[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / bant / biz / c / can / cgl / ck / cm / co / cock / d / diy / e / fa / fap / fit / fitlit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mlpol / mo / mtv / mu / n / news / o / out / outsoc / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / spa / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vint / vip / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Search | Free Show | Home]

EDH/Commander General /edhg/

This is a blue board which means that it's for everybody (Safe For Work content only). If you see any adult content, please report it.

Thread replies: 366
Thread images: 49

File: I Accidently All The Mana.jpg (75KB, 312x445px) Image search: [Google]
I Accidently All The Mana.jpg
75KB, 312x445px
"Madness" Edition

Previous: >>54940682

RESOURCES

>Official Site: Contains deck building rules and the current ban list.
http://www.mtgcommander.net

>Deck List Site: You can search for decks that other people have made. Authors often have comments that explain their deck’s strategy and card choices.
http://www.tappedout.net

>Horrible place with primers, access at your own risk.
http://www.mtgsalvation.com/forums/the-game/commander-edh

>Statistically see what everyone else puts in their commander decks based on what is posted to the the internet.
http://www.edhrec.com/

>Find out what lands you can add to your deck, sorted by category, based on a chosen Commander’s color identity.
http://manabasecrafter.com/

CARD SEARCH

>Official search site. Current for all sets.
http://gatherer.wizards.com/

>Unofficial, but has GOAT search interface.
http://magiccards.info/

Thread Question: What's the most fucked board you've seen? Did you cause it?
>>
File: 1502433408836.jpg (93KB, 849x497px) Image search: [Google]
1502433408836.jpg
93KB, 849x497px
Once you go jank, things get too dank.
>>
>Playing Rashimi
>Have Rashmi and Mind's Dilation on the field
>Get to play my opponents' decks and my deck at the same time

I think the best play last night was when an opponent cast an overloaded Cyclonic Rift, and Mind's Dilation's Trigger let me cast a Counter spell from his deck.
>>
>>54953990
i have a yidris deck that basically does the same thing. it casts like 4 cards off of a single card each turn. my group hates the fuck out of it but its my favorite to play cause its just so much fun
>>
>>54953895
Agreed. There is absolutely nothing that indicates the restriction is a copyable part of the ability, rather than an effect that applies specifically to the abilites granted by the static ability the restriction is part of. Eli is a fuckwit who needs to stop pulling RM fiat bullshit that contradicts the Comprehensive Rules and all existing precedent. Between that and his "hurr durr no fun rules interactions allowed" bullshit, he's just as bad as Tabak.
>>
>>54953895
>you may activate each of THOSE abilities once per turn
Now, I really do understand where you're coming from.
Quicksilver should either do absolutely nothing for him or let him go infinite.
However I think it's still very worth to run it just so you can drop it and copy Mairsil for the infinite abilities, not to mention Mairsil still being able to target other creatures with it.
>>
>>54953880
>What's the most fucked board you've ever seen?
Oh man, I have a bunch of these.
>Mayael resolving a Primal Surge by saying "oops, all permanents" and flooding the board with all the biggest shit you can imagine
>OG Kozilek/Ulamog coming on the board and swinging before an opponent even has four things to sacrifice, leaving them with an empty board against an Titan
>Dingus casul dropping a panic Obliterate managing to take everything off the board except Nicol Bolas, Planeswalker
I caused the first two quite a few times, but the last one is a special story that me and my no longer dingus casul buddy still laugh about. That misplay ended with a straight up lockout for three players.
>>
File: Image (2).jpg (36KB, 223x310px) Image search: [Google]
Image (2).jpg
36KB, 223x310px
Got in on the last thread pretty late. Haven't played magic in a while and looking to play some edh again. Looking for advice on this. This is my current deck.

http://tappedout.net/mtg-decks/19-08-17-mayael-the-anima-edh/
>>
File: 1474705810255.png (49KB, 448x439px) Image search: [Google]
1474705810255.png
49KB, 448x439px
So I looked at one of those StarCityGames Heavily Played Commander packs (The black one) and decided to price it out. For $75 it seems like you're getting about $120 worth of stuff. The only real money cards are Attrition, Diabolic Intent, Grave Pact, No Mercy, Ob Nix, The Fallen, and Wound Reflection.

Doesn't really seem worth it. to be honest.
>>
>>54954119
its still totally a combo piece and should be run.

I am just upset at the mystery rulling.
>>
>>54953880
>What's the most fucked board you've seen? Did you cause it?
rhe second people start doing "chaos" faggorty i just scoop. i dont want to spend two bored as fuck not even playing real magic cause some faglord wants to jerk off to his "le omg so ebin troll" deck

would rather just drop that game and play hearth stone on my phone instead
>>
File: 84.jpg (63KB, 312x445px) Image search: [Google]
84.jpg
63KB, 312x445px
>>54953930
Are there any 4cmc cost creatures that could possible make running this worth it?
>>
>>54954158
>stuff from kike city isnt worth it

no shit, they are just trying to unload stuff that isnt selling on you for a still higher price than heavily played stuff on TCGplayer. never buy from kike city games, they are basically the best buy of magic
>>
>>54954195
clever impersonator for one
>>
>>54954154
What is the point of Karametra in that deck?
>>
>>54954158
The thing with those packs is that you're getting cards that most people already have a ton of. You get some good stuff but you're better off just buying the singles you need of TCGplayer like normal. Its like buying a commander precon just for the commander, just not worth it.
>>
Here is my proposed ban list for the format to make it more fair and allow competitive EDH to flourish.

1. All mana ramp

2. All land destruction

3. All kill spells

4. All cards involved in infinite combos

5. The color green

6. All uncommons, rares, and mythic rares
>>
>>54954195
Any clone. Too bad it's one off things like Phyrexian Delver.
>>
File: aetherplasm.jpg (73KB, 312x445px) Image search: [Google]
aetherplasm.jpg
73KB, 312x445px
>>54954195
>get attacked
>transfigure for this and block with it
>put emrakul in play

gg no re
>>
>>54954328
>get into argument that you're running a banned card
>punch opponent in face
>take his cards
Easiest game of my life.
>>
>>54954318
Poorfag go away
>>
>>54954318
>Craw Wurm is a common
I know who is behind THIS post!
>>
>>54953880
can you only run this card in 5c decks because of symbols rather than words?
>>
>>54954281
Entirely for ramp. The deck goes into overdrive as soon as you can start casting guys from hand, plus using mayael. She easy enough to turn into a creature (mayael, parameter, any 3 green or 3 white idiot) and she pulls lands out of the deck so mayael activations are more likely to hit. She's been surprisingly powerful desu
>>
>>54954393
Yes
>>
>>54954357
>he knows

SHUT
IT
DOWN
>>
>>54953880
Haha, OP, you seemed to have forgotten the Discord info. Here it is:

/tg/ EDH General Discord
https://discord.gg/UE9Vqzu

Don't beat yourself up about it though. Just try to be less forgetful next time.
>>
>>54954541
filtered
>>
>>54954577
Sorry for violating your safe space. That was a dick move of me.
>>
>>54954328
Sorcery speed only.
>>
>>54954195
Rakdos Lord of Riots
Also goes well in a casual-oriented Marchesa Black Rose deck.
>>
>>54954713
Rakdos is a dead draw in most 3 colored decks, super hard to cast shit like that even with proper mana base, at least until turn 7.
>>
>>54954699
>quicken show and tell
>show aetherplasm
>switch for emma

:^)
>>
File: 72.jpg (62KB, 312x445px) Image search: [Google]
72.jpg
62KB, 312x445px
>>54954195
This doesn't have actual synergy with Mairsil himself but I'd argue better synergy with the rest of the deck unless you built artifacts.
>>
>>54954154

I'd move some of your Sorcery based ramp to creature based ramp, stuff like Druid of the Anima or Sylvan Caryatid. Is Purphoros really worth it in the deck, as it doesn't seem like his damage Trigger will go off all that often, and you are already playing fatties. I really like Stonehoof Chieftan and Iroas, God of Victory, as they make attacks that would not be profitable into the ability to break creature stalls or straight up profitable.

