Post a director's best, worst, most overrated, most underrated, and most Reddit movies
Here's an easy one
Pic related's are:
>Best
No Country for Old Men
>Worst
The Ladykillers
>Overrated
Fargo
>Underrated
The Man Who Wasn't There
The Big Lebowski
>>83958373
I want to live in the Big Lebowski world
>>83958373
thank you for including the reddit category. these threads are shit without it
now, pic related
> Best:
How Green Was My Valley
> Worst
Sergeant Rutledge
>Overrated
Stagecoach
> Underrated
The Quiet Man
The Searchers
>>83958373
>>83958373
Ladykillers is Kino
>>83958529
Man Who Shot Liberty Valance?
>>83958559
I had Liberty as the best until I thought again
Valley is a hair better bcz it will wreck you
>>83958529
>The Searchers
Sense when does Reddit have good taste?
>>83958373
>Best
Terminator
>Worst
Avatar
>Overrated
Titanic
>Underrated
The Abyss
Aliens
DAVID LYNCH
>Best
INLAND EMPIRE
>Worst
Dune
>Overrated
Mulholland Drive
>Underrated
FWWM
>>83958373
>Best
Raging Bull
>Worst
Shitter Island
>Overrated
Goodfellas
>Underrated
After Hours
Wolf of Wall Street
>>83958373
>best
Fargo
>worst
Oh brother where art thou
>overrated
Inside llewyn davis
>Underrated
A serious man
Lebowski
>Best
Dreams for Sale
>Worst
Wild Berries
>Overrated
Ten Nights of Dreams
>Underrated
Dear Doctor
Sway
>>83958579
>>83958373
hmm will watch
>best
Gone baby gone
>Worst
The town
>Overrated
Argo
I Killed My Lesbian Wife, Hung Her on a Meat Hook, and Now I Have a Three-Picture Deal at Disney
>>83958373
>best
Inside Llewyn Davis
>Overrated
No country for old men
>>83958529
Stagecoach is not overrated.
>>83958373
Thank you. The Man Who Wasnt There is fantastic. Top tier Coen Bros movie. No one ever mentions it.
Pretty much agree with your classifications. I would swap Fargo with O Brother, tho. I think Fargo deserves its praise, while O Brother is generally lauded while being kind of a slog.
>>83958666
It's popular therefore it's Reddit
>>83958697
Bringing Out The Dead should be on underrated
>best
Total Recall
>worst
junior
>overrated
True Lies
>underrated
Raw Deal
Terminator 2
>best
Apocalypse Now
>worst
Twixt
>overrated
The Godfather
>underrated
The Conversation
The Godfather part 2
>>83958695
his entire filmography
>>83959061
Nah
>>83959061
Nah
>>83958966
What's your favorite subreddit and don't even like because there are more Reddit users on this board than on Reddit.
>>83959184
>like
*Lie
>best
zodiac
>worst
the curious case of benjamin button
>overrated
the social network
>underrated
alien 3
fight club
>>83959184
"reddit" means "bad". nothing to do with the website
>>83959238
>>underrated
>alien 3
No, alien 3 is not only his worst, it is DEFINITELY the worst alien movie in the franchise.
>>83959130
Found the butt hurt redditor
>>83959238
Alien3 is pretty bad, dude. And I even like Alien 3.
>>83959261
No, Reddit means "things I don't like"
>Best
Reservoir Dogs
>Worst
Death Proof
>Overrated
Kill Bill Vol. 1
>Underrated
Kill Bill Vol. 2
Pulp Fiction
>>83959511
Kill Bill fucking sucks
>>83959649
ok..
>Best
The Master
>Worst
Inherent Vice
>Overrated
Punch Drunk Love
>Underrated
Magnolia
Boogie Nights, though it is still a brilliant film, "reddit" isn't always a negative thing
>>83959325
incorrect
"reddit" means overrated, edgelord and generally liberal
>>83959261
no reddit usually means overrated for reddit reasons
>Aliens is better then Alien because of Ripley and Newts strong mother-daughter type relationship!
>Big Lebowski isn't just a movie it's a way of life man
>Terminator 2 is better then Terminator because it shows Arnold as a father figure rather then merciless killer
those are reddit arguments tending to appeal to the emotional side of you
A Sparks thread? On /mu/?!
Cool.
Great band.
