We're currently working on Expansion 3 Happy Birthday

>>49883776
Honorable Mention to GMP about two weeks later.

So is Tengu Princess a boy or a girl?
I'll art up some other stuff too.

>>49883842
Boy.

>>49883776
gosh thank you anon

File: future gens.jpg (2MB, 5488x3376px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 5488x3376px

current status

File: images.jpg (5KB, 225x225px) Image search: [Google]

5KB, 225x225px

Why isn' there a Birthday Princess yet?

>>49884297
Didn't you see the OP? We have a Birthday Princess. >>49883776

>>49883842
>>49883862
Can confirm. It's supposed to be a boy, Prof. Oak.

>>49884391
What fetishes do you think she'll have?

>>49884528
According to Spreadsheet Princess ( https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/12IcT_vwIHKAMz-ghvB3fgHTr7DkHvjrbu4Hzlw4XCIU/edit#gid=0 )

<3 Swallowing
<3 Threesome
</3 Humiliation

>>49884297
>>49884391
>>49884528
>>49884539
https://images.custommade.com/GHFr21pWm0BD5N8bfXpuo6C_EpY=/custommade-photosets/25635/25635.140290.jpg

File: TenguKappa.png (87KB, 335x253px) Image search: [Google]

87KB, 335x253px

That's all for tonight.

>>49885168
I'd get cheeky with her beaky, if you catch my drift

>>49885168
Hot Damn.

>>49883776
I'm sitting here continuing to work on Gen3Exp and I noticed; a lot of these companion descriptions are much too long to fit. There's about 60 characters worth of space and some of these are over 100. So, as a note, please do look over these as I post updates. I'm not trying to change the intent of princesses and their companions, but I am editing so they fit the page.

File: Towergirls_Gen_3exp.png (1MB, 1800x4393px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 1800x4393px

WiP

>>49885577
Night Elf's power bonus has a typo. "Hars punishments"
Redcap's description has a typo. "This princess rebels against hte elites"
Water's description has a typo. "An elemental princess mad of water and ice"
Radiant's description has a typo. "This pricness"
Tiki's + sounds off. "Her command enchang spirits unseen." What?

Just a few points I noticed. Looking good though!

>>49885768
Thank you for pointing these out. I try and keep on top of it, but typos happen, especially with so much text.

She enchants spirits unseen, btw.

Well, last thread was fun, but it's time to get back on track
Time to repost Spreadsheet Pri-
>>49884539
...neeeeevermind! We good

>>49885768
found another typo on Tiki
"tranquil" is the word you're looking for, "tranquill" is the name of a pokémon.

>>49885168
Nice ones.

>>49885168
kappa looks great but i think tengus color scheme feels all off and he looks a little tooo... boyish

>>49885168
I'm with >>49887965

I think giving Tengu tamer hair and a more composed/reserved stance would be more appropriate.

File: BM Run.png (196KB, 1320x1986px) Image search: [Google]

196KB, 1320x1986px

Drafted up one of my two runs. This one being the brood master slaver run!

So many outfit rewards.

>>49890840
My dumb ass didn't notice that got cut off there

>>49890840
How'd you manage six slot cart at Gen 2? Unless you saved GM first and used her Rules Lawyering book for your free dowry? :^)

File: tmp_23354-BM Run2-429467778.png (47KB, 974x478px) Image search: [Google]

47KB, 974x478px

>>49890840
>>49890898

Adjusted part 2 then

>>49890935
If you take GM and the rules lawyering, that's 2 slots used, then you get two more. You still have the book with you. Six slots.

Nothing on the card says it doesn't apply for the current gen.

:^)

But wait...

I FORGOT THE SECOND FREE DOWRY!

Eh, I'll take the burning blade.

>>49891030
Oh, I didn't notice RLFD duh!
But if you take it as a free dowry that's TWO slots each gen.

>Towergirls /ic/ thread died
Should I go revive it?

>>49891075
I thought the free slots only applied on dowry sheets (gens 1 & 1.5)

Oh well. Wouldn't change much I think.

>>49879067
I think these fetishes work
>>49883879
Happy Birthday Sor!
>>49885577
Oh hay cool. Charts! Does anyone want me to update the 1d4chan page with the chart under (Incomplete)?
>>49885168
Nice job anon!
>>49886923
someone poaching your job, Stun?
>>49891161
Don't worry. I made the same mistake my first run.

>>49891303
>under (Incomplete) no thank you, Waq. WiP stay in the Work in Progress areas called threads and might just confuse someone reading it.

>>49885168
So, awesome work Please draw morePlease

I am just worried that it looks a little off from the Towergirls style. Hard for me to say for sure though since I am not artist. Design wise though it looks really awesome (Again I do not really know much about Tengu so check with Cheesecake)

>>49885168
Now that Phi mentions it, they are a bit overly detailed, especially Tengu.

>>49891116
I'm sure their regulars know how to make it.

File: 300percentcluckcluc.png (5KB, 434x461px) Image search: [Google]

5KB, 434x461px

https://picarto.tv/Eversor

Streaming!

DLC3 is coming along great, guys.

Have to see the whole thing before I diverted a run for it, but looks damn good anyway.

>>49885168
Looks pretty good, though I admit having the mask on the side of the head irks me.

>>49892801
i would remove the mask entirely as it covers up the much cuter puffball head ornaments

>>49891303
Hey Waq. I know you maintain the 1d4 stuff. Do you happen to know who runs the booru? I'd love to help keep fanart uploaded, but the mass uploader he links is no longer maintained and I don't have time to do that shit one by one.

>>49891116
>>49891481
I remade it.
>>>/ic/2720818

File: Knight Princess 3.jpg (633KB, 1383x2329px) Image search: [Google]

633KB, 1383x2329px

>>49893002
There is a pretty interesting Knight Princess fan art at the bottom of previous one

>>49892736
Dlc?

>>49893085
That's what I tend to call these sidegens when I save them.

>>49893002
Nice.

File: 1475464526406.png (1MB, 727x992px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 727x992px

I'd prefer an eldritch princess more like this one than the one we got.

>>49893191
...BROTHER, NOOOOOOOOO!!!!!

>>49893200
I've always felt her to be insufficiently eldritch (and the design in general is kind of a messy blob). My side project is sort of working towards fixing perceived lack of gribbly eldritchness, though. But since I can't really draw, it probably won't get very far.

File: __gauna_and_shiraui_tsumugi_sidonia_no_kishi_drawn_by_tomatika__eff86454ab443b34e10d57e6b294d169.jpg (3MB, 1750x1250px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 1750x1250px

>>49893200
does it qualify as an eldritch if it's a few months old?

File: Cuttlefish.png (14KB, 434x461px) Image search: [Google]

14KB, 434x461px

Progress from the stream!

>>49893488
Yeah, it will just be awhile before it qualifies as an elder.

>>49893200
I guess that one is a bit more....coherent.

File: FudgeCook.png (23KB, 434x461px) Image search: [Google]

23KB, 434x461px

Fudge Companion

File: Hyundai.png (5KB, 434x461px) Image search: [Google]

5KB, 434x461px

First sci-fi girl i have done i think

>>49893594
Interesting design. Is this based on anything?

