[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / bant / biz / c / can / cgl / ck / cm / co / cock / d / diy / e / fa / fap / fit / fitlit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mlpol / mo / mtv / mu / n / news / o / out / outsoc / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / spa / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vint / vip / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Search | Free Show | Home]

EDH/COMMANDER GENERAL

This is a blue board which means that it's for everybody (Safe For Work content only). If you see any adult content, please report it.

Thread replies: 335
Thread images: 85

File: 42.jpg (73KB, 312x445px) Image search: [Google]
42.jpg
73KB, 312x445px
Under represented tribes edition.

>Old thread: >>51214224

RESOURCES

>Official Site: Contains deck building rules and the current ban list.
http://www.mtgcommander.net

>Deck List Site: You can search for decks that other people have made. Authors often have comments that explain their deck’s strategy and card choices.
http://www.tappedout.net

>Another resource for commander discussion; they have an entire forum dedicated to discussing decks. People often make primers, which go into detail about how they built and play their deck.
http://www.mtgsalvation.com/forums/the-game/commander-edh

>Statistically see what everyone else puts in their commander decks based on what is posted to the internet.
http://www.edhrec.com/

>Find out what lands you can add to your deck, sorted by category, based on a chosen Commander’s color identity.
http://manabasecrafter.com/

>CARD SEARCHING

>Official search site. Current for all sets.
http://gatherer.wizards.com/

>Unofficial, but has GOAT search interface.
http://www.magiccards.info

>Question:
What color do you most like to play against and why?
>>
File: Gribbly.jpg (81KB, 520x640px) Image search: [Google]
Gribbly.jpg
81KB, 520x640px
>What colour?

I've always been a huge fan of black, must be my inner edgelord.

I'm working on a Sultai (ft. Eldrazi) deck, I've only played it once and Spawnsire of Ulamog went off like a charm. Tips and advice would be much appreciated

http://tappedout.net/mtg-decks/sultai-mill-drazi-1/
>>
File: myEDHGroup.jpg (1MB, 1500x1941px) Image search: [Google]
myEDHGroup.jpg
1MB, 1500x1941px
post Metas!
>>
>>51235899
Also Suggestions for a new deck?
Posibly thinking of Rashmi or Intet.
>>
File: us.png (899KB, 1500x1521px) Image search: [Google]
us.png
899KB, 1500x1521px
>>51235899
I'm looking for the spiciest copy/steal shit or monoblack tech
>>
When is the banlist being updated, sometime this week?
>>
>>51235694
I'm getting a Hatred for my orzhov deck. I want to know your opinions on the card and maybe some scenarios in which you have played it.
>>
File: Image.jpg (28KB, 223x310px) Image search: [Google]
Image.jpg
28KB, 223x310px
>>51236368
Forgot pic
>>
File: unnamed (12).jpg (104KB, 640x388px) Image search: [Google]
unnamed (12).jpg
104KB, 640x388px
I'm probably just ignorant but what are the numbered spaces on the top of this playmat representing? other players life totals? that seems cumbersome. increased casting cost of commander? why not just put a dice on there.

New EDH player and is curious. love the breya art but this seems like the only playmat I can find.
>>
>>51236465
How many times your commander has been in the c-zone?
>>
>>51236465
dunno, seems retarded though
don't buy playmats like an autistic manchild
>>
Just ordered Karn. Anybody got some spicy tech for him? I'm going more of a stax route
>>
File: thought-dissector-cropped.jpg (153KB, 464x664px) Image search: [Google]
thought-dissector-cropped.jpg
153KB, 464x664px
>>51236605
Might be fun in karn.
>>
>>51236368
It's good even just as tech.
>>
>>51236706
That seems fun. Being able to screw with opponents top deck manipulation has its benefits
>>
File: 1482721719292.png (127KB, 1500x2394px) Image search: [Google]
1482721719292.png
127KB, 1500x2394px
template for those wanting it.
>>
What are some cards that have drawbacks of usually being better for my opponent(s) than for you? Stuff like Hunted Wumpus and whatnot?
Trying to make highly flavorful (and noncompetitive) Five Color Badstuff featuring Korona for fun, not sure what to add to it beyond Wumpus, Boldwyr Heavyweights, Tempting Wurm, and the various red control-changing-unless-X cards.
>>
File: +847+8.png (2MB, 1552x1936px) Image search: [Google]
+847+8.png
2MB, 1552x1936px
how did I do?
>>
>>51237218
Shizuko gives everyone 3 green mana during their turns, you also have Iwamori who's a 5/5 monk for 4 and when he etb every opponent can cast a legendary creature for free.
There was also a counterspell in the onslaught block where the countered player was able to cast something else from his hand for free, don't remember the name.
>>
>>51237329
fold into aether??
>>
/tg i want to build a fun but still somewhat viable budget deck, what should i play? I like white but i hate blue, to this date i do not own a single blue edh deck. Im a pretty big johnny too.
>>
File: EDH playgroup.png (2MB, 1500x2394px) Image search: [Google]
EDH playgroup.png
2MB, 1500x2394px
>>51235899
decided to update it really quick
>>
>>51237354
That's the one I was thinking about, don't know why I thought it was from onslaught
>>
>>51237329
Any ideas for white or black? Or other ideas for blue?
>>
File: edh meta.png (2MB, 1500x2394px) Image search: [Google]
edh meta.png
2MB, 1500x2394px
>>51235899
>>
>>51237354
There's also Spellshift. And the various Polymorph effects.
>>
File: My_EDH_Group.png (2MB, 1496x2392px) Image search: [Google]
My_EDH_Group.png
2MB, 1496x2392px
>>
What are some good general tribal cards in any color/colors that DON'T provide a power/toughness boost? (so no coat of arms, etc)
I already have mana echoes.
>>
File: Image.jpg (35KB, 223x310px) Image search: [Google]
Image.jpg
35KB, 223x310px
>play flip lilliana for ages
>enjoy it, but it's average for a mono-b deck
>realize how well pic related works when I have him out
>swap lili for him
holy shit I have never know value like this.
Anyone have an experience where after only one game they are instantly hooked on a commander?
>>
>>51237873
I'm a big fan of Cover of Darkness, which will give your whole team unblockable if played against the right deck.
>>
>>51237990
it's strange that endrek sahr is so popular. i always thought he wasn't worth the mana. 5 mana 2/2 creature that requires additional investment to get value out of. meh
>>
>>51238035

He more or less exists for a lot of access to sac effects at little cost. There are few better sources of 'A dude to be sacced'
>>
>>51237990
Yeah, Karametra
>>
>>51238035
ashnod's altar
>>
>>51238035
Yes, but the additional investment you speak of is something you would normally be doing anyway. Having him on the field rewards you for it. Compare him to something like Melek, or Karametra. The cost and stats dont really matter considering what you are using them for.
>>
>>51238060
>>51238107
it's just not usually worth it to sac shit for fun in monoblack. ashnod's altar is pretty crazy with endrek, yes, but other than that the synergies are pretty weak.

