Rank all the Zelda games you've played fags. OoT >/=

OoT > AltP > MM > PH = SS = WW = TP etc.

Ocarina of Time > Wind Waker > Majora's Mask > Breath of the Wild > Twilight Princess > Minish Cap > Link's Awakening > Link Between Worlds > Link to the Past

I have a bad tendency to not finish Zelda games, makes it hard to rank.

File: images (1).jpg (4KB, 168x192px) Image search: [Google]

4KB, 168x192px

>>378394553
>putting OoA as the fourth worst Zelda game

File: 1494279538340.jpg (136KB, 480x864px) Image search: [Google]

136KB, 480x864px

Ranked entirely in terms of personal enjoyment and bears no meaning as to which games are the BEST:

Top-down: LA > ALBW > Temple of the Ocean King from PH > ST > AlttP > MC > OoA > LoZ > rest of PH > OoS
Side-scroller tier: AoL
3D: BotW > TP > MM > WW > OoT.
Currently playing SS but have only gotten to the second dungeon.

>>378394553
LttP>LoZ>AST>LBW>BOTW>eveything else

WW > TP > LttP > MC > Four Swords > PH
What's a good Zelda to play next?

>>378394553
TP>WW>ALttP>LA>ALBW>BotW>OoT>MM>OoS>OoA>FS>MCST>SS>PH>LZ1>LZ2

>hating the gameboy games
kys your'reself

>>378394553
ALBW > BOTW > WW > MM > SS = PH = SS > OoT > TFH > TP

Wind Waker

Breath of the Wild

Ocarina of Time

Majoras Mask

Link Between Worlds

Links Awakening

Link to the Past

Minish Cap

Twilight Princess

Spirit Tracks

>
POWER GAP
>

Phantom Hourglass

Oracle of Ages

BotW>ALtt>OoT>TP>WW>LA>MM>Oracle of Ages/Seasons>DS games

>>378395768
Meant to put SS = PH = ST

>>378395467
one of the two on N64

I've never been able to enjoy LttP

>Great tier:
ALttP
BotW
ALBW
OoT Master Quest
>Okay tier:
WW
AoL
LA (DX)
OOT
MM
>Forgettable tier
TP
Zelda 1
>DS games tier:
Phantom Hourglass

File: 1494871889862.jpg (23KB, 315x332px) Image search: [Google]

23KB, 315x332px

>all these fags posting hoping someone will reply to them and yet no one responds to others
On-topic instead of ranking them all, I'll say my top three are BOTW, Link's Awakening, and Spirit Tracks.

>>378395467
Link Between Worlds is surprisingly great

>>378396216
Spirit Tracks? Interesting, what appealed to you in that game? The Princess Zelda from that game was one of the best for sure.

>>378396309
I....what?

>>378395791
>hating phantom hourglass meme
Literally the only bad part was the Temple of the Ocean King.

Is seasons really considered the better of the two? I only got seasons cause I thought Din was hotter.

Is OoA or OoS better? Which one should I play first?

>>378396634
It depends on what you like. Seasons is more combat oriented and Ages is more puzzle oriented, thereby making it more tedious for some.

>>378396309
This is why autistic people should not be allowed opinions.

>>378394553
TW>OoT>MM>ALBTW>>>ST>PH>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>WW

Link between worlds is just a shitty and casual version of ALttP

>>378394553
OoT=/>TP>MM>WW>SS>ALBW

BotW>WW>MC>PH>TP>OoT>Zelda1
what do next

Botw > ST > MM > SS > TP > WW > ALBW > OoT > FSA > PH

can only rank the ones I've played

>>378396847
You should go back and play Link to the Past and you'll quickly realize it's just as casual. Shit can be 100%'d in an evening without breaking a sweat.

