Elemental damage: >Fire >Water/Ice >Wind/Lightning >Earth

>>385940571
>What's the 4th physical damage type,
Tearing.

>4th damage type
Emotional.
>Why is earth considered elemental instead of physical?
Because it's a fucking element.

>>385940571
Fourth physical should be bashing, like hand to hand combat. Light and Dark can be Matter/Antimatter

File: 1396047709938.gif (294KB, 190x190px) Image search: [Google]

294KB, 190x190px

>>385940792
>summon a rock
>bash an enemy with it
>"earth" damage instead of crushing damage

>>385940810
Same as crushing.

>>385940810
>Fourth physical should be bashing, like hand to hand combat.
That's crushing.

Slapping

>>385940571
Fire changes, Earth crushes, Wind tears and Water suffocates.

There. Fuck your thunder bullshit.

STEP THE FUCK BACK :

Elemental damage:
-Fire/Plasma
-Wind/Pressure
-Water/Ice
-Earth/Magnetism

Entropic damage:
-Dark/Chaos
-Light/Pure
-Death/Decay
-Life/Growth

>>385941097
>thunder
Anything but crushing damage

>>385940889
>>385940969
Crushing is mace/hammer
Smash is unarmed or a club like weapon

>>385941097
So... burning damage, crushing damage, slashing damage, and... suffocating damage?

>>385940896
>>385940969
I thought of crushing as having something on the other side of the force of impact, i.e. crushing someone under your foot with the earth underneath them to assist with an opposite force. Bashing being more horizontal with nothing on the other side of the victim.

>>385941228
>Crushing is mace/hammer
You forgot Love

>>385940571
>Nipple twisting damage

>>385940571

4th phys damage type would be either bleed or percussive. Different from crushing in that it doesn't harm the surface of the body, but it disrupts organ function.

File: 1342908090649.jpg (48KB, 529x700px) Image search: [Google]

48KB, 529x700px

>>385941175
>Life damage

File: 1360179144996.png (3KB, 168x141px) Image search: [Google]

3KB, 168x141px

>>385940571
>light and dark are both strong and weak against each other

File: 1392011971892.png (100KB, 250x250px) Image search: [Google]

100KB, 250x250px

Daily reminder that the most superior classical element combination is earth, water, fire, air. Any other sub element can be derived from these 4.

Air produces lightning, earth produces grass/plant/etc, water produces ice, and so on.

File: CantSpellGoodWithoutGod.jpg (68KB, 748x343px) Image search: [Google]

68KB, 748x343px

>>385941228
>A mace or hammer is a different damage type than a club

>>385941358
>bleed
That's a status effect, caused by slashing.
Piercing reduces/ignores armor, crushing stuns.

>>385941404
if they are both defensively weak to their opposite, then they are both offensively strong to their opposite.

>>385941275
this is the dumbest post ive read in a while

>>385941228
You can literally reach identical fucking results with a fist-shaped hammer that you would with your fist, if you punch hard enough.

File: spank.webm (3MB, 1000x562px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 1000x562px

>>385940571
>fire is strong against earth

File: 1300044776986.jpg (17KB, 250x250px) Image search: [Google]

17KB, 250x250px

>>385941371
>not killing your enemies by growing tumors inside them

>>385941547
Explain

>>385940571
>and why is earth considered elemental damage instead of physical
"Earth" also covers Nature type abilities involving pure life-force, solar energy and forest spirits. Just as how Water and Ice are physical things and Fire may have Lava attacks, it's still an elemental type even if you're manipulating physical things.

>>385940571
>Referring to electric as "Thunder"

This shit gotta fucking stop

>>385941709
>Nature type abilities involving pure life-force, solar energy and forest spirits.
What the fuck
Pretty sure that's some different categories of magic
Earth is about manipulating rock and sand and sheit

>>385940571
>Fire strong against Earth
>Throw some soil into a fire
>This somehow makes fire stronger
Should be Fire < Water < Earth < Air < Fire

>>385941709
That would be "nature" type not "earth" type. earth is just geomancy.

