Post the metascore of your favorite game and if you think it's

100
Fair

>Klonoa 2
>9.1
im satisfied

File: Bulborb_Larva_Army.png (284KB, 564x485px) Image search: [Google]

284KB, 564x485px

>Pikmin 2
>90

not too shabby if I say so myself.

>86
Sounds about right

>>384494831
>waiting on fourth reviewer
Yep, that's an accurate assessment of the game.

>71
what le FUCK

78
No. Should be 85 at the very least.

>Half Life
>96

I'll allow it

File: 15488635896.jpg (51KB, 256x363px) Image search: [Google]

51KB, 256x363px

>>384494831
>78
>Gladius

what bullshit, it was ahead of it's time.

>Digimon World 3
>47/100
fuck no, DW3, as much grinding as it has is not a worse game than MN9. it's a 75 at the very least

>>384495921
Just noticed the pc port is 78. The ps3 and 360 versions are 84. It's ok I guess.

File: ss (2017-07-19 at 03.07.16).png (43KB, 646x314px) Image search: [Google]

43KB, 646x314px

>>384494831
>Paper Mario
>93
The rating suits it very well.

>TWEWY
>88
Yeah, thats alright

File: dw2.jpg (52KB, 656x315px) Image search: [Google]

52KB, 656x315px

Digimon World 2. Game that got shat on by everyone because it was actually different. I wish we got more dungeon delving with future games.

>>384494831
>TTYD
>87
Yeah that sounds about right. Maybe a little bit higher but around this area.

File: metafaggot.png (6KB, 685x174px) Image search: [Google]

6KB, 685x174px

If only it had a score.

>>384494831
>97
Could be better.
Sonygros will understand this :).

>>384496086
>skill-based SRPG

Still nothing like it and it kills me inside.

Sub-90 is unforgivable for this gem.

>>384494831
>94
Unfair, too high.

>54
No

>63
Honestly better than I was expecting

File: 145e2f71ac393f24c8d9a0244c294eea.jpg (44KB, 569x479px) Image search: [Google]

44KB, 569x479px

>78
Absolutely not.

>>384496305
I would really prefer if you'd be quiet.

File: 1489330676904.jpg (239KB, 800x1117px) Image search: [Google]

239KB, 800x1117px

>69

Beyond forgivable. Every person who's rated it gave it a 10 and it deserves at least 9.

>>384496086
It was good, but it was full of flaws especially the crap story mode and end boss.

>77%
Mad shitters who couldn't get past the casual filter.

>89 and 84
>Age of Mythology + the Titans xpac
A pretty fair rating, although I could see both receiving 90+ quite easily

>>384496263
came here to post this. should be higher, but an 88 is definitely acceptable. I'm surprised it's that high, considering the learning curve of the combat system and the incompetence of game reviewers

File: 1489984365684.png (713KB, 488x1105px) Image search: [Google]

713KB, 488x1105px

>86
>MH4U
>Critics: "difficulty is too high for me because I'm a massive shitter, so I give it a 60."

The game should be a solid 90+ if there wasn't for the shitters.

File: 1857306854.jpg (42KB, 342x400px) Image search: [Google]

42KB, 342x400px

>>384496658
that was because it was a first of its kind. it would have done much better if it had a better release date. and sequels would cover a better story and ending. had some qt's in their '03 graphics

But i do agree the story and ending had a sudden stop.

>all time fav
>Thief 2: The Metal Age
87, meh, it was probably too much unlike every other first-person game for reviewers' tastes at the time

>recent fav
>Dishonored
91, shouldn't be higher than T2 at the time maybe but fair

>random fav
>FTL
84, absolutely disgusting

File: 1434538980699.png (182KB, 297x278px) Image search: [Google]

182KB, 297x278px

>93%
>Fair

Here's a bonus, the only negative review.

>"t seemed every time I started midly enjoying the game, I then ended up running around an area forever because the game never gives you any indication of where to go next, it treats the player like a kid yet it's just as stupid. The elemental weapon system is frankly annoying, especially when it's tied to learning magic. The camera is a pile of **** and your characters position in battle isn't controlled by you yet it affects the battles... This game is a trainwreck. Areas are designed to be annoying. Very little is obvious, nothing is compelling and everything feels pointless."

>Ace Combat Zero at 75
>Armored Core for Answer at 62
Get some fucking taste, reviewers

File: 1499838467177.jpg (108KB, 798x720px) Image search: [Google]

108KB, 798x720px

>Stalker: SoC
>82
I dunno. Even the user score is 84. I guess people just don't have taste or something. It's their loss.

>>384498873

Man. Skies of Arcadia really wasn't that difficult.

>>384499109

One of my favorite games and I don't think that's unfair.

>98
seems about right

96

I love it to death but objectively that's actually overselling it a bit. Subjectively though, fuck yeah it's fair.

>>384496510

It really scored that low? It was on the short side but it was really unique and well done. It really deserved a mid-high 80's like Dark Moon got.

>61
I bet the Jians did this

>90
Yeah that's about right

>84
>Unfair
Fuck you todd.

>Ace Combat 4
>89

Not good enough, AC5 is higher.

>Far cry 3 Blood dragon
>81
Why again?

