The top 11 games of 2017 so far are: 11. Persona 5 10. Tekk

Yes Horizon Zero Dawn is better than Zelda Breath of The Wild.

>>383265661
Swap Prey with Hollow Knight and this is a good list.

File: 1497111864081.png (96KB, 756x636px) Image search: [Google]

96KB, 756x636px

>this thread again

Here's a quick summary to save you reading 300 posts.

>>383265661
>>383265615
This is all this thread will become.

Because I feel that BotW is better than HZD. And so do a lot of people.
So enjoy your BotW versus HZD thread.

what a terrible year for gaming

I honestly dont care which one of these games is supposed to be the number 1 but it sure as hell isnt the fucking shitheap known as Horizon.

>>383265904
Yeah. Literally every other game on that list deserves to be above Horizon.

>>383265904
>I don't care but I still care enough to disagree with them

>>383265615
>Nier Automata
>Not number one

>>383265615
No, i do not agree. I think everything GG has made has been awful including their latest gimmick release.

11. Didn't play, looks too heavily story based but a fairly cool art style.
10. Used to love the series but this looked crap.
9. Might get it when it's really dirt cheap.
8. The demo was fairly crap and then I totally missed release.
7. Same as above.
6. Didn't interest me.
5. Loved the demo hated the game.
4. Pretty good. Disappointed there's no unlockables to keep me going (other than shitty cosmetics)
3. Arma 2 is it was worse, right? Skipped.
2. Hated every second then sold it.
1. Looked like absolute garbage.

This has been the best year of games in close to a decade, but no I do not agree with this list.

File: 1499457528156.jpg (45KB, 494x468px) Image search: [Google]

45KB, 494x468px

>>383266494
t.Contrarian

You don't even like video games. Why do you come here then?

>>383265615
Nah, BOTW is above and beyond Horizon. Persona 5 is better than both, though, and i'm offended it's that low.

>>383266494
Oh look a toddler and a steamfag at the same time

>>383266653
Like I said, this has been the best year in ages. I just can't stand the open world blight. I don't hate videogames because I don't like the same as you chucklefucks.

File: 1488990954810.jpg (114KB, 800x600px) Image search: [Google]

114KB, 800x600px

>>383265615
>11. Persona 5
>11

>>383266494
You really hate fun vidya gaymes don't you?

>>383266731
I play on PS4 and Switch mostly. You realise other games have come out right, you mongoloid.

>>383265615
Zelda would be number one if it had a female protagonist

>>383266825
Best year in ages? You don't seem to like any of the best games this year.

At best you like indie shit which just confirms your shit taste even further.

>In 10 years, people will still be talking about innovative things that 'Horizon Zero Dawn' does. They will still be talking about how gorgeous it is, how smart and funny its main character is, how it succeeded commercially in the shadow of a new Nintendo console and a new 'Legend of Zelda' game.

>While playing games, I often experience a small handful of emotions: frustration, accomplishment, fear. While playing 'Horizon Zero Dawn,' that list expanded dramatically -- outside of delighting in the graceful, smart gameplay systems that underlie the game's narrative focus, I often laughed out loud at Aloy's smart quips (she's the antagonist you see above). I found myself endlessly curious about the surprisingly deep lore of the game's world, its people and religions, and the main character's story arc. Perhaps most important of all, I actually cared about the main character, believed her motivations, and wanted her to succeed.

>'Horizon Zero Dawn' is a magnificent accomplishment of a game that stands out among standouts. And I didn't even mention the giant metal dinosaurs.

Played everything except prey from that list and yes, I'd agree. Except for injustice, that can fuck off.

>>383266969
Considering how forced the discussion here is already about the game, and how little people care about the alleged game of the decade now (TLOU) I heavily doubt anyone will be talking about GG's latest crap.

>>383266909
It basically does.

>>383265615
>Dead Cells not even on the list

I thought hard games were the cool things to praise? Or was it too hard for the author?

>>383266487
Automata shouldnt even be on the list.
It's not a game, it's pure art.

>>383265615
It they are going to make a Sony Exclusive take the 1st spot they might as well used a game that is actually good.