File: ryuko_matoi_klk_by_mrweirddude-d6r71hr.png (315KB, 900x900px) Image search: [Google]

315KB, 900x900px

>>385940889

>Summon an icicle
>stab an enemy with it
>"ice" damage instead of piercing damage

>>385941676
nevermind, the other poster saying a mace and club are different weapons is dumber
they're all the same type of force inflicting the same type of injury

>>385941471
>That's a status effect
Not if you're using magic to crystalize someone's blood inside their body and ripping it out telekinetically.

File: fredro bedro.jpg (32KB, 352x334px) Image search: [Google]

32KB, 352x334px

What kind of physical damage do wolf bites, or biting in general do?
Are whips slashing or piercing damage?
What kind of damage is poison?
What kind of damage is arcane/pure magic?

File: 1377872472951.png (57KB, 184x184px) Image search: [Google]

57KB, 184x184px

>>385941832
>>385941859
Incorrect, play more games. Earth covers the fruits of the land as well as the land itself, except in the rare games that split the aspects- in which case Ice and Water, and Wind and Lightning will likely be separate as well.

Corrosive?

>>385941874
>summon an icicle
>stab an enemy with it
>both piercing and ice damage

>>385940571
Impact maybe? Tearing is also good, as in being pulled from two sides.

>>385942069
>What kind of physical damage do wolf bites, or biting in general do?
Piercing I guess
>Are whips slashing or piercing damage?
I'd use Blunt damage for them
>What kind of damage is poison?
Earth
>What kind of damage is arcane/pure magic?
Non-elemental, or light

>evocation
>conjuration
>abjuration
>necromancy
>divination
>enchantment
>illusion
>transmutation
The only magic classes you'll ever need

>>385942072
You're a fucking idiot.
Earth magic is geomancy.
Nature magic is fucking druids and shit.
Unless you only play weeb shit because japs are boring as fuck and always copy the same designs.

>Temperature (heat, cold)
>Pressure
>Mind

>Cut
>Pierce
>Strike

3 for each, all magic goes in mind, fire/ice in temperature, earth in strike, wind/water in pressure

>>385941647
>what is lava and/or magma

>>385942072
>Incorrect, play more games
you mean more gay japanese games that dont make sense

>>385942160
Whips cut like a blade though, they don't crush or have a high impact, so it's more likely to be slashing.

File: 2563261636.jpg (73KB, 414x426px) Image search: [Google]

73KB, 414x426px

>>385941467
gonna need you to post sadpanda link or equivalent pronto friend

>>385942158
That's crushing.
Tearing sounds good, but what kind of weapon would deal tearing damage?

>>385942069
Fangs are crush, whips are slash, poison is a status ailment generally attributed to earth-elemental attacks.
Some games have "void" elemental for non-element attacks and "mystic" element for an elemental attack (meaning you can defend or be weak against it) that doesn't interact with other elements.

>>385940571
the fourth damage type is 'splitting', the kind of damage you'd deliver with an axe, OP

>>385942382
A whip.

>>385942390
fangs are piercing

>>385942382
tearing isnt a quantifiable damage type

>>385942478
Looks like you've never been whipped in your life then.

>>385942609
MADMAN! MODS!

If earth is physical than so is water. Jussayin.

>>385942609
you didn't have to take a 3 day vacation for me, but at least it was better than expected.

>What's the 4th physical damage type, /v/ and why is earth considered elemental damage instead of physical?

Chopping, like axes. Otherwise ranged but most ranged weapons are piercing so..

Also earth should stay elemental. Imagine for example light+earth creating life and dark+earth decay

>>385942641
Well, I'm guessing it depends on your source, but the games I played treated fangs attack as crushing.

>>385942641
>ripping a limb out is not a quantifiable damage type

File: 1330834301488.jpg (344KB, 1500x1500px) Image search: [Google]

344KB, 1500x1500px

>>385940571
>What's the 4th physical damage type, /v/?
Dicking

You guys are retarded
>Piercing is 0 dimensional, it's a point
>Slashing is a line
>Crushing is a 2D surface
The last one should be blasting, so it's 3D

>>385942775
>Well, I'm guessing it depends on your source
common sense? have you seen an animal with fangs?

