Why did Gandalf still have doubts that this is the one ring after

File: lotr.jpg (140KB, 1107x781px) Image search: [Google]

140KB, 1107x781px

Why did Gandalf say the ring was quite cool after pulling it out of red hot coals?

>>85235288
I took it as he didn't want to believe it to be true.

>>85235414
>IT'S KWITE KOOL
You just read that in his voice

>>85235782
No. No i didn't.

>>85235288
In the book it's very different. PJ cutting corners like he later did in the hobbit

>>85235288
Imagine finding the most powerful object in middle earth in the shire

>>85236634
but thats not a Silmaril

>>85236733
bluepill me on the silmaril aren't they just shiny stones?

>>85235288
sauron's lord of all the rings. I guess it would make sense.

>>85237834
they're really fucking shiny

>>85237899
So is the arkenstone

>>85237931
stop

File: JUST.png (42KB, 813x520px) Image search: [Google]

42KB, 813x520px

>>85237834

>demi-god sent to middle-earth to fight sauron
>has a ring
>doesn't care about that strange ring in Bilbo
>*20 years later*
>10 years of reading about rings
>ho that must be the ring

Why does Gandalf whistle while he whispers?

File: 1496711430689.jpg (62KB, 720x757px) Image search: [Google]

62KB, 720x757px

>>85238118

>>85238118
that's just how you speak moth

>>85238077
you realize there were many rings of power created and all have similar characteristics, could have been a fucking dud

>>85235288
his love of the halfling's leaf had clearly slowed his mind

>>85235288
He didn't actually see it, he just felt an evil prescence for a split second.

That was enough to spook him and start a 17 year long research quest to find out if that was actually Sauron he felt for that microsecond.