As someone that actually hates Microsoft and Xbox I have to say they've been the best at E3 so far.
Sony failed bad. I've owned every Playstation system and their revisions and I can't defend them. SotC is my favorite PS2 game but I can't get behind a remake of it. I've been playing MH since FU, World would be good if it didn't have that weird firefly shit. Open world MH can work since very basic stealth exists by ducking and the Monster Eye mechanic. God of War is just another one of those walking/cinematic/QTE-ridden "grown-up" non-games for people that don't really like games but work as game journalists or want to say they're "gamers". Spider-Man is another disappointment. Like everyone is saying, it's literally an Arkham game with QTE up the wazoo. Such a shame too, since all they had to show is a bit of non-scripted web-slinging, and maybe a mugging side piece, ending with a villain reveal to be good. I really wanted this to be good. It's up to Nintendo now. If not, then Microsoft takes the win. Crazy stuff here.