OOT > MM > TP > TWW >> OOA > OOS > ALttP > FSA > LA > TMC > SS >>>>ST > PH > TLoZ > TAoL

File: 1492180861191.png (106KB, 300x300px) Image search: [Google]

106KB, 300x300px

>>378396332
I have a peculiar fondness for trains and thus never tired of the overworld travel and instead kept a stupid grin on my face every time I would set out. The soundtrack was incredible and the game, in my opinion, used its gimmicks fairly well. The motion controls took getting used to but once I discarded my existing perceptions of what buttons should do, they were surprisingly intuitive. Its side activities and minigames didn't suffer from the "here's some random gameplay unlike the rest of the game" nearly as much as some other ganes. The dungeons, though not particularly challenging, were fun in the constant little "a-ha!" moments. In particular the Tower of Spirits with the Zelda and Link segments was a blast. The Spirit Flute parts were a fun respite and having to actually blow into the flute yourself was surprisingly immersive. Its significant portion of optional content such as other stations with their own puzzles or gathering the various stamps (stamping the book yourself is incredibly satisfying) alongside the cycle of finishing a sidequest, obtaining a force gem, and investigating the new tracks to uncover another station or sidequest made the game consistently enjoyable.

Plot-wise, seeing Zelda's growth from a naïve and self-centred princess to a mature and selfless ruler who never lost that spark of personality was wonderful. Spirit Tracks also made me laugh more than any other Zelda game.

I have my fair share of gripes about the game but I personally enjoyed it immensely.

More than anything I could feel the love for and fun with the game the creators had had.

File: 1492488520211.jpg (87KB, 956x715px) Image search: [Google]

87KB, 956x715px

>>378396964
God tier taste anon. Try LA sometime.

>>378396958
What are your favourite aspects of your favourite Zelda games, and your least favourite of those you like less? Then I can recommend.

I really want to Rank BotW as my favorite Zelda but something is holding it back, even after 250 hours. I really think it's the meh Sidequest, because everything else I liked.

That one Sidequest where that guy wanted 55 Rushrooms or w/e and giving me a single diamond really kind of stung.

ALBW>LA>ALTTP>WW>BOTW>MC>TP>PH

II>MM>OoT>LA>SS>TP>ALTTP>ALBW>WW>ST>BotW>I>MC>PH>OoA>OoS

>>378398753
Surprised to see someone rank SS relatively high. Fi didn't hamper your experience too much?

>>378399458
3D World was bretty gud

File: 1486473125018.png (1MB, 2200x2400px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 2200x2400px

now without the wrong image

>>378398753 #
What's II, AoL? And sell me on SS. I'm about to play it myself so I'd be interested to know why you like it.

File: 1476985819754.png (3MB, 2244x1948px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 2244x1948px

LttP>OoT>BoTW>LA>OoS/A>MM>WW>TP>FSA>ALBW>SS>MC>LoZ>PH>AoL>TH>ST

File: C_93ZcXU0AAdGTo.jpg (67KB, 1200x675px) Image search: [Google]

67KB, 1200x675px

>>378394553
BotW>OoT>MM>TP>LA>LttP>WW>OoS>MC>LoZ

>People still putting OoT anywhere in the top three in 2017

Autism has become an epidemic.

>>378399746
I wish they did more the Dragons, other than just using them as targets for farming items.

>>378399361
SS is good in spite of Fi. I look forward to fairweather WWHD fags slobbering all over the SS cock when it is remade with a traditional control option and some minor tweaks.

File: C_93e5MUQAIR9ap.jpg (76KB, 1200x675px) Image search: [Google]

76KB, 1200x675px

>>378399871
Me, too. Still really like them, though.

File: ed.jpg (15KB, 285x249px) Image search: [Google]

15KB, 285x249px

>>378399834
>OoT doesn't deserve to be in the Top 3 Zelda's

File: 20170330_130952.jpg (3MB, 4032x3024px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 4032x3024px

>>378399907
Tell me more famicom.

>>378400016
It really doesn't. I know rose tinted glasses and shit but holy hell has it aged poorly.

>>378400192
What deserves to be in the Top 3 in your opinion then

File: 1494803675599.jpg (614KB, 1714x1188px) Image search: [Google]

614KB, 1714x1188px

Made this a while ago, so there.

And BotW goes to the top tier.