I'd also put in one non-damage based boardwipe, Wrath of God or something. I also like Seasons Past as it can give you a second wind so to speak or help you recover from a Boardwipe.
>>
>>54954861
Necrotic Ooze is one of those cards that is good in almost any Mono-B or Bx deck simply because, even if you're not using it to combo, it can generate some decent value.
>>
>>54954861
I feel like with the amount of bounce and flicker most Mairsil decks will have Necrotic Ooze will actually be counterproductive unless your opponents are sure to have anything worthwhile.
>>
File: wut.jpg (9KB, 543x271px) Image search: [Google]
wut.jpg
9KB, 543x271px
>>54954195
Inverter of truth
>>
>>54954154
>set every card to foil to raise the price on tapped out
>add duals you dont have
>still only $1600
You are bad, stop making decks and delete your accounts
>>
>>54954824
Your pet card sucks, at least learn the rules before posting or go back to the modern general
>>
>>54955287
Not even the same anon, my guy.
>>
>>54953930
I want to play the dank jank lord, what are some spicy cards to include?
>>
File: Overgrown Battlements.jpg (38KB, 375x523px) Image search: [Google]
Overgrown Battlements.jpg
38KB, 375x523px
guys i saved mtg
>>
>>54955480
Mirror-Mad+Lab Man+Azami
Infernal Denizen
Shauku
Arcanis
Horseshoe Crab
Pack Rat
AEtherling
>>
>>54955559
>Horseshoe Crab
I know there's a few better untap options but I can't NOT run Horseshoe Crab.
>>
File: 1462120364488.jpg (767KB, 1574x1386px) Image search: [Google]
1462120364488.jpg
767KB, 1574x1386px
>>54953880
>What's the most fucked board you've seen?
This one
>Did you cause it?
Yes
>>
>>54955589
It looks like Daretti, Jace, and Lazav, but who's the 4th?
>>
>>54955494
Or you could print true dual lands that are only legal in commander.
>>
>>54955589
Hey get that picture of me off of 4chan!
>>
>>54954874
I like the sorcery ramps only for the ability to pull lands out of the deck. I'd be more inclined to play rocks over mana dorks just because they dodge wraths. That being said, purphoros is probably the weakest card in the deck and I think I only like holding onto it for the synergy with avenger. Iroas or stonehoof are probably both stronger.

>>54955253
>thinking I don't own duals
>thinking I don't own foils
>thinking I'm not fabulously wealthy

Poorfags like you ruin this game and make me sick. Quit. Today.
>>
File: nazimeme.jpg (4KB, 200x200px) Image search: [Google]
nazimeme.jpg
4KB, 200x200px
>>54955494
>screeches in investor
Delet this
>>
File: 203.jpg (64KB, 312x445px) Image search: [Google]
203.jpg
64KB, 312x445px
>>54955494
original name, donut steel
>>
>>54955664
oh wow i didnt bother googling it
>>
>>54955494
>no basic land types
meh
>>
>>54955494
>no basic land type

literally just print silver/gold bordered dual lands, ez pz
>>
>>54955637
Karador
>>
>>54955637
If I had to guess freyalise
>>
>>54955589
>unsleeved cards
>>
>>54955723
It was a dark time. I got better
>>
File: 1457852987492.gif (2MB, 270x175px) Image search: [Google]
1457852987492.gif
2MB, 270x175px
>>54955589
>Deretti player has no sleeves
>the only one with a playmat is the Jace player
>Avacyn the Purifier face down when it's the better artwork
>drinks with no lid on them
I agree, that's fucking awful.
>>
>>54955734
>dark time

if you cant afford 5 dollars for some sleeves you should probably focus on getting a job instead of playing EDH
>>
>>54955735
That lidless "drink" was a spit cup, my friend chews tobacco
>>
>>54955755
I don't think he means he couldn't afford them, anon.
>>
>>54955761
That's fucking disgusting.
>>
>>54955761
your friend should kill himself and you should not associate with him anymore, thats fucking disgusting
>>
File: 3pYGMd93.jpg (153KB, 420x377px) Image search: [Google]
3pYGMd93.jpg
153KB, 420x377px
>>54955761
It gets worse.
>>
>>54955589
>square table for 4 players
>ultra pro playmat
>the most basic of basic lands
>artifacts stacked on top of each other for convenience's sake
>pentivus with 14 counters on it
My autism burns with rage of every soul in hell.
>>
>>54955761
That is quite gross to be honest.
>>
>>54955780
Correct
>>54955755
I have a job, but I was pretty green to Magic at the time and didn't understand the importance of sleeves. I got smart, don't worry
>>
>>54955800
Darksteel Juggernaut, bitch nigga
>>
>>54955813
>pretty green to magic
>those cards
>that way or organizing your graveyard

not buying it
>>
File: Soldier.jpg (70KB, 312x445px) Image search: [Google]
Soldier.jpg
70KB, 312x445px
>>54955813
>tfw have a secret tech against people who play without sleeves
>>
>>54955813
>3 people at the table with sleeves that clearly understand the importance of sleeves
>yet the 4th one refused to use them
Autism is at work here
>>
http://tappedout.net/mtg-decks/riku-rug-goodstuff-1/
Does anyone have any sugestions to add/replace? I used to run Surrak as a commander, but Riku lets you copy creatures for extra ETB effects
>>
File: images (8).jpg (25KB, 300x416px) Image search: [Google]
images (8).jpg
25KB, 300x416px
>This triggers the /tg/
>>
>>54955988
I despise alters that have nothing to do with the original card. What in the fuck does The Joker have to do with Force of Will?
>>
>>54956022
>draw on an expensive piece of cardboard and everyboby LOSES THEIR MINDS
>>
>>54956074
Okay, you got me. I had a hard nostril exhale.
>>
>>54955988
I like that he's holding some period cards, including a recognizable Jester's Cap. That's the kind of note that brings "Technially skilled but shitty concept" alter to the level of "OK as alters go"
>>
File: 5Fu4ClW.jpg (103KB, 716x960px) Image search: [Google]
5Fu4ClW.jpg
103KB, 716x960px
>>54955988
I have seen so much shit, this doesn't affect me anymore.
>>
>>54956111
I was going to post that one but ive been temp banned before for pony content on non pony boards

Zeig heil mods
>>
>>54955494
>will just get played alongside taiga
Fuck no. Either pay up or suck up. Either be a busted cEDH faggot or play monocolor like a real man.
>>
File: 11072011medinaretard.jpg (30KB, 250x225px) Image search: [Google]
11072011medinaretard.jpg
30KB, 250x225px
>>54956111
>marker some ponies onto power 9
>raise the price a few hundred bucks
>>
>>54956111
I want to believe that the drawings are only on the outer sleeves.
>>
>>54956111
I never noticed the horrible "guru" duals above the ponies. They look like they were drawn with markers.
>>
>>54956207
I really want a copy of that card.
>>
>>54956111
Guru Duals are kinda cool. Pony P9 (well, p10) is horrifying. Not because of anything to do with bronies (I'm not one but I can't bring myself to hate the show over them either. I watched some when it was getting all the hype and for a kids show it was ok) or because of the technical skill exhibited (They look like what they're supposed to look like) but god damn what is your concept? Your reason for being? OK ha ha a couple of the ponies have colors or powers that would fit with the card they're depicted on, but that's key: A couple. The rest are stretches AT BEST, which makes your concept of a cycle weak and prevents it from recovering from the cringe of deciding to mix children's' television and classically esoteric MTG (Because they're both hasbro products now?) which maybeit could have done if it offered something creative or interesting.
>>
>>54956221
Nope. Some ponyfag posted them a few years ago all proud of his altered power. Everyone told him he was an idiot, but he went on about how he would never sell them, and thats that he wanted, so it wasn't an issue that he just tanked the value by at least 50%, etc. A few months later they showed up for sale.
>>
>>54955877
That's a fivehead.
>>
>>54955988
>giving a shit about a card that costs more than most of my decks and i will never buy
>>
>>54956480
Why even post then you bitter poorfag?
>>
File: 1LarjkG.jpg (47KB, 375x523px) Image search: [Google]
1LarjkG.jpg
47KB, 375x523px
>>54953880
>Implying anone plays enough basic lands for this to have effect
Maybe if they are all playing monocolour decks
>>
>>54956111
>>54956239
>>54956274
I thought the Guru Underground Seas were pretty good looking, but obviously I can't see much detail from the angle of the picture.
>>
>>54956584
It affects nonbasics with basic land types you retarded ccg scum of the earth
>>
>>54954195
Solemn simulacrum
>>
>Bought a Wade into Battle deck for 15$ 1 month ago
>Today, just Urza's incubator and Magus of the Wheel are together double than that

