would you watch LOTR CU standalone movies like THE HUNT FOR GOLLUM

>woodland realm patrol

kek, no

>>85446651
No. I never even bothered watching The Hobbit parts 2-3. LotR was made at exactly the right time. It's impossible to do the movies properly now. Hollywood can't tolerate a film rooted in practical effects that is tailored to the story instead of stretched out to maximize aggregate box office.

>>85446651
only if there was NO shriveledlittleshortdick legolas in any of them

The LOTR trilogy was great, but the Hobbit trilogy was awful. Anymore LOTR films and they'll wreck the whole franchise.

>>85446651
Before The Hobbit came out I would've been down for that, but after seeing that heaping pile of shit I'd rather they'd just stop making Tolkien adaptations.

Let LotR be remembered for how great it was.

>>85450220
Strange that the fan edits of The Hobbit that cut out the superfluous crap are more in line with the magic of the LotR trilogy than what the original director created.

>>85446651
No. No movie or series based on the books should ever be made again. I can't understand how a supposed fan of Tolkien's work would want to see it further bastardised of the works. Your suggestions are awful too lad.

>>85450368
What are the good ones? Was looking for some yesterday

>>85450579
The Maple Films one impressed me. Three movies on two 'discs' and they put all of the cut stuff on an 'Appendix' disk just like the original LotR DVDs so if you want to watch it you can.

>>85446651
Shut the fuck up and make Temeraire you fucking hack.

I want Sean Bean riding a dragon goddamnit.

If this fuckface is involved in any way, no.
I'd like to see del Toro's version.

>>85450579
purist edition

>>85450368
I should give that a try but even then I doubt it would retain the magic of the LotR trilogy. It would still be filled with CGI instead of great practical effects and make-up.
Also, do they cut out everything that isn't in the book? As in, no Azog storyline, no Necromancer stuff, no Legolas and Tauriel, no scenes with that terrible comic relief guy who worked for the Master of Laketown?

>>85450740
Is there more alfrid than necessary? this is a dealbreaker