File: phonika.jpg (57KB, 600x903px) Image search: [Google]

57KB, 600x903px

>>49893675
phonika as made by hyundai

>>49893594
Again, would torrent

Eversor, are your commissions supposed to be missing their crowns? Gardevoir got a crown didnt she?

>>49893860
i put the crown on gardevoir, I dont give em a crown unless yall wana make em a princess

>>49894029
Its cute either way

Good job with the commission choices so far

File: Hyundai2.png (4KB, 173x230px) Image search: [Google]

4KB, 173x230px

>>49893594
Phonika lite frame

>>49893675
Hyundai wants to build waifubots.

File: mole.png (80KB, 280x367px) Image search: [Google]

80KB, 280x367px

mole princess.

I'm not very happy with the design.

>>49893594
>>49893736
10/10 design.

Good taste.

>>49893594
Now if we can just sneak her into a Gen somewhere (would she qualify as Cameo?).

>>49895248
I'm tempted to suggest including a Gurren Lagann reference to spice up her design a bit, but she's at least a good starting point.

File: TenguKappa2.png (159KB, 537x653px) Image search: [Google]

159KB, 537x653px

>>49885168
Attempt 2

>>49895843
much better, i still feel like he needs his scrolls or books somewhere for a bit of scholorlyness but overall this is a much cleaner take on the design

>>49896260
Maybe like on a satchel, or on his back Ryze style. Also I believe we still need a proper Kingdom name and summary. (and not the shitty uncultured one I made yonder threads ago)

>>49896991
a big scroll across his back could work although that would be next to impossible to show with that pose

>>49893200
Gen 5: Flayer Princess.

>>49897130
With any pose really the wings are in the way.

File: moley.png (6KB, 245x295px) Image search: [Google]

6KB, 245x295px

>>49895248
ayy, guess who I just finished with. Guayo/RT did a mole gal not long ago as well

>>49898493
Hair drills...

File: CC77FD9C-727D-4433-A793-7F78FC55D102-7421-00000A8D8321F786_tmp.gif (1MB, 800x533px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 800x533px

>>49898580

>>49898493
>>49895248
Okay, just to be clear, the idea is to have one be Stationgirl Mole and the other is a Towergirl, right?

>>49898645
I believe so

File: QueenPrincess.png (28KB, 186x266px) Image search: [Google]

28KB, 186x266px

Something silly

File: StartMenu.gif (16KB, 850x550px) Image search: [Google]

16KB, 850x550px

Hey guy's I am taking a stab at a quest too. Take a look if you have some time!

http://towergirlschivalryedition.tumblr.com/

>>49899503
Neat, thanks for the heads up.

>>49898493
She's cute.

File: Towergirls_Gen_3exp.png (2MB, 1800x4393px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1800x4393px

>>49885577
Almost done with the princesses.

>>49885168
I integrated your latest rendition of these two. My only problem was that their were disproportionate. So I had to do a bit of editing to fix that. Please tell me if I went a bit too far with that. (Shrank him down and shortened & widened just her body, didn't touch her head.)

I also took the information I had from Spreadsheet Princess and applied it, whilst also finishing it out. It was missing a kingdom name and a quote. If anyone is curious, the quote is based on the fact that the concept of the Tengu has changed in the last thousand years. They were originally canine harbingers of war that only in the last three-hundred years or so became less demonized (and I mean that literally). What do you all think?

>>49885768
>>49886951
Linking these to remind myself tomorrow, as I was not able to get to them tonight.

>>49891585
300percentcluckcluck will never not be funny

>>49893031
Dude, if the booru had a function mass uploader system, I'd literally just go through the archives and grab ALL of their work. It's so goddamn amazing.

>>49893594
>>49894029
Just a thought; if Brave was up for it, you could have her in Stationgirls as, like, "Prototype Princess".

>>49895843
IDK if you're aware of this, buddy, but there are .psd versions linked in the OP. That reminds me! I need to update those fuckers. Reminder to myself I suppose.

>>49899362
Eeeeeehhh, not my cup of tea, but if people want it, I'm sure we can find a place for it.

>>49899503
Woot! Another Quest.

>>49901512
Also, as a note, layout is not final. I'm trying to avoid having too many Blue Princesses next to each other. While I'm sure Yvon d'Bleu would have a field day with this gen, it's not visually appealing to have all of them next to each other.

>>49885577
I don't like any of these...

>>49901560
Then perhaps you might like some of the updated ones, friend? Heh.
>>49901512

>>49901569
Not really. They're way too specific to have any broad appeal compared to the early ones. With those you cover all the standard "monster girl" tropes, but these just feel like a jumble of leftovers. Radiant and Paladin are basically the same theme, Redcap and Firework's themes are too "out there" to be enough of a hook, Wisp is a low-rent ghost, and while Scylla and Dark Elf would be fine filler I'm pretty sure there's already somebody who fills both their niches. About the best design is Kappa and she's attached to a trap fetish junk character.

This still needs a few rounds of adding new stuff and culling before it'll be good to go.

>>49901682
Rat is kinda redundant when there's already a mouse princess.

Not even a Dire Rat or anything, just...a rat.

>>49901682
To be fair, were at 160 princesses, 180 with Brave's Stationgirls. "Someone else already fills that niche" is going to be impossible to avoid with this many.

And I'd disagree that Radiant and Paladin are the same. Yes, they're both holy warriors, but one is a toned Spartan Vampire Hunter and the other is a Bible Thumping woman with a repressed libido. While I'm sure they'd get along, I wouldn't call them the same.

Additionally, I think it's poor criticism to say "the princess are samey and overlap ... but firework and redcap are too not normal."

And lastly, Rat appeals to completely different fetishes. Mouse is an inventor who shares you with her sisters. Rat is an almost pitiful figure who can remind you of your first girlfriend or yourself when you first started dating as a teenager. That nervous worry, trying to make sure that you're a good partner. Worry that maybe their cheating on you because you don't have the self confidence of an adult yet. They may have similar appearances, but they have wildly different personalities.

>>49901691
You know rat and mouse are different.
Mouse is like gadget from danger ranger.
While rat is rat species.

>>49901882
Plus Rat's got the whole "mafia don's daughter with a heart of gold" trope going for her
I actually got pretty invested in her lore as an atoner for her kingdom & clique

>>49901866
Good point.

Regarding fetishes and boni it makes the combination the difference.
And i dislike if the theme are too similar, but its ok to either rescue only the loved one or build a harem.

>>49902794
Yes, she seems more from basil the mouse detective.
Thx anon forgot to mention it.

>>49901512
>Still looking for the crown on Paladin Princess.
>Still can't find it.
I'm not the only one who can't see it, am I?

File: stationgirls2.png (910KB, 1529x1057px) Image search: [Google]

910KB, 1529x1057px

Stationgirls 2 recap. Plus virtual princess redesign.

>>49904513
I don't recognize the one with sunglasses, who is she?

>>49904550
dogfighter princess

>>49904513
>Tentacle/whatever Princess
>LGG Princess
>That one I can't remember the name of
>Ace princess?
>Crab Princess
>Ranger Princess
>Time Princess
>Mole Princess
>Simian Princess
>Virus Princess
>Redesign of Virtual I don't care for

>>49904513
Gonna throw out some Stationgirls ideas I've had lingering around.