>>83959177
Nah
>>83959805
>liberal
O i am laffin
>>83959846
I don't think you've ever been on Reddit if you think that Reddit appeals to the "emotional" side
>>83959846
this guy gets it
>>83958373
Fellini
>Nights of Cabiria
>Ginger E Fred
>La Dolce Vita
>And the Ship Sails On
>Nothing he made was Reddit. They probably overrate La Dolce Vita though.
>>83958373
That's just, like, your opinion, man.
>>83959890
on r/all most of the shit upboated is anti-trump/pro-bernie stuff yeah you can look at subs like r/the_donald but realize most of reddit hates those guys and wants to ban the subreddit
>Best
Dr. Strangelove
>Worst
The Shining
>Overrated
A Clockwork Orange
>Underrated
Paths of Glory
Full Metal Jacket
>Best
Memento
>Worst
Dark Knight Rises
>Overrated
Inception
>Underrated
The Prestige
Interstellar
>>83958697
Most underrated is Alice Doesn't Live Here Anymore.
>>83960002
Swap Paths Of Glory and Dr. Strangelove and you've got it
>>83960119
This.
>>83958373
>Best
Miller's Crossing
>Worst
The rest of them
Overrated
>Fargo
>Underrated
Miller's Crossing
All except for Miller's Crossing
>>83960002
>>Reddit/tumblr
Clockwork Orange
>Best
Porco Rosso
>worst
Ponyo
>overrated
spirited away
>underrated
The wind rises
spirited away
>>83959238
>>best
>zodiac
give this man a medal
K I N O
I
N
O
>>83958373
>Best
Return to Oz
>Worst
Return to Oz
>Overrated
Return to Oz
>Underrated
Return to Oz
Return to Oz
>>83959238
can't disagree with this
>>83960291
Miller's Crossing is my favorite Coen but you're a faggot
>>83960002
IMO eyes wide shut belongs next to paths of glory in underrated
>>83958734
>worst
>Oh brother where art thou
Kill yourself
>>83960362
hello plebbit
>>83959511
No love for Jackie Brown?
Nobody loves Jackie Brown. Which is a shame, because it gets better the more you watch it.
>>83960002
>Best
Barry Lyndon
>Worst
Lolita
>Overrated
Dr. Strangelove
>Underrated
Paths of Glory (the one thing you got right)
2001: A Space Odyssey
>>83960002
Dumb
>>Best
>A Clockwork Orange
>>Worst
>Fear and Desire
>>Overrated
>Lolita
>>Underrated
>Eyes Wide Shut
>2001
>Best
Carne
>Worst
Love
>Overrated
Enter the Void
>Underrated
I Stand Alone
Irreversible
>Best
M
>Worst
Gardenia
>Overrated
Metropolis
>Underrated
Hangmen Also Die
Scarlet Street
>>83959061
Yep
>>83958529
The Quiet Man is really great
>Best
Dodsworth
>Worst
A House Divided
>Overrated
Roman Holiday
>Underrated
The Little Foxes
Ben-Hur
Mel Brooks
>The Producers
>Spaceballs
>Blazing Saddles
>To Be or Not to Be
>History of the World or Blazing Saddles
>Best
Pinocchio
>Worst
Mary Poppins
>Overrated
Peter Pan
>Underrated
Fantasia
Alice in Wonderland
>>83959238
>the curious case of benjamin button
The way light was used in that movie was great, it starts at night, stays dark until the protagonist has seen war, then lights up, goes dark and grey again towards the end.
Alien 3 under rated? That was a comic book of a movie, ew.
Fight Club did things never seen before in cinema, particularly the black-white flash to actually make the audience suffer a punch to the face.
You're all over the place m8.
>Best
Streetcar Named Desire
>Worst
The Wild One
>Overrated
Apocalypse Now
>Underrated
The Men
Godfather
>Best
Vertigo
>Worst
Family Plot
>Overrated
Rear Window
>Underrated
The Lady Vanishes
Rear Window
>>83959279
"no"
>>83959307
yea ill admit it still isnt good, but i don't think its that bad either. for what its worth benjamin button is the only movie he made that i think is worse, but despite this i can still think alien 3 is his most underrated.. and i do.
>>83960902
reddit: the post
>>83960605
>irreversible
you're a faggot
>>83958670
How can one man be so wrong about everything?
