Would Neverwinter on Xbox One be a good alternative if you don't

It's nothing like a pen and paper RPG, at all. No game can ever really match pen and paper on a tabletop, but Neverwinter isn't even close by video game standards.

>>54127439
Unless you'er just itching to RP, including improvisational sort of sort of stuff with people within the game, not really. It's an MMO first and foremost, it just happens to have a D&D license and be set in the Forgotten Realms.

I understand it has some sort of player mission designer, so you could probably write up some smaller adventures for yourself and others and RP within that framework, but that'd require more time than just playing a game through Roll20 so that's a nonstarter.

>>54127678
Well, that just raises an intriguing question.

Which game, if any, even gets close to it?

>>54127439
Just buy a pc and elder scrolls: oblivion or morrowind

>>54127439
Depends on what you want from the game. I've played Neverwinter and was less than impressed. There is extremely little room for customising your character, multiclassing does not exist, iirc you can't even choose feats. There are a kind of enhancement trees where you can pick special attacks, but it mostly boils down to red damage or green damage.
You're locked into one combat style depending on your class. Want to pick up a shortbow as a rogue? Forget it. The spell lists for casters have been cut down to nearly nothing.
The environment scales with your level, so even though you technically get stronger, you can't go back to a previous quest and smell the flowers if you like. If you have trouble with something at one point, you'll have trouble with it forever. Combat basically consists of "time your dodge, attack, repeat until monster is dead".

That's not to say it's all horrible, though. If you're looking for an MMO that requires only minimal intelligence on part of the player it'll serve you well enough. If you want something closer to a D&D experience I'd look elsewhere.

Personally I like Dungeons&Dragons Online. It's a far older game originally set in Eberron but with FR content as well from when WotC really wanted to push that setting, dating back to 2006, and while it has its flaws and has in some ways moved away from its origins as a multiplayer D&D game for the PC, it is still FAR closer to D&D than Neverwinter is.
Of course you won't be able to play it on the Xbox, so if that's your only option for gaming... sorry?