[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / bant / biz / c / can / cgl / ck / cm / co / cock / d / diy / e / fa / fap / fit / fitlit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mlpol / mo / mtv / mu / n / news / o / out / outsoc / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / spa / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vint / vip / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Search | Free Show | Home]

Jumpchain CYOA Thread #769: Gun To A Knife Fight Edition

This is a blue board which means that it's for everybody (Safe For Work content only). If you see any adult content, please report it.

Thread replies: 468
Thread images: 51

File: 1459611948104.pdf (1B, 486x500px)
1459611948104.pdf
1B, 486x500px
>Google Drive
https://drive.google.com/folderview?id=0B20r6rsFLOg_Zk5RdVdya3hJNnc&usp=sharing

>Jumpchain IRC Chat
http://client00.chat.mibbit.com/?server=rizon.mibbit.org&channel=%23JumpchainCYOA

https://kiwiirc.com/client/irc.rizon.net/?#JumpchainCYOA

>Rules
http://pastebin.com/Gqj3iKyn

>How to Jumpchain
https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B1qb0_OLhDrDNjZmRG02SDFaRVk/view

>Last Thread
>>46413316
>>
File: 656a6a77de076409a8f0a7f9f18758d7.png (635KB, 1000x1412px) Image search: [Google]
656a6a77de076409a8f0a7f9f18758d7.png
635KB, 1000x1412px
Insomnia is never a good thing, except when it is.
>>
>>46428633
It's not insomnia if your sleeping patterns are screwed already.
>>
Questions to YJ Anon for Fallout 4.

-Any difference between SCIENCE! and regular Fallout's Certified Tech
-Can one import a companion into one of the other options, e.g. Behemoth, Deathclaw, etc, or are those default New Companions.
-The mention of a detective in the perk 'Mysterious Stranger,' is that meant to be a plot hook for Valentine or just flavor?
-If one buys Super Mutant as a race, can they eventually grow to reach Behemoth status?
-If I gave Harold's tree-body mobility, essentially making him an ent-ghoul, and went with his quest's ending of 'help spread plantlife and the Oasis throughout the rest of the Wasteland, how do you imagine he'd show up in the Commonwealth?
>>
>>46428733
I am not YJ annon but... How did you give Harold mobility? His heart and Internal Organs were deep underground. I am not saying you couldn't have done it but I am just very curious how?
>>
>>46428682
Can confirm.

Well, while I'm here, I'd like to hear some opinions on how to handle something in the X-Men jump. I was thinking of having a separate pool of points for purchasing powers, sort of like Manyfist did in the Arrowverse jump. However, I don't know if I should just hand someone free points or make them purchase an perk that gives them points for purchasing points.

On the one hand, I feel uncomfortable just handing someone free powers, but on the other, it also feels wrong to make people pay extra points to be able to buy powers - after all, I doubt most people will go to an X-Men jump and not be a mutant.

So, what do you guys think? Should I just scrap that idea altogether and make it so the powers just cost CP?
>>
File: 41e6d4321a244579235087ac48d024a7.png (935KB, 1000x1576px) Image search: [Google]
41e6d4321a244579235087ac48d024a7.png
935KB, 1000x1576px
>>46428682
I can't argue with that logic.

>>46428921
I don't think a separate pool of points for purchasing powers is necessarily a bad idea. I did something similar with my Ring of Red Jump and building Mecha.

The trick seems to be making one of the backgrounds linked to that power pool. For Example:

Background: Mutant (300 CP), gets Mutant Powers for Free

Perk: Mutant Powers (600 CP or free with Mutant Background) - Gives 600 Mutant Power Points.

That sort of thing. You could even offer it as a discount to Drop-Ins so no one feels railroaded.
>>
>>46428921
I'd say free, given that it's an X-men jump, with a powerless/non-mutant drawback. Continuing on this, I think a design like Arrowverse or Young Justice would work just fine, and that you shouldn't concern yourself too much with it. Up to you, though.
>>
>>46428921
I think it depends how much other stuff/regular perks and gear you are going to have.
Are you expecting that a jumper will want a selection of perks/gear _plus_ a power, or potentially have a jumper dump all their cp on one really awesome power and maybe one or two perks.
>>
>>46428907
Careful psyker-biomancy and copious use of the Geneforge and essence (carefully applied to avoid fucking up his already nutty brain) to shift his organs back up into his and Bob's 'trunk', followed by the injection and control of Imaginos to, along with Wood Release from Naruto, grant the tree a vague set of limbs (which the nanomachines shaped over time to be more dextrous). After that it was hooking up control of the limbs to Harold's... what remained of his CNS.
>>
>>46428921
Right now, I think a better idea would be to either give a certain amount of cp off of the first power you buy, or give a certain amount of cp that can only be spent on powers. There's no real need to set up a separate thing for powers, unless you want to use an alternate point system to balance powers against each other and cp-purchases, such as by giving out a certain amount of points and then making it expensive to purchase more.

However, this is based on the idea that the major focus of the jump with be on mutant abilities. If you can focus attention away from powers and towards perks and items, it would possibly be better as a subsystem with alternate point costs.
>>
>>46428921
What I would suggest is give everyone a certain amount of free CP to purchase powers from the power section
. I think you are right. This is an X men jump everyone is likely to be a mutant. While there are mutants who don't have powers or have incredibly weak meaningless powers that is more a drawback than an option.
>>
>>46428921
>points for purchasing points
Powers. For purchasing powers. Damn, I guess I really should be asleep now.

>>46428992
I hadn't considered that. Doesn't really fit with my original plans, but I do see ways they could fit together.

>>46429085
I don't really know. My standard format for perks is 100-200-400-600, so I'll probably have that and a similar one for items.

>>46429142
>>46429159
Actually, I kind of like this idea. I could give everyone enough points to get a decent power or a couple weaker ones for free, and if they want more or the stronger ones, they can pay for them.
>>
>>46428733
Certified Tech seems to be more slanted towards pre-war tech, while SCIENCE! is for Institute technology.

Default new companions.

Just Flavor.

Yes, given maybe a century or so.

I'm not sure; the ending of that quest seemed to imply that Harold wasn't growing individual trees, but one massive organism that was his body. You might give him his mobility back, only to kill off the rest of his body.
>>
Okay, I am probably retarded. I am completely failing to understand how Side Evolutions in general and the Spirit Warrior Items in the Digimon jump work.

Are the following digivolution lines actually valid? The first is my Digi-Spirits line, the second is for my digimon partner. I assume all Side Evolution purchases are discounted for Drop-In, and that they still get a free partner.

Duskmon > Velgrmon or Mephismon. Velgrmon > Gulfmon or Grand Dracumon. Mephismon > Belphemon: Rage Mode, Gran Kuwagamon, or Metal Seadramon.

Tsubumon > Upamon > Armadimon > Ankylomon > Cyberdramon or Skull Greymon. Cyberdramon > Zeed Millenniumon. Skull Greymon > Millenniumon.

Am I edgy? I feel edgy.
>>
>>46429234
Well, SCIENCE! also allows you to make a few pre-war things, but the focus is mainly on Institute technology. Forgot to mention that.
>>
File: Edg, Edge, and Edgy.jpg (78KB, 500x375px) Image search: [Google]
Edg, Edge, and Edgy.jpg
78KB, 500x375px
>>46429246
Yes, you are maximum edge. In all seriousness, I think that works, though I'm surprised you were able to acquire Zeed Millenniumon. I though he was off limits?
>>
Does your persona have to match your personality? If i choose some one fundamentally different to my nature would that still work or no?
>>
>>46429331
You'd assume so at first, but the jump doesn't forbid the guy.

I've never seen anything concrete to back up the Multiversal+ Everything stuff people say about him, so for the sake of having a chain that isn't just "And then we won everything forever" I'm gonna fanwank that he's at regular Mega levels of power.
>>
>>46429246
Looking online, Grand Dracumon can't evolve from Velgrmon. Other than that, assuming you buy a side evolution for each time you split the line(5 times, not including the Grand Dracumon one), you should be fine.
>>
>>46429422
Sounds about right. On that note, other than this>>46429439, you should be set.
>>
>>46429439
Same poster, I accidentally miscounted, it is 4 minus Grand Dracumon.
>>
File: 12f661ff5eeb2f44b08d8f679933c431.png (417KB, 1250x1036px) Image search: [Google]
12f661ff5eeb2f44b08d8f679933c431.png
417KB, 1250x1036px
>>46429391
Personas are made to match your personality by default. They're a representation of your inner traits, the way you tend to think, manifested in the Shadow World.

You /could/ choose a Persona fundamentally different, but it wouldn't be advisable. You'd be fighting part of yourself whenever you tried to summon it, hindering your ability in battle severely. While there most likely won't be any major problems, if your Persona and yourself are too different from each other, things could turn violent. It could not come when you call for it, or attack you instead of your enemies. Hell, it could even detach itself and turn into a full blown Shadow. There's no telling exactly what damage that would do to you on the way out. From there, you'd most likely have to rely on friends to go into the Shadow Realm and defeat your wild Shadow just to let you regain some of yourself again.
>>
Question: how powerful is a fully awakened/evolved Bel? Jump says a "rival to God", but what does that mean for other jumps?
>>
>>46429439
>>46429490
The notes said spirit warriors could side evolve based just on Type, with one of the viable choices for the darkness spirits being demon beasts, which Grand Dracumon is one of.

If the line about following the connected form rules means I still need an evo link, I'll just spare myself the CP.
>>
>>46429619

Presumably this is yet another "not actually omnipotent" god, so...
>>
>>46429619
I have a dumb question but what exactly is this Bel thing I keep hearing about from? and what is it?
>>
Okay, I'm thinking of starting a chain in order to be the ultimate Sixth Ranger.

Problem is I don't know where to start. I mean, Pokemon, duh, but I'm of two minds.

My first thought was to go and take the Drop-in perks. I'd have a bit of fun being the ultimate edgelord for a while, fighting bad guys and good guys alike, then mellow out on my next jump--or mid jump if I ran into a convincing Shounen Hero who could "win my dark heart over to the side of justice."

Being edgy is fun if you don't let it consume you.

Anyway, I got stuck on which pokemon I should end with. Do I go for the edgiest pokemon? Or do I go for synergy, and choose mostly support pokemon since the idea is I'll be competent enough at fighting and have enough guns to function as my team's primary damage dealer.

Or is there another Sixth Ranger idea I'm neglecting?

Another question: If you choose the "Small Town" perk that basically lets you play as the protagonist from X/Y but not necessarily in Kalos, I'm assuming you can't actually take your friends with you without pods, right?

Also, if you do take a companion, do they have to leave all their pokemon behind? Do you need a pod for each of their pokemon? Or is it a package deal?

Also, I know this has been asked before, but I'm asking it again: Companion-heavy jumpers, how do you handle having as many companions as you do given Jumpchain limits?
>>
>>46429705
Ah, in that case, I think it is fine.
>>
Trying out the name for now, seeing how it works out. Anyway, so here's the updated jump with backgrounds, tell me if they're too long, I wanted to convey the history and memories each background had.
>>46429619
>>46429734
>>46429734
Bels at full power are a match for YHVH, who was a level 108 in a setting where the highest level is 99, in a setting where a much weaker demon could wipe out all life on the planet. So there's that, though it will take sometime to reach that insane level of power(Universe busting), I'd say after you get your spark. Now, that may SOUND unfair, to cut the full power until post-Spark but again, a weaker aspect of the Great Will could create and destroy billions of universes, so...
>>46429782
Bel is a perk from the Devil Survivor jump: It essentially allows you to become a demon king, THE demon king, below only Lucifer himself, while also granting immense power.
>>
SHIT SHIT SHIT I FORGOT THE JUMP.
>>
>>46429846
Bud, I think you forgot something.
>>
>>46429619
Well, you're not omnipotent. Shin Megami Tensei's take on YHVH isn't all powerful, just strong enough that he can fake it pretty convincingly. The omnipotent being is the Great Will, the creature that calls itself YHVH just has a small fraction of its power. Still, he's a pretty powerful reality-warper. He's capable of destroying the world and recreating it anew if he has time to marshal his power, so to be considered on the same level as him means you could probably curbstomp a lot of opponents.

>>46429782
Devil Survivor 1. There's a non-discounted 800CP perk that makes you take the place of the game's protagonist, who is the reincarnation of Abel. As in Cain and Abel. "Bel" is an old Babylonian word meaning "master", so the demons that have the syllable "bel" in their name are the most powerful ones, inheritors of the power of the original primordial demon You start out pretty strong, and if you can kill and absorb all the others (Beldr, Jezibel, Bellial, Belzaboul and Belberith) you become as strong as that first demon was.
>>
>>46429574
Well im a hermit by the persona description but i cant think of any good ones for it so i was thinking of going justice.
>>
>>46429865
Never change, you lovable goof.
>>
>>46429866
>>46429878
Everytime, I swear...I'm getting really tired of my own goof ups.
>>
>>46429792
I would answer your first questions but I don't really know.

>Another question: If you choose the "Small Town" perk that basically lets you play as the protagonist from X/Y but not necessarily in Kalos, I'm assuming you can't actually take your friends with you without pods, right?

This is indeed correct, you just have friends there. They stay there when you leave. Technically you aren't even supposed to have your warehouse yet so you can't take them even if you wanted to without fan wanking or taking the return option in your warehouse.

>Also, if you do take a companion, do they have to leave all their pokemon behind? Do you need a pod for each of their pokemon? Or is it a package deal?

They would have to leave their pokemon or you would have to pod each.

>Also, I know this has been asked before, but I'm asking it again: Companion-heavy jumpers, how do you handle having as many companions as you do given Jumpchain limits?

I switch out. Even when I import I give people days off I try and give everyone some time... Except for those that I am married to or have adopted they get to stay out full time. I can't say it's a perfect solution but I try hard to make it work and make sure no one feels left out or neglected. When in doubt stack cooking perks... a good home cooked meal can go a long way towards making people feel appreciated.
>>
File: 0b4ed1b8c8eb8295e42290a10efa5b48.png (229KB, 1140x1200px) Image search: [Google]
0b4ed1b8c8eb8295e42290a10efa5b48.png
229KB, 1140x1200px
>>46429792
To be the Ultimate Sixth Ranger you need:
1. A Ledian and Bisharp Pokemon. If you need to ask why, get out.
2. A Dragon Pokemon in an absolutely killer Luchador Mask.
3. Possibly one of those Sword Pokemon I can't remember the name of.

Drop-In would probably be your best bet if you want to be an utter edge-lord.

The initial Pokemon Jump wasn't really designed with Companions in mind, so just wank something about what happens to their Pokemon when you do. Personally, I'd say they could bring 3 Pokemon and still be counted as a package deal based off a few other Jumps.

As for your last question, that's a very good one. I'd love to know that too. Is there actually some way to step around the 8+pods formula and bring along as many Companions as you damned well want?

>>46429872
Have fun with that.