thats just my imo tho
>>
File: Thalia, Guardian of Thraben_DKA.jpg (52KB, 312x445px) Image search: [Google]
Thalia, Guardian of Thraben_DKA.jpg
52KB, 312x445px
>>51237391
I run her. Nice way to say fuck you to combo, etc. I run other creatures and permanents with tax effects. Also, i use soldier lords and token spam as a way to finish the game. Lastly, i use creatures with ability to resurrect creatures.
>>
>>51237354
wow, that mana cost, what a useless card
>>
>>51238525
The card is obviously meant to counter your own spell, say an Ornithopter or a Gitaxian Probe (RIP) to put a huge bomb like Griselbrand, Emrakul or Elesh Norn into play
>>
>>51238579
its awful even if you use it like that

the green equivalent of doing that is like 4 mana and doesnt cost you an extra card
>>
>>51238598
Please, show me this green 4 mana equivalent you speak of.
>>
How should I build mono blue creatures
>>
File: J3od7.jpg (54KB, 375x523px) Image search: [Google]
J3od7.jpg
54KB, 375x523px
playing Jhoira with lots of MLD and board wipes. And then I remembered a majority of my play group plays superfriends and aren't affected by my board wipes. Any good cards to deal with planes walkers?
>>
>>51237873
if you're not playing green for general shamanic revelation type effects, there's always pauper allstar Distant Melody
>>
>>51238669
For a general, I would go with Either blue braids or patron of the moon.
>>
>>51238707
pyrohemia, perilous vault, all is dust, scour from existence
>>
I wanna build Xenagos. What are the must-have cards for him, as well as secret tech?
>>
>>51238769
EDHREC
>>
>>51238634
Elvish Piper, dragon arch.
>>
>>51238740
I'm wondering if I should have just as many instants and sorceries as creatures or if I should have more rocks, the only blue legendary I have is tromokratis
>>
Would playing phenax for like a dredge effect be too late in the game
>>
so, is there anyone at your playgroup playing Saskia the Unyielding? Is it strong?
I really want to build a Saskia deck but idk if it can be a good general
>>
>>51238847
Yeah, she's pretty strong, in the right game playing her can be the equivalent of just wiping one player off the table
>>
File: 1481053466498-tg.png (490KB, 600x691px) Image search: [Google]
1481053466498-tg.png
490KB, 600x691px
>>51238847
We have one. It's okay I guess? It always targets the control or pillowfort with its ability and then targets some poor, undefended sap. Normally gets bullied hard because no one wants to be target by her. I think I've seen it win once, but that's it.
>>
>>51238736
That's a good one, I should add that
>>
>>51235694
>not one fucking legendary Kavu

Now, do I actually ask for one and get monkey paw'd the fuck out like Ayli, Ludevic, and Ulrich, or go without forever is the real question.
>>
>>51239190
I can think of at least one legendary kavu
>>
>>51238035
>5 mana
>an issue in mono-black
>>
File: purphoros.jpg (151KB, 550x300px) Image search: [Google]
purphoros.jpg
151KB, 550x300px
Any spicy tech for this bad boy?
>>
>>51236489
>Not owning a playmat for each of your favorite decks

Boi...
>>
>>51239190
what's wrong with Ayli? She's a neat commander
>>
>>51238811
If you do Tromokratis, you're only running a ton of creatures if you're going full tribal. He otherwise is better suited for control/Stax/Voltron shenanigans.

I need to document my current build sometime, see what shit I could run but don't, so I get BTFO less.
>>
>>51236489
>don't buy playmats
Are you serious? Playmates are amazingly useful. They make it easier to pick up or move around your cards, plus they protect against dirty or rough playing surfaces.
>>
>>51239347
firecat blitz
>>
File: kill switch.jpg (30KB, 312x445px) Image search: [Google]
kill switch.jpg
30KB, 312x445px
>>51236605
Unwinding Clock
Mycosynth Lattice
Kill switch

You untap on everybody else's turn, throw the kill switch at the end of every turn but the player who goes before you.

You will be the only player on the board who can untap
>>
>>51239206
Yes, I know, but mono-blue Kavu is the worst idea imaginable. Why didn't we get a five-color with changeling?

>>51239352
She's definitely the best of the cards I named, and I own one with an intention to build Cleric tribal, but she's also so outclassed by other BW options, few of them actual Clerics , that it's a bit of a shame.
>>
>>51238790
That only shows the most used shit, NOT the best and of course it doesn't show secret tech. If you don't want to help, just don't reply.
>>
>>51239368
I do have four or five krakens, whelming wave, and some equipment interactions with smaller creatures until the bigger ones come out. I should just counter things that try to counter me?
>>
>bored with my other hobbies
>feel like brewing a deck for no other reason that i have nothing else that i feel like doing
>don't even care about playing edh itself, just want to brew and own more decks

ehhh

throw some ideas at me pls
>>
Banlist updated: No changes
>>
File: Reaper King_SHM.jpg (71KB, 312x445px) Image search: [Google]
Reaper King_SHM.jpg
71KB, 312x445px
>>51239428
Because we have a 5 colour changeling legend already
>>
>>51235776
To all the master decksmiths in here procrastinating, could you take a look?
>>
Sigarda, Heron's Grace human tribal

is this a good idea? is it spicy? i want to build a tribal that isn't just "smash some mouths lmao"

maybe i should build reaper king
>>
>>51238805
Dragon arch is a 5 drop artifact, not 4 green. Different anon by the way.
>>51239428
At least ayli is playable. Ulrich kind of is but not that much. Ludevic not that much.
>>
Need some spicy red generic tribal cards for a MURDER KING zombie deck I wanna try. I already have Mana Echos and Shared Animosity, plus some board wide haste effects and Purfuros like stuff. What else you got?
>>
>>51239601
Space theme.
>>
>>51236368
I run it in Saskia to get surprise kills when people won't block a token. Usually kills two people as a result.
>>
>>51239838
I recall doing UW Daxos human tribal and it was awful. It was almost pure mono white.
I feel like humans are good only in non-singleton formats, not sure what green humans are playable aside from Kamahl.
>>
>>51239869
shambling remains
>>
File: gay.jpg (20KB, 500x281px) Image search: [Google]
gay.jpg
20KB, 500x281px
>Post em :^)
>Spicy tech :^)
>$20 Budget with shipping :^)
>I only play online :^)
>>
>>51240166
well it's not really necessary to use green for much else than goodstuff and anthemy effects

any other tribal ideas? is reaper king fun and even remotely viable?
>>
>>51240228

Many Magic the Gathering players wonder why you're such a faggot?
>>
>>51239347
I've been testing that a little. I like Siege-Gang Commander. Great drop all-around.

Also, I run Ensnaring Bridge and Glacial Crevasses to stall out at the end.
>>
File: 1484146177147.png (82KB, 388x402px) Image search: [Google]
1484146177147.png
82KB, 388x402px
>>51240228
Post your great conversation starter, friend :^)
>>
>>51240263
He is and I feel like it's the best 5 colour commander out there, unless you're doing goodstuff.
I'm doing at the moment Zombies&Wizards tribal deck with GG, but so far I think that my favorite has been Cleric tribal with Ayli. I feel bad for not finishing my Tariel Angels&Demons tribal eons ago, since I completely lost interest in it.
Anyway, the most common tribes in EDH are angels, wizards, zombies and dragons at least from what I've seen.
If you insist on 5-colour, I'd say either elementals (with Horde) or changelings&scarecrows.
There exist really good tribes, but not everything gets support. I could recommend Soldiers or Warriors, since most of them are human anyway, if you want Sigarda.
>>
>>51240441

Have you tried just talking about EDH?
>>
>>51240511
i don't care about what tribe i'm building, i just don't want it to be completely weak and mindnumbingly boring. i didn't like my attempted zombie tribal because it was so slow and shitty, all it could do was smash someone for like 30 damage in a magical christmaslnad scenario
>>
>>51240228
It's always been $20 before shipping, not with shipping. Faggot.
>>
File: 1481055840257-v.jpg (33KB, 602x602px) Image search: [Google]
1481055840257-v.jpg
33KB, 602x602px
>>51239447
>Give me the must use cards.
>EDHREC only gives the most used cards.
>>
>>51239869
Goblin sharpshooter + basilisk collar to machine gun the board. Tymaret works well with a pingers approach.
>>
>>51240622

Not all of us are fucking autismbux having manbabies who can afford $20 plus shipping you fucking NEET. I have a family and a mortgage and I get $20 a month for MtG THAT INCLUDES SHIPPING fucking shitfaggot.
>>
People with 5+ decks how do you bring them to where you play?

