>Classic Shadow is introduced into the Classic Universe
>Sonic keeps the Drop Dash while Shadow is given the Insta-Shield
Would this be a good compromise?
With the option of changing the moves in Mania this wouldn't even be neccessary
I'd be down for Shadow using different shield abilities though
>>387511653
Is there really no way to use the optional moves during a saved-game playthrough?
>>387510963
No, Shadow should just use guns.
>>387510963
Shadow should have stayed dead at the end of SA2.
What could you even use the insta-shield for? Always seemed useless to me.
>>387512569
Then who would be Sonic's rival? Knuckles is a full-time good guy and Metal Sonic is a full-time bad guy.
>>387512617
It extends the hurtbox of your jump, you can abuse the fuck out of it against the Carnival Night 2 boss, also it makes you go through shit like the orbital's spike, it's easily the most broken thing in Sonic 3
>>387510963
Shadow has way too much baggage as a character to fit into an official classic-style Sonic game. Also the insta-shield is mostly useless.
>>387512906
>Also the insta-shield is mostly useless.
>>387512754
>it's easily the most broken thing in Sonic 3
I think you may just be using it wrong
>>387512742
Why does it even need a rival?
>>387512742
Who gives a shit about having a rival? Even with Shadow there Sonic mostly just bounces from game to game doing new things with new characters. Ever since he's been brought back he hasn't had the role of a rival at all.
no
Shadow has no point in existing when Knuckles was always a better Shadow. Keep Shadow contained in your boostshit
>>387513137
Shadow > Knuckles.
>>387513185
If you're 13 and still listen to Linkin Park.
>>387513075
Because the potential of a rival fight is limitless
>>387513137
>tfw no Knuckles with the hat
I'd rather have that then Shadow
>>387513034
I use it on bosses just to speed them up, but bosses are already piss-easy. Hearing someone call the instashield "broken" as if it's some huge big deal of a move is hilarious to me.
>>387513137
but Shadow is way more fun to play as than Knuckles in any game where they're together.
>>387512906
Given how hard they're trying to push Classic Sonic as an alternate world rather than just a past one, this would be a good time to sort of re-launch Shadow as a character.
Maybe instead of being an alien hybrid from space, he's just a normal, grumpy hedgehog.
T. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tQMEAh5rhsc
>>387513427
But Knuckles in non-Shadow games is more fun than all of Shadow's gameplay.
>>387512617
It's good for hitting enemies with spiked defenses and not much else.
>>387510963
You can unlock the Insta-Shield in Mania though.