So you've got Gondor's soldiers or Saruman's Uruk

>>47997297
Do what better?

The one that knows best how to use their weapons in conjunction with their brothers at arms. A variety of weapons means nothing if the army isn't organized. It might give an advantage in unpredictability, but that's about it.

>>47997337
Fight wars

>>47997348
That's not always true you need to remember logistics the uruks don't need supply lines cos they are killing machines the humans need supply lines badly and the orcs scavenge fucking everything so they are really an autonomous military force.

>>47997359
See my other post it just depends
>>47997359

>>47997387
The Uruks turned to cannibalism when the rations ran out.

Even Sauron required lines of supply, the book mentions vast slave fields offscreen that fed Mordors armies.

>>47997297
Depends on who has better training and experience, honestly.

>>47997405
Like give me an example

>>47997419
But the uruks can go for a longer period before falling to disassembly compared to humans .

>>47997387
I'm not saying scavenging for their weapons is a disadvantage in terms of supply. I'm just saying an army that has uniform weapons and the tactics to use them will be better in terms of effectiveness.

>>47997359
>Fight wars

Not every war is the same. There are a lot of different kinds of wars, where different things might be more or less important.

>>47997587
>Op can't into Art of War
>Recognizing dat terrain
>Following the shih

>>47997297
The Uruk Hai were indeed, one on one, better than Sauron's orcs. Hence why the fellowship was so surprised that they were running around during the day, and other shit that Mordor orcs weren't capable of.
An Uruk Hai (Or a soldier of Gondor) was worth 10 Mordor orcs, but the problem was there were 11 orcs.