>>383266969
>>383267128
I don't know who wrote this article at Buisness insider but they're complete fucking morons. HZD has already been forgotten by the masses, and BoTW is the game that will go down in history as a pivotal point for the Zelda franchise and Open World games in general.

>>383267247
All games are art you dumb shitposter

>>383265615
Have played p5 and hzd.

Shit, hzd seriously?

P5: Was great, but already kinda forgotten for me and I was hyped for years

T7 is a ton a fun even with friends who know dick-all about fighting games. Only casually played this and haven't played another before.

Nioh is one of the games I'm actually leaning toward getting a ps4 over switch

Nier likes to crash all the time. Glad I pirated it before buying. Spent 2+ hours trying to fix it

Isn't Injustice 2 broken? Haven't played

I played RE7 3 different times and still haven't got very far. My buddy has it on psvr, and we did that on acid, so I don't think I can play it any other way

PUBG is great. I wish it wasn't included since it's early access, but it's still a fantastic time. Here's hoping new map will be different but better

BOTW is a fantastic game that's not for me. I just have a problem with fast breaking weapons (which, admittedly wasn't too big a deal), hunting for food to sell and having to worry about "oh no, I'm out of arrows, this boss fight is pretty much DOA." Wish it had more music too.

(You) The Thread

>>383267326
>Nintendo fans actually believe this

>>383267369
>All games are art
Nice bait.

>>383267326
BoTW will go down in history as an example of how NOT to design your gear/weapon system.

>>383266969
Pretty sure Nier Asstomato is the only game that did anything new (read: combined a bunch of gameplay and story elements from different pixelshit games but in a 3D AA game) on that entire list

>>383267326
Pretty much. Look at all the people talking about TLOU. Truly the game of the year of all years, everyone talks about it.

I feel like the article was written months ago and got just published. It feels like the author is fully caught into the hype.

>>383267558
>nice bait
Your definition of art is more than likely lacking

>>383265809
What if your keyboard broke every time you posted a post? That's BotW

You can cut 10, 9, 7, and 6 from the list and flip Persona 5 with BOTW.

>>383265615

Am I the only one who thinks Nier was better than Horizon? Why do people keep rating Horizon high?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DUpPYvELLB8

File: 1497319660901.jpg (115KB, 499x499px) Image search: [Google]

115KB, 499x499px

Typical page paid by sony
Sure sony also won the e3

>>383265615

Keeping with what is already on the list and just shuffling to correct order.

11. Prey
10. Mario Kart 8 Deluxe
9. PUB
8. Persona 5
7. Nioh
6. Injustice 2
5. Resident Evil 7
4. Tekken 7
3. BotW
2. N:A
1. HZD

>>383268071

Because despite what people want you to think it's a very well made game and a new IP to boot. It's the best overall new IP of the year so far.

>>383267802
What if every time you shot a gun, you had less bullets?

File: 1480409969974.gif (3MB, 300x225px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 300x225px

>>383265615
>6. Injustice 2
>1. Horizon Zero Dawn

>>383267797
Art is something unique of its kind.

A 4 legged plain stool is not art, it's a simple work of a craftsman.
A cleverly designed stool is art.

A yearly FIFA game is not art.
A game that does something that hasnt been done before - is.

You forgot RiME and Get Even, two games which are sadly mostly ignored by /v/

>>383268081
Yes anon. Everyone is paid by sony. EVERYONE. Even your parents.

>>383265615
>.de
Yurofag propping up Sony games?
NAAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHHH

>>383268335

What if every day you wore the same armor/clothing that is constantly being hit by enemies it broken down until you were totally naked.

Oh wait I forgot Link's clothing/armor never shows signs of damage like that because the secret to BotW is that his clothing is really the ultimate weapon.

DLC coming 2018.

>>383265615
how many times have he had this thread?

>>383268335
What if your gun broke down 4 shots into a gunfight and you had to sift through your backpack to choose another weapon?

>>383268550

Starless is a game. Starless lets me get my dick cut off and turned into a human toilet. Starless, is art because no other game has let this happen before.