Atlantean Princess - A feather-winged human. Biologically immortal and a wealth of medicinal and philosophical knowledge, but way too fixated on the past.
Blob Princess - A hardy slime whose body develops and then replicates by division when she eats enough, but she has no self-control when it comes to eating.
Blue Princess - A blue-skinned human more or less. Comes from a technologically primitive planet, so she's in awe of Ace and wants to go on adventures with him, but she has no practical training of any sort and often forgets crucial details.
Ka'Telph Princess - Space catgirl/space elf. Comes from a proud warrior and fairly capable on her own, but she's a lousy team player and tends to use force as a universal answer to problems.
Marine Princess - Fully trained and equipped and perhaps the best buddy you could have, but possesses serious anger management issues and extreme xenophobia.
Satellite Princess - Orbital death cannon with humanoid upper body. Excellent reconnaissance, long-range combat and maneuverability, but rendered almost completely helpless outside of 0G environments.
Star Princess - Star-shaped, roughly the size of Critter Princess. Likes to dream big and help others pursue their dreams, but has a terrible sense of scale, physical or otherwise.

Do we have any XCOM related princesses yet? Like an XCOM Princess or an Ethereal Princess? I think an Ethereal would serve well as a boss for StationGirls.

>>49905069
>Not suggesting snek tits

>>49905204
We already have both a Lamia and a Snake Princess

>>49905279
Still better than a human or wrinkled taint-faced alien

>>49905279
We also have 3 Dwarves.

>>49901512
Great Progress

>>49901682
Have some way you would like to improve them?

True, there is a little overlap but I think we are still making some good content.

>>49904513
Nice, good work. If you're redesigning Virtual Princess (Since it seems like Virus Princess is getting her hair) could you give her some hair as well? Bald could be alright but it looks odd on her currently.

>>49904212
Hehe. Keep looking anon, you just need faith.

I'll try to remember to mention to Eversor

>>49895843
Hey Anon, I like your art.

>>49883986
What do you think of giving someone from next Gen a try. Like Buffalo Princess cause she is cute or whoever you feel like.

>>49905295
To be fair, there's not that big of a difference between 1 and 2

>>49905438
Virtual princess is not bald, she has a short '20s haircut.

Can someone add the 2 new tumblr quests, done by Gats and Eversor, to the OP next thread? Seems relevant.
(http://towergirlsquest.tumblr.com/ and http://towergirlschivalryedition.tumblr.com/)

>>49906645
Sure.
-Guy who does the OP

File: MLCPRO.png (50KB, 434x461px) Image search: [Google]

50KB, 434x461px

I was productive

File: Kappa.png (33KB, 434x461px) Image search: [Google]

33KB, 434x461px

Oh and these!

>>49891325
No problem
>>49891585
wow I totally forgot about this joke
>>49892980
unfortunately I do not, but you could potentially put the art in the (fanart) and (OC) sections of the 1d4chan page.
>>49893520
who's cuttlefish supposed to be the companion for again?
>>49893567
Nice.
>>49893594
10/10 would take her for a 'ride'
>>49894029
>>49894083
Speaking of which, should she be a Spaceprincess or a Spacefriend?
>>49895843
This design has my vote.
>>49896260
Speaking of design, would Kappa's lewdlore include anything from the classical Japanese myths?
>>49898493
>>49898588
Nice Brum, but also you terrify me sometimes.
>>49899503
Cool. I'll definitely give it a whirl
>>49901512
Thank you. The archive appreciates your contribution!
>>49904513
Excellent. I'll get my wikiwaqers to prepare outlines for discussion on StationGirls 2
>>49905069
These suggestions would have my vote

>>49906775
well considering thatb extracting lewdlore form folklore would give us a kappa into anal fisting i would prefer we didnt

>>49906804
fair enough

Gen V and Space edition turned out pretty well

>>49906720
Excellent this is way cleaner.

>>49904513
I think that Tendril Princess looked better with the dress. It made her look like she had gotten dressed up and was ready for a fancy party. Plus, having her wear clothes leaves more room for fanart and other works of the imagination.

>>49901866
>I'd disagree that Radiant and Paladin are the same

Would you put a Squid Princess and Octopus Princess in the same table? Would you put mouse and rat in the same one? Sorry, but it's just bad distribution.

>bad criticism
And yet it's completely true. The princesses on this chart all lack clear identities, and the only ones that have cohesive themes don't actually make any sense in the first place.

Whoever made these missed the point of why the first couple charts were good, and just decided that more is always better. Instead of a multitude of all-baked ideas, you need to build up and identify what's appealing about each girl.

Rat would be fine since in fiction rats and mice tend to be very different (mice are cute and demure, rats are trashy and brutish.) The Victorian theme is a nice touch. Problem is that she's not got enough characterization to differentiate her from the mouse. In fact the only thing her profile really talks about is that if you go with her her bothers will be around, which is not a personality trait.

Right now, this chart is basically 8 free slots for anything else because these princesses are just plain not any good.

>>49908425
What about everything else on the card?

File: Tengu.png (29KB, 434x461px) Image search: [Google]

29KB, 434x461px

>>49906720
Forgot to post this too!

>>49908550
Not bad.

>>49908425
This just reads like a bunch of personal taste and nothing more. Maybe this gen isn't for you? Try the next one.

>>49908746
>y...you just don't get it!

>>49908425
I am not quite sure what your specific complaints are. Maybe it would be good to point out some specific parts or give some suggestions on improvements so we get an idea for what you mean.

For example, Mouse and Rat are very different. Mouse is a confident quirky inventor while Rat is a sheltered girl nervous about her first relationship.

>>49908890
This kind of response doesn't help your case that you're not just madposting.

>>49908900
>Dinosaur Princess
No theme beyond "Jurassic Park." No fetish or personality traits. Needs a complete redo.

>Rock Princess
"It's funny because I made a rock pun!"
Again, there's no theme or world building. What's the personality? What fetish is this? What is the justification for this character other than filling a slot?

>Night Elf
The rabbit princess is already the breeding one. How is this different? Plus she's got no real characterization beyond her fetish, whereas the rabbit has the motherly gimmick. You could throw in some spider crap to make her more drow like, but right now she's just filler.

>Redcap
"Art! That's a theme, right?"
Can't be salvaged. Remove.

>Radiant
Absolutely generic "brown girl" with a tanning thing. With a little tweaking she'd be fine, since she's got a theme, except Paladin exists (we'll talk about her in a sec.)

>Water Princess
Apparently somebody felt all 4 elements needed reps, but forgot to give them anything unique or interesting. Needs to be completely remade.

>Bugbear
I guess somebody tried to make a joke here, and it didn't come across. She's the "loving BDSM" princess?

Whatever. Make the writing clearer and she's fine.

>Jotun
There are already princesses with this same personality, and the Dino princess is apparently supposed to be the other Giantess one? Who the fuck knows. I guess we just wanted to tick off all the Monster Manual reps though, so let's throw her in.

>Rat
Mouse.

>Tiki
Island dancer with spooky ghosts. Alright, that one is okay.

>Scylla
Clingy lonely octopus. That's fine, except didn't you just describe Rat as clingy?

>Fireworks
Woah Nelly what the fuck is this. What is the concept here? Who is this supposed to appeal to? Scrap it.

>Wisp
There's already a ghost. "Guidance" isn't really a snappy theme the way "clingy" and "no body" are. You could throw in some "teacher" vibes to cover the same ideas and the "naughty teacher" archetype

cont.

