Haven't had one of these threads in a while. Let's build a Commander deck, /tg/.
Please.
>>52859884
Riding the Dilu Horse
Imperial Seal
>>52859985
Good job, Anon.
>>52859902
Mah nigga.
Also blowfly infestation
Incremental Growth
Incremental Blight
>>52859884
>>52860073
>>52859884
pernicious deed
Soul Snuffers
>>52859884
I pulled a shiny one of those
:)
>>52860229
>shiny
what kind of mongoloid
>>52860260
Leave the newfag alone. "He will learn patience."
>>52860260
FOIL happy! Gosh I just like shiney better because it's funny to me! But yea. It's a rad card!
>>52860311
I got a foil promo one in my box. Every game I won was because of her.
>>52860434
+ phyrexian altar
>>52859884
This guy.
>>52859884
Black Sun's Zenith
>>52859884
>>52859916
>>52860016
>>52860073
>>52860076
I'm actually really liking this so far. If I don't buy Amonkhet stuff, I may still have to pick up Princess Snek.
Here's our win-con
>>52860073
fuck. I fucking hated those things when when i ran a Doran deck.
>>52864064
Hey Mack!
Sweepers are needed.
Random artifact hate for fun.
>>52863503
>>52867466
Fuck.
Then I'll put my favourite thing in this game. Proliferating.
Deadbridge Chant
>>52867605
Nobody plays White in Commander.
>>52869511
>nobody plays white in commander
>>52859884
Secret tech coming through.
>>52863926
lets run a backup too
we are going to have a lot of sneks right?
Utility goodies.
We're probably going to be killing a lot of creatures...
>>52860448
Only a regular one here, but she got so much hate. I think the best value I got out of her was killing a 2 drop, getting 2 snakes, eating an electrify, then bringing her back to hand and playing again for more snakes. She was a massive removal bait which let my glorybringer and crossing croc go by without dying.
Also seeing as we're throwing out -1/-1s like candy
Nest of Scarabs for more tokens
Melira, Sylvok outcast so all the "put -1/-1 counter on all creatures" doesn't wipe our board of tokens.
Maybe throne of the god pharaoh as well? if we're getting a lot of tokens, attack with them all, drain the life of the entire table.
This doesn't exactly combo with your sneks, but...
needs more ramp
sneks with sords
So is it just kind of and color identity legal card gets in, or what?
>>52870232
Oloro doesn't count since most people don't even cast him when they play him.
>>52869511
>whenever a retard voices his wrong opinion, he gets a (You) counter.
>>52871724
I like the way you think, anon.
Needs more mana rocks and/or counter synergy.
Time to ruin everything
We've got so many creatures from the tokens, do we embrace the meme of cryptolith rite?
Also strength in numbers so one snake becomes huge.
Since a lot of creature are gonna be dying
>>52874460
are you implying oloro decks are just dimir?
because you would be wrong
lets take a look at the top 10 most common commanders shall we?
>Atraxa, Praetors' Voice
>Breya, Etherium Shaper
Meren of Clan Nel Toth
>Oloro, Ageless Ascetic
Nekusar, the Mindrazer
Yidris, Maelstrom Wielder
Prossh, Skyraider of Kher
>Alesha, Who Smiles at Death
>Kaalia of the Vast
Omnath, Locus of Rage
literally half of the most common edh decks (as per edhrec which scans tapped out and other sites) play white.
white has some powerful cards in it
>swords
>path
>wrath
>RIP
>sun titan
>Stoneforge mystic
>thalia
>aura of silence
>Armageddon
and thats just mono white
>>52870621
this and blade of selves
>>52874645
as of this card I see 40 non land cards
we have a bit of ramp so its not like we would need 40 lands we are getting pretty close
>>52874257
The challenge is getting the thread to work together on a common theme. Not doing too bad, so far.
>>52871390
>not going big
>not going home
>>52874921
you are right
fuck it
may as well throw some tutors into the deck as well
hey you know whats good with tokens?
convoke
>>52871390
sneks?
>>52874703
I'm implying that Oloro decks are UBw, not ubW. Their strength is on their blue or black cards and not their white cards, and therefore they're not affected enough by Gloom for it to be worth running. Especially Oloro decks, which are barely affected by being unable to cast their commander.
>>52875110
I'll take that as you agreeing with me
>>52874645
Zulaport cutthroat as well?
>>52859916
Doubling season too, right?
No mention of this bomb?
>>52874640
Rookie question here, but does putting +1/+1 counters on a creature remove -1/-1 counters? I'm guessing no.