My group usually plays at eachothers houses and we have varying powerlevels so I usually like to bring all 5 of my decks with me but throwing the boxes in a book bag isn't great.
>>
>>51240730
>use the advanced filter to include some of the most expensive lands
>see the other power cards that people fit in with those decks
>>
>>51240824
i have a custom made wooden deckbox for carrying them around
>>
>>51240815
>$20 a month
Anon, I have a garbage minimum wage job and I rent a very expensive house, I'm sure you can afford more if you want to spend more.

>>51240824
Fatpacks. 3 decks fit in one fat pack, and I have a spare fancy case for my expensive deck. I usually just throw two fat packs into my backpack, maybe with some elastics if I'm going on a big journey. I brought 3 decks to new york on a plane, and it wasn't a big deal at all.
>>
>>51240824

I have a messenger bag that I just keep my Magic stuff in. It holds my six decks in those Satin Tower things, a playmat and a couple binders. I just toss it in the car and ez pz.
>>
File: custom.png (572KB, 442x589px) Image search: [Google]
custom.png
572KB, 442x589px
>ywn have a custom art commander this sick
>>
>>51240824
I found a toolbox that fits decks perfectly.

It holds all 7 of mine now with room for one more. If I bought a second one and swapped out the big tubs I could fit twelve but I like having the room for tokens and dice.

https://www.amazon.com/dp/B001G1CUK0/ref=twister_B01M3PL0CR?_encoding=UTF8&psc=1
>>
File: oh god, the horror.jpg (158KB, 375x500px) Image search: [Google]
oh god, the horror.jpg
158KB, 375x500px
>>51240887
No, I wont. That's fucking amazing.

But, I'll also never have an alter this bad.
>>
>>51240887

I have an erection. I have a couple alters, but nothing that dank.
>>
>>51240887
>filename isn't MonoRedComrade

You fucked up.
>>
>>51240905
God, your eye doesnt even know where to focus in all that mess.
>>
>>51240892
Do you have a picture with your decks fitting in?
>>
File: just kill me now.png (607KB, 417x561px) Image search: [Google]
just kill me now.png
607KB, 417x561px
>>51240935
I have one more from my horror folder. I just love illegible textboxes.
>>
File: Decks Box One.jpg (127KB, 480x644px) Image search: [Google]
Decks Box One.jpg
127KB, 480x644px
>>51240958
Yeah sure.

It's glarey as fuck though.
>>
>>51240977

Not a big fan of that desu, it's so bulky.
>>
>>51241020
Compared to the three fatpacks in a backpack I used to use I find this much more convenient.
>>
>>51240887
HOLY CRAP Give me twenty of those that's baller as fuck
>>
File: My Playgroup.png (3MB, 1500x3247px) Image search: [Google]
My Playgroup.png
3MB, 1500x3247px
>>51235899
Is fun enough, though I do get tired of U shenanigans rather fast.
>>
File: 1471554379797.jpg (36KB, 364x720px) Image search: [Google]
1471554379797.jpg
36KB, 364x720px
>>51240887
>>
>>51240887
I know this feel for my own favorite alter of my favorite commander.
Though I'd want it to keep the new watermark and not alter the text size and spacing. That was probably an oversight or a limit in whatever software whoever made this render used.
>>
I built this deck originally because I wanted to do something with King Macar, and it kinda snowballed from there. Thoughts, critiques, suggestions? I know mill is sub optimal, but I'm finding it kinda works well as a creature deck the longer the game goes.

http://tappedout.net/mtg-decks/its-a-mad-mad-mad-mad-deck/
>>
File: 1484166183761.jpg (357KB, 1211x900px) Image search: [Google]
1484166183761.jpg
357KB, 1211x900px
Give me a challenge anons, a deck building challenge. I'm willing to spend like 5 hours today building exactly one deck for a lucky person.

RULES:
>No tedious bullshit.
I don't want to spend the whole time searching through the gatherer for particular art or extremely obscure cards.

>Don't expect me to make a sub $50 Tazri Foodchain.
Self explanatory. Budget decks are my forte, but it needs to be realistic.

>Pick an interesting commander or an interesting strategy.
I'm pretty open minded, so it doesn't need to be revolutionary, I just don't really want to make a carbon copy derevi prison lockdown or narset infinite turns.

Otherwise? Basically anything goes. Feel free to give me suggestions.
>>
>>51241457
>I'm willing to spend like 5 hours today building exactly one deck for a lucky person as long as they follow my rules and tell me to build what I want to build

4chan has tons of porn boards if you want to jack yourself off. Why don't you fuck off to one of those?
>>
>>51241538
Already did that today. I just wanted to be obvious what kind of decks would be considered with clear criteria.

If no one cares, I don't really care, some anon just might like a new deck with minimal invested effort.
>>
File: Dean Mulder gets spooped on.gif (873KB, 400x226px) Image search: [Google]
Dean Mulder gets spooped on.gif
873KB, 400x226px
>>51241457

Zur, the Enchanter re-animator. It always seemed neat to me, but I can never seem to make it work.
>>
>>51241398
The grammar on that card is wrong.
>>
>>51241457
Surrak Dragonclaw as general, BEARS tribal.
And I don't mean bears as in the archetype of nearly any 2 cmc 2/2 range cards, I mean almost strictly cards that have Bear creature type or make Bear creature type tokens.
Bear's Companion, Balduvian Bears, Caller of the Claw, Druid's Familiar, Bear Umbra, Bearscape, Words of Wilding, Grizzly Fate, the whole 9 yards and then some.
>>
>>51241601
It's exactly the same as Aurelia was printed, so either Wizards fucked up or they intended it to read weird. (probably the latter, they tend to do that)
>>
>>51241594
That might be a winner. I'll give it like 15 minutes to see if any other anons have crazy suggestions.

>>51241608
Question: Are you that anon with the excellent Mike Ditka bear alter?
>>
>>51240824
I just use a cinch bag. Cost me $5 and holds about 7 boxes
>>
>>51241594
Alright I'll build it for you anon. It might be good, it might not, but it will be a thing that shows up here in a few hours.
>>
File: 1409096360471.jpg (66KB, 320x320px) Image search: [Google]
1409096360471.jpg
66KB, 320x320px
>>51241675

I'll be lurking around! I'm excited to see what you come up with, if this ends up being the deck you go with.
>>
>>51240584
Well, zombies are kinda like that. Wizard synergies are not really focused on combat, so that might be better for you
>>
File: 234.jpg (56KB, 336x469px) Image search: [Google]
234.jpg
56KB, 336x469px
>>51241457

Aristocrats tribal
>>
Best commander/colors for vampire tribal?
>>
File: Yee Ol' Coffee Group.png (3MB, 1824x2680px) Image search: [Google]
Yee Ol' Coffee Group.png
3MB, 1824x2680px
>>51235899
Too lazy to add the 3 other interesting poeple to frequent our group. Maybe in a future update.
>>
>>51239838
I built a deck for it, it's more flavorful than anything else but it can give you some ideas. One card the deck definitely needs is Mirror Gallery.
>>
>>51235899

your best mate looks pregnant
>>
>>51242517
Is that a JoJo reference?
>>
File: 1479869535314.png (25KB, 233x216px) Image search: [Google]
1479869535314.png
25KB, 233x216px
>>51240540
How is

