I don't care what anyone says, this here alone is why N

Kek. Automata isn't even in the top 5 games of 2017, much less being better than BotW.

>>383582826
>apples are better than oranges because apples are red, and red>orange
This is literally how you sound like

>>383582985
It's a far better game than BotW. In more ways than one.
Better combat
Better Soundtrack
Better Story
Better ambience

>>383583064
>All of the sudden BotW is not an Open World game.

>>383583092
>better combat
I actually disagree with this, funny. I think Nier unironically has worse combat than horizon zero dawn. The robots are just not fucking fun to fight

>>383583150
Oh fuck better compare Galatica with nier because nier has shootemup sections as well

Are you retarded anon?

>>383583159
It's still much better than BotW's gear-based combat, that's easily broken in multiple ways.

https://youtu.be/T15-xfUr8z4?t=54m25s

@54mins.

And just, then entire segment on combat,

>>383583296
Fuck off with this video, shill. I played both games, I don't need someone else telling what I feel about both. Are you saying nier's combat isn't easily broken by chips as well? It's just as breakable, especially since dodge can be spammed with zero consequence. At least in BOTW it gives no iframes

>>383582826
>NieR: Automata is a much better game than BotW
You're wrong. That's ok, you can be wrong.

>>383583419
Nice argument you raised there buddy, here you have visible examples of how the game is broken:

https://youtu.be/T15-xfUr8z4?t=1h1m58s

I played both too, and BotW was disappointing.

>>383582826
nier:

>Combat with no depth
>Shallow shmup and hacking sections
>Story that tries to be deep and is nothing more than anime tropes and superficial understanding of philosophy
>"Cinematic" moments like 2B's virus sectiom
>Chips make the already shallow combat even more trivial
>Has to collect materials/pray for enemy drops to upagrade things

BOTW

>Terrible weapon durability mechanic that was supposed to incentivize different approachs to combat but only makes it more tedious
>No enemy variety
>Empty open world
>Crafting
>The four " dungeons " suck balls
>Lol, story in a Zelda game

They're both shit, senpai. And what surprised me the most is that /v/ defends them when the both of them feature shitty mechanics that /v/ criticizes western games for using like ubisoft-tier crafting and leveling, and the open-world meme.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zw47_q9wbBE

>best song isn't even in the game

sasuga nintendoda

>>383583962
>best song
That's not the Vah Ruta battle theme...

File: nioh-listing-thumb-01-ps4-us-08dec15 (1).png (1MB, 1067x600px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 1067x600px

>>383583837
This. Both games are average although BOTW is better. Pic related is GOTY so far.

>>383584270
botw is trash

>>383584270
>Nioh better than BotW
What? By what standard?

>>383583549
Did you just post the same damn video twice? And I have an argument, you didn't address it at all. I argue that chips and dodge make combat much more broken in Nier. Hell healing is just as fucking easy as in BOTW

>>383584493
by any standard, BOTW is fuckin terrible

File: 1492456969462.jpg (22KB, 173x272px) Image search: [Google]

22KB, 173x272px

Agreed. I've always loved Zelda for the great music, since the original game.

File: CQNi1Qt.gif (945KB, 500x260px) Image search: [Google]

945KB, 500x260px

>>383582826
>ign or gamespot talked about game of the year recently
>basically say out loud nier automata was okay and horizon was shit compared to botw
>only real contender was smo
I can't imagine the butthurt when goty awards happens

>>383584592
lol?

>>383582826
the music it has is amazing though
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6_0GdN_iBmw&t=185s
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=C9cQ4cFo3jc
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hwyhYmGzKLU
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jyVX-s5YC3g
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Nlg43w1aK8M
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Lme2m6fkc4o

>>383584638
smo?

>>383584493
Combat, and combat only

Rest of Ni-oh is fucking shit, especially since it gets way to repetitive towards the back and you just can't go end it. Level design and visual design are also bland as fuck

The gear system is fucking trash too

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3FWVKu1gnWs

>>383582826
>one of the best games of 2017 is better than this other one of the best games of 2017
Pick a bad game to shitpost with.

>>383584493
By fucking gameplay, combat in BOTW blows ass.

