Sonic Rate thread. Rate them and post and rate others. Only list

File: Template.png (20KB, 800x1499px) Image search: [Google]

20KB, 800x1499px

>>376645541
Template

File: 1464819225426.jpg (20KB, 299x322px) Image search: [Google]

20KB, 299x322px

>Sonic Adventure 2
>S rank

Where's Sonic Lost World? I'd put it on B rank.

And you must be mad to put Rush above Rush Adventure.

>>376645541
06 should be shit tier, everything else that category should be D

>Sonic Colors
>S Rank

>>376645642
I really like the Tails/Eggman levels minus the pyramid one. I liked all the Knuckles/Rouge levels as long as you aren't going for a rank. Sonic/Shadow levels all great. Chao Garden was fun as hell with VMU or GBA. It's an opinion thread.

>>376645716
I never played the Lost World games. I just liked the traditional once you complete a level you go to the next level compared to the RPG/Ship mini game side of adventure. I could understand someone liking Adventure over rush though.

>>376645926
On DS at least. It got everything right from the Sonic Rush series but added new power ups and branching paths. The music is some of the most memorable tracks since genesis era.

File: download.png (10KB, 286x176px) Image search: [Google]

10KB, 286x176px

>>376645891
IGN shouldn't be able to post on 4chan.

God tier
------------
Sonic 2, 3 &K

great tier
--------------
Sonic 3, sonic, Sonic colors

good tier
-------------
S & K, Sonic CD, Sonic 4 pt 2, generations

ok tier
----------
Sonic adventure 1, heroes

shit tier
-------------
Unleashed, SA2, 3D blast

06 tier
--------------

Sonic 06

File: sonic opinions.png (62KB, 751x741px) Image search: [Google]

62KB, 751x741px

>>376645541
here's my old one from a while back because I'm too lazy to use the template

>>376645541
>Shit tier
Anything Sonic related

>>376645541
The first two games are good, 3&K and Generations are OK, and the rest are well-intended garbage at best.

File: 1193239611231.jpg (10KB, 305x222px) Image search: [Google]

10KB, 305x222px

>>376645541
Where's Lost World you shitstain

>>376645541
Sonic Adventure 2 was mediocre at best.

Yes, I played it, and I was 12 when I played it, just like you. Remove the goggles.

>>376646601
Good list. I am glad someone else agrees that Sonic CD isn't the best sonic game. It wasn't bad or anything but it feels like everyone gives that game more credit then it's worth

File: 1493525496459.png (560KB, 644x776px) Image search: [Google]

560KB, 644x776px

>>376645541

>Chronicles over Zero Gravity
>Battle on the same tier as Sonic 4

>>376645541
>Advance 2
>S-Rank
Dropped like an expensive vase.

>>376647856
Refer to
>>376646002
I understand people not liking the game I do but using the excuse meh nostalgia is such bullshit. I mean looking back at Mario 64 the controls weren't that great and several stages had questionable designs. I mean same concept as nostalgia there but meh it's mario therefore it has to be good and if you don't agree your retarded because meh.

>>376645541
You are exactly right, OP.
I'd probably put Sonic Battle in the B group but that's the only change

File: boostshit v3.png (2MB, 1370x609px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1370x609px

>>376645541

I'm just glad sonic R isn't in the shit tier.
It's really not that bad

>>376649469
None of those games utilize the D-Pad to make sonic move

>>376645541
But Sonic Adventure is shit.

>>376648935
The game just didn't know what the fuck it wanted to be and did nothing well.

No, acknowledging a game's faults and poor design is not the same as being blinded by fucking nostalgia.

>>376649469

oh boy, autism anon is back

God Tier
Sonic All Stars Racing Transformed
Sonic CD

Great tier
Sonic 1 2 3 & Knuckles

Good tier
Sonic Generations
Sonic Advance
Sonic Rush

Acceptable tier
Sonic Advance 2
Sonic Battle
Sonic Adventure 2 Battle

Not worth mentioning tier
All others

>>376645541
Black Knight is not nearly as bad as Secret Rings.