File: 1473116513931.jpg (1MB, 4928x3264px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 4928x3264px

>>385942730
>you didn't have to take a 3 day vacation for me

File: 2434523623545.jpg (16KB, 369x305px) Image search: [Google]

16KB, 369x305px

>>385942953
you wouldn't ban evade like a degenerate would you? I believed in you.

File: uBCGcTL.jpg (156KB, 555x900px) Image search: [Google]

156KB, 555x900px

>>385942842
>The last one should be blasting
You mean explosive?

>>385940571
Chop, for axe damage.

>>385942935
Have you seen monsters? Some of them don't have sharp fangs but still bite.
Regardless, the teeth might pierce but the actual biting part crushes.

>>385941650
>Not being literally Jesus
Drifters was a fun watch/read. Check it if you like organized violence and the Hellsing Ultimate glass bottle eyes thing.

>>385943203
if fangs aren't sharp they aren't fangs, they're teeth. teeth do the crushing, fangs do the piercing

File: Dag (3).jpg (356KB, 576x1024px) Image search: [Google]

356KB, 576x1024px

>>385943065

Blunt

>>385943294
>isekaishit

File: 456246256236.gif (54KB, 320x240px) Image search: [Google]

54KB, 320x240px

>>385943571

File: 1435644808850.jpg (69KB, 562x530px) Image search: [Google]

69KB, 562x530px

>>385940571

>game has earth magic
>it's not summoning rocks at people

I like lightning/air

Fire would be my favorite element in video games if it wasn't for the fact that it always loses against water aka the faggiest element ever

>>385943309
Ok anon, fine, my mistake for associating fang attacks with biting.

>>385942269
Lava is molten rock, and rock has a boiling point of 1200 degrees Celsius whereas water which is strong against fire in that picture only has a boiling point of 100 degrees Celsius

>>385942842
The what would implosion be?

>>385940571
twisting?
Shearing?

Earth and Water should be crushing, piercing, and/or slashing damage, makes no sense to have fucking earth and water damage types.

>>385940571
Non-lethal.

>>385945132
What is corossion? It ain't poison, as poison won't affect metals or rocks.

>>385945464
It's still considered Earth. Slimes have corrosion abilities and most of the times they're linked with the Earth element

>>385940571
Entropy and Order instead light and dark.

>>385945464
Depends how in depth you want to go, I guess they'd have their own acid damage.

Tearing, pulling, and twisting

File: 1443487116515.gif (2KB, 64x64px) Image search: [Google]

2KB, 64x64px

>>385942239
>>385942292
I'm sorry you're so upset about being objectively wrong, anon. Maybe playing some games will make you feel better.

>>385945772
Funfact: Alkaline for destroying flesh or causing some serious damage

Acid for metals and rocks

Both alter the structure of water, so it being earth like
>>385945701
said is dum

>>385942072
Earth + water = plant life
Earth + plasma = golems/mammals

>>385946269
You forgot air you autismo

>>385946389
Golem + air
Adding air to clay would not make a bird

This is the perfect elemental system:

Fire absorbs wind and becomes bigger fire
Water snuffs out fire
Wind manipulates the direction and state of water.

Earth is just hardy as fuck with no advantages or disadvantages against the other elements.

>>385940764
I agree with this man

>>385940571
W R E S T L I N G

Captcha: NEEDMORE CALLE

>>385946584
isn't life all 4 elements + order?

Earth for holding stuff together, have a platform and have gravity

Air for... air.

Water for universal solvent

Fire for temperatures above 0 Kelvin.

Order to create life neatly.
Entropy is the outcast edgelord that dominates the rest of the universe.

>>385945725
>thinking chaos and entropy are the same
Entropy is the opposite of life, not light.

>>385943791
No arguments against that, but there was still some fun to be had.

>>385947523
Order and entropy are opposites
Entropy is the the idea that everything will eventually cease, break apart, that sort of thing. It's closer to chaos than death.

>>385947718
Isn't death a form of entropy?
Entropy is that everything wants to return to the lowest energy ground state, right?
Anorganic molecules are lower in energy than, let's say, DNA.