>>383584660
super mario odyssy

>>383584658
/thread

>>383584658
This. Hyrule Castle is the best vidya track of the year so far.

>>383583549
Fuck off anderson, stop shilling your shit video

>>383583837
>crafting as a bad point
You haven't played botw have you? You don't even have to craft once the entire fucking game.

>>383583837
>They're both shit
I actually wish I could be this contrarian so I can save some fucking money.

>>383584726
I agree.

The only 3 games I could reasonably see taking Game of the Year this year are Breath of the Wild, Persona 5, and Super Mario Odyssey assuming it lives up to expecations.

File: 1499726523079.png (393KB, 462x497px) Image search: [Google]

393KB, 462x497px

>its another "nintendo will win goty" thread

you nintenbros never learn do you?

>>383584716
Archery in BOTW is the best of all the games released this year

Prove me fucking wrong nigger

Besides game play is not solely combat

>>383584861
What else could win?

File: NotEnoughZelda.webm (3MB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 1280x720px

>>383584591
Defend this.

>>383584795
>persona 5
>winning anything
It's too weeb. Even zelda might be teethering on the "weeb" rope

>>383584905
Mario Odyssey

>>383584951
>its another "nintendo will win goty" thread
>what else could win
>another Nintendo game
???

>>383584951
>falling for the hype

lol

>>383584913
Persona 5 won't win shit because people play games to play games. Not watch cutscenes.

>>383584908
too generous hitboxes.
Now can you address my argument about how combat in nier is broken to hell and back too?

desu have you even played BOTW? playing the game you will find plenty of examples of way too generous hitboxes yourself, you don't need to use someone else's

>>383584764

>Don't have to craft once in the entire game

Did YOU play BotW? Crafting is a huge part of the game. You need to craft resistance potions to get through certain areas.

>>383584998
>there is only one goty
I'm sure HZD will win GOTY at some places.

>>383583549
>pretending your long pointless rant is a video essay
Learn how to write an essay, then make it into a video.

Don't talk at your mic about shallow game analysis that everyone already knows to wank your own ego. This goes to you as well, Matosis and every other one of you autistic fucks.

>>383584905
western games and non-nintendo weeb games.

>>383585085
PlayStation Magazine will be desperate enough yes.

>>383585017
>craft resistance potions
No you don't. The old man gives you the winter clothes and NPCs hand you the heat resistant potions. Hell even if you don't have the potions in cold just use a torch

Seriously have you played the game?

File: RightHauntingCaiman.webm (2MB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1280x720px

>>383585015
He took half the boss's health with ONE attack. Are you insane?

Defend THIS.

>>383585017
I just ate food till I got to the city to buy some armor.

File: 1476484673568.jpg (26KB, 320x240px) Image search: [Google]

26KB, 320x240px

>>383582826
>this here alone is why NieR: Automata is a much better game than BotW:
>posts soundtrack

>>383585134
>winter clothes
>enough for the coldest parts of the map
You haven't played BotW

>>383585138
Funny enough they pass Tomato's typical anime orchestra garbage as good.

>>383585136
Where's your argument anon? Really where is it. Zelda's combat isn't great, its too easy, but my argument is that Nier's combat is both easy and broken too

>>383585136
Looks like a lot more than one attack. I saw the sword hitting it multiple times.

>>383585179
>coldest parts
Where? If I recall I got through all cold areas with the doublet and the torch

>>383585270
>torch
Yeah, combat with a torch?
You haven't played BotW.

>>383584690
that's actually pretty cool

>>383582826
It has tons of reasons it's a better game.


>>383583296
>Fuck off with this video, shill. I
>Fuck off with this video that objectively shows the flaws with BotW and it's combat

His deconstruction of BotW and all it's issues is incredibly on point.

File: CarefulRareBengaltiger.webm (2MB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1280x720px

>>383585214
>>383585227
>Flurry rush being broken easy to activate, and letting you take half the boss's health is good game design.

Defend THIS.

>>383585136
I'm genuinely confused, why is Anderson having such an autistic fit over this? So the flurry rush is designed to be lenient, why would that make the mechanic broken?