File: Zelda Wind Waker ending.jpg (37KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

37KB, 1280x720px

Which Zelda game had the best ending?

>>378400256
LoZ, MM, OoA/S

>>378400487
TP not having a celebration but instead quiet gave gravity to the situation, a feeling as if the long war had finally come to its end. The bit with Zelda happily discussing the union of light and twilight and her and Link's surprise at Midna busting the mirror broke my heart.

>>378400016
Do people really still pretend OoT still holds up?

>>378400923
Does Majoras Mask?

>>378400971
Yes.

>>378400971
Yes

>>378401075
How so? The transformations feel clunky these days.

>anons finally figuring out OoT was good for its time but has aged like rotten milk
Never thought I'd see the day.

They're all shit

>>378401245
Majoras Mask is a meme

>>378401305
At least put some effort in anon

>>378400971
Yes

File: interesting...jpg (70KB, 357x361px) Image search: [Google]

70KB, 357x361px

TP > OoT > MM > OoS = OoA > ALBW > Zelda 1 > SS = Zelda II > ALttP > MC > BotW > PH > WW > FS > ST > FSA

Don't remember LA well enough to feel right about ranking it and fuck ever playing Triforce Heroes, I've had enough multiplayer Zelda in my life.

MC>PH

>>378401586
TP over OoT and MM?

>>378401779
Over MM I dunno, but definitely over OoT

>>378394553
Four Swords Adventures > TP

>>378401779

I really, REALLY like the things TP gets right. It has its flaws for sure and I'd probably consider OoT and MM more well rounded games but TP brings me more personal joy.

>>378401856
You like the wolfcock and midna ass dont you. It's alright. I do too.

>>378394553
>greater-than-not-equal-to

Fucking what

>>378400168
SmoothCriminal.jpg

>>378401856
TP in general always appears to be the Zelda that splits the fans. Either it's someone's favorite Zelda game with the best dungeons ever or it's seen as a soulless copy of OoT that's incredibly boring.

Literally just finished Gamecube edition Wind Waker on an old Wii. Im 35, only nintendo system i owned was the 1st one & gamecube, so I never really understood all the Zelda hype. Now I'm browsing online toy stores for anything wind waker.

>>378394553
BotW>OoT>aLttP>WW>LoZ>MM>TP>SS

I played 2 and PH but can't remember them, never played any of the other handheld ones.

I want wind waker babies to leave

>>378401963

Actually, not really. I'm huge on its dungeons, the ambience of its setpiece moments and the hidden skills giving it the best swordplay base of any Zelda. Shame about the exploitable AI and piss poor damage output but fuck it, TP knows how to make a fun moment.

I recenttly bought SS limited edition to play on my Wii U.
Has anyone played it on the Wii U, is it upscaled?
I remember owning a Wii for all of a few days and tried to play SS on my HDTV and it looked terrible as it was an SD console.

>>378402065

Link's Awakening and the Oracles come highly advised if you liked ALttP. Minish Cap is also pretty good.

>>378401856
The things TP does well, it does really fucking well. It has the best dungeons and bosses in the series, hands down. It has ambitious but not always satisfying combat. It has a really weak overworld. It has a criminally underrated soundtrack. It has a fairly unattractive art style and way too much fucking bloom, even in the original, but especially in the HD version. It has FPS slowdown out the ass. It has the best sidekick in the series outside of Linebeck, and the Wolf gimmick was surprisingly well integrated.

Overall, I think it deserves the famous 8.8, but I still think it's the best 3D Zelda. Not my favorite, but the best. It's excellent where it really matters. Its main flaws are mostly cosmetic. But that makes it less fun to just kind of tool around in, compared to something like Wind Waker.

Just my two cents.

File: 1494692379517.webm (933KB, 814x458px) Image search: [Google]

933KB, 814x458px

>>378402182
You sure it wasn't this?

>>378394553
LA = ALttP > OoT > BotW > MC > WW > TP >> SS

>>378402443
they are ancient games though and I was never into hand held games.
I only played PH on a kids ds while I was traveling

>>378402556
>Midna moans when you sprint

10/10, infinite replayability.

