What this really one of the best games of all time or just

It's a game that really has everything going for it. The visuals and music (the music especially) are gorgeous, the story is compelling though the subject matter is well-covered, the voice acting is top notch, and the SP and MP experiences are well-crafted.

>>383598209
Gameplay was fun. Story was pretty darn good. Better than most AAA games.

>b-but it wasn't GOTY or GOAT and the AI was stupid and movie on rails cutscene memes Naughty Doggo is literally Hitler
It was fun enough and I would probably just forget about the game if people wouldn't stop talking about how much they don't like it on /v/.

It's a 5/10. Story is irrelevant when the gameplay is so boring I forgot what I was even doing half the time out of sheer uninterest.

Just a fairly well executed game. Every idea had been previously explored much more thoroughly in other mediums. If gameplay was just a vehicle for the plot and the plot did nothing original then who cares. Solid 7/10, which has been my opinion since the game came out.

Multiplayer was sort of fun.

>>383598209
Gameplay was shit. What set TLOU apart from most other AAA game is the amazing amazing character development. Besides that and the atmosphere, the game itself is pretty mediocre.

It's a good game but very overrated, it's designed to tick all the boxes that makes reviewers and normies think it's the best game ever.

File: IMG_0728.jpg (66KB, 600x338px) Image search: [Google]

66KB, 600x338px

TW3 and TLOU are the 2 greatest games ever made.

debate me.