>>376649869

Sonic CD is objectively flawed, it is not god tier

>>376649967
Nice meme

File: 1368612A9.jpg (40KB, 467x349px) Image search: [Google]

40KB, 467x349px

>>376645541
>Sonic Advance 2
>Better than 1 or 3
No

>>376645541
> no wii version of colors

File: 1492481941165.gif (3MB, 480x270px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 480x270px

>>376645541
>Sonic Adventure 2 in S Rank
>Sonic CD in A Rank

That's a god damn lie and you know it. You couldn't even come up with a list of good things in SA2B that put it ahead in all the good things in Sonic CD

Delete your image and never come back.

>>376645541
i'm not doing my rank, but i'd put sonic riders in S and sonic battle 1 tier higher. also zero gravity in B

>>376650082
The sign posts are fucking wonky.

CD's good, but not god tier.

File: sonic game ranks.jpg (1MB, 1370x2484px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 1370x2484px

>>376645541

Whats the best sonic to start with

>>376650779
1 on genesis

File: sa2.png (204KB, 324x324px) Image search: [Google]

204KB, 324x324px

>>376650779
SA2

>>376650779
The first one.
Play in fucking chronological order like every sane human being.

>>376650729
>heroes and '06
>s rank
didn't even read the rest

File: 1493066452377.jpg (80KB, 800x733px) Image search: [Google]

80KB, 800x733px

>>376650864
FUCK OFF WITH THAT 2D INDIE SHIT. NOBODY WANTS TO PLAY THE COURSE TWICE TO KNOW WHERE THE OBSTACLES ARE. THE FIELD OF VIEW IN 2D SONIC IS GARBAGE. IT WAS NEVER GOOD.

File: HEY IM GRUMP.png (549KB, 1766x758px) Image search: [Google]

549KB, 1766x758px

>>376650994
HEY IM GRUMP

File: HEY IM GRUMP3.png (373KB, 1887x863px) Image search: [Google]

373KB, 1887x863px

>>376651091
IM NOT SO GRUMP

>>376650729
>Not understanding how angles work

He turns 90 degrees in both instances, one of them is just a gradual curve while the other is an instant shift. If he went 120 degrees he would be facing 30 degrees BACK toward where he came from. Even by this person's retarded logic, the turn should have been a 60 degree turn, as in the other side of the semicircle from where these retarded measurements are from.

File: 5e1.jpg (95KB, 595x941px) Image search: [Google]

95KB, 595x941px

>>376651016
Dude, cut down the shit, I had a bad day.

aaaaand autism chan is back again

see ya

File: Lel.png (199KB, 416x379px) Image search: [Google]

199KB, 416x379px

>>376651016
This is a good reaction image because it not only shows you but it also shows me as well

File: kazooeater.gif (91KB, 350x228px) Image search: [Google]

91KB, 350x228px

>>376650729
i laughed

Where the fuck is Spinball?

>>376651016
>FUCK OFF WITH THAT 2D INDIE SHIT.
Indie is not a genre. A 2D game isn't necessary indie.
>NOBODY WANTS TO PLAY THE COURSE TWICE TO KNOW WHERE THE OBSTACLES ARE.
You don't need to if you play carefully.
>THE FIELD OF VIEW IN 2D SONIC IS GARBAGE. IT WAS NEVER GOOD.
If you mean Game Gear Sonic games, you are right. Otherwise, you simply have very bad reflexes. Or you shouldn't play those games running mindlessly.

>>376651426
in the trash

File: sonic and shadow.jpg (86KB, 500x478px) Image search: [Google]

86KB, 500x478px

every single sonic game is shit except for adventure 2.

you literally cant prove me wrong

Good tier
Generations

nostalgia tier
Sonic 2
Sonic Adventure 2

okay tier
Genesis era Sonic games
Colours

bad tier
unleashed
adventure
heroes
sonic 4

>>376645541
>Advance 2
>S rank
>Battle and R that low

You're the guy from the other thread aren't you.