>>385947718
>will eventually cease, break apart, that sort of thing
Oh.
You mean... FUCKING DIE?

Entropy is the force or process of the death of the universe - it grows colder, stiller, emptier.

Chaos is the fundamental of life - order alone doesn't bring it forth, it builds it from chaos.

>>385942069
In D&D bite attacks do all three types of damage.

Bludgeoning because you're being crushed by a strong jaw.
Piercing because teeth are sharp.
Slashing because after the enemy bites down it then tries to rip your flesh off.

File: huh_hibari.png (255KB, 1024x1024px) Image search: [Google]

255KB, 1024x1024px

>>385940571
>fire/lightning
>water/freeze
>wind
>earth
>arcane
>miracle
each of them effective against its opposite

a unit is weak against its element opposite and will recieve bonus damage of the appropriate physical counterpart like >>385940889 >>385941874 >>385942110 said before

fourth physical damage type is "Abbrasion". provenient from burns, poisoning, erosion, frostbite and such.

>play Digimon Cyber Sleuth
>there's a triangle for vaccine, data, and virus type mons- double damage on advantage and halved on disadvantage, easy enough
>digimon also have elemental affinity- fire beats grass beats water beats fire
>and electric beats wind beats earth beats electric
>ALSO dark and light beat each other
>and neutral's just there
And THEN, just when you've wrapped your head around that and figured out how to avoid dealing 0.25X damage for the most part, we'll just throw the Bugged status in for shits and giggles. Have fun!

File: 1478664825457.png (84KB, 400x400px) Image search: [Google]

84KB, 400x400px

>>385948536
>Abbrasion
I love it

>>385948606
cant wait for the sequel

File: chinese-5-elements-arrows.png (17KB, 320x295px) Image search: [Google]

17KB, 320x295px

make way for superior elements

>>385948536
>fourth physical damage type is "Abbrasion"
*Abrasive

>Aer
>Terra
>Ignis
>Aqua
>Ordo
>Perditio

Everything else is a compound of the above

>>385948973
might as well post rock paper scissors now, the actual good elements

>>385940571
Why are wind and lightning always paired together?

>>385948885
damn right, gonna be a blast

>>385949347
Because wind is lackluster by itself, since you can't see air
Storms pair both together

>>385948973
and where are the kangaroos?

>>385949347
fire + wind should equal lightning, IMO

>>385949347
Because there's no word for a lightning mage, but we do have aeromancer.

>>385950559
electromancer

The only complete elemental chart that makes sense is

Fire -> Ice -> Wind -> Earth -> Lightning -> Water -> Fire

Light<>Dark

Everything else is garbage

File: image.png (215KB, 500x328px) Image search: [Google]

215KB, 500x328px

>>385940571
>what's the fourth physical damage type
Gun.

>>385950885
That's piercing.
Bullets pierce.

>>385945725

Life wouldn't exist without entropy, so if anything order is darkness since it's all perfectly ordered nothingness

>>385940571
>Fire
>Water/ice
>Lightening/wind
>Earth

>Axe
>Sword
>Spear
>Hammer

File: image.jpg (16KB, 480x360px) Image search: [Google]

16KB, 480x360px

>>385951050

>>385940571
The missing physical damage type is Gun.

>>385950862

>wind beats earth

fucking how?

File: kJr70RfsSgySLnUdE28PSQ.png (172KB, 892x982px) Image search: [Google]

172KB, 892x982px

>>385940571
>slashing piercing crushing

Finisher damage is the fourth physical damage type u fucking plebs. It does pure damage and disregards all armor types.

>>385951797
>playing Warframe
... you don't get to call anyone a pleb.

>>385951976
shut up pleb

File: 1449537207353.gif (2MB, 400x300px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 400x300px

>>385944143
>Earth magic is almost always stupid shit like poison

What do you think of this chart?

Element->Sub specialization

Fire->Plasma/Magma
Earth->Magnetism/Nature
Water->Ice/Steam
Air->No fucking/Idea

Non elements
Light->Radiation/Laser i guess
Dark->Void/Gravity

>>385951730

It erodes the earth, just like in real life

>circular system involving at least fire, water or ice, and some third stupid element
>light and dark are completely isolated and oppose each other
so fucking sick of this
give me an element system that isn't the same garbage

> Ice,Electric,Fire elements
>Stab,Slash,Impact,Magical,Mental damage
Anything else doesn't make sense

>>385952393
Magnetism should just be Metal.
Air usually gets Lightning.

