I've seen some really shitty opinions on this board so let's settle this shit once and for all. Who is the best alchemist of Arland?
http://www.strawpoll.me/13899594
Totori is my wife!
>tfw no cake rorona
>>389821091
Your wife is a hussy and gets ravaged by dykes.
>>389820920
>all even
4 of you have shit taste. The other Meruru guy is a bro.
>>389820920
t-tummy...
Astrid is objectively the best alchemist of Arland.
Rorona is the most likable alchemist of Arland.
Totori is the cutest alchemist of Arland.
Meruru hasthe best gameof Arland.
Totori isn't just the best alchemist, she's the best girl. Of all time.
>>389821871
I'm genuinely surprised that there was actually more than one solitary Merurufag all this time.
>>389822545
I mean, they're all great, but I spent the most time with Meruru. Plus she's the cutest.
Someone give me the quick rundown on these games.
>>389820920
Rorona > Meruru > Totori
Applies to both characters and games.
>>389822651
You're trying to save a shop in Rorona, trying to find your mom in Totori, and trying to save your kingdom in Meruru. Each game has the previous protagonist as their mentor, and they're all about cute girls doing alchemy and making friends in the process.
>>389822651
gather materials to bend the very fabric of space and time to create things with the power of gods!!!
Plus other cute things.
>>389822651
You play as a cute alchemist that can craft items and go on adventures with other party members. The Arland games all have specific time-based deadlines that you must keep track of, and because of that they tend to be a lot more open-ended than other JRPGs.
Meruru is the cutest and has the best theme
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BxZUlO_PLYE
>>389820920
Astrid ruined everything before Dusk. The fact that she gets away with doing all the shit she does makes it seem like she's the pet character of Gust.
Meruru was the best.
Rorona was spunky but also borderline retarded.
Totori was too much of a pushover.
Meruru was cute and spunky without being too stupid and also knew when to take charge,
>>389820920
>assturd
>>389823123
I liked Meruru but she was a hair too genki for my tastes.
>>389823123
Rorona was an airhead but they all kind of were.
I never got into any of the atelier games except Meruru. Probably because it's clear what you should be doing, and there is noticeable progression or something? I don't know but after trying out the Arland trilogy and a bit of Escha, Meruru is the only one I actually finished
>>389823123
Totori has sidekick syndrome
We can all agree Sterk is the best husbando right
>>389823308
Rorona and Escha & Logy are pretty clear in what your goals are each month. It's Totori, and to a lesser extent Ayesha and Shallie, that are less directed.
>>389823167
>Not liking genki girls
>>389823308
Meruru combines the objective-based focus of Rorona and the open-ended exploration of Totori. The former keeps you on a bit of a leash with its time constraints while the latter drops you in the world with basically no guiding narrative until you're halfway through the game. Meruru takes the best of both games and finds a happy balance between them.
>>389822479
Patrician of the highest caliber.
>>389823501
Didn't say all that, just that she was a bit too genki for my tastes. You can blame Tomo from Azumanga Daioh for any apprehension I have on the matter as I found her quite annoying.
>>389823332
In Arland, maybe. Best in general is obviously Juris.
Astrid has the best skills by a mile
Rorona (Totori ver.) is the best of the playable three
>>389823610
>Not liking Tomo
You and I are enemies now.
>>389822651
JRPGs that are focused on highly intricate item creation systems and decent combat with lots of item use. Gameplay is usually structured around completing goals within a time frame. Stories are pretty laid back. Soundtracks are god tier.
>>389823123
Meruru was way dumber than Rorona, though.
>>389823869
Yeah, I was always more of a Sakaki guy. Guess we just like different types.
>>389823645
No way fag, best Dusk boy didn't even get an ending. I'm still mad.
>>389823984
>liking that fag more than best manly specimen Juris
I might've been able to maybe comprehend if you said that old alchemist dude, but Kyle? C'mon man.
>>389823610
I liked Tomo a lot when I first watched Azumanga 10 years ago. I watched it again earlier this year and I couldn't stand her. Back then I also thought Sakaki was best girl, but now it has to be Osaka.
