Why didn't Aragorn tell his army of green invincible ghosts

It was his special so its not fair on the team for Aragorn to get all the XP

Because muh oath

Why didn't Marcus Aurelius impregnate Harry Potter's One True Ring with the Blade That Was Broken and crash the plane with no survivors?

>>84415963
It was only available in the Pellenor Fields quest. It wouldn't get passed on to the Gates of Mordor level even if he didn't use it.

>>84415963
He could have, but instead he used them to save Gondor. They were a one and done deal. And they could have attacked Mordor, but it wouldn't have mattered, because they wouldn't have been able to kill Sauron anyways.

>>84415963

I dunno man, they seemed to be in a pretty foul mood after killing the orcs in Minas Tirith, I wouldn't chance not giving them what they wanted at that point.

What would have happened if one of those ghosts wore the ring?

ghosts being an invulnerable super army was hackson. their canon power was "being spooky"

They should've thought of the ghosts at the beginning and just had them escort Frodo to the mountain as their pledge.

They fulfilled their oath to defend Gondor.

>>84417999
Become even less agreeable ghosts.

>>84417999
they can't, they aren't corporeal

>>84418137
Nor was Sauron

>>84418334
he was when it he actually wore it.

Because he couldn't do shit without the king's sword which actually means he is a king and they have to listen to him

With some regular shit sword they would have just killed him

>>84418059

this.

>Elrond is the one that ultimately has the sword remade
>could've done it at any time but waited until the 3rd movie because plot
>could've just done it when everyone came to Rivendell and had Aragorn order the ghosts in the beginning to take it to Mt Doom

>>84418334
They're just dead men bound to Arda by Eru for being cowards. Sauron was a maia who bound himself to the ring.

>>84418546
Except they still have to reach Gondor to recruit the ghosts

more importantly, how did Isildur "curse" them into becoming ghosts? Isildur was just some human right? That sounds like something outside the scope of even Elrond/Galadriel's powers and they're literally magical elfs.

>>84418726
You can curse anybody if they break on oath

>>84418718
So? Just take gandalf's eagle airlines. There's a bunch of nonsense and danger cut out.

File: Eagles.png (196KB, 400x399px) Image search: [Google]

196KB, 400x399px

>>84418742

>>84418137
Aren't what, Sarge?

>>84418734

So, even say some kid peasant who was promised half a loaf of bread by another peasant that reneged could curse him into becoming a ghost?

>>84415963
They would have if Aragorn would have been willing to renegotiate the bonus situation.

>>84418768
lmao

I love these threads.

>>84415998
Because Marcus was straight nigguh.

>>84418768
That's not a fucking oath

>>84418768
Nah, I assume these have a scale so I guess it would be something like an itchy butthole for like a day, and stuff like braking your election promises or your wedding oath gets you erectile disfunction or a homosexual son.

It would only take one single ghost to kill all the orcs in mordor. And then another one to save Minas Tirith.

When Frodo was stabbed with the Modgul blade why didn't they freeze him?