>>49909209
>Rock Princess filling a slot
Because she was created a while back for fun.

>>49909209
>Scrap Fireworks

Fuck off.

>>49909209
>No theme beyond Jurassic Park
No theme for Kobold either, just her liking anal.

>The rabbit is already the breeding one
So we can never have a princess who wants a lot of kids again?

>Can't be salvaged. Remove.
No justification, you mention her theme and then toss it out.

>Generic
Disliking humans doesn't mean they can't go on charts.

>Forgot to make them unique or interesting.
You forgot to criticize Water Princess. You just said "I don't like her, redo her."

>Other princesses have the same personality.
Name them. Beyond that, what's wrong with a giant? There's a ton of them, it's not a check box you fill and then never do again.

>Mouse
Nothing like her.

>Didn't you just describe Rat as clingy?
More than one princess is clingy. A single personality trait is going to repeat.

>Scrap it
Because you don't like it? Again, you just said "I don't like Fireworks."

>There's already a ghost.
So what? You can't have another being in an a huge, worldwide category of beings because ghosts were done before? Why should she be a teacher? That comes out of nowhere, doesn't fit the art at all. Sounds like you wanting a teacher princess and not having the nuts to propose your own design.

>>49909209

>Fudge
Fat is my fetish and this leaves me completely cold. The design of "gooey chocolate slime" doesn't really fit the concept of "greedy hedonist glutton." Also she likes "nibbling" but hates "vore?" If she's afraid of being eaten why even entertain nibbling?

>Paladin Princess
And now we get to Radiant Princess: White Edition. Why are there two "holy" princesses beyond shoving two ideas somebody had in?

If you want Paladin to be a Bible thumper and Radiant to be "tan," fine, go with that. Put all the religion stuff into Paladin and give Radiant, I dunno, a beach or desert theme. Or Japanese if you want to go with sun things.

>Tengu
>trapfags
Not even once.

This gen is a mess.

>>49909295
Because she can recover from nibbling.

>>49909295
>Fat is my fetish
You have shit taste, I guess that explains why you're hating on all the princesses.

>Why are there two holy princesses?
One is a sunlight princess, one is a cleave and smite princess.

>Not even once.
They were in every single generation gats did, so don't whine at us about this.

>>49909250
That's not really a good excuse for her being crap.

>>49909209
Redap is supposed to be the prototypical militant hipster with a little bit of tumblr.
Wisps aren't ghosts in the traditional sense. They're malevolent ions made of spiritual energy that devour souls. They were never dead in the first place.
I don't know what you're talking about in regards to Jotun having an ununique personality. Militant antitheist is pretty unique amongst the religious zealots.

>>49909310
Hey, I have a neat exercise. Propose your own princess. C'mon, write one up.

>>49909260
t.fireworks princess creator

>>49909310
Rude. I don't even like Rock, but I think she should stay.
Also what the other Anon said. If you don't like it, propose a rewrite.

File: 1427038203534.png (197KB, 547x757px) Image search: [Google]

197KB, 547x757px

>>49909209
>>49909281
>>49909295
These are some awful opinions.

>>49909330
>Rude.
He's going out of his way to insult everyone and all the princesses, I think it's just either extreme butthurt or a dedicated trolling effort. I mean, anyone that disagrees with him gets responses like
>>49909328
>>49908890
I don't feel like he has good faith here.

>>49909337
Anon, >>49909281 is COUNTERING the other two posts. I'm telling him off for his 'criticisms'. So don't lump me in with him.

File: 1426143680022.png (28KB, 555x564px) Image search: [Google]

28KB, 555x564px

>>49909351
Whoops sorry didn't mean too

>>49909281
>sure Dinosaur is bad but Kobold is just as bad!
...I will never understand the propensity of some people to try and defend things by insulting other things. How does something else being bad make something good?

As for the ones with nothing to then, if somebody shows you a blank canvas, you can't criticize it beyond telling them to actually put something on the canvas.

Likewise when somebody shits out a shallow useless character with no core ideas, you can't tell them what's wrong with it beyond the fact they there's nothing fucking there.

I'm sure you worked really hard making this chart of all your half-baked waifus, but if you just try a LITTLE harder instead of furiously defending their honor I have no doubt that you can make something actually good. Go back and look at the older gens, and try to understand what people like about them.

>>49909400
>kobold is bad
This is some high level bait

>>49909345
>>49909351
>all criticism is trolling

No wonder you got banned to /trash/

>>49909415
Can you genuinely not read?
>>49909281

>>49909400
I'd rather defend because you don't seem to read half of them and at best glance at the rest before writing them off.

>>49909454
You shouldn't give him (you)s.
This reason this happens every now again is because you guys are way too easy to troll.
Just dismiss his shitty arguments and move on.

File: yea nope.gif (2MB, 500x281px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 500x281px

...this is why Superman works alone.

>>49909470
You understand this is why nobody participates in these threads anymore, right? The fact that any and all criticism gets dismissed as trolling. These threads have gone from a lively community to literal criclejerks.

>>49909400
Why don't you make a princess?

>>49909400
The point is to show your criticism is invalidated by the very first princess. If Kobold doesn't have a solid theme beyond "She's a kobold, this is her personality, she likes it in the ass." then what's wrong with any later princess being the same? Nobody is calling her bad except you.

>>49909209
>Rat
>Mouse

I think this summarizes a problem with your critiquing style. Between the two of those princesses there is hardly any overlap yet you are trying to throw out the new design for what seems to be no reason. You seem to be finding the most generic description you can think of for each princess while being ignorant of any other features that make them unique.

>>49909519
There's a difference between pointing out flaws and "this is shit, redo"
I actually enjoy some of the established character backstory for each of these new princesses. And keep in mind, the charts are only meant to be the bare essentials for something that can anyone can expand upon in their own way.
Plus it's just an expansion. If it doesn't personally satisfy, just move on.

>>49904513
>is finally ginger
>Is a girl
Heh. Staying around this princess too long is probably a bad idea, though it's super fun.

>>49909567
What did I just tell you to do.
>>49909470

>>49909599
People are still in the "maybe he's serious" phase. He put in more effort than our usual trolls.

File: 1461291814274.jpg (45KB, 439x598px) Image search: [Google]

45KB, 439x598px

I go out for a nice meal and come back to this?

>>49909608
kinda this and kinda "maybe if I say something constructive once without any name-calling the bickering will stop"

If it works, great. If not, oh well.

>>49909630
DLC soon

...so how are those cards comin' along? :D

>>49909608
>People are still in the "maybe he's serious" phase
Why?
Anyone who seen his responses should be beyond this phase by now.

>>49909656
I think a freaky horrible parasite princess would fit Station Girls.

>>49909567
>>49909558

When there's nothing on the page, there is nothing that you can offer constructive criticism about. The fundamental groundwork of those character are flawed from the start, and nothing short of completely remaking them can salvage them.

You seem to think it is the responsibility of others to protect your ego when criticizing your work. It is not. When you put something out, you have to be accepting of the fact that sometimes it will not be relieved well; that's part of being an artist.

You also seem to be convinced that I'm some moustache twirling outsider using criticism to smash your sandcastle, when instead I'm pointing out that it's falling apart so you can make it better.