>Best
Avatar
>Worst
Titanic
>Overrated
Titanic
>Underrated
Avatar
Titanic
>>83958373
is that tim burton
>>83958373
>>Best
>No Country for Old Men
probably
>>Worst
>The Ladykillers
definitely the worst
>>Overrated
>Fargo
You gotta be kidding, Fargo is pure kino, an absolute classic.
>>Underrated
>The Man Who Wasn't There
this so much
>The Big Lebowski
just no.
>Best
There Will Be Blood
>Worst
Punch-Drunk Love
>Overrated
Inherent Vice
>Underrated
Magnolia
Boogie Nights
>>83960788
>Worst
>Mary Poppins
Nigga fuck you.
>>83964844
Nah
>best
The Master
>worst
Hard Eight
>overrated
Boogie Nights
>underrated
Inherent Vice
There Will Be Blood
>best
Before Sunset
>worst
Tape
>overrated
Slacker
>underrated
A Scanner Darkly
Boyhood
>>83958734
Inside Llewyn Davis is a masterpiece you unwashed mongrel piece of shit
>Best
Red Desert
>Worst
Story of a Love Affair
>Overrated
L'Avventura
>Underrated
Identification of a Woman
Blow-Up
>>Best
House of 1000 corpses
>>Worst
Halloween 2
>>Overrated
The Devils Rejects
>>Underrated
Halloween
Haunted World of El super beasto
>>83958373
>Best
12 Angry Men
>Worst
The Wiz
>Overrated
Serpico
>Underrated
The Hill/The Offence/Fail-Safe (the majority of his filmography really)
Network
>>83958670
>Aliens
But how?
>>83958966
>underrated
Bram Stoker's Dracula
>>83958695
>>Underrated
>FWWM
And not Wild at Heart? FWWM hasn't been underrated for years.
>>83958373
Robert Altman
>Best
M*A*S*H*
>Worst
Quintet
>Overrated
McCabe & Mrs. Miller
>Underrated
OC & Stiggs
The Player
>>83966156
John Carpenter
>Best
The Thing
>Worst
The Ward
>Overrated
Big Trouble in Little China
>Underrated
Village of the Damned (srsly, watch it)
Halloween
Walter Hill
>Best
The Driver
>Worst
The Assignment
>Overrated
Southern Comfort
>Underrated
Trespass
The Warriors
Michael Mann
>Best
Heat
>Worst
Public Enemies
>Overrated
Collateral
>Underrated
Manhunter
The Last of the Mohicans
>>83958697
>Underrated
Not The King of Comedy
>>83958373
>>Overrated
>Fargo
>>83958734
>Best
Inside / No Country / A Serious Man / Fargo / True Grit
>Worst
Hudsucker / Barton Fink / Lady Killers
>Overrated
Miller's Crossing
>Underrated
Inside / Burn After Reading / Blood Simple /
>>83958373
>Best
Ed Wood
>Worst
Alice in Wonderland
>Overrated
Sleepy Hollow
>Underrated
Sweeney Todd
>Best
Unforgiven
>Worst
Pink Cadillac
>Overrated
Million Dollar Baby
>extremely and criminally underrated
A Perfect World
>>83966551
>overrated = bad
Go read a book, nigger.
>>83966474
Mann's worst movie is either The Keep or L.A. Takedown, public enemy is just 6/10, not the worst
>>83966581
>Worst
>Barton Fink
How the fuck can you be such a pleb!? What, you think Barton was in the right!?
>>83966650
Should have put it in the overrated category desu. I appreciate the film, but like Miller's Crossing and Intolerable Cruelty I was really disappointed with it, perhaps I'd built it up to much.
>>83966692
>Barton Fink
>that perfect movie nobody ever talks about
>overrated
Their overrated films are True Grit and Llewlyn, not Barton Fink
>>83958670
>Aliens
That is correct.
>>83959238
i'd say that's on the money
>>83958670
Absolutely this
>>83958670
100%
>best
Prince of Darkness/The Thing
>worst
Memoirs of an Invisible Man
>overrated
Halloween
>underrated
Ghosts of Mars/Escape from LA
>>83966624
>public enemy is just 6/10
what a godawful opinion, Public Enemies is MAJOR
The Keep is his worst film, though.
>>83966624
>Public Enemies is not Mann's worst
I disagree. It's his least ambitious, in terms of script, themes, structure and aesthetics, not to mention expectations due to the cast, characters, setting, and genre. It marked Mann's decline artistically and commercially, the first movie that anyone could have directed, it lacked his "touch," which is the worst thing that can happen to a director of pure kino.