>>46429865
Nice to know I'm not the only one who does that. You've still got a better track record than myself at least, so cheers. Have some mermaid side-boob.
>>
>>46429234
SCIENCE! is also just a tech perk, while Certified Tech is one of the better Reverse Engineer perks out there.
>>
>>46429957
Yeah, that too.
>>
Been out for a week, what'd I miss?
>>
>>46429949
So it wont be hazardous to my health ?
>>
>>46430011
I never said that. I just don't want to repeat myself when I listed exactly what would happen in >>46429574 . You want to pick a different Persona anyways, have fun with possible psychosis and total personality rejection syndrome.
>>
>>46430011
It would be extremely painful.
>>
>>46430033
Wouldn't taking the perk so that i know who i am perfectly stop that? Or since its not "me" if just realize how wrong i was taking it.
>>
File: DON'T SAY IT-HERE WE GO.png (272KB, 500x359px) Image search: [Google]
DON'T SAY IT-HERE WE GO.png
272KB, 500x359px
>>46430076
>Not you
Anon...
>>
>>46430109
I think ill go through more jumps and change as a person before going to persona itll make it easier on my head.
>>
>>46430076
If you take the perk that causes you to know exactly who you are, then wouldn't you wind up with the Arcana you actually are rather than the one you want to be?
>>
File: 300ee17fb65b9a515e6b3ac87e35a79e.jpg (916KB, 1131x800px) Image search: [Google]
300ee17fb65b9a515e6b3ac87e35a79e.jpg
916KB, 1131x800px
>>46430076
Taking Self-Awareness while having a mismatched Persona is the epitomy of a bad idea. The Poster Child of Bad Ideas. >>46430109 would happen pretty much the moment you stepped into the world. Your Psyche would schism and your Persona would go full Shadow Boss. Then you'd be forced to fight a Shadow without a Persona, so unless you brought some friends or some kickass Powers from others Jumps, it would be pretty much a game over.

Hell, that's assuming you can even affect Shadows with powers from other Jumps. I don't even know if you can.
>>
>>46430137
Character development saves the day!
>>
>>46430142
>Hell, that's assuming you can even affect Shadows with powers from other Jumps. I don't even know if you can.
Try to keep the SMT wank down man. If Yosuke can smack one with a bat, pretty sure the vast arsenal of magic, psionics, tech, physical and even conceptual powers can too.
>>
>>46430076
You'll probably be fine even without it. The jump says that the strain from having a Persona different from your personality is fairly manageable.

>Keep in mind that each Arcana does have its own innate characteristics, not only in the abilities that it can use but also in the type of person which it fits. Choosing an Arcana opposed to your personality may result in occasional difficulty as you and the mask you use come into conflict, but it will rarely be severe.

>>46430109
That only happened because Ameno-Sagiri (and by extension, Izanami) were fucking with the kids' Shadows. Denying your Shadow normally wouldn't cause anything like that. They'd get violent, but they wouldn't turn into giant monsters.
>>
>>46430140
Nah id still have the other arcana i had chosen id just know how fucked i would be?

>>46430142
Would defeating my shadow even acomplish anything? I get the feeling that talking out wouldn't really work in that situation.

>>46430151
Amen brother.
>>
>>46430173
There is apparently some new storm in the human psyche, so I think it would still happen.
>>
>>46430173
Huh that sounds way better than what yoro was saying.
>>
>>46430167
This. SMT gets insane at high levels, not at low levels. Most people with one or two good Jumps under their belt could deal with the average drudge Shadow without too much difficulty.
>>
>>46430167
I should probably just go to bed. I'm just jamming my fingers against the keyboard at this point.

You're right. I exaggerated.
>>
>>46430236
>>46430167
Yeah, the mooks are pretty weak, like even a starter jumper could kill them. Now, try to fight the HIGHER level ones with anything but late game is a good way to get your ass kicked. Hard.
>>
>>46430197
Talking it out might work. Shadows are beings of falsehood, the whole thing about them being the "true self" is just one more of their lies. Not a single one of the Shadows in P4 ever says anything actually real. It's all just superficial analysis of the kids' traits exaggerated out of proportion to make them sound as bad as possible. It wants you to accept its "revelations" as truth, so that you become an empty thing just like it. The reason they turn into monsters when someone shouts "YOU'RE NOT ME!" at them isn't because of some friction between the mask and the truth, it's because the Shadow is freaking the fuck out that its plan isn't working. So if you can convince the Shadow to just give up...maybe then it could work. Talk it out of the giant disco ninja frog stage, convince it that would be pointless, and get it to surrender without all that fuss. Because you're real, and it's not, so it better shut up with its whining and get the fuck back in your brain.
>>
>>46430271
Maybe, maybe not. Persona tends towards a lower level of power than mainline SMT does. It wouldn't be a trivial fight, but neither would you get immediately curbstomped.
>>
>>46430271
Yeah, but that's kind of the appeal of SMT. You get your ass whupped over and over again, barely hanging on for dear life, until you tear a cosmic horror apart with nothing but a pistol, a sword, and the Chief Gods of three separate belief systems.
>>
>>46430301
For the most part I agree, but Nyarlathotep amd Nyx are...Well, they'd be a major problem, I'd say. And there's one drawback that brings in Mem Aleph, YHVH, AND Polaris. So that's a thing.
>>
>>46430294
I feel like you're missing the point of the Shadows. The things they're obsessed with are the actual truth - the parts of the kids that they're refusing to accept about themselves. The reason why they twist it to sound as awful as possible isn't to leave the human empty, but because that's how the humans perceive them - this awful "thing" rather than a healthy part of their psyche that they need to come to terms with.
>>
>>46430343
>>46430294
Or it might be that you can just interpret them in a few different ways much like how the kids can interpret their own shadows in different ways? It ultimately has the same outcome.
>>
>>46430343
No, I'm pretty sure I've got the point down exactly right. Ameno-Sagiri outright tells you "yeah, nothing the Shadows said was real, I just had them say that in hopes you'd give in, wouldn't things be easier if the superficial analysis was the right one?". Did you actually play the game?
>>
>>46430294
Id feel pretty silly if i had to have a shouting match with myself. But there is merit to the idea.
>>
Jumpers, who is the companion that you went to the greatest lengths to get on your team?
>>
>>46430441
Lapis, by nature of her being the only companion which isn't in some way an alternate version of me, an extension of my soul/psyche, or my Parahuman Power.
>>
>>46430410
Not that anon, but I played the game and I don't remember saying any such thing. What I DO remember is him saying "Okay, you humans can't handle the truth, you don't want it, you just want a world of pretty lies, so you know what? I'll give you just that." Hell, the Shadows seem downright GIDDY to be rejected: Shadow Rise practically orgasms when she's rejected, and none of the shadows attack before they're rejected, implying they need to be rejected in order for them to attack. So it seems more like they're trying to attack people's psychological weak points so that they can kill and replace them in the new world order, which means that unlike what you said before, their plan wasn't failing, it was working.
>>
>>46430485
him saying* Bleh.
>>
File: bullshit.jpg (130KB, 750x600px) Image search: [Google]
bullshit.jpg
130KB, 750x600px
>>46429865
>Drop-Ins who have a history in, and memories of, the world
>record screech
>>
>>46430548
I see you did not read the first jump anon, so I'll explain it to you: You are a Drop-In to the SETTING, which is the Junkyard in part 1. Much like Sera, you are not native to this world, have no memories of it, and what not. We discussed this before and during the release of part 1, and everyone else was fine with it.
>>
>>46430007
New/updated jumps posted in the last week(ish):
Viscera Cleanup Detail
Polity
Digital Devil Saga (part 1)
Franken Fran
Assassins Creed
Star Wars (supplement notes)
Fallout 4
Kingdoms Of Amalur - Reckoning
Gundam Anno Domino
Heaven's Lost Property
>>
>>46430485
Well, you're right, there. He is responding to a human desire for superficiality to be true. But that doesn't invalidate what I said, the Shadows are still creatures of falsehood. The things they say aren't true, they're just what we assume to be true. The "accepting what your Shadow says turns you into one" thing, though, Ameno-Sagiri both says that people will be turned into Shadows as they accept the lies and we see it happen with Adachi and Namatame. You may have a point with the doppleganger Shadows, though. Ameno-Sagiri does say that the Shadows are tormented by truth, but that doesn't mean they can't also be happy to be confronted with it. Less of an "oh shit, the plan isn't working, time to kill all the kids" and more of a "yes, the plan isn't working, I get to kill the kids now! Yay!". So they're in pain, but happy because the pain gives them an excuse to kill their original and take their place instead of fuse with them.
>>
>>46430580
I did read the first jump, and "everyone else" was not fine with it.

And it's also bullshit, because (1) the setting is the Digital Devil Saga; the mere fact that the junkyard is "part 1" means it's not the setting, just a part of it; (2) you're certainly not a fucking Drop-In in part 2.
>>
>>46430441
Basically any of the drawback companions because I like having friends around and like free stuff. Of course, this also means I have to work the build around getting buff enough to pull it off, but who can say no to:
-Getting a free coat from Dante
-Having an elder evil dragon napping in your garden
-Being Alucard's third recurring nightmare
-So many rivals that they form a union
-And so on.
>>
>>46430441
I endured Generic Sugar Bowl so I could bring Kamina back from the dead and bring him on adventures with me.
>>
>>46430669
What would you suggest a Drop-In should get as perks and items, if not being modeled on Serph and Sera? DDS isn't exactly a very expansive setting.
>>
>>46430669
Uh, no? You are the first I've seen to complain about it. Go back to when it was first posted, people even asked me about it and I told them what it meant, and they said "Oh, okay." Hell, go back to when I first told anyone about it, and asked if anyone objected. No one did. Not only that, but the Junkyard IS the setting in the first game, and part 2 of the jump just continues that. Besides, as this anon said>>46430717, there is nothing else to base it on. Aside from this, it' s on the drive. It's been accepted. So there's that.
>>
>>46430485
I'm not so sure about that. If they wanted to replace people, wouldn't we have had a Shadow Saki walking around instead of her corpse being found? Seems more likely to me that their seeming glee is just part of their nature as lies. They're really pissed off at what you're doing, denying them, but they have to act happy about it because they're bizarro evil dopplegangers and that means doing things backwards.
>>
>>46430750
there are people here who get REALLY angry about having ANY sort of memories inserted. They'll go Drop In on every jump just so they don't have their mind adulterated in any way.
>>
>>46430768
>Shadow Saki
I..Huh. I actually forgot about her. Well, that theory crashed and burned.
>>
>>46430777
Not him, but what a bunch of pussies.
>>
>>46430717
Being modeled on them is fine, since like them you've been "dropped in"; it's just where you've been dropped in "from" is different. And that's easily fixed in the jump description too - Angel would still be very interested in a mysterious twin to Sera appearing in the simulation, especially if (which could be described in part 2) you also mysteriously materialised in the "real" world next to Sera when she came out of the sim.

>>46430750
I didn't object at the time because I thought you had a plan that didn't involve making Drop-Ins not actually Drop-Ins in part 2. My bad for keeping my mouth shut, I guess.
>>
>>46430421
There are people who don't get into shouting matches with themselves?

>>46430441
The Sisters of Battle. The whole story with them is involved, but I rescued them from a spacehole, got them brainwashed by accident, and became a psyker mostly so I could cure them. Taking care of them was the goal of three of the DLC.

Asriel was also a challenge, but honestly, it's one I enjoyed. Monsters are great and I had a perfect memory and got to make them presents. 10000 friends.

>>46430605
Thank you kindly, oh sweet Anon.
>>
>>46430777
Not much I can do about that. My hands are kind of tied here, due to this setting having enough to make a Jump out of, but not enough to make a proper Drop-In aside from Sera. I even talked about this, how it was a frustrating jump.
>>46430812
>I thought...
You'll forgive me if I'm confused here, Anon. I very clearly stated my intentions, I even went as far as to say "Memories" in the Drop-In section. Seriously, Anon, if you want me to do anything, you've got to tell me ahead of time. I specifically asked if anyone had a problem with it to avoid these kind of problems. So, Anon, if you have an issue or complaint, PLEASE tell me. I want to make this an enjoyable experience for everyone, including you, and I can't do that if you don't talk to me
>>
>>46430844
>My hands are kind of tied here
Not really. Plenty of Drop-in Powersets are BASED on a character without replacing that character or inserting memories.

Gravity Falls, for example. Most of the Drop In Powers are based on Mabel, but you don't replace Mabel, or get Mabel's memories if you drop in. The Kim Possible Drop In Tree isn't even CALLED drop in and it still doesn't tinker with your memories. But the powers are all based off of Ron.

Personally I don't much care, I'm not a drop-in purist, but the only one tying your hands is yourself. Is rewording it or adding a +0cp drawback that says "your mind remains unchanged and you have no non-native memories" really that much worse than having this drama pop up again and again? /jc/ is horrible about letting things go.
>>
>>46430844
Sorry. Lesson learnt about speaking up straight away, I suppose. Fwiw, it seems like a good jump otherwise, I'm just one of those drop-in only jumpers.
>>
>>46430800
So you prefer to be a patchwork onahole?
>>
>>46430441
Yion Green, Biomega/Blame. Since we opted to use our scenario points to fix the megastructure, and we have very strong feelings about allowing people who aren't in their right minds to kill themselves, we took on the burden of recovering Yion's mind the hard way.
>>
>>46430907
If that's how little confidence you have in your own sense of self and how you perceive other backgrounds, I imagine you must have had a very traumatic experience in your childhood.
>>
>>46430907
I prefer to think of it as having well travelled tracts of land.
>>
>>46430923
Would it really surprise you that someone who feels strongly about a game of pretend on the internet might have some trauma? I imagine a lot of us here are broken in some way or another.
>>
>>46430890
>>46430894
Look guys, it's like this: A big part of the game is memories, and how they affect who you are, and this has a much bigger impact than you think. If I just say, "No, you just popped in.", I'd be screwing you over, because the whole thing about the Atma virus is that's it's based off Solar Data/Karma, and you wouldn't have that if you were just dropped in, which would mean when the big guy stepped in, you would have no way of defending yourself. If, IF it really means that much, I can change it, but it'll be a bitch to figure out how to work that in with the lore that is available.
>>
>>46430934
I admit I hadn't thought about it that way until you pointed it out, though up until now I thought most people here seemed fairly reasonable and levelheaded, apart from having varying degrees of the usual autism.
>>
>>46430948
Maybe I'm missing something, but that seems like it would make a rather hardcore drawback.
>>
...Hmm. Wasn't Shaman King supposed to be posted?
>>
>>46430948
>If I just say, "No, you just popped in.", I'd be screwing you over,

Bam, make it a drawback. Then they can't call it a grave, it's the future they chose.

>A big part of the game is memories, and how they affect who you are, and this has a much bigger impact than you think.

I find this whole issue appealingly ironic, since the whole point is that people like >>46430894 are really careful about what memories make up their self.
>>
>>46430923
I had one or two, but it's more I actually like my sense of self/identity that I'd be leery about sticking my brain in a memory blender, ROB-powered or not.

>>46430926
Heh. Touche.