>talking about EDH decks
>talking about good cards in EDH
>talking about working around a budget for EDH
>talking about playing EDH online

not talking about EDH?
>>
File: As long as it works.jpg (17KB, 242x326px) Image search: [Google]
As long as it works.jpg
17KB, 242x326px
>>51242591
Definitely
>>
>>51242504
Probably Anowon or Old Drana for pure B, Old Olivia if you go BR, Jeleva if UBR, and Marchesa or Tariel for WBR.
>>
>>51242567
yeah he's a fat bastard
>>
>>51235899
>infect/phyrexian theme to Atraxa

Tell me more
>>
>Frogposting

kys my man
>>
>>51242504
Rakdos or Mardu.
>>
File: Sage in every field.jpg (31KB, 223x310px) Image search: [Google]
Sage in every field.jpg
31KB, 223x310px
>>51242504
Mono Black
>>
is Trostani really that bad? How often does it win?
>>
>>51242777

It seems like red adds some cool stuff though.
>>
>>51240887
Filthy communist scum!
its pretty cool though
>>
>>51242816
>>51242750

I like Mardu and I like Rakdos. Obviously for Rakdos the obvious answer is Oldlivia, but how about Mardu?
>>
>>51236044
Ritual of the Machine
>>
>>51242806
I don't really see how Trostani is bad. There are stronger WG options, and her mana cost is pretty harsh, but she gains you a truckload of life, and tokens are easy to come by.

The trick is to use cards like Mimic Vat to copy crazy ETBs, then using Trostani to copy them again for added value.

If I were to make an WG deck, I'd probably pick her, but then again I have too many decks planned.
>>
File: Gitrog.png (128KB, 223x311px) Image search: [Google]
Gitrog.png
128KB, 223x311px
Since i bought a Crucible of Worlds yesterday pretty cheap i thought i had to build Gitrog and so i did. Heres the first draft, i feel like i need more landfall but idk if there are any good ones that isn't already in the deck. I have excluded some card due to budget restrictions but in the future i will try to get my hands on cards such Titania and Urborg.

Decklist: http://tappedout.net/mtg-deckpaste/16-01-17-YvL-none/

Thanks /TG
>>
What is some good removal against the Theros gods in Golgari colors?
>>
>>51243241
wait until they become creatures and hit them with -x/-x effects
>>
>>51243264
The problem is that with assholes like Purphoros they can stay as creatures forever and still be viable. Are there some decent "exile enchantment" effects for green or is that white's domain only?
>>
>>51243288
*stay as enchantments I meant
>>
>>51243241
Dark Imposter, Eradicate, Fade Into Antiquity, Gild, Sever the Bloodline, Shauku Endbringer, Sisters of Stone Death.
Most of these rely on the God already being a creature though.
>>
>>51243311
>Fade Into Antiquity
This is a great one. More like this? Preferably stapled on some permanent?
>>
>>51241398
>untap all creature you control
>creature
>>
>>51243351
Sadly no.
Exile and other good God removals are nearly strictly White. (like Suppression Bonds, Darksteel Mutation, and nearly all enchantment exile)
>>
>>51242517
>Artificial Evolutioning Dovescape to say Scarecrows

Holy shit.
>>
>>51243288
No exile enchantments in green to my understanding, but there is forced sac like simplify
>>
>recuring nightmare is banned
Of-fucking-course. It was way too spicy the way I was going to use it anyways. I guess stupid diabolic servitude will have to do...
>>
>>51243241
Scour from existance, since you should be shitting out mana in those colours
>>
>>51243507
>Golgari colors
>BG
>Scour from Existence (WB)
u wot
>>
>>51243465
I run a plenty of enchantments though, anything like Simplify but not hitting myself? Mana isn't an issue.
>>51243507
Also an option, but feels kinda clunky.
>>
>>51243241
>>51243555
Deglamer and Unravel the Aether exist, if the God isn't their general.
Tribute to the Wild forces each opponent to sac an artifact or enchantment.
Harmonic Convergence if you can handle it coming back shortly.
Wave of Vitriol if you can handle hurting yourself too.
>>
>>51243537
Are you?
Scour from Existence is colorless you shambling shell
>>
>>51243606
Tribute to the Wild seems pretty great now that I look at it, for some reason I never noticed it only costs 2 mana.
>>
>>51237594
>EDH cube
Wait, how the fuck does that work?
>>
Just spent a hundred bucks on fetches and shocks. Firsf time I've ever bought fetches. Now I'm eyeballing an expedition Misty. Fuck this hobby
>>
>>51243606
>>51243667
Hold on, it says artifact OR enchantment, not AND. Damn it
>>
>>51243661
Oh, right, forgot the colorless one existed. Was getting it confused with Utter End and Anguished Unmaking.
>>
>>51243686

>Expeditions

Don't, they are ugly and plebs first pimp choice. Get some OG pack foils and roll around in all the KMC quality babes who want to sleeve your deck if you know what I mean.
>>
>>51243668

You draft a commander, then you draft according to the commander's themes and color identity.
>>
>>51243917
And how long does the drafting take?
Are the decks still 100 cards?
>>
Got this guy as a promo from AER prerelease, how do I build a deck around him?

Just Aura/Equip goodstuff and splash some vehicles in there or is there some spicy combos I'm missing?
>>
File: Zur the Enchanter.jpg (79KB, 400x559px) Image search: [Google]
Zur the Enchanter.jpg
79KB, 400x559px
>>51241926
>>51241594
Here's what I've got anon:

http://tappedout.net/mtg-decks/16-01-17-zur-reanimator/

After playtesting, the worst thing to happen is too many lands, but this deck should be pretty versatile, and can easily be changed into a variety of things, fitting your budget/availability of cards.

To get things into the yard, windfall, draw early, or just straight up play until they wind up in there. The deck should ramp pretty hard, so you'll be able to hardcast some of those fatties late game. Just beware, there are only two enchantments you can tutor up with Zur to reanimate anything, so don't discard them if they come up.
>>
File: Image.ashx.jpg (36KB, 223x310px) Image search: [Google]
Image.ashx.jpg
36KB, 223x310px
>>51237990
>Playing Eddy in a 6 player game
>Manage to get T1 Ophiomancer, T2 Phyrexian Altar and T3 Grave pact online at the same time
>Shut down 4 out of the 5 other players decks until T6 at which point a wrath cannot stop the sheer amount of forward momentum i've built up
>Endrek simply looks on and laughs as a crazy lady who shits out snakes manages to give me enough time to exanguinate everyone for lethal

I love my time spiral foil, it's so pretty and was dirt cheap

On a seperate note, I'm looking to let me inner Timmy out by building pic related, any spicy tech that I need to know about besides Mage Slayer?
>>
File: 23.jpg (64KB, 312x445px) Image search: [Google]
23.jpg
64KB, 312x445px
>>51244060
and of course I forget the fucking picture
>>
File: 115.jpg (65KB, 312x445px) Image search: [Google]
115.jpg
65KB, 312x445px
>>51244204
Omnath, Locus of Rage could be fun and pic related, which seems spicy in a ton of decks
>>
>>51242857
There's nothing obvious, so I would use either Queen Marchesa or Tariel. Probably the former, since she's much more useful by herself.
>>
>>51244214
Sigarda's Aid
Cram Equipment OR Aura's in, White has the strongest support in the game for them. Cross reference EDHrec on any of the monowhite voltron commanders. (Which is all of them)
Play any vehicles you like, none of them struck me as EDH bombs so whatever
>>
>>51243482
>repeatable uninterruptable (aside from counterspells) reanimation
What'd you expect?
>>
File: Nothing else to give.jpg (76KB, 960x647px) Image search: [Google]
Nothing else to give.jpg
76KB, 960x647px
>>51244107

Thanks Anon!