Feels fucking good. I don't know how Incubators didn't change price until a week ago. Planned on getting one as soon as I knew of Tribal decks
>>
>>54956584
scarlet pimpernel
my brother of african ancestry
>>
>>54954176
This would make some goood copypasta. I'm gonna save this.
>>
>>54956889
>Magus is $10-15
What the fuck I bought mine for $2

What happened?
>>
Gonna buy the Kitty deck, what are some good upgrades for it? I'm thinking about going a Hatebears shell with Mirri at the helm
>>
I feel like I forgot something very important in my Sliver Queen deck, but I can't put my finger on it. Ignore my shit mana base, I have a stash of other duals to look through somewhere, I'm just lazy and these are cheap fillers

http://tappedout.net/mtg-decks/budget-sliver-queen/

http://tappedout.net/mtg-decks/budget-sliver-queen/
>>
>>54957183
People really want their wheels.
>>
>>54957220
God damn am I glad I bought 2 OG Wheels for $25-30 apiece, now the Revised one is like $50 alone
>>
File: necro zur.png (2MB, 1916x1080px) Image search: [Google]
necro zur.png
2MB, 1916x1080px
Pretty sweet.
Million drake chump blockers, Necro pay life, Faith of the Devoted drain life, draw more, pay more, drain more.
>>
>>54957183
Its played in legacy now
>>
>>54953880
>What's the most fucked board you've seen? Did you cause it?

Yeah, with my Prossh deck. Sac outlets, tons of tokens, draw triggers, discard triggers, etc. Every time I sacrificed a creature everyone would have to sacrifice one of their own, I'd draw cards, they'd discard cards, they'd take damage, they'd take more damage, I'd gain life for damage taken, they'd lose life for my life gained, etc. It was pretty nuts.
>>
Is Kokusho the Evening Star good as Commander? Didnt he used to be banned? Im assuming you just sac and reanimate him again and again but im not sure theres that many reanimation spells
>>
>>54957603
There are when you're playing Kokusho. Corpse Dance with buyback, swing, sacrifice, rinse and repeat. Also toss a Blade of Selves on him, that's always fun.
>>
>>54957603
Grab a few amplifier effects; Exquisite Blood works well
>>
Which commander are sociopaths most likely to play?
>>
>>54957693
Derevi.
>>
>>54957432
What? Where?
>>
>>54957693
brago
>>
>>54953880
Would this card cause a Volcanic Island to tap for BR?
>>
>>54957693
Before, Leovold.

Now, probably Baral or Yidris
>>
>>54957733
>Islands produce G, Mountains produce U
No.
>>
Is Edgar the new best Vampire commander?
>>
File: Mandra.png (2MB, 2560x1440px) Image search: [Google]
Mandra.png
2MB, 2560x1440px
Still trying to cut this down, slowly but surely. Need to cut 20 more cards. (I always have an extremely hard time cutting down decks because whenever I consider cutting I card I think "but it could be useful in X situation...")

http://tappedout.net/mtg-deckpaste/edgar-markov-vampire-edh-3/
>>
>>54957816
Not until Ixalan and new white vampires. Until then it's still Olivia with C17 support.
>>
>>54957733
"If a land has more than one basic land type, the player tapping the land for mana can choose to produce mana of either color. But if it produces more than one mana, all mana is of the same color."
In the Naked Singularity rulings. So it can produce one or the other, but not more than the land would normally produce.
>>
File: strands2.jpg (32KB, 223x310px) Image search: [Google]
strands2.jpg
32KB, 223x310px
>>54957603
kokusho is one of the stronger commanders in monoblack, assuming no one plays rest in peace against you

and yeah, you just reanimate him over and over while casting creature-based black goodstuff to keep yourself safe. you can also clear the board whenever you feel like it since kokusho prefers being dead anyway. there's a billion good reanimation cards in monoblack, so don't worry about that

i actually have a kokusho decklist from back when my group still let me play it if you want to take a look
>>
>>54957843
Thank you.
>>
>>54957693
GW Selvala stax.
>>
>>54957825
Drop the white, dont let mardu meme you, vampires are black splash red using olivia 1.0 or mono black
>>
>>54957693
Taniwha
>>
>>54957932
even better, build edgar in monoblack, using his eminence ability to make vampire tokens to feed to your smokestack and contamination
>>
File: images (3).jpg (40KB, 451x326px) Image search: [Google]
images (3).jpg
40KB, 451x326px
>>54957962
Glorious
>>
File: u7807ucmq5_ur_wk20_300_cardart4.jpg (128KB, 620x462px) Image search: [Google]
u7807ucmq5_ur_wk20_300_cardart4.jpg
128KB, 620x462px
How come Marchesa 1.0 and 2.0 look so different?
Also she looks like she has a lot of really cute interactions in a R/B counter-style deck. Read: Vampires.
>>
>>54957932
Why wouldn't you gladly get better removal, board wipes and weenie synergy like Anointed Procession and Mentor of the Meek?
>>
File: Power Play.jpg (180KB, 800x1200px) Image search: [Google]
Power Play.jpg
180KB, 800x1200px
>>54958015
I dunno.
I do remember some anon came in once and posted their edit to Marchesa 1.0 by doing a foil peel and replacing the original art with the art from the conspiracy Power Play.
It looked 100x better and even felt more in character for her and more in line with the card.
>>
>>54958015
Marchesa 1.0 tailored and made herself up to look guady. She wanted people to think she was a spoiled lady playing at intrigue instead of the true mastermind, and was more than willing to use her appearance to provoke those thoughts, even from those who knew better. Queen Marchesa staged a bloodless coup. She needed to appear immaculately regal, and to give off the idea that even a hint of doubt in her power would be met with crushing response.

Or they didn't like how OG Marchesa looked and redesigned her.
>>
>>54958015
>>54958079
>>54958100
Do you think we'll get a Conspiracy 3?
What would the third Marchesa be?
>>
>>54958163
Spirit form like Brago would be the cop-out answer
>>
>>54958163
Marchesa, Queen Eternal. The cycle begins anew.
>>
>>54958163
Marchesa, Fallen with Adriana's boot on her head.
>>
>>54955761
it got worse
>>
Anyone have some spicy queen marchesa tech
>>
>>54958193
Only if we get a patricians scorn reprint with ghost marchesa on it.
>>
>>54958260
Something like Marchesa, Fallen Majesty sounds cool.
>>
>>54958015
Different artists, Gideon is a different person on every single one of his cards, Ajani is the nuwalker with the most consistency artwise because he's a fucking lionman and he's got no facial features or skin tone to fuck up.
>>
>>54957603
I've been running him ever since he got unbanned, and there are probably better choices, but Kokusho is definitely solid, especially if you run with a larger group. Run it exactly how you'd expect, really, spam sac and reanimate until everyone is dead and you have all the life.
http://tappedout.net/mtg-decks/the-sushi-train-has-no-brakes/
Here's my list to check out to get the gist of it.
>>
Animar reprint when?
>>
>>54958509
C18 :^)
>>
File: FlowersByIrene.jpg (35KB, 232x344px) Image search: [Google]
FlowersByIrene.jpg
35KB, 232x344px
>>54958163
>Conspiracy 3: The Begining
>Set years in the past
>Loli Princess Marchesa
>need for research purposes
>>
>>54958708
>c18 is literally just a reprint of animar, atraxa, prosh, and fag kings

wizard would totally do this wouldnt they?
>>
>>54955589
No fucking sleeves
WHY
>>
>>54955656
>asks for advice
>ignores advice

lol
>>
>>54956207
>raise the price a few hundred bucks

If I remember, the person who did the alters did them on commission from a store that wanted to cash in on the brony phase, and the owner ended up having to mark them down to like 75% the value of unaltered ones before someone would buy them.
>>
>>54958864
Its ok anon he is rolling around in money he doesnt need advice, infact 3 supermodels are blowing him while he phone posts from his private jet on his way to his home in the caymans
>>
File: microexpressions-disgust.jpg (28KB, 524x336px) Image search: [Google]
microexpressions-disgust.jpg
28KB, 524x336px
>>54958909
>phone posting
>>
>>54958934
phone posting is the cancer of 4chan
>>
>>54958940
Don't worry, soon all the ISP ranges will be banned.