>>46430948
Um... is the Atma virus the thing that allows you to transform into a demon? Because the part 1 Drop-In says you don't have a demon form?
>>
>>46430973
This, actually. I mean, normally I'd be concerned whether it'd be free points for the drop-in purist crowd but so far it only seems to be one guy and if things are as bad as >>46430948 makes them out to be it sounds like its' own basket of suffering.
>>
>>46430973
>>46431010
...That...That could work. I can work with that,
>>46431017
The Atma virus either awakens the Solar Data/Karma within the victim, or it is the Solar Data interacting with the Karma. The lore is...pretty weak on this one. It's why the Archangels and Satan act like they're the ones from SMT II, because they ARE the ones, or at least the data. So whether that was inside of people all along or was added, it's pretty important.
>>46431018
You'd be facing all the enemies without the ability to transform.
>>
>>46431004
SK Anon said next thread. I guess they're polishing things up first.
>>
>>46431017
>Um... is the Atma virus the thing that allows you to transform into a demon? Because the part 1 Drop-In says you don't have a demon form?
The description for Drop In in part 2 says you've been infected with the Atma Virus. So you should get a demon form (and immunity to the Black Sun, that's the really important part) once you leave the Junkyard.
>>
>>46431124
What does that mean for Jumpers who've previously taken immunity perks against viruses, diseases, toxins, etc?
>>
>>46431204
If the wiki is accurate, they'd still be fine, since the Black Sun causes "Cuvier Syndrome" which is the "disease" that petrifies people.
>>
>>46431204
It's not a..literal virus. It just's data. Corrupted Solar data, but data. So it should still affect you.
Speaking of which, after some research to make sure my memory hadn't failed me, I can safely confirm that being a memoryless Drop-In is impossible, because the Solar data is needed, and that carries the demon's memories. So you'd gain memories no matter what happens if you want to be able to transform.
>>
>>46431260
Is transforming that important (I mean, other than just to avoid being petrified, e.g. if you had anti-corruption perks)?
>>
>>46431299
Yeah, I'd say so. You'd be unable to use/learn any magic/skills, and you'd lack the raw power to fight the higher ranking enemies, unless you've already Jumped an SMT jump or enough other jumps. Even then, the bonus bosses would kick your ass, especially since the Demi-Fiend and Satan are considered the hardest JRPG bosses in video game history by many who have played, and are in-universe planet-universe-multiverse(SMT power levels are weird once you get to the big players) busting.
>>
>>46431222
The wiki threw me when it talked about the demons eating each other for their "high concentrations of magnetite". I was like, what, that's one of the most naturally-occurring oxides of iron, it's not like that's rare - but nope, apparently that's what DDS calls its setting's unobtanium.
>>
>>46431343
Not just DDS, SMT in general. Look at Soul Hackers, for example.
>>
>>46431343
Yeah, that was always a bit weird to me. I kind of just assumed since there were millions of demons running around, they had to literally use up like all the magnetite available.
>>
>>46431339
>Jumper stares up at the Demi-Fiend.
>Jumper turns to the MCs, "You can have this one."
>Jumper .oO (and this is why you don't take "Jumper replaces the Protagonist" drawbacks, folks!)
>>
File: True Demon Route.png (201KB, 540x357px) Image search: [Google]
True Demon Route.png
201KB, 540x357px
>>46431371
The funny thing is-he's a titchy Japanese teenager. You'd probably be staring down at him. Size doesn't rally matter in SMT; Lucifer rivals the Great Will and his forms are less imposing than most of the Great Will's avatars.

And you'd still be scared shitless
>>
>>46431371
Yep. Alright, I'm heading off to slumber land, so before I leave, let's go over what we have:
>Drop-Ins usually don't have memories
>However, due to lore, this is impossible, as memories are needed for transformation.
>Even if there were no memories/history, you'd still get your demon form's.
>So, drawback:No memories/history, no transformation.
>Solar Data, and this is important, is the literal demon.
>The demon can take over the weak willed, ala Metatron, Beelzebub, the Archangels, and Satan.
Anything else before I leave?
>>
>>46431411
I'm reading the wiki, and... why is DDS's God being a dick? "You're inflicting so much pain on each other... so rather than protecting the innocent, I'm just going to inflict even more pain on them by turning them and everyone they love into stone via a horrible petrifying sunlight!"

Wot.
>>
>>46431260
> I can safely confirm that being a memoryless Drop-In is impossible
I don't know anything about this setting, so I don't know how retarded this is to ask, but do you suppose you could partition out the memories somehow?
Like, give the jumper access to them, but without having them effect their actual memory? Sortof like an external memory chip or hard drive.

I understand that the memories are important, but Drop Ins are also often the wild card option, so if there were a way to fudge that a bit I think it might be justified.
Or you could always just give the option to not be able to transform, sortof a hard mode, but I don't know how many jumpers would be up for that.
>>
File: image.jpg (272KB, 673x1000px) Image search: [Google]
image.jpg
272KB, 673x1000px
>>46428921
X-Men movie franchises really don't have bad ass normals like that of YJ or Arrowverse. So my view on the manner is they probably should get some form of points for free.

Way I would probably do it is take the classification system from the comics. "Beta", "Alpha", "Omega-Potential". Beta is free, Alpha is X amount, and Omega Potential is like 800cp.

The classifications don't actually mean you're Omega Level Mutant just you get more points. Although you could have an option to dump all your points into a single power, to raise the power level.

Take Weather Manipulation for Yxp (Xmen Points).
Beta Level is manipulating weather in small area, and briefly. Cause a lightning strike, or cloud cover.

Alpha level would be a larger area and can create natural disasters like a Tornado with some effort. Instead of lightning you create a localized weak thunderstorm.

Omega Potential has the ability to eventually reach Storm's level. She's able to manipulate weather on massive almost global scale. Multiple tornadoes, with hail, massive thunderstorms with lots of lightning. Able to summon lightning almost instantly.

That's just my crazy ideas. Whatever you decide, it's up to you and I await the jump. X Gonna Give It To Ya!
>>
>>46431445
"God is a dick" is the common uniting theme of the Shin Megami Tensei franchise. It's just how he is, there's no point in questioning it.
>>
>>46431445
Welcome to jRPGs, where villains are reactionary and idiotic.
>>
>>46431445
Because he's lost all patience with humanity. After horrifically torturing and experimenting on telepaths in order to talk to God, they finally succeeded...And proceeded to traumatize and break her emotionally, while she was directly connected to him. He doesn't want to protect the innocent, because to him, no human is innocent, they ALL deserve to die, so He can start over in order to make a less evil mankind. This is actually less dickish then the other versions of him, who are outright egomaniacs.
>>46431446
Solar data works like that in canon, the problem is it has to have something to interact with: Karma. Karma require's an in-universe history/memories, otherwise God would just see you as a blank slate, you HAVE no Karma as far as he's concerned. The hard mode is being considered.
If there's nothing else? Good night, Anons.
>>
>>46431504
requires* Bleh.
>>
>>46431429
As the original complaining anon, I'm happy to take a "no memories/history, no transformation" drawback, so long as it doesn't also neuter prior anti-corruption perks ("no powers from other jumps" could be another drawback, and the truly hardcore/suicidal folks could take both).
>>
>>46431524
Works for me, we have a consensus. Now, for real this time, goodnight all.
>>
>>46431460
>spoiler

Honestly the only good part of the X-Men movie franchise I've yet to see. And by "good" I mean "worth a rewatch" once the novelty of special effects has worn off.
>>
>>46431548
I don't know the first half of First Class where it's about Nazi hunter Magneto and swinging Charlie Xavier is pretty good.
>>
>>46431568
Eh, point. I'm not really sure why First Class started losing my interest towards the end, actually. It definitely has some good moments. Maybe it was because it felt a little like the Charles and Eric Show with almost every other character being basically a caricature for them to snark at.
>>
103. Divinity: Dragon Commander
Age: 20, Race: Drop-In Human
Perks: Dragon Form, Political Marriage [Lizard Princess], Mass Production (-200)
Dragon Forms: Zephyr Dragon
Dragon Skills: Purifying Flames, Soar(-100), Rejuvanation (-100), Friends with Benefits, Ray of Power (-100), Mass Restoration (-200), Scakles of Steel (-400)
Drawbacks: Drinker (+100)

I wanted to import a companion as my new wife or husband, but the only one I'd really be interested in isn't the marrying type. So, let's go with a sexless marriage to a lizard lawyer and many attempts to woo the imp ambassador into bed. Camilla seems like she'd be down with that and someone with a good understanding of the law and reason can balance out my insanity fairly well. If she learns a little about compassion along the way, well so be it. She'll probably rule if I die somewhere in my chain, because I'm leaving her behind.

So, I'm a superfast jetpack dragon and I can use "This Is, In Fact, My Final Form" to combine all my draconic forms. I am a waterbending living thunder storm at this point. I can use water and lightning and breathe to heal and hurt, and I have access to production capacities and tech far beyond mere nuclear weapons. I've fought more demons and conquered more countries than anyone else currently present. The politics are worse for me than the war, really. Luckily I have all those racial unity perks to get good at engineering functional, diverse societies. It's the person to person interactions that suck. These guys are as self-centered and dickish as expected from politicians. The elves are stuck up hippies, the dwarves are capitalist scum, the imps are only interested in explosions, the humans are boring, and the lizards are egotistical to the extreme. The only thing they all agree on is that I'm in charge. That's good enough, I suppose.

The challenge here is to reconquer the world while only abusing booze.
>>
How buff are the Swords from Devil Survivor 2? Stronger or weaker than the high-end spiritual beings like Metatron, Remiel, Lilith and Beelzebub in the other games?
>>
>>46431504

This is probably too late, but I thought of a few suggestions for alternate options to the memory problem.

1. If it's just the history that's an issue. You could have an option to import your history from a previous Megaten related jump for the purpose of Karma. Like those 'your actions from this related jump carry over' drawbacks that sometimes show up.


2. A time extension drawback/option where you start several years before you normally would as an orphan (with no memories and probably almost no powers) Angel adopted to give Sera a sibling, and then you have to go though and survive the Cyber Shaman experiment without being able to change things or having the guarantee of background survival, with your Karma being what you built up during the pre-Junkyard period of the jump.
>>
>>46430173
>Denying your Shadow normally wouldn't cause anything like that. They'd get violent, but they wouldn't turn into giant monsters.

What about Shadow Labrys?
>>
Can someone please put this on the drive?
>>
>>46432891
Hold yer horses, give folks a chance to critique

To clarify, are Reiryoku and Furioku completely separate phenomena? Would having a high quantity of one not have any influence on the other?

Exactly what is an oversoul? It's mentioned in some of the perks but not explained well

This is taking a while to read so-stand by for more comments
>>
>>46432969
>To clarify, are Reiryoku and Furioku completely separate phenomena? Would having a high quantity of one not have any influence on the other?
Furyioku and reiryioku are both "soul-muscle" and the are "soul-muscle" living human and spirit respectively.

>Exactly what is an oversoul? It's mentioned in some of the perks but not explained well
Channeling a spirit through a physical medium, allowing to to affect the physical world. That's where the giant swords come from here
>>
>>46432891
This entire jump feels messy and confusing. Not to mention constant spelling and grammar errors. I seriously don't think this is finalised and really deserves another go over.

You also need to explain the basic terms a lot better given how heavily all the perks and items refer to them. Consider putting the most important stuff like Reiryoku and Oversouls and the like at the start, not hidden at the end amongst many other notes.

>A Dream
For 50cp, that's kinda a lot to give. You need to rewrite the amount of willpower you get.

>Elemental Rock Paper Scissors
What does this actually do?

A lot of the higher cost perks get weirdly meta and often reference other series. The Adeptus Mechanicus perk reference is particularly stupid.

>Shamanic Schools
This whole section is just a mess spelling, grammar and detail wise.

>Misc perks
A lot of these seem to be weirdly priced or just outright bad to have, the last 700 in particular.


Overall, my end opinion of this jump is that it has way more stuff then it needs. A lot of these perks and stuff seem like they could be seriously cut down or condensed into fewer overall so that the jump isn't so confusing and bloated.
>>
>>46432891
Exactly what elemental rock-paper-scissors actually does isn't explained very well.

How does creating artifact spirits actually work? Does it take a lot of spiritual energy or just an effort of communication? Does how powerful/the innate quality of an artifact matter at all e.g. which would be harder, granting an EX Noble Phantasm, the Light of Terra or a Sword of the Cross an artifact spirit?

Traditional Shamanism seems...kinda arbitrary in how far it improves-I'd go with "a great amount" or somesuch. Does it only apply to spiritual practices or magical ones too after the jump? What about techniques where they overlap like Kanka?

Mu-Mumyouyaku-mu: What does it being learned in "Hell" mean? Did your background retroactively study to Hell before your current location if you take this perk? By "supernatural energies" are things considered magic, psychic powers, divinity and reality warping in general covered or just spiritualism?

I presume 2 O'clock shadow refers to physiological strength in general where spirtual powers aren't a thing?

Why is Reishi priced so high for an ability that frankly seems like a drawback?

Tchosenjiraketsu: I feel this could at least use a link to the wiki to figure out exactly what it's capable of

Armor OS: Exactly HOW does it attack and defend?

Tsukumogami: Do spirits become more powerful the more powerful the artifacts they're based on would are? What are the ramifications for a 50 mile spaceship developing its' own spirit?

Minor god/deity needs more clarifications on what elements/concepts are valid, and in general-what they're like
>>
>>46432891
>Artifact spirit creation
Oh. Oh my. This will be fun. Vey fun.
>>
>>46433107
Did you suddenly become Transylvanian Anon?
>>
>>46433131
No, but the potential here is very interesting, especially when combined with all these AI perks lying around.

Also, the anons above are just dumb - most of this stuff is perfectly clear.
>>
>>46432891
I don't understand what the point of "Out of context” medium of choice is.

Also I just found the mystery box, it's kind of random and dumb but that's not really a serious criticism in itself, I'm just kind of bewildered at how out of place it is, but it's actually pretty solid with the exception of the underwear's poorly defined threshold and the kanabo's need for some kind of cap on how far it can grow/shrink. You did mispell "at" in Oni-daiko though. And why does the Mystery Box have a price? Can you not buy anything in it unless you pay the 300 CP charge?

Why does Naka-oni have a question mark at the end?

Okay. I think that's everything.

>>46433131
>Transylvanian Anon

Who?

>>46433148
I disagree.
>>
>>46433148
Yes, we should totally ignore all criticism from several sources because one guy doesn't mind it.
>>
>>46432891
Oh yes, one more thing-didja intend a 600 CP drawback cap or none? The 800 CP drawback's note about "slots" made me wonder.
>>
>>46432891
Oh wow, some of this jump is just plain lazy. You outright go for "Obligatory “you can only use this jump’s powers” drawback". Pretty disappointing honestly. Would've thought Toriko Anon would be a better influence but the jump's barely improved from the quality when it was first posted, just has more words.
>>
>>46433164
You have an opinion, I have an opinion. That's just how it goes
>>
>>46433206
Have to admit, when one side raises a bunch of constructive criticism and valid questions and the other just throws insults, you come off looking pretty silly.
>>
>>46433101
>Exactly what elemental rock-paper-scissors actually does isn't explained very well.
Ok so there was this fight when Ren/Len figured out how to make real lighting out of an Oversoul. An that one where Chocolove came up with using a wind aligned spirit (Pascal Avaff) to basically erode the plants OS of this Patch officer. It basically gives you the start of 'science magic'

>How does creating artifact spirits actually work? Does it take a lot of spiritual energy or just an effort of communication? Does how powerful/the innate quality of an artifact matter at all e.g. which would be harder, granting an EX Noble Phantasm, the Light of Terra or a Sword of the Cross an artifact spirit?
Very hard, at the bottom notes I think, explain that there are a lot of factors including history and raw power. There was this WWII(?) tank whose spirit was stronger than THE Spirit fo Fire Hao had.