>>385942353
Don't have the link on me but its futa with spiky cat dicks down there.

>>385942353
Found it for you, anon.
https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts/1752969
For future reference, if you have a cropped color image, reverse searching from sauceNAO to tineye, then using the Image Search Options extension to go back to sauceNAO if you find the full version on tineye, tends to get you to a booru link for your image.

File: runes.png (3KB, 244x326px) Image search: [Google]

3KB, 244x326px

One system I actually liked a lot, of all fucking things was Runescape's. The actual elemental aspect never really gets touched upon unfortunately, but if you think about it it's pretty clear that the runes themselves can be divided into distinct groups: traditional elements, 'bodily' elements, elements associated with the three main in-game gods, elements associated with the world, and elements associated with mortality, but the rest are a bit more varied.

I'm making a few simplifications here: the Life Rune was never officially released, though it has been acknowledged, and there was a later god rune that isn't really worth mentioning so I'm ignoring it.) While the system itself had many flaws, the lore behind it was really neat.

>>385952393
DLC element

Life->Death/Disease/Enhancement

>>385940896
>>385941547
How are those too similar but slashing and piercing aren't?

>>385952997
Guess Lighting makes sense for air but what could be the other specialization for it? Weather? atmospheric pressure? Vacuum?

I love how Persona 2 had a gorillion elements, even if the quantity didn't amount to that much depth

>>385954003
I also liked the combination runes generated by fusing two of the four main elemental runes because they actually made sense

>>385940571
>fire strong against earth
they are in symbiosis you fucking fag, they love each other not the other way around.

>>385955069
>they love each other not the other way around.
So they don't love other each?

The fourth physical element should be Force/Blast, for stuff like bombs and sound/shockwave-based damage

File: 1501628965607.jpg (27KB, 640x638px) Image search: [Google]

27KB, 640x638px

There are only five elements
Earth, Water, Life, Fire, and Air
rest is autism

>>385956080
I'm down with that.
Put them in a circle or something and I'll use it.

>>385955275
explosions are concussive damage

>>385951730
To be honest the whole elemental chart doesn't make sense

Why isn't fire strong against wind if when fire feeds off oxygen
Wind is strong against earth when the actual erosion in nature takes years to take place and even by this logic why isn't water strong against earth too??
This fucking chart has water and ice as separate elements so wouldn't ice win vs water as it just freezes it and makes it another weapon

I don't get why people make elemental strength/weakness charts as circles other than for the sake of simplicity

>>385940764
This right here.

>>385956080
>Life
Get the fuck out of here.

>>385956607
>what are healers
>what is disease

>>385956328
Because Fantasy physics != Real life physics and chemistry
Fantasy games with take inspiration for their element from mythology and pre-chemistry philosophy

>>385956703
Entropy and Order, faggot.

>God tier
Dimensional elements (time, space, gravity, etc)
Toxic/poison

>High tier
Darkness (Shadow/spirit based)
Astral/cosmic/psionic
Lightning/electric
Ice
Metal/Machinery

>Great tier
Plant
Water
Unelemental/neutral

>Good tier
Fire
Light (Holy/solar themed)
Wind/Air

>Meh tier
earth

>Bad tier
Darkness (edgy)
Light (love/girly cutsey power of friendship themed)

File: 1493312761867.png (56KB, 456x437px) Image search: [Google]

56KB, 456x437px

>Game has water, earth, wind and fire
>Combining wind and fire creates lightning
>Combining water and earth creates ice

>>385956860
''neutral''

So basicly, the abscence of everything else is a thing?
Nothing is a thing.
God this board is dumb.

>>385956860
>ice is an element
>isnt just a form of water element

>>385940764
the correct term is shearing

>>385940571
None of the elements are anything other than physical damage, you fucking Cuck. How the fuck do you think water damages you? Is drowning not physical? Is getting sliced by a high pressure water beam not physical? Are flames not FUCKING PHYSICAL? God fucking damn it, son.