I hate it so much. Work wifi blocks 4chan.
>>
File: 7355093062697275436-account_id=1.jpg (272KB, 2048x1152px) Image search: [Google]
7355093062697275436-account_id=1.jpg
272KB, 2048x1152px
>>54953880
> What's the most fucked board you've seen?
First time playing EDH in a long time, That Guy was playing a That Guy Deck that revolved around playing magic with everyone else's deck.

Steals my doubling season, Steals and copies my hive queen.

>>54957693
> pic related
>>
File: JA_3[1].jpg (87KB, 600x281px) Image search: [Google]
JA_3[1].jpg
87KB, 600x281px
I just got done converting my zombie tribal Scarab God to zombie tribal Sidisi, Brood Tyrant and scrapping Scorpion God for Grenzo, Dungeon Warden. Locust God seems worth keeping as the head of its deck though.

How have the Bolas Bugs done for you guys, now that it's been a while?
>>
>>54955584
Gonna throw that horseshoe crab in horseshoe crab prison.
>>
>>54955589

>drinks

I force my playgroup to place their drinks on the ground, one guy's cards once got ruined thanks to someone that wasn't even playing dropping a beer on the table

never again
>>
>>54957432
lulwut

do you even play legacy?
>>
File: images (1).jpg (12KB, 512x288px) Image search: [Google]
images (1).jpg
12KB, 512x288px
>>54959023
I dont understand the phone posting meme, is it because everyone on 4channel is stereotyped as a 30 something male neckbeard in their parents basement?, some people ned bants while thet are at work, we cant shitpost to other people around us
>>
Dumb Question Time:
>Necropotence, Phyrexian Reclamation and Volrath all out
>Pitch a fatty to Volrath, Necro triggers
>In response to Necro trigger on the stack, pay B and 1 life to return said fatty to my hand with Reclamation

Can I do this?
>>
What would you call a deck that doesn't have a specific wincon? It isn't going for a combo and not specifically general damage. It has some beaters but it isn't a deck dedicated to smashing face with huge creatures. Some removal but not control... What are these decks and are they any fun? I feel like they would either be really fun due to varying games or they'd be shit as they had no real focus.
>>
>>54959328
Yeah.
>>
>>54959367
Probably some kind of midrange. Midrange shifts back and forth between being control-y and smashy as needed and does a little bit of everything. Clone/copy decks are also in that similar vein. Goodstuff can be too (most midrange decks tend to be goodstuff ie. Jund in Modern).
>>
>>54959258
Its a standin for some goblin prison decks, same reason fiery confluence from c15 is pushing $12-13 dollarydoos
>>
>>54959367
Goodstuff?
>>
>>54959367
I would call a deck like that.... shit
>>
File: e55.jpg (161KB, 1890x1417px) Image search: [Google]
e55.jpg
161KB, 1890x1417px
>>54958509
When Wizards comes out with FTV: Commander Edition

>Yearly product of one high-tuned EDH deck (But not too high-tuned, don't want to make it too valuable)
>Focused around a highly played/popular commander (be it from a Commander set or a regular block)
>Includes reprints of expensive staples (Crucible of Worlds, Mana Vault, Seedborn Muse, Painlands, Shocklands, Doubling Season, etc) that fit the deck
>Basic lands included are either Guild Lands (If it's a 2-color deck) or Guru Lands (If otherwise)
>Rares/Mythics in the deck are all foiled
>Commanders all get new art
>Comes with one of those fancy new life counters in exclusive coloring
>Retails for $250USD
>First release is Animar + Eldrazis, followed by Prossh Foodchain
>>
File: stf98_Inside_Out2.jpg (69KB, 250x250px) Image search: [Google]
stf98_Inside_Out2.jpg
69KB, 250x250px
>>54958741
You're the creepy faggot at fnm with hentai playmats, aren't you?
>>
>>54959410
>>54959420
I figured they'd be goodstuff but type of thing but you still need to pick the individual cards. Doesn't that leave you with the same problem of getting powerful creatures or control cards etc?

Not really sure I've heard of a midrange commander deck.
>>
>>54959077
Scarab God does work in my Sidisi deck, he's alright even though I pulled like 3 of them already

Locust God is built up, just waiting for that one enchantment in C17 to come out before trying him out at my LGS.

Scorpion god a shit, I might throw him in Kaervek but I don't see him doing much in there.
>>
>>54959453
Midrange doesn't tend to work well in Commander because in commander you either want to build your deck toward an extreme or go full goodstuff. Midrange tends to be a more tuned form of goodstuff that wants the best of both sides.
>>
File: StarCityGames.jpg (25KB, 343x400px) Image search: [Google]
StarCityGames.jpg
25KB, 343x400px
>>54959444
>edh targeted product
>had modern staples
>sorry we sold out before preorder but we have new stock
>price is $500+
>lgs's face when
>>
>>54959488
Ah now that makes more sense.
>>
>>54959481
Scopry has some bullshit crazy synergy with alot of wither cards from shadowmoor/eventide like midnight banshee and kulrath knight, scorp is also the reason necroskitter jumped to 3 dolla
>>
>>54959367
Got an Atraxa.
Its wins a good amount of times through commander damage, swinging with a buffed horde or denying the oponants win cons.
It has a healthy dose of evrything.
Its not even truly good stuff.
It's just able to handle its self under most any situation
>>
>>54959796
>>54959488
That sounds good, but what about Riku? Seems like I can double the value of almost everything by paying another 2.
>>
>>54959831
Riku is good for goodstuff because there are tons of good ETBs and if anything could do midrange, it would probably be him. The thing is that the deck may rely on him too much if you aren't careful and Riku is definitely a high-priority target once he hits the table.
>>
>played magic for years
>only play mainly edh the last few years
>want to brew new decks
>wife isnt interested in playing and I feel like im forced to spend time with her instead
>binders full of cards I just look at and dont use anymore
>probably moving to a new country so there is no point even trying
Halp
>>
>>54959855
I figure he's just a nice bonus? Getting two Acidic Slimes is great but one will still work nicely. But I see what you mean. I might still give it a shot. If anything it's definitely why I was attracted to the format: I have singles of good cards but not playsets.
>>
>>54959857

No one cares about your blog.
>>
>>54959074
When did Riku clone/steal become a That Guy deck?
>>
>>54959913
>doesn't care
>cares enough to reply anyway indicating you do care
Y-y-you want me to suck your dick or something? ill gargle your cum and make love bubbles before I swallow senpai
>>
>>54958864
>asked for advice
>made me realize how shit purphoros is
>cut purphoros and bought and iroas to test

You don't know me.