>>378402661
> Midna has one of the best butts in gaming
>Almost no hotdogging porn of her on the internet.

I'm ready to shoot up a school.

>>378402515
I wish the sword skills would come back and be revamped with more enemies that took advantage of them.

>>378394553
mm = oot > hyrule warriors > botw > tp > la > oracle games = minish cap > albw > alttp > ss > 2 > dogshit > ph, ww, spirit tracks, etc

i quite enjoyed all of them except for the last few i listed. i'd rank zelda 2 higher if not for the insane difficulty

>>378402826
You and me both. TP's combat blew my mind at first, until I realized that most of the hidden skills were pointless in most situations. I would love to see that combat live up to its full potential.

Why does TP get so much hate?

>>378403040
It's better than OoT and retards refuse to accept it.

>>378402515

Yeah, TP is legitimately pretty mixed. Like its combat, the swordplay options are awesome and I'm sad that the games have regressed from there instead of progressed BUT in terms of item-based combat, most Zeldas kick its ass. I'm also dodgy on the bosses, they all look great and the last couple of them actually are but then you get big pushovers like Fyrus, Morpheel or Armogohma that are all bark and no bite or bosses like Stallord and Argorok where they're easy but it's also really fun to just go through the motions. Art style, I personally like the Twilight Realm and my main qualms are going for a semi-realistic style with Gamecube tier visuals (did not age well) with EXTREMELY hit or miss character design - some really good looking characters but a lot of oh god, what the fuck. Midna's a top 3 sidekick, Linebeck possibly puts her in her place but I think Ghost Zelda definitely does. And the overworld? Call me weird but I actually like that about TP - it's easily a main quest oriented entry with some dicking around to do but not a whole lot. I like the main quests of Zelda more than the exploration which has a lot to do with why I rated WW and BotW as low as I did. But that's just me and my shit tastes.

>>378402556

Pretty sure, actually. I mean yeah, she's got nice hips but shortstack's not quite my thing.

>>378402661

This, however, was a nice touch. Can't believe Nintendo let that one slide.

>>378403040
>8.8, OoT rehash, etc

Because it was trendy to rip on it when it came out, and some people hold onto that.

>>378394553
BOTW >>>>>>>>>>> Literal FECES >>>>>>>>>>>>>> every other zelda game > windwaker

>>378394553
WW > TP > MM > ALttP > OoT > BotW > ALBW > LA > ST > OoX > FSA > TLoZ > MC > SS > TFH > AoL > PH > FS

>>378396172
>zelda 1
>forgettable
you have to not be fucking 12 to post here

>>378403167

Oh yeah, and the soundtrack is indeed underrated as a tone setter. Doesn't stand too strong on its own outside a couple of tracks but it accents the wistful, melancholy tone of the game well. Even something like the Hyrule Field theme is never terribly triumphant in most of its dynamic incarnations but given the tone of the game, that actually fits.

>>378403167
I actually like the "pushover" bosses for how fucking massive they are. It's less about the threat and more about the puzzle. It's very, dare I say, Shadow of the Colossus. It's not hard in the sense that you risk dying, but that you have to figure out how to take down this massive beast who honestly might not even know you're fucking there until you start stabbing it. TP did that really well, I thought.

LoZ = AoL > LttP = LA = OoS > OoA > OoT = BotW > WW > MC = FS = FSA = ALBW > TP > MM > PH = ST = SS = TFH

>>378403251

BotW is closer to WW than any other 3D Zelda, it just does the whole open exploration thing much better. You climb mountains and soar through the sky instead of sailing on a rickety ass ship.

>all of these faggots using =
indecisive fucks

>>378403448
TP honestly gave me my love for fuckhuge monsters, and I would've never gotten into Monster Hunter as early as I did if not for it

>>378403448

In terms of presentation, absolutely. TP's bosses looked phenomenal across the board and the challenge is more in figuring out the trick than actually dying. Still, something like the second phase of Morpheel or Armogohma are basically non-issues on both fronts - you figure it out quicklyand they're dead a couple of whacks later. To this day I don't even know if the former example even attacks at all. But fuck if they don't look cool for being as weak as they are.