>Traditional Shamanism seems...kinda arbitrary in how far it improves-I'd go with "a great amount" or somesuch. Does it only apply to spiritual practices or magical ones too after the jump? What about techniques where they overlap like Kanka?
Pretty much, it's the opposite of the unorthodox perk. Extra power for following old stuff to the letter. As for the arbitrary... JOJO lets you summon steamrollers

>Mu-Mumyouyaku-mu: What does it being learned in "Hell" mean?
Part of the description. You don't actually go to hell. out of jump just extends to most other magic-spirit stuff.
>I presume 2 O'clock shadow refers to physiological strength in general where spirtual powers aren't a thing?
Every other setting has this concept of 'generic life force' that the Naruto jump uses for non-chakra users post jump. Is pretty much the same (will, soul, mana, etc)
>Why is Reishi priced so high for an ability that frankly seems like a drawback?
Well, Hao had it and he managed to convince most everyone in the doomsday brigade to die for him.
>Armor OS: Exactly HOW does it attack and defend?
1/2
>>
>>46430343
>healthy
Not all of them are healthy.
>>
>>46433101
>Armor OS: Exactly HOW does it attack and defend?
Think a small Susnano'o. It's a literal armor out of sprit.
>Tsukumogami: Do spirits become more powerful the more powerful the artifacts they're based on would are? What are the ramifications for a 50 mile spaceship developing its' own spirit?
For one, that it would be HELL to actually OS it. Thing with a spirit tend to become somewhat better/more efficient/stronger/more durable than they should because Supernatural Reasons. As for being able to actually OS it... It might cross into Guren Laggan territory.

>Minor god/deity needs more clarifications on what elements/concepts are valid, and in general-what they're like

OK back to Word
>>
>>46433255
See >>46433063
>>
>>46433162
Transylvania, like, the region? As in "I vould like to suck your blood blegh blegh"?
>>
>>46433255
do spirits count as companions? If you import an especially powerful item will it require a proportionately larger amount of your furyoku? What are some benchmarks for how much furyoku an item from another universe takes?
>>
>>46433219
>>46433255

Alright, thanks for the answers. I'd strongly recommend integrating them into the descriptions or the notes somewhere before calling it finished.

Sorry, you'll have to explain what you mean by "science-magic" to me a little further. Can you eventually apply things like the principles of atomic physics or weird scifi stuff like tractor beams to your spirit techniques or are you simply using a knowledge of physics to enhance the effect of magic?

>Susnano'o

I have literally never read Shaman King so you'll have to excuse my complete ignorance-unless you mean the mythological Japanese deity?

>Guren Laggan territory

Then I would question your wisdom in allowing something potentially more of a curbstomp than the 800 CP perks to be imported for the price of 200 CP in Ghost class then, but then I've honestly no idea about the series to tell whether it actually is that big a deal.

>>46433261
Oh right. Nah, brain fart on my part-I thought you were talking about a specific namefriend/fag I'd yet to hear of.
>>
>>46433297
>Susnano'o
Pretty sure he means the Naruto armor thing.
>>
>>46429846
>>46429865
>>46430750
>>46430844
>>46430948
>>46431055
>>46431260
>>46431339
>>46431429
>Stops being an anon and becomes an arrogant name again.
Why. Now you won't even bother listening to us and will think you're better and above us like the rest.

And can you PLEASE just give this autist an actual "No memories" drawback so I can keep the drop-in origin that gives cool history here? Then anon can get fucked over for being stupid, not get a demon form, and nobody else has to suffer.

Drop-in only people are fucking scum.
>>
>>46433162
>I don't understand what the point of "Out of context” medium of choice is.
Mainly, to get a compatible medium if a companion get s imported as a spirit.
>Also I just found the mystery box, it's kind of random and dumb but that's not really a serious criticism in itself, I'm just kind of bewildered at how out of place it is,
Yep. I thought I had to put at least something oni-related from the manga and if Mark of the Ninja lets you be voice in a head...
As for the price, It was to make up for the free oni form thingy. rechecking now
>Why does Naka-oni have a question mark at the end?
For the life of me I cant find it but it mey be a pdf thing.
>>
>>46433321
Dude, you need to get a spellcheck going on both your posts and your jump. You use a voice to text thing or is english not your first language or something? I understand if it's not, just means you need to put a little extra effort into making things look neat.
>>
>>46432633
There are some of us that WANT the Sera's sibling history, you know. Your two options shit on that. The ACTUAL sibling. Not your adopted shit.
>>
>>46433171
>Oh yes, one more thing-didja intend a 600 CP drawback cap or none? The 800 CP drawback's note about "slots" made me wonder.
Standard 600 point drawback, , 800-pointer being the exception. Not much to worry, with enough time you could figure out some most of the stuff, perks are to give an affinity and a jumpstart of the workings.
>>
>>46432891
What are the drawback limits? jumper must die says it takes all slots but i don't see restrictions anywhere else.
>>
>>46433317
You know, I was just thinking you were just being salty. But seeing how this SK guy is ignoring most posts criticising or asking for clarification, I can kind of see your point.
>>
>>46433317
>you won't even bother listening to us and will think you're better and above us like the rest

This runs on a number of assumptions, all of which are retarded. I mean, that Yorokonde fellow seems decent enough for example.

Personally I'm indifferent to names as a concept as long as they're strictly to serve a purpose and not a means of attention whoring. In the context of jumpchain it makes it easier to look up rulings/identify who to ask about a given thing.

I agree with you about Drop-in only people though

>>46433321
>>46433362

>compatible medium

Ah, that kinda makes sense.

>something oni-related
>free oni form thiny

I'm still a little confused but it does seem like you have some reasons for doing and in any case it's not like I think it's actually bad, just a little confusing. Really, I don't mind how you deal with this.

Anyway, thanks for being patient enough to answer all my questions! I feel like I should have more to say but I don't and am basically rambling in text form because I really wish I could give you more advice on how to improve and such, but again-my complete ignorance of the setting is crippling my ability to critique.

I'll just try and try and come up with a build in a few minutes. Looks like I'm really jumping blind this time.

>>46433398
See >>46433362
>>
>>46433426
*try and come up with a build

This is what I get for trying to speed-read and type at the same time. On the bright side, I don't think anything I or anyone else suggested is likely to change the pricing for anything I'm thinking of taking.
>>
>>46433415
I'll admit to also being salty, to be fair. A lot of that is missing this conversation because I slept early.

I'm definitely hoping I can catch him later to STRESS that some of us really like the current drop-in and want to keep it as-is, so that hopefully the solution he comes up with for annoying drop-in only people doesn't infringe on that.

>>46433426
>I agree with you about Drop-in only people though
You're alright people, anon.
>>
>>46433293
Well, there was this W-Laws tank that was actually stronger than Hao's Spirit of Fire, but some of it might be because of the 'being of light' Luchist used for it's creation. Actually that would explain a good chunk of the Angel's strength... Im not sure honestly, the only Tsukumogmai I remember were with the X-Laws, but I guess if a Tank could wipe out an island in one shot... Then AGAIN some living and spiritual weapons would just get made compatible...

I'm honesty stumped, I can't figure out where the 'car' and the 'being of light's boon' start and end in the angels.

As for spirits being companions, nah. Just be ready to explain why your van has a soul and where did you get a ghost chainsaw.
>>
>>46433438
>>46433452
t-thanks, I don't like hating people at all, but some of them just get so damn pushy

Also, for what it's worth this post >>46431055 suggests to me he's thinking of solving the issue with a drawback where you're truly drop-in, so it's most likely you will get to keep your background as whatsherface's twin living in the database, database~
>>
>>46433468
Why are you only answering select posts? There have been many questions given you've ignored, do you just not understand them or are you too lazy or are you trying to sneak certain things by?

If you are just lazy or attempting to get more power, it's sad to see we've gained another jumpmaker just to find out they're awful at the whole deal.
>>
>>46433468
okay cool , I'm already full on companions and I've got some pretty powerful gear that would be nice to have as a spirit.

the thing is as a late game jumper I've really upgraded this stuff heavily, I'm worried I might not be able to channel it, is the spiritual strength derived from the strength of the item itself or the strength of the spirit of the item? i.e if I imported the scarab gun from Halo would it require more strength than an in universe .22?
>>
>>46433297
>Then I would question your wisdom in allowing something potentially more of a curbstomp than the 800 CP perks to be imported for the price of 200 CP in Ghost class then, but then I've honestly no idea about the series to tell whether it actually is that big a deal.
Because the Reiryioku of a Mile-long spaceship ghost would break your soul. A tank (granted it had some extra power) was so strong they guy could only attack once to erase an island before collapsing. A curbstomp super machine's spirit would kill Hao, the strongest shaman in the series let alone you.

But it still a thing because even if you cannot directly blast people with it, it's a decent supernatural upgrade.
>>
File: 56572.png (7KB, 100x100px) Image search: [Google]
56572.png
7KB, 100x100px
Remember, being an anon keeps you honest.
>>
>>46433483
That's exactly my issue with them. They're always complaining and always insisting they get things exactly their way. It irks you after a while/

Yeah, I saw that post, which made me feel a bit better. I just want to make sure, which is why I posted that and also why I'll ask him directly if the current version is going to stick around when he comes back on.
>>
>>46433511
>>But it still a thing because even if you cannot directly blast people with it, it's a decent supernatural upgrade.

Could you please elaborate on this? I was under the impression such items were really able to interact with the world unless manifested, would the tank you mentioned be able to go off on its own and do things?
>>
>>46433497
I answer as I read, some explanations I need some thinking.

>>46433510
>the thing is as a late game jumper I've really upgraded this stuff heavily, I'm worried I might not be able to channel it, is the spiritual strength derived from the strength of the item itself or the strength of the spirit of the item? i.e if I imported the scarab gun from Halo would it require more strength than an in universe .22?
Well, a scarab would be very strong just from the fact of ALIEN LAZOR BEAM OF DOOM. But even if you cant it's still a good upgrade and you might be able to partially OS it.

I remember about someone using a sprit stronger than himself either partially, or in minute spans for individual actions.
>>
>>46433614
>I answer as I read, some explanations I need some thinking.
It's been over an hour since the first posts you started ignoring were made. If you're going to bullshit, at least try to do it well.
>>
>>46433636
Don't forget anon, the very first post that responded to his work was ignored too. So the 'answer as I read' thing falls apart too!
>>
>>46433355

Those weren't suggestions for replacing the current Drop In background, but ideas for alternate 'no memories' drawbacks.

Basically normally you would be Sera's actual sibiling who experienced the horrible stuff with her backstory during your backstory.

Meanwhile the second drawback suggestion would have Angel adopt you up as a kid to handle the no memories and sibiling issue (without doing something creepy like starting you as an infant), you then grow up with Sera and have to actually survive the horrible stuff in the backstory, and probably end up annoying God do to deciding you were too good to use the perfectly functional reincarnation cycle it had set up or something.

Personally I think anyone that actually uses this idea if Devil Survivor Anon adds it is either a moron or suicidal. Since it basically means your doing the equivalent of telling a God that decided that humanity does not deserve to live and is only 'beaten' in canon by convincing it to change it's mind that you think their world isn't good enough to have been born in.
>>
>>46433573
>Could you please elaborate on this? I was under the impression such items were really able to interact with the world unless manifested, would the tank you mentioned be able to go off on its own and do things?

The tank was actually being used by a shaman at the time.

On risk of sounding like ripping off 40K, It's a machine spirit. Shots are somehow more accurate, fuel lasts longer for some reason, the material is more resistant, cars might do weird stuff now and then like lock the brakes and prevent you from crashing with the ass that skipped the red light, planes may land themselves if you fall asleep flying them, computers might happen to crash or shut down when someone tries to open your internet history...

Mysterious/spooky helpful stuff.
>>
>>46433695
Different versions of the drawback? My feelings are completely different then. In that case, I like the orphan one you suggested most as a drawback. It's cute and involves you into the story without crippling you entirely within this world and getting you really involved without irritating the 'no memories' crowd. It also is the most similar to the drop-in without drawback, so nothing gets too messy as far as what discounts you're using and such.

Really my only issue personally is I like the current version drop-in and want it to stick around. as long as these are all drawback suggestions then I'm fairly cool with any of them since the current one sticks around for those that like it and it also quiets those annoying types. However I don't know if they would like that solution, I'm just saying I like your idea for a drawback best myself.

That sounds devious, I love it. Getting under Brahma's skin and making things worse for your sister and everyone else just because you don't like having a history? It's so hilariously selfish and them getting into trouble for it is pretty... karmic.
>>
File: antispiralhuman.jpg (48KB, 383x420px) Image search: [Google]
antispiralhuman.jpg
48KB, 383x420px
>>46432891
Alright, let's get this blindly jumped, preliminary build rolling.

Drawbacks: Night parade of one hundred demons, How Small... (1600)

A normal family, age 15

Rolled The Patch Village

Shamanism (Free)
Family Support (Free)
Anon-pedia (1550)
Flowing OS (1300)
Elemental rock-paper-scissors (1100)
Neo Shamanism (800)
Furioku Level: 5000 (Free)
Mu-Mumyouyaku-mu (0)

Okay, let's figure this out. Our family was a bunch of normal, non-shaman ornary folks. We are somehow in some sort of exotic village that normally bars foreigners. Who use American currency.

This is the worst Hawaii vacation trip ever. No, we're not moving. Look, we own some business franchises all over the world. D'you want us to sue you guys penniless? No? Then damn well point us to the best hotel in town so we can find a cushy vantage point to watch the fireworks.

No, we're no interested in this spirit tournemant thing. We're just here to throw peanuts at the losers.

Besides, we have Bradeline's Well to run. Being a shounen and all it's quite likely there isn't a proper afterlife set up so we'll have to play psychopomp, and figure out where all those defeated spirits are supposed to go.

Good thing oni periodically show up near us! With the combined authority granted from King of Hell, Crown of Makai, Bels and Whistles buffed by Conquer your Demon as well as Lucifer's defeat even if the bastard withheld the final secret of cinnamon toast crunch and Shining One we'll soon have a fanatically loyal labour force working for us in no time. We're delegating Yuugi to manage 'em while we set up the equipment for gathering mystical combat data from watching these suckers fight over nothing.

A shame Bao took that cursed batarang prank so seriously. It was just a prank, though to be fair we'd go homicidally mad after weeks of hearing DAAAAAAARKNESS, NO PARENTS
>>
File: photo.jpg (51KB, 512x512px) Image search: [Google]
photo.jpg
51KB, 512x512px
>>46433695
While I agree with you, it is a jrpg. Pissing off the local supreme deity figure is just the kind of thing that you’re supposed to do.
>>
>>46433837
Funny enough, in this game the story is actually about reaching the supreme deity and calming him down.
>>
Question about the Disney Princess jump. Do the characters I pick for the other roles HAVE to be in the same roles they had in canon?