File: horizon.webm (3MB, 960x540px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 960x540px

>>383268290
>it's a very well made game
HAHAHAHA

Played all 3
Prefer PUBG

>>383268770
Yes, it's art.
Just like sculptures made of trash and paintings made by smearing poop on the canvas.

>>383268769
Not him but Link is the gun and the weapons are the bullets in the analogy.

>>383265615
I don't get what people see in Horizon, I've played it and it's mostly just like a mass produced Ubisoft open world game.
The best thing about it is the enemy variety, but the combat isn't very good so it doesn't mean much

File: 279.jpg (41KB, 375x375px) Image search: [Google]

41KB, 375x375px

>injustice 2
>better than tekken 7

>>383268769
You mean what if there was a reloading mechanic?

THE HORROR

>>383268071
If you played Horizon then you would know that the cutscene you posted is 0.5% of the game.

>>383268931
>never been a gun before
>you're a gun in this game
Trully a revolutionary GOAT experience.

>>383266494
Your favorite game was another Mario Kart rehash?

File: 1499396696541.png (75KB, 364x603px) Image search: [Google]

75KB, 364x603px

>>383268780
>Wear stealth gear in tall grass
>"LOL LOOK HOW STUPID THE ENEMY IS THEY CANT EVEN SEE ME"
You done?

>>383269239
Of course, and I'm sad that you're missing out on the GOTG.
It doesn't do anyone good to sour grape and vent their envy through shitposting.

File: Escape from the planet of the robot monsters.jpg (166KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

166KB, 1280x720px

>>383265615
wow the most famous games everyone talks about.
Do critics do research any more, or nah?

>no Yakuza
Sad!

File: IMG_20170306_210620.jpg (4MB, 4032x3024px) Image search: [Google]

4MB, 4032x3024px

>>383268780

>>383269512
post your black hand

>>383269439
>projecting this hard

>>383269234
Every dialogue scene in Horizon is unbearable, and they're constant all the way through.
The NPCs' weird, twitching faces and the bad writing give me a headache.
Though, I have to say they wouldn't matter much if the game was otherwise good

>>383265615
>10. tekken 7
>6. injustice 2
>7. Nier automata
>1 Horizon
Wow

>>383269732
>muh projection

>>383265615
I went through this thread yesterday, not again so soon, y'all have fun.

File: GG.png (27KB, 624x265px) Image search: [Google]

27KB, 624x265px

>>383265615
>So far
Horizon will go down the list. I'd be surprised if it's higher than 5, and that's just because people will remember the name.

File: horizon zero ai.webm (3MB, 960x544px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 960x544px

>>383269385
>>"LOL LOOK HOW STUPID THE ENEMY IS THEY CANT EVEN SEE ME" XDXDXD
kek

>>383265615
>Hollow Knight not on the list
>first place being worse than almost all of the rest of the list, specially Persona 5, Nier and Zelda
Shit list desu.

>>383269669

Well thanks for making absolutely no sense. Than again I was just as confused when BotW glitched like that, trapped me in a platform and forced me to restarted the game.

>>383269008
You can say about the game itself what you want but from a casuals perspective it makes sense. Tekkens story mode was garbage, they replaced all the fun gameplay modes with treasure battle and the customization is worse than the one in injustice. Obviously tekken 7 is the better fighting game but injustice outclasses it in everything around it.

>>383268962
It's a good PS4 exclusive, but if it was released on other platforms, it'd be considered way worse than FarCry 4, but not everyone is going to play it since it's tied down to a sony console.

>>383270059
>Posts more pre-release footage that has been patched since day 0 and even further on since then.

>>383265615
>L-ook! It w-was an innovative game! Sony wins again... ha ha ha...

>>383268071
Pcbro spotted

>>383270058
Crash isnt a new ip though, so why the comparison?

>>383267527
Yes, Nintendo fans, but if you actually pay attention to the developer scene, studios around the industry have straight up come out and said that Breath of the Wild was a mic drop to all the other open world developers and proof that they were nowhere near accomplishing perfect open world design despite how comfortable and lax in their game design they had become.