>>378403469
They're also similar in how little content they have to offer dungeons/puzzle wise

>>378403669
I hate you for saying this, but I can't refute it.

>>378394553
I get why OoT is highly regarded, it had some of the best themed dungeons and along with everything else made it feel like an adventure, but why is WW liked so much? I liked it when I played it and on replaying it I couldn't stand how mediocre most of the dungeons were

>>378403018
I wish more of the hidden skills had been useful, unlike the great spin. Pulling off the helm splitter and especially the backslice or whatever it was called was ridiculously fun, especially since you could miss (i.e. they weren't homing attacks). Give us more varied button inputs and actually expect the player to use them.

As an extremely minor point, I fucking love being able to put away your sword with a flourish and wish more Zelda games did that.

I liked SS for similar reasons, the enemies that forced you to pay attention to your sword beyond blindly stabbing the attack button, though I prefer button inputs to the wiimote.

> Top tier
Ocarina 3DS
Majoras mask 3DS
BotW
Seasons
> good tier
TPHD
Ocarina N64
Majoras mask N64
Ages
ALBW
> Mid tier
Links Awakening
TP Wii
WWHD
> poor tier
Zelda
ST
WW
> couldn't bring myself to finish tier
Zelda 2
PH
SS

EVERYONES FAVORITE ZELDA GAME IS NOT THE BEST ONE.

>>378403780
Gamecube children have grown up.

>>378403669

Yep. A similar comparison (but of contrasting flattery) can be made between TP and SS, which is to say TP was dungeon-oriented and SS then went full retard with the notion. Or maybe even did it better if you really like dungeons and never liked Zelda overworlds.

>>378403780
I like WW so much because of the circumstances at the time in my life, and it's bright and generally happy characters/adventure was comfy. The game still makes me smile.

Anyone wanna give me the reasons why Ocarina of Time is widely regarded as not just one of the best games of all time, but THE best game of all time?

I played it a lot as a kid but never got very far, bought it recently on the 3DS. I'm at the Fire Temple right now, and it's definitely a good game but I wouldn't put it in the top 5. Even for the time it seems good but not great.

Maybe I'm just not a big fan of the Zelda formula because I just don't get it. I'd honestly say A Link to the Past was better so far.

>>378403824
>As an extremely minor point, I fucking love being able to put away your sword with a flourish and wish more Zelda games did that.

This shit was so fucking sexy that I would go out of my way to kill an enemy with a hidden skill just to do it. It's that kind of polish that makes me happy to play TP after all these years.

>>378403780
>but why is WW liked so much?
Great atmosphere, it was pretty different at the time, great visuals (though now they're starting to age)

>>378404064
Once I figured out how to do I literally did it after every single enemy in the god damn game. Makes me rock hard every time.

>>378404064

TP understood the little things, which is something that thankfully came back in BotW under different guises. I mean, it was the first Zelda where you could pick up an arrow fired into the ground or how projectiles could bounce off your unbrandished shield. Some of those little details were "muh dick" tier.

>>378400564
>oot has aged badly but thinks mm hasn't
ha

Will BotW hold up graphically for as long as WW did?

>>378404326
No, BOTW doesn't even hold up today and cel-shading always looks good.

>>378404309
The varied gameplay the masks give in MM is what gives it the advantage over in OoT in terms of aging.

>>378404195
>I mean, it was the first Zelda where you could pick up an arrow fired into the ground

I remember playing TP for the first time and seeing an enemy arrow sticking out of the ground. I thought, "it would be awesome if I could walk over and pick that up." Then I tried it and it worked. It was fucking magical. It's such a little thing, but it's such a simple oversight that most games make that I never expected it to work. TP was pure polish. I was really glad to see that attention to detail in BotW, too.