>>383585179
anything is enough as long you have a stock of hearty durians

>>383585309
>His deconstruction of BotW and all it's issues is incredibly on point.
lol, not really

File: 1490020041534.webm (3MB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 1280x720px

>>383585136
Defend this.

>>383585180
It seems like pretty good anime orchestra from what I've heard, but it still isn't something you'd ever remember like Zelda, Metal Gear, pretty much anything else. It's objectively "good" but it's not necessarily memorable. Call of Duty music is like that too.

>>383585136
Well he was using the master sword. I would think if you wait that long to do the first dungeon you'd be ridiculously overpowered.

>>383585328
Except no one said it was good design you dumb nigger. I'm saying Nier's just as bad

This is your last (You) unless you come out with an actual argument

>>383585340
So you haven't played BotW? Ok

>>383582826
why the fuck are you comparing nier to zelda?
are you fucking retarded?
both are great games but not even slightly comparable

>>383585297
Or a great flameblade or whatever. works too

>>383585359

Feel free to refute any of it.
I'll wait

File: 1490026365989.webm (2MB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1280x720px

>Nier: Waifu Bait is a much better game

>>383585398
Unless you drop into cold water durians can get you anywhere baby. Or you can just wear the warm doublet and get a fire-element weapon. Simple as that

>>383584638
>ign and gamespot suddenly matters
you nintenbros are funny

>>383585328
The guy brought a strong weapon to his first blight ganon. I destroyed my second blight ganon even faster due to getting mastersword early.

>>383585469
What are his points? I wouldn't refute his point that combat is really fucking easy and simple, but if he shits on exploration I do have a bone to pick with him

File: FixedDefiniteKawala.webm (2MB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1280x720px

>>383585375
>A game about exploration punishes you for exploring by making the bosses even bigger pushovers.

Really makes ya think.

Defend this.

>>383585361

It's easy. Being easy is not a flaw.

One has abysmal combat mechanics, terrible movesets, pathetic "boss" fights, and combat that punishes you for using weapons.

>>383583962
Final boss music is actually the best song in the game imo.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gaaLWh-5Esc

I didn't like it at all when I first heard it, it's bizarre out of context. After completing the game though, I think it's great. I'm a sucker for final boss music that reprises a game's main theme, and this game goes above and beyond with that by incorporating the field music, Ganon's music, Zelda's music, and other various motifs found throughout the game. It perfectly encapsulates that feeling of adventure they were shooting for.

Shame the fight itself is a bit shit.

>>383585552
>punishes you by making fights easier
Isn't that a reward? A punish would be making fights harder you memeing fuck

Nier Automata ost is fucking garbage
how can anyone like it?

>>383585551
The act of exploration and how you move around the world is the one thing that is praised.

However the empty world is a big issue discussed.

>>383585551
He said it's the best open world in a game he's ever played.

>>383585601
Wait are you talking about Nier or breath of the wild? I really can't tell. Especially on the hard difficulty

>>383585361
I'm not seeing anything wrong here,keep in mind I haven't played it yet

>>383584638
>ign or gamespot
Stop,you faggots should stop using these retards only to shitpost

>>383582826
>Unengaging boring combat
>Repetitive enemies
>Tumblr-tier story (read a book you faggots)
>PS2-tier bland environments
>Muh waifu material
>Endless grinding
>Have to play through game 5 times to get ending
Sure famalam. It's retarded to compare the 2 in the first place, but Nier Autismo is just plain shit and the only people who fell for it are fat ultraweeb neckbeards.

>>383585669
He never said it was empty iirc, or he didn't say it in a negative way. He said it's the game with the best exploration in years too, so it can't be that big of an issue

>>383585702
If you just mash the dodge button it's impossible to get hit.

>>383582826
wow I guess botw is terrible after all *throws botw cart out the window*

>>383585383
D-defend this!

>>383585675

>Nier
>terrible movesets
kek


BotW has liek 3 movesets in the entire game

NieR Automata is album of the year, that just happens to come with quite a good game.

It never commits enough to its own premise and lacks the sharp focus of other similar games like the original Nier or MGS2. All these games are weird and jump around, but Automata is the only one that does nothing really well, everything is just okay with some amazing moments, all carried by the music.