Because I want to make Elsa the Villain just to see what it'd look like.
>>
>>46433924
I know OAA at least also chose a villainous Elsa, so-it seems you're free to delegate roles
>>
>>46433959

Thanks for answering.
>>
>>46433614
Had enough time to think Lazy anon?
>>
File: 6a11714767e185da406051b86459ed44.jpg (722KB, 960x1468px) Image search: [Google]
6a11714767e185da406051b86459ed44.jpg
722KB, 960x1468px
>>46432891
Well, overall, I think it captures the feel of the setting and did a good job including a wide mix of powers and perks to give everyone something to shoot for.

That said, you truly do need to edit your Jump before it goes up on the Drive. Perks should not be cut across pages (Shamanic Schools section, I'm looking at you), spelling and grammar are both major issues that need to be addressed, and you really should consider organizing the Perks a little better. On that front, I would suggest grouping all the Backgrounds-related Perks together, (i.e. Drop-In, Normal, Shaman Lineage, Patch, then everything else by order of cost).

The Shamanic School section needs some additional clarification about what you actually get for your 150 to 250 points (or more), which is quite a lot to spend on something so vaguely worded. Is it required to take one to be a Shaman? Does taking one of them grant you a package of Perks?

Some of the Perks should probably have their point cost lowered or clarified to explain why they cost so much. Armor OS doesn't seem worth 500 points unless it protects against a truly ungodly amount of punishment for the amount of energy you put into it. I would also recommend the "Free for Background" Perks getting bumped up to 100 points. Does "A Dream" actually increase your Furioku levels? I would also suggest numbering your notes, both to make it easier to determine when one ends and another begins, but because then you can insert the number into the main part of the Jump for easy reference.

Please, please don't abbreviate OverSoul as OS in some places, but not others. It's very jarring to read.

>>46434024
For all you know, he could have a Word Document open right now and is vigorously correcting every issue even if he had not spoken directly to them. Especially considering the flood he has received.
>>
>>46434237
>it captures the feel of the setting

So it's essentially Bleach?
>>
>>46434261
It's another spirit-focused shounen series if that's what you mean.
>>
File: 6b5aee3fed6f65a1012816b28785da11.jpg (305KB, 794x1100px) Image search: [Google]
6b5aee3fed6f65a1012816b28785da11.jpg
305KB, 794x1100px
>>46434261
It does have some similar elements, but I can't really give you solid details. I could spout off what I remember, but it's been a while since I read through the comic and I don't want to say anything to obviously mislead. It's very heavily spirit based, yes, but it heads off in a different direction.

Honestly, if anything it reminds me more of The Law of Ueki than Bleach.
>>
>>46433766

Yep. They were basically me thinking 'So how do you solve the issue of needing a history to use this stuff and refusing to have a new one', and coming up with those ideas as a solution.

Both of which can basically be summarized as 'Here's a probably horrible completely non background history you got to live thought instead'.


I figure that unless Brahman is an idiot it would probably notice that you were never actually born during the telepathic communication with you and Sera that convinces it to destroy humanity. Considering that Brahman already starts with a negative opinion do to what occurred during the 'conversation' adding something that can be interpreted as 'Your world sucks and isn't worth living in anyway' is highly unlikely to help with things. Unless possibly making a wrathful God into a depressed wrathful God counts as helping.
>>
>>46434403
I still don't see why you think he'd interpret it as an insult, considering you're actually there and living in it, and you're not even a proper part of humanity.

I mean, I guess I could kinda maybe see that if I squint and he also gets to see the choices you made picking your background, but then /still/ you're actually there for longer, instead of refusing to live in his world.

On a somewhat unrelated topic, do these Mantra thingies teach you skills/are skills, or are they actual abilities you won't be capable of without buying them? Like, could I copy Megido or even Celestial Ray by just copying the people/demons that use them?
>>
>>46433827
There is a proper afterlife, but it's merged with/take place inside God. The same God whos' soul some Native Americans are trying to dump on the strongest guy to pick up their flyers.

The lore is a bit vague in it .
>>
>>46433497
That's completely unfair anon and you damn well know it. It's easy to miss posts when your already responding and he could be thinking of answers or otherwise occupied.

You don't make a good case that jump makers should listen to the community when instead of giving a newish jump maker a benefit of the doubt you basically say he sucks and thats it.
>>
>>46434745
>easy to miss posts
He ignored the very first post which was significantly long, several posts after at random intervals, ignored several attempts to draw his attention to all of these posts and when he did respond, his given reasoning completely falls apart. He then ceased responding to most responses again.

>Thinking or occupied
He responded to several fairly long posts in just minutes but still hasn't to the very first in hours nor to multiple other posts throughout the conversation time. He was not occupied because he was still responding to some posts, just ignoring most of them.

Totally unfair, obviously.
>>
>>46433827
>second spoiler

I see you've been to LEGO Jump before this.
>>
>>46434864
So he misses some and suddenly its evasion despite the fact you even admit he's answered similarly long posts? Do you have any reason he might be avoiding it, or are you just being pissy?

Yes it is unfair to assume malicious intent. As soon as he answered one you knew he was answering them.
>>
>>46435019
He consistently misses and doesn't answer despite them being pointed out several times over and him acknowledging that he has noticed them but is taking time to think (Said time is now several hours with no response, despite him continuing to respond to later questions). The fact that he has answered similarly long posts isn't a point for him, it just proves that it does not take hours to think of a response to a long post. Reasons? Laziness is one (The one remark he's pretty consistently ignored is anything relating to his spelling and grammar), trying to get certain things through and not answering criticism over those.

Yes, he was answering questions. Was it all? No, he only answered some and has still not answered several despite showing he is aware of them.
>>
>>46434554

While I did consider the possibility of annoying them that wasn't the main issue. The issue is less it being a potential insult and more that from their pov your a being that was never actually born in their reality, who obviously didn't want to be, and who accidentally telepathically helped convince Brahman they should destroy humanity do to a horrible experiment you were going through. That seems like the kind of thing that would make it even less likely to convince them that their decision was wrong. Basically 'living' was a poor word choice where I should have put 'actually be born into'.
>>
I figure it's probably too late, but I kind of like the idea of Drop-In "dropping in" at the start of the telepathy experiments in DDS2, powerless, and only remembering all of the awful shit they did to you once you escape the simulation - just like Sera.
>>
File: level choices.jpg (61KB, 400x572px) Image search: [Google]
level choices.jpg
61KB, 400x572px
A query about the Persona jump for those who have played more of the series then I have. What is the Revelations drawback based on, and how much more dangerous does it make the jump? I’d rather not have to worry that I could die to something like a car crash, or some knave leaving a banana peel at the top of some stairs, but on the other hand, if the drawback means that Yog-Sothoth, Cthulhu, and Jack Frost are going to jump out of a hedge to mug me every time I try go shopping, then I might want to reconsider taking it.
>>
File: 1425656480892.jpg (482KB, 1920x1080px) Image search: [Google]
1425656480892.jpg
482KB, 1920x1080px
So, when a jump offers you non-canon companions, do you prefer

A. Pre-constructed characters with set powers and personality
or
B. Being given a small stipend of CP to build a companion?
>>
>>46435170
It's based on the earlier Persona games, where there were monsters running around pretty much everywhere. The first game basically starts with a zombie and demon attack in a hospital, and by the end of the second game there's a floating city and Adolf Hitler is running around with the Lance of Longinus.
>>
>>46435174
The first one. More flavour to the jump is always better.
>>
>>46435170
>normal and fuck you
>not fuck you and fuck you with a cactus.
>>
>>46435216
What? No it's not.

>>46435170
What it does is make the rest of SMT (Strange Journey, the Devil Survivor games, Nocturne etc) all happen in the Persona jump as well during your time there. So hyper dangerous.
>>
>>46435091
You do realize that an answer might take longer to answer based on the question itself right? As for why the first post was pretty lore specific so maybe he just needed to look at a wiki and yes is that lazy? No lazier than the anon who could of looked up said answers himself on a wiki. And why respond to anything about grammar? Either he will fix it or he will not, he needs to respond to your ass like he works for you or something? And as for needing to fix it would be nice, but there are plenty of spelling monstrosities already on the drive.
>>
Hey if you upgrade a ACU with a piece of technology do its schematics for itself update as well?
>>
>>46435174
Personally, I prefer pre-constructed, by far. But even then I most prefer picking up canon companions.

If I wanted to get a blank slate to fill in, I'd clone something myself.
>>
>>46435170

It's probably based on how the first Persona game and Persona 2 didn't have a separate 'shadow world'.

Basically in Persona 3 shadows could only show up during a special time period most people don't experience. Meanwhile in Persona 4 it was in an alternate dimension.

The earlier stuff did not have that. Basically it means you don't have to deal with a world where you don't have your powers, but don't get a world where you won't need them.
>>
>>46435289
It's sad to see the sheer extents you will go to apologise for him.

Longer? It has been hours anon. And not just for the first, but all of the unanswered questions. From what I can see, plenty of the ignored posts have questions relating to the jump, not just lore. Why respond? Because it gives people an update that he has noticed and is working on it. Updates like that prevent complaints like these or the many earlier from happening. But of course, how dare we ask to be kept informed and have criticism answered. The mighty jumpmaker can do as he pleases and anon here will do his best to support him.
>>
>>46435249
I think you're confusing the +0 CP drawback with the +300 CP drawback.
>>
>>46435390
...I am the dumb incarnate. Excuse me while I go commit sudoku for my stupidity.
>>
>>46435249

That's the Strange Journey drawback which requires the Revelations drawback.
>>
>>46435249
>What it does is
No, that’s the Strange Journey drawback, and I’m not touching that with a Monkey King’s pole. I just trying to get an idea of how much and what kind of shit Revelations (the 0 CP drawback) is likely to put me though.
>>
>>46435399
>>46435409
Thou only deepen my shame.
>>
>>46435366
As oppose to you the great and dependable hound of the will of jump-chain? He who hours later still demand that the will of jump-chain be followed by those silly little jump makers who dare think that just because they decide to make a jump they don't have to follow the Will.

Maybe he is busy with other things? Or is in the process of changing his jump instead of answering every single question individually? I mean at best you could say he should of said he was going to work on the jump, but even that sounds like you expect the dude to ask "do you want fries with that"?
>>
>>46435409
*through
>>46435416
Sorry, that was not my intention. Thank you for trying to answer my question anyway.
>>
>>46435454
You keep saying he was busy, yet he continued to answer questions long after the ones he ignored were posted and even after he acknowledged they were there. Is he in the process of changing things? Yet he responded to questions that were just as minor or based on wanting clarifications as others he did not respond to and in random places as well. If he really was doing that, why would he respond to anyone at all instead of just fixing things?

Your arguments basically devolved to little more then dislike that people expect criticism to gain a response and repeating the same disproven ideas over and over, so unless you can introduce something new, don't respond.
>>
>>46435302

Almost certainly - though I would scan the part with the ACU's systems first so that its self-repair system knows what to do.
>>
>>46435409

Basically exactly the shit you have to go though in the shadow world, but without having to actually go to the shadow world to do to.
>>
>>46434403
Yeah, I get you. You're basically doubling the motivation he got from Sera (wow humans are treating each other like shit) plus your own jumper weirdness on top.
>>
>>46435551
Question, do you always react like a whiny little attention-whoring bitch whenever someone doesn't reply to your posts?
>>
File: newblood.jpg (536KB, 768x960px) Image search: [Google]
newblood.jpg
536KB, 768x960px
>>46435674
>a whiny little attention-whoring bitch
>>
>>46435692
So that's a yes?
>>
>>46435674
Gotta say anon, I am pretty amused you literally went down to just throwing insults. Wouldn't this all have been easier if you were just honest from the start?
>>
>>46435703
Not him, just smug.
>>46435717
That's him.
>>
>>46435736
Hi!
>>
>>46435631

Technically even the normal version should double the motivation. It's that this idea adds more than just doubling it.

Mostly since Brahman would probably 'know' that one of the people that gave it the motivation didn't want to be part of the group it's destroying in the first place (from it's pov). Which means you have to not only convince it that it's wrong, but that you have to do so while it can use you as evidence it was right.

Then like you said there's additional jumper weirdness.
>>
>>46435551
You act like this is an uncommon practice in forum talk and therefore reasonable to question. But in fact it happens all the time, I've past over hard to answer questions for hours even days at a time and answer easier questions with the full intention of answering them, or possible instead just write up the changes to the jump and only answer smaller questions. This is actually completely normal to anyone with any experience debating or conversing at length on the internet.

And just a quick reminder, you have no power over him actually answering those questions, the same with if I decide to response to you until I decide not to. Understand?
>>
File: 1458425610762.gif (195KB, 800x600px) Image search: [Google]
1458425610762.gif
195KB, 800x600px
>>46435692
>Everyone does it, so it must okay!
>>
>>46435717
I'm a different anon. I just noticed that your entire argument seems to spawn from you feeling pissy because you got ignored.
>>
File: 1376304063454.jpg (47KB, 406x364px) Image search: [Google]
1376304063454.jpg
47KB, 406x364px
>>46435748
Howdy. How are you doing today?
>>
>>46435760
That's what I meant, man. Doubling+ instead of the normal doubling.
>>
>>46435717
If you are talking to the one that has been responding to you thats me, >>46435674
is not me. Although I can see why you would love to think it was.
>>
>>46435772
How wonderful that your personal experience just happens to completely support your own argument and yet at the same time have zero actual proof. And more opinions too! I can almost feel myself being convinced already.

And you have no power over what I call him in response to him not responding, the thing that started this entire argument. Funny how things come around huh? I know you have this big thing bout your side being absolutely in the right at all times, but try to be reasonable. Understand?

>>46435796
Ah, the return of the insults. Criticism? Tish and pish. Desire to see a better jump? Preposterous. Why, how could anyone even comprehend someone dissenting from unceasing worship of a jumpmaker for the act of creating a single jump?


Now, gentlemen, as fun as this has all been, I'm afraid we'll have to make our sappy farewells and continue another day. Au revoir mi amigos.
>>
>>46435912
It's more that you keep harping on about how your post got ignored. That seems to be your entire motivation. I'm not saying anything about 'his jump sucks' or whatever, because all I'm doing is noting what seems to be your problem.
>>
>>46433924
They have to be in A role they played. Elsa was both villain and princess, depending on the part of the story she was in. Mulan is hero/princess. Story roles are actually pretty flexible for the jump.
>>
>>46435816

Just thought I should clarify that I'd expect this to be super hard mode if it got used, and not just normal hard mode.
>>
>>46436092
That's what makes it fun. Just how much is 'no memories ever!' worth it to those people?
>>
>>46433515
>implying anyone's honest on the internet

admittedly if this is sarcasm, it's 4 AM i cannot into reading comprehension
>>
>>46435912
>How wonderful that your personal experience just happens to completely support your own argument and yet at the same time have zero actual proof.

