen V hits
>it's shit
>Gen VI hits
>everyone loves X/Y
>nobody like OR/AS but that's because Hoenn is shit too
>Gen VII hits
>everyone loves S/M
>m-m-m-muh genwunners

Unova is right down there at the bottom of the heap with Hoenn. Dejected shit regions that nobody likes.

>>30808005
>everyone loves Platinum
Funny joke. Fucking nobody I knew liked anything in gen 4 except for HGSS and that was because it was a remake of GSC.

>>30808005
>everyone loves X/Y
Maybe in Bizarro World.

File: 1481705114793.png (184KB, 359x255px) Image search: [Google]

184KB, 359x255px

>>30808005
>Everyone loves X/Y
>Evoryone hates Gen V
anon...do you even browse /vp/?

>>30808005
>>everyone loves Platinum
>>everyone loves HG/SS
Eh, Platinum wasn't regarded this highly regarded until about last year. In fact when it was revealed people hated the fact that the BF was downgraded as fuck and wasn't the Emerald version. It was a fun time on /v/ when those leaks came.
Not to mention the fact that it barely tried to fix DP.

HGSS is highly regarded solely because of nostalgia rather than the actual merits of the game.

>>30806015
New protags called Natebert and Rosalda who go through both parts of the story?

File: 1440827007496.jpg (57KB, 600x600px) Image search: [Google]

57KB, 600x600px

>>30807845
jokes on you, genwunners are a fucking thing. Literally everyone at my job (yeah shitty retail job) that has played pokemon with the exception of one, all bitch about ice cream and trashbag. Even in the new games. They also eat up shit like GO and I've one of them talk about "I'm so glad it's only the original 150"

and they never shut up about trashbag and ice cream. goddamn that shit is so fucking annoying.

File: IMG_1065.png (28KB, 507x565px) Image search: [Google]

28KB, 507x565px

>>30808005

File: 131178569135166663.png (99KB, 244x357px) Image search: [Google]

99KB, 244x357px

>>30808203

>unovabortions actually defending trashbag and icecream

>>30808267
Trashbags for New York so well though

They need to take Trash out everyday there. Pretty disgusting tbqh

>>30807390
Nope, it is Emerald.

File: 1480683097414.png (777KB, 777x777px) Image search: [Google]

777KB, 777x777px

>>30808267
>actually defending a pile of goo and a pokemon ball flipped upside down

>>30808267
I'm not defending it. but when the only bad thing people have to say about new pokemon is "trashbag and ice cream" it's basically saying "my head is too far up my own ass to actually try something out, I'm just gonna bandwagon hate it because that's hip"

File: 569.png (1KB, 96x96px) Image search: [Google]

1KB, 96x96px

>>30808267
They're cute, kill yourself

>>30808005
You don't go out and talk with other nerds much, do you? Most people disliked XY.

>>30808397
XY are normie games, buddy. They're generally well liked outside of contrarian shitholes.

>>30808300
Emerald is a classic

>>30808417
>normies
>giving a shit about anything but Kanto and Johto

>>30808417
Yeah, they're liked

But they're shitty normie iPhone tier games

And that's what the devolpers were going for iPhone tier shit

>>30808417
Even normies can see X and Y's terrible flaws

>>30807156
>didn't realize people hated gen V
>some of my friends get back into Pokemon thanks to GO and SM
>most of them say that their last game was Black/White and it killed their interest in the series or that their last game was HGSS and they didn't even try BW
>tfw I really liked gen V because it was the first gen to mix up the formula in any meaningful way

>>30808433
It's also the worst selling

>>30808543
Sold twice as much as Crystal

>>30808555
Nigga, what?
Not even your trips can make your post be real.

File: 1481394120862.png (16KB, 238x224px) Image search: [Google]

16KB, 238x224px

>>30808538
I think it's because they didn't really have any old mons that would appeal to them more. It's probably why GF has been so scared to go more than 70+ mons a region besides the fact that we've got nearly 800 mons.

>>30808588
This is so fucking stupid. Did people seriously not get sick of fucking Zubat, Tentacool, and Geodude after 4 fucking gens in a row with them?

File: kekhelmet.jpg (26KB, 360x360px) Image search: [Google]

26KB, 360x360px

>>30808176
>natebert

>>30808417
This
Normies thought it was cute that the game gave you a group of friends instead of a real rival and normies liked being overleveled by 10 levels at all times and using OP megas to crush everything

>>30808588
Not him but Gen 5 was technically the most like gen 1 in terms of a new world to explore. It hurts my head

>>30808830

>make 150 Pokemon, the majority of which are worse than the old Pokemon
>WHY DOESN'T ANYBODY LIKE IT?