This is the kind of diva behavior that destroys projects.

>>49909658
>>49909608

>criticism is bad and wrong and can never come from a constructive place
>nobody would ever try and help us course correct, because we could never do anything wrong in the first place.

If you have no respect for what you're doing here then please, just admit it. This is the sort of behavior that hurts the entire project.

>>49909683
This many completed lists down the line, your fear is unfounded.

>>49909656
Down to the last three, one of which I think we're just waiting on an updated Companion image for.

Did we ever come to a general consensus on how Gemini Princess was going to be designed?

>>49909754
IIRC the "Companion" was going to be the boy half of our dear Shrodinger's Dick.

>>49909668
sounds neat, though I've kinda gotten the feeling that we aren't really staying focused.
I was more asking about EXP 3.

StationGirls is sounding good though!

>>49909750
Previous charts being good does not mean this one will be. In fact, everything points to the opposite.

>>49909793
All I've seen from you is "She's bad I hate it throw it out." with little to no justification then when people point out how flimsy your arguments are you go "You guys are a circlejerk for ignoring my criticism!"

I don't know why that guy thought he could argue with you. All of us need to agree to just ignore you.

>>49909769
I meant Gemini Princess, proper. Last I recall, there was a dispute on just how much "equipment" she should be toting.

>>49909788
I just want to see how Drake ends up.

>>49909810
Why are you still replying to him then?

>>49909817
Oh, they decided it would be "Female head forefront, has vagina. Male head forefront, has dick. Both heads decide to share equally, has both."

>>49909810
hmm yes good point. We ARE perfect and flawless, and could never do anything wrong.

Le rock joke so funneh! XD

>>49909832
Warning signal "Hey guys stop talking to him."

>>49909817
Well in all honesty if she's half-trap then I think the second rack has to go since, y'know, traps tend not to have boobs.
It kinda looked off anyway

>>49909919
Cute

>>49909810
>All I've seen from you is "She's bad I hate it throw it out."
Actually, he said many things other than that, but the people attacking his arguments tend to rewrite them into simplistic soundbites while ignoring the parts they can't trivialize.

>>49910106
>He
>His
Bro nobody is buying it.

>>49910123
It's so obvious I don't know why he's even trying.

We good with what we have on the spreadsheet for the remaining Princesses and ready to pick up brainstorming the rest of the Companion chart?

>>49910255
NO, OBVIOUSLY WE NEED TO MAKE THIRTEEN MORE PANDA DRAFTS AND MAKE A NEW REANIMATED PRINCESS

...yeah I think we good

>>49910123
Anyone can look at >>49909209 and >>49909295 and see that there were many points of critique made which aren't covered by "YOU JUST DON"T LIKE IT", or look at >>49909281 and see that most of the responses were either just that or a similarly extreme strawman. If you want to respond to criticism, respond to criticism.

>>49910255
No, but we're going into defensive siege mode so I don't think we'll be able to get much discussion done unless you want to wait for things to cool down.

>>49910255
Yeah mostly.

Someone posted two courtiers last week, did anyone save them? They had art.

>>49910123
>only one person would dare criticize me
"No."

Anyone else think this is the same guy as yesterday who came in to whine about how 'gay' we were and how we should go to /qst/?

>>49910371
No, but I bet there are lots of people who'd LIKE to think so.

>>49910345
>"defensive siege mode"

It is absolutely pathetic that anything opposing the hivemind triggers this kind of reaction.

>>49910371
Really? You're doing this? Making everybody you disagree with into a fucking boogeyman?

Imma check for details in a bit, but do we have a general list of companion names for this gen so far?

>>49910394
The only one I know we actually have a full fleshed out idea for is Maid Courtier.

File: Courtiers.png (202KB, 1000x500px) Image search: [Google]

202KB, 1000x500px

>>49910348
I don't think I have the most up-to-date art/card for Kabuki, but were these the two?

>>49910427
Oh yeah, forgot about Kabuki

>>49910427
Yes I believe so. It's 4 for each category of general/courtier/master/beast right? So that's 2 left for courtiers unless anyone else remembers other designs posted in thread.

I did a few companions, no art

Scribe Master
Alchemist Courtier
Aurumvorax Beast
Goblin General

>>49910457
>Aurumvorax Beast
what

Wait, I forgot. I think I read for an idea to move Sugarloaf over to the new companions from the treasures in order to fix formatting issues?

File: w h y.jpg (3KB, 124x87px) Image search: [Google]

3KB, 124x87px

>>49909209
He's right you know. This gen look pretty lame and lacking identity all around.

File: Aurumvorax-BrynnMetheney.jpg (303KB, 800x593px) Image search: [Google]

303KB, 800x593px

>>49910461
A six legged badger with literal gold fur

File: Screenshot (28).png (77KB, 282x785px) Image search: [Google]

77KB, 282x785px

Damn who knew people would actually be able to make money off of towergirls.
Has anyone here actually tried his game to see if it's any good?

He's samefagging really fucking hard for them (you)s

>>49910465
I heard that. Was that decided upon?

>>49910483
I remember it starting off with human getting fucked by goblins so I said fuck off to that game.

>>49910485
What, >>49910471 ?

Nah, that's me but I see where his post of >>49909736 came from.

Really shit, desu

>>49910483
Well they need to pay for that high quality Theboogie art.

>>49910493
I'd be behind the idea and I think Photo was, but I don't think there was a unanimous agreement on the thread. Then again it wasn't really picked up by anyone for discussion when it was mentioned.

File: Screenshot (29).png (53KB, 301x707px) Image search: [Google]

53KB, 301x707px

>>49910483
Shame dukes doesn't get anywhere near that much.

>>49910493
>I remember it starting off with human getting fucked by goblins
What?
No it doesn't.
Nothing like that ever happens.

>>49910471
Honestly, I'd be more inclined to believe he's not baiting if his few actual criticisms weren't surrounded by stupid bullshit

File: Monster Girl Island.png (298KB, 738x414px) Image search: [Google]

298KB, 738x414px

>>49910514
We should get the Monster Girl Island group to do some Towergirls stuff I can dream. Some 3D Towergirl waifu action would be awesome.

The Monster Girl Island demos were the tits

>>49910485
Just don't even acknowledge their existence or it just gives him more reason to post.

>>49910534
In the version with the old art it does. You walk in on human princess drunk and getting spitroasted by goblins/orcs.

>>49910385
Anon, there's a reason the mods kicked them out to /trash/ at one point

>>49910547
Your thinking of a different game cause theres no such thing.

>>49910564
Dude, go back and play it.

>>49910427
[x] MOLEST THE MAID

Also, Kabuki is a great design, but the art is...lacking. No offense to whoever made it, but it needs a bit of updating to match the art of everything else.

>>49910569
No you link what you're talking about.
Burden of proof is on you.

>>49910579
MO at this point is basically to have Eversor go over all the lines, at the least, even if the art is competent. So I don't doubt he'll get slightly redesigned.

>>49910579
IIRC, Maid was made and drawn by Photo

>>49910579
I think the idea is that it's like an old Japanese charcoal drawing.
While that's neat, I agree that it should probably be modernized to TG style

>>49910478
>six-legged
>Clearly eight legs

Still, that thing is fucking scary. Give its Towergirls version a Honey Badger look, and it's 10/10

>>49910545
The models look nice, but I'm worried that the animations aren't good. I've neverseen good monstergirl 3D, and this looks nice, but I'm cautiously negative.

