Out of the three remakes we've had so far, which one was

Objectively it was HGSS. I'd rank them HGSS > FRLG > ORAS, but none of them are particularly "bad". ORAS obviously was missing Emerald content, FRLG had the postgame, and HGSS had the most content, along with little things like the extra routes, Pokeathlon, Lati@s Battle, Sinjoh Ruins, Battle Frontier, etc.

Yeah, HGSS strictly because I'm a sucker for turning around and checking up on my Pokemon.

HGSS are literally the best Pokemon games ever made

>>28604442
ORAS wasn't bad because it didn't include Emerald content, it was bad because it included XY content.

File: 1467442817643.jpg (144KB, 1066x800px) Image search: [Google]

144KB, 1066x800px

holy FUCK hgss is hard to play through
it's not even that it's challenging, it's just slow as fuck. was the rest of gen 4 this slow? I remember having a better time with this game.

>>28606963

Platinum is better paced, it's the best game of Gen IV due to polishment but HGSS is great anyways.