>>54958909
4 but thanks for backing me up.
>>
>>54959444
So Premium Deck Series: Commander. I didn't think All Foil Burn/All Foil Slivers sold well enough for them.
>>
>>54959284
mobile users are almost exclusively normies and redditors
>>
>>54960234
But that's wrong. I use it when I'm in the office with nothing to do or when I'm on the train. I have to do shit to support this crappy lifestyle somehow.
>>
>>54960230
>picked up 4 copies of fire and lightning for $15 each in a sale bin at some small toy store
>my legacy burn deck is lit af
>>
>>54960234
I guess im a normie then, I should kill myself, also I used to use reddit for puca and now cardshpere, im a fucking abomination
>>
>>54957292
What program is this again?
>>
>>54960273
>at the office
fuck off normie
>>
>>54960325
Ha im at work now too, fuck making $64 an hour on a Sunday morning, I want to stay home and shitpost brewing decks with cards ill never own
Reeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee
>pictureofafrog.png
>>
>>54960325
Life isn't free, anon, and I don't intend to mooch off of people. I've been here for too long to be a normie at this point.
>>
>>54960362
>thinks he is hot shit
>works on weekends

what a loser
>>
>>54959444
>Rares/Mythics in the deck are all foiled
product ruined
>>
>>54960325
I bet you are going to tell us you are a chef at Wendy's next.
>>
>>54960283
That's pretty sweet. F&L would be worth as much for the Chain Lightnings if nothing else.
>>
>>54960387
>living the meme
>>
Anyone got a "that guy" story?
Ill start
>go to LGS for Commander league
>League rules are spells that destroy all lands only destroy 4 of the spell owners choice instead, 5 trigger limit per turn to help curtail infinites
>sit down for league game
>pull out Teysa,Orzhov Scion
>Mimeoplasm, Aurelia, and Nissa Flipwalker are at table
>Nissa dudes deck is monstrously tall, some dude asks if its triple sleeved
>Yes its triple sleeved
>its not only triple sleeved, but its all foil, altered art, random Gold Border effect, and most cards have a signature, it looks like a fucking mess
>dude takes fucking minutes to shuffle each time
>League game going on, I get turn 3 Teysa into turn 4 Blasting Station+Darkest Hour, start pinging Mimeoplasm player for 5 each turn and then on my next turn make it 10 with a Blood Artist, kill him on his 5th turn upkeep
>he gets salty and storms off
>meanwhile Nissa dude starts ramping out of control, Genesis Waves for 19 and puts down all his big creatures plus a Helix Pinnacle
>"ha good luck beating me now im winning on the next upkeep it has shroud btw :)"
>Aurelia player fucking Insurrections and kills him with all his own creatures
>dude flips the fuck out gets super salty
>Blames me for pulling out the Darkest Hour combo
>Aurelia player flat out tells him his deck was annoying to be at the table with and wasnt fun
>Nissa dude grabs his twin tower sized deck and storms off, hasnt been back since
>>
>>54960418
Yeahi was happy, playsets of fireblast, chain lightning, price of progress, flames of the bloodhand (when it was played before skullcrack) 16 lightning bolts all in foil
>>
>>54960451
Why didn't you kill the Nissa player first? There's nothing more satisfying than screwing over some fag who thinks their deck is some special bullshit. Actually, it would be better if you played a lot of steal effects and handled them yourself. Mindslaver Lock to not even let him play with them.
>>
File: unnamed (4).gif (5MB, 320x214px) Image search: [Google]
unnamed (4).gif
5MB, 320x214px
>>54960451
>triple sleeved, but its all foil, altered art, random Gold Border effect, and most cards have a signature
>>
>>54960542
I killed Mimeoplasm first because he has probably the most answers to the combo in his deck and such. Aurelia was attacking Nissa player fast and early. Even if Aurelia hadnt insurrectioned the entire board I would have killed him anyways on his upkeep. Basically he was at 28 on my turn I drained him to 18, on Aurelias turn I would have drained him to 8 had he not Insurrectioned and then on Nissa players upkeep once the Helix Pinnacle trigger goes on the stack I drain him to 0 and he loses. I flat out told this to his face and you could see the anger in his eyes that he knew he was going to lose despite the Helix Pinnacle in play.
>>
>>54960632
Like a Foil Arbor Elf, with a gold border painted on, a signature and fucking altered art wings painted on with like a staff thing.
>>
>>54960664
You should feel bad for making fun of the mentally handicapped
>>
>>54960632
>Cast stain the mind against him
>Spend 20 minutes looking at his fuck awful deck
>Eventually, pick the shittiest alter
>"Accidentally" drop it in the floor and roll over it with your chair when you try o pick it up
>>
Quick rulings question, if someone were to play jokulhaups and another person had an indestructible creature with a bunch of artifacts equip to it, would the artifacts still be destroyed? Or in general can artifacts be destroyed by board wipes if they are equip to a creature?
>>
>>54960781
Equipment are artifacts so thet are destroyed, the indestructible creature doesnt give things attached to it keywords, I.e you can disenchant equipment on a hexproof creature because its not targeting the creature but the artifact
>>
I want to build Inalla with my win condition being her activated ability. How to build?
>>
File: darksteelshit.png (619KB, 621x445px) Image search: [Google]
darksteelshit.png
619KB, 621x445px
>>54960781
Other guy gave the answer already, but compare the text on these cards.

Woulda pulled a third example of an equipment that gives indestructible without being indestructible itself but there isn't one.
>>
>>54960692
Isnt Bitter Ordeal strictly better because you can get more cards? I guess you dont see their hand, only their library.
>>
>>54961232
I guess sadistic sacrament is the best. I was just making a lame joke.
>>
>>54960781
Where does it say that equipment gains the abilities of the creature its attached to? Just read the rules, it'll solve 90% of your questions.
>>
>>54960947
Ashnod's/Bloodline Necromancer or any other infinite creature producer.
>>
>>54960947
Panharmonicon, Sidisi's Faithful, Sundial. I'm fairly sure you can go infinite with a mana altar but you may need other toys too.
>>
File: images (7).jpg (13KB, 381x386px) Image search: [Google]
images (7).jpg
13KB, 381x386px
>>54961288
Nice redundant post that adds nothing to the thread
Dude asked a valid question, you chose to be a cuntwaffle on your own accord
>>
>>54961346
Asking a question doesn't make it valid. It'd be like asking if Kiki-Jiki gave all your creatures haste. No, read the cards and don't be retarded.
>>
>>54961346
>adds nothing to the thread
Do you know where you are?
>chose to be a cuntwaffle
Yeah, and? It was a retarded question that two seconds of searching could have answered, you bet I'm going to be rude.
>>
>>54960947
>>54961340
b-but what if I don't want to go infinite as a main wincon...
>>
Tips for mono green Nemata saproling swarm??
>>
>>54961540
Then you do it the slow way and build up enough wizards to tap every turn until people are dead. It's made a lot easier if you have a way to copy Inalla's ability.
>>
>>54961560
Doubling Season.
>>
>>54961400
Ignorance can be forgiven, apathy shows intention. Once there is proof of knowledge, you're justified in being a dick, but you don't know until someone tells you.

>>54961440
Don't act like a teenager for no reason. If you don't have something helpful to say, saying nothing is probably the better option.

What decks do you play?
>>
>>54961540
If you don't go infinite, at least go very large. You need a lot of wizards to kill with Inalla's tapping, so unless you're trying some sort of Conspiracy/Xenograft/New One Coming in Ixalan trickery with massed tokens you're going to have to abuse the ETB to make moar wizards.
>>
So what does /edhg/ think of the new commander 2017 decks?

Any day 1 buys?
>>
>>54961593
I play atraxa, narset and derevi stax, I am a far superior player than you could ever dream of pal
>>
>>54961623
Dragons are poop
Vampires are less poop, more of a shart
Wizards could be fun
Cats are probably the best out of the nox but no value
If you can find them for msrp grab them, they are already going for $15-$20 more than msrp on places like amazon
>>
>>54961623
I'll be buying Inalla, Bloodline Necormancer, Path of Ancestry, Galecaster Colossus, and the new art Apprentice Necromancer.
>>
>>54961540
I understand and agree with I dont want to go infinite regularly I definitely think one should have the option always just as your nuclear option to wipe out that one mother fucker and his motherfucking hitler tier deck
>>
>>54961582
>>54961605
I was considering effects that untap my Wizards like Paradox Engine or Dramatic Reversal and chain a bunch of spells to make as much damage as possible then play an extra turn spell and something like Magus of the Will or Past in Flames and do it all over again. But maybe thats Magicchristmasland
>>
>>54961720
>But maybe thats Magicchristmasland
Pretty much, but I still use Dramatic Reversal for the hell of it. My Wizards tend to have extra abilities from Azami/Patron Wizard/Sigil Tracer so draining someone with Inalla, casting Dramatic Reversal, and then having several flexible WIzards ready to go again is a really nice option for just 2 measly mana.
>>
>>54959384
Awesome, thanks
>>
>>54961691
oh for sure. I have an infinite combo in all of my decks to beat THAT deck or for the yugioh moment but as a rule I imposed on myself all of them must involve at least three different cards.
>>
>>54961780
Ashnods, bloodline necro and inalla
thats three
>>
>>54961623
NEW BLOOD
>>
>>54961632
None of those decks are particularly rules-intensive. If you said you ran Grenzo doomsday, breya eggs, or some ungodly storm deck, I would have understood your penchant for rules lawyering, but you just listed two linear three colour decks and the most popular commander on edhrec.