>>49910544
Thing is, there's a difference between suggestions as things are being made which we do plenty of, and 'I don't like/get more than half of them, tear it down and start over' this close to completion of another list.

>>49910618
Aurum Badger don't give a fuck!

>>49910582
Alright. Here's the specific scene for Human:

https://towerkc.blogspot.com/2016/02/adult-preview.html#comment-form

Here's a blogpost talking about how he wants the princesses to cheat on you and fuck monsters (with a pic of slime with an orc):

https://towerkc.blogspot.com/2016/01/hey-guys.html#comment-form

>>49910673
>NTR
Yep, that turned me off from that game. That's the worst fetish, tied with scat.

>>49910725
Agreed. No idea why he thought to force that kinda crap into a game that's supposed to be about waifus.

>>49910725
Cuck is pretty bad, though scat is way worse imo.
Though that's just me

File: Its not like I wanted to save you, baka-xeno.png (1MB, 1400x785px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 1400x785px

>>49904513
Anyone else think we could add at least 1 new Station Girl princess based off of a Xeno race from Xenoblade Chronicles X

>>49910618
I knew someone would say that

The demos seem well made to me, I'm hopeful

>>49910673
That sounds like an awful mechanic.

Unless you made it so only a conscious effort on your part would set their devotion that low.

>>49910756
sure, looks like a cutebold.

>>49910731
Well, to be fair, they're both legit fetishes. Everyone is entitled to their own interests, obviously, but when something is that niche, it's a bit of a deterrent for folks with more normal deviant tastes. Most princesses are pretty much pure versions of some kind of fetish, often more than one, but when another fetish is introduced that doesn't really fit the mold, it's jarring.

I mean, Kobold and Slime are the two I'd never expect to even delve into NTR, out of the bunch.

>>49910779
It's basically a bunch of awful mechanics tied together by him offering money to good artists and people not knowing about how bad he's gonna make the fetishes. Like Breeding Season, basically. Hopefully it falls apart like that did too.

File: 1451326567301.jpg (33KB, 389x395px) Image search: [Google]

33KB, 389x395px

>>49910803
Nah man. It's always over the line. Nobody who likes it isn't scum, and the way they keep forcing it in out of the blue where it doesn't belong (here and elsewhere) just makes them the lowest of the low. At least scatfags almost always keep their shit to themselves, so to speak.

Now, I'll admit I don't know if any of this is planned or in the current version, because I haven't played it due to this crap in the earlier versions. So maybe someone slapped some sense into him.

>>49910471
I'd say that if the gen is split in half, with the really good princesses kept and the middling ones saved until they're fixed, and we just get a bunch of new princesses to fill out the current gen it'd be a lot better.

There's promise but a lot of the ideas just flat out aren't there yet.

>>49910725
>>49910731
>>49910754
>>49910779
>>49910805
None of that stuff is actually in the game currently and even the first event is not "walking in on human princess drunk and getting spitroasted by goblins/orcs".
Just your standard princess get captured by monsters and you come in to save her in the knick of time kind of thing.
She doesn't get fucked.

>>49910855
i was thinking of taking the various princesses through a round of refining one at a time putting them through the thread to polish and improve them (ignoring calls for big overhauls and cutting unliked fetishes) basicly improving the wording and working to squeeze a bit more personality and character out of each profile, does that seem like something the rest of you would be behind?

>>49910544
>>49910632
>I'd be inclined to agree if it didn't disagree with me

>>49910901
Cheesecake, please don't reply. It's the shitposter samefagging about how all the princesses are terrible and need to be replaced (for unspecific reasons and by other people of course)

>>49910901
No, because you're capitulating to a troll.

>>49910546
>ignore all criticism
>the only correct opinion is mine

good idea desu

>>49910875
>She doesn't get fucked.
She's naked and bent over with an orc flush against her crotch and her face jammed into another's lap. Pretty sure her holes are filled right now in that screenshot.

>None of that stuff is in the game
See >>49910854

I don't know what's in there currently because of what was in the past.

>Currently
But this is a problem. If that feature is still planned, then the complaints are still valid.

>>49910549
I can definitely see that.

At this point it's not even about the CYOA anymore for some of you. It's just a way to mass produce bland waifus. Have you completely forgotten the purpose of this whole endeavour? Or have all the people with the good ideas just abandoned the project?

>>49910673
Oh man let me tell you as an actual cuck that scene was a huge cocktease.
Unfortunately theres 2 scenes neither of which she gets raped in.
First one where you come and just kill the orcs and the second where you can hang back and watch but all that happens is knight princess cames in to save her instead.
Honestly I feel like he was deliberately trolling cucks with that shit.
I was so hopeful.

File: 1476857949489.jpg (86KB, 460x391px) Image search: [Google]

86KB, 460x391px

>>49910969
>as an actual cuck

>>49910912
>I'm going to ignore all criticism and white knight because I can't stand the idea of anyone opposing my circle jerk

It definitely can't be that there are real problems with what you're doing, right?

>>49910901
I mean, it's pretty obvious what he's doing here, you see the same replies going on and on saying the same things, whining about the same topics, all agreeing with each other while others are talking about other things. And you think he's being legitimate?

>>49910922
>>49910912
i mean its something i had been discussing with ever already so i felt it was worth bringing up

>>49911006
Worst timing, dude. Wait until he's banned at the least.

>>49911002
thats true enough

>>49910944
>She's naked and bent over with an orc flush against her crotch and her face jammed into another's lap
Thats only because it was before he had custom sprites so he had to use the default ones as placeholders.
The text in the event makes it a lot more clear.
>what was in the past
Except the stuff that was in the past wasn't what you thought it was.
>If that feature is still planned
If you're talking about the second thing I don't see how it could be consider he's long since transitioned to real time combat.

>>49911006
I personally think everything looks fine. If anything, their stories are more distinct than some of the OG princesses

File: Naza the Prone.jpg (118KB, 638x443px) Image search: [Google]

118KB, 638x443px

>>49910790
In the game, they are essentially a race of NEETs. You help rescue a large group of them and give them a place to park their spaceship until they can repair it. In return, they use their ridiculously advanced technology to make new weapons, armor, generators, and other things for New Las Angeles.

They tend to be lazy, develop addictive personalities and habits, and can be pretty autistic. They are also very physically weak, and as such they never really had interest in making weapons and armor until you ask them to and make an alliance with them.

Also the weapons and armor they make for you are weeb as fuck, mainly due to being introduced to human animated cartoons and pizza.

They are but one of the many Xeno species you encounter in the game, along with spess nekos, shapeshifting assassin amazons, some squid people, short cottonball jews, silicon based living robo Hassan expies, wierd semi-hivemind bug vulcans who reproduce using a specific liquid made with a viral cocktail, a race of large jawless NotOrcs wo are divided between two ethnicities who hate eachother (one of which is pic related), and of course spess elves with crystalline hair and skin.

Granted I'm over simplifying it, but trust me when I say that the races are actually kinda fun and interesting to interact with through the various missions ingame

>>49911026
Look, we're going to have to see if he tries to bring back monster rape. I'm not convince he abandoned the idea.

