What's the /tg/ opinion on Re:Monster and Tensei Shitara

There've been a number of RE: quests here (though they're all more or less dead or dormant right now), and they were fairly popular.

http://suptg.thisisnotatrueending.com/archive.html?tags=Re-Monster
http://suptg.thisisnotatrueending.com/archive.html?tags=RE:%20Monster

The general perception I've seen of them is that it's an interesting idea but RE: is horrifyingly bad due to the MC being a Mary Sue and the whole goblin rape camp thing.

No, no, rape would be too... boring. They used Aphrodisiacs to coerce elves. Totally doesn't propagate Slut-Elves, amiright?

Yeah, in all seriousness it's more interesting as a concept than an actual story. Tensei Shitara seems to almost go the same route, but the character may be slightly more fallible.

Re:Monster looks like stupid shit for reasons like >>48741716 explained.

>>48741476
RE: Monster is absolute garbage, though the premise spawned some quests here. Ironically, the authors of those quests universally agree that the source material is terrible.

>>48741476

Re:Monster as a story ---> https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5gpiq_DNWGo

As a setting it's alright and a fun playground to play and write in.

Don't know enough about the slime one to have an opinion on it.

>>48741476
Re and slime concept are decent. The story themselves are shit.

>>48741476
started out kind of interesting then turned into harem mary sue shit real fast.

>>48743702
>started out kind of interesting then turned into harem mary sue shit real fast.

I don't get why people read light novels when they don't like harem mary sue shit. It's like reading trashy romance novels and hoping for a decent story.

More like REEEEEEEEEEE: Monster amirite

>>48746009
fair enough. i just didn't expect it to be at the level it is. and i like to keep my harem shit in /h/ personally.