All damage is physical, besides mental damage of course.

>>385942842
Piercing isn't 0 dimensional because it's a continuous point.

>>385956080
>no Cold
>no Lightning

>>385941647

SAUCE

>purposely adding as many different elements as possible instead of elegantly folding them into as few as would be reasonable and actually playable
why though

>>385957309
>lightning = fire + air
>cold = air + water

>>385957463
Some argue that more element interactions = more strategy. I can see where it comes from though I think that dual-typing and a few elements are enough to satisfy.

>>385940571
Earth would be physical

>>385957583
Just look at the lists people post in this thread, though. Huge lists of nonsense, most not even slightly thematically linked. It's like they just jotted down as many separate thoughts as they could with no consideration for design at all.

File: final_circles.gif (14KB, 361x361px) Image search: [Google]

14KB, 361x361px

you are all smalltime

>>385941358
Not a bad idea, but I'd call it sonic. Mental damage with some added mezzing.

>>385959475
>people still fucking consider Ice to be an element
>literally cold water
>people will say that lightning is a new element entirely and not just a part of fire element

>>385959475
>clouds and wind are the same thing
>earth somehow makes ice
>wind extinguishing fire
get this brainlet out of my sight

>>385959764
>lightning
>part of fire

>>385959920
It literally sets shit on fire, you tard.

>>385959764
>Lightning part of fire
>Not part of air
okay fag

>>385957020
There's unelemental damage and attacks in games with elemental systems you dummy

>>385956881
>water and earth into ice

What

Water + Earth should be plant, water + wind should be ice

>>385956860
> Top tier
- Classic elements:
Fire
Water
Wind
Earth

>Good tier
- Pure forms of natural energy:
Lightning/Electricity

- Classic duality as symbolism:
Life and Death
Light and Darkness
Order and Chaos

>Mid tier
- Separating common phenomena associated with an element:
Heat
Cold
Ice
Mud
Air pressure
Vacuum
Magnetism
Gravity

>Bad tier
- Trying to pass non-elemental magic and elemental magic:
Poison
Spirit
Shadow
Actually wielding and casting light magic
Actually wielding and casting darkness magic
Arcane as a type of elemen
Magic damage

> Shit tier
Casting man-made concepts as elemental magic:
Soul
Time
Dimensional magic
Death as an element (usually wielded as shadow or darkness or necromancy)
Life (Healing or manipulating life)
Astral/Aether/Heaven/Quintessence
Mind
Ying yang or body energy

>>385959995
>>385959920
>sets fire wherever it strikes
>30k kelvins
>sun's surface is only 6k kelvins
how would it be a part of anything else

File: 1497073041744.jpg (203KB, 707x1050px) Image search: [Google]

203KB, 707x1050px

>>385940571
You're now remembering Ragnarok Online and how it actually had Poison and Undead property attacks. Poison is only useful for the sake of not being Neutral and Undead is useless in all scenarios.

Magic attacks ought to have physical modifiers too. An Ice Spear attack should be both Water and Pierce. The two types should not be mutually exclusive.

>>385960084
If we think of elements as more abstract things, earth would be mass and wind/air would be the lack of mass.
So, ice is solid water and air+water would be some form of gas. Like a cloud, or mist.

>>385959920
>>385959986
>>385959995
>>385960260
Electricity would be Air + Fire

>>385960298
>ice spear
>elemental weapons
stop with this faggotry

>>385960405
Technically, electricity would be air+water+fire, since it takes all those elements to make thunder.
Or, if we want to be even more accurate, lighting would just be fire, since it's plasma and plasma is a form of fire.

File: angry.jpg (56KB, 386x426px) Image search: [Google]

56KB, 386x426px

>>385960428
>implying non-magical classes should be cucked out of elemental attacks

I bet a magefag is behind this post. Don't fall to it.