>>378404326

Probably not THAT long but I do think its artstyle will have some legs. WW might've been divisive but that artstyle will serve it just as well 15 years from now as it does now, almost 15 years after it first launched.

Breath of the Wild

WW>botw>mm>oot>loz>loz2>minish cap>four swords

botw is funner. but ww was funner at the time

>>378404463

>TP was pure polish.

It really was. A shame it has the legacy of being an OoT rehash because most of the glories it can claim were really quite subtle. TP is an understated game that refused to toot its own horn, there's tons of really cool ideas and concepts in it but rarely does it truly present those triumphs in the same way that, say, OoT contextualized the series into 3D or MM completely set itself apart with the 3-day mechanic and Bomber's Notebook quests. It wasn't revolutionary, it was just a really fucking good game that did some cool shit that some people tend to overlook.

>>378404876
>It wasn't revolutionary, it was just a really fucking good game

Exactly. You lose points for not doing something completely different, apparently. I appreciate the fact that TP was willing to take a successful formula and bring the most it could out of it. I think there's value in that.

>>378404876
It was definitely a solid game, that probably will never get out of OoT's shadow. TP seems to just be the game that has an equal amount of haters and fans

I've only played OOT because it was supposedly legendary. I enjoyed it, majora next on the list, then the one with midna since she pleases my dick.

If only BotW had better side quest (not Shrine Quest), I think it be my favorite. Quite a few of the 76 side quest are just kinda eh.

>>378405634
A lot of the side quests are really weak, but I think they mostly exist to force you to explore. All of my favorite parts of the game happened when I was just wandering.

>here's a mountain
>I'll climb it, because why not
>what the fuck, there's a dragon up here
>I have to snipe off these calamity parasites while I fly around, what the fuck
>holy shit, I saved a god and now I have to kill it, fucking what

This fucking game.

>>378394553
>OoT before MM
>OoT before BotW
Nah.

>>378405927
MM is debatable, but BotW over OoT? No. The music, dungeons, and bosses are all superior in OoT.

>>378406129
And the overworld, combat, and characters are all worse.

>>378406129
Agreed. But I think it comes down to preference. OoT is a fairly linear game, so it's crafted towards a particular play style. Yeah, there are minor sequence breaks built into it, but it mostly follows a strict path, so they can design it with the anticipation of you having done something else first. Open world games don't have that luxury, so they have to design everything to accommodate a player who hadn't seen any other part of the game yet. It severely limits the potential of open world games to build in a meaningful way, while simultaneously enabling them to craft a unique experience for each player. It's a tradeoff, and it really depends on what you like more. I appreciate both styles, but I prefer a tightly crafted linear game to a vast but generic open world game.

1. MM
2. OOT
3. Minish Cap
4. Twilight Princess
5. ALTTP
6. Wind Waker
7. Link's Awakening

Honourable mention: Alundra -- enjoyed it more than any Zelda game

>>378406452
Don't get me wrong, I still think BotW is an incredibly solid game. Princess Zelda in the game is the best Zelda there's ever been IMO, and I enjoyed what there was of the story. Hyrule Castle was quite fantastic as well. But the similarity of the blights, interior of divine beast (while still being good in their own right) and overall lack of memorable music hampered it a bit. The music was by no means bad though.

>>378394553
I'd put WW before ALttP otherwise flawless list

>>378407059
Oh, and forgot to add that unfortunately the second phase of the final boss in BotW was probably one of the worst in the series.

File: tony.jpg (110KB, 768x1024px) Image search: [Google]

110KB, 768x1024px

>>378403273
>>378404554
>WW
>best

>>378394553
Tingle's Love Balloon Trip > Tingle's Rosy Rupeeland > Tingle Balloon Fight > Too Much Tingle Pack

>>378407170
My bad. I had fake fun playing WW. Of course I meant OoT is the best.

File: get in the cannon.png (145KB, 716x720px) Image search: [Google]

145KB, 716x720px

BotW==WW>LoZ>LA=OoT>ALTTP>LoZ2>TP

I also played Oracle games, SS and Spirit Trucks but I never completed them so whatever.