>>383585741
>Muh waifu material
not a negative
>Endless grinding
lol?
>Have to play through game 5 times to get ending
you play through it twice for ending a/b
you play through a different arc for c/d/e

you're retarded

>>383585807
Yeah but Nier has fucking terrible movesets for an extremely action-focused game. And weapons become more of a chore as hacking is always the best options on hard difficulty. Normal is way too easy too, enemies are so braindead you can just repeat the same combo over and over again

>>383585842
Route B was such a damn chore I almost dropped the game

C D and E are also pretty short

>>383585914
Delete this webm. Right now.

>>383585914

>optional flashy shit when all of those enemies can be one hit

This can be done in tons of games.

>>383582826
>muh minimalist soundtrack

Nah, Breath of the Wild has a fantastic OST. It's minimalist field themes are the ultimate pleb filter. It went against the grain of what people expected from a Zelda game's music, and the end result is a really memorable and unique soundtrack that feels tailor made to capture the themes/tone of the game. It's subtle when it needs to be, but not shy when it comes time to be as grandiose as previous Zelda title either.

Even if you dislike the direction personally, it's hard to argue that it isn't at least distinct. Especially amongst it's peers.

Compare it to the music another open world fantasy game, Horizon Zero Dawn, and the difference is night and day.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z0SAuvSghHo

Not trying to pick on that game though, just saying.

>>383585970
route b was much shorter than a, i found it entertaining due to the different perspective

Haven't played the new zelda but Nier was kind of a disappointment coming from the superior first game

>>383585998
>one hit
Have you played the game lol. Only guardian arrows can one hit later on in the game

>>383586004
>and the end result is a really memorable and unique soundtrack

Literally the ONLY part of the BotW "OST" that I can recall is the random Piano key repeat that plays in the fields sometimes because it's so jarring to hear randomly.

Contrast this with Hyrule field in OOT which I can still hum exactly from memory and I'm a Nintendo hater

>>383586037
First game's combat was so bad that it's almost worth just watching it on youtube.

I don't understand these threads
can't we just be happy that there are multible good games?
I think haveing two good games is better than one

>>383586114
>Have you played the game lol

>RED fucking Bokoblins
>hAvE yOU pLAyeD tHe GaME lOL

>>383586132
>Katy Perry is better than Vivaldi because her music is so catchy xD!

>>383586132
>I'm an X hater
>can't hum the lost woods theme
Are you a literal child

>>383585998
Are you fucking blind? Not only is not a single enemy in that webm one hit, but that clip is exactly the kind of strategy the game encourages on a regular basis with it's level design.

The fact that isn't a forced/scripted setpiece makes it all the more impressive, as every player gets to make their own little moments like that thanks to the tools provided by the game's engine/AI.

>>383583092
>Better combat
>Better Soundtrack
>Better ambience
No.

>>383582826
BotW doesn't have a minimalist soundtrack, it has more music in it than Nier does. It just isn't present in the main field areas so that the environment can do some heavy lifting with the ambiance. Literally every town, dungeon, different combat scenario, boss, miniboss, and unique area has several music pieces. Automata's soundtrack has some amazing pieces, but they are diamonds in an otherwise mediocre OST, especially when compared with Nier's godlike soundtrack.

>>383586198
Even red bokoblins can't be one hit unless you drink attack boosting elixers and used a charged attack. Normal blows take like 3-4 hits on strong weapons. Maybe I'm remembering wrong because I have not seen a red bokoblin in ages

>>383586132
I'm sorry that you're too ADHD to notice all of the subtle variations in the music, stuff that's hard to pick up on when just Youtubing the OST, or even acknowledge all of the other area specific tunes in the game.

Probably because you didn't play it.

>>383586259

with Weapons that aren't that Tooth pick Traveler's sword they're destroyed in 1 hit easily.

>but that clip is exactly the kind of strategy the game encourages on a regular basis with it's level design.
If you want to be flashy and inefficient. It's easy and safer to just walk in and kill them by throwing a bomb at a group.

>>383586314
on my 2nd playthrough on master mode i've been one shotting every Red boko since I left the plateau

>>383583296
So he is mad that you can be strong by using things that make the game easier. I guess playing Automata on the easiest difficulty breaks the game.