>>49910901
That would definitely help, absolutely.

The biggest problem though is that there's no real strong groundwork for this gen. Some of the underdeveloped ones need to be saved for later and replaced with some more traditional monstergirls to bolster the ranks. Everything's just too unfocused right now.

>>49911041
He never implemented the idea in the first place you dunce.

>>49911055
But he was planning it, is the thing. That means it's something he wanted.

File: 0e3.png (187KB, 600x339px) Image search: [Google]

187KB, 600x339px

>>49911036
>Nerdy Alien Cutebolds

>>49911074
No he wasn't.
Do you lack reading comprehension?
Did you ignore everything I just told you?
Monster rape never something he planned to implement.
In fact judging from this post >>49910969 he was trolling people who did want it.

>>49911002
>you see replies agreeing that there's something wrong
>therefore it's only one person, because there's no way multiple people would agree

...

>>49911106
Did you read the second blogpost I linked you to?

>>49911081
I'm gonna have to warn you though. Ma-non (that is their race), despite being somehwat long lived are not very fertile. Nor does their culture put any emphasis on child rearing. To them, reproduction is usually seen and an occasional chore to attend to when their population levels decrease. You never see child Ma-non in game because they are all raised and educated communally in nurseries back on their home planets, so they never make it on a ship until they are full-fledged adults.

Now, if you want a REAL woman, you get yourself a nice Tree Clan Prone or a focused and nervous Wrothian girl.

>>49911136
What he's proposing isn't monster rape.

>>49911144
That's just being nitpicky. It's still the girls cheating on you to fuck monsters.

>>49911150
Again as I said that was back when the game had turn based combat so the princesses having sexual attacks makes sense but that doesn't make sense with real time combat So theres no chance of it ever being implemented.

>>49911143
>Cute, Nerdy, 0 Lust, Cutebold
I'm STILL okay with this. Not all princesses need to be for fug.

>>49911204
They're all going to be fugged tho

>>49911195
Again, because he had that planned, I don't trust him anymore. So I'm going to have to wait and see if he tries any kind of similar concept (anyone that's played VH knows how it can work.)

>>49910632
But he did post some actual, specific criticism. Looking back at it, the exact point where conversation broke down was when someone chose to attack his points rather than respond to them, though there were bad signs before that, such as the one person who tried to use the false dichotomy.

If anything, what's warranted is a proper response to his points, and since no one else is trying...

>>49909209
>Dinosaur Princess
She does have a personality. It's described pretty well on the card. As for her "theme", I think that "ancient dinosaurs" are enought of one.

>Rock Princess
Okay, yeah, there's not much there besides a bunch of rock jokes.

>Night Elf Princess
She's not the first pregnancy fetishist, but she's still her own character. If you took away the "breeder" aspect she'd still be distinctive, and if you compared her to another breeder (like, say, Rabbit Princess), it wouldn't be hard to tell them apart.

>Redcap Princess
Painting does qualify as a theme, yes. And she also has her own personality too.

>Radiant Princess
Yeah she's a pretty plain execution of the "holy sun warrior" concept; if there is a personality there, it seems to be vaguely alluding to it at most.

>Water Princess
Any ideas on how to make her "unique or interesting"?

>Jotun
I'm not seeing this redundancy. Yeah, there are other huge princesses, but she's not just a copy of them.

>Rat
She's quite a different character from Mouse Princess.

>Firework Princess
Irrational enthusiasm is her thing. That's enough of a thing to me.

>Wisp
Okay, yeah, she looks pretty bare-bones.

>Fudge Princess
If you don't like the way she does the feeder fetish thing, then how would you prefer it? Though I see your point about the vore; maybe she could like "licking" instead of biting.

>Paladin Princess
This time I see what you mean about redundancy, though she could be distinguished from Radiant Princess while keeping them both "religious".

>Tengu
Personal taste.

>>49911324
>But he did post some actual, specific criticism.
If you're not him, then you're going out of your way to defend a guy who accidentally made points while saying "It's shit and I hate it." to most princesses and keeps demanding they all get tossed out and replaced with monstergirls. And he responds to people that disagree with greentext mockery. You're basically trying your hardest to discount the community for the sake of this one hostile asshole.

I dunno why, but I like when threads get like this.
Like pretty shitted up, but yielding discussion that could be beneficial in the process.

>>49911431
I'm not seeing anything beneficial. Even that idealistic optimist above doesn't even agree with the asshole, he just refuses to acknowledge that maybe he was being an asshole and doesn't mean well.

Would /tg/ a Lagann Princess? Like, a princess representing everything about Gurren Lagann? small kingdom, but they control mechs. I'll do some Art if there's enough interest.

>>49911431
pretty sure that's 4chan in a nutshell
>ayooo

>>49911449
>he just refuses to acknowledge that maybe he was being an asshole and doesn't mean well.
this

>>49911324
I appreciate you trying to get some civil discussion on actual details of the Princesses themselves.

>Rock / Water
Yeah, I think these are the oldest designs on the chart and probably the best examples of lacking personality. Some touch up could help. To be fair though Water Princess does have the whole temperature thing and cold personality to help her out some.

>Wisp
No love for Wisp waifu. She has a couple personality +/-s, which part is leading her to be bare-bones?

Rest of your points seem good.

>>49911451
If you can execute it well, it might work.

>>49911451
Why not just make a mecha princess?

>>49911451
Draw it up; the more the merrier.

>>49911471
I love Wisp personally. She seems sweet. A lot of people think the only personalities are overbearing and abrasive ones.

>>49911451
I mean Bro Courtier is already a TTGL ref, but like others have been saying, think up a card and/or a design and we'd all love to see it.

Don't worry everyone, if there needs to be touch-ups, Spreadsheet Princess will always be there:
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/12IcT_vwIHKAMz-ghvB3fgHTr7DkHvjrbu4Hzlw4XCIU/

#BestPrincess

>>49911451
Yoko would be a good cameo and if you can get the giant mech concept to work that could be a stationgirl.

>>49911483
Thanks

>>49911504
Spreadsheet Princess is Tower Princess tier levels

>>49911504
Update?

>>49911403
His hostility was a response to people who refused to respond to his points his points, instead choosing to insult him while trying to ignore and deny the fact that he was making any. That doesn't justify the points themselves, or the "I'm not responsible for the tone of my own posts" nonsense, but you can't exactly call someone a troll for not holding a constructive discussion, when they've already attempted to do so and only got "YOU'RE A TROLL!" in response.

>>49911549
senpai that just sounds like a bunch of naivety to me. Nobody else was responding to themselves and trying to force an issue like him, and his criticisms really were largely bunk. Even if you don't want to admit it, your own post basically concluded the same as the other replies, just in a nicer way. You gotta accept that sometimes people are just assholes.

>>49911574
I'm honestly starting to believe it's just him samefagging again but just trying a different tactic to stir shit.
At least we know his post style so we'll know if it's him when he replies to this.

>>49911044
I legitimately believe this post to either be a false-flag or a samefag. I can't decide which, but I'm leaning towards the former.

>>49911690
>Traditional monstergirls
>Saved for later (referencing that other post about tossing half of 'em out)
It does fit, considering his arguments are mostly about taste.