>>389824063
Kyle was a total bro to Juris and a charming hunk of man to Ayesha. What's not to like?
>>389824167
Kyle couldn't even keep poor Juris company for a nice drink. How depressing!
>>389824069
Osaka's always been a delight but I'll always be about dat Sakaki.
Sterk is best boy
How will Merurufags ever recover?
>Detected possible malicious code in image file.
What.
>>389824424
>4 faggots actually voted for Astrid
>>389824510
The question wasn't which Arland I liked the most but which one is the best alchemist. Astrid could outclass Rorona, Totori and Meruru in alchemy 3v1.
>>389824510
Best alchemist means the best at alchemy, not best person, most fuckable, best design, etc
Meruru is my wife
>>389824604
How can she be your wife when she's my wife?
>>389824670
How can she be your wife when she's everyone's wife?
>>389823610
Wtf is a genki?
>>389824838
hyperactive
>>389824838
Lurk for two years before posting.
>>389824934
Just 2 year retard? Is hat your standard retard?
>>389824167
Ayesha a cute.
>>389825012
>2 year
>hat
>>389825075
Wtf is an anime?
>>389824838
Googling the term and using a little common sense on the first page would get you your answer.
>>389825012
>>389825368
But i am a retard. How could i possibly have common sense?
>>389824167
Best Dusk boy in that picture is clearly Ernie.
>>389825507
If you have that much self-awareness then I believe in your ability to use an internet search engine.
I intend to pick up a PSVita someday and play the older games, but I've never played an Atelier game before and I noticed that there're two newer ones on Steam.
They don't seem to get much love though. Will I be ruining myself if I play them first? It could be awhile before I pick up a Vita.
>>389825732
Atelier is for fapping not playing
>>389825732
I've only played sophie from the new trilogy but it was by far worse than the arland trilogy. They cut a few mechanics, made the progression in the game a joke and was generally just worse. If you've never played the series it might leave a bad taste in your mouth but if you plan on playing the others anyways then you can try it out.
>>389825530
I don't believe that anyone actually likes Ernie. His only notable trait is how boring he is.
>>389825732
Yes, the two games on Steam suck, wait until you get your Vita, then start with either Ayesha+ or Rorona+, because both of those games are great.
>>389825954
Spoken like a true boring beta
>>389825732
Sophie is a good game if you aren't an Atelier fan.Its basically a relaxing version of Recettear where instead of selling goods you collect in a shop, you use those goods you collected to make things as part of quests.
Meruru is the best.
Even Astrid says she's surpassed her already.
Best alchemist and best game.
>>389827585
Post prove
>>389827623
Don't have a screenshot. Not sure if the Potion if Youth needs to be initiated but if you talk to Astrid before you go to the castle on the final day she says Meruru has already surpassed her.
>>389825732
atelier fans seem to dislike sophie and firis
I've never played firis but sophie is very good imo. The only other ateliers I've tried before were totori and ayesha but I didn't like either of them
>>389825530
HOT DAMN.
Ernie fucks.
FUCK atelier. Worse than nep.
I don't want to finish Rorona Plus because then there will be no more Arland.
>>389832320
You take that back you son of a bitch.
>>389832493
What about Totori-chan and Meruru-chan. Why did you hate them?
>>389832618
I've already played them. I mean more specifically the post game content of Rorona Plus.
What I want to know is whether Meruru still has the time limit like Totori had.
I sorta fucked up and forgot to make the Boat since I went a bit battle crazy and its killed my motivation to replay the game.
>>389833120
I dont remember but yes? It was honestly a moot point though. The time was so lenient it might as well not exist.
>>389833304
So it was more lenient than Totoris or am I just literally retarded that I hit the time limit for Totori?
>>389833425
Yes. Unless you are the type that just spending times doing literally nothing. The only strict one is Rorona. I dont really remember about Meruru but if it exist it certainly more lenient than Totori, since i never bothered thinking about time limit in that game.
>>389833425
You're a bit retarded, yes.