>>385960587
>le i hav no imagination and an iq of 5 so i'm going to do the most uncreative thing with elements
for what purpose

>>385941228
>hit someone with a hammer-shaped rock on a stick
>crushing damage
>hit someone with a spell that hits them with a hammer-shaped rock
>earth damage

>>385941442
daily reminder that Trails' system of Earth Water Fire Air / Space Time Mirage is the best

>>385960909
Or use a non-shitty engine and have it do crushing, earth damage instead of one or the other like Monster Hunter.

>>385961052
Then you end up with a system where split damage types are either shit or broken.

>>385960867
There are 999 things wrong with the RPG genre , in particular with MMO games, but the 4-elemental system is not one of them. There's no reason to reinvent the wheel here. You may want to put in some snowflake elements in there but there's no reason to change the basic ones.

>>385961406
You've completely missed my point. I'm all for elements, I'm just against doing lame boring shit with elements like making a spear from ice.

File: visual aid.png (15KB, 591x382px) Image search: [Google]

15KB, 591x382px

>>385942842

piercing is 2d as well. slashing and piercing just travel in different directions on the same 2d plane.

>>385954634
Chainmail protects against slash but not puncture.

>>385952393

air should get sound and/or lightning

>>385960428
Ice spear is a sorcerer and wizard spell though.

I used to play the mobile game that OP's image is from and let me tell you mutually effective elements are annoyingly overpowered in comparison to the rest of the effectiveness chart. At least Pokemon has multiple weaknesses for each type.

>Not using the Trinity: Ice, Lightning and Fire

>Poison is purple, not green
>Lightning is any other color than white with a slight blue glow
>Wind is green, not light blue or light grey

Why do the japs get these things so wrong?

File: MV5BMTUzOTg4MzM5MV5BMl5BanBnXkFtZTcwNzIwNTc3NA@@._V1_UY1200_CR84,0,630,1200_AL_.jpg (99KB, 630x1200px) Image search: [Google]

99KB, 630x1200px

>>385950045
Right here friendo

Does any game use electromagnetism, gravity, radiation, ... as elements?

how about you fucks think of something that would facilitate good gameplay rather than trying to figure out who's bullshit magic damage type is right. Its all wrong, okay? There is no such thing as ice damage or water damage or whatever the fuck faggot damage type they put in games these days. The point isn't to make sense, its to incentivize playing certain ways at certain times.

According to scientific research, your zodiac sign determines which elemental power you get.

>Fire (Destructice Magic)
Aries
Leo
Sagittarius

>Earth (Defensive Magic)
Taurus
Virgo
Capricorn

>Air (Supportive Magix)
Gemini
Libra
Aquarius

>Water (The power to cry and be fucking useless)
Cancer
Scorpio
Pisces

Which power do you get, /v/?

>>385962930
There's gotta be some sort of logic behind it though. You don't cast fire spells to heal people unless you're going out of your way to justify it.

>>385942242
I'd suggest Energy for heat and cold, Force for water, air and any other physical force like cut, pierce and strike but also gravity, and Matter for earth and metal.Then have Life for nature and healing.

File: Advantage_Table.png (646KB, 730x453px) Image search: [Google]

646KB, 730x453px

Find a flaw.

File: 1472795540807.png (60KB, 196x232px) Image search: [Google]

60KB, 196x232px

>>385963038
Zodiac signs for me are in the same category as Unicorns, the Tooth Fairy, and Scientology. So please, go fuck yourself.

>scientific research
lel

>>385963290
>wood is an element
>thunder is an element
>being so severely autistic

File: 1497114097092.jpg (30KB, 436x336px) Image search: [Google]

30KB, 436x336px

>>385963038

>Aquarius
>air

>>385963038
>The power to cry and be fucking useless
This should not be as funny as I think it is

>>385942641
>>385940764
>>385957131
I recall one LN had someone bypass the slash/pierce/blunt system by just using a high-speed drill that does shearing damage. There was no shearing resistance in the bullshit magic RPG system so it just ignored defences altogether.

>>385963553
That's TTGL

File: [laughs microscopically].jpg (76KB, 724x620px) Image search: [Google]

76KB, 724x620px

>>385963038
>(The power to cry and be fucking useless)

>>385941442
Someone watched a lot of Avatar

>>385963290
so there's the two separate loops, but are they all together in a circle of 8? Which way is the blue circle going, or is it not?

