See a lot of confusion on this.
The islands are as follows from west to east:
Pony
Melemele
Akala
Ula'ula
Melemele is the first we visit. Akala is the second.
We now have to agree on what we mean by "second island". Is it Melemele or Akala? Same goes for first, third and fourth island.
>Pony
It's Poni
>>29565459
Of course. I'm very sorry.
>>29565329
Akala is second.
Third is Ula'ula
Fourth is Poni
>>29565329
Melemele -> Akala -> Ula'ula -> Poni -> freedom (aka postgame)
Mele Mele is the fist island because you fucking start your game there.
The next island you can travel to is Akala, so it's the second island.
End of story.
In Ocarina of time, the first dungeon is the Great Deku Tree, not the westernmost dungeon on the world map, for fuck's sake.
>>29565602
I think he meant the fact that people keep mistaking the island names for each other.
>>29565623
This. And also some people claiming "the island with the lighthouse" is the third island when it's akala.
Unless there is a lighthouse on ula'ula or poni which i didn't see