Breath of the Wild making a huge impact on the open world game genre is pretty much an objective fact at this point.

>>383270451
Why hasn't anyone made a webm showing this patched AI?

>>383270451
Not that anon but the AI is indeed pretty retarded in that game most of the time.
The game has good graphics, good enemy variety, good ranged combat and great setting. However none of these is phenomenal and both the characters and story are pretty bland (the only likable one is unironically Aloy) making for a good but not a great game.

>>383270696
Because the game is dynamic. Capturing the same moments is near impossible.
>>383270742
Only Human AI which has since been patched in the latest patch even.

File: 1311879811651.jpg (85KB, 400x400px) Image search: [Google]

85KB, 400x400px

>>383270451

That reminds me we just got the free patch/update that gives us new game+ as well as ULTRA HARD mode.

I love it when developers add new difficulty levels and for free as they were always intended to be.

>>383270247
Replace PS4 with switch and you perfectly described botw.

File: 1420961754316.png (2MB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1280x720px

>No Yakuza 0
>No Dead Cells
>No Hollow Knight
>Fucking Mario kart in fourth
>Persona 5 stone dead last

Every time I look at these lists they make me angry.

>>383265615
What a bunch of shitty games, is this unironically the worst list of games since the 90s.

>>383270840
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4lIz3B6Lhdg
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Lvx9SViyyqc
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o_cLrShaxM0
so good
>b-but it's dynamic!

>>383270975
Journalists have irredeemably shit taste, tell us something new.

>>383270975

MK8D is the only one that really pisses me off it should be 11 or not even on the list to begin with. It's basically Mario Kart 8 GOTY edition.

>/v/ now defends a game where the MC is voiced by Ashly Burch
What a time to be alive

>people just proudly post normalshit and discuss ecelebs on /v/ now

>>383270945
Not when devs from other open world games praise it. Didn't hear them mention anything on Horizon.

>>383271060
>Walks out of corrupted zone with a corrupted watcher
>It doesn't follow you to the end of earth but instead returns
Literally what?

>>383266494
>8. Demo was fairly crap
The Nioh demos were fucking great you shitter

>>383265615
>>383266653
If you actually played and enjoyed a single one of those games you don't like video games, you like "videogames". There was at least a single good game so far this year and it's not even on the list what a joke.

>>383271246
Ofcourse you wouldn't because /v/ only shits on the game.

https://gamingcentral.in/witcher-3-devs-loving-horizon-zero-dawn-congratulate-guerrilla-games-fan-art/

>>383265615
is horizon really that good? From what Ive seen its just a boring TPS with an ugly protag.
Or its just Sony shilling everywhere?

>>383271435
You have been cuddled by 1 single RPG that kept your dick hard for months and now you don't have that RPG anymore. It is time to realize that not every game needs to be designed to keep your dick hard for months.
You are a blight on /v/ mentality.

>faggots that don't play video games
>.de

Everyone knows FIFA is the best video game of 2017.
Sales don't lie.

>>383271435
>There was at least a single good game so far this year and it's not even on the list what a joke.
Which?

>>383271606
Then BOTW came out and blew it out of the water. That's pretty much a participation award what you posted.

>>383265615
HZD was pretty fucking good. It has flaws, but it wasnt the feminist sjw bullshit /v/ tried to claim it was.

>>383265615
>11. Memersona 5
>10. Memekken 7
>9. Memey
>8. Memeioh
>7. Nier Automemea
>6. Inmemestice 2
>5. Resident Memevil 7
>4. Memeio Kart 8 Memeluxe
>3. PlayerUnknown's Memegrounds
>2. The Legend of Memelda: Breath of the Meme
>1. Meme Zero Dawn

Yeah, no.

>>383271868
nice moving the goalpost

>>383270975
can you really be upset that yakuza isn't on the list? its fundamental flaw is being grindy as fuck.

on top of that you have
>sloppy control response for blocking
>repetitive/unvaried minigames
>subtitle entrypoint/willingness to read
>open world encounters akin to pokemon
>long cutscenes
>unforgiving bosses (if you play any difficulty below hard)/constant item abuse

You and I might be able to overlook these, but it's pretty glaring that this game has its flaws.