You ever thought for just a moment that is why I decided to enter this conversation? That I have had personal experience with coming back to a conversation later which is why I said what I said? And to be fair we have the same amount of evidence and opinions in what we say.

And sure I have no power over what you call him, I DO however have the power to state why I think the way I do and why I think you are overreacting. This is a power we all share here, the power we don't have is actual control over another poster.

As an example I have no control over you responding to me, I could say that you are basically quiting because you know you've run out of logical reasonings to object and instead of admitting you are wrong you are quiting the conversation. I can say this, but I can't actually make you respond, see?
>>
File: lies.gif (3MB, 697x458px) Image search: [Google]
lies.gif
3MB, 697x458px
>>46436203
Don’t be ridiculous. Does that face look sarcastic to you? I would hope not!
>>
>>46436265
Stop teasing and make an Arthur jump.
>>
Fuck it. Topic time.

You know those OC powers, anons? The ones where you basically 'fill in the blank,' like Stands, or Hatsu Custom Techniques, Reality Marbles, Noble Phantasms, that kinda shit?

Describe them. What they are, what they do, your thought process behind them, all that shit.

>>46436265
IT'S FUCKING 4 AM AND MY COFFEE MACHINE IS BROKEN

SLEEP-DEPRIVATION-RETARDATION

GIMMEABREAK
>>
File: 1295197859453.jpg (28KB, 560x355px) Image search: [Google]
1295197859453.jpg
28KB, 560x355px
>>46436384
______No.______
>>
>>46436384
I know for sure I'm going with "always on precog and postcog scrambling" for my PS238 custom power, because information can win wars and I don't like dealing with some motherfucker scrying how I like my eggs just to poison every chicken in the farm to get to me.

My stand was just a giant middle finger to teleporters and portal fighters. It's a pair of wicker-goblins riding jet engines that let me cancel teleporters and move portals about willy nilly. I can also warp space a bit to generate mazes with invisible walls that send you out other places in the maze. It's one of those game stands as opposed to one of those I-win stands.

I've thought up a possible Reality Marble:
Who helps you up when you're knocked down flat?
Who holds the mop when your plans go splat?
Who stays tough when you think that's that?
Come heaven or hell, it's Noble the Rat!

And then things go cartoony. Gilgamesh tries to fire the Gate of Babylon inside and I end up outlined in weapons. I pull one out to fight and we keep swinging in the same pattern until the weapons get tired and go for a drink.


I am just Jumpchan's favorite show, after all
>>
>>46436622
yeah going to be limited to only for about an hour's time and a city block sphere in distance, unless you go for multiple purchases but it will work. And significantly powerful precognitive and post cognitive people will probably notice that blind spot by sensing the area around it, finding its shape by the absence of their information.
>>
>>46436384
I couldn't come up with a proper music-themed Stand name, so I named mine The Sun. It basically accelerates growth/development in whatever it touches, like punching a sapling and making it into a giant of a tree, punching someone's face and aging them to death, etc. When Awakened, it can regress something into a prior form. When in Requiem, it can manipulate someone's growth in a way that wasn't really intended, like making a future manlet into a tall guy, or giving someone cancer.

It takes the form of a humanoid star, with black spots acting as eyes.

Destructive Power: C

Speed: A

Range: C

Durability: B

Precision: A

Developmental Potential: Not sure on this
>>
File: 205b3cfcfc2ba5f416c4e1499e451fee.jpg (413KB, 1509x862px) Image search: [Google]
205b3cfcfc2ba5f416c4e1499e451fee.jpg
413KB, 1509x862px
>>46436622
>>Spoiler
I both love and hate you for making me read that and remember.
>>
>>46436726
Neato! Thank's bancho, I can work with this. I just have to operate on a smaller timescale than initially planned, but there's lots of wiggle room.

And I didn't mean that I'd completely block them out, it'd be more like any action involving me becomes a bizarre fever dream.

>try to read elonanon's next series of actions
>things break out into a musical
>everything catches fire as he explodes into a storm of pepper
>the moon breaks down and tells us it's problems
>the colors start to run and time won't stop laughing
Only one of these things are true
>>
File: The Zoot Cat (12).jpg (193KB, 1480x1080px) Image search: [Google]
The Zoot Cat (12).jpg
193KB, 1480x1080px
It may be a bit silly, but would there be any interest in a Tom & Jerry jump?
>>
>>46436862
Do It!
>>
>>46436862
I'd be plenty interested. Loved that show as a kid.
>>
>>46436862
No clue how you would be able to do it, but if you think you can pull it off, go for it.
>>
>>46436862
I was going to do a generic toon jump, but didn't get very far because life sucks and is hard. I just realized I'm late for work right now, but if you want I can shoot you my notes tomorrow? There's probably something there you can use.
>>
File: one more time.gif (3MB, 480x270px) Image search: [Google]
one more time.gif
3MB, 480x270px
>>46436862
ONE MORE TIME
>>
>>46436862
Yes. Do it.
>>
>>46436860
also remember that it's not an absolute defense, if someone has sufficient psychic power they can still scan you, but depending on how many times you purchase it you should have a decent amount of protection.
Also remember that this is protection from psychic power, something like a shard power from worm would penetrate it easily as that's more of a Laplace's demon kind of thing.
>>
Would Chaos in the Blood from webmage make chaos your base blood for the branch of sin powers in Deadman Wonderland?
>>
File: 7a9.jpg (81KB, 680x510px) Image search: [Google]
7a9.jpg
81KB, 680x510px
>>46436910
As much as I am not a fan of generic jumps, for this kind of setting it might work better, mainly because the only real thing that differentiates this kind of cartoon is usually just the characters. As a result I think there might be significant difficulties in coming up with items. However I will still go ahead with at least drafting out something to see how much content unique to tom and jerry I can come up with. Would appreciate a look over your notes to get me started though.
>>46436891
>>46436905
>>46436906
>>46436930
>>46436963
Also fuck me I was not expecting such an enthusiastic response. All the more reason to give it a shot I suppose.
>>
Could you have beings like azhura madra, angra mainyu, shiva, vishnu, shakti, and indra as your persona or is that too much? Im trying to find a good persona.
>>
>>46437062
>pic
I just dont understand this stupid meme.
>>
>>46437106
Yes. I think any mythological being is fair game for a persona.
>>
>>46437062
>>...for this kind of setting it might work better...
I agree with you there. Perhaps the Locations could be nods to each of the more famous cartoons if you were to do things that way.

Give me the ability to pull convenient items out from behind my back and you will be my hero.
>>
>>46437208
There are perks for that. Like one in FF8 nobody ever talks about because they're busy making paramagic or being elemental demigoddesses.
>>
>>46437160
But some of those beings are absolutely ridiculous would i need hidden depths or the ultimate persona thing to get them?
>>
>>46437106

Gods being persona's is a think that has occurred a lot. Anyway I decided to check the canon stuff.

Angra Mainu is a Tower Arcana Persona.

Shiva is a Chariot and Tower Arcana Persona

Vishnu is available as an Emperor, Sun, and Temperance Persona.

Indra is avaliable as a Heirophant and Emperor Persona.

Ahura Mazda hasn't appeared in persona yet. Shakti meanwhile hasn't appeared or is a priestess arcana persona if Parvati counts.
>>
>>46437301
Personas are a LOT more limited than SMT demons in power level.
>>
File: 6c87b190dbd7757430969b6368c7a033.jpg (951KB, 1600x989px) Image search: [Google]
6c87b190dbd7757430969b6368c7a033.jpg
951KB, 1600x989px
>>46437270
Oh my, would you look at that. And in my least favorite Final Fantasy world too. Thanks for pointing it out. Now if you'll excuse me, I've got an edge-lord to drop kick and a perk to pick up.
>>
>>46437336
Would you say anything from Celtic Mythos could make for a good Hermit?

I tried to wing it with Dagda, but given SMT IV FINAL's coming along soon and how Dagda's evidently going to be part of the Deicide plot, I'm not sure anymore.
>>
>>46437392
If you mean Squall, the dude eases up on his own, even if he doesn't want to admit it. He clearly starts caring about his friends and Rinoa (ew) after long enough.
>>
>>46437421
Woah woah woah Rinoa is a great girl I.see no reason for the ew there.
>>
>>46437301
One thing to note is that a Persona is not the entity itself, but rather a manifestation of your personality and inner thoughts that can look like the entity. They also are canonly tamed Shadows, and can revert back to being a Shadow if you reject its lesson or suffer extreme psychological damage.
>>
>>46437421
I do mean Squall. And I know he does, but he's also killed fairly early on, so I wasn't going to go by the game's story in any case. I just really want to kick him in the face and I've got the perfect Perk from Generic Fighting Game Jump to do it.
>>
So here's what I've got for powers so far: http://pastebin.com/X89YAGKV

In addition, you'll be able to buy certain powers as higher tiers. For example, buying Inorganic Form as an Alpha power would get you 75 ton strength and much better durability, and as an Omega it would get you 200 ton strength and small-nuke durability.

Thoughts?
>>
>>46437301

Persona's usually aren't as powerful as the demons and gods their based on without protagonist power, and even then their power can vary.

For example Hermes was someones starting non-evolved persona.

So basically you would probably have to train to unlock it's full potential no matter what.
>>
>>46437482
No he isn't? I mean unless you did it.
>>
>>46437473
>Mary Sue personality hole that acts like a spoiled brat and a moron all the time and originally only hooked up with Squall to make Seifer jealous for skipping out on their date.

>>46437482
That theory is stupid.
>>
>>46437474
...

So, wait. WIth a Jumper fully capable of changing over eons, if one's Arcana wound up changing - would the Persona instantly go Shadow?

Are you essentially having to stasis yourself in order for your Persona to stay tame?
>>
>>46437485
You're going to have to write a ton for that mechanic.
>>
>>46437511
Technically if you took self aware you would be able to change your Persona at least once.
>>
>>46437531
Shit-ton of writing now to save from Marvel-jump-tier headaches later on down the line?
>>
>>46437550
Or he could just not let you upgrade powers on the tiers.
>>
>>46437485
Looks pretty damn awesome to me.
>>
>>46437531
I'm not leaving it nearly as open-ended as Marvel. I'll probably just go ahead and write up a supplement about in on the few powers it'll be available for.
>>
>>46437485
Looks like you've got a ton of the basics covered nicely. Thumbs up.

>>46437505
The theory might not be well received, but I happen to believe the evidence points to it being true quite firmly. I won't try to convince anyone else to change their views on the game, but it's how I'm going to proceed through my version of the Jump.

>>46437501
Nah. I'm not that psychopathic. I'll just wait for him to get an ice spear the size of a telephone pole shoved through his chest.
>>
File: image.gif (2MB, 480x270px) Image search: [Google]
image.gif
2MB, 480x270px
>>46436930
Literally Me
>>
>>46437511
I'm not Wild Card, so I'm just going off research into Persona stuff, but my guess is that your Persona would evolve with you as long as you don't go against who you are. In other words, if you suddenly change from being a hero to an edgelord, you might have to deal with your Persona fighting against you, but if you just slowly change as a person over time, your Persona will slowly change along with you.
>>
>>46437511
No. Personas are fine with change as a person, in fact they encourage it. They're a means for healthy emotional growth, not a way to pigeonhole humanity into strictly defined roles. The problem isn't changing, it's lying. So long as you're honest with yourself about who you are, your Persona will be fine. And technically, it won't ever turn into a Shadow, even if you do fall into self-delusion. It will just try to kill you, it'll stay a Persona while doing so.
>>
>>46437401

There's probably something, but that list was literally me checking the megami tensei wiki.

So far the only Celtic Persona I've found is Taranis whose a Chariot Persona, but one being available means others are probably an option even if they haven't shown up in canon yet.
>>
>>46437595
Is there a generator for these?
>>
>>46437485
Looking pretty cool so far.
>>
>>46437584
I was gonna say something, but given I rolled with the theory that Zion and the "real world" are merely another level of the true Matrix for my stay in that universe, I don't really have the right to talk smack to others about this type of thing.
>>
>>46437673
I always took the "Zion is just another level of the Matrix" thing to be more metaphorical than literal. It's not a part of the Matrix in the sense that it's a virtual world, but in the sense that it's a controlled one. You're still dancing to the machines' tune when you're in Zion, you've just been given the illusion of freedom.
>>
>>46437673
>>46437726
I kinda want to blow Zion up for being a den of debauchery.
>>
>>46437584
But he does get better. I mean Im not completely sure how but its not like the ice kills him.
>>
>>46437106
You can, but no matter what you pick it will look like a disco robot.
>>
>>46437821
There's a fan theory that most of FF8 is Squall's dying dream. It's not a very satisfying theory, as "it was all a dream" explanations never are, but it does explain a lot of the weirdness in the second half of the game.
>>
>>46437482
>>46437584

How exactly does that work?
>>
>>46437336
So for angra mainyu id neec hidden depths
Shiva,vishnu,and indra are obtainable off the bat
What would Azhura madra be as a perona im thinking justice

>>46437355
Really? Dont persona have that growth factor.

>>46437474
So what would be a persona for someone who is selfish, and extremely lazy but wants the best for everyone even the people who dont deserve it.
>>
>>46437912
Susanoo? Are you a drunk pervert?
>>
>>46437584
Pls, an ice spear the size of a telephone pole through the chest wouldn’t kill a paraplegic Moogle with ebola, you need something with a bit more oomph to hurt a human.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hTc9sLmOR0A
>>
>>46437920
Ill admit to being as perverted as everyone else but i dont drink. Besides i think jump me by living through all these different lives is going to be completely different than me unless my first jump is drop in persona.
>>
>>46437960
Can't be susanoo then. Sorry.
>>
File: 20faecbd939a051ddfea0ae3a0bd5f27.jpg (706KB, 1080x1080px) Image search: [Google]
20faecbd939a051ddfea0ae3a0bd5f27.jpg
706KB, 1080x1080px
>>46437895
I don't really want to go into all the detail here and I've lost the link to the YouTube video that compiled and explained all of the evidence.

>>46437884 explained it very concisely actually.

>>46437941
Okay, you made me laugh and I'll give you a loving slow golf clap for that. Most of the Final Fantasies go pretty insane near the end. I had forgotten that FF7 was /that/ over the top though.
>>
>>46437485
Wanna know something funny?
Quicksilver & Wanda aren't mutants. They're normal humans experimented on Counter Earth by High Evolutionary. Magneto was never their father, they were just lead to believe he was.
>>
>>46437973
Eh ill live. But didnt the persona jump say you could choose any arcana even if its not yours but youd have just some difficulty and not total personality war.
>>
>>46438020
Is that true in all continuities?
>>
>>46437912

>What would Azhura madra be as a perona im thinking justice

I have no clue, but his subordinates are avaliable as Justice, Star, Judgement, Heirophant, and Temperance Personas

>Really? Dont persona have that growth factor.

They do but the same ability in Persona tends to be weaker than the SMT version. For example in Persona the basic stat boosting spells affect a single target, but in SMT it affects the entire party.

Also when an actual mythical figure appears in the Persona games it's usually a lot more powerful than a Persona.
>>
>>46438083
I can only think or Sraosha as his subordinates. I kind of want to go angra mainyu even though were complete opposites.