It's definitely very different from what I had been trying to come up with on my own, and i'm interested to see how it does. I'm not going to make any changes, except the lands since I might as well get some use out of the esper manabase that is languishing in my binders.

I'll be playing some EDH Thursday, and I will report back to /edhg/ with how we did.
>>
>>51244444
Uh.. check em?
>>
>>51244601
No problem anon, I'm just happy you're actually going to test it out, and I hope it doesn't disappoint too too much.

Now that being said, if you're getting a better manabase, you can probably cut Burnished Hart (who was on the fence anyways) sword of the animist, and solemn simulacrum. I'd suggest Grand Abolisher, Necropotence, and Aqueos Form/Seal of the Godhead.
>>
Should I run Umezawa's Jitte in Toshiro?
You don't get a flavor opportunity like that very often.
>>
>>51244107
>http://tappedout.net/mtg-decks/16-01-17-zur-reanimator/
No Attunement? No Dance of the Dead?
>>
>>51244896
Why not? The Jitte can kill small creatures to trigger Toshiro's ability.
>>
>>51245073
>Attunement
Pretty spicy, honestly didn't know that was a thing.

>Dance of the Dead
Eh, this one didn't make the cut because it keeps the creature tapped down unless you pay mana for it. I mean, there is mana to spare, and lots of things don't need to be untapped to do things, but in general, this deck is a little light on wincons, so keeping your fatties tapped might fuck you over more than it will help. Pretty sure I should have included Battle Mastery as well.
>>
>>51239190
What IS a kavu?

Is it a beast? A mutant? It's certainly not distinct enough from a generic baloth to warrant its own creature type.
>>
>>51245073
>>51245181
Oh, this is also the first Zur deck I've ever built. I didn't realize how fragile he would be until I started testing him out. The attack-based trigger is nice, but it's not as easy to pull of as it looks.
>>
>>51242504
I have an Old Olivia deck and I have to say that she is awesome for Vampire tribal as she buffs herself and your field nicely. Szadek is a nice one if you just like your commander to be something annoying to everyone, since he can get really nasty really quickly. Especially if you can give him Double-Strike. He's also good for the ability to splash blue and get some good counter-spells going.

Jeleva is a probably the better option if you want Vampire Tribal in 3 colours, but if you don't like milling your own shit, i'd say that Garza Zol is a little expensive to field, but she's actually a really nice late-game creature.

And Olivia:Mobilized For War is a great Tiny Leaders commander, just be warned, she does leave your hand looking barren, so put as much draw as you can in there.
>>
>>51245217
I think they're mutants. Dominaria (the actual planet) created them to help fight Phyrexia
>>
>>51240916
Or red dawn.jpg
>>
>>51239190
Think that's bad? I want to make an Elephant Tribal. Problem is, there is only 1 Legendary Elephant and he's from Unhinged.

You'd think there would be at least 1 legendary Loxodon?
>>
>>51245547
They're native there, they went into hibernation and were brought back to fight phyrexia.
Not sure on their mutantness, though.
>>
>>51245217
>>51245547
>>51245721
http://mtgsalvation.gamepedia.com/Kavu
>>
>>51245681
Not only is he from unhinged, he's also monowhite.
I love my Frankie Peanuts deck though. Each of my friends has an un-deck
>>
>>51243241
>no song of the dryads or worldbreaker are things i can see...
>>
>>51243747
Yes but that would cost me actual money since I got rid of all my trade stuff ages ago and the shop where I get credit doesn't have any, also expy misty is dope
>>
>>51243241

you have so many choices printed int he last couple of years you can pretty casually take your pick from. You're almost in the best colors for it honestly.
>>
>>51237292
Post breya deck
>>
>>51243241
Brutalizer exarch works as long they are not creatures
>>
File: monstrousonslaught.jpg (47KB, 265x370px) Image search: [Google]
monstrousonslaught.jpg
47KB, 265x370px
>>51244204
This looked spicy to me.
>>
So, I am thinking about buying a little loot over "eBay Kleinanzeigen", kinda Germanys craigslist, hoping to find a few gems because its nearby, cheap and the seller made shitty pics so nobody so far bought it.

What is /edh/s experience with random loots from sites like craigslist?
>>
>>51243241
primal command
>>
>>51240824
I use an HP laptop bag, fits a playmat in tube, a 4-pocket dragonshield binder, up to 8 ultrapro pro deck boxes, and I use a leather hard drive case that fits my dice and counters. Fits tight but not terribly so, enough that if my bag falls, nothing will jolt around and get damaged.
>>
>>51241398

>digital "alters"

try again
>>
>>51240824
I have a spare messenger bag that holds four or five decks, dicebag, token box, and playmat, with room for my phone charger in a side pocket. I need another playmat tube so I can keep a spare in my regular bag with a deck
>>
>>51237990
Arjun, when i drew my deck out after casting two spells, i knew i could work with it
>>
>>51244060
fill your deck with all 0 and 1 drop equipment, aetherflux reservoir, mana positive rocks, cost reducers, and maybe paradox engine %^)
>>
File: 58.jpg (58KB, 336x469px) Image search: [Google]
58.jpg
58KB, 336x469px
>>51244204

Pic related, dragonlair spider, artifact mutation, tempt with vengeance when you have a way to give thromok haste/trample and have him eat everything, etc

lots of tokens, anon
>>
File: what.jpg (58KB, 687x814px) Image search: [Google]
what.jpg
58KB, 687x814px
>custom card art
>can't see the text
>>
>>51245217
>not distinct enough from baloths

You actually have a bit of a point there, but in my mind it's the other way around. Kavu could've been broadened into a more perennial type, maybe making later generations Kavu Beasts to show the species diluted since the invasion/preserve tribal interactions of Onslaught block. Definitely too late for that now though.

>>51245681
One of the first Legacy, or Type 1 rather, decks I tinkered with ages ago was an Elephant tribal deck on Cockatrice or one of the other old online MTG clients. Elephant Grass and Elephant Graveyard included, naturally. I even lamented being unable to do an Elephant EDH tribal some generals back, so I totally get you.
>>
>>51246938
I've tried playing with Predatory Advantage and I can't really recommend it. Dragonlair Spider and Dragon Broodmother do the same thing but so much better, even a Huntmaster of the Fells has more of an impact.
>>
Any love for Pauper EDH here? I want to play some RW deck but I don't know many cards (haven't played in several years). Any ideas?
>>
File: Death_by_Leaf.png (211KB, 241x347px) Image search: [Google]
Death_by_Leaf.png
211KB, 241x347px
Any ideas for my Nath deck?
>http://tappedout.net/mtg-decks/nath-of-the-gilt-leave/
>>
What Simic commander is the most fun?
>>
>>51247526
>build "fun" deck to bring to magic night
>excited to pull off some jenkery
>friend pulls out his nekusar deck
>wins turn 3
>other person pulls out brago
>infini combo turn 4
>proceed to lose 3 more games before i leave
>>
File: 2017-01-12 16.38.43.jpg (3MB, 4128x2322px) Image search: [Google]
2017-01-12 16.38.43.jpg
3MB, 4128x2322px
>>51240887
I run Surrak Mono-Red (with splashes) and mostly use Snow Mountains, so my friend made this alter for me.
>>
>>51244060
I feel he goes straight to the point as a voltron commander. Nothing complicated, just make sure you have spells to pop your opponents stuff
>>
File: Ruhan_of_the_Fomori.jpg (34KB, 223x310px) Image search: [Google]
Ruhan_of_the_Fomori.jpg
34KB, 223x310px
I'd like to try this commander out. Already thrown in Assault Suit, what can I do that allows a 7/7 to be thrown around like a baseball?
>>
>>51247526
Simic Partner Pals
>>
>>51247633
Vow of Duty/Flight/Lightning are pretty good since they also make him unable to attack you.
Throw in Frenzied Fugue to have someone else's thing run to you every turn.
If you want to make more crazy control swapping shenanigans, throw in Risky Move, Puca's Mischief, Conjured Currency, etc.