>>378396309
>le ebin stickman meme
This is all the evidence needed.
Its time for a fucking purge

>>378407262
It's ok, we all make the 'having shit taste' mistake sometimes

>>378394553
ALttP > ALBW > BotW > MC = FS = FSA > TP > SS > WW > OoT > PH = ST > MM > AoL > LoZ > OoA = OoS = LA

File: IMG_0715.png (315KB, 423x384px) Image search: [Google]

315KB, 423x384px

Wind Waker > Breath of the Wild > Link's Awakening > A Link to the Past > Majora's Mask > Oracle of Seasons > Ocarina of Time > Hyrule Warriors > Twilight Princess > Skyward Sword > A Link Between Worlds > Link's Crossbow Training

>>378400923
OoT > infinite power gap > playing literally anything else > watching paint dry > eating shit > power gap > all other Zelda games

>all these varied opinions

There is no best Zelda game

>>378407519
>MM below SS

!?

File: 1488759985133.jpg (21KB, 300x316px) Image search: [Google]

21KB, 300x316px

>>378407803
>love OoT
>have nothing but contempt for MM despite it being extremely similar
wat

>>378407907

Obviously. But much like Radiohead rankings on /mu/ Zelda rankings are just good fun in and of themselves.

>>378408005

I was more alarmed at the bottom 3 personally, especially considering their top pick.

>>378395210
So long as Jabun's Belly exists, I agree.

>all these BotWfags

What the fuck?

OoT = MM > MC > LttP = WW > LA = OoS > OoA > SS > Zelda 1 > BotW > TP > LBW

>>378408395
I guess the honeymoon phase hasn't entirely worn off yet.

>>378408005
I enjoyed SS a lot, had no problem with the motion controls and felt it was one of the best stories in the series. The handholding isn't bad enough to outweigh what I liked

>>378408132
I never got into the bottom three at all, just never found much of any enjoyment in them, if OP had specified ones I'd beaten, they wouldn't even be on the list, among a few others as well.

>>378408509
I wonder how /v/ will look at it when the sequel inevitably blows it the fuck out by actually having a variety of dungeons as part of the environment, among other content that nintendo clearly didn't have time for.

>>378408701
I wasn't criticizing you if it seemed I came across that way, it's rather refreshing to see someone rate SS higher than OoT WW, and MM actually.

>>378408864
I really do think if BotW had dungeons of the caliber seen in some of the earlier 3D Zeldas, it would have been 11/10 game.

OoT>BotW>WW>TP>LttP

>>378408864
>>378409175

That's what I sorely miss from BotW so I look forward to that actually.

>>378407059
BotW was competent, and one of the better open world games I've played, mostly thanks to that undeniable Nintendo polish, but it's far from the best Zelda game. It has many merits, but many, many detriments. It was a refreshing break, but not where the series needs to go in the future.

>>378409281
That and it desperately needed better enemy and weapon scaling. The stronger enemies like the different colored variants and the minibosses have a ridiculously larger amount of health than the beginner enemies which stick around in the late game. So most players end up not wanting to use their good weapons on them but generally their entire inventory will be good weapons.

The armor upgrads are also broken. With flat damage reduction instead of a percent damage reduction most enemies, including bosses, become a joke. Especially since there's no cool down to healing items. Like damn just make Link get too full to eat with more expensive foods giving better health/stomach space.

I think this one would be the hardest to implement and some might oppose it but I'd personally like to see a smaller world with less or no shrines and instead have dungeons/mini dungeons that give entire heart containers instead of pieces.

And where the fuck are the caves?
The ones in the game are shallow as fuck and the geometry generally looks like shit. We needed more caves like the one hiding the leviathan skeleton in the north west. And I'm no weeb that thinks overacting=good but the voice acting was pretty bad in some cases.

>>378410669
This. But there is room for BotW and more Zelda games like it.

>>378411045
Agreed. I'd like to see an improved BotW in the future, just not every Zelda game to be open world from now on.

>>378394553

I unironically have only played OoT so

OoT > every game in existence