You have aspirations to be someone knowledgeable, but you have the resume of a twit.
>>
>>54961819
not wanting to win like that every time doesn't mean i'm not putting that shit in ;^)
>>
>>54960632
The guy laughing in the back makes this so much better
>>
>>54961720
DR on a stick and Paradox Engine (+ Azami for draws?) would do it, yeah.
>>
>>54961873
Indeed
Just slap that bloodline down and scream yugio style and obliterate them all
>>
File: EliShiffrin.jpg (18KB, 300x300px) Image search: [Google]
EliShiffrin.jpg
18KB, 300x300px
>>54953930
Has he killed the jank?
>>
>be fit
>social
>dressed well clean cut
>casual drop down a hentai playmat
>continue to joke and be friendly the whole time

who else is /throwing people off/
>>
>>54956274
The whole compsition of that monolog was fucking horrible
>>
>>54961623
dragons need about 50 bucks put into a mana base and are fine. wizards are ok, definitely the "best" deck imo. vampires are the deck i would buy for a friend trying to get into magic. cats are shit and need to be broken down for other decks

that being said i buy them all anyway every year
>>
>>54962052
But why? You just have to smile and play confidently, then most people shit their pants. Don't get rattled by removal, don't bitch about luck, just fucking Shrek some fools and pretend like it's all going to plan until you scoop, or win.
>>
>>54962052
>dress like hobo
>4000 super friends deck
>>
File: 1501169118049.png (635KB, 850x500px) Image search: [Google]
1501169118049.png
635KB, 850x500px
>throw Sundial of the Infinite into Inalla Tribal
>throw Patron Wizard in there
>create tons of tokens that stick around
>stop the player whose turn is after mine completely from casting anything ever
Whew, this could be disgusting as fuck in 1v1, even without Sundial and just playing a Wizard every turn on-curve.

Speaking of that: what are some busted ETBs I could toss in for general value with Conspiracy/Xenograft?
>>
>>54962190
Removal spells on dudes is probably your best bet since they're good value even without the extra.

Things like Shiekmaw or Fleshbag Marauder. Duplicant.
>>
Anything come out since Tarkir that would work well with Bolster? I always liked that mechanic and all the new dragon stuff in the new EDH has got me wanting to rebuild bad Dromoka.

Things in GW that remove counters from creatures or have odd P/T. Or benefit heavily from getting more power or toughness ala Wild Beastmaster.

That deck was more fun than you'd think for what essentially amounts to bad Ghave.

Bolstering on phantoms, White Mikaeus, etc.
>>
>>54962032
No, because either you have Quicksilver Elemental on the field and it can activate its own ability as many times as you want, or you have Quicksilver caged and activating it lets you activate it again. Again, Gilded Lotus and Knacksaw Cliquec caged, and Quicksilver Elemental, either caged or on the field, still goes infinite.
>>
File: 1471359883809.jpg (75KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]
1471359883809.jpg
75KB, 1280x720px
>Already got Mishra artifacts
>Want to build Mairsil for jank
>Also want to build a Nicol Bolas "I play your hands/decks and control your creatures" deck

Help me out I don't wanna have 3 Grixis decks, let alone 2
>>
>>54962527
I dunno man, Mishra artifacts is already jank. Mairsil is just being more consistent, which isn't what you want with jank.
>>
>>54953880
Oh yeah I ran this and Reality Twist so many times. Drop in that Eon Hub and screw upkeep.
>>
My combos are too threatening for my playgroup and I was keeping it to a minimun of 3 cards to combo. Whats a fun commander that doesnt have combos that is fun to play? Im currently playing nekusar, mizzix, avacyn and omnath of rage.
>>
>>54962862
Considered a Tron deck? Those are usually pretty combo-less and straightforward.
>>
>>54962862
Old Sigarda Equipment Voltron is quite fun, has plenty of support, and thanks to her having hexproof and un-saccable she's incredibly hard to get rid of. Just slap a Darksteel Plate on and go to town.
>>
>>54962898
My avacyn used to be kalemne tron, I had to change it because I was usually "winning" by turn 3-4
>>
>>54962862
Build GW Selvala Enchantress with Krond enchantments Voltron as a secret commander
>>
>>54962527
>Already running Gwendlyn "Bad Touch".dec
>Mairsil drops, gotta have it
>Also want to do a novelty deck with Inalla, seems like it could be a lot of fun based on tappedout test runs too.

I know your pain.
>>
>>54962898
>>54962919
>Tron
You mean Voltron. Tron is an established modern deck revolving around "urza-tron" lands being set up early to let you shit out something like Karn or Ugin. No, it is not arbitrary. Yes, it is important.
>>
>>54962919
What's your playgroup playing?

Might help with finding something that would be fun in it and not too dumb.
>>
>>54962953
Technically, the deck should be called 'Tron, since it's about assembling Voltron on your board, which is the same thing you are doing with those EDH decks.
>>
>>54962953
They're both references to Voltron you aspie fuck.
>>
>>54962953
It matters, but i understood what he meant eventually. I thought he meant colorless green or robots at first
>>
>>54962970
No your right, that's exactly right. But syntactically when discussing magic, it's important to make the general distinction because they have entirely different meanings.

For example, Uril 'Tron, Sram 'Tron, and UG 'Tron are three different things.


>>54963003
Yes, but in the context of discussion it's confusing. I had no idea he meant winning with a bunch of things on his commander, I was expecting Eldrazi.
>>
>>54962970
Not him, but you call it tron when its referencing lands because its one less syllable a la "shock land", "fetch land" or "check land".

Voltron is a strategy implying actually using voltron to beat face.
>>
>>54962651
Mairsil is more consistently jank. Mishra artifacts only have a small handful of cards where Mishra actually matters, so you're mostly just play Grixis Artifacts. Mairsil lets you board the jank train pretty much immediately each game.
>>
>>54963063
>>54963079
Modern General, please.
Nobody but you guys has problems understanding that Tron still refers to Voltron tactics.
>>
>>54962956
We have a prossh, shu yun, animar, zur, old sigaurda, atraxa and surrack as the main assortment. Theres tasigur, kruphix, damia, several atraxas, a few other mizzix, another nekusar, that ravnica gb chick ,5c superfriends, horde of notions and a few mono black decks as auxiliaries that people play.
>>
>>54960781
to reference this guy>>54961033
If the card doesn't explicitly say it is indestructible it is destroyed by the jokulhaups or any card similar. Good way to get around this is to do a mass exile.
>>
>>54962052
>dress like a girl
>they get thrown off when you reveal your 12" dick in bed
>>
File: Autism as Context Blindness.png (797KB, 769x1000px) Image search: [Google]
Autism as Context Blindness.png
797KB, 769x1000px
>>54963063
>>54963079
>>
>>54963122
Anon, almsot all of those sound like powerhouse spike decks and I see no reason why you playing combo decks in the middle of that mess would be a problem apart from the fact that they don't want to lose any games.
>>
>>54963141
Do you also call pineapple 'apple and expect people to understand you, my friend?
>>
>>54963166
If I'm holding a pineapple I might. Your analogies are worse than your ASD.
>>
>>54963091
Clearly they do. Just use the right words to describe something and everyone is happy. It's like calling a craw wurm a Tim because it's something Timmy would use. It's just catchy enough to cause confusion, which is why it's important to make the decision.