And thanks i didnt know that.
>>
So I'm going to be updating Property at some point today. Goal is to make Rule Breaker more worthwhile, make Heart Bell cheaper and give Drop-Ins more stuff to play with. This will include tweaks to Hacking Field that were brought up to me previously.

Did anyone else have suggestions or input for the jump?

Hard Mode: Nothing related to Pandora Prototype.
>>
>>46438020
I'll pretend that didn't happen if you do.
>>
>>46438161
A way to not die if you want to be actively involved in the plot.
>>
File: do_this.png (82KB, 625x626px) Image search: [Google]
do_this.png
82KB, 625x626px
>>
>>46438316
He asked for suggestions, I had one. Wouldn't call that bait.
>>
>>46438161
A way of powering up to match the later parts of the plot that doesn't become outrageously broken once you take the scope of the chain itself in account.
>>
What are some ways to accelerate time in the Warehouse besides the Narnia clock?
>>
>>46438209
>>46438357
Somebody answer that phone.

Because I fucking called it.
>>
>>46438161
A way to keep up with the others would be nice. And by keeping up I don't mean 'can stomp all over the main protagonists and antagonists'. Just being a credible threat, even if I'd still be a fair ways behind would be nice.
>>
>>46438477
That second post wasn't even me. I'm actually a little happy someone else agrees.
>>
>>46438465
SCP-2400.

When the door is closed, time within the space inside 2400 moves at a rate of 140 seconds for every 1 second outside.
>>
>>46438465
Dead Space, maybe. But you'd have to reverse engineer their Stasis-tech yourself.
>>
>>46438515
I only posted because it's a legitimate concern for some and I wasn't sure if you were baiting.

So, yay for both us? Or all of us, what with the other guy.
>>
>>46438161
Honestly the only things I want you either cant do(explain how the hell synapse tech works and what can be done with it), or things you already have stated you aren't including, like a pandora system that let's me consume other tech(honestly this is as much that I find doing that more interesting, as I don't find the existing angelroid stuff that's getting a buff interesting), or maybe a pandora system for an existing companion. Though even putting the pandora system in a companion, it would kind of make it annoying because then there would be a piece of tech in her that I have no real ability to interact with.
>>
>>46438065
Thankfully no. Micheal Fassbender as already stated Magnetk is QS' father.

>>46438191
Marvel is fucking up all their IPs. Mutants are now InHumans, long time mutants aren't actually mutants, Captain America was depowered, repowered, and replaced by Falcon. Thor is no longer Thor. Fantastic 4 are no more. Sue is a slut. Spidey sold his marriage for an old woman. There's yet another Civil War this time over Minority Report.

DC is having yet another rebranding due to Convergence which was the multiverse collapsing upon itself into one world.
>>
>>46438991
Magento*
>>
>>46438991
>Sue is a slut.
Many, you know this has ALWAYS been true in EVERY continuity.
>>
>>46439013
>Magento

They changed his power so he manipulates colors now? Jeez.
>>
>>46438991
>Marvel is fucking up all their IPs
Eh, they've been doing that for years.

>Spidey sold his marriage for an old woman
Please tell me you're talking about One More Day and that didn't happen again.

>DC is having yet another rebranding
Now that I didn't know. Seriously?
>>
>>46439036
He's FABOULOUS now.
>>
>>46438991
Mutants/Inhumans are easy to understand, if scummy. Fox won't give up the Xmen rights, so since Marvel makes most money off of movies now, they're ruining the Xmen IP and replacing it with a similar concept they can market.

As far as Falcon and Lady Thor, you and I both know it's retarded diversity pandering to people who don't even buy comics and their sales will tank for it.
>>
http://pastebin.com/cyfCzCKZ

Jump-Chan picks up a Murloc
>>
>>46439103
>Fox won't give up the Xmen rights,
They have no reason to, they have the full power of Hugh Jackman. Hell even if they didn't combine him with the seeming innate popularity of Wolverine, and had him play pretty much any other character they'd still likely be doing alright.
>>
>>46439231
A jumper Murloc eh?
>>
>>46439231
That is strong.
>>
>>46439231
Pretty good stuff.
>>
>>46439103
>Lady Thor
I don't follow comics cuz comics are for nerds.
Was there actually butthurt over that? Because I thought it could have been a good idea.
>>
>>46439262
Yep. No Warehouse, no companions going to try to keep him low-powered.

>>46439297
>>46439382
Thanks!

Any votes on where he's getting thrown next?
>>
File: Ow_the_edge.jpg (63KB, 400x366px) Image search: [Google]
Ow_the_edge.jpg
63KB, 400x366px
>>46439085
>DCs IP
As someone who just saw Batman v. Superman, allow me to sum it up for you:

EDGYEDGYEDGYEDGYEDGYEDGYEDGYEDGYEDGYEDGYEDGYEDGYEDGYEDGYEDGYEDGYEDGYEDGYEDGYEDGYEDGYEDGY
>>
>>46439424
>Any votes on where he's getting thrown next?
Kirby
>>
>>46439424
Rick and Morty or Futurama, maybe?

Those seem like places where he'd fit in by not fitting in.
>>
>>46439444
>spoiler
Hasn't it been like that since the start of N52? Did it get worse?
>>
>>46439408
>not a nerd
>in jumpchain
I don't follow the comics either.
How would Lady Thor be a good idea? I honestly can't think of any good reason to change a character's gender.
>>46439444
Didn't batman use guns and kill people in that movie? As in going directly against his shtick?
>>
>>46439424
Castlevania or Crypt of the Necrodancer.
>>
>>46439408
Anon, suddenly ousting Thor as worthy, putting some random girl in his place, then having her try and be 'cooler and hipper' than him because 'girls can do it too' is not a good idea. Add onto that the WRITERS for this shit. They rant constantly about patriarchy and how politics they don't like are evil and such. Have you seen that issue where instead of writing a character's dialogue they just whine about politics in a 'censor' bar?
>>
>>46439489
Batty's having nightmare dream sequences including such things as bats ripping his face off

>>46439503
Lots of guns. So many guns. Two gatling guns acting as a larger gatling gun level of guns.
>>
>>46439503
IIRC, it wasn't so much "changing a characters gender" so much as it was Thor the person stopped being Thor the Hero, and a woman became Thor the Hero instead. Or something.

Unless they changed that for some reason. In which case, that's fucking stupid.
>>
>>46439610
It is the character Thor, for all intents and marketing purposes. But yeah, see >>46439539 for why it's gone TERRIBLY.
>>
>>46439539
>Have you seen that issue where...
No, I haven't. I've never read comics. Like at all.

And I misspoke. I should have said "the idea seems neat" rather than it being a good idea.
As always, even a good idea can be ruined by stupid people.
>>
In the Infamous jump if you choose conductor weapon and your an electrokinetic could you have coles Amp as your weapon?
>>
>>46439658
I suppose, in theory. Having more people who are worthy of Mjolnir HAS worked before. We all love Beta Ray Bill after all.
>>
>>46439658
Not that anon but give me a second to grab that page, I just found that entire page just... really wierd
>>
>>46439641
Don't forget the girl going up to Thor, tapping him in the chest with Mjolnir, and saying "calm thine tits".

>>46439692
Well, sure, but when Thor himself is around? No. Especially for this kind of crap. Shit like that is why Marvel is going to tank; all they can do at this point is bank on nostalgia because their subscriptions are going down at a constant rate.
>>
>>46439103
Yeah, not sure what they were thinking. Comics fans are a perfect intersection of literal misogynists and people pathologically averse to change. I don't know what kind of reaction they expected.
>>
Does anybody know if drawbacks from the Servant Supplement are permanent, or do they get revoked after the jump like normal ones?
>>
>>46439744
They get revoked.

>>46439673
Don't see why not.
>>
>>46439408
They could have done something interesting with it. They could.

But that all went out the window when they had a super villain stop in the middle of a fight with Thorita, tell her boyfriend off, and surrender to her because she "respects what she's doing, taking over Thor's place". Or something like that.
>>
>>46439514
>>46439479
>>46439454

Gonna roll between these!
>>
>>46439739
You don't have to be a my soggy nits to hate diversity pandering, dear anon. It's disingenuous of you to claim that people who hate shitty writing and poorly-planned pandering suddenly hate women. Have you ever even read Girl Thor's issues?
>>
>>46439539
>>46439658
Found it
>>
>>46439610
But why was replacing Thor a good idea? He's fairly popular iirc, and was fairly amusing without being completely OP. Not to mention the fact that he was Odin's son, and as far as I know he didn't have sisters, so I just don't see how they could have replaced him with another Thor at all without some kind of ass pull.
>>46439739
>literal misogynists
What? How?
>>46439761
I think that's possibly the stupidest thing I've in the last couple of months.
>>
>>46439503
>How would Lady Thor be a good idea? I honestly can't think of any good reason to change a character's gender.
Alright there were two instances of this in the comic and one sort of in mythology... Norse Mythology was kind of weird like that.
The first instance of it was in an alternate future story where Loki convinced Odin to turn Thor in to a woman because of his treatment of women. Why Odin ever listens to Loki is beyond me.
The second and main continuity example is actually I believe... Jane Foster with Thor's hammer. Thor became unworthy to weird Mjolnir do to plot reasons and she managed to be worthy for plot and comic sale reasons..
The female Thor is a completely different character than the male Thor. As for why gender bend characters? well it's often an attempt to make them more interesting when a character has gotten kind of stale... also spoiler... err screw it... that is my fetish.
>>
>>46439833
>What? How?
Methinks anon is the aforementioned type of person who Marvel is pandering to despite not buying comics.
>>
>>46439754
Oh ok thanks.
>>
>>46439825
...

I thought. I thought that was an edit. That's serious?
>>
>>46439874
It's serious, and the writers have defended it on their tumblrs talking about how clever and cool they are for writing it.
>>
File: thor-2.jpg (365KB, 1332x2048px) Image search: [Google]
thor-2.jpg
365KB, 1332x2048px
>>46439874

Moralizing is the bane of nuance.
>>
>>46439853
So, you're not going to explain how then.
I'll just assume you're full of shit in that case.
>>
>>46439834
>comic sale reasons
It was an ingenious plan to lose sales, yeah.
>>
>>46439925
I was telling you that the anon you were quoting was that. I'm not the person you quoted yourself. So I did in fact tell you how anon thinks people are misogynists. Because they are a tumblrtard.
>>
>>46439919
...

[Assorted Noises of Disappointment, Annoyance, Irritation, and Flat-Out WHY]
>>
>>46439833
>as far as I know he didn't have sisters
wiki says he has two sisters by his father, but he's also a son of Gaea(though he isn't aware of this), so he has a lot of half siblings.
>>
>>46439928
I thought female Thor was outselling male Thor, or did the short term shock value finally wear of and people are realizing it's stupid?
>>
>>46439999
People hate it and it's selling like crap.
>>
>>46439833
>I think that's possibly the stupidest thing I've in the last couple of months.
It was pretty... Yeah.

Here, I found the page:
>>
File: iPPaXFU.jpg (837KB, 1988x3056px) Image search: [Google]
iPPaXFU.jpg
837KB, 1988x3056px
>>46440019
Goddamnit.
>>
File: 12b.gif (406KB, 300x200px) Image search: [Google]
12b.gif
406KB, 300x200px
>>46439919
MY EYES ARE BLEEDING! What the fucking fuck.
>>
>>46439928
Sometimes I wish I could get actual sales figures for comics. Just because I think it would be interesting to see firsthand which gimmicks sell and which ones fail.
>>
>>46439966
Because marvel has discovered the easiest way to get money is to piss off fans and ruin their I.P.s
Then they can reboot them to the way they should be drawing unsuspecting fans back when comic sales start to falter so they can do it again when comic sales hit another lull.
>>
>>46439825
>unsolicited opinions on Isreal???
I'll admit it, I laughed.

But why does Odin have an opinion on Israel at all? Shouldn't it be Wakanda
>>
>>46439919
>>46440040
>>46439825
Yeah, that's definitely the stupidest thing I've read in months.
>>46439946
Oh, well then yeah. My bad.
It annoys me that people make assertions, especially really far out there generalizations and then don't actually say why. Anon may as well have said no women can drive well or all minorities do drugs. It's the same frustrating concept.
>>46439994
They already had there own identities though, yeah? So why the hell would they just suddenly be Fem-Thor?
>>
>>46440016
Oh good because I heard Marvel was flaunting the opposite. I am glad to see people aren't quite that stupid and sheep like.
>>
>>46440088
The identity of Thor actually happens to follow the hammer, and that is well established. Current fem Thor is actually an ordinary dying cancer patient, because, really I don't fucking know.
>>
>>46440040
>someone surrenders and so they brain her with a giant metal fucking hammer

yeeeeeep.
>>
>>46440148
Sympathy points.
>>
While we are on the topic of comic characters suddenly being girls? What is up with comic characters suddenly being black? What is this I hear about a black Wally West in DC?
Also to make it relevant to jump chain I wonder if something like this is going to wind up as a drawback in one of the marvel or DC jumps. "Suddenly part way through your stay you are a different gender or ethnicity. Can't be changed by shape shifting."
>>
>>46440148
How the hell did a cancer patient even get the hammer? Did Odin just plunk it down in front her or something? The more I learn the more retarded this seems.
>>
File: image.jpg (167KB, 480x736px) Image search: [Google]
image.jpg
167KB, 480x736px
>>46439825
Yeah, that kind of shit totally isn't up to the usual standards we expect out of our comics.
>>
File: S6cJeSg.png (410KB, 527x608px) Image search: [Google]
S6cJeSg.png
410KB, 527x608px
>>46440184
I guess, but it just comes off so poorly. Really the only mildly amusing thing to come out of it is this image.
>>
>>46440224
It's the same kind of diversity pandering. People who don't read comics whine on their tumblrs and twitters, Marvel changes it either to try and get them to buy comics or because those tumblrwhiners get a writing or art job, and then sales proceed to drop as the whiners don't ACTUALLY care about comics, they just like complaining, and your long term fans are now pissed that you retconned their favorite character and are writing them poorly.
>>
>>46440224
It's just to go 'see, we can be diverse, and anyone who hates it is an asshole, now we've gotten headlines so buy our comics'.

It's like if you were to cast a black woman as Hermione who had no acting talent just to get headlines (as opposed to casting someone who is an accomplished stage actress, which is what happened).
>>
>>46440262
That's not really amusing. That's just another sign of their shitty writing.
>>
>>46440262
It's funny until you realize it's not. And then it will never be funny again.
>>
>>46440278
I will forever be pissed at JKR for her response to that.