>>383584769
Not that guy but played both on PC and didn't have to spend a single dime.

>>383586374

>every single time someone has a criticism of BotW you retards respond with DIDNT PLAY LOL
Honestly pathetic.

>>383586448
>red bokos
>master mode
LIAR

>>383586448
>with Weapons that aren't that Tooth pick Traveler's sword they're destroyed in 1 hit easily.

It's a good thing all you have are sticks and Travelers Swords at the early points in the game where you're fighting Red Bokoblins then huh?

>If you want to be flashy and inefficient. It's easy and safer to just walk in and kill them by throwing a bomb at a group.

>I hate fun

>>383585601
I agree, Nier really is pretty bad. Good thing none of that applies to BotW.

>>383586448

>red bokoblin
>master mode

Where? I need a photo

>>383586521
Well maybe if you put in more effort to formulate opinions that don't come across as uneducated as they do, you wouldn't be mistaken for a shitposter.

>>383586448
There is like one red bokoblin in the entirety of master mode. Who do you think you're fooling?

>>383586525
>>383586602
Meant the tier 1s. my mistake.

With all the strong weapons on every single floating balloon platform (which are conveniently above water often) you often weapons that 1 shot the blues.

>>383585998
Yeah, I watched a friend play through all of Automata by running away and spamming the gun. Why both with the mediocre swordplay when you can easily run n gun and hack shit?

>>383584865
>Besides game play is not solely combat

Good post. Everybody needs to read this line.

>>383586715
>one shot blues
Show me.

>>383586715
>1 shot blues
I still find it hard to believe, especially since they have buffed health. You're saying they fall in water right?

If not they won't get one shot

>>383586715
You should stop digging and give up while you're ahead.

File: 1493287754199m.jpg (156KB, 1024x782px) Image search: [Google]

156KB, 1024x782px

>>383584638
Personally, I haven't stopped laughing since BotW launched. Watching /v/ getting so savagely and hilariously BTFO was the most satisfying thing I've witnessed in along time.

And watching the salty kiddies desperately shitposting for 4 fucking months solid as they frantically try to convince themselves otherwise is just glorious.

Long may it continue.

>>383586737

That's essentially the "drop a bomb and run away" strat in BotW

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0203jbYU0TI

>>383586801
easiest example is that there is a Knight's Claymore on the Waterfall platforms near the Cryonis Shrine.
Straight up 1 shot blue bokos.

>>383586836
see above
You can acquire weapons with 35+ power in Master mode everywhere.

Blues being one shot isn't even farfetched.

>>383586923
Cool, thanks for the weapon recommendation

>>383586132
It's not worth anon
There was a MFA anon on other thread that called BOTW OST lazy and not memorable compared to past Zeldas.Guess what happened? same shit that's happening here
And yeah,he posted proof.

>>383584908
>using a weapon specifically designed to bust the bosses up easier than others
>which you must have played for many hours and explored half the content in the game to get
>makes the boss easier
And they didn't show the part before that where it had to be shot out of the sky, or after it where you must get it down with ice cubes flying at you and half the room being underwater.

Now, defend Nier's trash "perfect dodge into easy combos" combat which, unlike BotW, doesn't have any variety to offset it.

File: 1454314368379.jpg (23KB, 294x333px) Image search: [Google]

23KB, 294x333px

Breath of the Wilds only real flaws are that of pacing, and a lack of variety. Those really don't become apparent until like 60+ hours into the game though, where Link is an overpowered monster with so many weapons that he's literally throwing them out for new ones before they can even break. When you've already filled out the entire map and seen a good chunk of what there is too see, and the magic starts to wear off a bit as the game becomes a checklist scavenger hunt instead of a grand exploration adventure.

That said though, the game somehow still manages to sneak in a surprise here and there. They just become fewer, farther away, and less impact the longer you've been playing. Given how open they wanted the game to be however, I don't see any way they could have really avoided this while still maintaining some semblance of progression.

Everything else about the game, from the moment to moment gameplay to the aesthetic to the music, that shit is tighter than a virgin pussy and far outweighs any of the negatives found in it's late game.