>>376645541
>Sonic Riders Zero Gravity shit whilst Sonic Riders is C

Get out of my sight

>Sonic's Schoolhouse, the ultimate masterpiece is under Sonic Chronicles

What's wrong, Tommy? Don't you want to play in my schoolhouse?

>>376650729
no sonic 3D
REEEEEEEEEEEEEE

>>376649775
I mean It wanted mix faster speed based levels, with Panzar Dragoon style shootem ups, and explore the level to find the item levels. All can be replayed to your content, you get items that you can raise chao with if you want to. Pretty much what it wanted to be.

Admitting Mario 64 has game faults and poor design and thinking it's still deserves praise but admitting SA2 has faults and saying it sucks shows that you have mariostalgia bud.

>>376649775
>The game just didn't know what the fuck it wanted to be
Of course it did. It wanted to be a game with separate game styles.
It pulled it off pretty well mind you aside from the camera in general and the aiming in the mech segments.

>>376650729
Clearly dropped on the head as a child. The Sonic Adventure 3 Facebook page called, they want their autism back.

File: Help.png (38KB, 264x214px) Image search: [Google]

38KB, 264x214px

Sonic games need to be ranked on how FUN they are to play.

None of this "ranking" bullshit because everyone plays Sonic for different reasons.

File: facepalm.jpg (35KB, 600x600px) Image search: [Google]

35KB, 600x600px

>>376650389
>Holy shit someone else has opinions different than mine
>he is stupid and I am right

>>376652089
How about you chaos control right the fuck back to Redddit

>>376650779
Whatever you want. Just look any of them up and play the one that looks the best to you

File: angle explanation.png (205KB, 909x702px) Image search: [Google]

205KB, 909x702px

>>376651208
SHUT THE FUCK UP

>>376646425
>it got everything right

No it didn't. It is substantially slower than Rush and lacks a second playable character. Music took a nose five as well.

File: images (1).jpg (2KB, 92x92px) Image search: [Google]

2KB, 92x92px

>>376652189

File: Sonic Tier List.jpg (2MB, 1341x1499px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1341x1499px

>>376645541
Your list is pretty close to my tastes, so I just (horribly) modified it.

I skipped a few sequel and a lot of GG games, they're between B and C for the most part.

Also, anyone could tell me what is supposed to be so good about Advance 2 ?
I was very close to put it on shit tier, since it was one of the most painful experience I had with a platformer.

>>376645541
>Sonic Adventure 2 in S rank
What the fuck? Half the game sucks major cock.

File: 1494350921445.png (12KB, 603x222px) Image search: [Google]

12KB, 603x222px

>>376651542
i hope your house gets robbed by a pack of feral niggers. boostfag.

>>376651873
fuck you boostlet casual

>>376652739
I legitimately hope you die in a house fire.

YOU RETARDS ARE WHY SEGA MADE YET ANOTHER BOOST TRASH GAME! FUCK YOU!

However:
Adventure 1>Adventure 2

Shadow was a mistake.
Tails on shooting sections was a mistake.

File: [boostshit] max speed sharp turn.webm (2MB, 490x591px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 490x591px

>>376652901
which sonic gameplay do you prefer though? I feel like Sonic's was more polished in SA2. Can't live without that bounce bracelet now.

File: math is hard.png (236KB, 909x702px) Image search: [Google]

236KB, 909x702px

>>376652320
Jesus you're retarded. That angle means absolutely nothing, after 5 seconds in both scenarios sonic is facing 90 degrees away from where he was facing initially.

File: [Adventure] max speed sharp turn.webm (2MB, 475x484px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 475x484px

>>376652995
highschool dropout detected.

>>376652980
I admit Sonic controlled better in 2 but the level design of Sonic's stages was better in 1, in my opinion. Overall, I prefer 1, also for being able to run around a hub world.

>>376652692
I forgot about the Sonic Blast on GG that was so bad I would have put it in my original post oh well.

I just liked how Advance 2 was speed orientated game play. I liked that with R button you could jump higher to get to someplace just slightly higher or kick an enemy in front of you (homing attack is still better though). It really is a different style of sonic and Dimps went crazy with the boost pads. The Special Stage was the worst part of the game whoever thought that was a good idea hadn't played there own damn game.