MGS3:S
94 maybe a tad too high

File: 15522_front.jpg (95KB, 640x908px) Image search: [Google]

95KB, 640x908px

>pic related
>96
>fair af desu

File: THE ORDER 1.jpg (74KB, 666x666px) Image search: [Google]

74KB, 666x666px

>>384494831
63%

Hurts like hell.

>80
Ehhh it's buggy and unfinished. Seems reasonable when you consider most reviewers only played five minutes and it's definitely a flawed masterpiece.

>>384507005
How can that one be your FAVORITE game?
Have you only played absolute garbage so far?

>>384507250
I've been gaming for more than two decades. The Order: 1886 is the best game I've ever played. I'm sick of explaining why.

>>384507352
>I'm sick of explaining why.

Oh I bet you are.

>>384507135
>second favourite
>79
What the fuck. The game is practically perfect. 1up gave it a perfect score but fucking giantbomb nuked the average giving it a 4/10.

87
Deserves lower Imo

92

fair, the game's high are incredible but the lows do drag it down a big.

>>384499109
82 is fine considering how that game runs unmodded

>>384503753
84 isn't that bad when you consider you have to re-mod new vegas from the ground up to make it stable
still got jew'd out of their bonus by todd, though

File: ws_Hitman-_Blood_Money_1600x1200.jpg (273KB, 1600x1200px) Image search: [Google]

273KB, 1600x1200px

>82
Fair enough I guess.

>92
I am surprised it's this high but yes it deserves it

>15
>deserves lower imo

File: 360d4053d47248f565e5958b0a921e08110442f6[1].jpg (175KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

175KB, 1280x720px

>97

fair

>>384494831
>94
the user score is better at 82
anyone who gives it above an 80 probably has autism

95
Yeah it's pretty accurate

>>384503646
HE

>Capcom vs SNK 2
>81
Not saying it's not fair but I'd see a 85 as a better fit. Oh well.

>>384508154
Why is a trash game your favourite game?

86%
Red Alert 2

I'll take it. No negative reviews and only 1 or 2 mixed, probably detailing what I suspect is balance issues or maybe lack of Yuri campaign. That said, user score is a 9.0 so I'm not complaining.

>>384507352
We'll it's just not that good anon, must take a lot of explaining.

>>384508981
>96

I'd say it's fair.

>>384496531

This. A really great JRPG. Pretty standard story but the characters/battle system/alchemy all make up for it. My favourite JRPG alongside Atelier Iris 2.

>Ikaruga
>87

Gamecube version got an 85 which is totally wrong, that port is the worst thing ever.

>>384507005
>>384507352
Yeah that was a fun movie but whats your favorite game anon

>>384509260
To be fair most people only played the GCN version and don't know any better.

>>384494831
95
I agree

File: IMG_5819.png (478KB, 1242x2208px) Image search: [Google]

478KB, 1242x2208px

Fair and shockingly accurate.

File: 1493504178121.jpg (49KB, 186x219px) Image search: [Google]

49KB, 186x219px

>Bloodborne
>92

I think it's fair :)

>>384509116
Except the game we're talking about got a 63.

97, seems about right although i would rate it 95-96 personally since u can only play it for 3 hours on the go.

>>384494831
>Battlefront 2
>84
Too low

File: Untitled.png (61KB, 638x247px) Image search: [Google]

61KB, 638x247px

>>384494831
It is the best of the 3 so I'd call that fair.

>>384507135
>>384507463
Vtmb and Catherine btw.

File: Super Mario 64 Title Screen.jpg (17KB, 250x187px) Image search: [Google]

17KB, 250x187px

94

Yeah, it's fair.

File: 2017-07-19 14.42.40.jpg (243KB, 1057x1131px) Image search: [Google]

243KB, 1057x1131px

Greatest game I have ever played. If you haven't played this masterpiece, stop shitposting for a bit and get to it.

File: il2 metascore.png (41KB, 424x210px) Image search: [Google]

41KB, 424x210px

I guess.

File: 1490065542481.png (2MB, 1920x1090px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1920x1090px

Reminder: if you score less than a 7.5/10, then your game is worse than Party Babyz.
Not so fast, God Hand.

File: 385037f6-365a-4d4b-92de-6edcfa3661be.png (118KB, 256x306px) Image search: [Google]

118KB, 256x306px

>89
>Never gets a sequel
The score is fair, the lack of sequel is not fair

File: Untitled.png (34KB, 720x315px) Image search: [Google]

34KB, 720x315px

>>384494831

>Metal gear solid 2
>97
Fair

>The Final Fantasy Legend 2
>It's not on Memecritic

Now what?

>Final Fantasy Tactics Advance
>87

Me likey.
When is the next tactics game out?

>>384512194
100% this

Reminder that 5/10 means it's an average game and anything above that means it's better than average.

>>384513558

Nigga please, this is /v/.

Anything below an 80 that doesn't line up with my opinions is unplayable.

>>384513558
wrong vidya reviews follow the US school system's grading (70% = C) unless otherwise stated

>>384494831
>Mario Kart Double Dash!!
>87.
Makes sense, most people hate its slippery controls.

>95
It's pretty accurate, yeah