>>385940571
best element is non elemental.

File: Pegasus 2.jpg (49KB, 410x308px) Image search: [Google]

49KB, 410x308px

>>385963496
>being so severely autistic that you don't get a joke
>>385963906
The loops are separate and the elements have absolutely no reason to be ordered like this.

>>385963346
this post brought to you by water

File: 1485858550801.jpg (68KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

68KB, 1280x720px

>>385964049
Ragnarok Online has this and all the skills that have it are fuck-you tier.

>the skill damage is non-elemental
>meaning that it ignores checking elements altogether and does full damage to everything
>cannot be reduced by any means, usually

>>385964219
By that post I would be Fire, but there's literally nothing wrong with Water.

>>385957168
Water, air and earth are all matter combined with kinetic force, so yes, that would be physical. But fire is just heat/energy with no mass behind it. It does not hurt you by hitting you hard, but by denaturing the proteins that make up the tissues of your body (burning you). So in a sense it would be energy-based damage, not physical based.

File: 056d9a592854a5c3776dae3b1ae24e29.jpg (802KB, 883x1165px) Image search: [Google]

802KB, 883x1165px

>>385940571
void is best element

>>385964453
>ow the edge
I bet you like Rogues and Dagger weapons, too?

Elemental damage:
>Toxin
>Radiation
>Electromagnetic
>Plasma

Physical damage:
>Ballistic
>Unconscious
>Cigarettes
>Asphyxiation

The most perfect damage system of all time.

File: warmth.png (4KB, 64x80px) Image search: [Google]

4KB, 64x80px

>>385963078
excuse me

Why have elements?

File: NEOGEOPOCKET--Biomotor Unitron_Jun15 18_28_57.png (7KB, 160x152px) Image search: [Google]

7KB, 160x152px

>>385964453
>Not liking glorious light

File: 1462857899826.png (316KB, 670x487px) Image search: [Google]

316KB, 670x487px

>>385960087
Aether (or Void) is just as much part of the classical elements as Fire, Water, Wind and Earth.

>>385964574
yes because im not a cuck, dps all the way baby no tank shit

File: __remilia_scarlet_and_scorpio_milo_saint_seiya_and_touhou_drawn_by_h_new__141dafdb032a294fcd9560ca3c271e72.jpg (786KB, 850x1200px) Image search: [Google]

786KB, 850x1200px

>>385963038
fuck you faggot

>>385963078
you speak like a fool child. Fire is core of the soul! I guess you think air or water can heal? maybe? no. only fire will gives you salvation. if you are like me a true man you heal all wound with flame.

>>385965057
I agree with you but dagger/rogue archetypes are shit. They're always either broken OP or garbage.

>>385965251
You're the one who's a fool. I don't care about core of the soul or salvation. It all pales in comparison to Wind and the ability to fly.

>>385965594
>Not making a jet pack spell to fly with fire.

>>385956328
The only ones that really make sense in my mind as perfect circles that haven't already been said (such as >>385940571 and >>385948973)


>Fire > Air > Earth > Water > Fire...
Fire combusts oxygen in air, air erodes away earth and picks up stuff off the ground, the earth absorbs water into the soil, water extinguishes fire

and

>Fire > Air > Earth > Lightning > Water > Fire...

Fire combusts oxygen in air, air erodes away earth and picks up stuff off the ground, the earth grounds electrictiy, water is conductive to electricity, and water extinguishes fire

File: very shit.png (440KB, 640x480px) Image search: [Google]

440KB, 640x480px

>>385964582
>electromagnetic
>radiation
>plasma

>seperate

>>385965594
so why you didnt just tell me you are a woman? its ok to use air and water for women. Men will use fire and earth because for real fighting not sisy flying. I will burn atmosfre and you fall to the grave.

>>385964582

elemental damage
>sound
>gravity
>wood
>murder

comrade damage
>anger
>alcohol poisoning
>volcanic
>nationalism

non-newtonian damage
>piercings
>slash(the guitarist)
>bitter
>sour

fixed

I hope this bumps one more time