>>30807455
That's easily all of Gen 5 though. Do you not go outside /vp/?

>the majority of which are worse than the old pokemon
maybe like 20% are legit terrible. the rest range from passable to great

File: 1481151525637.jpg (51KB, 310x288px) Image search: [Google]

51KB, 310x288px

>>30808892
>Not liking some of the most based designs in the series since Gen III
(you)

>>30808892
>make 150 pokemon
>most of which are ignored because people are too assblasted about three of them

>>30808908
>Do you not go outside /vp/?
Yes, and gen 4 still gets the least recognition and when it does it's mostly a strong dislike.

Just look at how it's anniversary turned out. On one of Pokemon's biggest years at that.

>>30808892
I'd rather take 150 brand new Pokemon over 80ish new ones with one third of them being forms of gen 1 Pokemon.

>>30809028
Not to mention most of the mon in SM are straight up trash to use too.

>>30808417
This.
Funnily enough XY's fanbase is starting to grow now that SM is out simply because of how SM removed nearly all of the QoL changes from the two prior gens.

>>30808975
>Gen 4
>least recognition
>when HGSS is in Gen 4

Unless you're one of those retards that don't count remakes as part of their respective generation, then yes, Gen 5 is still lower than Gen 4 in how the fanbase views it.

So we can all agree that a perfect game would be something like SM but with B2W2's postgame and XY's QoL changes, yeah?

>>30809141
So, BW2 with a C-Gear that works online?

File: Untitled.png (12KB, 688x232px) Image search: [Google]

12KB, 688x232px

>>30808555

>>30809141
I could go with that.

>>30807845
That te was around long before gen 5, but here's your (you).

>>30809205
*term
fuck

>>30808306
This. If you seriously condemn an entire gen just because of a few Pokemon designs you really need to get over yourself.

>>30809105
Pretty sure it's the same autistic retard who thinks his opinion is shared by everyone in the rest of the community

Its already had remakes.

>>30809187
No, because B2W2 isn't as good as BW.

File: 1454979895413.png (50KB, 400x400px) Image search: [Google]

50KB, 400x400px

>>30807418
SHUT THE FUCK UP /VP/ IS SUPPOSED TO BE MY GEN 4 SAFE SPACE WHERE WE IGNORE ANY CRITICISMS!!

>>30809237
Wouldn't that mean he's a sinnoh nut then?

>>30809252
Eh, story wise it's worse.
Every other area it's better.
Just throw in the breeding changes and hordes and you have the perfect game.

I don't see much point in remaking it. The only touch up it really needs is the massive reduction in barriers to make competitive shit that 6th gen brought.

>>30809028
Pokemon by Generation:
- 151
- 100
- 135
- 107
- 156
- 72
- 81
Pokemon by base form's debut:
- 182
- 94
- 140
- 78
- 156
- 71
- 81

As you can see, a lot of Pokemon track to Kanto, and Sinnoh added a lot of new evolutions. It's still has more Pokemon than Kalos, though.

File: 131169904539031510.jpg (69KB, 750x750px) Image search: [Google]

69KB, 750x750px

>>30809255

>genfivers in full damage control

>>30808397
Look who's talking. If you went somewhere else aside from /vp/, you would know XY are simply praised by normies which btw, newsflash Pokemon is a normie game.

>>30809255
Strawmanning won't make your taste less shit, anon.

>>30809286
things BW1 did better than BW2
>story (Team Plasma kind of factors into this also)
>Ghetsis
>Victory Road Badge Gate
>protag designs
I think that is it. I still kinda prefer BW1 because of these things anyway tho

>>30809306
>genfivers in full damage control
>when the post is replying to an anti-gen 4 post
what?

>>30809264
I'm talking about the guy who believes that everyone hates gen 4 since he does too

This is tragic because generation 3 was the most middling mediocre generation in the series (I'm talking RSE, not FRLG) and it got remakes

Gen 5 had polish. Polish is pretty much all that can make a Pokemon game memorable. It's not like any of the games are grossly unbalanced / ugly / break the mold significantly

>>30809398
>gen 3 is the most middling mediocre generation in the series
Do people seriously believe this or are you jumping on the meme bandwagon where it's cool to hate gen 3 just because?