>>83959238
>the social network
>overrated
>>83965267
I tried watching his Halloween with an open mind the other day but stopped it the moment Myers spoke. Giving him a voice ruins a big part of what made the original so good.
>best
Sunset Boulevard
>worst
Love In The Afternoon
>underrated
Stalag 17
Fedora ;^))P
>>83966474
>Big Trouble overrated
>Halloween and Warriors reddit
Faggot.
Hal Ashby
>Best
The Last Detail
>Worst
Lookin' to Get Out
>Overrated
Being There
>Underrated
Bound for Glory
Harold & Maude
Jim Jarmusch
>Best
Dead Man
>Worst
The Limits of Control
>Overrated
Only Lovers Left Alive
>Underrated
Ghost Dog
Patterson
>>83966880
>>83966845
Idk, bale and lang were good in it. It's just mediocre film.
The Keep is shit. There's no redeeming qualities, maybe couple of good shot.
L.A. Takedown is cheap straight-to-tv trash, the only good part about that movie is that it was later remade as The Heat.
>>83967004
Lol, you prove my point. Yours is a Redditor reaction. Don't be late for first shift at Walmart on my account. Me? I'm not due on set for three more hours.
>>83966581
>>Overrated
>Miller's Crossing
Given that it's never talked about, I'd hardly call if overrated.
>Best
Dogville
>Worst
Dancer in the Dark (absolute trash)
>Overrated
Antichrist
>Underrated
Europa
Melancholia
>>83966826
>>best
>Prince of Darkness/The Thing
>>worst
>Memoirs of an Invisible Man
>>overrated
>Halloween
>>underrated
>Ghosts of Mars/Escape from LA
Correct, absolute Patrician taste.
>>83965292
Fail Safe gets me every fucking time. Even the name gives me goosebumps.
>>83960119
I'd switch the Following with the Prestige desu
>Best
La region centrale
>Worst
Presents
>Overrated
<---->
>Underrated
'Rameau's Nephew' by Diderot (Thanx to Dennis Young) by Wilma Schoen
Wavelength
>>83958670
Perfect
>>83958373
>The Big Lebowski
kind of annoyed but it's kind of true I guess...
>>83959238
Objectively correct but Fight Club is a really good movie, is he the only man to create reddit-kino?
>>83960119
Reddit is Dark Knight lol
>>83960788
Accurate af
>>83965157
>overrated
>Boyhood
>>83958670
completely wrong
>Best
300
>Worst
Batman v Superman
>Orverrated
Batman v Superman
>Underrated/Widely Misunderstood
Sucker Punch
Watchmen
>>83958373
>The Big Lebowski
that would be Fargo dumbass
>>83958373
If underrated is graded not just off obscurity but also quality as it should be Burn After Reading is easily their best lesser known movie
>Best
Barry Lyndon
>Worst
Killer's Kiss
>Overrated
Full Metal Jacket
>Underrated:
The Killing
>Reddit:
2001: A Space Odyssey
>>83958670
You had me until Aliens.
>>83958697
>>Overrated
>Goodfellas
good
>Wolf of Wall Street
you meant Taxi Driver
>>83966719
>Llwelyn
Now you've done it
>>83958734
>>best
>Fargo
>>worst
>Oh brother where art thou
>>overrated
>Inside llewyn davis
kill yourself
>>83960119
>>Best
Prestige
>>Worst
The Following
>>Overrated
Memento
>>Underrated
Insomnia
The Dark Knight
>Best
The Thing
>Worst
Ghosts of Mars
>Overrated
Halloween
>Underrated
In the Mouth of Madness
I don't really think there is one for Carpenter
>>83959238
>zodiac
Maybe you're right. I generally dislike movies based on true events/ biographies. This one was no different. It's not that it was a bad film, it just felt like watching a documentary.
>>83965267
absolute shit taste
>>83968386
Ftfy
>Bane?