File: Untitled.png (895KB, 1367x700px) Image search: [Google]

895KB, 1367x700px

>>383270451
I tried to find where this "pre-release footage" is from, but all I found is a thread from yesterday with someone saying pretty much the same thing 14 hours ago. Have you been browsing 4chan for 14 hours?

>>383271767
I played vanilla wow for a little less than a month that's not a very new game.
>>383271860
Battle Brothers was fun, it's like a turn based Mount and Blade with fantasy elements.

>>383271972
>High five for effort is the same as "praise"
No goal has been moved

>>383271860
I bet he means Yakuza 0

That just seems like the pick a guy who made that post would have

>>383272159
>>383272119

>>383271969
you can't just dismiss a game by calling it a meme

>>383265615
>4. Mario Kart 8 Deluxe
>1. Horizon Zero Dawn
These 2 are too high.

>11. Persona 5
>7. Nier Automata
These 2 should be in top 3, how are they so low?

>>383272159
>That just seems like the pick a guy who made that post would have
why would you think that?

>>383272254

>you can't just meme this game by memeing it a meme

Meme

>>383265615
Horizon zero what?
Is that an indie?

>>383271704
If you can't get enough of Assassin's Creed and Far Cry, you would probably like Horizon

>>383272343
>not "you can't just meme thismeme by memeing it a meme"

memememe

>>383272308
>These 2 should be in top 3, how are they so low?
>7. Nier Automata
Yes
>11. Persona 5
No

>>383272079
It is pre-release because it comes from the Horizon streamer who streamed the whole game before release (before day 0 patch that specifically mentioned to do tweeking with several things like that in the game).
There is no way a person could sleep within a 14 hour period of time could they?

File: 7-1-2009-11-27-11-pm.png (561KB, 865x651px) Image search: [Google]

561KB, 865x651px

>>383265615
>Mario Kart
I love Mario Kart as much as anyone out there guys, but come one, that game alone is clear indication that this is not to be taken seriously.

>>383265615
Pretty much this >>383272308

>>383272119
>I played vanilla wow for a little less than a month that's not a very new game.
So you are one of those RPG cucks who needs a game to grind away at or else they feel like playing every other game is meaningless. Interesting.

>>383272449

>memenot memeou memeant memeust memememe memeis memey memememeing memeit memea memememe

mememememememememe

File: horizon1.webm (3MB, 640x360px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 640x360px

>>383270451
>>383270840
>b..but has been patched since day 0
>t..the game is dynamic
top kek

File: still just.jpg (59KB, 460x690px) Image search: [Google]

59KB, 460x690px

>>383265615
>persona above Number 10
>enhancement port under Number 5
>Horizon Zero Dawn #1

>>383272663

Horizon Zero more like Horizon Zero content

>>383265615

At least 7 of these are franchises, at least one of which is older than my grandmother.

How about some new content, guys?

>>383272616
look at what you posted, anon
look what you've become

>>383272783

>memeook memeat memeat memeou memeosmemed memenon memeook memeat memeouve memecome

meme meme meme mememe meeeme

>>383265615
Tekken 7 >>> Injustice 2

lmao

How is PUBG any different from other survival games?

File: a4867dd0aa78ccb66c871b46c66af063.png (295KB, 854x963px) Image search: [Google]

295KB, 854x963px

>>383272079
Here is proof that this webm was posted to /v/ before the game even released.

File: koopa_troopa-angry.jpg (26KB, 368x359px) Image search: [Google]

26KB, 368x359px

>MK reash higher than Persona 5
>BotW behind HZD
>Injustice in the list

This list is making me salty as h*ck

File: 1497919886412.jpg (102KB, 536x590px) Image search: [Google]

102KB, 536x590px

>>383272592
No i played vanilla wow with a friend, for the first time. But i don't think it would be as fun unless you had a friend to talk to while playing it.

>>383271704

I thought the same thing and then I played it.