Some other ideas would be to give him Shroud (not Hexproof) so that other people can't target him for their own effects, give him Vigilance or put an aura on him so you can forcibly untap him so he has to attack (Second Wind would be good) I say your aura because whenever he changes control you still control the auras, so you can use them to forcibly untap him.
>>
File: rishkar.png (138KB, 223x311px) Image search: [Google]
rishkar.png
138KB, 223x311px
Is Rishkar a good add for Marath, even if the deck doesn't have a heavy +1/+1 counter theme?
>>
File: A shiggity diggity doo.gif (1MB, 264x264px) Image search: [Google]
A shiggity diggity doo.gif
1MB, 264x264px
>>51243698
>He doesn't have Autocard Anywhere
>>
File: Done(Tim).png (3MB, 1500x3247px) Image search: [Google]
Done(Tim).png
3MB, 1500x3247px
>>
>>51247913
>>51241180
The hell did I miss you?
>>
>>51247927
I dunno, also you forgot to change your filename.
>>
>>51247939
Forgot? Nah, just lazy.
>>
someone give me a degenerate, bullshit deck that can beat derevi, leovold and brago
>>
>>51247770
>Creatures you'd probably be better off swinging or blocking with are now Lawnmowers, too

Honestly, probably not. It seems like any slot that that has him would be better off with a Cryptolith Rite/Earthcraft or a more efficient +1/+1 engine.
>>
>>51247971
Wildfire Wanderer
>>
File: Argentum_Armor.jpg (9KB, 178x248px) Image search: [Google]
Argentum_Armor.jpg
9KB, 178x248px
>>51247745
Those are good ideas. Hey, does Argentum's ability allow the controller at the time of it attacking or the owner to destroy target permanent?
>>
>>51248052
The controller of the Armor decides, even if someone else controls the creature, since the destruction ability is on the armor and not given to the creature.
>>
File: dog_waffle.png (497KB, 540x540px) Image search: [Google]
dog_waffle.png
497KB, 540x540px
>>51248092
Thanks again for answering my dumb questions, I think I'm going to like this deck more than I probably should. My friends are gonna hate me though, they all take this game really seriously.
>>
My playgroup let me build Black Braids as my commander, has anyone got some spicy tech thats not top line EDHREC?
>>
>>51248211
If you're going for lockdown:
Bottomless Pit to force discards, Contamination to fuck with mana bases, Curse of the Cabal for an ever-present sac threat (just suspend it and watch their boards dwindle), The Abyss to Terror a creature every upkeep.
I also am pretty fond of exile for removal in EDH, so I like cards like Bitter Ordeal, Head Games, Nightmare Incursion, Praetor's Grasp, Sadistic Sacrament, and Grinning Totem to go searching in people's libraries and permanently remove threats from the game.
Tabernacle at Pendrell Vale is a land that gives all creatures an upkeep cost of 1 or they have to sac it, so it's good to keep wide decks in check.
>>
So, why aren't you playing this bad boy in every black deck you own /edhg/? I've been building Silas Renn Stax and it's been a great piece to add to my Artificer's Intuition package.
>Eats Atraxa SuperAids for breakfast
>Takes counters off Smokestack if you want it to
>Adjusts your Chalice of the Void if you need to (but not in response to a spell, that doesn't quite work)
What's not to love?
>>
File: 137.jpg (70KB, 312x445px) Image search: [Google]
137.jpg
70KB, 312x445px
>>51248348
I'm gonna go pour myself a nice tall glass of bleach, have a nice night guys.
>>
>>51248348
>>51248363
I bought one just to fuck over my friend's Atraxa counters deck.

>>51248297
Thanks for the suggestions
>>
So my current 3 decks are:

Ezuri, Claw of Progress, +1/+1 counters
Daxos the Returned, enchantment oppression
Alesha who Smiles at Death, weenie reanimator.

What should my next deck be if I want to move as far from those archetypes as possible? I have Gahiji, Honored One, Chainer, Sultai Sidisi and the Gitrog Monster sitting around, but my extended playgroup has just about everything for trade.
>>
File: 1256771483464.jpg (163KB, 500x500px) Image search: [Google]
1256771483464.jpg
163KB, 500x500px
That does it /tg/, ive decided to say fuck it.

I can't build a proper swingy golgari deck to keep trying to deny myself from just playing prossh or kaalia for the sake of not being "that guy"
>>
File: 1484280044159.png (177KB, 367x321px) Image search: [Google]
1484280044159.png
177KB, 367x321px
>>51248747
>play golgari because its my favorite
>always first to get targeted because im too stupid to not blow my load asap
suffering
>>
File: 1477332505881.png (393KB, 437x550px) Image search: [Google]
1477332505881.png
393KB, 437x550px
>magic group with friends is ok
>lose pretty often but whatever, still have fun mostly
>friend in group gets salty that experienced player is winning
>starts buying expensive decks
>the money arms race in our group has begun
>>
Just finished building my Kami of the crescent moon stasis deck. Could anyone maybe take a look at it and judge my horrible deckbuilding skills?
http://tappedout.net/mtg-decks/i-a-m-t-h-e-l-a-w/
>>
>Be Spikey as fuck
>Locals has many timmy and true casual players
>play EDH together
>they get super upset that I counter their potential game-ending combos or stop them from preventing me from winning the game

I'll never understand this mindset where "Counterspells" should be removed from MTG so kiddies can pretend they're playing a completely different game.
>>
>>51248747
just play narset if you really want to be "that guy"

>>51248993
anyone who doesnt have a little spike in them is someone you should avoid playing with. they will get massively butt hurt no matter what you do
>>
>>51248883
just wait until they get BTFO by a budget deck, thats always fun to watch

>what do you mean my $3000 deck with a full set of duels doesnt auto win?
>>
File: gayduck.png (255KB, 892x363px) Image search: [Google]
gayduck.png
255KB, 892x363px
>>51248993
>play golgari
>table has zero blue
>combo weed lord does some gay infini combo and wins
>"LOL WHY DIDNT U GUYS DO ANYTHING???"
>>
>>51248993
>Sit down for a pick-up game of EDH before prerelease with some people who were there early
>"Oh yeah we're cool with everything so long as it isn't degenerate"
>Use Alesha Reanimator. Not super high powered
>Call me degenerate for explaining how Fiend Hunter can exile something permanently.
>everyone scoops after I ult Flip-Lili and Deadly Tempest the board.
I mean, I feel a bit bad, but these weren't people just playing precon decks.
>>
>>51240887
>>51240916
>>51245555

Dont you mean REALSOVIETDAMAGE.png
>>
>>51249151
her name is loliana
>>
File: MyMeta.png (2MB, 1500x2394px) Image search: [Google]
MyMeta.png
2MB, 1500x2394px
>>51235899
group looks decent, would play with
>>
>>51249536
But she doesn't look like a loli at all.
You can't fool me.
>>
>guy at pre release with a binder worth like 4 grand
>think about following him home and robbing him

honestly why would you bring something like that out in public?
>>
>>51249591
>tfw no loli commander
>>
File: 1465456415616.jpg (37KB, 460x276px) Image search: [Google]
1465456415616.jpg
37KB, 460x276px
>>51235973
Rashmi is the shit. You fly under the radar, can play most any strat, interact lots, and you benefit far more from manipulating your deck than with Intet. You also exploit cheating mana costs, especially the force of will mechanic and emerge and such. It's become my most pimp deck
>>
>>51249611
>Literally one of the reasons I always have a Balaclava and a knife with me
One day I'll see an opportunity.
>>
>>51243241
Song of the Dryads, Unravel the Aether, Sever the Bloodline, Ashes to Ashes.
>>
>>51249148
You are in colors with plenty of ways to remove things(doom blade, song of the dryads, go for the throat, unravel the aether) what the fuck are you whining about.
>>
File: Angry-Peyton-Manning-Stare.gif (2MB, 324x317px) Image search: [Google]
Angry-Peyton-Manning-Stare.gif
2MB, 324x317px
>>51249757
because my list is full of cards for my own gay combo
let me complain
>>
>>51249787
lol ok, my bad
>>
File: Image.jpg (33KB, 223x310px) Image search: [Google]
Image.jpg
33KB, 223x310px
>>51235694
Witches, the most under appreciated tribe
>>
>>51239838
Build it once just to play something else besides enchantress. If you are not completely fixed on just h00mans and add some goodstuff, it can be a fun deck.