>>383587006
>MFA
Opinion discarded. MFA faggots are the fucking worst with their superiority complex when they are working in fast food restaurants

>>383586132
So you never once played BotW. Got it.

>>383587229
I don't know he might have skipped through some areas with good music given the nature of the game

But then again how can you not appreciate hyrule castle? You have to go through that right?

>>383587006

How depressing.
I genuinely like the game and can accept all it's flaws instead of outright denying that it has flaws.

I don't even care that the game has a weak OST but for many people the zone/field Music in Zelda games is a big deal.
Hell, the series has Orchestral concerts

>>383587006
The Molduga and Tarrey town tracks alone are better and more memorable than most Zelda OSTs combined, so your opinion doesn't really mean much to me.

>>383587330
See >>383586280

You are litetally just ignoring tracks the the many village and town themes, the miniboss themes, Hyrule Castle, and the Blight battles, among others.

>>383587295
I highly doubt that, as even the main quest stuff has killer music. Divine Beasts, each individual town, and any track related to Zelda or Ganon

If Rito Village doesn't stick in your head after spending some time there, you literally don't have a soul.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7QZ1MV_Au44

>>383583092
>better soundtrack
I love the game, but it has barely any music at all. They really fucked up there.

>>383587330
Some people arn't so autistic that they think different = bad.

They made the field music minimalist because they knew that people would be spending the majority of their playtime there, and having a blaring field tune constantly looping for 100+ hours would be tiring real fucking fast. If you've ever done extensive grinding in an MMO type of game, you'll know exactly what the devs were thinking about when they came to this decision.

Having chill, non-intrusive piano that changes subtly depending on location/scenario is far more preferable, with the more grandious tracks saved for specific areas/setpieces. It also doing a good job of setting the mood in this new ruined, abandoned Hyrule is just an added bonus.

It's subjective to be sure and you're entitled to your opinion, but it's an intention design decision that far from a flaw.

File: faggots.jpg (72KB, 960x540px) Image search: [Google]

72KB, 960x540px

>>383587341
Literally couldn't even recall what Tarrey Town sounded like til I opened the game to post this screen shot because BotW defenders are cancer.

It's straight up pathetic that 90% of the "defense" of criticism in these threads is "you didn't play it"
Actually, sitting here listening to Tarry town, it sounds like a boring minimalist rip-off of the typical Etrian Odyssey series' town music.

>>383587529
>ignoring
You mean "forgetting" them once I was no longer in the area because they're so one-note and quickly forgotten.
God I hate you all

>>383588003
>One-Note
Whatever the fuck does it mean? The dungeon music even changes as you go

>>383587923

I agree with this whole post and enjoyed the BotW OST.
I'm not in the camp of the minimalist OST being bad

>>383588073
Lacking in variation
Simple
etc

Causes them to become white noise quickly and forgotten just as quickly.

>>383583092
Niers combat is a shit tier version of bayonetta

>>383588205
simple? The dungeon music is ambient and fantastic, with various underlying tones while getting more triumphant as you go. So underrated

Why the fuck would anyone want to compare Zelda and Nier, that's the real question? They're two completely different types of games with very different things they're trying to accomplish. It's cliche to say, but you're comparing apples to oranges.

At least with Horizon shitpositing, it kind of makes sense seeing as they're both open world fantasy games with a focus on bow combat, hunting mechanics, exploration etc.

But this bait is just silly.

>>383588003
>pulled image of the game from the internet
>claims to have played it
>clearly everyone that says the music is great is wrong, me and the voices in my head are right
Bow is the music "one note" when almost every track in the game has at LEAST two variations depending on the situation? Tarrey Town has about 5 of them, if I recall right. Sorry your memory is shit, bro.

These kinds of fucking threads are the /v/ equivalent of clickbait. Breath of the Wild is currently popular so you dickride the success to push your shitty opinions.

You could have just made a thread about NieR's OST but you had to go and be a faggot about it.

>>383588312

I'll try to pay more attention to the music when I get to the beasts on master mode but I can't even recall what any of them sound like atm

>>383588349
Not even gonna read beyond your first line.
Not playing the Goal Post game with you

>>383588205
>Lacking in variation
>Simple
Neither of which can be applied to BotW's music, least of all the former.