Vernacular is regional and organic through syntax, if it wasn't for people bitching about semantics you'd have people flibbity flopping their flaveh glave and scrumptdiddling their biddles.
>>
File: 1500379448716.jpg (46KB, 375x523px) Image search: [Google]
1500379448716.jpg
46KB, 375x523px
>>54963091
I mean, i have a guy at my table who actually uses a TRON style edh deck using kruphix to bank up a bunch of mana to shit out eldrazi. It uses urza tron as a key mana factory. Calling it a voltron deck would be incorrect.
>>
>>54963178
>I'm a vauge dick and use words wrong on purpose.
I believe the word for you is "charlatan".
>>
>>54963063
>Uril Tron
Enchantments Voltron

>Sram Tron
Artifacts/Enchantments Voltron

>UG Tron
Does Simic even have a Voltron commander? It's either huge mana/card draw or going wide with Newzuri
>>
>>54963178
People would point out that the fruit you're holding is actually a pineapple and not an apple and if you say you just made an abbreviation nobody uses to describe that fruit you will get laughed at
>>
>>54963181
>clearly they do
But nobody complained about confusing semantics, it was just one guy pointing out that "Tron" should read "Voltron" because the modern strategy also uses the short-hand term "Tron" for what it does. Even the guy I mentioned it to immediately understood what was meant.
>>
File: arc1485_art.jpg (121KB, 620x453px) Image search: [Google]
arc1485_art.jpg
121KB, 620x453px
I am building a group fight deck - a deck that forces all the pillowfort, stax, group hug decks to actually do something and fight each other. My playgroup's deck (including my own) are pretty slow, so I just want to shake up things.

Are there any primers/guides on this sort of deck?

I have made a small list of card that could work and gotten to a mono red selection without any beaters of my own yet - http://tappedout.net/mtg-decks/group-fight-prototype/

Am I missing something important? Is something there super bad? Should I add an extra color?
>>
>>54962862
>fun commander
>nekusar
nigga u dumb
>>
File: Image (15).jpg (32KB, 223x310px) Image search: [Google]
Image (15).jpg
32KB, 223x310px
>>54963260
Use this fellow
>>
>>54963220
UG 'Tron is a modern deck.

Sram 'Tron is really zero cost cantrip equipment tribal.

Uril 'Tron is really a naya enchantress deck using auras.

Nothing about the word 'Tron implied any of those meanings, which means it's too ambiguous to be used incorrectly to refer to Voltron.

>>54963241
I am that guy. Just because I eventually understood you doesn't mean it's clear or correct. The only context clue I had was "kalemne tron" which is completely nonsense in the correct context.
>>
>>54963260
...Fumiko.
>>
File: 1500924523746.jpg (177KB, 960x955px) Image search: [Google]
1500924523746.jpg
177KB, 960x955px
>>54962379
Solemnity
>>
>>54963294
Reading comprehension
>>
>>54963260
http://tappedout.net/mtg-decks/02-02-17-mogis-god-of-slaughter/

this is my group slug deck, just be warned your group will probably hate it
>>
>>54963299

I feel like 3 colors is a bit too much with all the RRR enchantments.

>>54963315

Nice, I had never fully read her and only knew about the bushido X part.
>>
>>54963338
nigga i dumb
>>
>>54963157
While my initial thought was on those lines, I feel that its something im doing. I have gotten mindslavered just because quite a few times.
>>
>>54963309
(Vol)tron in general and every single instance still refers to "assembling small pieces of a machine that will multiply in power once fully combined and win you the game from that point on" and is correct for every Tron deck as well as Voltron.

If someone knows what a Tron deck does, they could easily deduct its correlation to a Voltron deck and that they are literally the same thing.
Plenty of people I know even call the modern decks Voltron.
>>
>>54963344
Nah you'll be fine don't worry about it, also green and white have some nice tech to protect yourself while you watch the rest of the table throw shit at each other
>>
>>54963368
Of course they could easily, but the point is they shouldn't have to infer context. This is why Voltron is used in edh and Tron has a specific meaning in the context of modern, then using Tron to refer to an edh deck more specifically refers to the modern context.

I doubt Ghave Voltron means the same thing as a Ghave combo deck, though they both assemble small peices to build something exponentially more powerful.
>>
>>54963368
Nigga just call stuff with their proper name, it's 3 fucking letters more, it doesn't need to be abbreviated.
>>
>>54963241
When there are clearly defined terms, it's not to anyone's benefit to muddy them. In order to save typing 3 letters, you've now had to type all these posts defending your choice. Will it be worth having to have this conversation again next time you skimp out on typing the whole term?
>>
>>54963491
We do not negotiate with terrorists.
>>
>>54963502
We could start calling them just terrors nobody would get confused by that!
>>
>>54963502
Not negotiating with terrorists is negotiating, but in a consistently uncompromising way.

Do you even speak English anon? Please tell me you're like in highschool and barely stumbled through Macbeth.
>>
>>54963329
Least I got one response.
>>
>>54963309
Here's a thought exercise.
I searched the archive real quick:
>Sram Tron
3 posts (All of which are IN THIS THREAD)
>Sram Voltron
36 posts

>Uril Tron
5 posts (3 of which are IN THIS THREAD)
>Uril Voltron
179 posts

>Eldrazi Tron
1351 posts
>RG Tron
736 posts

Before today, not a single person in /tg/'s history had said "Sram Tron" instead of "Sram Voltron". It becomes exceedingly obvious that the usage for Tron as a shortened form of Urzatron eclipses using it as a shortened form of Voltron by literally thousands of posts. You're sacrificing clarity for the sake of defending something used less than 1% of the time.
>>
>>54962379
Atraxa
>>
>>54963611
You forgot Utron and BGTron :^)
>>
>>54963502
>>54963611
>3 posts
>5 posts

So what are the chances this one guy is the only person to have ever used "Tron" to mean "Voltron"?
>>
>>54963611
Anon you and I are in agreement. I was saying it's too vauge to abbreviate and used intentionally misleading contexts.

I had a whole separate argument about how nothing relating to artifacts applied to Uril and there was nothing intrinsic to the word to imply the strategy without using it in the correct context.

You I like.
>>
>>54963655
U Tron brings up too many unrelated things.
BG Tron only has 46 results, it's not as ubiquitous.
>>
>>54963674
>Anon you and I are in agreement.

Yeah, my bad. I meant the "You're sacrificing clarity" thing as more of a general statement, not an accusation.
>>
>>54963658
What are you saying, anon? It's CLEARLY a widespread and commonly used way of saying Voltron and has been used by generations and generations, i can prove to you that it goes back to ancient Korean oral tradition
>>
File: 1405846867015.jpg (22KB, 600x863px) Image search: [Google]
1405846867015.jpg
22KB, 600x863px
>ITT: /lit/ spending more time shitposting about wrong nomenclature than talking about Commander
>>
File: 14000_200w.jpg (26KB, 200x285px) Image search: [Google]
14000_200w.jpg
26KB, 200x285px
>>54953880
>What's the most fucked board you've seen? Did you cause it?
My Arcum Dagsson deck made about a dozen copies of Knowledge Pool with Prototype Portal by means of Unwinding Clock because I out-counterspelled the board and then the game lasted about 7+ hours before everyone scooped and I won be default. I could have won with fat creatures or Nev's disk combos, but I like playing with my food too much.