The Dark Knight Rises
Inception
Batman Begins
The Prstige
The Dark Knight
Interstellar
Dunkirk
>Underrated
Memementos
>>83968780
>Dunkirk
kek
John Singleton
>Best
Boyz N Da Hood
>Worst
2 Fast 2 Furious
>Overrated
Poetic Justice
>Underrated
Higher Learning
>Shaft
Tony Scott
>Best
True Romance
>Worst
Domino
>Overrated
Crimson Tide
>Underrated
The Last Boy Scout
Top Gun
John McTiernan
>Best
Die Hard
>Worst
Rollerball
>Overrated
Crimson Tide
>Underrated
Predator
Last Action Hero
>>83967175
kys
>>83959238
>>overrated
>the social network
>not Se7en
kill you'reself
>>83958966
But part 2 was the better movie
>>83970190
Yeah, and therefore reddit
Best: Scream
Worst: scream sequels
Overrated: None
Underrated: Cursed
Reddit: None
Michael Bay
Best: Armageddon
Worst Pearl Harbor
Underrated the rock
Overrated pain and gain
Reddit transformers
>best
There Will Be Blood
>overrated
Magnolia
>Underrated
The Master
Inherent Vice
>>83972065
Vice is not reddit it's definitely tied with twbb
>>83972086
t. Reddit
>>83958373
You got it all wrong.
>Best
A Serious Men
>Worst
The Ladykillers
>Overrated
The Big Lebowsky
>Underrated
The Man Who Wasn`t there
Oh Brother Where Art Thou
>>83960605
>Best Carne
In what fucking universe is Carne better than Enter the Void. Carne is a little over average student film.
>>83958373
>Best
Der Siebente Kontinent
>Worst
Das Schloß
>Overrated
Nothing could be overrated, the man is perfect
>Underrated
Everything he has ever done
Funny Games US
>>83958529
>>The Searchers
Wouldn't reddit cry about a strong white male figure rescuing his daughterfu from barbaric indios?
>>83974267
>>83966719
True Grit is underrated if anything, no-one ever talks about it
>>83972111
kek
>Best
The Matrix
>Worst
Reloaded/Revolutions
>Overrated
V for Vendetta
>Underrated
Bound
Speed Racer
>>83974475
Who are these handsome alphas?
>>83974505
Just some nu-males that got lucky with one movie and have been shit ever since
>>83959238
Dont listen to this fags, alien 3 is underrated.
>>83959511
I would sayy its slightly different.
>Best
Django Unchained
>Worst
Death Proof
>Overrated
Reservoir Dogs
>Underrated
Kill Bill Vol. 2
Pulp Fiction
>>83958670
100% correct.
>>83960668
I'd put Spione as the underrated (favorite kino of old' Adolf by the way), otherwise on point.
>>83969155
>>Underrated
>Predator
>Last Action Hero
Switch those and you're good
>>83959717
>Best
PDL
>Worst
Inherent Vice
>Overrated
TWBB
>Underrated
PDL
Inherent Vice
>>83959846
Thats correct.
Like redditors like rick and Morty because "muh existentialism and science lmao".
Or fight club because "fuck the corporations man".
Reddit is college dudebros or tumblerinas just getting into film.
>>83960002
>Best
BL
>Worst
Spartacus
>Overrated
ACO
>Underrated
PoG
ACO
>>83959717
I would agree with this, though there will be blood is easily his best. Incoherent vice blows dick
>>83960770
This is more or less correct and I'm suprised I found someone who agrees with me on this pleb board
>Best
To The Wonder
>Worst
Thin Red Line
>Overrated
Tree of Life
>Underrated
New World
redditors don't get Malick
>Best
Chimes At Midnight
>Worst
The Stranger
>Overrated
Citizen Kane
>Underrated
F For Fake
Lady From Shanghai
>>83974648
Django unchained is his worse film.
The only patrician film Tarantino ever did was Jackie Brown.
>>83964844
>Best
Punch Drunk Love
>Worst
Inherent Vice
>Overrated
There will Be Blood
>Underrated
The Master
Boogie Nights
FTFY
>>83960478
>underrated
>eyes wide shut
bring this to an immediate halt
>>83960788
>Best
The Jungle Book
>Worst
Walt Disney produced copious amounts of garbage while still alive. Mary Poppins is not one of these things.
>Overrated
Cinderella
>Underrated
The sword in the stone
Fantasia
>Best
Phantom Of The Paradise
>Worst
Black Dahlia
>Overrated
Carrie
>Underrated
Carlito's Way
Scarface
>>83958695
>underrated not Blue Velvet
>>83975567
many consider blue velvet one of his best. In no way is it underrated
>>83958373
>Best
O Brother Where Art Thou
>Worst
lol as if
>Overrated
Intolerable Cruelty
>Underrated
The Ladykillers
No Country for Old Men