It's actually pretty good. Not #1 GOTY good but much better than I thought it would be.

>>383271870
>>383271868
>>383271972
>>383272006
>>383272079
>>383272159
>>383272254
>>383272308
>>383272346
>>383272434
>>383272483
>>383272526
>>383272561
>>383272663
>>383272703
>>383272712
>>383272890
>>383272921

These posts were all made by me.

File: 9a5.jpg (49KB, 677x403px) Image search: [Google]

49KB, 677x403px

>>383265615
>injustice 2 over tekken 7
>horizon in first place
yurofags have shit taste

>>383272329
It's one of the few "big name" games that came out this year that isn't on the list.
Fans of the series are automatically a little bit butthurt because their series is generally disregarded in the west by even the publisher itself, so an angry post makes sense.
It's got oddball aspects to the gameplay that keep normies from playing it and make it the perfect sort of title for contrarians on /v/ to laud over to show their superior taste.

it just fits.

>>383265615
Imagine being so insecure about your favorite exclusive, you have to accept someone else's opinion piece as fact that it's indeed number 1?

>>383265615
Videogames are absolutely dead

File: sicker than your average nigger killer.jpg (26KB, 449x395px) Image search: [Google]

26KB, 449x395px

>>383265615
I literally want to puke.

>>383265615
>businessinsider.de
who?

>>383273214

There are some good games in that list though.

And oh! They're all Japanese... surely this is a coincidence right? No way Western games are marketed towards filthy normies...

>>383273191
Sounds like Nier more than anything, although Automata has achieved pretty good sales all things considered

Here's an actual list by someone who actually played these games

10. Nioh
9. RE7
8. Tekken 7
7. Horizon Zero dawn
6. Hollow Knight
5. Mario Kart 8 Deluxe
4. Nier Automata
3. Persona 5
2. Breath of the wild
1. Yakuza 0

>>383273537
Here's a good list.

>>383273530
Nier is on the list in the OP

File: 1365634356432.jpg (446KB, 2528x1080px) Image search: [Google]

446KB, 2528x1080px

>>383273537
Swap Persona 5's position with Nier and you're golden

>>383268335
What if your gf enjoys sex a little less every fucking time ?

>>383273071
two of those were made by me

>>383273701
Better go clear some enemy camps to pick up some new sex moves.

>>383273537
Nioh doesn't deserve to be in the top 10, top 20 maybe, but a dark souls clones belong lower

>>383273684
Nier Automata was extremely average
it had 2 or so good feelz moments but that's it

>>383273537

10.Nioh
9.RE7
8.Horizon Zero Content
7.Hollow Shite
6.Yakuza 0 Interest
5.Mario Cart 8 Redux
4. Nier Dissapointment
3.Tekken 7
2.Shit Breath
1.Persona 5

>>383274012
>>383273894

>>383273830
>>383273789
>>383273747
>>383273701
>>383273684
>>383273630

>>383273608
>>383273537
>>383273530
>>383273431
>>383273334
>>383273290
>>383273214


>>383273209
>>383273191
>>383273096
>>383273071
>>383273043
>>383273019

>>383272921
>>383272903
>>383272890
>>383272889
>>383272850
>>383272783
>>383272712


>>383272708
>>383272703
>>383272663
>>383272616
>>383272561
>>383272526


>>383272483
>>383272449
>>383272468
>>383272434


>>383272343
>>383272329
>>383272308
>>383272254
>>383272246
>>383272159

Every single of these posts were made by me and me alone.

>>383274178
5 of those posts were made by me

File: despair and no erection.jpg (44KB, 750x421px) Image search: [Google]

44KB, 750x421px

>>383265615
>Resident Evil 7 higher than Persona and Nier
>an early access game and WiiU port this high
Whoever made this list is fucking mental.

1.Persona 5
2. Dragon Quest 8 on 3DS
3. Prey
4. Tekken 7
5. Crash trilogy
Honorable mention to Nioh because I didn't finish it but think was great from what I played

is HZD really that good? It looks pretty but isn't it still just a shallow far cry game in the end?