Lesson of the game? You can't wait out a man who has nothing to look forward to.
>>
>>54963658
He's at least the first person to have said "kalemne tron" in the history of /tg/, compared to 89 instances of Kalemne Voltron.
>>
>>54963743
Stop trying to damage control so desperately
You could've avoided all this if you just didn't respond to the guy that pointed out your error and move on, instead you stubbornly tried to defend your incorrect use of terms and that's a battle lost at the start
>>
>>54963785
I'm not even that anon. The fact that you guys have been rambling on for 20 minutes since his last response is just ridiculous.
>>
Holy shit can you guys stop argueing about voltron decks and fucking pick me a commander to play?
>>
>>54963801
>rambles about rambling
>doesn't bring a commander related argument to put the thread back on track
You're a shitposter like everyone else
>>
>>54963834
Zur.
Build him as Tron :^)
>>
>>54962379
Try Crystalline Crawler
>>
>>54963834
Uril Tron :^)
>>
File: Image (13).png (134KB, 223x311px) Image search: [Google]
Image (13).png
134KB, 223x311px
>>54963834
Here
>>
>>54963857
I never claimed I wouldn't be one.
No point denying being a shitposter. Might as well be true to yourself.
>>
>>54962527
>tfw every deck I want to build has black in it

I need a box full of demonic and vampiric tutors
>>
>>54963834
Karn, make sure to cast him using urza tron tho :^)
>>
>>54963883
Once you go black, anon.

The only way to cure yourself is by riding a big, white deck for a while.
>>
>>54963883
>I need a box full of demonic and vampiric dicks
FTFY
black players are either female or closet fags
>>
>>54963883
>BLACKED

No, seriously, why is black so much fun to play as or splash in? It's almost always worth it. I've never felt bad for adding black to a deck.
>>
>>54963860
This is the first thoughtful response I've gotten and is actually a great suggestion. Thanks!

It is easy to forget to check commander products for new synergies.
>>
>>54963919
Show me where the Cabal Coffers touched you, anon.
>>
>>54963903
Well I'm playing mostly B/W so there is that.
>>54963919
If I suck your dick will you buy me some?
>>
>>54963936
Every black lover i know is a fag, trap or female
>>
>>54963945
Sure but you have to swallow
>>
>>54962190
Won't work, they're exiled at the beginning of the next end step. If you skip your end step they're exiled on your opponents end step.
>>
>>54963945
Go and build either Jareth, Kalemne, Brion or Ruhan Giant Tribal then.

They'll be the biggest white decks you'll find.
>>
>>54961632
The fact that someone typed this out to be impressive is actually embarrassing
>>
>>54963951
I love BW and my foil Sorins.
>>
>>54963991
You've seen nothing, kid
>>
>>54963976
If he ends the turn when their trigger goes on the stack he keeps them
>>
>>54963951
I thought that was Green?
>>
Anyone want to take a glance at this Sek'kuar list? It is sans manabase so far.

http://tappedout.net/mtg-decks/sekkuar-fast/

Do you think the removal and wrath package is solid enough?
>>
>>54964040
Thats where they meet on the color pie
>>
>>54964032
Good to know, I always thought it would check again.
>>
>>54963976
>If you skip your end step they're exiled on your opponents end step.
You're correct about this, but you're missing the point. You don't use Sundial to skip your end step, you wait until the delayed trigger is put onto the stack, and then end the turn. The triggered ability will be exiled, but since it did fire off, it won't trigger again.
>>
>White
Extremely average people, just want simple games of Commander, no regard for Power level
>Blue
Stereotypical """"Intelligent"""" Fedoramasters who think they have an IQ rivaling Einsteins because they can counter spells and cantrip
>Black
Edgelords and gays
>Red
Slightly autistic, wants to do wacky things, dislikes arrogant players
>Green
Dudebros, females, occasional hypercompetitive turboautists
>>
>>54963930
Black adds a ton of consistency and good creature removal to any deck. You get card draw, tutors, reanimation, and kill spells along with some choice combo pieces.
>>
>>54964108
And the color pairs?
>>
>>54963931
Aye, I threw it into G/W tokens a while ago. You might be able to abuse it with Dragonscale General and the like
>>
>>54964093
If you skipped the endstep before the trigger it would but the card doesnt need to see if the trigger is successful, only that it went to the stack.
>>
>>54961560
Life and Limb
Sporemound
Make sure you have a way to sac or bounce Sporemound, unless you want a draw.
>>
>>54963951
Can confirm, fucked a trap after the game, they played Shirei
>>
>>54964150
Good shit, man. I'll be fucking around with a list for the big dragon again.

The spiciest thing I ever managed with it was Gigapede or Gemini Engine.
>>
>>54964145
>White / Red
Armchair general who would rather be playing Stratego. Styles themself as the next Caesar, but is much more similar to Varus.
>>
>got slapped with a bad case of life
>ended up having to buy a new car
>I gotta liquidate one of my commander decks to make ends meet until my fulltime pay kicks in two weeks from now
Shit sucks. I refuse to take apart my Sliver deck or Eldrazi deck though.

Goodbye Sheoldred.
>>
Putting together my Inalla deck right now to start picking up cards the moment my paycheck comes in at the end of the month.
Anything I'm necessarily missing here that should absolutely be included and isn't in the price range as Snappy is, since I'm on a bit of a budget?

Also, ignore lands so far, didn't bother with those yet.
http://tappedout.net/mtg-decks/inalla-wizard-tribal-2/
>>
File: 1472709608698.jpg (138KB, 568x566px) Image search: [Google]
1472709608698.jpg
138KB, 568x566px
>>54964418
>keeps slivers and eldrazi over all else
Embarrassing
>>
>>54964503
>letting go of the definitive tribal deck
>after they just released some of the best tribal support cards for commander
>letting go of my pride and joy colorless commander deck
>>
>>54964567
>>colorless commander deck
I really hope we eventually get a 5 color Emrakul.
>>
>>54964464
Sigil tracer? Would glen elendra archmage be within your budget?
>>
>>54964567
>brainlet tribal deck
Fixed that for you
>>
>>54964643
>>54964643
>>54964643
New thread
>>
I'm looking for some help with my Sunforger Soldier deck: http://tappedout.net/mtg-decks/jor-kadeen-soldier-tribal-current/
More specifically, I'm looking for ways to protect Sunforger from removal, especially exile effects. I'm currently thinking Rebuff the Wicked would be a good solution, but I'd like some other suggestions.
>>
>>54964602
Sigil Tracer does sound good, might try fitting it in.
Glen Elendra would be alright, might put her in in place of Kess, Merchant of Secrets, Mercurial Chemister or Sage's Dousing.
>>
>>54955494
>Increasing the powerlevel of the format fixes the format
You would also need to ban aburduals in order to get the effect you desire
>>
>>54964671
Leonin Abunas
Relic Ward
Hanna's Custody
Indomitable Archangel
Spectral Guardian
Fountain Watch
Darksteel Citadel
Can't think of any other things, and half of these are probably too specific in use, but they're something.

Other more generic things include
Mana Tithe
Rebuff the Wicked
Lapse of Certainty
Mage's Contest
Reroute
Shunt
>>
>>54953880
>blackholes make me uncomfortable on a primal level
>even just seeing one on a fucking magic card makes me squirm
>feel like I'm gonna get sucked into it
There's a reason I cannot handle playing games like Elite Dangerous
>>
>>54964839
>Leonin Abunas
>Fountain Watch
These seem really solid, thanks man.
>Darksteel Citadel
You mean Darksteel Forge. It's alright though, there's a guy in my group who always mixes them up.
>>
>>54959857

My wife plays edh with me. Just be more dominant and make her play it.
>>
>>54957693

Any form of indirect control like leovold or stax
>>
>>54961623

Getting them all, keeping cats, gut the wizards, w/e the vamps, keeping Tigam and lands and burning the dragons.
Thread posts: 366
Thread images: 49


[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / bant / biz / c / can / cgl / ck / cm / co / cock / d / diy / e / fa / fap / fit / fitlit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mlpol / mo / mtv / mu / n / news / o / out / outsoc / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / spa / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vint / vip / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Search | Top | Home]

I'm aware that Imgur.com will stop allowing adult images since 15th of May. I'm taking actions to backup as much data as possible.
Read more on this topic here - https://archived.moe/talk/thread/1694/


If you need a post removed click on it's [Report] button and follow the instruction.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com.
If you like this website please support us by donating with Bitcoins at 16mKtbZiwW52BLkibtCr8jUg2KVUMTxVQ5
All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties.
Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from that site.
This means that RandomArchive shows their content, archived.
If you need information for a Poster - contact them.