The fuck kind of monstergirl does he even want? I'd believe him more if he told us WHAT HE ACTUALLY WANTS. The only fetishes of his I can spy is fat and teachers, but no coherent proposals or even a type of monstergirl.

>>49911574
You're just assuming the worst. The fact that people were shouting him down while strawmanning and ignoring his points is simply not justifiable, and people tried to shout down anyone who did otherwise because "it must be the BAD GUY in disguise". Even now, people are still trying to push the narrative that "he just doesn't like it, and anyone who says otherwise is the same person". Even if he did have secret sinister motives that people like to assume, all that's proven is that going into total war mode will stop rational discussion before it starts.

>>49911324
>Water Princess

Scylla already has a shipwreck thing, so you can't do that. The "cold" thing fits an ice character better, and just feels like padding to flesh out a character with no ideas behind her. In fact, the "heat" and "Freezing Lake" thing make it clear that she's SUPPOSED to be an ice character instead of a water one. Likewise, the amorphous thing is done better with a slime character.

If you absolutely must have a water elemental, you could give her some kind of Aquarius elements, like having her carry a pot or amphora, or have a pot crown or something (like how some cultures balance pots on their heads.) That'd at least give her some visual interest. Or go all-in with the ice elements and give her ice elements, like an ice headdress or something.

If you want to play with the amorphous thing and the "cold personality" thing, you could say someting about her sometimes being icy, hard and uptight but flowy and liquid when she's relaxed. Have her have a tsundere ice queen personality or something.

There's just so many different directions you could take her, and she is in desperate need of some kind of gimmick or "hook" to make her interesting, both visually and as a character.

Also "Unusual pen" makes no sense as her fetish.

Let's just stop and move on.
While there are admittedly some weaker princesses that might need a quick look-over
>coughrockcough
bickering isn't solving anything either.
New slate, moving on

>>49911751
Move on to what?

>>49911690
Yes definitely, any kind of wrongthink must be those evil outsiders

>>49911638
Ha, he proved your point.

>>49911758
If you weren't an outsider you'd have been here when these were being made and arranged. It's only been going on for several weeks. You'd have been here at least once.

>>49911483
>>49911471

What is Wisp's personality? What does Wisp Princess do? All the card says is that she guides people. Right now half of her card references the moths instead of her, and if thr Moths are the interesting part of her then why not just have Moth Princesses instead?

>>49911755
just discussing the princesses instead of arguing over whether troll or not

>>49911744
I feel design-wise there's enough to work off of (or at least no less than the OG girls) though I do agree that maybe we should step back a bit from the whole "cold" thing and lean more towards water aspects than ice.

>>49911758
>>49911765
HEY, *hsst* bad forum. NO fighting.

>>49911765
Yep same word choice and tone as always.
I knew it.

>>49911814
Yeah we already have a Moth Princess, so maybe a bit more Wisp aspects are in order

File: image.jpg (64KB, 500x534px) Image search: [Google]

64KB, 500x534px

>>49911574
>Nobody else was responding to themselves and trying to force an issue like him

you really think that only one person would dare disagree with you? That all your problems are due to one person and if you just root out that evil meanie everything will be perfect?

>>49901512
>>49911839
>Provides wise guidance
>Wants to see you succeed
>offended when ignored
That's a personality.

The only thing about moths on her card are the companions and the bonuses. I can see you complaining that one of the bonuses isn't directly from her, because that's how Gen 3 cards work, 1 for the companion 1 for the princess. But otherwise her card is actually about her.

>>49911844
Considering nobody was bitching and trolling before you came here that is actually fairly likely.

>>49911726
You're convinced that the issue is that somebody is trying to change your precious chart to suit themselves, when the issue is that the chart just doesn't work in its current form.

>>49911044

When he said to save half of them for later, he specifically said it was because the current gen is an unfocused mess, and dumping so many princesses without strong concepts behind them makes it worse.

>>49911872
Maybe reword the wealth bonus a bit?
"The Wisps' ethereal glow gives you a deep restful sleep each night"

>>49911814
She's the mirror opposite of Moth Princess in the standard Gen III.

>>49911751
All of them.

>>49911893
>He
Stop trying this nonsense.

And you are, considering most of your complaints are "I don't like thing." and your only suggestion is "Toss half of them out and replace them with undefined traditional monstergirls."

>>49911899
Yes, yes, maybe. Look, you're not gonna get anything constructive while >>49911910 is here. Look for posts that might get him banned and hope a mod stops by.

>>49911921
...yeah I should probably leave and wait for things to die down a bit (hopefully)

see y'all tomorrow <3

>>49911921
Aaand now you're begging for the mods to delete dissenting opinions.

You realize there's no global rule against disagreeing with you, right?

>>49911881
>>49911911
Stop replying to posts you think are him.

>>49911765
There was no point to prove. Unless you mean the point that constant cries of "TROLL1 TROLL! TROLL!" are a larger detriment to discussion than the actual points they're trying to lie about.

>>49911921
You can clearly spot the exact point where discussion broke down. It was the posts directly after the alleged "troll", which falsely claimed that he made no points and demanded that people shout him down rather than respond to him in any way.

>>49911951
It's hard not to when people like Cheesecake keep getting hooked. It's easy to ignore him when he's on his own, but then one of our own gullible members fall for it you kinda have to counter him just to keep them from thinking it's actually a widely supported opinion.

>>49911951
Infact just assume anyone who agrees with him is just him samefagging

>>49911954
>he's still trying

Keep fucking trolling, I dare you.

>>49911966
Bitch at Cc then.
Stop giving the shitty troll (you)s.

>>49911979
You don't sound like the people arguing against him earlier.

You sound like a falseflag.

>>49911966
Cheesecake is an idiot.

>>49911988
Post timers certainly make it possible.

>>49911969
>Infact just assume anyone who agrees with him is just him samefagging
Even the ones who post objective, verifiable facts in response to lies that contradict them?

>>49911969
This. We know what the real fans think, so just assume anybody saying otherwise is the shitposter. We're beyond the point where we need suggestions.

>>49911921
>Look for posts that might get him banned
This one >>49909843 has ironic shitposting that should get him banned.

>>49912015
Interesting theory.

Alternative: The people who make legitimate points and discuss them are the "true" fans. The people crying for blood against the "trolls" and "shitposters" while demanding that everyone shut down all discussion, and falsely claiming that it isn't taking place even when it clearly is, are trying to shut down discussion.

>>49912038
>he's still samefagging

>>49912038
>The people crying demanding that everyone shut down all discussion are trying to shut down discussion.

I don't buy it. You sure you aren't the troll?

I bet you're the troll. You didn't agree with me. MOOOOOOOOOOOOOODS

So I guess this was his plan, then?

I think we should head on to the new thread >>49912107

>>49912117
This was really stupid. They can migrate too, you know.

>>49912104
To falseflag the opposition so he can troll more, yeah. You see it a lot in the jumpchain thread from their shitposter.

>>49912104
What, to offer criticism and have thin-skinned babies tear themselves apart pointing fingers and calling everyone names instead of acknowledging that there is a problem?

Yeah, that was definitely it.

>>49912137
Did you not notice we hit bump limit?

>>49912147
Things were civil until he showed up.

>>49912166
That is him you idiot

>>49912161
Yeah but we're at page 5, we got like two hours to go in this one.

>>49912174
And you just replied to him again, retard.