On theme 'must-haves':
>Angel of Glory's Rise
>Thalia's Lancers
>Bastion Protector
>Saffi Eriksdotter
>Containment Priest
>Ulvenwald Mysteries

I also recommend that Flash human from the new commander set. It's hilarious against other aggressive decks.
>>
File: Image.jpg (29KB, 223x310px) Image search: [Google]
Image.jpg
29KB, 223x310px
>>51249807
I would've loved to see them actually flesh out Witches as Curse-makers, and flesh out Curses and Curse support at the same time.
Oh well.
>>
>>51249676
guns beat knifes kiddo
>>
>>51249834
You know, that would be awesome, curses have been forgotten, that would be cool if they brought them back and witches as their main support. I can see u/b curse control deck becoming a thing
>>
File: gonti.png (126KB, 223x311px) Image search: [Google]
gonti.png
126KB, 223x311px
http://tappedout.net/mtg-decks/d-a-r-k-f-a-n-t-a-s-y/

Feedback? The maybeboard is a list of things I'm trying to get, but please suggest cuts.. Also, lmk if there's any monoB or gonti staples I'm missing.
>>
>>51249807
>Wizard
>>51249834
>Shaman

Score one for consistency. That's just another way you don't actually have Witch tribal - aside from the obvious bit of not using Witch as a creature type.
>>
File: 0.jpg (9KB, 480x360px) Image search: [Google]
0.jpg
9KB, 480x360px
>>51249980
Deep dark fantasies?
>>
Non stax way to use Derevi
>>
File: ballerina.jpg (93KB, 630x355px) Image search: [Google]
ballerina.jpg
93KB, 630x355px
>>51250070
Something like that

>>51250126
You could focus on creatures with tap effects, but you're still going to draw massive amounts of hate just for it being Derevi.
>>
>>51250070
hey buddy, leather club is two doors down
>>
>>51250126
Unfortunately, like >>51250152 said, certain commanders have a huge stigma around them, and so they get hated out of games even if you try to reassure the other players that it's not a typical deck of that commander.
Derevi, Oloro, Narset, pretty much any infamous commander is gonna get this treatment, so it's usually better to use a different commander and include them as part of the 99 if you must include them at all.
>>
>>51236605
Liquimetal Coating on opponent's lands and then use Karn to make them 0/0 creatures. ;3
>>
>>51236605
Liquidmetal Coating or Mycosynth Lattice to be able to use Karn's active to kill any land you want.
>>
>>51250264
2late bub
>>
>>51249980
Mike but no Trike? Or Trike's Lil Brudder?
>>
>>51243668
In this cube specifically, you have 5 packs of 16 cards, 15 cards from the normal pool, and 1 from the commander pool, and build a 70 card deck
>>
File: my edh.png (2MB, 1500x2394px) Image search: [Google]
my edh.png
2MB, 1500x2394px
>>
File: slobad.jpg (713KB, 1021x800px) Image search: [Google]
slobad.jpg
713KB, 1021x800px
>>51234025
Don't know if you're still there, but I typed up version 1.0 of my slobad list!
>>
>>51250529
>>51234025

http://tappedout.net/mtg-decks/slobads-time-to-shine/
>>
File: chandra.jpg (108KB, 768x432px) Image search: [Google]
chandra.jpg
108KB, 768x432px
>>51249628
This is the closest you'll ever get to a loli commander
>>
File: walkingballista.jpg (48KB, 265x370px) Image search: [Google]
walkingballista.jpg
48KB, 265x370px
>>51250415
Ooo, forgot about Trike. Who is the lil bro though? Walking Ballista comes to mind but I think that needs a third combo piece like Blood Artist to work.
>>
>>51250186
The only way you can get away with the stigma is if you show the deck or people already know that the deck is not the typical degenerate build.
>>
>>51250603
Nah, the Ballista works the exact same as Triskelion with BMikaeus.
Triskelion and Ballista both remove their last +1/+1 counter to ping something, then die, and because they died while having 0 +1/+1 counters they get Undying trigger and come back with 1 +1/+1, then you use that to their abilities to ping, etc, infinite dmg/etb/ltb.
>>
>>51250579
The fuck is with her pants.
>>
>>51250640
Mike does give a +1/+1 buff though, so you'll need a sac outlet for the Ballista unlike Trike
>>
>>51250640
That doesn't work though. Ballista ETBs with just the single +1/+1 counter from undying which it must use to ping itself. You can only get infinite ETB/Death Triggers rather than straight up win the game with Trisk.
>>
File: dicks.jpg (182KB, 640x960px) Image search: [Google]
dicks.jpg
182KB, 640x960px
has anyone done a "Battle of wits" edh deck? i just finished mine and im super happy with it. using nig mizzle drac og as my commander.
>>
>>51251024
Well you can't win with Battle of Wits.
Since it's 100 card deck, hard limit. Not minimum, and battle of wits is 200.
>>
>>51251092
Isn't there some card that allows you to add cards to your deck from outside of the game?
>>
>>51251112
Spawnsire of Ulamog and the wish cycle, which don't work in commander since there's no sideboard. if your group houserules it though it's fine.
>>
>>51251176
>if your group houserules it
You don't need a house rule. The "sideboard" rule was only applicable to sanctioned events. Everywhere else, the card is fully designed to get you any card you own from outside the game.

Fully fucking legal to get up, go to your closet, and pull something out of a fucking shoebox.
>>
>>51251092
>Not using opalescence or starfield of nyx to turn battle of wits into a creature and win with combat damage.

Step up your game, senpai.
>>
>>51248558
Could do an Arcanis the Omnipotent self-mill deck, or Azami, Lady of Scrolls wizard tribal
>>
File: shite.png (2MB, 1080x1920px) Image search: [Google]
shite.png
2MB, 1080x1920px
>>51251024

702.123b: Your deck must contain exactly 100 cards, including its two commanders. Both commanders begin the game in the command zone.
>>
How does this seem for an Original Teysa deck?

