>x game isn't an RPG because it doesn't fit

>expecting me to even acknowledge something that doesn't fit my autistic standards
Fuck off Frodo

X isn't an RPG, dingus.
It's a space sim

Witcher 3 fag detected

Why do JRPG fans honestly believe 99% of the games are RPGs just because the publishers said they are?

>>383346517
Persona and/or Morrowfag detected

>x game is an RPG because it has stats

>>383346456
Underated

Nothing is an RPG.

>>383346517
I like witcher 3 but calling it an rpg is just stupid.

The Legend of Zelda is an RPG because you play the role of Zelda

>>383346912
Why?

I'm playing a role. That of Geralt.

It is a role playing game by definition.

If a game doesnt have
>character creation
>questlines that arent forcefed (including the main quest)
>(ideally) questlines with multiple coutcomes
then it isn't an RPG.

>>383347078
>>383347085
Every game is a RTS, cause in real time i strategize what to do :)

>>383347085
So is any video game where you play a character an RPG? No. You are just ignorantly calling it an RPG because of the medieval fantasy setting.

>>383344628
t. todd

>>383347085
yeah dude Zelda is my favorite RPG!

>>383346517
Hello Gothicfag!

File: ohshitimsorry.png (442KB, 492x463px) Image search: [Google]

442KB, 492x463px

>>383344628
>I got btfo when I called Zelda an RPG so now I'll make a passive-aggressive thread due to my lack of argument against the person I was talking to

>>383347189
But by that logic a lot of games that call themselves RPGs would in fact not be RPGs.

>>383347632
exactly
RPG has become a a meaningless buzzword

>>383346730
Well, the ones who make and produce games usually define what the games are. Makes sense, right?

I mean, if I wanted to make a new genre of music the best way to do that would be for me to create new music and call it that genre instead of autistically screeching at artists that produce in a certain genre that they don't produce said genre.

>>383347078
>>383347269
Every game is a first person action game, because I am looking at the screen through my eyes and I have to press buttons to make things happen.

im glad im not autistic

>>383344628
>Maybe if I leave the statement ambiguous people won't call me a faggot for thinking Zelda is an RPG

>>383346912
>Player choices change the outcome of the plot
>Not an RPG
Pick one

>>383344628
Is Call of Duty an rpg?
Yes

>>383348571
>you get to roleplay as a bunch of different people during a single run
It's clearly the best rpg.

File: mongolian pleasure.jpg (36KB, 800x600px) Image search: [Google]

36KB, 800x600px

>>383344628
>any game with any qualities remotely resembling those found in RPGs are RPGs
>I have no standards

File: 1455631213282.png (712KB, 518x691px) Image search: [Google]

712KB, 518x691px

>>383344628
>x game isn't a roguelike because it doesn't fit my autistic standards

>>383347748
>want to make smooth jazz
>play blast beats at high bpm and highly distorted metal riffs
>but I call it smooth jazz so it is
post-modernism was a mistake

>>383348132
Every game with multiple endings is an RPG

>>383344628
Niggers just dont understand that all (most?) games have core gameplay that those games based on, as example Final Fantasies is just turn-based tactics, you cant "role-play" for shit in those.
If you want people to "role-play", you need to provide ingame instruments for that, it shouldn't be just your imagination.
And "RPG" "action" "shooter" genres, as of now, is just marketing stamps to sell the game, they are meaningless.

>>383350126
Whoa, calm down there with the n-bomb buddy. Totally uncalled for

>>383350567
Im not from muricas, its not offensive here, to me or to anyone i know.

>>383350784
That's probably because you're all either white or a bunch FUCKING NIGGERS.