File: Ha (2).gif (2MB, 250x250px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 250x250px

>>376652089
>Ranking system
>Unable to defend your ranking arguments
>Play it off as if "OPINIONS DUDE"

>>376653110
>Sonic moves around even when his legs stand still
Quality game huh

>>376652995
Holy shit son are we going to turn this into a research paper?

File: [boostshit] walking up and down results in circular motion.webm (3MB, 356x258px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 356x258px

>>376653204
fair enough

>>376653323
at least THE PLAYER did it. fuck off to temple run reskin generations

>>376653323
Even I can see you are trying to derail with a point unrelated to the argument.

File: 1475459495119.jpg (58KB, 566x569px) Image search: [Google]

58KB, 566x569px

>>376653402
>>376653110
>>376652980
sonic is a fucking cripple in the boost games. what the fuck.

How do i fucking get good in this game

>>376652901
I like hub worlds but I still to this day never understood why sonic needed one. Also 1 had Big which was a shitty fishing mini game and Amy who felt like a legitimate waste of a character. Sonic and Knuckles had the best stages. Though I really agree shooting stages were a bad choice for Tails having him do the same levels as sonic but race style was a bad idea. I really wish they gave him a chance for his own style missions.

I mean Shadow the game was a mistake but he is literally a different skinned sonic.

>>376653460
Can you blame him?
It's not like the person he's replying to is on the sane side.

>>376653110
>I don't understand how angles work
>this guy just called me out on it
>better call him a high school dropout and post this webm that proves him right

Sonic maintains zero directional momentum in that webm, which is exactly what I implied from the very start. There are no physics applied to his motion, just how long have you gone without hitting something and what direction are you pushing on the controller. Boost games have momentum so even after hitting right you don't magically lose all forward movement.

I don't even care which one you think is better, the fact that you can't understand how to make a graph is just so unbearably stupid. After the 5 seconds of pushing the controller to the right, Sonic has gone from facing one direction to 90 degrees away from that initial direction, either left or right depending on your input. He has turned 90 degrees in both scenarios, the angle you are measuring is arbitrary and shows almost nothing relevant at all.

>>376653206
Well, maybe I should give Advance 2 a second chance.

I remember the level design being really terrible and the boss design atrocious.

>>376653643
Blame his reckless movement in the adventure games broke his legs because they aren't physically possible.

>>376652886
>literally throwing shit at people like an ape because nu Sonic Team isn't making the Adventure 3 you want

Oh am laughing. You also already have SA3, it's called Sonic 06. Go play that and don't come back.

How many of you guys got into the Mario vs Sonic meme back then or were you uninterested into?

File: dumb fuck1.png (219KB, 1041x702px) Image search: [Google]

219KB, 1041x702px

>>376653687
are you retarded? This is simple 2D particle motion physics, 1st 2 weeks of classes in AP physics 1. You seem to be ignoring the negative position in the Y direction. Would this "correction" make you understand?

>>376645541
Sonic Riders should be B rank and Sonic All-Stars Racing Transformed should be A rank, but other than that I agree.

>>376653735
There are without a doubt a few stages with hopefully you know what's coming up moments but no were near as bad as Advance 3. I never really noticed any level design problems there is for the most part varying paths making multiple playthroughs not feeling stale. The bosses are running and there are a few especially the one holding knuckles that are cheap.

Really It is one of those games that gets better on multiple playthroughs and feels geared towards people who speed running in sonic games. Cream makes the game super easy and I recommend playing through the game as her first to see how the game is laid out before committing with the other players.

>>376653735
>I remember the level design being really terrible and the boss design atrocious.
It's the epitome of hold right to win and all of the bosses are sickeningly simple.

>>376654479
boost position is 30 degrees above Adventures'. This is very easy to understand.

>>376654610
Apparently I don't speak English fuck.