They're colorless which sucks BUT they're still fodder for sac effects and combo well with darkest hour (granted game has been by that point but still)
>>
>>51251482

Whoops,that one is for partners
Here's the normal one

903.5a: Each deck must contain exactly 100 cards, including its commander.
>>
>>51249661
Do you have a list?
>>
>>51251395
>"Abilities which refer to other cards owned outside the game (Wishes, Spawnsire, Research, Ring of Ma'ruf) do not function in Commander without prior agreement on their scope from the playgroup."

http://mtgcommander.net/rules.php
So yes, otherwise known as a houserule
>>
>>51250603
Yes, I was talking about Walking Ballista, which is a pretty damn good card. While it's not an immediate wincon like Trike, which was why I called it the little bro, you are running Blood Artist now. Also, with any free sac outlet out, you get infinite damage that way. Ashnod's Altar, Phyrexian Altar, Carrion Feeder, Nantuko Husk and its ilk, even your Dimir House Guard.
>>
>built a monoblack deck back in november
>reworked it into a reanimator recently and then built a different kind of reanimator in dimir, spent many an hour brewing them
>whew im glad thats over with
>start thinking about new decks to brew
>the things i'm the most interested in are rakdos reanimator, alesha ETB bears, orzhov lifedrain

help

i cant stop thinkin about that BBC (big black cardstack)
>>
>>51251488
i don't like upkeep/end step effects because they don't scale very well. all you're getting is that one shitty token per turn. meanwhile something like ogre slumlord shits out tokens like crazy, only the sky is the limit
>>
>>51251663
mtgcommander.net is not comprehensive rules, and the comprehensive rules have no such statement about abilities which refer to other cards owned outside the game. The only relevant rule is 108.3b stating that the owner of a card outside the game but not in a sideboard or another magic game is its legal owner. Kitchen table EDH is not a sanctioned Commander event.
>>
>>51251176
yea i use spawnsire to cheese 200 eldrazi onto the battlefield, then evacuation them all back to my hand and time reversal them all into the deck.
>>
File: ashy.png (373KB, 750x834px) Image search: [Google]
ashy.png
373KB, 750x834px
Who's your favorite walker aesthetically and mechanically edhg?

For me:

AESTHETICALLY : ashiok
MECHANICALLY: Dovin Ban
>>
>>51252642
>Aesthetic
Venser
>Mechanic
Tezzeret, AoB

I like blue, don't bully me. At least it's not Jace
>>
>>51252642

AESTHETICALLY : Tezzeret, Agent of Bolas
MECHANICALLY: Tezzeret the Seeker
>>
>>51243465
There's 2 exile enchantments in green.
>>
>>51252642
Kiora and Xenagos, in that order
>>
Recently made and ordered this:
https://deckstats.net/decks/40058/639885-ruff-riders/en

Whatcha think, /tg/? I'm not necessarily out to win any tourneys at my LGS with this or anything, just wanted to make something fun/dumb that might actually work out sometimes.
>>
>>51249097
>>51248883
I don't know about your playgroups powerlevel, but in a weaker meta, this thing can kick ass.

http://tappedout.net/mtg-decks/mikaeus-extreme-sub-20-budget-edh/

It's like $40 now though. They need to reprint Mikaeus
>>
>>51252642
Dovin Banana is one of the most boring and uninspired planeswalkers ever printed.

>>51252675
Throwing my vote in there, unfortunately the new tezzeret is really boring, although with 5 starting loyalty is probably pretty good.
>>
>>51252739
9/10 needs more sram

...

In fact. ..


Just make sram the commander
>>
>>51250579
>>
>>51252408
Too much work. You spawnsire to cheese 200 old Titans onto the field. 199 of them Legend rule themselves into the grave, then they shuffle themselves into your library after hitting the yard.
>>
File: ultra pro satin tower.jpg (6KB, 216x233px) Image search: [Google]
ultra pro satin tower.jpg
6KB, 216x233px
I love these fucking things

The question is. ..

How much abuse can the brick really take?
>>
>>51252942
A lot? I've never seen anyone damage one at least, but it's not like you go around trying either.

Go check out the tolariancommunitycollege video on it, he usually goes into those kind of details.
>>
>>51252642
Aesthetically: Elspeth, Knight-Errant
Mechanically: Garruk, Primal Hunter
>>
What does /edh/ think of my budget Maelstrom Wanderer brew? Thinking of building this next and wanted everyone's thoughts on it. Is it lacking in any particular area?
>>
>>51253089
Did...you want to post your list?
>>
>>51253089
>>51253129
Welp, I'm a retard.

http://tappedout.net/mtg-decks/a-maelstrom-enters-the-battlefield/
>>
>>51253130
>>51253130
>>51253130
New thread is up. I forgot the subject like a complete R-tard, but it's pretty close if y'all want to migrate.
>>
>local EDH group at college
>meta is control/combo, everyone splashes or mainly plays blue
>im a new player, the only aggro player running red/white
>get pooped on all the time and am consistently the worst player because all I like to do is swing out and get countered, or blocked from attacking
>
>continues for 4 months and gets to the point where they joke about me scooping once my commander is knocked off

>learn more about the game
>find out that land destruction is a thing

>go to group with pic related
>get mana base with artifacts
>play MLD cards
>play pic related with boots
>start pumping out creatures with haste
>slowly deal 21 to everyone with double strike

>get hated out of the match so quickly next game
>"Land destruction is a dirty way to play" talk
>yet its the only way to safely play aggro

SO why is land destruction so hated on?
>>
>>51247473
You run too many "discard matters" cards that are just dead weights when you don't have Nath out. Stuff like Megrim and Liliana's Caress is pretty useless in EDH in my opinion. Also Bottomless Pit hurt me more than the opponents way too many times to run it anymore.
>>
>>51252642
aesthetics: any liliana
mechanics: ugin, but that's probably too easy. chandra flamecaller and torch of defiance i have really liked too.
>>
>>51253258
because people are mongoloids

you suck at spoiler tags btw
>>
File: Child of Alara.jpg (41KB, 300x300px) Image search: [Google]
Child of Alara.jpg
41KB, 300x300px
>>51249628
Gotchu Senpai
>>
File: wGIrMS8.jpg (731KB, 3150x2098px) Image search: [Google]
wGIrMS8.jpg
731KB, 3150x2098px
>>51252642
AESTHETICALLY : Nissa
MECHANICALLY: Garruk Wildspeaker

Yes, i'm a hippie
>>
>>51252642
MECHANICALLY: Elspeth, Sun's Champion
AESTHETICALLY: The Alt-Art Nicol Bolas
>>
>>51253258
I didn't know they actually represented keywords like shroud on the actual cards, next time i want to get a flying card printed.
>>
>>51252867
Why use old titans?
use new ulamog instead, get dem sweet sweet etbs famalamadingdong.
>>
>>51255024
>any titan
>cast trigger
>>
>>51249980
Strands of night and cloudstone curio would help you abuse all your delicious ETBs more if you wanted to.
>>
>>51249151
>>Call me degenerate for explaining how Fiend Hunter can exile something permanently.
You mean their commander? Please explain how it works.
>>
>go infinite with Krenko and have to make my opponent deal with hundreds of his ETB triggers which he spends 10 minutes dealing with only for me to pass turn coz all my goblins come in tapped and for him to concede at the end of his next turn
>>
>>51249969

Witches would be like the perfect U/B/G control tribe.
>>
>>51251668

I feel like in the good Mikaeus deck Walking Balista is better than Triskelion because it comes out for free and wins the game instantly if it's not answered.
Thread posts: 335
Thread images: 85


[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / bant / biz / c / can / cgl / ck / cm / co / cock / d / diy / e / fa / fap / fit / fitlit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mlpol / mo / mtv / mu / n / news / o / out / outsoc / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / spa / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vint / vip / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Search | Top | Home]

I'm aware that Imgur.com will stop allowing adult images since 15th of May. I'm taking actions to backup as much data as possible.
Read more on this topic here - https://archived.moe/talk/thread/1694/


If you need a post removed click on it's [Report] button and follow the instruction.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com.
If you like this website please support us by donating with Bitcoins at 16mKtbZiwW52BLkibtCr8jUg2KVUMTxVQ5
All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties.
Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from that site.
This means that RandomArchive shows their content, archived.
If you need information for a Poster - contact them.