And I don't even care if she's black or not.
>>
>>46440278
Don't pretend headlines weren't the primary goal though, even if they did at least have the decency to pick someone who can act.
>>
>>46440266
So why don't they get actual decent writers to write their diversity pandering? Then maybe they'd actually get people who wanted to read them instead of rolling their eyes at a garbage medium trying to be relevant, and their fans wouldn't be quite so pissed off because their favorite comic would still have someone competent heading it.
>>
>>46440261
At least they can actually write dialog, anon. Instead of inserting your political opinions in a censor bar so you don't have to.
>>
>>46440262
She didn't actually even say that, did she?
>>
>>46440314
I missed a good chunk of that, I lost interest when it turns out the actress is actually decent and not just some scrub they used for nothing but the headlines. What was her response? Please don't tell me she decided to go 'but black hermione is canon'.
>>
>>46440333
Because those cost more money and don't want to be involved in this shit.
>>
>>46440344
She went "YOU CAN'T SAY HERMIONE WASN'T BLACK!" so basically.
>>
>>46440289
>>46440307
It's amusing for a couple moments as a reaction image. I was just saying that is the highlight, and it's an edit.
>>46440341
No "Calm thyself down" is what she actually says, and that isn't even amusing for a moment.
>>
>>46440344
Kind of.
She half-assed a response by saying "Well, if you read the book, it never SAYS she's white."

Which is true. It never says "Hermione is white"
But it implies it so fucking heavily that it might as well have come out and said it.

Fucking JKR
>>
>>46440266
You know what... let me say this. There should be more diversity in comics. That is true. However I don't the ruining established characters to do so is the way to go. These people are supposed to be writers, artists and creative types. Make new characters who are female or black, or Muslim or gay; Take old characters who were those but were minor characters and make them important and make sure they are better written. I shouldn't have to tell the big comic book companies their business but.... If you are trying to pander the last thing you want it to come off as is pandering.
My God... YOu know the justice league cartoon had several cast changes because it was too white and too male. They went with John Stewart over Hal Jordan and Hawk girl instead of Hawk man and they made them awesome so you can't tell me they can't do this properly.
>>
>>46440389
You really can't, though. There's really nothing we see regarding Hermione that precludes her from being black.
>>
>>46440416
That woman really needs to learn when not to comment on things. Or respond with any degree of intelligence, just go 'everyone imagines a different Hogwarts when they read, who am I to decide whether Hermoine is black, Ron is a gypsy, or Harry is Japanese?'
>>
>>46440433
I don't believe in diversity for the sake of diversity. It's anathema to creativity and vision. You don't make a character you were inspired to, you don't make his elements all match up and tell a story because you care, you do it to meet some quota. "Oh we need a black superhero. Let's just do this.". That's shit.

That said I don't care at all if someone walks into the office and says "Hey what if I made a superhero who is based on the legends and mythology of Africa? Maybe a spider-themed hero based of Annassi?", that's cool. The hero is black not because of pandering or a quota, but because the creator imagined them to be, and it is his original concept to make them that way. That's how it should be. Vision.
>>
>>46440389
>>46440416
>>46440456
Didn’t someone prove that wrong? Found a page that talked about her pale skin, or something of that sort?
>>
>>46440433
Oh, and I will agree with you on John Steward and Hawk Girl, because those previously existing characters were elevated and made important. A concept you already expressed in your post that I agree with, using your catalog like that is another good, valid way to expand your cast if you really feel like there should be a black hero or the like. And on top of that? They were written amazingly.
>>
>>46440505
Yes. There were lines about her face being pale and such.
>>
>>46440460
>Ron is a gypsy
I have no idea why, but this thought cracks me up.
>>
>>46440480
That only works if the default is "whatever seems interesting" instead of "generic white guy with brown hair." So unless you tell them "hey, add diversity," the absolutely won't.
>>
>>46440460
>Harry is Japanese
EXPERRIALMIS

...
Sorry, I couldn't not.

But yeah. She has a very bad habit of not knowing when to stop talking and inevitably ends up contradicting herself.
Like the whole "wand chooses the wizard" thing, who is parroted heavily by Ollivander....who doesn't bother making shitty wands.
Or better yet, what happens if an evil person tries to cast the Patronus?
>>
>>46440529
Those were scenes in which she was frightened - in other words, where her face was naturally pale compared to normal.
>>
>>46440537
I don't see that as a problem, either. If the creators imagine a character as being white, why is that meant to be a problem? That's their vision. Diversity is not something to strive for because you want diversity brownie points so you can feel good about yourself. If it's to be a thing it needs to develop naturally.
>>
>>46440558
You know for a fact that's you desperately reaching, anon.
>>
>>46440542
>what happens if an evil person tries to cast the Patronus
Well, apparently it's a deer. Snape, despite having a sad backstory, was an absolute creep and a horrible excuse for a human being. Even bad guys can have happy thoughts.
>>
>>46440505
Well, it's not impossible for her to be a pale-ish black person. Or indeed for a black person to go pale in fear.

But again, while it never explicitly says one way or another, it's heavily implied in multiple ways that she's white. Or at least very light skinned, with nothing to contradict such. And as we all know, if you hear hooves, you don't think zebras.
>>
>>46440542
>Like the whole "wand chooses the wizard" thing, who is parroted heavily by Ollivander....who doesn't bother making shitty wands.
What's the problem?
>>
File: this.gif (243KB, 500x281px) Image search: [Google]
this.gif
243KB, 500x281px
>>46440480
>>46440561
>>
>>46440590
Or in a much more damning example, Umbridge's is a car.

But if you go with the EU, so,wome evil casting a Patronus causes them to be devoured by worms.
>>
>>46440530
You know all the jokes about the most unrealistic part of Harry Potter being that a ginger has two friends? Now imagine if he was a ginger gypsy.
>>46440542
They get eaten by maggots.
>>
>>46440644
>Umbridge's is a car
what

WHAT

>captcha: Select all images with cars
ARE YOU FUCKING KIDDING ME
>>
>>46440644
JK Rowling is one of the few people I apply Death of the Author to.
>>
>>46440561
It won't develop naturally, though, because people just fall into their comfort zone of "white male is default, everything else has to be justified." You need to push people until we get to the point where you don't have to justify making a character something else; you just make whoever fits.
>>
Is Adventure time good jump for 2nd jump if i don't take drawbacks ? I would take Elemental Monarch (Ice) and Door Lord.
>>
Burgli in Castlevania, oddly more material than you'd think.

http://pastebin.com/nivFrhv4
>>
>>46440480
>Hey what if I made a superhero who is based on the legends and mythology of Africa? Maybe a spider-themed hero based of Annassi?

I fucking love this idea.

Make him team up with Peter Parker at some point.
JJJ will shit himself.
>>
>>46440617
He makes this huge deal about how there is only one perfect wand for a specific person and how using anything else will give you bad results.

Yet he arbitrarily limits himself to three cores (Dragon heartstring, Phoenix Feather and Unicorn hair) because he considers them to make the "best" wands. Even though there's at least three other cores that make perfectly acceptable wands (thestral hair, Veela hair and thunderbird feather)
>>
>>46440666
I meant cat. But the image of Umbridge the Muggle Hater with a car Patronus was too good, so I let it stand.
>>
>>46440703
Then it won't happen, and that is not a major problem either. A writer's vision, their own creativity, is far more important than any feel-good pandering for social points. That is all.
>>
>>46440703
You do not need to push people to do jack. Someone should not be forced to pander just because you want them to.
>>
>>46440745
Captcha has overruled you. Either way, the happy memory she probably uses for her patronus is having Harry write lines.
>>
>>46440710
It's hella dangerous but survivable.
>>
>>46440703
Because, surprise surprise, at least in the west, white IS the default
It would be different if we were talking something that took place in Africa or Japan or somewhere. But if you take a random person from the UK, chances are they're going to be white.
>>
>>46440716
I too think there's a lot of potential for African heroes. Annassi is a fun one, because he's a bit of a trickster, so you can have a fun but wise hero. Anybody would be better than Mary Sue Black Panther, frankly.
>>
>>46440480
I agree with you for the most part.
That being said, black nick fury from the movies is a champ. They got a good actor and his race didn't matter much for his character so I didn't care.
Now what does piss me off is black human torch. Fuck, I wouldn't have even cared if they just made his sister black too! Just make it consistent, fuck.
No I don't care if they weren't related by blood in the movie. There supposed to be goddamn siblings.
>>
>>46440712
Dracula rules the dark, Burgli rules the water.
>>
>>46440720
Thunderbird Feather you have a point on, but Thestral and Veela Hair are total bitches to use because it's extra picky.
>>
>>46440712
>http://pastebin.com/nivFrhv4

are you trying to keep him low-power on purpose? Basic Bending wouldn't have been expensive.
>>
>>46440712
Why is a murloc a compelling protagonist.
>>
>>46440836
I feel that, if you have a good enough writer, almost any sort of decision outside the 'rules' can be forgiven. They wrote him well, so nobody cared, more or less.
>>
>>46440720
>thestral hair
Used in one wand, and without known properties, almost certainly a bad idea considering everything
>Veela hair
Useful if you have Veela blood, not likely to bond to anyone else, if you are part Veela and you give him a hair of your Veela grandmother I bet you could convince him to make you a wand.
>thunderbird feather
Actually a pretty good point
>>
>>46440856
Well, yeah. But maybe a particular person is destined to have a bitchy wand?
Or maybe they're best matched to a shitty fire-crab snot wand or something.
>>
>>46440703
Well maybe they need to change the writers. We all have our own biases and such. With the slop that the current group of writers has been producing (not just talking about the forced deversity but stuff like one more day) I think it might be time to get some fresh blood in there. Maybe the companies should create a couple of books to try out new writers and artists. Just short stories. The artists don't have to be any color or gender just young and trying to get in to the industry. Any ideas that work or talent they find can be moved on to bigger books
>>
>>46440908
They shouldn't change the writers, really. They should hire competent writers who apply regardless of race though, and if you get a good black writer who wants to make black heroes, let him.
>>
>>46440703
>>46440703
There are many heroes that are are female or a minority. It the pointless change that's shit.
You want an female Asian super hero or whatever? Just make new one. Then nobody's going to bitch as long as it's written well.
Forcing poorly written pandering in is just mutilating the artist's vision.
Also? In the US, and Europe, where most of these stories take place the majority of the populace is white. It would be stupid if most of the heroes and villains weren't.
>>
>>46440856
Not that anon, but if there's only one perfect wand for a person, what are the odds that everybody that goes to Ollivander will never NEED a wand with one of the cores he doesn't use?

He's basically telling an unknown fraction of potential customers to go fuck themselves because he's too chickenshit to make the kind of wand they need.

That's his prerogative I guess, but how is he still in business with an attitude like that?
>>
>>46440878
>>why is a developed character with their own motivations, cultural identity and a novel point of view a compelling protagonist?

>> Seriously? .jpg
>>
>>46440868
Keeping him low tier on purpose. It's going to get harder to do that as time goes on but I'm doing my best.

>>46440878
Everyone likes an underdog?
>>
How do you set up a filter for a trip? I wouldn't normally bother, but there's one guy in these threads that really gets on my nerves.
>>
>>46440894
Those were just examples. They could be anything.
Basilisk eyestalk, Hippogriff feather, Augury brain Dementor baculum, whatever.
>>
>>46440946
To be fair, Ollivander's is a business. He has to make wands that can match a good majority of people. And a wizard can use wands that aren't a perfect match, they just won't work nearly as well. So from his perspective, your best bet is to make most of your wands from materials that are proven to both be relatively powerful and relatively compatible so most of your customers will get on fine. Then, you offer a service where you'll custom make wands from other materials the customer supplies for people who are part Veela or whatever and would be compatible with their ancestor or some other weird magical beast.

What you don't do, though, is mass produce wands from picky stuff like Veela or Thestral Hair, because if you do that you won't make any money.
>>
>>46440918
Now I have to disagree, not that they shouldn't hire on basis of race but you seem to be under the assumption they have competent writers to begin with and I think evidence shows not all of them are particularly competent. I am all for hiring competent people regardless of race or gender but I am saying some of the people writing comics are just bad at it and should be replaced with new blood and maybe giving new people a chance is how you find that new blood.
>>
>>46440749
>>46440783
It's awfully easy for you to say that when your stories are the ones being told all the time.
>>
>>46440710
Well the protagonist is a 14 year old boy, and he's survived so far. What was your first jump, Pokemon?
>>
>>46440990
>Augury brain Dementor baculum
Look if there is someone out there that has to have a wand with that as the core, I would say you are better off just not giving that person a wand.
>>
>>46440988
Who is it?
>>
File: 4654.jpg (57KB, 586x438px) Image search: [Google]
4654.jpg
57KB, 586x438px
>>46440990
Tell me more.
>>
>>46441008
I'm the first post you quoted, and guess what anon? I'm not white. So no, 'my stories' haven't been told all the time. And on top of that, I think people who need a character to be their race and/or gender to empathize with must be mildly sociopathic.

>>46441005
I guess I see what you mean now. Yeah, their current writers are shit and they'd be better off for firing most of them.
>>
>>46441008
So tell your own damn story. The only reason the stories that are told all the time are being told is that someone started telling them and they caught on.

Works best if you tell it to an audience that can relate. Don't go bitching if you tell people a story they can't get into and it falls flat on it's face.
>>
>>46440988
>copy !PRaxIvP5pQ
>bottom of page, hit [Settings]
>hit [+]Filters and Post Hiding
>check filter & highlight specific threads / posts
>hit the [Edit] button next to that one
>paste !PRaxIvP5pQ into 'Pattern,' checkmark 'On,' set type to 'Tripcode,' checkmark 'Auto' and 'Hide.'

>Save everything
>>
>>46440990
>Dementor baculum
I want to meet the wizard who pairs with that wand.
>>
File: 1449464102876.gif (858KB, 240x228px) Image search: [Google]
1449464102876.gif
858KB, 240x228px
>>46441008
I'm a karaite jew, fuck you.
>>
>>46441142
Not him, but I've never heard that term before so I'm kinda curious. What's up with you guys?
>>
>>46441055
Well you see, when a momma Dementor and a daddy Dementor love each other very much...

Now that I think about it, it's canon that dementors can breed. So unless they bud like hydra or something, I'm not going to finish that thought because my brain is already scarred enough.
>>
>>46441199
I think the intent was that Dementors intentionally cause suffering so more can form from it.
>>
>>46441060
Alright, but some of us actually would like more representative characters. If that makes me a sociopath then at least I'm in good company, considering the way authors can't empathize with characters who aren't of their race or gender.

>>46441077
Working on it. That's why I do Jumpchain - I treat it like writing practice.
>>
>>46441199
What do you think they do with the souls they devour, Anon? You didn't think they just used them as nourishment, did you?
>>
>>46441314
Then do as that other and get out there. I realize that's what you're doing and that's good, but like anon said, it's the only good way to handle that, instead of forcing writers to compromise their vision.
Thread posts: 468
Thread images: 51


[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / bant / biz / c / can / cgl / ck / cm / co / cock / d / diy / e / fa / fap / fit / fitlit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mlpol / mo / mtv / mu / n / news / o / out / outsoc / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / spa / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vint / vip / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Search | Top | Home]

I'm aware that Imgur.com will stop allowing adult images since 15th of May. I'm taking actions to backup as much data as possible.
Read more on this topic here - https://archived.moe/talk/thread/1694/


If you need a post removed click on it's [Report] button and follow the instruction.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com.
If you like this website please support us by donating with Bitcoins at 16mKtbZiwW52BLkibtCr8jUg2KVUMTxVQ5
All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties.
Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from that site.
This means that RandomArchive shows their content, archived.
If you need information for a Poster - contact them.