>>376645541
>sonic racing transformed
>b rank
Yeah nah, S rank or kill yourself

>>376653735
You're thinking of advance 3 boy

>>376653687
He is talking about relative motion, aka comparing adventure's final position to boostgames. in this case, boost is 30 degrees above adventure.

>>376649869
Best list itt

>>376646601
this

>>376654479
I "understand" perfectly fine, your angle is based on two points, and it's a valid angle, but that angle is NOT the angle of the fucking turn. If that was the turn Sonic took, it would mean he was moving along the y axis in the NEGATIVE direction, then just suddenly flipped almost entirely around (in the boost scenario). But he's moving in the POSITIVE direction, so his turn is based on the fucking top half of the semi circle, not the fucking bottom. He turns 90 degrees in both. If all you're comparing is the ending position, then sure your angle works, but what the fuck does that have anything to do with how far he's turned?

Your angle measures change in position, the CORRECT angle (90 in both scenarios) measures change in momentum direction.

And you could easily still prove your point if you actually incorporated the factor of time, because then you could show that adventure sonic changes his direction instantly while boost sonic changes it gradually, which is what you're trying to argue.

>>376654889
He is moving the goalposts to relative motion, look at his original chart that directly says that 90 and 120 are the TURN RADIUS. I called him out on that, he changed the definition of his graph so that his retarded angle would be correct.

>>376654792
Nah, he's right with Advance 2.

What is wrong with boosting?

>>376645541
>Sonic SchoolHouse

kek
at least SEGA know their fandom

>>376645541
I'd argue sonic school house is a better game than sonic 07. I loved school house.

>>376655409
>>376649469
>>376652980 #1 boostgame modifies your inputs
>>376653402 #2 to the point it makes sonic feel unnatural to control
>>376653110 #3 Now compare it to adventure, 100% true control

this is why boostgames force you into a 2d section in order to have any platforming. 3D platforming is nearly impossible with boost physics, whereas adventure is full of 3d platforming and nobody had trouble finishing them.

>>376656401
>to the point it makes sonic feel unnatural to control
You realise that the boosting games have more natural physics and controls right?
Nothing going at Sonic's speeds should be able to go at a 90 degree angle that quickly without breaking every bone and muscle in their legs.

>>376656705
I'm aware. but natural physics do not work when you try to do 3D platforming while moving at high speeds. hence they force you into 2D sections in boost games.

Imagine how bad it would feel to control having a mario kart 3D platforming game. Sonic feels even worse than mario kart to control in boost games though.

>>376657523
>but natural physics do not work when you try to do 3D platforming while moving at high speeds
It's possible, but that would alienate the casual audience that don't like games with a modicum of challenge.

>>376645541
>Chronicles and Riders in anything but shit tier
Not a bad list otherwise

is Secret Rings that bad?
I remember playing it years ago and thought it was ok, but I reading here it's almost the worst sonic game

>>376658113
I don't understand the hate the game receive here either.

The gameplay worked ok and the skill system was actually very fucking good.
Seems like people associate this game with Black Knight, which was an unplayable mess.

>>376658113
Initially it's bad because of the slog you have to go through. Then you get a few upgrades and you're going fast.

>>376645541
>adventure games
>good
Take off the goggles.

File: 1464844609637.jpg (108KB, 900x600px) Image search: [Google]

108KB, 900x600px

>>376645541
You played Sonic's Schoolhouse?

File: 1476695770175.jpg (54KB, 500x500px) Image search: [Google]

54KB, 500x500px

>>376659361
>boostshit
>good
hope u get hit by the shockwave of a muslim suicide bomber at medium-max range so you just bleed to death.

>>376650294
>Advance 3
>not fucking shit
Give me a brake.

>Modern is 2D Boost to win
>Adventure has fractuered as fuck gameplay with shitty friends, shit physics, and edgy plots
>Classic has too small a screen to see where you're going, and is either memorization or hold right to win

Was Sonic ever good?

>all this love for sonic battle
People actually liked that game? I thought it was fucking trash

File: 1484774977775.jpg (675KB, 894x900px) Image search: [Google]

675KB, 894x900px

>>376661510
>>376660593
>>FF