>>383588205

>Every dungeon, town, and unique area, as well as certain enemies, has it's not only it's own theme music, but in most cases several variations on it's music depending on things like time of day, weather, the player being indoors or outdoors, the player's progress in a quest, etc.

>Music lacks variety

Fuck off nigger.

>>383588383
Well yeah, I imagine you wouldn't read posts that blow you the fuck out. You are literally lying through your teeth (or fingers, rather) at this point. Again, sorry you have a shit memory.

>>383588205
I think you should see a doctor, as I think you've got a problem with short term memory loss.

>>383582826
Original Nier has much better soundtrack and story
And BOTW has much better everything

>>383588383
I will give you the sparknotes version of that post, friend:

"How is the music "one note" when almost every track in the game has at LEAST two variations depending on the situation? Tarrey Town has about 5 of them, if I recall right. Sorry your memory is shit, bro."

>>383588593
Thiiiiiiiiis.

>>383588361
Exactly this. BotW butt blasted sonybros so hard that after 4 months they are still making bait threads.

>>383582826
>"I don't care what anyone says"
>posts on /v, obviously baiting
Ok, anon. Sure.

File: 1499514596417.png (34KB, 350x289px) Image search: [Google]

34KB, 350x289px

Can't we just agree that they're both equally good games, and are just fun to play?

>>383589623
I think most people would. OP is a shitposter stirring the pot.

See >>383588348

>>383588748
Nier is a multiplat

>>383582826
hahaha grow some taste

>>383586132
>Contrast this with Hyrule field in OOT which I can still hum exactly from memory and I'm a Nintendo hater

18+ board friend

>>383582826
>new age garbage like Automata's ost
>good

Kill yourself

File: American games.gif (3MB, 1471x1846px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 1471x1846px

I've played five hours of BoTW. So far it's pretty much like any other open-world but with better scenery. When does it get good?

>>383587923
I love how the shitposters completely ignore this post.

>>383588348
They're both videogames, though. And if you've played both you should be able to elect which one you enjoyed most.

>>383591458
When you turn on pro hud. How far in are you? It's fine to take off your training wheels

>>383591458
You do some stuff on the Great plateau, and then you go to Karakiko, then Hateno, then back to Kakariko, and then the game kind of just stops telling you where to go. You can go anywhere you want after that.

>>383591476
I enjoyed both, for different reasons.

I really love fucking Ghost Trick too, it's one of my favorite games of all time, but I wouldn't compare that to Breath of the Wild either because it's completely redundant. They're completely different games that are appealing for completely different reasons.

The gameplay, story, aesthetics, presentation, music, writing, none of it is even comparable because the game developers had completely separate goals and ambitions with each individual project. They arn't competing with each-other to provide comparable experiences.

>>383583296
Nier fucks up the defense mechanics aswell, you can heal from 1 to full with no animation and on hard you can get one shotted out of nowhere even going hard on defense and +HP chips

File: WiiU_screenshot_TV_01C94.jpg (442KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

442KB, 1280x720px

ignore; just posting BotW screens

>>383583214
You're overreacting bro.

They are similar games in a similar genre. Now just chill, can you?

>>383583837
>Terrible weapon durability mechanic that was supposed to incentivize different approachs to combat but only makes it more tedious
>No enemy variety
>Empty open world

These are reasons enough why BotW is a shitty, overrated game.

OoT and MM, games from 15 years ago, are better designed than this boring trash.

>>383594590
Those are reasons why you think BotW is shitty and overrated. I'm sure many people disagree with you though

>>383583296
>citing that horrible video as proof of anything
Joseph Anderson is a meme, and he's complaining about something he didn't encounter, which developers knew most people wouldn't encounter. Great point there

>Comparing two completely different games that just happen to have released around the same time

When is this shitty fucking board gonna let us have decent BOTW/Automata threads again

>>383583837
>They're both shit, senpai.
No, you're just a typical /v/tard shitting on everything and nitpicking

>>383594694
>people disagree with an opinion
no shit

>>383594908
All Automata threads are nothing but robutt posting. They'll never be good again. You want to talk Nier you need to make a Drakengard thread.