I was reigning myself in from thinking it was possible to get say, an infinite persist somehow.
>>52877131
They actually cancel each other now (since mirrodin2 iirc)
secret tech
>>52877169
so putting a +1/+1 on something that Persists, will let it persist again then?
Huh. Neat.
>>52877417
>121.3. If a permanent has both a +1/+1 counter and a -1/-1 counter on it, N +1/+1 and N -1/-1 counters are removed from it as a state-based action, where N is the smaller of the number of +1/+1 and -1/-1 counters on it. See rule 704.
>>52875110
>Oloro doesn't play white much
hownew.png
>twenty wraths
>humility
>return to dust
>hundreds of lifegain creatures and other "lifegain matters" effects
>sun titan
>>52878063
not without this one faggot
cant just jam shit that looks good in
>>52877727
You know what the most popular "lifegain matters" card in Oloro is? Sanguine Bond. The next 4 most popular ones are either Black of Artifacts.
You know what the most popular wrath card in Oloro is? Cyclonic Rift
For gods sake, more Oloro decks play Propaganda than Ghostly Prison!
White is the 3rd most important in this 3-colour deck.
>>52878063
Protean Hulk is banned, unfortunately.
>>52877494
Kind of curious that they don't mention any other type of stat-altering counter. There's a lot of things like "+1/+0 counters" in the old cards before they stopped having fun.
>>52878249
not anymore
>>52878249
Oh baby you are in for a fun time.
>>52859884
>>52879334
>>52879561
Oh my god did they really unban it?!
>>52880209
Unbanned from the mtgcommander.net team.
Technically, they're not WotC, though. So it goes back to "which banlist are you using" now.
Are we still doing this?
>>52882643
Wotc doesnt have a banlist unless you count the lolMTGOlol list which is just the RC list + bugs and about 2 months behind
bump?
>>52877131
In a nutshell yes, as a state based action if both type of counters exist they will cancel each other out.
However there's some interactions if a creature with a +1/+1 counter gets enough -1/-1 counters put on it to put its toughness to 0 it would result in the creature dying with both +1/+1 counters and -1/-1 counters on it before the state based check for removing the counters happen.
A notable example is if a Hangarback Walker with three +1/+1 counters on it gets three -1/-1 counters put on it by a Skinrender. This results in the Hangarback Walker dying with both three +1/+1 counters and three -1/-1 counters on it. Last know state checked that there were three +1/+1 counters on it before it died and puts three thopter tokens into play.
keep going you fucks
>>52886368
Magic is weird, yo.
More spot removal, I think. Plus full art.
Sekrit tek for snek
>>52893359
As long as we're proliferating and wanting creatures to die.
>>52893485
And to round out green/black proliferate cards.
>>52877242
>>52877314
Infect and Wither don't put -1/-1 counters on creatures, they deal damage IN THE FORM OF -1/-1 counters
>>52894165
Which puts the -1/-1 counters on as a result. Or do you think that they don't get put on?
>>52871905
With a token doubler it does
>>52894165
/tg/ is bad at magic is not a meme.
>>52894691
Yes it is because, /tg/ is, in fact, bad at magic. Meme doesn't just mean something is a joke.
I pulled force of will masterpiece at a pre release... its on ebay for £180... what do you think? Underpriced?
Oh hey, are you playing reanimator/artifacts/anything? It would be a shame if I just fucking stole everything.
>>52895003
I think you're in the wrong place but i'll reply anyway.
Force of Will isn't going anywhere. That means you have two solid options.
1) Sell now while demand for FoW Invocation Is high and the supply is relatively low.
2) Sell long after Amonkhet has rotated and the demand for the masterpiece isn't as high as it is now but the supply is 0.
That might be a long wait but will get you more money in the long run. That said you might not need the cash in five years, you might have lost the card or you might be dead. We're talking an extra £100 at the most here.
Whatever you decide do it quick because the price is only going to go down and down as the initial demand wavers off and the supply goes up.
>>52894633
It also directly converts snakes to scarabs with scarab nest, and if you have the clan exile lady stopping -1 counters on your dudes its fine.
http://tappedout.net/mtg-decks/4chan-sucks-at-magicdek/
here it is
already have too many cards, not enough ramp and not enough lands
still better than half of the lists on /edhg/ though
>>52897403
dat curve doe!
>>52897403
Well, obviously it needs lands, ramp, and mana rocks/dorks. But I think it's a good skeleton.
>>52894165
JUDGE!!
>>52897536
>ramp, and mana rocks/dorks
thats not how it works
>>52897551
Yeah, what the fuck do you want?