>>30809398
actually I take this back XY is ugly but it's an exception

>>30809416
It was the most generic, least interesting game that brought very little to the series.
Also I personally don't like many of the gen 3 designs, I hate the color schemes. Everything is either too saturated or too desaturated (Manectric is disgusting)

>>30809465
>Manectric is disgusting
This is how I know you're retarded.

>>30809394
He's not exactly wrong.
Aside from Lucario and obvious Cynthia fap bait not many people care for gen 4.

Also I just have to point out the irony of your posts.
You're pretty much getting mad at him because you like gen 4 and think the rest of the community likes it too.

>>30807504
without any dp/plat remake? Sounds far fetched

>>30809465
>least interesting game that brought very little to the series.
I know there seems to be people defending it heavily at the moment but that falls to 4 where the only thing of note it brought to the table was the split.
3 set up the foundation of modern pokemon games as well as adding new and important features like Natures, Abilities and Double Battles as well as an IV checker.

>>30809497
>Manectric is not disgusting
and that's how we know you're retarded

>>30809498
My only posts about gen 4 in this thread were >>30809237 and >>30809394. I never claimed that everyone liked it.

>>30809340
BW1 still has my favorite story in the series. SM came close but didn't quite top it. Probably because I liked Lillie enough but I didn't waifu her

File: 1478669405094.png (157KB, 445x604px) Image search: [Google]

157KB, 445x604px

>>30805953
>The only reason why anyone is going to want gen 5 remakes in the future is because gamefreak forgot to put a champion ribbon or any new ribbon at all in unova

while most gen 5 desingns are shit, the story and the battles were really good and i collect ribbons to remember those moments

>>30809605
>I never claimed that everyone liked it.
You don't have to say it outright. Your tone tells it all.

>>30809386
>not knowing what false flagging is

File: 1463977524346.png (10KB, 84x178px) Image search: [Google]

10KB, 84x178px

>tfw everyone talks shit about the vanillite line
>No one remembers the fucking monkies

There's a reason Simisear got dead last

>>30808975
Did any gen besides the first two get any recognition at all (and gen 2 only did because their remakes happened to come exactly 10 years later)? I don't think that's a quantifiable way to judge how much recognition a generation receives.

>>30809676

Fucking hell I did forget about them. And those pieces of shit got thrown at you more often than Magikarp.

>It's another three elemental monkies trainer

File: CwUTINeUoAENWNp.jpg (49KB, 680x840px) Image search: [Google]

49KB, 680x840px

>>30809632
I feel like the SM story dropped the ball after the raid on the Aether Paradise. Storming that place fighting Aether and Skull grunts and then Lusamine at the end was some of the most fun I had in this series since gen 5.
But fighting Ultra Beast Lusamine in Ultra Space was just a let down, especially since it wasn't really ur problem and you were just going there for Lillie sorting out her family issues

>>30809682
>Did any gen besides the first two get any recognition at all
I don't think you understand.
DP's anniversary was this year and it went completely under the radar despite Pokemon being in the limelight.

>>30809676
The monkeys had the same problem the genies did; one was fine, they didn't need to make three of them. Simisage actually isn't a bad design at all IMO so it would've been just fine if it was just him and Pansage. The others are awful though.

>>30809737
What happened for RS's anniversary?

>>30809749
The height of "REMAKE WHEN" and "THIS WAS MY CHILDHOOD" and so on.

>>30809465
>most generic, least interesting
>brought little to the series
I thought you just had shit taste but turns out you're an actual braindead moron instead.

>>30809676
If it wasn't for his shit stats simisage would be perfect

Aipom ambipom and all the infernape line are on my top favorite pokemon

But for some reason i can only like Simisage, we really didn't need the other 2 specialy hot monkay dik, since we already had a fire monkey

>>30809655
Nah, your just putting words in his mouth. It's amazing how you've come up to that conclusion

>>30809872
>It's amazing how you've come up to that conclusion
What do you expect with someone who's getting mad because 4 isn't popular?
Just this post alone >>30809237 is him assuming everyone that dislikes it is samefagging.

>>30809655
I literally never said that though. I just disagreed with your theory that since you dislike it everyone agrees with you. That has nothing to do with whether people like it or not, which I don't know.

>>30809931
I was talking about you, not everyone who dislikes it.

>>30805953
>will this be the only gen to not get remakes

God I hope so, it'll mean I'll only go 2 years without buying the next game instead of 3

I liked Gens IV and V a lot and feel like they were a good place for the games' stories (not too barebones like I-III or too railroady like VI and VII)

>>30807336
ya but 2 of them were remakes